kinda disappointed about lenore dove because she just felt like lucy grey 2.0 to me. and i wasn’t huge on lucy grey to begin with, she just seemed like a manic pixie dream girl to me but at least she had more development than lenore dove. it irritated me how obsessed haymitch was with her when to me she didn’t have much about her that was that intriguing. i’m not gonna talk about maysilee because i already have they would have made such a good couple and im still upset about it, but i do think that just making lucy gray 2.0 was lazy writing. i think suzanne found the raven poem and went ‘omg! symbolism!’ and that’s fair but the least she could do was make lenore interesting in her own way.
and i want to add - one of the many problems with the manic pixie dream girl is that she doesn’t have any flaws. haymitch being in love with lenore is obvious and lazy writing because she’s flawless, she loves him no matter what, she is kind and optimistic to a fault (and in a way that is never challenged), she’s beautiful, perfect, etc. and we never see her show any unlikable traits. of course he loves her. it’s far more interesting for two people to love each other while recognizing their flaws. take katniss and peeta for example. katniss has plenty of flaws, she’s stubborn and bitter to the point where she can sometimes lash out at the people around her. peeta knows this, was sometimes on the receiving end of it, and loves her because of it. at the end of sotr haymitch says that peeta compares him and katniss sometimes and says they’re very alike, i think in that sense he’s recognizing her flaws. similarly, peeta is optimistic, trusting and kind to the point where he could be seen as some to be ‘weak’ and unable to hold his own, ie his refusal to kill anyone. at first katniss thinks this is naive but comes to see the strength in it and loves him for it. they love each other knowing each others flaws, having seen each other at their worst. we don’t get the same from haymitch and lenore, or from snow and lucy grey frankly. lucy, i would argue, doesn’t even love snow for who he is, but for who she imagines he is, she says he’s ’pure as the driven snow’ but clearly he’s not even at that point in the book. anyway. panem toda-