User talk:Bovlb

Previous discussion was archived at User talk:Bovlb/Archive 1 on 2019-03-11.

This is a description field. Please do not use this field to post messages. To start a new topic, use the field labelled "Start a new topic".

Looks like Christopherc2588 is heavily involved with The Heather Cutler Foundation

Do you think this is an issue?

I agree that that they seem to be a single-issue editor, but this is not necessarily a problem. (Their IRL identity seems fairly obvious, in fact, but we don't need to get into doxing.) Many of their items have references and identifiers, but some do not. They are not responsive to user talk messages, which is definitely a problem. My inclination here is that it is more productive to focus on the specific editing problems (notability, poor descriptions, failure to respond to feedback) rather than suspicions of conflict of interest. I have left them a note asking them to respond to feedback.

Hi, the Lake Como LTA is back as 93.148.144.72, and it's adding a lot of wrong statements. Could you stop it and rollback?

Other commitments are preventing me from being able to spend much time on Wikidata at the moment. I recommend you contact someone else. Sorry.

Ok, thank you for the reply!

Special:Contributions/Alexi5428 and Special:Contributions/Alexisv2772 were blocked last year for similar reasons and are almost certainly the same person. It's likely they also created the weremember.com page [Q125956105: Difference between revisions - Wikidata].

Thanks for that. I think this would be best discussed at Wikidata:Requests_for_deletions#Bulk_deletion_request_70.124.254.35.

Is there any reason why you don't nominate items for deletion the normal way or do clean-up first? We now have discografies linking to deleted items which isn't ideal.

If you feel strongly about this, it would be nice if you took it up with Project Music first so we could have a discussion about how to best make changes to a data model affecting literally tens of thousands of items.

Note to self: This is a branch from Topic:Y6vsj0p2nszsnt34

It is normal practice to delete discographies, lists, etc. that don't have corresponding articles.

It is also normal practice *not* to remove inlinks for deleted items. This makes it easier to undelete if they turn out to have been deleted in error. There is a bot that tidies up such broken links after a delay.

Άννα Παναγιωτοπούλου ΟΧΙ Γέννηση 30 Απριλίου 1945 ,30 Απριλίου 1947

@D.S. Lioness: I have merged these threads. Five threads on the same topic is at least four too many, especially as discussion should be taking place elsewhere.

Regarding Wikidata:Requests for comment/Sources of data, it's only been a few days, but the lack of response may be because of your failure to read and and follow the instructions at Wikidata:Requests for comment. What you posted is a question, not a request for comments.

where i have to put the question, please  ?

Duplicate threads Topic:Y4y67d6glsd282uo; Topic:Y4u14xha5h8k94rd, Topic:Y4wnpm2795if4lr3, Topic:Y4x5d7wk5i8xpfi7.

If your concern is about the specific item, Talk:Q4767397. For a more general question, Wikidata:Project chat or Wikidata:Αγορά.

I gave you a partial block from this item (in an attempt) to prevent edit warring, and you were one of those removing sourced claims. If you have further questions about protection and blocking, you can raise them at Wikidata:Administrators'_noticeboard#Request_semi_protection_Q4767397.

Duplicate thread Topic:Y4u10322m2bb5ma3

I would appreciate it if you could answer the question I have been asking for so many days here Wikidata:Requests for comment/Sources of data - Wikidata and no one has answered. Thank you in advance

Duplicate thread Topic:Y4u10322m2bb5ma3

Άννα Παναγιωτοπούλου Γέννηση 30 Ιουλίου 1945 / 30 Ιουλίου 1947

Άννα Παναγιωτοπούλου λάθος ΟΧΙ Γέννηση 1947

You should be discussing this at either Talk:Q4767397 or Wikidata:Administrators'_noticeboard#Request_semi_protection_Q4767397 but in brief, we do not generally delete attested claims, even if they conflict and we decided to prefer one to another.

Duplicate thread Topic:Y4u10322m2bb5ma3

Please, User:235 inikos removed claims about 1947 date of birth.https://www.wikidata.org/w/index.php?title=Q4767397&diff=prev&oldid=2155358292

I believe the current state reflects the available sources. If you have more, please provide them. I'll keep an eye on it.

Of course i have more, plenty of them. But which is the meαning ? To jam up the entry ? or write something reliable ?

You blocked me from editing ?? and not the other users who remove sourced claims ???

This is not the first time we have had an entry with multiple attested dates of birth (e.g. S. E. Hinton (Q117425)). Deletion of attested claims is not the solution. Better sourcing and discussion is the way.

My sourcing is the best greek sites, discussion i can;t have in my own, no one interests to discuss.

Duplicate thread Topic:Y4u10322m2bb5ma3

Άννα Παναγιωτοπούλου Γέννηση 30 Ιουλίου 1945 / 1947

Άννα Παναγιωτοπούλου λάθος ΟΧΙ Γέννηση 30 Απριλίου 1945 ,30 Απριλίου 1947

You may like to participate in the conversation at Wikidata:Administrators'_noticeboard#Request_semi_protection_Q4767397

Please I need your guidance, I've tried so much to get better, but it seems difficult to me.

I'm not sure how to advise you. The only thing you seem to have attempted here is creating an item on "Kemelord", but you stopped without creating any claims. You might find it helpful to read Help:Contents.

I’ve almost finished, but was taken down. Is it still possible to still make claims for recover?

Can you explain how this items meets our notability criteria? You might also find it helpful to read Wikidata:Guide to requests for undeletion and User:Bovlb/How to create an item on Wikidata so that it won't get deleted.