IAS 21 Foreign Currency
IAS 21 Foreign Currency
IAS 21 Foreign Currency
On 7 May 2006 an entity with a functional currency of dollars ($) sold goods
to a German entity for €48,000. On this date, the rate of exchange was $1 =
€ 3.2.
The sale is translated into the functional currency using the exchange rate in
place on the transaction date.
Receivables (€48,000/3.2)……………….$15,000
Revenue……………………………………………………….$15,000
On 20 July 2006 the customer paid the outstanding balance. On this date, the
rate of exchange was $1 = €3.17.
Illustration: Exchange difference on settlement
IAS 21 requires that exchange differences arising on retranslation of monetary assets and liabilities must be
recognized in profit or loss.
Treatment of year-end balances:
Do not retranslate
Other items in the statement of Non- If an item is
financial position, e.g. non- monetary carried at fair
Items value, the fair
current assets, inventory
value should be
translated on the
date it was
determined.
Illustration: Monetary Items
On 7 May 2006 an entity with a functional currency of dollars ($) sold goods
to a German entity for €48,000. On this date, the rate of exchange was $1 =
€ 3.2.
The sale is translated into the functional currency using the exchange rate in
place on the transaction date.
Receivables (€48,000/3.2)……………….$15,000
Revenue……………………………………………………….$15,000
By the reporting date of 31 July 2006, the invoice had not been settled. On
this date, the rate of exchange was $1 = € 3.4.
Illustration: Monetary Items
Receivables are a monetary item so must be retranslated into the entity’s
functional currency at the year end using the closing exchange rate.
The receivable at year end should therefore be held at $14,118
(€48,000/3.4). The following entry is required:
Profit or loss (exchange loss)…………..$882
Receivables ($15,000-$14,118)…………..$882
Criticisms of IAS 21
Lack of theoretical underpinning: It is not clear why foreign exchange gains and losses
on monetary items are recorded in profit or loss, yet foreign exchange gains and losses
arising on consolidation of a foreign operation are reported in other comprehensive
income.
Long-term items: It is argued that retranslating long-term monetary items using the
closing rate does not reflect economic substance. This is because a current exchange
rate is being used to translate amounts that will be repaid in the future.
The average rate: IAS 21 does not stipulate how to determine the average exchange
rate in the reporting period.
Monetary/non-monetary: The distinction between monetary and non-monetary items
can be ambiguous.
Foreign operations: IAS 21 uses a restrictive definition of a ‘foreign operation’. IAS 21
should use a definition of a foreign operation that is based on substance rather than legal
form.
End of Chapter 7