Krashen's Affective Filter Hypothesis & Affect in Language Learning
Krashen's Affective Filter Hypothesis & Affect in Language Learning
Krashen's Affective Filter Hypothesis & Affect in Language Learning
2- Acquisition/ Learning
Hypothesis: 'Adults have two distinctive ways of developing competences in second languages .. acquisition,
that is by using language for real communication (natural environment) ... learning .. "knowing
about" language'
3- Monitor Hypothesis:
'Conscious learning ... can only be used as a Monitor or an editor'
(those who use the monitor a lot are slow learners => too conscious of what they say)
4- Input Hypothesis:
'Humans acquire language in only one way - by understanding messages or by receiving
"comprehensible input"'
(comprehensible input = data we hear around us; if we are relaxed, it goes directly to our heads)
5- Affective Filter 'A mental block, caused by affective factors ... that prevents input from reaching the language
Hypothesis: acquisition device'
In this presentation, we are only interested in the fifth hypothesis -- The Affective Filter
Hypothesis-- which stipulates that a number of 'affective variables' play a facilitative, but non-
causal, role in second language acquisition. These variables include: motivation, self-confidence
and anxiety. Krashen claims that learners with high motivation, self-confidence, a good self-
image, and a low level of anxiety are better equipped for success in second language acquisition.
Low motivation, low self-esteem, and debilitating anxiety can combine to 'raise' the affective filter
and form a 'mental block' that prevents comprehensible input from being used for acquisition. In
other words, when the filter is 'up' it impedes language acquisition. (Krashen, 1985)
What we conclude then is that Affect plays a very important role in second language acquisition.
It needs to be taken into consideration by L2 teachers so they make sure that the students'
affective filter is low at all times in order for learning to take place.
Since this presentation is only related to Motivation, it will not cover the two other variables: self-
confidence and anxiety.
Before we start by defining motivation, mentioning its sources and different theories/models and
their implications, we believe it is worth asking one question that seems to guide all theorists'
and researchers' work: "Why do people learn a second or foreign language? In other words, what
is their Goal?
1- Why Do People Learn a
Second/Foreign Language?
After all, we, as teachers, need to find the student's motives so that we can accommodate them.
4- Definitions of Motivation
However simple and easy the word "motivation" might appear, it is in fact very difficult to define. It
seems to have been impossible for theorists to reach consensus on a single definition.
•Here are a few that I have found in the literature:
•According to the Webster's, to motivate means to provide with a motive, a need or desire that
causes a person to act.
•According to Gardner (1985), motivation is concerned with the question, "Why does an organism
behave as it does?
Motivation involves 4 aspects:
•A Goal
•An Effort
•A Desire to attain the goal
•Favorable Attitude toward the activity in question.
•Motivation is also defined as the impetus to create and sustain intentions and goal-seeking acts
(Ames & Ames, 1989). It is important because it determines the extent of the learner's active
involvement and attitude toward learning. (Ngeow, Karen Yeok-Hwa, 1998)
Motivation is a desire to achieve a goal, combined with the energy to work towards that goal.
Many researchers consider motivation as one of the main elements that determine success in
developing a second or foreign language; it determines the extent of active, personal involvement
in L2 learning. (Oxford & Shearin, 1994)
Sometimes a distinction is made between positive and negative motivation.
Positive motivation is a response which includes enjoyment and optimism about the tasks that you
are involved in.
Negative motivation involves undertaking tasks for fear that there should be undesirable
outcomes, eg. failing a subject, if tasks are not completed.
What can we infer from all those definitions? What are the keywords that "Motivation"
triggers in our minds?
2- Definitions of L2
It is crucial here to mention the difference between a Second and a Foreign language, which are both
referred to as L2.
People who are living in an English-speaking community/country are learning English as their
SECOND language. "The learner of the second language is surrounded by stimulation, both visual and
auditory, in the target language and thus has many motivational and instructional advantages." (Oxford
& Shearin, 1994)
.
As for those who are not living in an English-speaking community/country, they are learning English
as a FOREIGN language. "Foreign language learners are surrounded by their own native language
and have to go out of their way to find stimulation and input in the target language. These students
typically receive input in the new language only in the classroom and by artificial means, no matter how
talented the teacher is." (Oxford & Shearin, 1994)
3- Good L2 Learners
Research has shown that the use of specific learning strategies & techniques while
studying a second or foreign language leads to success. "The conscious, tailored use of
such strategies is related to language achievement and proficiency. (Oxford, 1994)
Some of those strategies:
Rubin (1975) suggested that good L2 learners
are willing and accurate guessers;
have a strong drive to communicate;
are often uninhibited, and if they are, they combat inhibition by using positive self-talk, by
extensive use of practicing in private, and by putting themselves in situations where they
have to participate communicatively.
are willing to make mistakes;
focus on form by looking for patterns and analyzing;
take advantage of all practice opportunities;
monitor their speech as well as that of others;
and pay attention to meaning.
One of the factors that influence the choice of strategies used among students learning a
second/foreign language is Motivation. More motivated students tend to use more strategies
than less motivated students, hence, they tend to be more successful. (Oxford, 1990a)
MOTIVATION
.
*Goal *Energy
*Effort *Active involvement
*Desire *Persistence
"While teachers and school systems have drawn on both of the first two sources of motivation,
the third source is perhaps under-exploited in language teaching. This is the simple fact of
success, and the effect that this has on our view of what we do. As human beings, we generally
like what we do well, and are therefore more likely to do it again, and put in more effort . . .
In the classroom, this can mean that students who develop an image of
themselves as ‘no good at English’ will simply avoid situations which tell them what they already
know – that they aren’t any good at English. Feelings of failure, particularly early on in a
student’s school career, can therefore lead to a downward spiral of a self- perception of low
ability – low motivation – low effort – low achievement – low motivation – low achievement, and
so on." Littlejohn, Andrew, November, 2001 ENGLISH TEACHING professional, Issue 19, March 2001
In general, explanations regarding the source(s) of motivation can be categorized as either extrinsic
(outside the person) or intrinsic (internal to the person). Intrinsic sources and corresponding theories can
be further subcategorized as either body/physical, mind/mental (i.e., cognitive, affective, conative) or
transpersonal/spiritual.
Note: Conation = inclination to act purposefully; impulse. (Webster's)
"It is an intrinsic 'unrest' of the organism, almost the opposite of homeostasis.
A conscious tendency to act... a conscious striving." (English & English, 1958)
Note: Vicarious learning = the acquisition of knowledge or ability
through indirect experience and observation, rather than direct
experience or practice.
Accomplishment/Industr
y Middle Childhood/ Child learns to do things well or correctly in comparison to a standard
vs. Elementary or to others
Inferiority
Initimacy
Develops ability to give and receive love; begins to make long-term
vs. Young Adult
commitment to relationships
Isolation
Generativity
vs. Middle Adulthood Develops interest in guiding the development of the next generation
Stagnation
Ego Integrity Develops a sense of acceptance of life as it was lived and the
vs. Older Adulthood importance of the people and relationships that individual developed
Despair over the lifespan
F- Humanistic Theories
Humanistic "theories" of learning tend to be highly value-driven
and hence more like prescriptions rather than descriptions.
They emphasise the "natural desire" of everyone to learn. They
maintain that learners need to be empowered and to have
control over the learning process. So the teacher relinquishes a
great deal of authority and becomes a facilitator.
.
Hierarchy of Human Needs: (Abraham Maslow, 1954). It is
based on two groupings: deficiency needs and growth needs.
Within the deficiency needs, each lower need must be met
before moving to the next higher level.
The first four levels (Deficiency Needs) are:
1) Physiological: hunger, thirst, bodily comforts, etc.;
2) Safety/security: out of danger;
3) Belonginess and Love: affiliate with others, be accepted; and
4) Esteem: to achieve, be competent, gain approval and recognition.
According to Maslow, an individual is ready to act upon the growth needs if
and only if the deficiency needs are met.
The remaining four levels (Growth Needs) are:
5) Cognitive: to know, to understand, and explore;
6) Aesthetic: symmetry, order, and beauty;
7) Self-actualization: to find self-fulfillment and realize one's potential;
Self-actualized people are characterized by:
Being problem-focused;
Appreciating life;
Showing concern about personal growth;
Showing ability to have peak experiences.
8) Transcendence: to help others find self-fulfillment and realize their
potential.
The essence of the hierarchy is the notion of “pre-potency”, which means
that you are not going to be motivated by any higher-level needs until your
lower-level ones have been satisfied.
Hierarchy of Motivational Needs.(Alderfer, 1972)
.
Fill the Heart, not just the Money Bag.
Edward L. Deci
Humanists stress the need for personal growth. They place a great
deal of emphasis on the total person, along with the related news of
personal freedom, choice and self determination.
G- Social Cognition
Self-efficacy: (Bandura, 1986, 1997) it highlights the belief that a particular
action is possible and that the individual can accomplish it. =>judging one's
own ability and competence.
Self-regulation: (Bandura, 1986, 1997) it highlights the establishment of
goals, the development of a plan to attain those goals, the commitment to
implement that plan, the actual implementation of the plan, and subsequent
actions of reflection and modification or redirection.
A- Behavioral Theories 1-
=> extrinsic motivation Stimulus, response, association (invo
Behaviorists explain motivation in 1- Classical conditioning 1- Pavlov luntary)
terms of external stimuli and 2- Operant conditioning 2- Skinner
reinforcement. The physical 3- Observational/social learning 3- Bandura 2- Stimulus, response, reward =
environment and actions of the reinforcement
teacher are of prime importance. 3- Modeling (imitation) + Vicarious
learning
1- Expectancy of success +
Instrumentality (see the connection
B- Cognitive Theories
between activity & reward) + Value
=> intrinsic motivation
1- Expectancy-value 1- Vroom / 1964 the results.
Cognitivists explain motivation in
2- Attribution theory 2- Heider, 1958 / Weiner, 1974 2- Attribute success/failure to factors
terms of person's active search
3- Cognitive dissonance 3- Festinger / 1957 that are: internal/external/under
for meaning and satisfaction in
control/out of control
life. Thus motivation is internal.
3- Act to resolve conflict or
discrepancies.
"An integratively oriented learner would likely have a stronger desire to learn the
language, have more positive attitudes towards the learning situation, and be
more likely to expend more effort in learning the language (Gardner, 1985).
The Gardnerian theory of SLA motivation is based on the definition of motivation
as "the extent to which the individual works or strives to learn the language
because of a desire to do so and the satisfaction experienced in this activity"
(Gardner, 1985).
E- Deci & Ryan (1985): Self-Determination (autonomy) Theory: it is
based on the relationship between extrinsic and intrinsic motivation
and the basic human need for autonomy. It proposes that a person
must be able to initiate and regulate, through personal choice, the
effort expended to complete a task in order for the task to be
intrinsically rewarding.
Intrinsic motivation: the performance of a task for its own sake.
It values rewards gained through the process of task
completion, regardless of any external rewards.
Extrinsic motivation: the pursuit of some reward external to the
completion of the task, such as good grades. It is believed to
undermine intrinsic motivation; individuals will often lose their
intrinsic interest in a task if the task is seen as a means to an
end.
<=> Extrinsic or Intrinsic Motivation, depending on whether the
stimulus for the behavior originated outside or inside the individual.
F- Dornyei (1990): He postulated a motivational construct consisting of:
an Instrumental Motivational Subsystem
an Integrative Motivational Subsystem
Need for Achievement
Attribution about past failures.
"Instrumental motivation might be more important than integrative motivation for foreign language
learners."
.
* environmental support (i.e., extent of teacher and peer support, and the integration of cultural
and outside-of-class support into learning experience)
integrative motives;
affective motives;
language attitudes;
intrinsic motives/attitudes towards L2
learning/enjoyment/interest;
self-concept;
confidence/self-efficacy;
anxiety/inhibitions;
success/failure-related (attributional) factor;
expectancy;
need for achievement;
Effort
Valence
B- Vroom (1964) Expectancy Value Theories: Expectancy
Ability
Instrumentality
Attitudes
Beliefs about self
Six factors that impact motivation in Goals
H- Oxford & Shearin (1994)
language learning Involvement
Environmental support
Personal attributes
Language Level,
I- Dornyei (1994) Taxonomy of motivation Learner Level, and
Learning Situation Level.
Motivation of instrumentality
Intrinsic motivation
J- Wen (1997) Incorporated expectancy-value theories
Expected learning strategies and efforts
Passivity towards requirements.
1. affective/integrative
2. instrumental/pragmatic
3. macro-context-related
K- Dornyei (1998) Seven main motivational dimensions 4. self-concept-related
5. goal-related
6. educational context-related
7. significant others-related
8- Factors that Affect Motivation
.
"Motivation to learn is a competence acquired through general experience but stimulated most
directly through modeling, communication of expectations, and direct instruction or socialization by
significant others (especially parents and teachers)." (Brophy, 1987)
"To a very large degree, students expect to learn if their teachers expect them to learn."
(Stipek, 1988)
Several factors affect students' motivation to learn a second language.
.
Internal Factors
Age cf. Piaget, Maslow, Alderfer, Erikson, Vygotsky, ...
Girls are known to acquire languages faster than boys. Hence,
Gender
their motivation would be higher.
Religion .
Goals Why the learner is studying the language.
Need How much the learner needs to study this language.
Interest (and curiosity) How interested the learner is in learning this language.
Attitude How the learner views this language and its speakers.
Expectancy How much the learner expects to succeed.
Judging own ability and competence.
Self-efficacy / Competence
How capable of success they think they are.
The more academically sophisticated the student's native
language knowledge and abilities, the easier it will be for that
Native language proficiency
student to learn a second language, then the more motivated
s/he will be.
First foreign language .
External Factors
Encouragement
· Expectations
· Feedback
· Scaffolding
Teachers · Task presentation
· Teaching strategies & techniques
· Rewards
Relevance
Course content & Classroom atmosphere Attractiveness
Challenge
Relaxed, positive atmosphere (low affective filter)
Oxford & Shearin (1996:139) also offer Practical Suggestions for Teachers:
1. Teachers can identify why students are studying the new language.
Teachers can find out actual motivations (motivation survey).
Information on motivation can be passed on to the next class in a portfolio.
Teachers can determine which parts of L2 learning are especially valuable for the students.
2. Teachers can help shape students' beliefs about success and failure in L2 learning.
3. Teachers can help students improve motivation by showing that L2 learning can be an exciting
mental challenge, a career enhancer, a vehicle to cultural awareness and friendship and a key to
world peace.
4. Teachers can make the L2 classroom a welcoming, positive place where psychological needs are
met and where language anxiety is kept to a minimum.
5. Teachers can urge students to develop their own intrinsic rewards through positive self-talk,
guided self-evaluation, and mastery of specific goals, rather than comparison with other students.
Teachers can thus promote a sense of greater self-efficacy, increasing motivation to continue
learning the L2.
There are a variety of specific actions that teachers can take to increase motivation on
classroom tasks. In general, these fall into the two categories discussed above: intrinsic
motivation and extrinsic motivation. (Huitt, 2001)
Intrinsic Extrinsic
Some teaching strategies that can be used to foster motivation and provide better transfer opportunities of
language skills include the following: (Ngeow, Karen Yeok-Hwa, 1998)
* Encourage learners to take ownership in learning.
Have learners take ownership of the learning assignment by letting them identify and decide for themselves
them to apply what they have learned to attain these learning goals.
"The best way to create interest in a subject is to render it worth knowing, which means
to make the knowledge gained usable in one's thinking beyond the situation in which
learning has occurred." Bruner (1960, p.31)
Some effective suggestions for improving the affective climate of the SL learning environment:
By Paula Kristmanson
•Encourage and support students at all times but especially when they are
struggling or lacking confidence in certain areas.
•Be energetic and enthusiastic about what you are teaching and on those days
when you do not have that energy, provide activities that require the learners to
put forth the majority of the energy.
•Create an atmosphere in which students are not afraid to make mistakes and are
encouraged to take risks.
•Avoid tension-causing strategies such as surprise quizzes, overly competitive
activities, putting students in front of their peers with no warning or chance for
preparation, and correcting errors in a negative, accusatory fashion.
•Allow students opportunities to talk about themselves, their interests, and their
culture.
•Through preplanned and spontaneous activities, provide opportunities for
interaction in the target language in and outside the language learning
environment.
•Encourage goal setting and a sense of dedication and continuous commitment to
the language learning task through meaningful, relevant and authentic language
learning activities.
•Encourage learners to seek out opportunities in their lives that will help in the
learning of the target language.
•Create, through the presentation of attainable goals and reasonable challenges, a
learning environment with a definite potential for success.
•Recognize the "little successes", improvements and progress of all students both
individually and with the entire group.
Students:
Walking your talk is a great way to motivate yourself. No one likes to live a lie. Be honest with
yourself, and you will find the motivation to do what you advise others to do.
--Vince Poscente (Invinceable Principles)
YOU CAN BE WHATEVER YOU WANT TO BE
by Donna Levine
There is inside you
all of the potential to be whatever
you want to be
all of the energy to do whatever
you want to do.
Imagine yourself as you would like to be,
doing what you want to do,
and each day, take one step
towards your dream.
And though at times it may seem too
difficult to continue,
hold on to your dream.
One morning you will awake to find
that you are the person
you dreamed of
doing what you wanted to do
simply because you had the courage
to believe in your potential
and to hold on to your dream.
http://www.wow4u.com/youcan/index.html
Additional sites:
Keys to Motivation
http://www.motivation123.com/keys.html
Techniques to Help You Get Motivated Today
http://www.motivation123.com/motiv-fortuneteller.html
Get Up and Go - Motivation
http://www.study.com.au/magic/skills/motivate.html
Motivation is the force that causes you to take action - apply the effort & commitment needed to do something.
There are two important parts to motivation:
People tend to be most successful when working toward positive outcomes on things they find
personally fulfilling. In such cases they will do whatever it takes to get the result that they want. One
of the most important tasks is to decide what you want . . .
If you don't plan where you are heading, you might end up in an occupation or life style that is not
very satisfying.
If you haven't decided yet, identify a range of wishes for the future, and set about exploring the
background of people who have achieved that lifestyle.
Mapping out a plan to achieve your dreams is often called writing up a list of goals. Click here (
http://www.study.com.au/ideal/idpdf/studentp/goal_sample_page.pdf) for an example.
Make a Treasure Map of your Goals:
Make a map of the things that you wish to achieve during your life.
Start by listing the key areas, then adding more detail.
You will notice that each time you return to your map
your vision for the future will become clearer.
Use words, drawings or pictures from magazines.
Start with a picture of yourself.
A good strategy is to make a poster size collage for your
bedroom wall to help you focus on your goals each day.)
Whatever you call your preferred future direction, write it down, draw
it, paint it, make a collage of your direction and work toward it.
If you can find something better, simply adjust you goals and
direction.
Remember to link your goals to your school work.
To create greater motivation for your school work take time to find as
many positive connections between the subjects you are doing and
possible benefits for achieving your goals.
What is motivation?
http://www.unisanet.unisa.edu.au/motivation/
Motivation is a desire to achieve a goal, combined with the energy to work
towards that goal. Students who are motivated have a desire to undertake
their study and complete the requirements of their course.
Are you a motivated student?
Being a motivated student doesn’t mean you are always excited or fully
committed to your study, but it does mean you will complete the tasks set for
you even when assignments or practicals are difficult, or seem uninteresting.
Give yourself some quality time to work through the steps in this program.
Eight step plan to help you search for, and find motivation. The eight step plan for finding motivation to
study can be shown as:
Step 1 Give yourself time
Step 2 Work with all of you
Step 3 Focus on goals
Step 4 Make study a priority
Step 5 Feel good about yourself
Step 6 Take care of your health
Step 7 Visualization
Step 8 Build on your knowledge
1- Give yourself time
You probably have not lost motivation overnight. You will need to give yourself
time to find it again. Lost objects are most easily found when you:
· are calm
· have some time to search
· are able to concentrate on one thing at a time
How can you begin to relax, give yourself time and concentrate on one thing at a
time?
When you have completed the "My Goals" table ask you self the question:
Where does study rate on my list of important goals?
If
· study has been omitted from your list of goals or
· is a low priority or
· is not achievable,
then you are experiencing loss of motivation to study.
There may be many aspects of your life that are important to you other than study. You
may, for example,
· have family commitments,
· want to have paid employment,
· you may want to travel overseas.
Any of these may be more important goals for you than study.
If you have a large number of goals, or study is a low priority for you, you may choose
to
· make an appointment with a counselor,
· talk with a friend or
· see a teacher
about what is happening for you in relation to study and how you can decide which
goals to make priorities.
Next Step:
You can either
· talk with a friend about your priorities or,
· make an appointment to see a teacher or
· make an appointment to see a counselor or
4- Make study a priority
If in Step 3 you discovered that study is a priority for you right now, you will need to get yourself going.
When you have answered the questionnaire you will have completed a study plan for yourself
which includes goals, time management and self rewards. With a study plan you will be able to
undertake study and will be well on your way in your search for motivation.
You might also like to search out how to:
manage your time and study workload
avoid procrastination
5- Feel good about yourself
Feeling good about yourself and recognizing your achievements may be a key factor in helping you find
motivation. When we have a sense of well being and self esteem we can tackle difficult or uninteresting tasks with
a positive outlook.
Use the "Feeling good about yourself" questionnaire to discover positive attributes about yourself and
how to use them. You might find collecting positive attributes about yourself a difficult task. You could
ask a close friend or a family member about positive aspects they recognize in you.
Use the "How healthy am I?" questionnaire to assess your level of health.
Remember
Changing eating and exercise patterns is not easy.
Some experts say that small consistent changes are more effective than extreme changes to lifestyles.
Different ways of eating and different ways of including exercise seem to suit different people at different
times, eg. you might find that a short burst of regular exercise in the morning by yourself suits you; you
might find that you look forward to a weekly game of netball, basketball or badminton in the evening; or you
might find that a yoga or tai-chi class suits you
You can experiment with what suits you best.
7- Visualization: Encouraging your mind to work for you
You might find that visualizing a situation, and a context in which you have successfully achieved your
goals, is an effective motivational force. You can visualize yourself studying at your desk at home, working
through your study program easily and efficiently and then seeing
yourself completing your work and handing it up.
At weekly intervals, you can use the Keeping up the search for motivation checklist The checklist will help you
knowledge about yourself in searching for, and maintaining, your motivation to study.
http://www.unisanet.unisa.edu.au/motivation/