Videos by Adrian C . Pirtea
This is the recording of an online lecture I gave on 18 October 2021, in the framework of the lec... more This is the recording of an online lecture I gave on 18 October 2021, in the framework of the lecture series "Visions of Paradise and Hell," organised by Mihaela Timuș (Romanian Academy of Sciences). The lecture focuses on the apocryphal work known as the "Six Books on the Dormition of Mary" and its later reception in Syriac and Arabic. Research for this lecture was carried out as part of my on-going project "The Making of the Byzantine Ascetical Canon" (MonasByz), funded by the European Research Executive Agency, MSCA grant nr. 841476.
Feedback and criticism welcome! 176 views
PhD Thesis by Adrian C . Pirtea
PhD Dissertation (Freie Universität Berlin, 2017), 2020
This is the complete, slightly revised version of my PhD (Freie Universität Berlin 2017, publishe... more This is the complete, slightly revised version of my PhD (Freie Universität Berlin 2017, published online : 2020).
NB: The page numbers differ from the original version submitted in 2017. When citing the dissertation, please refer to the new page numbers, as shown in this file.
The dissertation is also available through Refubium (https://refubium.fu-berlin.de/handle/fub188/26662) and ProQuest.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
An English summary of my PhD thesis written in German (Freie Universität Berlin, 2017).
Original... more An English summary of my PhD thesis written in German (Freie Universität Berlin, 2017).
Original title: Die "geistigen Sinne" in der ostsyrischen christlichen Mystik. Untersuchungen zum Wahrnehmungsbegriff und zur Gotteserkenntnis in der griechischen und syro-orientalischen asketischen Literatur der Spätantike.
I am currently revising the thesis for publication.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Papers I: Patristics & Eastern Christianity by Adrian C . Pirtea
Der Mensch als Bild des unergründlichen Gottes. Von der Theologie zur Anthropologie und zurück, eds. Georgiana Huian , Beatrice Wyss and Rainer Hirsch-Luipold (Berlin: De Gruyter), 2023
Pirtea, Adrian C.. "Divine Incomprehensibility and Human Wonder: Tehrā/Temhā in Isaac of Nineveh ... more Pirtea, Adrian C.. "Divine Incomprehensibility and Human Wonder: Tehrā/Temhā in Isaac of Nineveh and Early Syriac Ascetical Literature" In Der Mensch als Bild des unergründlichen Gottes: Von der Theologie zur Anthropologie und zurück edited by Georgiana Huian, Beatrice Wyss and Rainer Hirsch-Luipold, 259-284. Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783111022406-014
Dieser Beitrag untersucht die Rolle des Staunens in dem Aufstieg des Menschen zur Gotteserkenntnis. Es wird gezeigt, dass das dynamische Verhältnis zwischen Staunen, Wissensdurst und Erkenntnis, das Platon und Aristoteles beschreiben, in ähnlicher Form auch in der syrischen Patristik erkennbar ist. Nach einer skizzenhaften Geschichte der Begriffe tehrā und temhā ('Wunder', 'Staunen') in der frühsyrischen Literatur, wird die komplexe Theologie des Staunens bei Isaak von Ninive eingehend behandelt.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses (ETL) 98/3, 2022
This article discusses the Manichaean Middle Persian translation of the Shepherd of Hermas (Berli... more This article discusses the Manichaean Middle Persian translation of the Shepherd of Hermas (Berlin, Turfan Collection, M97) and investigates the possible reasons as to why Manichaeans developed an interest in this early Christian work. After a short overview of previous scholarship, I provide a codicological, palaeographic and philological analysis of M97 and its relationship to the Greek, Latin, Coptic and Ethiopic versions of the Shepherd. The relevance of another Manichaean fragment from Turfan that mentions ‘Hermas the Shepherd’ (M788) is also briefly addressed. The main part of the article attempts to explain how the text of the Shepherd was transmitted to the Manichaeans in Central Asia and what function this work had in Manichaean church life. I argue that the Manichaean Middle Persian version of the Shepherd played an important, yet hitherto unacknowledged role as a collection of didactic parables, and that its usefulness for homiletics and preaching is analogous to the Manichaean Sogdian Book of Parables (Āzandnāme) derived from Buddhist sources.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
E. Vergani - S. Chialà (eds.), Symposium Syriacum XII, held at St Lawrence College Rome, 19-21 August 2016 (Rome: Pontificio Istituto Orientale), 2022
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
A. C. Pirtea, "The Syriac and Sogdian Prefaces to the Six Books on the Dormition of the Virgin Mary," in C. Barbati - V. Berti (eds.), Iranianate and Syriac Christianity in Late Antiquity and the Early Islamic Period, Austrian Academy of Sciences Press, Vienna 2021, pp. 279-331, 2021
NB: Please contact me for the full paper.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
C. Macé and J. Gippert (eds), The Multilingual Physiologus. Studies in the Oldest Greek Recension and Its Translations (IPM 84), Brepols, Turnhout, pp. 263-280, 2021
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
A. Jouravel / A. Mathys (eds), Wort- und Formenvielfalt. Festschrift für Christoph Koch zum 80. Geburtstag, Peter Lang, Berlin: pp. 327-352, 2021
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Published in: I. Biliarsky, M. Mitrea, A. Timotin (eds), Religious Rhetoric of Power in Byzantium... more Published in: I. Biliarsky, M. Mitrea, A. Timotin (eds), Religious Rhetoric of Power in Byzantium and South-Eastern Europe. Proceedings of the session held at the 12th International Congress of South-East European Studies (Bucharest, 2-6 September, 2019), Muzeul Brăilei Carol I / Editura Istros, Brăila 2021, pp. 37-61.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Vigiliae Christianae, 2021
In 543 and 553, two church councils initiated by Justinian condemned Origen's belief that stars p... more In 543 and 553, two church councils initiated by Justinian condemned Origen's belief that stars possess rational souls. In this article, I place Justinian's anathemas in the wider context of sixth-century debates on Biblical cosmology and on the validity of astral sciences. In the first part, I review the arguments for and against astral ensoul-ment and astral signification in Origen, Evagrius, and other Christian and Neoplatonic authors. The second part consists of an in-depth reading of two sixth-century Christian authors who reacted differently to Origen's ideas: Sergius of Rešʿaynā (d. 536) and John Philoponus (d. ca. 570). While Sergius endorses and expands on the Origenian view by integrating Evagrian and Neoplatonic elements, I argue that John Philoponus constructs his arguments not only in opposition to Origen, but specifically as a reaction to the Origenist-Evagrian line of interpretation represented by Sergius. Finally, I offer a few examples of how Sergius' and Philoponus' divergent readings of Origen can contribute to a better understanding of later debates on similar issues in Byzantium and the Islamic world.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
M. Toca, D. Batovici (eds), Caught in Translation. Studies on Versions of Late-Antique Christian Literature, Brill, Leiden, 85-103, 2020
This is the published version of the paper presented at the EASR Conference in Leuven in 2017.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Pirtea, Adrian. "The Origin of Passions in Neoplatonic and Early Christian Thought: Porphyry of Tyre and Evagrius Ponticus." In Platonism and Christianity in Late Antiquity, edited by Panagiotis Pavlos, Lars Janby, Eyólfur Emilsson and Torstein Tollefsen, 258-74. London: Routledge, 2019., 2019
This chapter explores the connections between Porphyry of Tyre’s (d.305 CE) philosophical ethics ... more This chapter explores the connections between Porphyry of Tyre’s (d.305 CE) philosophical ethics and the ascetic theology of Evagrius Ponticus (d.399 CE). The main foci of this comparison are Porphyry’s and Evagrius’ theories of the soul’s passions (pathē) and the attempt of the two authors to trace back the origins of passions to the interaction between embodied souls and the realm of sensibles. Through a close reading of several key passages in their writings, Pirtea argues that both Porphyry and Evagrius reconstruct a similar “causal chain” in order to explain the emergence of human passions. On the basis of Plato’s and Aristotle’s psychology, Porphyry and Evagrius link the appearance of passions to the pleasure and pain experienced in the act of sense-perception and to the memories, desires, and opinions arising from those experiences. Pirtea further argues that Evagrius’ ideal of reaching a state of “freedom from passion” (apatheia) - long believed to be a token of Stoic influence - is in many respects a reflection of the discussions concerning apatheia in Plotinus’ Enneads and in Porphyry’s Sententiae and De abstinentia. Moreover, in describing the aim of the ascetic as a life “according to the intellect,” Evagrius even adopts Porphyry’s phraseology. The close parallels between Porphyry and Evagrius discussed in this chapter therefore challenge the prevalent theory of an alleged Stoic background for Evagrius’ teachings and provide a new perspective on the relationship between Late Antique Platonism and Early Christian asceticism.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
N. Sims-Williams (ed.), From Liturgy to Pharmacology. Sogdian Christian Texts from the Turfan Collection (Berliner Turfantexte 45), Brepols, Turnhout, 2019
A new edition and English translation of the Sogdian fragments E27/31 and E27/126, now identified... more A new edition and English translation of the Sogdian fragments E27/31 and E27/126, now identified to belong to the Christian Sogdian translation of Isaac of Nineveh's Second Part (Gnostic Chapters, IV.39-46 and a few smaller fragments). The chapter also includes a preliminary critical edition of the Syriac original corresponding to the preserved Sogdian fragments.
Further info: http://www.brepols.net/Pages/ShowProduct.aspx?prod_id=IS-9782503584195-1
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Daniel King (ed.), The Syriac World, Routledge, 2019
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Papers II: Ancient Philosophy & History of Science by Adrian C . Pirtea
B. Mak - E. Huntington (eds), Overlapping Cosmologies in Asia: Transcultural and Interdisciplinary Approaches, 2022
Note: Please contact me for the full paper!
The belief that celestial dragons are the cause of e... more Note: Please contact me for the full paper!
The belief that celestial dragons are the cause of eclipses was widespread in antiquity and the Middle Ages. In the astral sciences of premodern Eurasia these evil beings were often identified with the astronomically computable lunar nodes, allowing for the prediction of eclipses and the astrological interpretation of their effects. After an introductory section which offers a brief historical and methodological survey on this subject, the main part of the chapter discusses the reception of the eclipse-dragon theory in early Iranian and Coptic Manichaeism. As a close reading of the Middle Persian Šābuhragān and other related sources indicates, Mani’s understanding of eclipses resulted from the intentional overlap of two different views on eclipses, both of which were useful in addressing key issues in the Manichaean system: the divinity of the two luminaries and the effects of eclipses and other phenomena on the seasonal cycle and on plant life in particular. This concern can only be explained within the framework of Manichaean soteriology, according to which the divine light-elements that mixed with darkness at the beginning of creation are imprisoned in matter and have to be redeemed through a cosmic purification process. The last section analyzes the Coptic Kephalaia and explores how the Manichaean communities in Late Roman Egypt adapted Mani’s ideas as a result of their encounter with Ptolemaic astrology.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
P. Magdalino, A. Timotin (Hgg.), Savoirs prédictifs et techniques divinatoires de l'Antiquité tardive à Byzance, Pomme d'Or, Geneva 2019, S. 343-369., 2019
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Zur Lichten Heimat: Studien zum Manichäismus, Iranistik, und Zentralasienkunde im Gedenken an Werner Sundermann, Harrassowitz, Wiesbaden 2017, pp. 535-554., 2017
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
The purpose of the following essay is to analyse the Biblical concept of kavod (i.e. “Divine Glor... more The purpose of the following essay is to analyse the Biblical concept of kavod (i.e. “Divine Glory”), as it appears in the writings of the Jewish philosopher Saadia Gaon (882–942), especially in his Commentary on the Sefer Yezira and in the Book of Beliefs and Opinions. The main concern will be to find out whether a coherent theory of kavod can be extracted out of Saadia’s texts, and to explain how these ideas are to be understood in their proper historical and religious context. As an epilogue, I shall give two examples of Christian authors – somewhat younger than Saadia – who also dealt with the same theological issue of Divine Glory: the Arabic-speaking Coptic theologian Sāwīrus ibn al-Muqaffa' (d. 987), and the Byzantine monk Symeon the New Theologian (949–1022).
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Uploads
Videos by Adrian C . Pirtea
Feedback and criticism welcome!
PhD Thesis by Adrian C . Pirtea
NB: The page numbers differ from the original version submitted in 2017. When citing the dissertation, please refer to the new page numbers, as shown in this file.
The dissertation is also available through Refubium (https://refubium.fu-berlin.de/handle/fub188/26662) and ProQuest.
Original title: Die "geistigen Sinne" in der ostsyrischen christlichen Mystik. Untersuchungen zum Wahrnehmungsbegriff und zur Gotteserkenntnis in der griechischen und syro-orientalischen asketischen Literatur der Spätantike.
I am currently revising the thesis for publication.
Papers I: Patristics & Eastern Christianity by Adrian C . Pirtea
Dieser Beitrag untersucht die Rolle des Staunens in dem Aufstieg des Menschen zur Gotteserkenntnis. Es wird gezeigt, dass das dynamische Verhältnis zwischen Staunen, Wissensdurst und Erkenntnis, das Platon und Aristoteles beschreiben, in ähnlicher Form auch in der syrischen Patristik erkennbar ist. Nach einer skizzenhaften Geschichte der Begriffe tehrā und temhā ('Wunder', 'Staunen') in der frühsyrischen Literatur, wird die komplexe Theologie des Staunens bei Isaak von Ninive eingehend behandelt.
Further info: http://www.brepols.net/Pages/ShowProduct.aspx?prod_id=IS-9782503584195-1
Papers II: Ancient Philosophy & History of Science by Adrian C . Pirtea
The belief that celestial dragons are the cause of eclipses was widespread in antiquity and the Middle Ages. In the astral sciences of premodern Eurasia these evil beings were often identified with the astronomically computable lunar nodes, allowing for the prediction of eclipses and the astrological interpretation of their effects. After an introductory section which offers a brief historical and methodological survey on this subject, the main part of the chapter discusses the reception of the eclipse-dragon theory in early Iranian and Coptic Manichaeism. As a close reading of the Middle Persian Šābuhragān and other related sources indicates, Mani’s understanding of eclipses resulted from the intentional overlap of two different views on eclipses, both of which were useful in addressing key issues in the Manichaean system: the divinity of the two luminaries and the effects of eclipses and other phenomena on the seasonal cycle and on plant life in particular. This concern can only be explained within the framework of Manichaean soteriology, according to which the divine light-elements that mixed with darkness at the beginning of creation are imprisoned in matter and have to be redeemed through a cosmic purification process. The last section analyzes the Coptic Kephalaia and explores how the Manichaean communities in Late Roman Egypt adapted Mani’s ideas as a result of their encounter with Ptolemaic astrology.
Feedback and criticism welcome!
NB: The page numbers differ from the original version submitted in 2017. When citing the dissertation, please refer to the new page numbers, as shown in this file.
The dissertation is also available through Refubium (https://refubium.fu-berlin.de/handle/fub188/26662) and ProQuest.
Original title: Die "geistigen Sinne" in der ostsyrischen christlichen Mystik. Untersuchungen zum Wahrnehmungsbegriff und zur Gotteserkenntnis in der griechischen und syro-orientalischen asketischen Literatur der Spätantike.
I am currently revising the thesis for publication.
Dieser Beitrag untersucht die Rolle des Staunens in dem Aufstieg des Menschen zur Gotteserkenntnis. Es wird gezeigt, dass das dynamische Verhältnis zwischen Staunen, Wissensdurst und Erkenntnis, das Platon und Aristoteles beschreiben, in ähnlicher Form auch in der syrischen Patristik erkennbar ist. Nach einer skizzenhaften Geschichte der Begriffe tehrā und temhā ('Wunder', 'Staunen') in der frühsyrischen Literatur, wird die komplexe Theologie des Staunens bei Isaak von Ninive eingehend behandelt.
Further info: http://www.brepols.net/Pages/ShowProduct.aspx?prod_id=IS-9782503584195-1
The belief that celestial dragons are the cause of eclipses was widespread in antiquity and the Middle Ages. In the astral sciences of premodern Eurasia these evil beings were often identified with the astronomically computable lunar nodes, allowing for the prediction of eclipses and the astrological interpretation of their effects. After an introductory section which offers a brief historical and methodological survey on this subject, the main part of the chapter discusses the reception of the eclipse-dragon theory in early Iranian and Coptic Manichaeism. As a close reading of the Middle Persian Šābuhragān and other related sources indicates, Mani’s understanding of eclipses resulted from the intentional overlap of two different views on eclipses, both of which were useful in addressing key issues in the Manichaean system: the divinity of the two luminaries and the effects of eclipses and other phenomena on the seasonal cycle and on plant life in particular. This concern can only be explained within the framework of Manichaean soteriology, according to which the divine light-elements that mixed with darkness at the beginning of creation are imprisoned in matter and have to be redeemed through a cosmic purification process. The last section analyzes the Coptic Kephalaia and explores how the Manichaean communities in Late Roman Egypt adapted Mani’s ideas as a result of their encounter with Ptolemaic astrology.
This article reviews a collection of twenty-six studies on Eurasia in Late Antiquity, edited by Nicola Di Cosmo and Michael Maas (Cambridge, 2018).
The last section of the Syriac Six Books on the Dormition of Mary (cant 123-124) contains an extensive description of the Virgin's journey to Heaven and Hell. This description differs significantly from the other known apocalypses of the Virgin (the Greek Apocalypse of the Virgin, the Ethiopic Apocalypse, the Obsequies Apocalypse, etc.). Based on the previous studies of Richard Bauckham, Stephen Shoemaker, Simon Mimouni and others, this paper will focus on a few neglected aspects of this apocryphal work. First, I will address the reception history of the Six Books in the early Islamic period, through an investigation of the earliest Arabic translation, its monastic context, the circulation of Syriac and Arabic manuscripts in Palestine and Sinai and their readership (ninth-tenth centuries). I will then briefly discuss the role of end-time expectations in the original and subsequent redactions of the Six Books, the question of personal vs. universal judgment of sinners, and the link between the Virgin's bodily assumption and that of Enoch and Elijah.
Full program here: http://www.sanktignatios.org/en/downloads/ProgrammeContemplativeTraditions2019.pdf
https://theo.kuleuven.be/en/general/calendar/versions-of-the-apostolic-past-ancient-translations-of-the-apostolic-fathers
http://kuleuvencongres.be/easr2017/articles/Programme/session/65
The present volume offers an introduction to the significance of the Greek text, a new examination of its manuscript tradition, and a completely revised state of the art for each of the ancient translations. Two chapters of the Physiologus, on the pelican and on the panther, are edited in Greek and in each translation; these editions are accompanied by a new English rendering of the edited texts as well as short interpretative essays concerning the two animals.
Although some of the translators’ names are known, scholars have only recently begun to study these translation activities and projects in more detail. Focusing on the cases of Antioch (incl. the surrounding monastic landscape) and Mt Athos (incl. its interactions with Thessaloniki and Constantinople), this workshop will address the following questions: Who are the main individuals, groups and institutions involved in these translations? What kind of evidence about these translations is still available today (narrative sources, manuscripts, etc.) and how can it be analyzed? Can the work of translator teams be detected in the extant sources and how can we study their translation techniques and methods? What is the relationship between the monastic and the urban translation centres? Are there any translation practices shared between Athos and Antioch that could indicate mutual influence and exchanges?
In addition, the workshop will explore other cases of monastic translations in the Eastern Mediterranean, such as the reception of the corpus of Antiochene translations during the Copto-Arabic Renaissance, or the later Graeco-Slavonic translations on Mt Athos.
Participants: Alice Croq (Université Paul Valéry - Montpellier), Joe Glynias (Harvard University), Miriam Hjälm (Sankt Ignatios College (EHS)/Uppsala University), Christian Høgel (Lund University), Habib Ibrahim (University of Tübingen), Joshua Mugler (Hill Museum & Manuscript Library), Sandro Nikolaishvili (University of Southern Denmark), Adrian C. Pirtea (Austrian Academy of Sciences, Vienna), Lewis Read (University of Vienna), Daria Resh (Swedish Institute at Athens / SDU), Marijana Vukovic (University of Southern Denmark)
The workshop is organised as part of Dr. Adrian Pirtea's Marie-Sklodowska-Curie research project "MonasByz" (Grant Nr. 841476), which is hosted by Prof. Claudia Rapp at the Department of Byzantine Studies of the University of Vienna.
Please find the poster and flyer attached. Pre-registration is necessary: Please click on the link on the last page of the flyer and follow the instructions for registration.
For any questions, do not hesitate to contact Adrian Pirtea directly (adrian.pirtea[at]univie.ac.at).
We look forward to welcoming you all at the workshop!