Judging romcoms based on morality is a bad way to watch them. But god, what an unlikeable cast of characters! Jonah and Annie are constantly cruel and selfish, surrounded by an ensemble of enablers who bring out the worst in them. There is one honest line in this film, and it's "I don't deserve you, Walter".
The reverence shown to older films doesn't help. A generous person would call it a love letter to nostalgia. I would call this a…