Production Management
Production Management
Production Management
Edition-2006
1
QUANTATITIVE MODELS IN PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
INDEX
INTRODUCTION
3
INTRODUCTION
PRODUCTION PLANNING
& CONTROL
5
PRODUCTION PLANNING & CONTROL
6
PRODUCTION PLANNING & CONTROL
7
PRODUCTION PLANNING & CONTROL
8
PRODUCTION PLANNING & CONTROL
9
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
FACTORY LOCATION
10
FACTORY LOCATION
Introduction
The prime criterion for a preferred location is the least total cost, the minimum
delivered-to-customer cost of the product or service. The location of factory may well
have a substantial effect upon the operation of the unit and on the factories within a
geographical region. No set of rules can be laid down whereby the solution to the
problem of location can be solved or programmed. There are, however, a number of
factors, such as raw material availability, labour costs, and so on, which should be
considered and these factors will be discussed in detail later.
A plant location problem is not encountered everyday, but the factors that can create
a problem are constantly developing. Technological improvements make existing
products non-competitive. New products replace established lines. A requirement for
different materials or a change in the source of materials alters supply costs, power,
water or other resource needs are subject to production levels which in turn are a
function of demand. Any or all of these factors can force a firm to question whether
its plant should be altered at the present location or moved to another locality.
11
FACTORY LOCATION
It is worth differentiating between the problem of location and of site. The location is
the general area and the site is the place chosen within the location. The decision on
siting thus probably proceeds in two stages: in the first stage the general area is
chosen and then a detailed survey of that area is carried out to find possible sites.
Thus, a study to identify the best location typically starts with an evaluation of
regional factors and progresses to particular communities within the favoured
region. Information of a general nature suffices to rate regions. They are compared
with respect to market proximity, raw material, tax rates, and other characteristics
of special interest to the organisation seeking the site. The factors affecting the choice
of a community and a particular site within the community involve specific details.
The models given here for factory location can be used for both the selection of a
location and also for the selection of a site in a particular location. The selection of a
site decision is probably made by taking into account the more detailed factors than
considered for selection of a location (……. is the view pleasant? ……. is there a good
restaurant nearby?…….).
12
FACTORY LOCATION
3. Availability of materials
While it is true that good transport facilities will enable goods to be obtained and
delivered readily, a location near main suppliers will help to reduce cost and permit
staff to go readily to see suppliers to discuss technical or delivery problems. Any
buyer who has tried to improve deliveries from an inaccessible supplier will bear
witness to the considerable difficulties involved.
4. Availability of services
There are six main services that need to be considered, namely –
a) Gas d) Drainage
b) Electricity e) Disposal of waste
c) Water f) Telephone
Certain industries use considerable quantities of water for food preparation,
laundries, metal plating, etc. Others use a great deal of electricity for chemical
processing and so on. An assessment must be made of the requirements of the factory
for as far ahead as possible. Underestimating the needs of any of the services can
prove to be extremely costly and inconvenient.
14
FACTORY LOCATION
8. Availability of labour
Labour may be more readily available in some cases than in others. The Department
of Trade & Industry can provide information on this point. Certain areas, however,
have traditional skills. For example, woollen products in Punjab and coir products in
Kerala. It is very rate today that a location can be found which has appropriate
skilled labour both readily available. (Big cities, however, could be excluded from this
generalization.) The choice has to be made between a location where skilled men
exist but are not readily available and where there is a supply of unskilled labour. It
must be remembered that new skills can be taught, processes simplified and made
less exacting and key personnel moved.
The importance of labour depends, of course, on the particular firm, its policies and
its products. If the firm is science-oriented, it should anticipate going to an area
where engineers and scientists congregate because it is unlikely that many can be
lured to remote sections.
16
FACTORY LOCATION
9. Labour stability
Thorough precautions to assure low production costs are of no avail unless the
proposed new polant can operate with continuity and tranquil labour-management
relations. More than one company has been forced out of business because of
unreasonable or prohibitive labour demands. Wage increases and jurisdictional
disputes continue to be important points of conflict.
The question of labour stability must be approached from a positive standpoint.
There are certain strong points of community attitude that should influence its
selection. Perhaps, the most crucial question that can be asked about a community is
“What is its past history?”
10. Availability of housing
Where staff has to be recruited other than locally, housing will need to be available.
It is general experience that the offer of good housing can be of greater assistance in
attracting staff than almost any other factor.
17
FACTORY LOCATION
17. Taxation
Few industries have relocated their plants solely because of unfavourable State taxes.
It is rather the cumulative effect of this factor and other high cost factors that may
prompt a manufacturer to consider relocation.
It is difficult to satisfy all the above factors for plant location. However, a
compromise between what is wanted and what can obtained may be the only solution.
20
FACTORY LOCATION
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
22
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
It is usually accepted that there are three main types of production, namely: job,
batch and flow production. It is important to realize at the outset that these types of
production are not necessarily associated with any particular volume of production
and that depending upon the circumstances the same task can be undertaken by any
of the above methods.
These three different types of production all exhibit distinct characteristics and
require different conditions for their effective inception and working. The
circumstances in any factory at any time must be carefully considered before a
decision is taken as to the method of production to be used. Frequently, the type of
production employed depends on the development of the company concerned. Many
factories start on a job production basis, proceed as volume increases to batch
production methods, in part at least, and finally manage to flow-produce all or some
of the products concerned.
23
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
24
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
By its use some degree of specialization of labour is possible, and capital investment is
kept low, although the organisation and planning required to ensure freedom from
idle and waste time is considerable. It is in batch production that the production
control department can produce most benefits, and these can often be spectacular,
but it is also in batch production that it will be found most difficult to organize the
effective working of a production control department.
In order to clarify the difference between job and batch production, consider a small
quantity of units, say five, being made by a number of operators. Under job
production conditions the operators would be divided into five groups and each
group would be responsible for the complete manufacture of one unit. Under batch
conditions, however, the work content of each unit would be broken into a number of
operations not necessarily of equal work content, and the operators would again
divide into groups. The first group would then complete the first operation on all five
units, passing the batch as a whole on to the next group and so on until the
manufacture was complete. In general, the batch is not passed on from one operator
or group to the next until all the work is completed on that operation. Transferring
part batches can often lead to considerable organizational difficulties. It should be
noted that during the batch manufacture of the five units mentioned above, four units
25are always at rest, no work being carried out on them. In fact, the rest periods of any
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
one unit from a batch of a total = (n-1)/n x 100 percent, of the total batch production
time. This is characteristic of batch production, where the work content of the
material increases irregularly and results in a substantial work-in-progress. In
addition to the rest period indicated above, the organizational difficulties of batch
production may well generate other rest times, where numbers of batches are passing
through the same production stages, and competing for resources, it is usual to move
a batch from an operator or machine into a “buffer” or “work-in-progress” stores, to
wait there for the next operator or machine to become available. The sequencing of
batches from different jobs to reduce this source of “rest” is one of the most difficult
problems encountered in the management of a production unit, and however
successfully it is solved, there will inevitably be some element of rest time brought
about by this competition for resources. Thus in batch production, there is a rest
period for each unit in the batch, whist work is proceeding on other members of the
batch, and another rest period whilst the whole batch is in buffer store. This often
results in the time between the origination of work on a batch and its eventual
completion being much greater than the simple manufacturing time for the batch.
26
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
The effect of the considerable time lag between an initial investment in material and
its subsequent translation into cash upon the sale of the finished product can be very
serious in terms of the investment in capital which is tied up in the work in progress.
On the other hand, the presence of buffer stores permits the production unit to
absorb shocks and changes, thus building in some element of flexibility, and it assists
in making more effective use of the various limited manufacturing resources. This
balancing of investment in material against investment in resources is a continually
recurring task, and one to which there is rarely a simple unique answer.
only the stage at which the fault occurs, but also all the stages in the production line.
Thus, a fault occurring at one stage of a flow production line which cannot be cleared
within the time cycle of the line, will result in that stage being held up. This, in turn,
causes all stages previous to it to be held up and all stages subsequently to run out of
work. The line as a whole, therefore, must be considered as a single entity and not
allowed to break down at any point at all.
In order that flow production can function satisfactorily, the following requirements
must be met:
1. There must be continuity of demand. Should demand be spasmodic, there will be
a build-up of finished work which can give rise to storage difficulties.
Alternatively, if production is caused to fluctuate along with demand, then the
setting up and balancing of the flow line will need to be carried out frequently,
giving an excessively high total cost. In industries with widely varying demands,
a leveling out is achieved by making for stock during the “flat” periods, the stock
supplementing the current production during “peak” periods.
28
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
2. The product must be standardized. A low line is inherently inflexible and cannot
accommodate variations in the product. A quasi variety is achieved by varying
finished, decorations and other externals.
3. Material must be to specification and delivered on time. Due to the inflexibility
mentioned above, the flow line cannot accept the variations in material which
can be incorporated in a batch or job production process. Furthermore, if
material is not available when it is required the effect is very serious, since the
whole line will be frozen.
4. All stages must be balanced. If the requirement that the material does not “rest”
is to be fulfilled, then the time taken at each stage must be the same. This can
lead to inefficiency due to inability to balance stages. For example, assume a
product with a work content of 10 hours has to be made at a rate of 400 a week,
and the normal working week is 40 hours, then –
The total weekly work content = 400 x 10 hours.
Hence the number of operations required = (400 x 10)/40 = 100
And the time for each operation = (100 / 600) hours
29 = 6 minutes.
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
To meet the required production, then, a flow line with 100 stages needs to be set
up, the work content of each stage being 6 minutes. It may be found, however,
that one stage has a work content of only 3 minutes and that it cannot be
compounded with any other stage. Under these circumstances, this stage must
have an idle time content of 3 minutes. This is known as “synchronizing loss”
and the only way of avoiding this would be to increase the rate of production so
that, in fact, all stage times could be reduced to 3 minutes. In the situation where
an element cannot be reduced to the required stage time – for example, a
machine-controlled operation is 10 minutes – then resources must be increased
so that the effective operation time becomes less than the stage time. This can
lead to an under-utilisation of resources.
5. All operations must be defined. In order that the line will maintain its balance, all
operations must remain constant. This can only be done if the operations are
recorded in detail.
30
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
31
TYPES OF PRODUCTION
The following advantages can be derived from the effective institution of flow
production techniques –
(a) The direct labour content will be reduced, since the comprehensive pre-
production planning which is necessary will often produce economies in
time.
(b) Assuming the product is initially designed correctly, then reproducibility, and
hence the accuracy, is high.
(c) Since inspection is “in line”, deviations from standard are rapidly picked up.
(d) Since there is no rest period between operations, work in process is at a
minimum.
(e) Again, since there is no waiting period, the provision of work-in-process
stores is unnecessary, and the total storage space required is minimized.
32
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
FACTORY LAYOUT
33
FACTORY LAYOUT
Introduction
The disposition of the various parts of a plant, along with all the equipment used
therein, is known as the Plant Layout, which should be designed to enable the plant to
function most effectively. Plant Layout is a companion problem to Plant Location. A
decision to relocate provides an opportunity to improve total facilities and services. A
decision not to relocate is often accompanied by plans to revise the current plant
arrangement. The re-layout must be designed to reduce increasing production costs
that gradually evolve from piecemeal expansion or to introduce an entirely new
process. In either case, the re-layout strives to maximize production flow and labour
effectiveness.
The disadvantage is that the required movement of materials and machines may be
35 cumbersome and costly.
FACTORY LAYOUT
for Product 1, Product 2 and Product 3 have their own line of machines (K,L,M, and R,S,T) and,
even though machines A,K,R are identical and interchangeable, work is not transferred from
36 one product line to another.
FACTORY LAYOUT
Advantages are:
1. Reduced handling of material.
2. Reduced amounts of material-in-process, allowing reduced production time and lower
investment in materials.
3. More effective use of labour (a) through greater job specialization and (b) through ease
of training.
4. Easier control of production allowing less paperwork and effective supervision.
5. Reduced congestion of floor space otherwise allotted to aisles and storage.
Disadvantages are:
1. Unless volume is very high, machine utilization may be low, with a subsequent high
capital investment.
2. One machine breakdown may immobilize a complete production line.
3. The system is inflexible, being unable to accommodate changes.
4. Unless the production is true flow production and all operations balanced, buffer stock
(work-in-process) will be inevitable.
5. The pace of the line is set by the slowest operation.
6. Any changes in product design, volume, etc., in the line will normally require a major
investment.
37
FACTORY LAYOUT
38
FACTORY LAYOUT
Advantages are:
1. Better machine utilization allows lower machine investment.
2. It is adapted to a variety of products and to frequent changes in sequence of operations.
3. It is adapted to intermittent demand (varying production schedules).
4. The incentive for individual workers to raise the level of their performance is greater.
5. It is easier to maintain continuity of production in the event of –
(a) machine or equipment breakdown;
(b) shortages of material;
(c) absent workers.
Disadvantages are:
1. Substantial pre-production planning is required if machine loading is to be high.
2. Control is difficult.
3. Buffer stocks are essential; hence, relatively high investment in raw materials and work-
in-progress.
4. It increases handling, space requirements and production time.
5. Close supervision is essential.
39
FACTORY LAYOUT
40
FACTORY LAYOUT
In actual practice, most layouts are a combination of the basic layouts discussed above.
They are made to utilize the advantage of all three types of layout.
Criteria for a good layout -
While the techniques employed in making a layout are normal work-study techniques, the
process is a creative one which cannot be set down with any finality, and one in which
experience plays a very great part. Furthermore, it is not possible to define a good layout
with any precision. However, there are certain criteria which will be satisfied by a good
layout, and these are discussed below:
41
FACTORY LAYOUT
1. Maximum Flexibility
A good layout will be one which can be rapidly modified to meet changing circumstances. In
this context, particular attention should be paid to supply points, which should be ample and of
easy access. These can be simply and cheaply provided at the outset of a layout, and failure to
do so can often present very necessary modifications to unsatisfactory, outdated or inadequate
layouts.
2. Maximum Coordination
Entry into, and disposal from, any department should be in such a manner that it is most
convenient to the issuing or receiving departments. Layout requires to be considered as a
whole and not parochially.
4. Maximum Visibility
All men and materials should be readily observable at all times; there should be no
“hiding places” into which goods can get mislaid. This criterion is sometimes difficult to
fulfill, particularly when an existing plant is taken over. Every piece of partitioning or
screening should be scrutinized most carefully while introducing undesirable segregation
and reducing effective floor space.
5. Maximum Accessibility
All servicing and maintenance points should be readily accessible. For example, a
machine should not be placed against a wall in such a manner that a grease-gun cannot
reach the grease nipples. The maintenance under these circumstances is likely to be
skimped at best and will occupy excessive time. Similarly, a piece of plant in front of a
fuse box will impede the work of the electricians and may cause unnecessary stoppage of
the machine when the fuse box is opened. If it is impossible to avoid obscuring a serviced
point, then the equipment concerned should be capable of being moved. It should not be a
permanent installation.
43
FACTORY LAYOUT
6. Minimum Distance
All movements should be both necessary and direct. Handling material adds to the cost of the
product but does not increase its value. Consequently, any unnecessary or circuitous
movements should be avoided. It is a common failing for material to be moved off a work-
bench to a temporary storage point. This intermediate rest place is often unnecessary and
unplanned, being used only because an empty space appears convenient. The providing of
‘extra’ shelves, benches and tables should be questioned very thoroughly and avoided if
possible.
7. Minimum Handling
The best handling is no handling, but where handling is unavoidable it should be reduced to a
minimum by the use of conveyors, lifts, chutes, hoists and trucks. Material being worked on
should be kept at working height and never placed on the floor if it is to be lifted later.
8. Minimum Discomfort
Poor lighting, excessive sunlight, heat, noise, vibrations and odour should be minimized and if
possible counteracted. Apparently, trivial discomforts often generate troubles greatly out of
proportion to the discomfort itself. Attention paid to the lighting and general decoration and
furniture can be rewarding without being costly. Recommendations on the intensity of lighting
for various tasks are published and most manufacturers of lighting equipment will provide
useful advise on the subject.
44
FACTORY LAYOUT
9.Inherent Safety
All layouts should be inherently safe, and no person should be exposed to danger. Care must be
taken not only of the persons operating the equipment but also of the passers-by, who may be
required to go behind a machine, the back of which is unguarded. Adequate medical facilities
and services must be provided, and these must satisfy the Chief Inspector of Factories.
Experience shows that the factory inspector is not only most competent to advise on these
matters, he is always ready to be of assistance.
10.Maximum Security
Safeguards against fire, moisture, theft and general deterioration should be provided, as far as
possible, in the original layout.
11.Unidirectional Flow
Work lanes and transport lanes must not cross. At every point in a factory, material must flow
in one direction only, and a layout which does not conform to this will result in considerable
difficulties, if not downright chaos, and should be avoided.
45
FACTORY LAYOUT
12.Visible Routes:
Definite lines of travel should be provided and, if possible, clearly marked. No gangways should
ever be used for storage purposes, even temporarily.
The co-existence of a large number of criteria makes the definition of an “optimum” schedule
virtually impossible. Furthermore, the writing of a computer programme for plant layout
becomes a task of considerable difficulty unless some very drastic simplifications are made.
46
FACTORY LAYOUT
1. The overall process time and cost will be minimized by reducing unnecessary handling
and by generally increasing the effectiveness of all work.
2. Labour supervision and production control will be simplified by the elimination of hidden
corners in which both men and materials can be misplaced.
3. Changes in programme will be most readily accommodated.
4. Total output from a given plant will be as high as possible by making the maximum
effective use of available space.
5. A feeling of unity amongst employees will be encouraged by avoiding unnecessary
segregation.
6. Quality of products will be sustained by safer and better methods of production.
47
FACTORY LAYOUT
1. Lack of control.
2. Congestion of men and materials.
3. Excessive re-handling.
4. Long transportation lines.
5. Frequent accidents.
6. Low worker performance.
48
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
PRODUCTIVITY
49
PRODUCTIVITY
Productivity is a measure of how much input is required to produce a given output, i.e.,
it is the ratio of output to input.
Measurement of productivity
1) Labour productivity = amount of output
amount of labour
2) Capital productivity = sales turnover
capital employed
3) Profit productivity = profit
investment
52
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
53
MATERIALS MANAGEMENT
Materials Management is the planning, directing, controlling and coordinating those activities
which are concerned with materials and inventory requirements, from the point of their
inception to their introduction into the manufacturing process. It begins with the determination
of materials, quality and quantity and ends with its issuance to production to meet customer’s
demand as per schedule and at the lowest cost.
INVENTORY CONTROL
55
INVENTORY CONTROL
Inventory control
Inventory is referred to accumulation of items or goods required by the
company for its products or as an aid to production. A manufacturing firm
generally carries the following 7 major classification of items with
inventories:
56
INVENTORY CONTROL
STEPS TO INSTALL A
SCIENTIFIC INVENTORY CONTROL SYSTEM
58
INVENTORY CONTROL
EOQ MODEL
Assumptions:
• The demand of the item occurs uniformly over the period at the
known rate.
• The replenishment of stock is instantaneous.
• The price per unit is fixed and is independent of the order size.
• The cost to place an order and process the delivery is fixed and does
not vary with the lot size.
• The inventory carrying charges vary directly and linearly with the
size of the inventory and are expressed as a percentage of average
inventory investment.
• The item can be procured in the quantities desired, there being no
restriction of any kind.
• The item has fairly long shelf life, there being no fear of deterioration
or spoilage.
59
INVENTORY CONTROL
Preparation of model
Two costs are involved for the inventory decisions :
Procurement cost and Inventory carrying cost.
60
INVENTORY CONTROL
= S x Cp
q
61
INVENTORY CONTROL
1 Order Inventory
Annual Inventory = Price per
x x carrying
Carrying Cost 2 Quantity Unit
cost
= q x Cu x i
2
Annual Inventory = S q x Cu x i
x Cp +
Carrying Cost q 2
62
INVENTORY CONTROL
qo =
√ C .i
2 . S . Cp
u
63
INVENTORY CONTROL
Therefore -
Economic order Quantity =
√
2 x [ Annual Consumption (units)] x [ Procurement cost/order ]
Price /unit x Inventory carrying cost
64
INVENTORY CONTROL - ILLUSTRATIONS
• A company uses 75 numbers of an item per month. Each unit cost the company Rs.25/-.The
cost of ordering is Rs.36 and inventory carrying charges is 1.5% of average inventory
investment per month respectively.
In what economic lots should the item be purchased to minimize total cost? It minimizes
waste by identifying the causes of excessive variability in the quality of product.
• Impellers are procured by the water pump manufacturer from a local firm and are
consumed at an average rate of 500 numbers per month. If the procurement cost is Rs.36 per
order and the cost of holding it in stock is Rs.1.20 per unit per year, determine the quantity
that should be procured at a time to optimize the cost involved.
If the consumption of the above item increases to 40 numbers per day and its actual
inventory carrying cost is Rs.0.2 per unit per day, what shall be its revised EOQ quantity?
• A manufacturer of control panels spends Rs.3400 per annum on its purchasing activities.
Rs.67200 is spent each year in maintaining inventory of Rs.4.21 lacs (expenses referred above
are only the variable portion of the total expense).Around 850 orders are placed every year
to replenish stocks of the various items. One of the items whose annual consumption is 9600
numbers is bought by the company at the rate of Rs.30 each. How frequently should the
company receive the staggered deliveries and in what quantities?
65
INVENTORY CONTROL - ILLUSTRATIONS
• The requirements of a particular size of oil seal at an automobile firm is estimated at 40,000
numbers next year. The oil seal is available locally with a lead time of two weeks and it cost
Rs.10 each.
The cost of order writing, follow up, primary inspection and inward stores is computed at
Rs.50 per order. The holding cost is estimated at Rs.2 per unit for storage plus 20% per unit
per year on account of opportunity cost of the capital.
a) How many units should the firm order at a time to optimize the inventory cost?
b) What is the annual inventory cost?
• ABC Pump Company uses 60,000 valves per year and the usage is fairly constant at 5000
valves per month. Each valve cost the company Rs.1.50. The carrying cost for the company
has been estimated at 15% of the average inventory investment. The cost to place an order
and process the delivery is Rs.30.
a) Calculate economic order quantity.
b) What is stock turnover rate ignoring safety stocks if EOQ is ordered frequently?
c) What will be the effect on total cost if stock turnover rate is reduced to one third by
infrequent ordering?
66
INVENTORY CONTROL - ILLUSTRATIONS
• A manufacturer of a hand grinder requires a special roller bearing at the rate of 300
numbers per year. Each bearing cost the company Rs.36. The procurement cost and the
inventory carrying cost have been calculated at Rs.30 and 20% respectively.
If the supplier offers discount of Rs.2 per bearing on an order of 200 or above, should higher
quantity be purchased?
• A chemical firm buys 2500 units of a particular item annually from a vendor at a cost of Rs.3
per unit. It has now received a revised price schedule from the vendor which is as follows:
Order quantity Price per unit
Less than 500 units Rs. 3
Between 500 and 1250 units Rs.2.90
1250 units and above Rs.2.85
The total of placing an order and executing the delivery once is Rs.25 and inventory carrying
cost as a percentage of average inventory investment is 20%. Determine the economic order
quantity of the item.
67
INVENTORY CONTROL - ILLUSTRATIONS
• Monthly consumption of an item having unit price of Re.1 has been estimated at 300 units.
The inventory carrying cost and the procurement cost for the company have been computed
at 18% and Rs.36 per order respectively. Stock records show that this item can normally be
procured within a period of one month. If the company adheres to the policy of one month
safety stock for all ‘A’ and ‘B’ category of items.
Calculate –
re-order quantity
minimum level
re-order level
maximum level
average inventory
assuming re-order level system of replenishment.
68
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
MATERIAL HANDLING
69
MATERIAL HANDLING
Material handling may be broadly defined as the movements of materials from one place
to another. It may be picking up or putting down, moving horizontally or vertically or in
any inclined plans of materials, of any kind in their raw, semi-finished or finished state.
OBJECTIVE
Material handling often does not add anything to the value of the product but only
increases the cost. Handling costs constitute a substantial portion of the total cost of
production. Besides, material handling is also found to be responsible for a large
percentage of product damage. 80 to 90% of industrial accidents and other disadvantages.
In spite of this, material handling is an essential feature of industrial activity. Materials
have to be moved from one place to another without which all the activities would come to
a standstill. Material handling often accounts for improved utilization of men and
machines, and provides for specialization of skills and the related advantages.
Since material handling cannot be eliminated completely in any organisation, the objective
of material handling may be stated as instituting an efficient system of handling.
Eliminating unnecessary and wasteful handling system saves money and time, reduces
damage to materials and makes the work safer.
70
MATERIAL HANDLING
Some Principles
Some of the major principles in the design of an efficient system of material handling are:
a) Reduce handling to a minimum: As far as possible, materials should always move
towards completion, over the shortest distance without back-tracking. A large amount of
handling can be eliminated by planning the location of operations so that one operation
finishes right where the next begins. The flow of product should receive top priority in
planning of layout.
c) Combine handling with other operations: Many times, handling may be made a
productive activity by combining with other operations, such as production, inspection
and storage. In process industries, materials undergo physical and chemical changes while
in movement, handling devices may be used as live storage of materials may be sorted and
inspected while they are being handled.
71
MATERIAL HANDLING
e) Handle materials in unit loads: It is easier and quicker to move a number of materials
at a unit rather than piece by piece. Modern material handling devices are designed to
take advantage of unutilized loads.
f) Use gravity where possible and mechanical means, if necessary: The simplest and
cheapest way to handle materials is by using gravity. Often chutes and inclined boards can
be conveniently used to transport materials quickly to the point of use without much
investment on costly handling equipment. Where it is not possible to use gravity for
various practical reasons, some mechanical means should be considered. Lifting and
carrying of heavy materials mechanically saves time and reduces fatigue of workers.
72
MATERIAL HANDLING
g) Select proper handling equipment: There are as many types of handling equipment
available today as the number of materials to be handled. And any single equipment may
not solve all handling problems. It is therefore necessary to choose the equipment suitable
for the job under consideration. The equipment selection needs to be done carefully so
that there is an efficient coordination of all handling, resulting in overall economy. Use of
standardized equipment facilitates maintenance and repair.
Another important factor in the selection of equipment is flexibility. Industrial activity is
subject to constant changes and handling equipment should provide for this change. In
other words, the equipment selected should be capable of a variety of uses and
applications.
73
MATERIAL HANDLING
i) Buy equipment for overall savings: In selecting equipment, savings in overall handling
cost must be the guiding principle rather than the first cost of equipment. Arriving at the
handling cost is a difficult problem but a fairly accurate estimate can be obtained by
determining the handling elements and applying work measurement.
In India, labour is still comparatively less costly and a longer period may have to be
allowed for amortizing the handling equipment. All direct and indirect savings are to be
taken into consideration while deciding on handling equipment.
j) Use labour consistent with handling jobs: Manual handling could be done by unskilled
labour, whereas mechanical handling may require semi-skilled or skilled workers. Proper
allocation of skills helps in overall economy. As far as possible, direct production
operators should not be used for handling operations. It is preferable to have a separate
gang of material handlers to ensure proper utilization of production workers.
k) Train workers and maintain equipment: Careful operation and proper upkeep are
essential for getting the maximum out of the handling equipment. Careful selection and
training of employees in principles, operation and safety rules and planned maintenance of
equipment are worthwhile investments in the long run.
74
MATERIAL HANDLING
75
MATERIAL HANDLING
A second characteristic of conveyors is that, unless they are of the portable type, they
occupy space continuously. As a result, they must be installed in locations in which they
will not interfere with the flow of other traffic. For example, if two work stations are
located on opposite sides of an aisle which is used as a path of travel by men and trucks, a
floor mounted conveyor could not be used to link these two work stations. Therefore,
unless cross traffic can be bypassed, no serious consideration would be given to the use of
conveyors.
In so far as listing of different types of conveyors is concerned, the ones most frequently
encountered are the following:
Gravity Conveyor: As the name implies, gravity conveyors rely on nature for their driving
force. Roller, wheel and chute conveyors call in this category. They are used primarily to
move materials and are a relatively inexpensive type of conveyor as a rule, although for
some applications, such as in moving grain, they can be quite expensive. Compared with
other types, gravity conveyors are highly flexible and transportable and are well suited to
variable paths. Movement is restricted, however, to route that involves some degree of
vertical fall.
76
MATERIAL HANDLING
Endless chain conveyors: These conveyors are usually driven by an electric motor and, as
a consequence, are usually more expensive than gravity conveyors. They have several
important advantages, however. These conveyors can move materials up as well as down,
and the progress of the materials can be closely controlled. In addition, special carrying
devices and containers can be attached to the chain. Frequently, production tasks such as
dip painting, cleaning and washing may be performed as the conveyor moves. Finally, by
varying the speed of the conveyor at different points, or by building loops into it, work-in-
process inventory may be stored between operating stages.
Belt conveyors: Belt conveyors are also driven by electric motors. These belts are usually
made of some flexible material such as rubber. However, special belts are used in many
industries. In the baking industry, for example, Teflon-coated metal is utilized to prevent
sticking. The belt passes over rollers, which normally create a trough in the centre of the
belt where the materials are concentrated. Conveyors of this sort are used mainly for
transporting bulky material. Baggage is moved from the ground to the baggage
compartments of airplanes and shipped by conveyor belts. They are also used to move
ores from the min face to work areas. Stock brokerage firms and insurance companies
even use them to route papers to various parts of their buildings. When work is to be
performed, however, the materials must be taken from the belt and later replaced when
the work is completed.
77
MATERIAL HANDLING
Other conveyor equipment: Pipelines are often employed for moving liquids and gases
such as gasoline and natural gas. Pneumatic tubes are used in some firms for rapid
dissemination of internal communications.
Screw conveyors have been successfully used to lift materials in both grain elevators and
food-processing industry to move delicate foods in steady streams without damage.
Industrial trucks: Industrial trucks which represent the second category of material
handling equipment, are vehicles powered by hand, fuel or electricity, which are capable
of transporting materials horizontally between any two points. As opposed to a conveyor,
a truck is able to more from one location to any other location so long as suitable traveling
surface is available and its path of travel is not obstructed. For this reason, the prevalent
method of handling material in a firm engaged in intermittent manufacturing is by means
of trucks. The variable path of travel they are able to follow permits them to transport
materials from one work station to any of a number of other work stations at which a
subsequent operation is scheduled to be performed.
A second desirable feature of trucks is that they occupy a given amount of space
intermittently. This means that a certain amount of space in a given location is required to
house a truck for only as long as the truck is in that location. As soon as the vehicle is
moved, the space is free for other uses.
78
MATERIAL HANDLING
As in the case of conveyors, there are many types of trucks, and each of these can be
equipped with a variety of attachments. But the most important ones are as follows:
Hand operated vehicles, tractors, platform trucks, forklift trucks, straddle carriers.
When the loads are not too heavy and the hauls are short, manual equipment may be
used. However, when the load size and weight and the distances to be traveled are great,
powered equipment is used. Today, most industrial trucks are powered. They are
generally equipped with forks or platforms that can be raised or lowered to facilitate the
movement and storage of materials, and for this reason the loads are generally placed on
pallets or skids.
Cranes and hoists:
The third classification of material handling equipment consists of cranes and hoists. This
equipment is able to move materials vertically and laterally in any area of limited length,
width and height. It is used primarily when material must be lifted prior to being moved
from one point to another. These points may represent different work stations or different
locations at a single work station. For example, if a part is large or heavy, the operator
may find it necessary to use a hoist to aid him in loading or unloading the machine.
Subsequently, a crane may be used to move the part to another work-station.
79
MATERIAL HANDLING
One of the advantages of cranes and hoists is that they are able to transport objects through
the overhead space in the plant. Consequently, space is utilized, which would otherwise be
unused, and floor space is freed for other uses. To illustrate, it might be possible to move a
large heavy casting by means of a truck from one work-station to another. However, this
would create a need for wide aisles at appropriate locations in the plant. If a floor space is at a
premium, a more desirable alternative would be to transport the item through the air by
means of a crane which would either eliminate the need for certain aisles or, at least, permit
the use of aisles which may be required for the movement of smaller objects. But there are
cases in which cranes and hoists are used, not because they free floor space but because they
are the best available means of positioning material in a particular location.
However, when considering cranes and hoists, it is important to keep in mind that any one
unit of this equipment is capable of serving on a limited area.The size and shape of this area
will vary with the kind of crane or hoist being used. Nevertheless, the equipment is somewhat
more flexible in this respect than are conveyors, but not a flexible as are industrial trucks.
Also, it will be found that cranes and hoists are as likely to be used intermittently as in
continuous production.
Again, there are many types of equipment which are placed in the crane and hoist category.
However, the most common ones are the following: overhead bridge cranes, gantry cranes,
jib cranes, elevators, lifts, chain hoists, air hoists, electric hoists.
80
MATERIAL HANDLING
Overhead bridge crane are commonly employed in factories where large, heavy pieces of
equipment such as electrical transformers, generators and power regulators are
manufactured. These cranes ride on parallel overhead rails and are usually designed so
that they can service any place in the work area of the plant.
Another common type of crane, which is designed for outside work, is the gantry crane. It
moves in limited areas on wheels, providing its own superstructure, and is chiefly used for
such tasks on moving lumber and loading and unloading in railroad freight yards. Large
cranes of this sort must be disassembled if they are to be moved from one location to
another. This is their main limitation.
Elevators and lifts are used to raise everything from materials to workers. Since moving
materials on this type of equipment is quite costly, the modern trend is to construct one
storey plants, thus eliminating the need to raise and lower material between floors.
81
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
JOB SEQUENCING
82
JOB SEQUENCING - ILLUSTRATIONS
Also work out the total elapsed time for an optimism sequence. What is the total machine
time on machine-A and machine-B?
83
JOB SEQUENCING - ILLUSTRATIONS
• In a machine shop 8 different products are being manufactured, each requiring time on the
two machines ‘A’ and ‘B’ as given below:
Determine the optimum sequence to minimize the total manufacturing time for all the
products.
84
JOB SEQUENCING - ILLUSTRATIONS
• We have five jobs each of which must go through three machines A, B and C in the order
ABC. Processing time in hours is as given below:
Job A B C
1 16 10 8
2 20 12 18
3 12 4 16
4 14 6 12
5 22 8 10
Determine a sequence for the five jobs that will minimize the total elapsed time. Find also
the idle time of the machines A, B and C.
85
JOB SEQUENCING - ILLUSTRATIONS
• Find an optimum sequence for the following sequencing problem of four jobs and five
machines. The processing time in hours is given below:
Job A B C D E
1 7 5 2 3 9
2 6 6 4 5 10
3 5 4 5 6 8
4 8 3 3 2 6
86
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
METHOD STUDY
87
METHOD STUDY
Method Study and Work Measurement are the two basic techniques of work study. While
Method Study aims to improve the existing methods of operations and procedures, work
measurement helps to assess the human effectiveness. Though these two are distinctly
separate techniques, they are very much interdependent. The application of both these
techniques in adequate proportions based on the nature and type of problems would result
in maximum benefits to the organisation.
Method Study is essentially concerned with finding better ways of doing work. It is a
technique of cost reduction. The philosophy of Method Study is, “there is always a better
way” and the tools of Method Study are designed to systematically arrive at this “better
way of doing a job”. Method Study can be applied to almost all types of work, whether it
be a factory, electrical or any other type of activity. The scope of Method Study is not
restricted to manufacturing industries alone, but extends to all other spheres. Methods
improvement has been very successfully adopted in banks, hospitals, offices and retailing,
in addition to defence, agriculture and all types of industries. There are various techniques
which are suitable for tackling Method Study problems on all scales and for all types of
work. There is no limit to the types of work which can be profitably studied. Another
important aspect of Method Study is that often, with limited capital expenditure, it would
be possible to obtain considerable economies in the use of resources and achieve large
monetary savings.
88
METHOD STUDY
Method Study is the systematic recording and critical examination of existing and proposed
ways of doing work, as a means of developing and applying easier and more effective
methods and reducing costs. (Definition adopted in the B.S.Glossary of terms in Work
Study.)
OBJECTIVES
The objectives of Method Study are –
i) Improve basic processes.
ii) Improve the design of plant and equipment.
iii) Improve factory, office and work place layouts and handling of materials.
iv) Improve the use of material, plant, equipment and power.
v) Improve the working procedures.
vi) Improve the working environment.
vii) Improve quality.
89
METHOD STUDY
90
METHOD STUDY
Selection of work for Method Study is the first step. The field of choice for Method Study
is quite wide and every job is amenable to improvement. But the selection of the job
should be based on scope and need for improvement, resulting economy, priority,
objective and similar other considerations. Once the job has been selected, the next step is
to record all the pertinent facts relating to the present or proposed method. There are a
variety of recording techniques suitable for different types of situations. A proper
recording is necessary since it forms the basis for further investigation. Critical
examination is the crux of Method Study. All these recorded facts are subjected to a
thorough examination. Nothing is taken for granted and each activity is challenged with a
view to get as many alternatives and improved methods as possible. All the alternative
proposals thus obtained are evaluated and the most practical and economical method is
developed. Considerable planning and preparation is necessary before the proposed
method is installed. Full cooperation and participation from the Management, Supervisors
and workers is essential for the implementation of the new method. A number of
difficulties may crop up when the proposed method is under operation. There is also a
tendency on the people to get back to the old methods with the slightest of excuses. Proper
maintenance through routine and regular checks is an important factor in the Method
Study procedure.
91
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
QUALITY CONTROL
& INSPECTION
92
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
It is important that production process meets the quantity goals established in the
production schedule, but it is of equal importance that the output meets the quality
specifications as well. To manufacture products of desired quality, control over their
quality must be exercised throughout the production and associated functions, including
production planning, procurement and distribution. Quality considerations are present in
every aspect of the production cycle – from the purchase of raw material to the customer.
Monitoring all the quality level is usually assigned to a staff group that reports to the top
management. Organisationally, this group is commonly referred to as Quality Control.
The authority that quality control exercises varies according to the relative defect of
controlling quality and to management assessment of the consequences of circulating the
defective products.
Since quality assurance enters into so many linkages within the production system, more
support is needed from all levels of management than for most of the functions. No single
department or staff can assure quality by itself. It takes cooperation of line workers, the
supervisors and related staff organisation.
Quality assurance is a skill. Like other skills, if it is not continuously exercised, it will
deteriorate. Also, it has been said that “quality is everybody’s concern.” But a job that
belongs to everybody can easily become a job that nobody does.
93
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
The overall value of the quality organisation should be judged by the ratio of cost incurred
to cost saved, and not by the glamour of its own advertisements.
Cost of vigilance versus cost of error: In most production situations, the cost of vigilance
and error varies inversely. Greater vigilance may take the form of extra time taken by
individual worker, close supervision, additional test for products and inspection of all or
portion of the output. The cost of error includes re-work, rejects and customer
dissatisfaction. Somewhere between the extremes of no vigilance and extra vigilance is a
point where control over the magnitude of errors produces a minimum total cost.
Inspection versus quality control: Inspection is an act of comparing a product with
accepted specifications or other recognized standards. The purpose of this inspection is to
know where the product conforms to or does not conform to the specified quality limits
expressed in the specifications. Units of the product found to conform are accepted;
others are rejected.
Inspection is essentially a post-mortem operation performed on the product after it has
been completely processed. As a screen operation, the purpose of inspection is to separate
products into two classes: accepted and not accepted.
Inspection operation itself adds nothing to the value of the product. Hence, the inspection
operation itself does not improve product quality and neither does it reduce rejections,
since it involves no corrective action on the operation.
94
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
The problem is, how to guarantee a product of high quality to the customer and not
burden the manufacturer with the loss of high percentage of rejections entailed by the
inspection screening operation. The answer to this lies in quality control.
Quality control is a system of inspection, analysis and action applied to a manufacturing
process so that by inspecting a small portion of the product currently produced, an
analysis of its quality can be made to determine what action is required on the operation
to achieve and maintain the desired level of quality. In its broader application, quality
control is a preventive tool and is used to minimize rejections to the end that all products
and processes will meet the specified quality limits.
When and where and how to inspect: Where to inspect depends largely on when the
inspection is scheduled. The location of most inspection stations is at the site of production
– the receiving dock for incoming shipments, the assembly area, the construction site,
distribution points, etc. In a fixed-position layout, inspectors must come to the product to
check quality at various stages of development. In product layouts, particularly
mechanized production lines, products come to the inspectors at special stations built into
the line. Receiving “floor inspectors” examine output from the individual work stations
associated with a process layout.
95
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
Deciding where to inspect during a production process is simply a matter of common sense
– when it will do the most good. Logical choices are the beginning and end of the
production process. Raw material and component inputs should be inspected to see
whether they meet expected standards. Acceptance of substandard inputs obviously
jeopardizes outgoing quality and may damage equipment or disturb process continuity.
Outgoing products are examined to protect the producer from customer discontent or
buyer rejection.
During the production process, inspection is scheduled in front of operations that are
costly, irreversible or masking. Considerable expense is avoided by eliminating defective
units before they undergo a costly phase of their development or before they pass through
a process that cannot be undone, such as welding, pouring concrete, or mixing. Chemical
operations such as painting and encapsulating may hide defects easily detectable before
the masking operation.
From the foregoing, it may appear that products are continually under inspection.
Actually, workers continually check the quality of their own or a machine’s output, but
there are just a few distinct inspection stations. Constant formal surveillance would not
only increase cost, it would also create an uncomfortable atmosphere for workers. The
timing and location of inspection points are key features in the design of any testing
programme.
96
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
How to inspect: The two basic types of inspection are called “variables” and “attribute”.
When precise measurements are made of dimensions, weight or other critical
characteristics capable of expression on a continuous scale, the products are being
subjected to variables inspection. The alternative to exact measurements is to set limits
within which the product is judged acceptable or defective. A go-no-go rating results from
an attribute inspection. Since a good or bad grading normally requires less time and skill
to make and uses lower-cost equipment than exact measurements, attribute inspection is
usually less expensive than variables inspection. It is generally assumed that the variables
measured have a normal distribution.
Precise measurements require closely calibrated devices, rulers, micrometers, scales,
meters, etc., capable of measuring the product’s fineness standard. Devices to check
attributes are designed to provide a quick verdict of acceptability – go-no-go gauges, snap
gauges, templates, etc.
Statistical sampling techniques frequently reduce inspection cost. The use of samples to
replace 100% inspection is usually appropriate for machine output where units are not so
likely to vary as are hand-crafted products. High production quantities and expensive
inspections also suggest sampling. Then there is destructive testing (the performance test
destroys the unit tested) which absolutely rules out 100% inspection.
97
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
98
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
99
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
There may be other sources of variations in a system which further cause the product to
deviate from set standards. These individual causes can be identified and eliminated
economically. The magnitude of variability due to these causes varies with the conditions
of the production process, nature of the raw material, behaviour of operations etc. These
causes are known as assignable causes. The reasons for the presence of assignable causes
can be (i) differences among workers performance (ii) differences among machines (iii)
variation in material and (iv) variation due to the interaction of any two or all the three
factors e.g. tool wear, errors in setting poor machine maintenance etc.
The chance and assignable causes combine together to lower the quality of the product.
Any item which is not in accordance with the quality specifications is known as defective
item and is liable to be rejected by producer and consumer. The object of quality control
is to minimize the proportion of defectives in the given lot.
Inspection is the method of locating defective items by examining these against
specifications and statistical quality control is to ascertain whether the variation in the
quality of the product is due to chance causes or due to assignable causes. If the process is
found to be in statistical control then it indicates that the variation in the quality is due to
chance causes only; otherwise presence of assignable causes is detected and some
corrective action is planned to improve the quality of the product. Control charts are the
basis of Statistical Quality Control technique.
100
QUALITY CONTROL & INSPECTION
A Control Chart is a graphical aid for depiction of quality variation in output from a
production process. As opposed to the aim of acceptance sampling (to reject or accept
products already produced), control charts aid in the production of a better product. The
charts have three main applications:
101
PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT
SAFETY
102
SAFETY
Safety should not affect productivity. Safety should be there for machines and for the operation
of the machines.
Take the example of a press operated by an operator, putting the material with hands, with the
operating buttons at the bottom (operated by the leg). If the synchronism between the hand and
leg misses, there could be an accident.
103
SAFETY
Whenever any or all of the following four factors come into play, an accident can occur:
104
SAFETY
Isolate the dangerous areas. Example: Forging, smelting furnaces, paint booths.
Accident preventors are –
Mask
Water-curtain
Air-curtain
105
SAFETY
• Design:
Design has to incorporate safety devices. For example, machine guard. Machine guard
should be such that it should –
hinder the work;
be able to prevent the work;
be able to withstand wear and tear;
allow for easy maintenance and lubrication of machine. A scientific
plant layout.
Another example of accident prevention: Safety clutch in gun.
106
SAFETY
• Fire protection:
You must have means for fire protection. Some areas may be “non-smoking” areas.
Fire-prevention and fire-fighting equipment like fire alarms should be kept.
• Good house-keeping:
You must have means for fire protection. Some areas may be “non-smoking” areas.
Fire-prevention and fire-fighting equipment like fire alarms should be kept.
• Working clothes:
Clothes should not be loose fitting and there should be no loose ends, e.g., ties etc. Long
beards should not be allowed.
107
SAFETY
• Others:
1. First-aid.
2. Proper escape routes in the event of an accident.
108