!
" #
$
$
%
$
&
! $ $
'( ) (
* +
+# , -
. ' ) $ *
/0 1 ,
!"
#
!
" #
$ !% ! & $
' ' ($
' # % % ) % * %
' $ '
+ " % &
' !#
$,
( $
- .
!
"- (
%
. %
% % % $
$ $ -
-
- -
// $$$
0
1"1"#23."
4& )*5/ +)
* !6 !& 7!8%779:9& %
2 ; !
) -
* &
< "-0 = -" :>9?
/- @:>9?4& )*5/ +)
"3 " & :>9?
FINANCIAL INCLUSION TO REACH OUT RURAL AREA
PREFACE
This dissertation is original, unpublished and independent work by the authors, Dr.S.Vasantha
and Ms.R.Paveethiraa .I would like to acknowledge many people for helping me during my
research work. I take this opportunity to express my gratitude and thank each one of them. This
dissertation is based on the data collected from the villages of Kancheepuram district in Tamil
Nadu. Literature review is taken from previously published article and which was
acknowledged. The interview schedule survey has been conducted among the rural people to
examine the financial literacy, analyze the banking habits, usage of banking services and to
examine the awareness level towards usage of technology in accessing financial services. Based
on the analysis and interpretations of data the challenges of financial inclusion to reach out rural
people are identified to suggest measures to promote financial inclusion to reach out rural
people. Finally, I also appreciate the respondents who were willing to share their experiences. It
was a privilege to meet the respondents personally and get the questionnaire filled. The study
was a great experience for me to meet the underprivileged people to bring them under the ambit
of inclusive growth. The authors are very grateful to Management of Vels University for the
successful completion of this research work. Finally we are thankful to the Lambert
Academic Publisher for publishing our research work
Dr.S.Vasantha
Ms.R.Paveethiraa
TABLE OF CONTENTS
S.NO
CONTENTS
1
INTRODUCTION
2
THEORTICAL BACKGROUND
3
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
4
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
5
DATA ANALYSIS AND
INTREPRETATION
6
MAJOR FINDINGS OF THIS STUDY
7
SUGGESTIONS
8
9
CONCLUSION
BIBLIOGRAPHY
PAGE NO
1
25
34
49
55
69
70
71
72
ABSTRACT
Financial inclusion is one of the most important aspects in the present scenario for
inclusive growth and development of our economy. Financial inclusion means
connecting all individuals, who are in the remote rural areas, to a well-functioning
financial system. Financial Inclusion is one of the essential conditions for
reduction of poverty and socio- economic inequalities in the society (Rangarajan,
C.R., 2008). It is one of the tools to reach out the bottom of the pyramid and bring
them under inclusive growth. The CRISIL report stated that the three big
challenges of financial inclusion to reach our rural were high cost, lack of robust
technology, and lack of awareness, and while these challenges are significant. It
further states that there is a need for greater stakeholder coordination, greater
consumer understanding, trust and protection. Throat (2007), observed
cumbersome documentation procedure, unavailability of diversified products and
services, high transaction costs, and easy availability of informal credits are major
barrier to achieve financial inclusion. The research was conducted among the rural
areas of Kancheepuramdistrict,Tamil Nadu.The data was collected through
interview schedule tostudy the financial literacy among the rural people, to analyze
the banking habits and usage of banking services among the rural people and to
examine the awareness level towards usage of technology in accessing financial
services. The literature collected from various published articles and research
report helped the researcher to examine the challenges of financial inclusion to
reach out rural people and to suggest measures to promote financial inclusion in
rural area
-1-
1 INTRODUCTION
The financial inclusion term was first time used by British lexicon when it was
found that nearly 7.5 million persons did not have a bank account. But financial
inclusion concept is not a new one in Indian economy. Bank Nationalization in
1969, establishment of RRBs and introduction of SHG- bank linkage programs
were initiatives taken by RBI to provide financial accessibility to the unbanked
groups. Dr. C. Rangarajan committee states that “Financial inclusion may be
defined as the process of ensuring access to financial services and timely and
adequate credit where needed by vulnerable groups such as weaker sections and
low income groups at an affordable cost”. Financial Inclusion is the affordable cost
in a fair and transparent manner by mainstream institutional players. India has a
rural population of about 780 million with limited or no access to financial
services. According to the World Bank, India has 600,000 villages, of which only
74,000 have access to banks. Financial inclusion may be interpreted as the ability
of every individual to access basic financial services which include savings, loans
and insurance in a manner that is reasonably convenient and flexible in terms of
access and design and reliable in the sense that savings are safe and that insurance
claim will be paid with certainty (Mor and Ananth, 2007) The branch banking
route apparently is not very practical due to the huge cost of opening the branches
vis-a-vis volumes expected, high costs of operations, limited banking hours,
illiteracy, non-availability of alternate channels in rural centres, etc. Further,
financial inclusion through branch network may adversely affect customer service
at branches due to increased traffic and larger numbers of people to be attended to
within the limited hours of banking. Financial inclusion can be described as the
-2-
provision of affordable financial services, viz saving, credit, insurance services,
access to payments and remittance facilities by the formal financial systems to
those who are excluded. So, financial inclusion refers to access to vast range of
financial product and services at affordable cost. It not only includes banking
products but also other financial services such as loan, equity and insurance
products. In India, the focus of the financial inclusion at present is more or less
confined to ensuring a bare minimum access to a savings bank account without
frills to all. However, having a current account/savings account on its own, cannot
be regarded as an accurate indicator of financial inclusion. [Vallabh and Chathrath,
2006].
1.2 .NSSO Survey Results
The Committee debated the various dimensions of inclusion and concluded that
while aspects such as savings, remittance facilities, insurance, etc. were important,
nevertheless exclusion was particularly germane from the standpoint of access to
credit by vulnerable groups. The Committee accordingly scanned the data put out
by the NSSO in the situation assessment survey on "Indebtedness of Farmer
Households" (2003). The Committee noted that the definition of indebtedness as
adopted in the survey referred to farmer households having outstanding loans from
institutional or non-institutional sources4 in cash or kind having a value of Rs.300
or more at the time of transaction. As per NSSO data, 45.9 million farmer
households in the country (51.4%), out of a total of 89.3 million households does
not access credit, either from institutional or non-institutional sources. Only 27%
of total farm households are indebted to formal sources (of which one-third also
-3-
borrow from informal sources). In other words, 73% of farm households do not
have access to formal credit sources. For purposes of this analysis, "financially
excluded" households will be defined as those not having any debt to formal credit
sources. The various aspects of such exclusion among specific regions and
population groups are indicated below.
1.3. RATIONALE FOR FINANCIAL INCLUSION
Finance has come a long way since the time when it wasn't recognized as a factor
for growth and development. It is now attributed as the brain of an economic
system and most economies strive to make their financial systems more efficient.
It also keeps policymakers on their toes as any problem in this sector could freeze
the entire economy and even lead to a contagion. The earlier research focused on
how finance helps an economy. Now, research shows that financial inclusion is as
important. The new avenue for research in finance is - making financial inclusion
workable. Patrick Honohan (of Trinity College, Dublin) in his research developed
an index to measure access to finance in 160 countries. If the index is put on a
world map it can be clearly seen that those economies having higher indices are
usually those, which we term as developed/advanced economies. It is not implied
that financial inclusion alone has led to the development but is an important factor.
The policymakers have set up their task force/committees to understand how
financial inclusion can be achieved including advanced economies like United
Kingdom. India also set up a committee under the chairmanship of Mr.
C.Rangarajan to suggest measures to increase financial inclusion (hence called the
Rangarajan Committee on Financial Inclusion). The World Bank had organized a
-4-
conference in March 2007 and has released a report titled "Finance for All" in
November 2007.
The first question that comes to mind is why can't financial inclusion happen on its
own? Why do we need to make a policy to increase the same? Like any other
product or service, why can't it find a market of its own? The reasons are:
a) Financial Exclusion: It has been found that financial services are used only by a
section of the population. There is demand for these services but it has not been
provided. The excluded regions are rural, poor regions and also those living in
harsh climatic conditions where it is difficult to provide these financial services.
The excluded population then hasto rely on informal sector (moneylenders etc) for
availing finance that is usually at exorbitant rates. These leads to a vicious cycle.
First, high cost of finance implies that first poor person has to earn much more
than someone who has access to lower cost finance. Second, the major portion of
the earnings is paid to the moneylender and the person can never come out of the
poverty.
b) High cost: It has also been seen that poor living in urban areas don't utilize the
financial services as they find financial services are costly and thus are
unaffordable. Hence, even if financial services are available, the high costs deter
the poor from accessing them. For example, to open a checking account in
Cameroon, the minimum deposit requirement is over 700 dollars, an amount
higher than the average GDP per capita of that country, while no minimum
amounts are required in South Africa or Swaziland. Annual fees to maintain a
checking account exceed 25 percent of GDP per capita in Sierra Leone, while there
are no such fees in the Philippines. In Bangladesh, Pakistan, Philippines, to get a
-5-
small business loan processed requires more than a month, while the wait is only a
day in Denmark. The fees for transferring 250 dollars internationally are 50 dollars
in the Dominican Republic, but only 30 cents in Belgium.
c) Non-price barriers: Access to formal financial services also requires documents
of proof regarding a persons' identity, income etc. The poor people do not have
these documents and thus are excluded from these services. They may also
subscribe to the services initially but may not use them as actively as others
because of high distance between the bank and residence, poor infrastructure etc.
d) Behavioral aspects: Research in behavioral economics has shown that many
people are not comfortable using formal financial services. The reasons are
difficulty in understanding language, various documents and conditions that come
with financial services etc.
Figure 1. Household Access to Financial Services
-6-
1.4. Financial exclusion in India
Financial exclusion is the lack of access by certain consumers to appropriate low
cost, fair and safe financial products and services from mainstream providers. It is
observable at individual, family, or household level, but can also be heavily
concentrated in suburbs or regions, and sometimes among ethnic minorities in a
suburb or region. There are several reasons for financial exclusion:
Lack of awareness
Low income and asset
Social exclusion
Illiteracy
Distance from branches
Branch timings
Unsuitable product
Language,
Staff attitudes, etc
1.5. CHALLENGES OF FINANCIAL INCLUSION
The challenges are of structural, social and regulatory in nature. The structural
challenges are the branch expansion in rural unbanked areas. Human resource
operation in remote area is not profitable for bank that is nearly adjusting 600
million new customers. Offering a simple load product without proper security is
the risk for bank management. Processing capacity of the banks is also limited. To
overcome this some central processing centers are required to open Regulatory
Challenges are to see the followings : i) viability ii) security iii) capacity iv) cash
handling v) setting of local service points vi) enrolment process – time consuming
-7-
and identity problems vii) issue of personalization cards viii) connectivity
problems ix) reconciliation of transaction with business correspondent (BC) and
CBS x) bank staff not confident at operating level xi) business correspondent (BC)
cum technology vendor is an ideal combination xii) prospective BCs are sitting on
the fence and watching others. Similarly the Social challenges are i) rural populace
having inhibition to approach bank branches ii) illiteracy of lower economy status
so inhibition iii) lack of active customer education campaign.
Modern banking requires literacy skills that are often not present. Potential
customers need to invest time and effort in understanding banking opportunities
and costs. There may be also a collective action problem. Unless a critical mass of
people is willing to invest in banking literacy, everyone else will find that their
individual efforts in developing banking literacy will not pay off. Because banking
activity is costly in terms of fees and transaction costs, opening a bank account
only becomes attractive if the individual has a minimum income (Beck and
Demirguc-Kunt, 2008).
Due to lack of awareness, low financial education and procedural hassles, many
still prefer to borrow money from informal sources like money lenders and also
rapid expansion, the number of bank branches in the country is still inadequate
(SomasroyChakraborty&Nupur Anand,2014). According to a nation-wide survey
on financial behaviour, India has the highest account dormancy rate even more
than countries like Kenya, Tanzani, Uganda, Nigeria, Pakistan and Bangladesh
. Only 48 per cent of Indian adults have bank accounts and nearly half of them lie
dormant.
-8-
1.6. FACTORS AFFECTING ACCESS TO FINANCIAL SERVICES
Gender Issues: Access to credit is often limited for women who do not have,
or cannot hold title to assets such as land and property or must seek male
guarantees to borrow.
Age Factor: Financial service providers usually target the middle of the
economically active population, often overlooking the design of appropriate
products for older or younger potential customers.
Legal Identity: Lack of legal identities like identity cards, birth certificates
or written records often exclude women, ethnic minorities, economic and
political refugees and migrant workers from accessing financial services.
Limited literacy: Limited literacy, particularly financial literacy, i.e., basic
mathematics, business finance skills as well as lack of understanding often
constraints demand for financial services.
Place of living: Although effective distance is as much about transportation
infrastructure as physical distance, factors like density of population, rural
and remote areas, mobility of the population (i.e., highly mobile people with
no fixed or formal address), insurgency in a location, etc., also affect access
to financial services.
Psychological and cultural barriers: The feeling that banks are not interested
to look into their cause has led to self-exclusion for many of the low income
groups .However, cultural and religious barriers to banking have also been
observed in some of the country's Social security payments
-9-
Bank charges: In most of the countries, transaction is free as long as the
account has sufficient funds to cover the cost of transactions made.
However, there are a range of other charges that have a disproportionate
effect on people with low income.
Terms and Conditions: Terms and conditions attached to products such as
minimum balance requirements and conditions relating to the use of
accounts often dissuade people from using such products/services.
Level of Income: Financial status of people is always important in gaining
access to financial services. Extremely poor people find it difficult to access
financial services even when the services are tailored for them. Perception
barriers and income discrimination among potential members in grouplending programmes may exclude the poorer members of the community.
Type of occupation: Many banks have not developed the capacity to
evaluate loan applications of small borrowers and unorganized enterprises
and hence tend to deny such loan requests.
1.7. VILLAGES COVERED
NSSO 59th Round Survey Result shows that51.4% of farmer households are
financially excluded from both formal/ informal sources. Of the total farmer
households, only 27% access formal sources of credit; one third of this group also
borrowed from non-formal sources. Overall, 73% of farmer households have no
access to formal sources of credit. Across regions, financial exclusion is more
acute in Central, Eastern and North-Eastern regions. All three regions together
accounted for 64% of all financially excluded farmer households in the country.
- 10 -
Overall indebtedness to formal sources of finance of these three regions accounted
for only 19.66%.
Figure 2. Villages Covered
The number of banking outlets in villages with population more than 2000 as well
as less than 2000 increased consistently since March 2010. World Bank report
stated that for rural India about 40% of households has deposit accounts, 20% have
outstanding loans and only 15% have any insurance. As per census 2011, only
58.7% of households are availing banking services in the country. However, as
compared with previous census 2001, availing of banking services increased
significantly largely on account of increase in banking services in rural areas
1.8. FINANCIAL INCLUSION PLAN - ACHIEVEMENTS SO FAR
India has launched more Yojana schemes but this is the scheme launched by our
prime minister on Independence Day meeting in 15 Aug 2014. India’s ambitious
financial inclusion plans aimed as 15m bank accounts were opened the first day of
- 11 -
the Jan DhanYojana scheme, our Prime Minister ShriNarendraModi has new
initiative for every Indian household to have at least one bank account by 2018.
Table 1.PradhanMantri Jan - DhanYojana (Accounts Opened As on
27.05.2015)
(All figures in crores)
S.No
Banks
No Of Accounts
No Of
Balance
Debit
In
Cards
Accounts
% of
Zero
Balance
Accounts
Rural Urban Total
1
Public Sector Banks 6.75
5.64
12.39
11.59
13480
53.7
2
Private Banks
0.39
0.27
0.65
0.59
992.17
49.65
2.4
0.42
2.82
2.06
3048.17
54.09
9.53
6.33
15.86
14.24
17520.3
53.6
3
Regional Rural
Banks
Total
Source: www.pmjdy.gov.in
1.9. A VIEW ON JAN DHAN YOJANA
The Jan DhanYojana (JDY) would be implemented in two phases. In the first
phase, the aim is to provide universal access to banking facilities through a
business correspondent or bank branch, zero-balance bank accounts with overdraft
facility of Rs.5,000 after six months and RuPay debit card (domestic card payment
network which competes with MasterCard and Visa) with inbuilt insurance cover
of Rs.100,000. Those who open accounts by January 26, 2015will be given life
insurance cover of Rs.30,000. In the second phase starting from 15th August 2015,
- 12 -
the focus of JDY would be to provide additional financial services such as micro
insurance and pension schemes meant for unorganized workers.
The government claims that the JDY is a major departure from the earlier initiative
launched in 2005 which was primarily aimed at promoting financial inclusion in
the rural areas with focus on the coverage of villages, whereas the JDY aims to
provide banking services in both rural and urban areas with focus on the coverage
of individual households. One of the new features of JDY is the creation of local
monitoring committees and a web-portal to monitor its implementation at the
national level. The JDY is being run in a mission mode with the Finance Minister
as head of the mission.
Even though there is no universally accepted definition of financial inclusion (FI),
it has become a buzzword in development circles lately. From Queen Maxima of
the Netherlands to World Bank to G20, everyone espouses the concept of financial
inclusion. In simple terms, financial inclusion means delivery of banking services
(such as savings accounts, loans, remittance and payment services) at an affordable
cost and in a convenient manner to the poor and marginalized sections of society.
For India, financial inclusion has become a key policy concern as there are over
600 million citizens who lack basic banking and financial services. In India,
financial exclusion has strong linkages with poverty and is predominantly
concentrated among the vast sections of disadvantaged and low income groups.
One of the important factors behind rising farmer suicides in the countryside is the
lack of access to cheap credit from banks and institutional sources.In India and
- 13 -
elsewhere, financial exclusion is not merely restricted to rural population. A large
number of urban dwellers, migrants and informal sector workers also lack access
to banking and other financial services.The JDY is not the first major initiative to
promote financial inclusion in India. It should be rather viewed as financial
inclusion 3.0 – as two policy initiatives on Financial inclusion were launched
previously.
Financial Inclusion 1.10
After independence, the first initiative on financial inclusion was launched in July
1969 when 14 of the largest privately-owned banks were nationalized. The bank
nationalization marked a paradigm shift as the policy aim was to take the banking
services to poor people. Before nationalization, privately-owned banks were
located in metropolitan and urban areas. Much of bank lending was concentrated
in a few organized sectors of economy and limited to big business houses and large
industries. Whereas farmers, small entrepreneurs, laborers, artisans and selfemployed were totally dependent on informal sources (mainly traditional
moneylenders and relatives) to meet their credit requirements. The share of
agriculture in total bank lending was a meager 2.2 percent during 1951-67.
There were several policy objectives behind the bank nationalization strategy
including the transformation of “class banking” into “mass banking,” expanding
geographical and functional spread of institutionalized credit, mobilizing savings
from rural and remote areas and reaching out to neglected sectors such as
agriculture and small scale industries. Another policy objective was to ensure that
- 14 -
no viable productive business should suffer for lack of credit support, irrespective
of its size.
1.11.Rapid Expansion of Branch Network in Unbanked Locations
At the time of nationalization, scheduled commercial banks had 8,187 branches
throughout the country. But in 1990, the branch network increased to 59,752.
What is even more important is that out of 59,752 bank branches, 34,791 (58.2
percent) were located in the rural areas. In contrast, the share of rural branches was
17.6 percent in 1969. Such a massive expansion of bank branches in the rural areas
was the result of 1:4 licensing policy under which banks were given incentive to
open one branch in metropolitan and one branch in urban areas, provided they
open four branches in the rural areas.
In the early 1970s, the concept of priority sector lending (also known as directed
lending) was evolved to ensure that adequate credit flows to the vital sectors of the
economy and according to social and developmental priorities.
In addition, the establishment of regional rural banks (RRBs) in the mid-1970s
also widened the reach of banking services. The RRBs were jointly owned by the
central government, the state government and the sponsor bank. Between 1975 and
1987, 196 RRBs were established in the rural India. The mandate of RRBs was to
serve small and marginal farmers, agricultural laborers, artisans and small
entrepreneurs in the rural and remote areas. Further, banks were directed to
- 15 -
maintain a credit-deposit ratio of 60 percent in the rural and semi-urban branches
in order to ensure that rural deposits are not used to increase urban credit.
In rural areas, there was significant rise in bank deposits and credit. According to
official data, the share of rural deposits in total deposits increased more than five
times, from 3 percent in 1969 to 16 percent in 1990. The share of agriculture credit
in the total bank credit increased from 2.2 percent in 1968 to 13 percent in 1980
and further to 15.8 percent in 1989. The share of small-scale industry in the total
bank credit which was negligible before nationalization reached 15.3 percent in
1989, a significant achievement by international standards.
There is no denying that the banking system under the nationalization regime was
not perfect as it could not reach out to each and every household but at least a
serious effort was made to spread banking services: geographically, socially and
functionally. There are very few parallels in the history of banking in the world
where such large-scale geographical expansion and functional diversification of
the banking system (with social and developmental orientations) took place within
a span of two decades.
Admittedly, there were cumbersome lending procedures, inadequate supervision,
corruption and political interference which affected functional efficiency and
profitability of the banking system. Nevertheless, the bank nationalization drive
was inspired by a larger objective to promote social and development banking in
India.
- 16 -
1.12. The Neglect of Financial Inclusion under Banking Sector Reforms
One of the adverse consequences of banking sector reforms launched in the 1990s
was the steady decline in the number of bank branches in the rural India. During
1994-2006, bank branches in rural areas were closed down to meet the profitability
criteria and to achieve higher efficiency levels. In absolute terms, the total number
of rural bank branches declined from 35,329 in 1994 to 30,119 in 2006. In other
words, as many as 5,210 bank branches in the rural India were closed down during
1994-2006. On an average, two bank branches were closed down on each working
day during this period.On the other hand, a rapid expansion of branches in the
metros and urban areas has been witnessed in the post-liberalization period.
According to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) statistics, 5,960 new branches were
opened in the six metros during 1994-2006.
In 1994, the share of rural branches was 57.16 percent but it declined to 37.18
percent in 2013, indicating the worsening of the rural-urban ratio of bank branches
in the post-liberalization period.In the 1990s, the banking sector witnessed a
secular decline in agricultural credit. This is in sharp contrast to the 1970s and 80s
when a significant shift in bank lending in favor of agricultural sector took place.
The proportion of bank credit to agriculture and small sector industries declined
from 30 percent in 1994 to 18 percent in 2013, despite several initiatives launched
by the government to revive bank credit to these sectors which generate largest
employment opportunities in the rural areas. The share of deposits raised from
rural areas declined from 15 percent in 1994 to 9 percent in 2012. All these
- 17 -
statistics reveal a sheer neglect of the banking needs of people living in rural and
semi-rural areas during the post-liberalization period.
1.13. Financial Inclusion
Concerned over these adverse developments, another initiative towards FI was
launched in 2005 with greater emphasis on branchless business correspondent
model to provide last mile connectivity to unbanked villages.
In 2005, the RBI pushed banks to provide a “no-frills” zero-balance account with
minimum charges for other services. Other major policy initiatives under this drive
included relaxation in know-your-customer (KYC) norms, easier credit facility,
introduction of General Purpose Credit Card (GCC) and support to microfinance
institutions and Self Help Groups.
The focus on FI was further intensified in 2009 when the RBI directed banks to
draw up a road map to cover nearly 74,200 villages with more than 2,000
population with one banking outlet by 2012. To achieve this target, several new
regulatory measures were introduced. For instance, the domestic banks (both
public and private) were given freedom to open branches in Tier-2 to Tier-6
centers without prior approval from the RBI. In order to encourage banks to open
branches in the predominantly unbanked North-East region, domestic banks were
allowed to open the branches in rural, semi-urban and urban centers without the
prior approval from the RBI. Later on, banks were mandated to open at least 25
percent of their new brick-and-mortar branches in the unbanked rural areas.
- 18 -
Under the financial inclusion plans adopted by banks, 7,459 new branches were
opened in rural areas in three years during 2010-13. However, this period saw the
domination of banking correspondents (BCs) to provide banking services to
unbanked population. Most of the villages covered under this drive were through
BCs. As discussed in more detail below, the BC model failed to adequately
accomplish its intended purpose despite a rapid increase in its outreach.
1.14. Misplaced Emphasis on BC Model
A business correspondent is a representative of bank who provides doorstep
banking services through the use of smart card handling devices which are
connected to the main servers of the bank. The handheld device can identify the
bank customer through finger prints and facilitates basic transactions such as
depositing and withdrawing cash. The RBI has allowed banks to use the services
of NGOs, microfinance institutions, non-banking finance companies and post
offices as BCs.
Since 2006, the policymakers have supported the expansion of banking services
through BC model on the pretext that it provides services at the doorstep of
customers living in unbanked locations and reduces the costs involved in putting
up and operating a brick-and-mortar branch.
There is no denying that the BC model has expanded its reach across the country
in the last eight years. The RBI’s annual report for 2013-14 notes that “nearly
248,000 BC agents had been deployed by banks as on March 31, 2014 which are
- 19 -
providing services through more than 333,000 BC outlets.” Close to 117 million
zero-balance accounts have been opened up by the BCs as on March 31, 2014. In
addition, there were 60,730 BC outlets in urban locations as on March 31, 2014.
These are pretty impressive numbers. But empirical evidence from Sundergarh in
Orissa to Surendranagar in Gujarat suggests that access to bank accounts has not
translated into use. More than 80 percent of zero-balance bank accounts are
dormant.
In cases where customers receive wages under the National Rural Employment
Guarantee Act (NREGA), they simply withdraw the entire amount immediately
after the NREGA disbursement. Not even 5 percent of zero-balance account
holders make deposits into their bank accounts. If people are not actively using
their bank accounts, it defeats the very purpose of financial inclusion.
Banks, on their part, are not interested in promoting awareness activities on the
usage and benefits of formal banking services as they lose money on zero-balance
accounts due to few transactions and low balances. Most banks view zero-balance
accounts as a corporate social responsibility thrust upon them by the government.
For banks, serving poor clients is a social obligation rather than a viable business
opportunity. With the result, the potential benefits of access to formal banking
services are not fully realized.
- 20 -
1.15. The Inherent Weaknesses of BC Models
Some caution is obviously warranted because the JDY relies heavily on the BC
model for expanding banking network in both rural and urban areas. One of
primary reasons behind the unsatisfactory performance of BC model is the poor
remuneration (Rs.2000-3000 per month) paid to business correspondents. For such
a meager amount, it is unfair to expect a BC to visit villages or slums at regular
intervals, open new bank accounts for poor people, process financial transactions,
educate customers about banking services and answer all queries of the customers.
With the result, there is a high attrition rate among BC agents across the country.
Surveys have found that more than half of BC agents are untraceable.
Under the JDY, the BCs will get a minimum compensation of Rs.5000 per month.
This is a welcome move but there are several other important factors which act as
a barrier in the delivery of banking services through BC model. Some of these
factors include inordinate delay in issuing of smart cards to customers (three to six
months); limited utility of smart cards as services such as remittance are not
loaded; inadequate cash handling limit given to BCs; devices not working properly
due to technical problems or poor network connectivity; lack of trust in BCs; lack
of customer-centric banking products and services; poor governance and
inadequate supervision of BCs; and absence of a comprehensive strategy for
financial education.
If these impediments are not addressed, the JDY may turn out to be another
government program under which ambitious targets of opening millions of bank
- 21 -
accounts are achieved on paper but very little meaningful financial inclusion is
actually accomplished on the ground.
It is imperative that the policy focus should shift from the quantity of inclusion to
the quality of inclusion. The success of the JDY should not be measured only on
the basis of number of new accounts opened. The measure of success should also
include clearly defined targets for usage and transactions.
1.16.The JDY Should Emphasize on Physical Branches
Given the unsatisfactory outcomes of the BC model, the JDY should give greater
emphasis on brick-and-mortar branches which enjoy a high degree of trust and
acceptability among the rural people. Besides, there are several transactions (e.g.,
loans) require physical branches and direct interaction with the bank officials.
In a rural setting, a mini-branch (consisting of two staff persons) can easily serve
4-5 villages and provide a full range of banking services. This would ensure that
the villagers will no longer have to take substantial travel and expense to visit a
mini-branch. A mini branch linked with a nearest large branch could function as a
hub-and-spoke system. In Andhra Pradesh, for instance, HDFC bank has recently
established several mini-branches and found it to be a commercially viable model
to offer full banking services to rural people.
The last-mile connectivity is very crucial for the success of JDY. Given the large
outreach of post offices across the country, postal networks could be explored to
provide banking products and services at a low cost.
- 22 -
Like “Post Office on Wheels” which provides a variety of postal services through
a mobile van in the country, the mobile van banking is another credible delivery
model which could be used to serve large customers located in the far-flung rural
areas at regular intervals.
1.1.1 NEED FOR THE STUDY
Financial inclusion is a policy measure to address the issue of poverty which
would ensure avenues for people. It is estimated that globally over two billion
people are excluded from access to financial services, of which one third is in
India. Access to various financial services enables the poor people to participate in
the growth of the economy. Many banks are forced to adopt financial inclusion
rather than their own interest. Only few banks are actively involved in financial
inclusion to promote economic development. The banks have encountered various
problems while adopting financial inclusion Viz. Improper repayment, the need for
additional workforce, more time consumption, heavy work load, high cost etc.
Hence, many banks are not fostering fully fledged financial inclusion plan to
accelerate the growth of the country. This study attempts to address the issues
involved in the adoption of the financial inclusion plan and to widespread the
financial inclusion.
1.1.2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
- 23 -
To study the financial literacy among the rural people.
To analyze the banking habits and usage of banking services among the rural
people.
To examine the awareness level towards usage of technology in accessing
financial services.
To examine the challenges of financial inclusion to reach out rural people.
To suggest measures to promote financial inclusion in rural area
1.1.3. SCOPE OF THE STUDY
This study attempts to cover all the 5 villages of kanchipuram district in Tamil
Nadu.. This district is potential for the agriculture. Agriculture is the main
occupation of the people with 47% of the population engaged in it. Paddy is the
major crop cultivated in this district. Groundnuts, Sugarcane, Cereals & Millets
and Pulses are the other major crops cultivated. 76.50 Metric Tonnes lands are
cultivated in Fuel wood and 8.039 Tonnes in Cashew. Palar River along with
Tanks and wells are the main sources of irrigation in this district. The study covers
the sample size of 200 respondents. The survey has been conducted in the villages
which are not having banking facilities.
1.1.4 HYPOTHESIS FRAMED FOR THIS STUDY
¾ H1: The age of the respondents does not depend on the bank transaction with
the bank officials
- 24 -
¾ H2: There is no association between demographic variables of the
respondents with respect to reasons for not availing loans.
¾ H3: There is no significance difference between reasons for not availing loan
from bank and source of finance.
¾ H4: There is no significant difference between towards lack of knowledge
about banking services and usage of various schemes of banks.
2. THEORTICAL BACKGROUND
2.1 OVERVIEW OF FINANCIAL INCLUSION
"Financial Inclusion" focuses attention on the need to bring previously excluded
people under the umbrella of financial institutions. There is no universally
accepted definition of financial inclusion. Financial Inclusion is generally defined
in terms of exclusion from the financial system. The working or operational
definitions of financial exclusion generally focus on ownership or access to
particular financial products and services .Furthermore, the definitions have
witnessed as shift in emphasis from the earlier ones, which defined financial
inclusion and exclusion largely in terms of physical access, to a wider definition
covering access to and use and understanding of products and services.
The financial services include the entire gamut - savings, loans, insurance, credit,
payments etc. The financial system has to provide its function of transferring
resources from surplus to deficit units but both deficit and surplus units are those
with low incomes, poor background etc. By providing these services, the aim is to
- 25 -
help them come out of poverty. So far, the focus has only been on delivering credit
(it is called as microfinance but is microcredit) and has been quite successful.
The access to finance could be divided into four segments:
1. The proportion of the population that uses a bank or bank like institution.
2. Population which uses services from non-bank "other formal" financial
institutions, but does not use bank services.
3. The population which only uses services from information financial service
providers.
4. Percentage of population transacting regularly through formal financial
instruments and,
5. The population which uses no financial services.
Since measuring inclusion is perceived to be difficult, financial inclusion has
generally been defined in terms of exclusion from the financial system. It focuses
on ownership or access to particular financial products and services. Specific
indicators such as number of bank accounts, number of bank branches that are
generally used as measures of financial inclusion can provide only partial
information on the level of financial inclusion in an economy. In India, the
financially excluded sections comprise largely marginal farmers, landless
labourers, oral lessees, self employed and unorganized sectors enterprises, urban
slum dwellers, migrants, ethnic minorities and socially excluded groups, senior
citizens and women. Some of the important causes of relatively low extension of
institutional credit in the rural areas are risk perception, cost of its assessment and
management, lack of rural infrastructure, and vast geographical spread of the rural
areas with more than half a million villages, some sparsely populated.
- 26 -
2.2 EFFECTIVE DELIVERY MODELS
Several models have been tried, namely like opening of banking outlets, Business
correspondent model, bank led model, basic savings basic deposits accounts, Kisan
credit cards & general credit cards, self-help group-Bank Linkage for pursuing
financial inclusion.
Opening of Banking Outlets
Banking outlets are banking centre or financial centre is a retail location where a
bank, credit union, or other financial institution offers a wide array of face-to-face
and automated services to its customers. So opening of banking outlets in
unbanked areas help people of under banked to get financial aids.
Basic Savings Bank Deposit Account
It will include deposit and withdrawal of cash; receipt / credit of money through
electronic payment channels or by means of deposit / collection of cheques at bank
branches as well as ATMs and services will be free.
Business Correspondent Model
It is a strategy that has been advocated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
ensuring greater financial inclusion and increasing the outreach of the banking
sector, especially in the rural areas. The model intends to use the services of NonGovernmental Organizations/ Self Help Groups (NGOs/ SHGs), Micro Finance
Institutions (MFIs) and other Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) as intermediaries
in providing financial and banking services for people in rural and areas outside of
the Banks’ coverage.
- 27 -
Bank Led Model
RBI has advocated a bank-led model for financial inclusion with thrust on
leveraging technology. Many PSU and Private Banks have started using ICT for
covering all sorts of people for their financial services partnering with Telecom
companies. Mobile banking, online shopping, etc., and several other technology
driven financial services gaining momentum with the help of bank led models.
Kisan Credit Cards
It was started by the Government of India, Reserve Bank of India (RBI), and
National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) in 1998-99 to
help farmers access timely and adequate credit. Banks have been advised to issue
KCCs to small farmers for meeting their credit requirements. Up to March 2013,
the total number of KCCs issued to farmers remained at 33.79 million with a total
outstanding credit of Rs.2622.98 billion
General Credit Cards
To enable farmers to withdraw cash from ATMs anywhere in the country, banks
need to convert KCCs/GCCs to electronic credit card. Further, banks may explore
the possibility of issuing multipurpose cards which could function as debit cards,
KCC and GCC as per the requirements in rural areas.
Development in Self Help Groups- Bank Linkage
The SHG - Bank Linkage Programme is a major plank of the strategy for
delivering financial services to the poor in a sustainable manner. It helps in
bringing more people under sustainable development in a cost effective manner
- 28 -
within a short period of time. As on March 2011, there are around 7.46 million
saving linked SHGs with aggregate savings of Rs.70.16 billion and 1.19 million
credit linked SHGs with credit of Rs. 145.57 billion (Source: NABARD, Status of
Microfinance in India).
Growth in Micro Finance Institutions
Though RBI has adopted the bank-led model for achieving financial inclusion,
certain NBFCs which were supplementing financial inclusion efforts at the ground
level, specializing in micro credit have been recognized as a separate category of
NBFCs as NBFC-MFIs. At present, around 30 MFIs have been approved by RBI.
Their asset size has progressively increased to reach Rs. 19,000 crore as at end
Sept 2013.
2.3 FINANCIAL INCLUSION INITIATIVES
International Initiatives
The current approach to financial inclusion can be United Nations initiatives,
which described the main goals of inclusive finance as access to a range of
financial services including savings, credit, insurance, remittance and other
banking / payment services to all bankable households and enterprises at a
reasonable cost. The Report of the Centre for Global Development (CGD) Task
Force on Access to Financial Services (October, 2009) has given the broad policy
principles for expanding financial access, including some mechanisms. The G20
Toronto Summit (June, 2010) had outlined the “Principles for Innovative Financial
Inclusion”, which serves as a guide for policy and regulatory approaches aimed at
- 29 -
sound adoption of innovative, adequate, low-cost financial delivery models,
helping provide conditions for fair competition and a framework of incentives for
the various bank, insurance, and non-bank actors involved in the delivery of a full
range of affordable and quality financial services. The global financial crisis has
brought the need for financial inclusion into greater focus worldwide as it is
believed that widespread incidence of financial exclusion was one of the factors
that precipitated the financial crisis. While spread of financial inclusion is
recognized through formal financial institutions such as banks, credit unions, post
offices or microfinance institutions, the approach of keeping some/ all of these
entities as a part of the core or as support players, varies from country to country.
National Initiatives
Several countries across the globe now look at financial inclusion as the means
for a more comprehensive growth, wherein, each citizen of the country is able to
use his/her earnings as a financial resource that they can put to work to improve
their future financial status and simultaneously contribute to the nation’s progress.
Initiatives for financial inclusion have come from the financial regulators, the
governments and the banking industry. While the banking sector has taken several
steps to promote financial inclusion, legislative measures have also been initiated
in some countries.
2.3.1 INITIATIVES STARTED BY COMMERCIAL BANKS
INDIAN BANK: The bank has established an exclusive microstate branch in
Chennai for financial inclusion of lower income people who are also
- 30 -
migrants form villages settled in different parts of the city by bringing large
number of under privileged persons into the banking fold through the
concept of SHGs. In the case of SHGs, a line of credit is provided to them
giving flexibility, with simplified accounting procedures. The bank proposes
to open one more such specialized branch in Chennai and in 10 other metros
and urban across the country.
UNION BANK OF INDIA-Village Knowledge Centers: Keeping in view
the urgent requirement to educate the rural inhabitants and farmers in
particular, for updating them with the latest technological developments, a
pioneering effort has been initiated by Union bank of India by establishing
Village Knowledge Centers (VKCs) at strategic rural locations. So far, the
bank has established 198 KVCs all over the country.
Pilot Project in Andhra Pradesh: Andhra Pradesh Government has embarked
on a pilot project with six banks. Viz SBI, SBH, Andhra Bank, Union Bank,
UTI Bank and AP GrameenaVikas bank, to make payments of social
security pensions and AP Rural Employment.
SELF-HELP GROUP - BANK LINKAGE PROGRAMME: An SHG is a
group of about 15 to 20 people from a homogenous class who join together
to address common issues. They involve voluntary thrift activities on a
regular basis, and use of the pooled resource to make interest bearing loans
to the members of the group. In the course of this process, they imbibe the
- 31 -
essentials of financial intermediation and also the basics of account keeping.
The members also learn to handle resources of size, much beyond their
individual capacities. They begin to appreciate the fact that the resources are
limited and have a cost. Once the group is stabilized, and shows mature
financial behavior, which generally takes up to six months, it is considered
for linking to banks. Banks are encouraged to provide loans to SHGs in
certain multiples of the accumulated savings of the SHGs. Loans are given
without any collateral and at interest rates as decided by banks. Banks find it
comfortable to lend money to the groups as the members have already
achieved some financial discipline through their thrift and internal lending
activities. The groups decide the terms and conditions of loan to their own
members. The peer pressure in the group ensures timely repayment and
becomes social collateral for the bank loans Generally, the SHGs need selfhelp promoting institutions (SHPIs) to promote and nurture them. These
SHPIs include various NGOs, banks, farmers' clubs, government agencies,
self-employed individuals and federations of SHGs. However, some SHGs
have also been formed without any assistance from such SHPIs. There are
three different models that have emerged under the linkage programme:
• Model I: This involves lending by banks directly to SHGs without
intervention/facilitation by any NGO.
• Model II: This envisages lending by banks directly to SHGs with facilitation
by NGOs and other agencies.
- 32 -
• Model III: This involves lending, with an NGO acting as a facilitator and
financing agency.
2.3.2 RBI POLICY INITIATIVES FOR FINANCIAL INCLUSION
Many policy initiatives have been taken for financial inclusion such as:
¾ Making Available basic banking “no frills” account either with „nilெ or very
low minimum balance.
¾ Issuing of general credit cards to eligible beneficiaries without insistence on
security, purpose or end use of credit
¾ Introduction of KCC (Kisan Credit Card )
¾ Allowing banks to utilize the services of NGOs, SHGs, MFIs and other civil
society organization as intermediaries in providing financial services
¾ Credit linking of SHGs, support to MFIs
¾ Introduction of financial sector ( regulation and development ) bill 2007 to
develop and regulate the MFIs
¾ Constitution of financial inclusion fund and financial inclusion technology
fund to strengthen the institutional and technological infrastructure for
greater financial inclusion.
¾ Finance literacy would help in using savings, credits and insurance services.
¾ Stipulation of Priority sector lending. Priority sector comprises agriculture,
SSIs, Small road and water transport operator, Small business, retail trader,
self employed persons, housing loan, micro credit, artisan, village and tiny
industries etc.
- 33 -
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In this chapter the researcher discusses about studies which have been undertaken
the part in India and overseas regarding problems, issues and challenges of
financial inclusion. Some of the key findings of the available literature are
presented below.
3.1 FINANCIAL SERVICES AND DELIVERY MODEL
Beck, Demirguc-Kunt and Peria (2006) stated Access to financial services allows
lower income groups to save money outside the house safely, prevents
concentration of economic power with a few individuals and mitigates the risk that
poor people face as a result of economic shocks’.
Rangarajan Committee (2008)explained that the financial services include the
entiregamut of savings, loans, insurance, credit, payments, etc. The financial
system is expectedto provide its function of transferring resources from surplus to
deficit units, but both deficit and surplus units are those with low incomes, poor
background, etc. By providing these services, theaim is to help them come out of
poverty. Rural branches of commercial banks must go beyond providing credit and
provide extension services, including advice on farm-related activities. And the
Committee on Comprehensive Financial Services for Small Business and Low
Income Households has suggested providing a universal bank account to all
Indians above the age of 18 years. This target is to be achieved by January 1, 2016,
- 34 -
less than two years from now. The Aadhaar will be the prime driver towards rapid
expansion in the number of bank accounts.
Ravichandran and Alkhathlan (2009), explained a very few people have access to
banking services. Lack of awareness, low incomes and assets, social exclusion,
and illiteracy are the barriers from the demand side. Distance from the bank
branch, branch timings, cumbersome banking procedure, requirement of
documents for opening bank accounts, unsuitable banking products/schemes,
language barriers, high transaction costs, and attitudes of bank officials are the
barriers from the supply side. The authors discussed bank-SHG, bank-MFI, MFINBFC (with non-banking financial companies), and bank-post office linkage
models and proposed new models such as rural students banking model and RBIeducation institute linkage models.
Prabha (2012) stated the importance of technology in delivery of financial services
to unbanked areas, a technology driven low cost platform has been designed,
which since its implementation is the preferred route for reaching out to the
excluded sections of the society.
Dr. AtulBansal (2012) analyzed banks need to take bold decisions and reach out to
rural India with strategies and business models which are beyond the realm of
conventional thinking
D. Subbarao (2012) explained RBI's rationale for endorsing the bank-led mobile
banking model. He said that while globally the delivery of payment services
- 35 -
through mobile has followed two models viz. bank-led model and non-bank led
model, the first model offers a couple of key advantages over the second one.
Jake Kendall (2012) explained bank led model in that he believe that payments are
an optimal gateway product for financially underserved households. Unlike credit,
insurance, and savings, payments do not require trust by either party.
RBI Committee (2013)decided to invite suggestions from various stakeholders
with a view to enabling them to share their thoughts on the subject from
organizations that are engaged in developing new models of financial services
delivery, in rural as well as urban contexts and have subject matter expertise.
R. Magesh Kumar &C. Samuel Joseph (2013), focused an overview of various
business models and highlights the need and importance of these emerging
profitable models which are in need to be adopted by all banks and financial
institutions towards Financial Inclusion in India.
K.HemaDivya (2013) focused on the objective of financial inclusion to deliver
banking services at an affordable cost to vast sections of the low-income groups of
society. It is argued that as banking services are in the nature of public good, it is
essential that availability of banking and payment services to the entire population
without discrimination is the prime objective of public policy
C.Paramasivam, V.GaneshKumar(2013) Stated that inclusive growth is possible
only through proper mechanism which channelizes all the resources from top to
bottom. Households with low income often lack aces to bank account and have to
spend time and money for multiple visits to avail the banking services, be it
opening a savings bank account or availing a loan, these families find it more
- 36 -
difficult to save and to plan financially for the future. It is an attempt to discuss the
overview of financial inclusion in India.
Rinky Bhatia, Arun. B. Menon (2013) stated an estimated 2.5 billion working-age
adults globally have no access to the types of formal financial services delivered by
regulated financial institution. It is argued that as banking services are in the nature
of public good; the availability of banking and payment services to the entire
population without discrimination is the prime objective of financial inclusion
public policy.
GadamsettySaiArun(2013) Stated high economic growth in the past decade has
lead to huge economic inequality in India; various efforts have been made to
achieve the objectives of the financial inclusion. One such effort is adoption of
ICT in Indian banking sector. Today, banks have centralized operations; banks and
branches are increasingly moving to core banking solutions (CBS), network-based
computing, and new delivery channels such as networked.
ShwetambaraSairam (2014) stated that the cost of serving the rural segment is so
high that banks do not consider it as an economically viable business proposition.
Consequently, the regulator and the government through stipulated guidelines have
been driving banks to provide financial services in these areas .It reviews the
various cost effective rural credit delivery models across the world which could be
emulated by banks in India to transform their rural financing into a lucrative
proposition for both the rural customers as well as for themselves.
- 37 -
B.M.Ramamurthy stated that in order to accomplish this banks are targeting
poorest segment with the support of NGOெs and informal sector comprising small
Self Help Groups (SHGs). The study has attempted to examine the performance
and impact of selected banks and SHGs on financial inclusion.
Ramesh Subramanian (2014) examines whether it would be feasible for banks to
achieve the objective of financial inclusion. The low penetration level of bank
branches in rural India, the high cost of operations/transactions of rural bank,
product design and suitability etc are the challenges for the task. Among the
alternative models Non-Banking Finance Company-Micro Finance Institutions
seem to suit the most suitable. Financial inclusion will lead to economic
development and NBFC-MFIs can play an important role in developmental agenda
of the central government and RBI.
MireyaAlmazán and Elisa Sitbon (2014) overviewed a global smartphone adoption
is set to ramp up massively in the coming years, particularly in developing
markets. As more unbanked consumers gain access to smartphones and mobile
internet services, new opportunities for mobile financial services models will arise.
This GSMA Mobile Money for the Unbanked (MMU) White Paper discusses the
factors at play and their significance to the evolution of mobile money.
3.2 FINANCIAL INCLUSION INITIATIVES
- 38 -
Lata Krishnan (2013) stated the corrective measures taken against financial
exclusion and the financial inclusion initiatives taken by the Government of India
and the RBI. And she stated financial inclusion covers the financial literacy level
of the population, their banking habits and the coverage of the entire financial
system. Government of India and the RBI are keen on introducing and supporting
financial inclusion programmes in India. She explained about the indian financial
system which is effectively controlled by the government of India and RBI has
been reacting positively in order to solve the problems of financial exclusion and
her study has been conducted by various committees and they have suggested
several steps to be taken by the RBI and our indian government.
Dr.M.M.Gandhi (2013) explainedthe main reason why the large section of the
rural populationstill remains under below poverty is financial exclusion, which is
proving to be a major obstacle in the path of India’s economic growth. The
Reserve Bank of India (RBI)’s dictate (2005) obligated the Banks to adopt the
national policy of financial inclusion and take initiatives and suitable measures
therefore. The objective data derived from the RBI’s reports and other empirical
studies unequivocally pinpoint that the main reasons of financial exclusion are lack
of opportunities and access to finance, financial illiteracy, besides poor
performance, apathy and negative approaches of the Banks. Therefore, financial
inclusion, today, has become the national objective and major concern for the
economic policy decision maker.
- 39 -
SonuGarg (2014)focuses on approaches adopted by various Indian banks towards
achieving the ultimate goal of financial inclusion forinclusive growth in India and
analyses of past years progress and achievements. He concluded that for achieve
targets of financial inclusion programme, it is
need to empowering MSMEs
through provide timely and adequate finance because MSMEெs are the best
medium for achieving inclusive growth which generate local demand and
consumption, provide employment to millions of freshers.
Dayananda. K. C (2014)tries to understand policy initiatives by the government for
financial inclusion, reasons for financial exclusion, steps taken by the government
for financial inclusion and implications of financial inclusion. He said that all
activities mainly depend on financial. Financial sector is like blood in human body
.All economic and social problems due to financial sector exclusion. We can solve
all these problems and strengthen the weaker section only through financial
inclusion.
Harshit Eric Williams (2014) focusedin his study founded number of commercial
bank, scheduled commercial bank, RRBs and non scheduled commercial banks
number are reduced during the period between 2008 and 2013. And he analyses
the various initiatives taken by RBI and various banks for encouraging financial
inclusion services so as to achieve rural, social and economic growth.
Anuradha C. HastakAndArunGaikwad (2015) stated for standing out on a global
platform India has to look upon the inclusive growth and financial inclusion is the
- 40 -
key for inclusive growth. There is a long way to go for the financial inclusion to
reach to the core poor. As the Honorable prime minister of India has taken
initiative and started ‘Pradhanmantri Jan DhanYojana’, the efforts taken by RBI
have been strengthened. The fact is number of bank accounts opened by urban and
rural poor are increasing but whether these accounts will really provide financial
services to urban and rural poor is matter of concern.
3.3 OPPORUNITIES AND TECHNOLOGY
Geach (2007) studied financial exclusion and mobile phone technology. He found
that the use of electronic communication throughout the world has not included
everyone. He argues that the vast majority of the world‘s population is still unable
to gain access to digital technology, especially the Internet. These people are
located in rural or poor inner city areas that are less likely to have Internet access.
Advances in mobile phone technology could provide the solution to this problem.
Thorat (2007) stated that the ATMs, internet banking, smart card-based products,
mobile access, and so on, and are using IT for customer relationship management,
customer transaction pattern analysis, credit profiling, and risk management.
Sangwan (2007) studied financial inclusion and self-help groups (SHGs), and
found that over the last 15 years, India has witnessed unprecedented growth in
financial services unfolded by liberalization and the globalization of financial
services due to the adoption of information technology (IT) and the unlocking of
the regulatory framework. However, alongside this positive development, there is
- 41 -
evidence that the formal financial sector still excludes a large section of the
population.
MandiraShanra&JasimPaise (2008) suggests that the issue of financial inclusion is
a development policy priority in many countries. Further physical & electronic
connectivity and information availability, indicated by road network, telephone &
internet usage also play a positive role in enhancing financial inclusion.
Medhi et al. (2009) focused the mobile banking adaptation and usage by lowliterate and low income users. Due to the increasing penetration of mobile phones
even in poor communities, Mobile-phone-enabled banking (m-banking) services
are increasingly targeting the ʊunbanked to bring formal financial services to the
poor. However, more research is required to understand the issues that prevent
low-income, low-literate populations from meaningfully adopting and using
existing m-banking services in order to scale up financial inclusion through
technology.
Chakraborty (2009) focused on technology, financial inclusion, and the role of
banks showed that technology can operate on any platform. However, the
technology solution to the business needs should be user-friendly without much
third-party or IT vendor intervention or support requirement for operating the
same. Banks need to redesign their business strategies to incorporate specific plans
to promote financial inclusion of low-income groups, treating it as both a business
opportunity as well social responsibility.
- 42 -
Vijay Kelkar (2009) explained an innovative proposal for promoting financial
inclusion as
well as improving the delivery of a number of government subsidies. Currently, a
number of subsidies are given via multiple channels, such as food subsidy,
fertilizer subsidy, kerosene subsidy, power subsidy. Given the reach of information
technology, it is now possible to deliver subsidies more efficiently and effectively
to the target groups.
Reddy (2010) suggested a new approach for banks to reach wider populations in
rural areas establish mobile-banks/representatives/agents who operate on a
commercial
basis
rather
than
relying
on
self-help
groups.
These
agents/representatives work on commission basis and hence, are self-motivated
and cost-effective in assisting banks in service provision/deposit mobilization.
Shunko Rojas (2012) stated mobile banking, institutional innovations and
improvements in performance have revolutionized the field making private actors,
international institutions and governments focus on this industry in constant
development.
3.4 CHALLENGES ON FINANCIAL INCLUSION
Leeladhar (2005) stated despite making significant improvements in all areas
relating to financial viability, profitability and competitiveness, there are concerns
- 43 -
that banks have not been able to include vast segment of the population, especially
the underprivileged sections of the society.
RBI (2009) stated that access to well-functioning financial system by creating
equal opportunities enables economically and socially excluded people to integrate
better into the economy and actively contribute to development and protects
themselves against economic shocks.
Das (2010) studied the scaling up of technology to build inclusive financial
systems in India. The systems that provide connectivity need to be relatively
inexpensive if they are to be commercially deployed, given the lower incomes in
rural areas compared to those in urban areas. Recently, ICT implementations have
emerged as a powerful tool to reduce operating costs, making it viable for financial
institutions to expand into rural and low-income areas. Despite the success of
microfinance services in many countries, access to financial services in remote
rural areas remains a challenge in India.
KrishnaveniMuthiah (2010) found limited access to affordable financial services
such as savings, loans, remittance and insurance services to the vast majority of the
population in the rural area and unorganized sector is believed to be a constraint to
the growth in these sectors. The behavioral pattern shows that many people were
not comfortable with formal financial services. The reasons were difficulty in
understanding language, various documents and conditions that come with
financial services etc.
- 44 -
Joseph Massey (2010)said that role of financial institutions in a developing
country is vital in promoting financial inclusion. The efforts of the government to
promote financial inclusion and deepening can be further enhanced by the proactiveness on the part of capital market players including financial institutions.
Financial institutions have a very crucial and a wider role to play in fostering
financial inclusion. National and international forum have recognized this and
efforts are seen on domestic and global levels to encourage the financial
institutions to take up larger responsibilities in including the financially excluded
lot.
VighneswaraSwamy P M (2011) has critically analyzed the issues and challenges
involved in financial inclusion for inclusive growth and have also successfully
attempted to highlight the factors that can aid in achieving financial inclusion for
inclusive growth in India, particularly in the context of the feared global slowdown
and negative impact of high inflation on the Indian economy. And also suggested
some policy choices for successful implementation of the policy of financial
inclusion for sustainable growth of Indian economy.
Dr.AnuragB.Singh, PriyankaTandon(2012) Stated that more than 150 million poor
people have access to collateral-free loans.However there are still large sections of
the world population that are excluded from the financial services market. In India
half of the poor are financially excluded from the country's main stream of the
banking sector. Still in India 22 percent of the people are living below the poverty
- 45 -
line. Their monthly income is less than $1 per day and they are living in most unliveable conditions.
Dr. VivekSingla (2013) stated thatin India various challenges are faced in the way
of the financial inclusion such as lack of financial education, seasonal income of
the poor, physical distance of the bank’s branches, complicated procedure to avail
financial services etc. Hence, Government, RBI and Industry have to take various
measures to provide the benefits of financial inclusion to the weaker section of the
society. There is a huge need to adopt various strategies for the financial inclusion
such as adaptation of advanced technology, opening up the bank branched in rural
areas, introduction of new saving schemes for low income people etc.
Sachindra G R (2013) explained Financial Inclusion has far reaching
consequences, which can help many people come out of hopeless poverty
conditions. The financial markets must act responsibly and ensure that the spirit of
financial inclusion is not breached in the future. He witnesses the challenges of
financial inclusion in India agent and vendor risk, consumption oriented
expenditure patterns, dormant accounts, inadequate awareness levels, lack of
infrastructure. low literacy rates. measuring actual extent of financial exclusion.
poor saving habits, recovery related issues, small ticket transactions & high
transaction costs, sustainability factor, varied local conditions.
Elisabeth Rhyne (2013) statedfrom the Global Findex, more than 2.5 billion people
lack access to even a basic bank account a huge gap in inclusion and an enormous
- 46 -
opportunity. Demographic changes, economic growth and advances in technology
are making global financial inclusion more possible than ever before. With a
massive new market of people demanding new services as incomes rise among the
bottom 40 percent, the stage is set for dramatic leaps in access in the next few
years. Emerging technologies are bringing down costs and opening new business
models while providing greater access to a range of services.
M.ShahulHameedu(2014) stated that internationally efforts are being made to
study the causes of financial exclusion and designing strategies to ensure financial
inclusion of the poor and disadvantaged. The reasons may vary from country to
country and hence the strategy could also vary but all out efforts are being made as
financial inclusion can truly lift the financial condition and standards of life of the
poor and the disadvantaged.
Parveenkumar (2014) examined that financial inclusive is an innovative concept
which make alternative technique to promote banking habit of the rural people
because India is considered as largest rural people consist in the world financial
inclusion is aimed at providing banking and financial services to all people in fair
transparent and equitable manner at affordable cost. He broadly explain the
challenges involved in financial access to low income families are as socioeconomic factors, geographic factors, high operational costs, limited availability of
appropriate technology, inadequate banking products, financial inclusion and
banks' business plans, greater emphasis is required on financial inclusion for the
aged.
- 47 -
PavanKapoor&Dr. AlkaSingh(2014) concluded that undoubtedly financial
inclusion is playing a catalytic role for the economic and social development of
society but still there is a long road ahead to achieve the desired outcomes.
SomasroyChakraborty&NupurAnand (2014) Due to lack of awareness, low
financial education and procedural hassles, many still prefer to borrow money
from informal sources like money lenders and also rapid expansion, the number of
bank branches in the country is still inadequate.
C.R.L. Narasimhan (2014) said latest inclusion plan will have as its focus
households rather than geographical areas. After satisfactory conduct of accounts it
is proposed to offer reasonable need-based credit facilities for which overdraft
facilities will be sanctioned. A smart card (RuPay card) will be issued to enable
customers to operate their accounts even without BCs. Simultaneously suitable
awareness will be created among the financially excluded. In the second phase,
there is a proposal to make available a pension scheme for identified individuals in
the unorganised sector and offer microfinance products through governmentowned insurance companies.
Dr. EuginPrakashPathrose& Allen Baby (2015) stated that all commercial banks
have been working under the directive of the Reserve Bank of India to ensure that
every household has access to banking services. Though significant progress has
been made, there are many challenges on the way. This study is a critical step in
- 48 -
this regard, which aims to identify the key issues faced by the target population in
accessing and using financial services.
4. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter explains the methodology employed by the researcher for this
research work. This chapter describes research design adopted for the study in
detail, nature and sources of data collected for the study and the details about data
collection to used for the research further this chapter provides detail information
about the various test employed to determine the reliability of the instrument.
Finally this chapter provides detail about statistical packages and tools used for
analyzing the data.
4.1 RESEARCH DESIGN
The main objective of the study is to determine the financial literacy and examine
usage of banking services among the rural areas of kancheepuram district, Tamil
Nadu. Therefore descriptive research design is adopted to study the financial
inclusion to reach out rural area. It is a plan of organizing framework for doing the
collection of data.
4.2 DATA COLLECTION PROCEDURE:
Data refers to information or facts. It includes numerical figures, non-numerical
figures, descriptive facts, and qualitative facts. Collecting the information and data
is an important part in completing this thesis. Primary data can be used for this
study.
- 49 -
PRIMARY DATA:
The research is mainly based on the primary data. The data has been collected
from the four villages of Kanchipuram district namely thiruvadisoolam,
kannivakkam, potheri, pulikudivanam. The instrument used for the collection of
data is interview schedule Theinterview schedule is prepared in English and
translated to Tamil for the convenience of the respondents.
SECONDARY DATA:
The secondary data has been collected from the website, relevant articles and
research journals. Secondary data is data that is published by an entity different
from the one that originally collected and published the data, so in this study
secondary data is collected from company, accounting books, journals.
4.3 RESEARCH INSTRUMENT
A research instrument is a survey, interview schedule test, scale, rating, or tool
designed to measure the variable(s), characteristic(s), or information of interest,
often a behavioral or psychological characteristic. Research instruments can be
helpful tools to your research study. Before the survey questionnaire was
administered to the respondents, a pre-test of the questionnaire was conducted. The
pre-test was conducted on a 50 samples and the samples were randomly selected in
rural areas of kanchipuram district to fill out the questionnaire.
4.4 RELIABILITY TEST FOR DATA COLLECTION INSTRUMENT
Reliability of the research instrument refers to its ability to give consistent
results on repeated trials. In other words, a reliable instrument gives the same
- 50 -
value when measured repeatedly with the same object (Gaur & Gaur, 2009). The
question of reliability arises only for the questions used to measure attitude which
cannot be accurately measured. In this research, statements are used to measure
Perception Towards Bank, Reasons for Not Availing Loan, and Lack of
Knowledge about Banking Facilities, Source of Income from Others and Usage Of
Various Schemes Of Banks.
.
All the statements are in five points Likert scales. The statistical package
SPSS is used to calculate Cronbach alpha value for measuring the reliability of the
instrument. If the alpha value is more than 0.6, it is assumed that the instrument is
reliable. Initially, alpha value is calculated for the data collected through pilot
study. This survey has been conducted not only for testing the reliability of data
collection instrument but also for making required changes in the interview
schedule in order to extract necessary information from respondents. The interview
schedule has been altered based on the feedback given by the respondents during
the initial pilot study.. The measured reliability values in different stages are
presented in the following table.
TABLE 4.4 RELIABILITY TEST
VARIABLES
NO OF
CRONBACH'S
ITEMS
ALPHA
Perception Towards Bank
9
.676
Reasons For Not Availing Loan
4
.693
Lack Of Knowledge About
5
.875
- 51 -
Banking Facilities
Source Of Income From Others
2
.787
Usage Of Various Schemes Of
5
.696
Banks
Source: primary data
4.5 STATISTICAL TOOLS USED FOR THIS STUDY
Statistical tools used for this study are:
¾ Percentage analysis
¾ Descriptive analysis
¾ Chi square analysis
¾ Paired t test
¾ One way Anova
PERCENTAGE ANALYSIS:
Percentage analysis is helpful to find a percentage and frequency of the variables
used for the study. The researcher used percentage analysis for the demographic
variables, usage of technology to access financial services and no frill account.
DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS
Descriptive analysis means analysis of data that helps describe, show or
summarize data in a meaningful way such that, for example, patterns might emerge
from the data. Descriptive statistics do not, however, allow us to make conclusions
beyond the data we have analysed or reach conclusions regarding any hypotheses
we might have made. They are simply a way to describe our data. Descriptive
- 52 -
statistics are very important because if we simply presented our raw data it would
be hard to visulize what the data was showing, especially if there was a lot of it.
Descriptive statistics therefore enables us to present the data in a more meaningful
way, which allows simpler interpretation of the data. There are two general types
of statistic that are used to describe data:
¾ Measures of central tendency
¾ Measures of spread
CHI SQUARE TEST
A chi-squared test, also referred to as Ȥ² test (or chi-square test), is any statistical
hypothesis test in which the sampling distribution of the test statistic is a chisquare distribution when the null hypothesis is true. Chi-square is a statistical test
commonly used to compare observed data with data we would expect to obtain
according to a specific hypothesis. For this study the researcher has used pearson
chi square test.
PEARSON'S CHI-SQUARE TEST
Pearson's chi-square test also known as the chi-square goodness-of-fit test or chisquare test for independence. It is used to test whether there is any difference
between the observed (experimental) value and the expected (theoretical) value.
PAIRED t TEST
A paired t-test is used to compare two population means where you have two
samples inwhich observations in one sample can be paired with observations in the
- 53 -
other sample.
ONE WAY ANOVA
The one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) is used to determine whether there
are any significant differences between the means of two or more independent
(unrelated) groups.
4.6 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES
For this research, the researcher has used purposive sampling. Purposive sampling
also known as judgmental, selective or subjective sampling is a type of nonprobability sampling technique. Non probability sampling focuses on sampling
techniques where the units that are investigated as based on the judgment of the
research.
4.7 SAMPLE SIZE
If the sample size (‘n’) is too small, it may not serve to achieve the objectives and
if it is too large, we may incur huge cost and waste resources. The sample must be
of an optimum size i.e., it should neither be excessively large nor too small.
Technically, the sample size should be large enough to give a confidence interval
of desired width and as such the size of the sample must be chosen by some logical
process before sample is taken from the universe. Size of the sample should be
determined by a researcher. For this study researcher has taken 200 samples of
unbanked rural areas from kancheepuram district.
- 54 -
5. DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
5.1 PERCENTAGE ANALYSIS
5.1.1 DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES OF THE RESPONDENTS
Respondents were asked about their demographic profile, which included age,
education, occupation, gender, monthly expenditure, maritalstatus. The Responses
are presented in the form of table whichisas follows
TABLE: 5.1.1 DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES OF THE RESPONDENTS
DEMOGRAPHIC CATEGORY
VARIABLES
AGE
15-25
26-36
37-47
48-58
59-69
70-80
YES
EDUCATION
OCCUPATION
MARTIAL
STATUS
GENDER
MONTHLY
EXPENDITURE
FREQUENCY PERCENT
42
62
43
37
15
1
143
21.0
31.0
21.5
18.5
7.5
.5
71.5
NO
57
28.5
AGRICULTURE
DAILY WAGES
SELF
EMPLOYMENT
DEPENDENT
YES
NO
MALE
FEMALE
MINIMUM RS.1000
RS. 1000-2000
RS. 2000-3000
MINIMUM RS. 3000
13
62
6.5
31.0
1
.5
124
178
22
25
175
21
19
40
120
62.0
89.0
11.0
12.5
87.5
10.5
9.5
20.0
60.0
- 55 -
Source: Primary Data
CHART 5..1.1 AGE OF THE RESPONDENTS
00.5%
AGE GROUP
7.5%
15-25
21%
26-36
18.5%
37-47
48-58
21.5%
31%
59-69
70-80
Source: Primary Dataa
CHART 5.1.22 GENDER OF THE RESPONDENTS
S
'EZ
WZEd
ϴϳ͘ϱй
ϭϬϬ
ϱϬ
ϭϮ͘ϱй
Ϭ
DĂůĞ
&ĞŵĂůĞ
'EZ
Source: Primary Data
- 56 -
CHART 5.1.3E
EDUCATION OF THE RESPONDENT
TS
PERCENT
EDUCATION
71.5%
100
28.5%
0
Literate
iiliterate
LITERACY
Source: Primary Data
CHART 5.1.44 MARITAL OF THE RESPONDENTS
S
DZ/d>^ddh^
ϴϵй
WZEd
ϭϬϬ
ϱϬ
ϭϭй
Ϭ
DĂƌƌŝĞĚ
hŶŵĂƌƌŝĞĚ
Source: Primary Data
- 57 -
CHART 5.1.5OC
CCUPATION OF THE RESPONDEN
NTS
WZEd
KhWd/KE
ϴϬ
ϲϬ
ϰϬ
ϮϬ
Ϭ
ϲϮй
ϯϭй
ϲ͘ϱ
ϱй
ƵůƚƵƌĞ
ŐƌŝĐƵ
Ϭ͘ϱй
ĂŝůLJǁĂŐĞƐ
^ĞůĨ
ĞŵƉůŽLJŵĞŶƚ
ĞƉĞŶĚĞŶƚ
KhWd/KE>s>
Source: Primary Data
CHART 5.1.6 MONTH
HLY EXPENDITURE OF THE RESPO
ONDENTS
DKEd,>zyWE/dhZ
WZEd
ϲϬй
ϲϬ
ϱϬ
ϰϬ
ϯϬ
ϮϬ
ϭϬ
Ϭ
ϮϬй
ϭϬ͘ϱй
DŝŶŝŵ
ŵƵŵ
ZƐ͘ϭϬϬϬ
ϵ͘ϱй
ZƐ͘ϭϬϬϬͲϮϬϬϬ ZƐ͘ϮϬϬϬͲϯϬϬϬ
DŝŶŝŵƵŵ
ZƐ͘ϯϬϬϬ
Source: Primary Data
INTERPRETATION
From the above table it is clear that, 21% of the respondents are from the age
group of 15-25, 31% of the respondents are from the age group of 26
6-36, 21.5% of
the respondents are betweenn the age group of 37-47, 18.5% of the reespondents are
- 58 -
between the age group of 48-58, 7.5% of the respondents are from age group of
59-69 and .5% of the respondents are between the age group of 70-80.
It has shown that 71.5% of the respondents are educated and 28.5% of the
respondents are not educated.
It is noted that 6.5% of the respondents are doing agriculture, 31% of the
respondents are daily wage, .5% of the respondents are self employed, 62% of the
respondents are dependent.
It is shown that 89% of the respondents are married and 11% of the respondents
are unmarried
It is given that 12.5% of the respondents are male, 87.5% of the respondents are
female.
It is given that 10.5% of the respondents’ expenditure is Rs.1000, 9.5% of them is
in between Rs.1000-2000, 20% of the respondents is in between Rs.2000-3000,
60% of the respondents has minimum Rs.3000.
TABLE: 5.1.2 USAGE OF TECHNOLOGY TO ACCESS FINANCIAL
SERVICES
USAGE OF
TECHNOLOGY
ATM CARD
CREDIT CARD
MOBILE
USAGE
FREQUENCY PERCENT
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
NO
84
116
3
197
144
56
- 59 -
42.0
58.0
1.5
98.5
72.0
28.0
CHART 5.1.7 USAGE OF ATM CARD TO ACCESS FINA
ANCIAL
SERVICES
WZEd
h
h^'K&dDZ^
ϲϬϬ
ϰϬϬ
ϮϬϬ
Ϭ
ϱϴй
ϰϮй
zĞƐ
EŽ
h^'
Source: P
Primary Data
CHART 5.1.8 USAGE OF CREDIT CARD TO ACCESS FIN
NANCIAL
SERVICES
WZEd
h^^'K&Z/dZ
ϭϱϬ
ϵϴ͘ϱй
ϭϬϬ
ϱϬ
Ϭ
ϭ͘ϱй
zĞƐ
EŽ
h^'
Source: P
Primary Data
- 60 -
CHART 5.1.9 USAGE
E OF TELEPHONE TO ACCESS FINA
ANCIAL
SERVICES
WZEd
h^'K&d>W,KE
ϭϬϬ
ϳϮй
Ϯϴй
ϱϬ
Ϭ
zĞƐ
EŽ
h^'
Source: Primary Data
a having
From the above table it can bbe revealed that 42% of the respondents are
ATM cards and 58% of the rrespondents are not having ATM cards.
It is given that 1.5 % of the rrespondents are having the credit card and 98.5% of
the respondents are not haviing the credit card.From the survey it can be observed
that 72% of the respondents are using mobile and 28% of the respond
dents are not
using mobile.
LE 5.1.3 NO FRILL ACCOUNT
TABL
PARTICUL
LARS
FREQUENCY PERCENT
YES
34
17.0
NO
166
83.0
TOTAL
200
100.0
- 61 -
CHART 5.1.10 NO FRILL ACCOUNT
EK&Z/>>KhEd
WZEd
ϭϬϬ
ϴϯй
ϴϬ
ϲϬ
ϰϬ
ϭϳй
ϮϬ
Ϭ
LJĞƐ
ŶŽ
Source: Primary Data
From the above table, 17% of the respondents are having no frill account and 83%
of the respondents are not having no frill account.
5.2 DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS
TABLE: 5.2.1 AVERAGE MEAN AND STANDARD DEVIATION FOR
AGE AND MONTHLY EXPENDITURE
Table 5.2.1 Descriptive Statistics
N
Minimum
Age of the
respondents
Monthly
expenditure
Maximum Mean Std.
Deviation
200
1
6
2.62
1.242
200
1
4
3.29
1.016
From the above table the average mean for the age of the respondents is 2.62 and
standard deviation is 1.242 and the average mean for the monthly expenditure is
3.29 and standard deviation is 1.016.
- 62 -
5.3 INFERENTIAL ANALYSIS
5.3.1 CHI SQUARE TEST
H0: The age of the respondents does not depend on the bank transaction with the
bank officials
H1: The age of the respondents depend on the bank transaction with the bank
officials
Table 5.3.1 Age of the respondents * bank transaction with
the bank officials Cross tabulation
Demographic
Bank transaction with the bank officials
Variable
strongly Disagree
disagree
no
agree
opinion
Total
strongly
23
6
8
3
2
42
26-36
39
8
9
5
1
62
Age of the
37-47
21
11
6
4
1
43
respondents
48-58
18
4
9
4
2
37
59-69
4
3
5
1
2
15
70-80
P value
value
agree
15-25
Total
Chi
square
0
0
1
0
0
1
105
32
38
17
8
200
19.923
.463
Since p value is 0.463 which is greater than 0.05 hence H0 is accepted at 5% level
of significance therefore the age of the respondents does not depend on the bank
transaction with the bank officials.
- 63 -
5.3.2 CHI SQUARE TEST
H0: There is no association between demographic variables of the respondents with
respect to reasons for not availing loans.
H1: There is association between demographic variables of the respondents with
respect to reasons for not availing loans.
Table 5.3.2Chi square association for demographic variables*
reasons for not availing loans Cross tabulation
Demographic Reasons for not availing loans
Variable
Lack of
High
More
knowledge
interest
formalities
Age
23.169 (.281) 8.107 (.991) 22.207 (.329)
Education
20.325 (.000)**
Occupation
10.041
11.384(.023)*
(.040)*
22.682
27.894 (.006)**
27.701 (.006)**
(.031)*
1.212 (.876) 1.919 (.751) 5.955 (.203)
No
Documentation
24.923 (.204)
7.045 (.134)
26.357 (.010)**
Gender
2.499 (.645)
Marital
6.057 (.195) 3.455 (.485) 6.775 (.148)
6.557 (.161)
status
Monthly
19.570 (.076) 5.698 (.931) 12.601 (.399)
(.569)
expenditure
** denotes 1% level of significance, * denotes 5% level of significance
Since p value is .281 and it is greater than 0.05 level of significance. Therefore H0
is acceptedso there is no association between age and lack of knowledge. Since p
value is 0.991 and it is greater than the 0.05 significance level H0 is accepted so
there is no association between age and high interest. The p value is 0.329 and it is
greater than the 0.05 significance level. Hence H0 is accepted so there is no
- 64 -
association between age and more formalities. Since p value is 0.204 it is greater
than 0.05 significance level. Therefore H0 is accepted so there is no association
between age and no documentation. The p value is 0.000 hence H0 is rejected at
1% level of significanceso there is association between education and lack of
knowledge. Since p value is .040 therefore H0 is rejected at 5% level of
significance so there is association between education and high interest. The p
value is 0.23 and it is less than the 0.05 significance level therefore H0 is rejected
so there is association between education and more formalities. Since p value is
0.134 and it is greater than 0.05 significance hence H0 is accepted it is concluded
thatthere is no association between education and no documentation. The p value
is 0.006 hence H0 is rejected at 1% level of significance so there is association
between occupation and lack of knowledge. The p value is 0.31 and it is less than
0.05 level of significance therefore H0 is rejected, there is association between
occupation and high interest. Since p value is 0.006 hence H0 is rejected at 1%
level of significance, there is association between occupation and more formalities.
Since p value is 0.010 therefore H0 is rejected at 1% level of significance, there is
association between occupation and no documentation. The p value is 0.876
which is greater than 0.05 level of significance. Hence H0 is accepted so there is no
association between gender and lack of knowledge. The p value is 0.75 which is
greater than 0.05 level of significance.Therefore H0 is accepted so there is no
association between gender and high interest. The p value is 0.203 and it is greater
than 0.05 level of significance Hence H0 is accepted so there is no association
between gender and more formalities. The p value is 0.645 it is greater than 0.05
level of significance therefore H0 is accepted so there is no association between
- 65 -
gender and no documentation. Since p value is 0.195 and it is greater than 0.05
level of significance therefore H0 is accepted so there is no association between
marital status and lack of knowledge. Since p value is 0.485 and it is greater than
0.05 level of significance. Therefore H0 is accepted so there is no association
between marital status and high interest. Since p value is 0.148it is greater than
0.05 level of significance hence H0 is accepted so there is no association between
marital status and more formalities. The p value is 0.161 and it is greater than 0.05
level of significance therefore H0 is accepted so there is no association between
marital status and no documentation. Since p value is 0.076 and it is greater than
0.05 level of significance therefore H0 is accepted so there is no association
between monthly expenditure and lack of knowledge. Since p value is 0.931 it is
greater than 0.05 level of significance .Therefore H0 is accepted so there is no
association between monthly expenditure and high interest. The p value is 0.399
and it is greater than 0.05 level of significance. Hence H0 is accepted so there is no
association between monthly expenditure and more formalities. Since p value is
0.569 it is greaterthan 0.05 level of significance Therefore H0 is accepted so there
is no association between monthly expenditure and no documentation.
5.3.3 PAIRED T TEST
H0: There is no significance difference between reasons for not availing loan from
bank and source of finance from others.
H1: There is significance difference in attitude between reasons for not availing
loan from bank and source of finance from others.
- 66 -
Table 5.3.3 Paired Samples Test
Paired Differences
95% Confidence Interval of
the Difference
Upper
Reasons for not
Pair 1 availing loan - .808
alternate ways
T
Df
Sig. (2tailed)
.217
199
.829
Since p value 0.829 and it is greater than the 0.05 level of significance. Therefore
H0 is accepted so there is no significance difference in attitude between reasons for
not availing loan and methods of sourcing finance.
5.3.4 PAIRED t TEST
H0: There is no significant difference between towards lack of knowledge about
banking services and usage of various schemes of bank.
H1: There is significant difference between lack of knowledge about banking
services and usage of various schemes of bank.
Table 5.3.4 Paired Samples Test
Paired Differences
95% Confidence Interval of
the Difference
Upper
Lack of
knowledge about
Pair 1 banking services – 2.987
usage of various
schemes of bank
** denotes 1% level of significance
T
Sig. (2tailed)
3.707
- 67 -
Df
199
.000**
Since p value 0.000 it is less than the 0.01 level of significance. Therefore H0 is
rejected at 1% level of significance so there is significant difference between lack
of knowledge about banking services and various schemes of bank.
5.3.5 ONE WAY ANOVA
H0: There is no significant difference in opinion towards source of finance from
others between different occupation groups.
H1: There is significant difference in opinion towards source of finance from
others between different occupation groups.
TABLE 5.3.5 ONE WAY ANOVA
Sum of Squares
Df
Mean Square
F
Between Groups 198.770
3
66.257
4.514 .004**
Within Groups
2876.585
196
14.676
Total
3075.355
199
Sig.
** denotes 1% level of significance
Since P value is0.004 it is less than the 0.01 level of significance. Therefore H0 is
rejected at 1% significant level so there is significant difference in opinion towards
source of finance from others between different occupation groups.
- 68 -
6. FINDINGS
It is found that among 200 respondents, 31% of the respondents are from the age
group of 26-36 and 0.5% of the respondents are comes under the age group of 7080.
It is observed that 71.5% of the respondents in the rural areas are educated and
28.5% of the respondents are uneducated.
It is found that. 62% of the respondents are dependent and 0.5% of the
respondents are self-employed. It is observed that 6.5% of the respondents are
doing agriculture and 31% of the respondents working as a daily wage.
It is noticed from the survey that 89% of the respondents are married. According
to this study it is observed that 87.5% of the respondents are female and 10.5% of
the respondents are male.
60 % Majority of the respondents said that they need minimum Rs.3000 as
monthly expenses
The study shows that 58% of the respondents are not having ATM cards and 42%
of the respondents are having ATM cards and also using it..
It is found that 98.5% of the respondents are not having credit cards and only
1.5% of the respondents are having credit cards.
It is noticed that 72% of the respondents are having mobile and 28.5% of the
respondents are not having mobile. The study shows that majority of the
respondents are having mobile and using it.
It is observed that 83% of the respondents are not having no frill account and
only 17% of the respondents are having no frill account.
- 69 -
Through this study the under the age group of 26-36 of the respondents has
strongly disagree. It is evidenced that there is no association between the age of
the respondents does not depend on the bank transaction with the bank officials
The study found that lack of knowledge, high interest, more formalities are the
reasons for not availing loan
There is association between demographic variables of the respondents with
respect to reasons for not availing loans.
The analysis shows that there is no significance difference between reasons for
not availing loan from bank and source of finance from others.
It is found that there is significant difference between lack of knowledge about
banking services and usage of various schemes of bank.
It is evidenced there is significant difference in opinion towards source of finance
from othersbetween different occupation groups.
7. SUGGESTIONS
The major reasons for failure of Financial Inclusion in the past in spite of
initiatives were: a) absence of technology, b) lack of reach and coverage, c)
inefficient delivery mechanism, d) absence of business model, and e) lack of
compassion for poor among rich. But, today, there is an increase in focus on
inclusive growth. Banking technology has progressed fast enough and more
importantly the realization that the poor is bankable has arrived. Various
immediate measures which government of India should implement or which are
under implementations but should be executed in a more effective manner are
- 70 -
Strengthen agency banking (micro finance institutions, business facilitators
and business correspondents). Our very old post offices will be an ideal
channel to pursue the future long term goals of agency banking especially in
rural India.
Achieve synergies between the technology providers and banking channels
to expand reach. Application developers will be required to synergize core
banking with micro financial applications.
Increase coverage under mobile banking and satellite banking and develop
new platforms.
Have interest rate ceilings specified for NGO/MFI for they tend to charge
higher rates of interest in a sugar coated form. These legalities can be
introduced once an NGO/MFI enters into partnership with a bank.
Corporate social responsibility: The CSR cells of MNC's and other firms can
contribute by means of a common platform or even individually.
Contribution can be cash grants to registered NGO/MFI's, which will be
responsible for disbursement, or the CSR cell can act as potential customers
for goods produced by the cottage industries. This model has been highly
successful in the United Kingdom and even in eastern rural regions.
8. CONCLUSION
Developing and under-developed economies all over the globe are looking
for new modes and means to contain poverty and include their citizens in
the financial system. It is becoming increasingly apparent that addressing
financial exclusion will require a holistic approach on the part of the banks in
- 71 -
creating awareness about financial products, education, and advice on money
management, debt counseling, savings and affordable credit. The banks would
have to evolve specific strategies to expand the outreach of their services in order
to promote financial inclusion. It is widely known that financial inclusion is a
means to an end and not an end in itself. Financial inclusion alone cannot lift
millions of poor Indians out of poverty but the regular usage of banking products
and services can provide them with an opportunity to overcome poverty and
improve their lives. The real challenge is to encourage poor people to actively use
a variety of formal banking services (including savings, credit and remittance) so
that their dependence on informal sources is greatly reduced. This study helped the
researcher to approach the unbanked rural area to identify the penetration of
banking and the need for adoption of financial inclusion in unbanked areas tocreate
a meaningful financially included population.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Anuradha C. Hastak And ArunGaikwad (2015), “Issues Relating To
Financial Inclusion And Banking Sector In India”, The Business &
Management Review, Volume 5 Number 4 ,January,pp 194-202.
2. Dr.AnuragB.Singh and PriyankaTandon, “Financial inclusion in india – An
analysis”, International Journal Of Marketing, Financial Services &
Management Research, Vol.1 No.6, June.
3. AtulBhansal (2012), “Profitable Models For Financial Inclusion”, Global
Journal Of Management & Research Oct-Nov.
- 72 -
4. AkhilDamodaran, “Financial Inclusion: Issues And Challenges”, Akgec
International Journal Of Technology, Vol. 4, No. 2, pp 54-58.
5. Dr. AsyrafWajdiDusuki “Banking for the Poor: The Role of Islamic Banking
in Microfinance Initiatives”, Proceedings of the 2nd Islamic Conference
2007 (iECONS2007) organized by Faculty of Economics and Muamalat ,
Islamic Science University of Malaysia.
6. Beck.T, Demirguc-Kunt, A and Peria, M. S. M (2005), “Reaching out:
Access to use of banking services across countries” , pp. 52.
7. Biswas, N., 2010. Biometric ATM: Boon to Indian Rural Bank Customers.
Southern Economist. ISSN 0034 –4046, 48(14).
8. Chakraborty, K. C., 2009. Technology, Financial Inclusion and the Role of
Urban Cooperative Banks, RBI
9. Dr.K.C. Chakrabathy “Financial Inclusion And Banks: Issues And
Perspectives”, Rbi Monthly Bulleting Nov. 2011
10.Defender Prasad Pander And Amity Kumar Katia, “Financial Inclusion In
Indian Scenario”, International Journal Of Management Research And
Development.
11.Das, P. K., 2010. The Up-Scaling of Technology to Build Inclusive
Financial Systems in India. Journal of Education Administration and Policy
Studies, 2(5): 67–70.
12.Dr. EuginPrakashPathrose, Allen Baby, Dr. Uma Maheshwari M (2015), A
Study On The Challenges Faced By Customers In Financial Inclusion,
International
Journal
Of
Scientific
(Ijsrm),Volume 3, Issue 1, pp 1989-1995.
- 73 -
Research
And
Management
13.Equity Bank Group Annual Report, 2010.
14. Elisabeth Rhyne(2013), “A Global Challenge: Can We Achieve Financial
Inclusion By 2020?”, Source:Http://Blogs.Worldbank.Org/Psd/Global-ChallengeCan-We-Achieve-Financial-Inclusion-2020
15.GadamsettySaiArun, “Understanding Financial Inclusion in India and Role
of ICT in ICT”, International Journal Of Innovative Research And
Development, Vol 2 Issue 12, 2013
16.Geach, N., 2007. The Digital Divide, Financial Exclusion and Mobile Phone
Technology: Two problems, one solution? Journal of International Trade
Law and Policy, 6(1): 21–29.
17.Ghosh, A., 2007. Financial Inclusion through Micro Finance in India and
Emerging Role of POSB: An Analysis.
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1655737.
18.Dr. Lata Krishnan (2013), “Financial Inclusion Initiatives”, Episteme: an
online interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary & multi-cultural journal Volume
2, Issue , September
19.Dr. ParulAgarwal (2014), “Financial inclusion in india – a review of
initiatives and acheivements”, IOSR journal of business and management,
vol 16 issue 6 ver I pp 52-61.
20.Dr. VivekSingla (2013), “Financial Inclusion- Financial Services For
Everyone”, international journal of reviews, surveys and research(IJRSR).
21.Dr. M.M. GANDHI (2013), “FINANCIAL INCLUSION IN INDIA Issues
and Challenges”, International Multidisciplinary Journal of Applied
Research, Volume 1, Issue 3, June.
- 74 -
22.Divya Joseph (2014), “A Study On Financial Inclusion And Financial
Literacy”, International Journal Of Business And Administration Research
Review, Vol.2, Issue.4, Jan-March.
23. GadamsettySaiArun (2013), “Understanding Financial Inclusion in India and
Role of ICT in ICT”, International Journal Of Innovative Research And
Development,Vol 2 Issue 12.
24. Geach. N (2007), “The Digital Divide, Financial Exclusion and Mobile
Phone Technology: Two problems, one solution?”, Journal of International
Trade Law and Policy, 6(1): 21–29.
25.HemaDivya.K (2013), “A Study On Impact Of Financial Inclusion With
Reference To Daily Wage Earners”, Journal Of Business Management &
Social Sciences Research (Jbm&Ssr) Volume 2, No.6, June.
26.HarmeetKaur& Dr. Bhawdeep Singh Tanghi (2014), “Financial Inclusion: A
Way To Sustainable Growth”, GianJyoti E-Journal, Volume 4, Issue 1 JanMar.
27.Harun R Khan (2012), Keynote Address Delivered By ShriHarun R Khan,
Deputy Governor, Reserve Bank Of India At The Symposium On “Financial
Inclusion In Indian Economy” Organized By The Indian Institute Of Public
Administration, Bhubaneswar On June 30.
28.Harshit Eric Williams and Azhar Abbas (2014), A study on financial
inclusion initiatives undertaken by indian banking industry, new man
international journal of multidisciplinary studies vol 1 issue 12, dec.
- 75 -
29.JayatiGhosh (2013), “Microfinance And The Challenge Of Financial
Inclusion For Development”, Cambridge Journal Of Economics, September.
Pp 1-17.
30.Josiah Aduda& Elizabeth Kalunda (2012), “Financial Inclusion And
Financial Sector Stability With Reference To Kenya: A Review Of
Literature”,Journal Of Applied Finance & Banking, Vol. 2, No. 6, Pp. 95120.
31.http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/Publications/PDFs/RTP081110FL.pdf, pp. 123
32.http://www.pmjdy.gov.in/ progress report/account-statistics-country.aspx.
33.Kushalakshi And Dr.A.Raghurama (2014), “Financial Inclusion In India:
PolicyInitiatives And Challenges”, International Journal Of Scientific
Research, Volume 3, Issue 2 , February
34.Leeladhar.V (2005), Commemorative lecture, “ FedbankHormis Memorial
Foundation at Ernakulam on December.
35.LaxmiMehar (2014), “Financial Inclusion In India”, Innovative Journal Of
Business And Management 3: 4 July -August.
36.MandiraSarma and JesimPais, “Financial Inclusion and Development: A
Cross Country Analysis”, Indian Council for Research on International
Economic Relations, pp 1-28, 2008.
37.Mohan Rakesh (2006), Economic Growth, Financial Deepening And
Financial Inclusion, speech, Deputy Governor, Reserve Bank Of India At
The Annual Bankers’ Conference, November.
- 76 -
38.Medhi, I., Ratan, A., and Toyama, K (2009), “Mobile Banking Adoption and
Usage by Low-Literate, Low Income Users in the developing World”
Internationalization, Design and Global Development Lecture Notes in
Computer Science, Volume 5623/2009: 485- 494.
39.Michael Chibba, “Financial Inclusion, Poverty Reduction and the
millennium Development Goals”, European Journal of Development
Research Vol. 21, 2009.
40.Nitin Kumar, Financial Inclusion and its Determinants: Evidence from State
Level Empirical Analysis in India.
41.C.Paramasivam and V.Ganesh Kumar, “Overview of financial inclusion in
india”, International Journal Of Management And Development Studies, Vol
No.2 ,Issue No.3, March.2013
42.The Micro Finance Institutions ( Development & Regulation ) Bill, 2011 as
of June 2011
43.M-CRIL Micro Finance Review 2011 –Anatomy of Crisis a Financial and
political Analysis by Micro Credit Ratings International Ltd.
44.Naveen
Kolloju(2014),
“Business
Correspondent
Model
Vis-À-Vis
Financial Inclusion In India: New Practice Of Banking To The Poor”,
International Journal Of Scientific And Research Publications, Volume 4,
Issue 1, January.
45.C. R. L.Narasimhan (2014), “The challenge of financial inclusion”,The
Hindu Newspaper Article, August.
- 77 -
46.Oya Pinar ArdicMaximilienHeimannNataliyaMylenko (2007), “Access to
Financial Services and the Financial Inclusion Agenda Around the World”,
The World Bank, pp 1-17.
47.Parveen Kumar (2014), “Financial Inclusion In India- Current Position And
Challenges”,
48.Asian Journal Of Multidisciplinary Studies ,Volume 2, Issue 7, July.
49.Ramesh Subramanian (2014), “Financial Inclusion - Micro Finance a
Sustainable Model”, International Journal of Research (IJR) Vol-1, Issue-6,
July.
50.RohitSarkar, “Vision 2020 for India: The Financial Sector (Planning
Commission Report)”.
51.Reddy.A(2010), “Rural Banking Strategies for Inclusive Growth”,
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1532226
52.Report on the Steering Committee on Micro Finance and poverty alleviation
– The Eleventh Five Year Plan ( 2007-08- 2011-12) by Development policy
division, Planning commission ,New Delhi May 2007..
53.ShwetambaraSairam (2014), “Banking with the unbanked sector”,
International Journal of Recent Scientific Research Vol. 5, Issue, 2, pp.408414, February.
54.Sachindra G R (2013), “Need For Financial Inclusion And Challenges
Ahead - An Indian Perspective”, Iosr Journal Of Business And Management
(Iosr-Jbm) , Volume 9, Issue 5 (Mar. - Apr), Pp 33-36.
- 78 -
55.SonuGarg and Srikanth.R (2013), “A Study on - Financial Inclusion - Role
of Indian Banks in Reaching Out to the Unbanked and Backward Areas”,
International Journal of Applied Research and Studies,Volume 2, Issue
9,Sep.
56.Sonia Marcolin and Anne Abraham (2006), “Financial literacy research:
current literature and future opportunities” , faculty of commerce- papers
(archive).
57.Sadhan Kumar Chattopadhyay, “Financial Inclusion in India: A Case-Study
of West Bengal”.
58.Sendhilvelan, M., and Karthikeyan, K., (2006), “No Frills Account: A Basic
Drive for Financial Inclusion”, Southern Economist, Vol. 45.
59.SomasroyChakraborty&NupurAnand (2014), “Financial inclusion may
remain an unsolved puzzle for now”, The Business Standards Newspaper
Article, Aug.
60.Srikanth.R (2013), “A Study on - Financial Inclusion - Role of Indian Banks
in Reaching Out to the Unbanked and Backward Areas”, International
Journal of Applied Research and Studies,Volume 2, Issue 9,Sep.
61.Thorat,U(2007),
Financial
Inclusion
and
Information
Technology,
http://www.bis.org/review/r080917d.pdf.
62.V. Ramkumar (2007) ,“Financial inclusion and financial literacy sbi
initiatives”, cab calling, july-sep.
63.Thorat, U,”Financial Inclusion – The Indian Experience”, HMT-DFID
Financial Inclusion Conference, Whitehall Place, London, UK on June 19,
- 79 -
2007. [31] Thorat, U., 2007. Financial Inclusion and Information
Technology, http://www.bis.org/review/r080917d.pdf.
64.Vasantha, S., Varadharaj, V., &Varadharajan, R. (2013). self help group
bank linkage model as catalyst for financial inclusion in an unbanked rural
area. Indian Journal of Commerce & Management Studies, 4(1).
65.VighneswaraSwamy P M (2011), Financial Inclusion In India: An
Evaluation Of The Coverage, Progress And Trends, The Iup Journal Of
Financial 10 Economics, Vol. Ix, No. 2, pp 8-25.
66.VijayaBhaskar P (2013), “ Financial Inclusion in India- An Assessment”,
Speech delivered at the MFIN and Access-Assist Summit organised in New
Delhi on December
(http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/Speeches/PDFs/MFI101213FS.pdf).
- 80 -