Ancient History Collected

@aeidemnemosyne / aeidemnemosyne.tumblr.com

Blog to collect all things ancient history that I have/will encounter in my study Focus will be on Greece, Rome, and Egypt

"The Finding of Moses" Lawrence Alma-Tadema, 1904.

Alma-Tadema is most well-known for his depictions of scenes from Greek myth. These, as well as other scenes from (an imagined) daily life in various historical time periods show of his various skills as an artist.

Luscious in its colour and the realistic composition of a group of people together, The Finding of Moses is no exception. But that is not what the focus will be on here.

Two figures stand out from the small crowd gathered here. Firstly, there is Pharaoh's daughter, who gazes at the baby Moses that is carried by two of her attendants. Of these, one might find their eye drawn to the woman carrying the basket at the front. Though shaded by the basket on her back, her complexion is considerably lighter than the others in the prossession (even lighter than Pharaoh's daughter).

If this woman is a personal attendant to the princess (or, in less lovely but probably more accurate terms, a slave), it would not be too far-fetched to conclude that Alma-Tadema has depicted a North-African woman with albinism.

The perception of people with albinism in antiquity is not always clear. For one, it differs per time-period and region whether this condition impacted someone negatively to a major or minor degree. Overall, it would have contributed to a feeling of exclusion from the general populace.

Within the context of the painting, and some accounts of people with albinism being seen as closer to gods or bringing fortune in and of themselves, it makes sense that this woman could be part of the inner circle of the royal family.

Recommended reading: Hilton, John Laurence. “Albinism in the Ancient Mediterranean World.” Journal for the Study of Religion 34, no. 1 (2021): 1–28. https://www.jstor.org/stable/27117876.

"IV. Transformation of females into males is not anchange of sex. idle story. We find in the Annals that in the consulship of Publius Licinius Crassus and Gaius Cassius Longinus a girl at Casinum was changed into a boy, under the observation of the parents, and at the order of the augurs was conveyed away to a desert island. Licinius Mucianus has recorded that he personally saw at Argos a man named Arescon who had been given the name of Arescusa and had actually married a husband, and then had grown a beard and developed masculine attributes and had taken a wife; and that he had also seen a boy with the same record at Smyrna. I myself saw in Africa a person who had turned into a male on the day of marriage to a husband; this was Lucius Constitius, a citizen of Thysdritum. . . ."

  • from: Pliny the Elder, Natural History, 7.4

Between information on the birth of twins and triplets, Pliny the Elder makes a brief mention of trans-masculine persons (as well as intersex people in 7.3). What his exact reasons are for this are unclear. It does provide us with the possibility that one could socially transition in Antiquity, and that a new name/presentation was even accepted in f.e. the case of Arescon.

Recommended reading: Parker, Holt N. “The Myth of the Heterosexual: Anthropology and Sexuality for Classicists.” Arethusa 34, no. 3 (2001): 313–62. http://www.jstor.org/stable/44578440.
"29. Hagestratus with headaches. He suffered from insomnia on account of headaches. When he came to the Abaton he fell asleep and saw a dream. It seemed to him that the god cured him of his headaches and, making him stand up naked, taught him the lunge used in the pancratium. When day came he departed well, and not long afterwards he won in the pancratium at the Nemean games."

At an Asclepieion, someone suffering from a kind of illness could go to seek a cure. The above text comes from a stele found at Epidaurus that is dated to the 4th century BCE. It lists roughly forty accounts of visitors relaying their ailments and the subsequent cure they received from Asclepius.

Hagestratus, in addition, was taught a move to win a wrestling game.

Recommended reading: Renberg, Gil. Where Dreams May Come (2 vol. set), (Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill, 01 Jan. 2017) doi: https://doi-org.proxy-ub.rug.nl/10.1163/9789004330238.

Icosahedral (20-sided) quartz crystal die, Roman 1st-3rd centuries AD, collection of The Musée du Louvre.

The Louvre account tells us that it is 1cm high, rock crystal – “en cristal de roche” – and Roman empire period.

Each face has a Latin letter on it, and also the corresponding Roman numeral. The ten lateral faces bear the letters A to K, and the numerals 1 to 10.  The upper five triangles bear the letters L to P and the numbers 11 to 15.  The lower five triangles bear the letters Q to V, and the numbers 16-20.

This item is by no means unique.  A considerable number of polyhedral dice have been recovered from all over the Roman empire.  The majority are inscribed with Greek or Latin numbers or letters.

One unique example was an icosahedron – 20 sided dice – found in Egypt, which had the name of a different Egyptian god on each side.

What were these things used for?  Obviously they were intended to be thrown, and to give a random result.  But what then?

One often-heard explanation is that they were used in conjunction with divination handbooks.  There is a 2nd/3rd century Greek oracle book, the Homeromanteion, preserved in three papyri, which refers to throwing lots to obtain a number, which can be used to look up ready-prepared oracle questions and answers.

Thracian Tattoos

"Thracian Woman killing Orpheus" Pistoxenos Painter, circa 470-460 BC. NAMA nr. 15190.

Earlier this year, during an excursion to Greece, I came across this fragmented cup at the National Archaeological Museum in Athens. It bears the image of the murder of Orpheus by a Maenad (or at least a Thracian, more on that later). What piqued my interest, however, was what seemed to be a tattoo of a grazing animal on the right arm, as well as geometric designs on the wrists.

At the time I deemed it a solitary case until I came across the image below.

"Death of Orpheus" Black Fury Painter, circa 400-375 BCE. APMA nr. 02581. Print by K. Reichhold.

Here, the murder is depicted with a much larger group of Maenads/Thracians. Orpheus, his person largely missing, can be identified in the middle with his left hand clinging to the lyre. Additionally, he is the only one in this group lacking body art on the exposed limbs.

The assaulting group bears rocks, knives, and other weapons, while their arms and legs are covered with simple line drawings of animals resembling deer, as well as abstract geometric patterns. To draw comparisons with the upper cup drawing would not be out of the question.

I was hesitant to call them tattoos at first, but an article by C.P. Jones more or less confirms that they were, based on various historical sources. Tattoos (Or stigma from στίζω: to mark. Not to be confused with the English use of the term) for decoration were a rare occurrence in antiquity, but there seems to be an exception for Thrace, where tattoos on women were a sign of esteem.

Recommended reading: Jones, C. P. “Stigma: Tattooing and Branding in Graeco-Roman Antiquity.” The Journal of Roman Studies 77 (1987): 139–55. https://www.jstor.org/stable/300578. (See section VI for the specific case of Thrace). Schildkrout, Enid. “Inscribing the Body.” Annual Review of Anthropology 33 (2004): 319–44. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25064856. (A general overview of tattoos and body art throughout history and in cultures across the world).

Black History Month Special

"Perseus and Andromeda" Titian, circa 1554-1556.

Perhaps a better-known case of someone from Aethiopia, Andromeda makes for a good case study. The subject of a number of artworks (primarily paintings, f.e. see above by Titian), Andromeda's rescue by Perseus seems a favorite myth in the visual arts.

But when one puts these images side-by-side, it becomes abundantly clear that many artists favored a specific interpretation of Andromeda as someone with white skin.

A previous post went into the etymology of "Αἰθίοψ". It is explicitly mentioned that Andromeda hails from "Aithiopia". This is not to be confused with modern-day Ethiopia, and generally is a term that refers to the outer edges of the known Greek world. On the basis of that, the assumption could be made that Andromeda was black (African), brown (Indian/Persian), or perhaps mixed. But still, simply relying on Aithiopian would be in the realm of speculation.

Ovid, however, is a rare case in ancient texts where we encounter a visual descriptor of Andromeda's skin. Even rarer, he does this multiple times.

Ovid is particularly known for Metamorphoses, where Andromeda is introduced with the following note: "nisi quod levis aura capillos moverat et tepido manabant lumina fletu, marmoreum ratus esset opus" (book 4, lines 673-675) Artists that read the Metamorphoses and are accustomed to the white marble pillars and temples, would come to the conclusion that Andromeda was as pale as can be.

But Ars Amatoria, a lesser-known work by Ovid (probably due to it being censored for its erotic topics, as recent as 1930s US), is more direct on Andromeda: "Alba decent fuscas: albis, Cepheï, placebas" (book 3, line 191) "Nec suus Andromedae color est obiectus ab illo" (book 2, line 643)

Interestingly enough, though the latter comment could suggest a negative undertone in regard to color, Ovid is quite positive in regard to darker-skinned people or at least felt the need to include them in this text.

Among the tons of white Andromedas, there are still some that strive for a little further reading of Ovid.

From left to right: A. van Diepenbeeck, 1655 ; J.J. von Sandrart, 1698 ; Unknown, 15th century

Recommended reading: Yaker Ekall, Patricia. "Andromeda: forgotten woman of Greek Mythology." Art UK. 17 August 2021. https://artuk.org/discover/stories/andromeda-forgotten-woman-of-greek-mythology (mentioned in the above) McGrath, Elizabeth. “The Black Andromeda.” Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 55 (1992): 1–18. https://doi.org/10.2307/751417.

Black History Month Special

"Aesop Narrates His Fables to the Handmaids of Xanthus" Roberto Fontana, 1876. Engraving by Gallieni.

Even if one has not heard of the name Aesop, they undoubtedly have come across The Tortoise and the Hare, The Boy who cried Wolf, or any other of the hundreds of fables attributed to the man. Yet besides these tales, very little is known about Aesop himself other than that he lived from about 620–564 BCE and was a slave. The only pseudo-biographical account that exists is The Aesop Romance, which has been called out for lacking any historical credit. One thing it did popularize was the depiction of Aesop as someone with dwarfism (perhaps not with the best intent. The Aesop Romance lists this among several unflattering characteristics).

Another discussion is that of Aesop's race. The general term for the African people in ancient times was "Αἰθίοψ" (Aithíops), which translated to "burnt-face"(noun) or "red-brown"(adjective) and was used for the people the Greeks encountered in northern Africa. Andromeda is a famous Ethiopian.

It has been argued that Aesop's name is a form of Aithiop that has altered over time. It is not unthinkable that the θ became an s-sound and the second ι was dropped. Another argument made by Richard Lobban in (recent) scholarship is that (Egyptian) animals play a very prominent role in the fables. Animals as subjects/actors in Greek myth and tales are a rarity, and more common in African folklore.

That Aesop is described as a slave by most accounts does not confirm his possible African identity. Slaves in ancient times were often prisoners of war and the like. Race would not make Aesop a slave by definition, but if he were one, being an Ethiopian would have made it likely that he was a storyteller/entertainer in the household (Snowden, 1970).

Referring to Aesop as Ethiopian/black started in the 13th century and continued till the present day. Though (as is frequently the case...) not without some grumbling.

The painting that the above image refers to won the first prize during its exhibition at the Fine Art Academy of Brera in Milan. A French critic at a Parisian showing noted: "Why is M. Fontana's Aesop, expounding with forceful comic gestures some sort of moral, apparently very agreeable to the young women stretched limply among the oleanders, black as an Ethiopian? Perhaps M. Fontana knows more about Aesop than we do, which would not be difficult."

And, yes, while there is no indisputable evidence that Aesop had been "black as an Ethiopian", there also is no evidence of him having been white either. A white default is questionable in modern times, but this is equally so when one talks about Ancient Mediterranean and the frequent interactions between the peoples surrounding it.

Recommended reading: Lobban, Richard A. “Was Aesop a Nubian Kummaji (Folkteller)?” Northeast African Studies 9, no. 1 (2002): 11–31. http://www.jstor.org/stable/41931299. Snowden, Frank M. Blacks In Antiquity: Ethiopians In the Greco-Roman Experience. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1970. https://hdl-handle-net.proxy-ub.rug.nl/2027/heb31888.0001.001. Snowden was a prominent African-American classicist to whom we owe much of the research into the lives of black people in ancient times. Like women, people of color and other minorities were (and still are) under-researched in scholarship.
"They were likewise taught not to cut but to thrust with their swords. For the Romans not only made a jest of those who fought with the edge of that weapon, but always found them an easy conquest. A stroke with the edges, though made with ever so much force, seldom kills, as the vital parts of the body are defended both by the bones and armor. On the contrary, a stab, though it penetrates but two inches, is generally fatal."

So writes Flavius Vegetius Renatus in his De Re Militari. The so called "Roman Thrust" is in theory indeed effective, were it not that it is mentally harder to do than slashing. The Roman Republic thrived on a good view of the military. Taking part was not only encouraged, but brave acts on the battlefield were openly rewarded which inspired soldiers to return on campaigns, as well as others to join the imperialist effort. On the other hand, lack of discipline was severly punished.

Recommended reading: Grossman, Dave. On Killing : The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society. 1st ed. Boston: Little, Brown, 1995. (Sect. 3 Ch. 5 goes more into detail on the thrusting as opposed to slashing matter). Milne, K. H., 2020. The middle Republican soldier and systems of social distinction. In J. Armstrong, M. P. Fronda (eds.), Romans at War. Soldiers, Citizens, and Society in the Roman Republic, London, 134-154.

Protective childbirth tattoos found on ancient Egyptian mummies

Lower back tattoos may seem like an early 21st century fad popularized by low-rise-jeans clad celebrities, but new archaeological evidence from Egyptian mummies shows the practice is actually more than three millennia old.

At the New Kingdom site of Deir el-Medina (1550 B.C. to 1070 B.C.), researchers Anne Austin and Marie-Lys Arnette have discovered that tattoos on ancient flesh and tattooed figurines from the site are likely connected with the ancient Egyptian god Bes, who protected women and children, particularly during childbirth. They published their findings last month in the Journal of Egyptian Archaeology.

Deir el-Medina lies on the western bank of the Nile, across from the archaeological site of Luxor. Beginning in 1922, around the same time that King Tut’s tomb was found, the site was excavated by a French team. Read more.

As per my previous post, I'm working on something with Iphigenia in Aulis. This film adaptation is still on my watchlist, but I heard from someone I trust on this topic that it is a heartwrenching one.

Michael Cacoyannis is perhaps best known for directing Zorba the Greek (1964) but has also made a film adaptation of Elektra (1962) and The Trojan Women (1971, starring Katherine Hepburn as Hecuba).

Its age gives it its charm and merely based on the trailers I would already say that I prefer Cacoyannis' visualization of this Greece as a world that struggles, not the marbled and glittering version we see in many Hollywood productions.

I'm analyzing parts of scene 5 of Euripides' Iphigenia in Aulis, comparing two translations with the original text.

One of the case studies is a translation by Edward Einhorn, who happens to be a theatremaker. Going back to the site where his translation can also be found, I noticed that it has been adapted into an audio play by Untitled Theatre Company no. 61. Textwise, there are some changes made to make it better suited for modern performance groups. Also, changes in word translation to add a more impactful or tense meaning.

It is a fairly short listen (about 90 minutes) and performed with great voice work accompanied by some sound effects. Pretty much like your usual audio-drama podcast.

And for those interested, there is also a graphic novel adaptation of the script.

In search of some background music, I came across this lovely group.

Daemonia Nymphe is a band founded in 1994 by Spyros Giasafakis and Evi Stergiou. Their music is made with replicas of ancient Greek instruments, such as the aulos and kithara. The group has not been active much in recent years. Their most recent album stems from 2013, but they have released a couple of singles in the meantime. Judging from videos of live performances, these are quite theatrical.

Though their songs definitely have modern influences, they use original hymns as a basis for lyrics and composition.

Recommended listen: Daemonia Nymphe (2006 album). Hypnos from Psychostasia (2013).

"Ladies in Blue" 1600-1450 BCE / Palace of Knossos, Crete

This largely reconstructed fresco was discovered between 1900 and 1905 by Sir Arthur James Evans in the palace of Knossos on Crete. It is one of a number of images found that depict women of the Minoan civilization (3500 - 1100 BC). The women depicted are dressed in colorful clothing, while also wearing elaborate jewelry in their hair and on their bodies. The chest, in typical Minoan fashion, is bare. The image that is reconstructed by Émile Gilliéron does not indicate the breasts as is the case in other Minoan imagery.

Recommended reading: Lee, Mireille M.. "9. Deciphering Gender in Minoan Dress" In Reading the Body: Representations and Remains in the Archaeological Record edited by Alison E. Rautman, 111-123. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2000. https://doi-org.proxy-ub.rug.nl/10.9783/9781512806830-011
You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.