Chimera is signifier of wealth of lokhāṇḍā metal equipment
-- Gargoyles on Notre-dame cathedral in Indus Script Meluhha grapheme tradition
The chimeras on Notre-Dame de Paris
are stone statues that are part of the
cathedral's history and a key feature of
the site:The chimeras, along with the
gargoyles, are primarily practical,
draining rainwater off the roofs to
prevent damage to the walls.
lo 'fox' (WPah.) rebus: lōha ʻmetalʼ (Pali) Rhino horn. kāṇḍā 'rhinoceros’ rebus: khaṇḍa 'equipment’.
Together, lokhāṇḍā 'metal tools, pots and pans of copper’.
02-11-2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
1
Urbanism and guild-master of metalwork artisans, smelters – M-417
--Six Crested eagles/protomes of animals radiating from a dotted-circle/ladder – Anatolia sealing, M-417
A close-up of a stone
Description automatically generated with low confidence
A picture containing indoor
Description automatically generated
Graphemes Signs 7 and 326 fused
into Sign 17 (as on M-417 Seal)
-- Indus Script Hypertext – Guild-master of metalwolrk artisans, smelters
--Dot in circle Anatolia sealing. pota dhā̆vaḍ 'metal infusion, iron smelter'
02-11-2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
2
karabha- ‘camel’ rebus kharva ‘nidhi of Kubera’ kul ‘tiger’ rebus kol ‘working in iron’
– Gargoyles of Notre-dame cathedral
Pk. karabha- m., °bhī- f., karaha- m.
'camel’ (CDIAL 2597)
rebus: Pk. khavva- 'hunchbacked,
dwarfish’(CDIAL 3832) kharva ‘cups
and vessels baked in fire’ ‘nidhi of
Kubera’ kul ‘tiger’ rebus: kol ‘working
in iron’
“In conclusion, the gargoyles of Notre-Dame Cathedral are fascinating architectural features that serve both functional and
symbolic purposes. Their elaborate designs and menacing appearance not only contribute to the captivating Gothic aesthetic
of the cathedral but also serve to remind us of the power of human imagination and creativity. As we continue to appreciate
and protect Notre-Dame Cathedral, the gargoyles will remain an enduring symbol of the ingenuity and artistry that has
allowed this magnificent structure to stand the test of time. As guardians of this iconic masterpiece, the gargoyles silently
watch over the city of Paris, evoking a sense of wonder and awe in those who admire their intricate craftsmanship. Their
presence on the cathedral's façade is a testament to the talent of the artisans who brought them to life, and a reminder of
the rich history and cultural legacy embodied by Notre-Dame Cathedral.”
https://www.friendsofnotredamedeparis.org/cathedral/artifacts/gargoyles/
02-11-2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
3
Semiotics – clincher evidence,
tributes listed on Black Obelisk of
Shalamaneser III, 823 BCE
-- Indus Script animal hieroglyphs are signifiers
-- Signified are wealth categories
-- Animals are NOT the tributes, rebus metaphors, wealth categories are
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
4
Black Obelisk of Shalamaneser III, 823 BCE-1
This is one side of the original obelisk, which stands two metres tall
and has four sides, each with 5 picture panels interspersed with
cuneiform inscriptions. There is also cuneiform above and below
each set of pictures. The inscriptions record the annals of thirty-two
years of the reign of the Assyrian king Shalmaneser III (r. 858-824
BC). Most of the illustrations record the tributes brought to
Shalmaneser by various vassal kings. This panel: plaster replica;
black alabaster original. Height 112 cm, width 55.5 cm, depth 5.5
cm.
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
5
Black Obelisk of Shalamaneser III, 823 BCE-2
The top panel of the replica shows Sua, the Gilzanite, bringing tribute to
Shalmaneser, who is standing to the left, armed with a bow and arrows and
accompanied by an attendant and soldier. Above this scene are the winged sundisc, divine symbol of the god Assur, king of all of the great gods, and the eightpointed star, divine symbol of Enlil, creator and father of the gods.
The second panel, which is possibly the most significant, depicts Shalmaneser
receiving tribute from Jehu, king of Israel, who is prostrate before the king.
Shalmaneser holds a bowl in his raised hand and is sheltered by a parasol held by
an attendant.
The tribute of the country of Musri, illustrated on the third panel, consists entirely
of animals led or driven by attendants dressed in knee-length garments.
The fourth panel illustrates two lions hunting a stag in a forest, perhaps
reminiscent of the countries which Shalmaneser has conquered.
The bottom panel records the tribute of Karparunda of Hattina, brought forth by
porters wearing pointed caps.
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
6
Black Obelisk of Shalamaneser III, 823 BCE-3
The tribute of the country of Musri, illustrated on the third panel, consists entirely of animals led or driven by
attendants dressed in knee-length garments. Details of third panel in four registers A,B,C,D.
•Side A: Attendants bring "tribute from Muṣri: two-humped camels". Muṣri, meaning
'borderland', probably refers to a country far to the east.
•Side B: Exotic animals from Muṣri: "a river-ox [water-buffalo], an [Indian] rhinoceros
(and) an antelope". The sculptor seems never to have seen a rhinoceros or waterbuffalo.(The sculptor seems to call 'unicorn' a rhinoceros; and a water-buffalo as riverox).The sculptor shows unique horns of an antelope showing a winding, curved, Ushaped serpent with two cobra-hoods.
•Side C: "Female [Indian] elephants, female monkeys (and) apes" from Muṣri.
•Side D: More "monkeys" and their keepers from Muṣri. The way the monkeys are
carved suggests... monkeys were not new sights for the Assyrian court at this time.
http://oracc.museum.upenn.edu/nimrud/livesofobjects/blackobelisk/index.html
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
7
Let us focus on the translation of Akkadian inscription on
Scene III Tribute of the land of Musri.
1. a-a se-ri-si-na (Camels whose backs are doubled) --Side A
2. A river ox (hippopotamus)
3. A sakea (rhinoceros)
4. A susu (antelope) -- Side B
5. A bazîtu (elephant)
6. uqupu (monkeys)
ranku ‘antelope’ rebus: ranku ‘tin ore’
Unicorn: खोंड khōṇḍa ’young bull’ rebus:
kōṇḍa ’artisan village’ PLUS singhin ‘horn’
rebus: singi ‘ornament gold’; kunda ‘fine
gold’
11/2/2024
River ox may be a water-buffalo
̄ go ʻ buffalo bull ʼ? -- more prob. < raṅká-<-> s.v.
Ku. N. rã
*rakka --raṅku m. ʻ a species of deer ʼ Vās., ˚uka -- m.
Śrīkaṇṭh. .(CDIAL 10559)Rebus: raṅga3 n. ʻ tin ʼ lex. [Cf. nāga
̄ g f., rã
̄ gā m. ʻ pewter,
-- 2, vaṅga -- 1]Pk. raṁga -- n. ʻ tin ʼ; P. rã
̄ k; N. rāṅ, rāṅo ʻ tin,
tin ʼ (← H.); Ku. rāṅ ʻ tin, solder ʼ, gng. rã
solder ʼ, A. B. rāṅ; Or. rāṅga ʻ tin ʼ, rāṅgā ʻ solder, spelter ʼ, Bi.
̄ gā, OAw. rāṁga; H. rã
̄ g f., rã
̄ gā m. ʻ tin, pewter ʼ; Si.
Mth. rã
ran
̆ ga ʻ tin ʼ.(CDIAL 10562)
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
8
karabhá m. ʻ camel ʼ MBh., ʻ young camel ʼ Pañcat., ʻ young elephant ʼ BhP. 2. kalabhá -- ʻ
young elephant or camel ʼ Pañcat. [Poss. a non -- aryan kar -- ʻ elephant ʼ also in karḗṇu -- ,
karin -- EWA i 165]1. Pk. karabha -- m., ˚bhī -- f., karaha -- m. ʻ camel ʼ, S. karahu, ˚ho m., P.
H. karhā m., Marw. karhau JRAS 1937, 116, OG. karahu m., OM. karahā m.; Si. karaba ʻ
young elephant or camel ʼ.2. Pa. kalabha -- m. ʻ young elephant ʼ, Pk. kalabha -- m., ˚bhiā -f., kalaha -- m.; Ku. kalṛo ʻ young calf ʼ; Or. kālhuṛi ʻ young bullock, heifer ʼ; Si. kalam̄̆bayā ʻ
young elephant ʼ. OMarw. karaha ʻ camel ʼ.(CDIAL 2797) Rebus: karba 'iron’ kharva ‘nidhi of
Kubera’ kharva ‘cups and vessels baked in fire’
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
9
Let us focus on the translation of Akkadian
inscription on Scene III Tribute of the land of
Musri.
5. A bazîtu (elephant)
6. uqupu (monkeys) – Side C
Ibha ‘elephant’ rebus: ib ‘iron’
kuṭhāru 'monkey'
rebus: kuṭhāru 'armourer (products)‘
मर्कट markaṭa m n (S) A monkey or an
ape.Rebus: मरर्त marakata m
S An emerald.
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
10
Monkey 1: eraka ‘upraised arm’; rebus eraka ‘metal infusion’ Kuwi (F.) mūhū (pl. mūska) monkey
(hanuman); (S.) mūhu monkey; (Su.) muhu (pl. muska), (Isr.) mūhu (pl. mūska) black-faced
monkey.Ta. mucu langur, Semnopithecus priamus. Ma. mocca a light-coloured monkey (or with 4626
Ka. maṅga). Ka. musu, musuku, musuva a large and black kind of ape; (Hav.) muju black monkey;
(Gowda, Dr. Ling., p. 98) mucca black-faced monkey. Koḍ. muccë langur. Tu. mujji, mujju a black
monkey. Te. koṇḍa-muccu large black-faced monkey, baboon. Kol. muy black-faced monkey;
(Haig) muī langur. Nk. muy black faced monkey.Pa. muy id. Ga. (P.) muy id. Go. (Tr.) mūnj
(pl. mūsk) langur monkey (female); (W.) mūnjāl ape; (M.) munj monkey; (D. Mu.) mūnjal, (Ma.) mūnji,
(S.) mūnju, (Ko.) mūnj black-faced monkey (Voc.2937). Kui mūsu (pl. mūska) sp. monkey or
ape. Malt. muge baboon rebus: mũhã̄ = the quantity of iron produced at one time in a native smelting
furnace of the Kolhes; iron produced by the Kolhes and formed like a four-cornered piece a little
pointed at each end
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
11
Monkey dressed as a woman
Monkey 2: रत्नी
ratnī f (रत्न) In monkey-sports. A term given to the female monkey
habited as a woman.(Marathi) Rebus: rátna n. ʻ gift ʼ RV., ʻ treasure, jewel ʼ Mn.
[√raṇ1] Pa. ratana -- n. ʻ jewel ʼ, Pk. rayaṇa -- , ladaṇa -- m.n., Si. ruvan -- a.(CDIAL
10600) ratnākara m. ʻ jewel -- mine, ocean ʼ Kāv. [rátna -- , ākara -- ]Pa. ratanākara -- m. ʻ
mine of jewels or precious metals ʼ, Pk. rayanāara -- m.; -- Si. ruvanāra ʻ ocean ʼ (EGS
148) prob. ← Pa.(CDIAL 10601) रत्न n. ( √1. रा) a gift , present , goods , wealth ,
riches RV. AV. S3Br.; a magnet , loadstone Kap. Sch. (cf. मणि); रत्न-हविस ् n. a partic. oblation in the राजसूय (having reference to persons who may be
reckoned among a king's most valuable
treasures) Ka1tyS3r. (cf. रत्न ्/इन ्). रत्त्नन ् mfn. possessing or receiving
gifts RV.; m. pl. N. of certain persons in whose dwelling the रत्न-हविस ् (q.v.) is offered by
a king (viz. the ब्राह्मि , राजन्य , महहषी , पररिक्
ू ,ग्रामृ ती , सेना-नी , सत
िी , क्षत्त ृ , संग्रहीत ृ , भाग-दघ
ु , and अक्षािाप) TBr. S3Br.( °नन-त्ि n. TBr. )
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
12
Location of borderland Mari
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
13
Tributes are from Musri
Panel 3 on the obelisk lists tributes from Musri. Muṣri, meaning 'borderland', probably
refers to a country far to the east -- perhaps from Hindanu province (which is east of the
Musasir mountains) or further east from Meluhha.
Alternative. Musri (Assyrian: Mu-us-ri), or Muzri, was a small ancient kingdom, in
northern areas of Iraqi Kurdistan. The area is now inhabited by Muzuri (Mussouri) Kurds.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musri
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
14
Thorny (signifier)–millet culm as flagstaff; (signified) maritime
dhow
र्ंठाळ kaṇṭhāḷa ‘thorny' rebus
kãṭhāḷ
ʻmaritime‘;र्ाठळी kāṭhaḷī, र्ां
ठळी
kāṇṭhaḷī one of the inferior
grains, Panicum
frumentaceum or miliaceum
(Molesworth. Marathi)
िलगुुः 'goat' (face of the unicorn)
िलगा valgā, bāga ʻrein' बरग
baraga 'millet' rebus (metath.)
baghlah 'Arab dhow‘;'Ganjam
sailing vessel‘
Cognate Baqarah or baggarah
(( )بقارةArabic) Rebus:
वाघी vāghī (वाघ) A fast-sailing
vessel of a particular description.
The Baghlah
(Shuwai'i)
Length 70 - 130 feet
Weight 150 - 400
tons.This vessel was
used during the
13th/19th centuries,
mainly as a ocean
going cargo vessel.
Many were built in
Sur Oman during
these years.
The mosaic standard was found in the temple of
Ishtar, in pieces scattered on the floor, which would
account for the arbitrary arrangement of the figures.
Painting of a Maldivian baggala. Acrylic on
Ca. 2500 BCE. Louvre
canvas.
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhow#/media/File:S
d2-baggala.JPG
15
How can four monkeys and other animals
constitute tributes to Shalamaneser III?
Indus Script cipher and decipherment provide the
explanation; the monkeys and other animals are
hieroglyphs (signifiers) which signify Meluhha rebus
readings of specific wealth resources (signified) produced
by Meluhha artisans and settlers of Musri (Muzuri,
Mussouri Kurds), north Kurdistan. Evidence of Meluhha
settlers in borderland Mari is well attested by the
procession which carries the 'unicorn' on flagstaff.
11/2/2024
https://dcpune.academia.edu/SrinivasanKalyanaraman/Pa
pers kalyan97@gmail.com
16