i got a soft spot for you: part two
pairing: rafe cameron x female reader | exes to lovers
part one / part two / part three (coming soon)
cw: brief mentions of alcohol/substance abuse.
♫ you know i got a soft spot for you
i need you 'cause you're everything that i’m not...
the last place you wanted to be was in a random kildare bar, flanked by sweaty bodies while electronic music reverberated through your skull.
your friends had somehow convinced you this was just a part of the “healing journey” after your breakup.
it sounded like a good idea on paper - or rather, text. but once you put yourself into your favourite outfit and took a shot of liquid courage, the novelty was already wearing off.
him being the only thing on your mind all summer. you thought that time would naturally heal the wound you were nursing, but it soon became evident the gap was too big to fill.
besides, filling it with alcohol and parties — given what you’d been through, was laughable. in a not-so-funny manner.
before your mind could slip further away from the present, you heard the sound of your name pull you back.
“it’s y/n, right?” a guy in a fitted polo chimed as he saddled up to your section of the dance floor.
you didn’t recognize him. a slight panic began to crawl up your throat.
it was extinguished by a tap on your shoulder, as one of your friends revealed themself.
they shot you a wide grin with two thumbs-up before ushering the rest of the group away.
just great. i’ve been ambushed with a set up.
you pushed out an exasperated breath and retrained your focus on the guy in front of you.
“sorry, uh — i don’t know your name…” you replied, offering a polite smile.
maybe this was good. talking to someone new could be good for you.
he was fairly handsome, blonde waves kissing the top of his shoulders and a pair of deep brown eyes.
“i’m paul. i’m in town for an estate sale,” he grinned, but it didn’t feel overly warm. there was an air of arrogance embedded in his expression.
“oh! well, that’s pretty interesting…” you trailed, waiting for him to continue.
when he didn’t, you nodded awkwardly, absently searching for your friends.
paul must’ve registered your lack of interest because he worked quickly to remedy this sinking ship.
“look — i’ve kinda been working up the courage to talk to you all night,” he said, before scratching the back of his head. “care for a dance?”
without waiting for your answer, paul reached out his hand just as a new song began playing, something with a slower tempo.
“i gave the dj a ten to play this song, what do ya say?” he gave you a toothy smile.
deciding quickly that one dance couldn’t hurt, you placed your hand in his as you began moving to the beat.
halfway into the song, paul took it upon himself to twirl you outwards, leaving you to follow his lead.
you tried to focus on the moment as the strobing lights flashed overhead and the music swelled.
but just then, the dam you'd built so high, abruptly broke.
a singular memory from a year ago burst through with a force strong enough to put your next step off kilter.
“you’d think you were born with two left feet, rafe cameron,” you giggled as rafe struggled to avoid stepping on your toes.
you were suddenly transported back in time to your cousin’s wedding a year ago.
“listen, we all can’t be as graceful as y/n l/n,” rafe sighed, exacting another misstep. but there was a smirk on his face, the kind of smirk where his eyes would crinkle with pure admiration.
“i told you we should have practiced before — ah!” your next sentence was cut short as the two of you fell into a tangled mess of limbs in the middle of the dance floor.
the absurdity of the situation outweighed any embarrassment and soon, the both of you were in uncontrollable hysterics.
a giggle tumbled from your lips as you spun before evolving into a full unabridged fit of laughter.
your heart pinched, the memory wedging itself deep within it. an overwhelming feeling of longing came next, just as the song was ending.
paul spun you inward to his body, before dipping you downwards to end your dance with a flourish.
blood rushed to your head, and it wasn’t due to being propelled downward, although that added a dizzying pressure behind your eyes. you needed some air.
you would thank paul for the dance, exit quietly and —
“wow. a girl as gorgeous as you AND a great dancer?” paul leaned in. too close. “i’m in love,” he murmured in your ear.
“i’m so in love with you, rafe.”
and with that, the dam was shattered.
“why is that not good enough for you? are the drugs and alcohol all you fucking care about?”
that morning was now playing on a vicious loop in your mind. you, standing in front of rafe on his porch, packed bags hanging from your arms.
“of course not! fuck — y/n, baby, please. i’ll get better — i will. i will. i’m sorry!”
“i’ve heard that so many times before, rafe. but you know what i haven’t heard once come from your mouth?”
“i’m sorry — i have to go,” you shook from paul’s hold, leaving him stunned and alone in the middle of the bar.
you began to rush towards the exit, running past your confused friends as you clutched a hand to your heaving chest.
“i’ve never heard you say you love me.”
barreling through the side door, you spluttered out a few ragged breaths, the scent of sea salt reaching your nose.
you teetered towards the shore of the beach opposite the bar, feeling an overwhelming urge to sink your knees into the cool sand to ground yourself.
all of a sudden, a familiar voice cut through the night air.
your head shot up, never expecting to hear your name pass his lips again.
rafe’s blue eyes held you in place.
you drank him in. his hair was buzzed and he appeared to have packed on some muscle. he looked healthy.
when your gaze finally settled on his, his throat wobbled. his next intake of breath thick with emotion.
here he was, in all his glory. time seemed to come to a halt.
“wait! y/n…” paul appeared, throwing the back door open. he was panting slightly but righted himself when he spotted you.
this could not be happening.
rafe had been in the middle of taking a step towards your crumpled form, burning with the need to hold you. he retracted, standing up tall and shoving his hands into his front jean pockets.
he felt like a fool as he followed your line of sight to paul, agony flashing across his face.
unable to steal another glance at rafe, you slowly rose, making your way towards paul.
wiping your tear-stained face, you offered an unconvincing “hey.”
paul seemed to clock rafe’s facial expression, the desire apparent.
his jaw ticked and suddenly, the suave aura paul had exuded, evaporated. once you reached him, he scoffed incredulously, earning a confused look from you.
“so what? you ditched me to run out here for another guy?” paul spat, crossing his arms defensively.
“what? no - i just needed some — ”you began.
“save it. girls like you aren’t worth my time.”
you were suffering from whiplash. this guy, this stranger, had just shown his true intentions.
discomfort bloomed in your chest.
“woah — listen here, dumbass,” rafe snarled, taking large strides towards paul, venom oozing from his voice.
and rafe did indeed stop.
because you had said his name and it sounded so good.
“think whatever you want,” you replied, not giving paul the decency of eye contact. he huffed before muttering some other insult and stormed back towards the bar.
the only sound to be heard was the gentle lapping of waves against the sand. you were suddenly feeling very tired.
you turned to rafe, who was now only a few steps from you, his towering frame just about absorbing all of the light the full moon had to offer tonight.
your heart ached as you instinctively wrapped your arms around your body. rafe noticed and cleared his throat, becoming overly invested in the pavement beneath his feet.
“uhm… thank you. for being there while he…” you had no idea what you were saying. heat rose to your cheeks.
rafe shook his head swiftly and waved you off.
“no — i mean, i didn’t do much. you were, you were great. you handled that very well, i mean,” he mumbled, rubbing the back of his neck.
a small smile pulled at the corners of your mouth, but you were brought back to reality when you remembered the memory you were recounting before you broke out into tears in the middle of a crowded bar.
“look, y/n i — ” rafe started, capturing your stare, wanting to be in your presence for just a little longer.
“no, please. i’m not interested in hearing what you have to say. i can’t handle any more empty promises,” you remarked, recalling how many times rafe would apologize and claim he would change his destructive habits.
“but i’ve actually been doing pretty well,” rafe spoke quickly, desperate to keep your attention. he didn’t have the words to express himself.
a humourless chuckle left your lips.
“and i’m happy for you, rafe. really, i am. but you’ve already shown me that i don’t fit into your life,” you sniffed.
great, the tears were threatening to spill once more. how pathetic.
it was like you had slapped rafe square across the face. that’s what you thought of him?
pure shame and regret bubbled in his chest as he combed through every stupid mistake he’d made that led to this moment.
rafe then noticed his face was wet. silent tears were streaming down his face. he hastily brushed them away before you could see, coming to terms with the fact he was losing you all over again.
if only he could hear you say his name one more time. if you would just look at him.
unable to say more, you turned to trudge back towards the bar, determined to find your friends so you could go home.
“you’re the only piece of my life that made sense,” his voice was raw, ladened with truth.
the confession nearly stopped you in your tracks as you shuddered an uneasy breath.
you willed yourself to keep your head forward, denying the urge to turn around and take one more glance at the boy you had loved so deeply.
“just let me prove it to you…” rafe whispered as he watched your figure disappear into the bar.
too late, don't wanna fall, baby, i just
don't need somebody else to throw me aside
but i’m up all night, thinkin' "bout how
it could be you to change my heart... ♫
a/n: AHHHH. i really enjoyed writing this part. getting insight into y/n’s mind during the bar scene and then their encounter under a full moon on the beach. the next part will be the finale, so keep an eye out for it! i’m planning to get it out quickly.
also, thank you so much for the engagement on part one! i was thrilled to see even a few people are enjoying this little story. it’s very encouraging and i appreciate it!