Avatar

Well, I never.

@elaynetrakand / elaynetrakand.tumblr.com

Formerly themiddleliddle

Itโ€™s come to my attention that some people are traversing the interwebs of fandom without ever hearing of the Ms. Scribe Story or the Cassandra Claire Debacle.

At surface level, this is concerning because they are awesome stories, and everyoneโ€™s life is made a little better when they find an awesome story.

On more serious levels, fandom is a wacky place, full of people doing wacky, occasionally damaging things to each other. Some of that has evolved, but some of it is the same as it ever was. History rocks because you can learn from the mistakes of others, and maybe hurt people a little less in the future. Fandom being a giant, convoluted web of passion, some history that could use sharing goes missed.

The two stories linked are from early 2000s Harry Potter fandom. The Ms. Scribe Story is a tale of one personโ€™s aggressive use of sockpuppets to work their way up fandom hierarchy. The Cassandra Claire Debacle is about how the top name in that fandom hierarchy is a plagiarist.

Theyโ€™re prime examples of fandom being fandom in intensely negative ways. I donโ€™t think Iโ€™ve ever seen a brand of fandom toxicity that isnโ€™t on display in some way within these write-ups, and while that is admittedly sort of depressing, having things to point at that make you stop and think, โ€œWait, Iโ€™ve seen this before, this is not a thing I want to be part of,โ€ can keep you out of some of the deeper fandom pitfalls.

They are also deeply fascinating reads. If you havenโ€™t explored them before, or only know the summary versions, give them a shot.

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.