i was watching season 2, thinking to myself "wow from like an 'objective good person-standpoint' this is the best thing claudia has ever done" in reference to the way she REFUSED to let soren lie to callum and ez (downright furious). but of course, the more i thought about it, the more it just made this

image
image

even worse.

I finally wrote a The Dragon Prince fanfic! It’s sad. Please be mindful of the tags and content warnings.

Yield

After the battle over the prison of Aaravos, Terry leaves two siblings on the bloodstained beach to look for their father. He returns to only one. In the hours between, Claudia makes her choice. But not lightly.

Or, hey, remember when an eighteen-year-old girl who’d just had her leg cut off in the sea gruesomely murdered her baby brother to save her dad’s life? Let’s talk about that.

Y'know as much as I loved Viren swearing off dark magic in 5x09 and how much it had taken for him to finally reach that point, I did have a thought in the back of my head what would he have done if killing Sir Sparklepuff had been required to keep Claudia alive?”

Because if you’re willing to do anything, how do you give that willingness, that devotion, up? Especially in parallel with an arc of realizing you haven’t prioritized your children enough, which continues on into S6.

It was easy enough (not easy, but viable) to refuse the ritual when it’s just your life on the line. Yes there will be emotional suffering, but he’s hoping to spare Claudia from a worse path and it’s Viren’s life on the line; it’s well within his verdict to choose not to save himself / his ego or anything else he’s placed above his family. And I couldn’t shake the feeling that despite his conviction and growth culminating here in a lot of ways, that if it had been for Claudia (or Soren), Viren would’ve done it.

That’s not to say I think he would’ve repeated the mistakes he made with Lissa (both 6x06 and particularly 6x08 made that abundantly clear) but that Viren swearing off dark magic was, if his character was put in certain situations, not something that would hold. 6x01 having him use the same language and belief system (“You do anything for your children” if switching it up to but “never the other way around”) felt like apt set up for him to do it again, and uh… then 6x08 happened. The difference, I think, is that Viren accepts that he did and does have a choice, he’s making one now, and it is a sacrifice.

Him actually doing all along what he always said he was doing, basically.