Disrespected Part 2 Alternate Ending: P.S
NonIdol!SeonghwaXafab!readerXnonIdol!Soobin
So a lot of this will be a little bit of a repeat of the other ending… but a lot will be different I hope you enjoy it anyways 🙂 thank you @n1nme4r I’m happy I can give an alternative ending where she doesn’t forgive him because same
Seonghwa paced around his bedroom trying to figure out how to apologize to you. Nothing could excuse what he did and how he treated you, but he had to try. He had to think of some way to make this right. He loves you, he really does and he can’t explain why he did what he did and there’s no excusing it. He’s just hoping he can fix it before it’s too late
He raised a shaky hand to your door, hesitating for a second before finally knocking. What if you weren't home? What if you didn't forgive him? What if you found someone else? What i- his thoughts were cut off by the door opening. You feel your eyes widen at the sight in front of you. The bags under Seonghwa's eyes were very prominent and he was wearing his lazy day sweatpants. "What are you doing here?" you ask crossing your arms "I um I just wanted to uh I" Seonghwa started to stutter, you couldn't help but look at him like he was stupid. He let his friends insult you, HE insulted you and now he's here at your door blubbering like a fish "ummm... I'm just going to close the door" you say as you awkwardly start to close the door "wait" he shouts and next thing you know his arms are wrapped around your waist, his face buried into your tummy "I'm sorry Angel, I'm so fucking sorry. I don't expect you to forgive me but fuck, I fucked up really bad. I hurt you in ways I never wanted. I don't think you're boring at all and I am so so fucking sorry about ditching you on our movie night. You're so perfect, a literal Angel and I'm so sorry for not treating you as such" Seonghwa was on his knees begging you to forgive him but the damage was already done "Seonghwa, you do realize that that wasn't the first time you ditched me right? You did it during our café date, our picnic date, and on our year anniversary. If I bored you that much why didn't you just end things instead of hurting me?" you questioned pushing him off you
"Please Angel, give me another chance. Let me make this up to you. I never thought you were boring, I should have never let them talk about you like that, I should've defended you. Please, I will do literally anything you ask, I just want to make this up to you" he whimpered, tears streaming down his face. You just stood there contemplating, you loved him a lot but he hurt you more than anyone ever has and you definitely didn't want to go through that again. You sigh as you take a step back in your apartment and he looks up at you with hopeful eyes “Look Seonghwa i appreciate you coming over and apologizing but I just don’t see us working things out or getting back together” his heart shatters at your words, he was hoping you’d at least be willing to talk things out “No no no no please Angel, please. I will do ANYTHING please don’t this. I’m sorry, I’m so so sorry. I swear I’ll treat you right. I’ll drop my friends. I’ll tell them to apologize too. Tell me what I need to do please” he was sobbing at this point but for some reason, you don’t feel bad. You spent so many nights in his place, wasted so many tears, worried for him when you didn’t need to, and you were done. “There’s nothing to do. No more chances. If I’m being completely honest, this relationship should’ve been over a long time ago but I held on because I thought things would get better, YOU would get better. I don’t want you to drop your friends, I don’t want you to force them to apologize to me, I want you to leave and let me be. I want you to leave and live your life like you always do, without me. It should be a lot better now that I’m not being a bore to you” and with that, you shut the door leaving Seonghwa to wallow in his sadness.
In the weeks that followed Seonghwa continued to try and win you back but failed every single time. You don’t know how many gifts, flowers, or notes you’ve thrown away. Sometimes you think about keeping some just because of how nice they are… but wouldn’t that just encourage him? You didn’t want that. You finally blocked his number seeing as ignoring his thousands of texts and calls wasn’t enough. Seonghwa was in shambles, he finally realized he couldn't smooth talk his way back in anymore. The guys finally stopped talking bad about you when he snapped, yelling at Wooyoung for making some comment about the way you were dressed. He didn't mean to make a scene but he couldn't take it anymore. "She's trying to dress cute now? How much of an attention whore can you be?" Wooyoung cackled as Mingi and Yunho laughed along "WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU?" the voices in the courtyard seised and everyone turned to look at the group at their round table. Seonghwa stood feeling his hands shake with anger "Woah, what's your problem?" Wooyoung was confused as to where this was all coming from "YOU! You're my fucking problem. All you do is run your mouth" At this point both boys were up and at each other’s throats “Don’t give me shit when you’re the one that started this all. ‘I don’t even like my own girlfriend’ isn’t that what you said? The same exact words. Didn’t Hongjoong tell you it was wrong to talk so bad about her? So don’t try and act all high and mighty now” Wooyoung spat before snatching his bad up and storming away with San at his heels. When Seonghwa turned to leave he saw you standing there, eyes widened in shock. He watches as your friends whispers something in your ear before dragging you way from the scene
A few months went by and Seonghwa still held onto the hope that you would change your mind even after everything that happened, but you never did. He would see you around campus from time to time, laughing and smiling with your friends, never sparing him a second glance. “Dude why are staring at her? Are you still not over her!?” He barely heard Yunho right beside him, too engrossed in following your movements, seeing who you interacted with and how you interacted with them. Confusion seeps in when he sees Choi Soobin approaching you, two coffee in hand. The confusion soon turns into jealousy when he sees Soobin hand you one of the coffees watching as your eyes widen for a moment, the anger steps in when he sees a soft smile spread on your face, your eyes twinkling the tiniest bit. “Umm Hwa, you’re about to snap your pen in half… and I don’t think you want ink all over the place” Seonghwa looks down to his clenched fist “shut the fuck up San” he seethes gathering his things and storming off, the group of friends just stare at his figure as he walks away.
Seonghwa’s head was full of questions. Since when did you talk to Soobin? Since when did Soobin bring you coffee? Since when do you drink HOT coffee? He didn’t understand. He thought he was making some progress, especially when you made eye contact with him the other day and held his gaze for 2 seconds. But boy was he wrong, little did he know you were searching for Soobin who was conveniently standing a few feet behind him. He had heard from Yunho’s girlfriend, whose brothers girlfriends cousin was friends with one of your friends, that you had a date tonight. An actual date!
He didn't know what he was thinking but here he was dressed in a black hoodie and sweatpants, sitting a few tables down watching you laugh with Choi fucking Soobin. It didn't help that this was the same restaurant he brought you to on your year anniversary. The same restaurant he left you at to go to the bar with his friend. Now you’re here with another man looking happier than you ever did with him. He watched as the date came to an end and when you stood up to leave you made eye contact with Seonghwa. Your face changed from happy to irritation, Soobin placed a hand on your should confused to your sudden mood change. Seonghwa stood to make a hasty exit but he had to pass you two in order to leave. Soobin gave him a little nod when he brushed past them but he couldn’t even look at you two.
As Seonghwa sat in his room alone he could help but think about how happy you looked without him, with someone else. He finally accepted that you were never coming back to him and that someone else was giving you everything that he never did. Soobin’s friends absolutely adored you and he has nothing but amazing things to say about you. You were a little cautious at first just with everything you had gone through but it was like night and day with the two relationships, you finally felt appreciated and loved.