ARTICLES AND ESSAYS
Brittany Romanello
On a warm and breezy Sunday afternoon, Julissa1 opens her door and
gives me saludos, a traditional greeting kiss on the cheeks. Stepping
inside, I am engulfed by the familiar smell of green plantains with
cheese, yellow rice, and roasted meats. I immediately tie up my hair
and get to work. I stir the rice with her young daughter on my hip
while Julissa’s mom chases after her older child. We fall into a comfortable rhythm as melodic as the cumbia music in the background. These
foods and this trust placed in me to help prepare them are the result
of many close years spent together, and I am touched every time I am
included in this tradition. Finally, when all is ready, Julissa calls upstairs
to the family: “Come eat! Hermana Brittany is here!” I cannot help but
smile when she calls me hermana, her “sister.” Her reference to me
signifies a dual meaning: I am not only like a family member to her,
but additionally, the term hermana is used among Spanish-speaking
members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (also known
as Mormons) to signify solidarity and integration with one another.
This sentiment of el/la hermandad (brotherhood or sisterhood) is an
important practice to remind Church members that we are socially and
spiritually tied to and reliant upon one another. For Latina migrants
in the Church, la hermandad is an essential part of navigating spaces
within Mormonism that are complex, predominantly white, and/or
1. All interview participants’ names have been changed.
5
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
MULTICULTURALISM AS RESISTANCE:
LATINA MIGRANTS NAVIGATE
US MORMON SPACES
6
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
I remember my mother working odd jobs because she didn’t have
papers. Growing up, I would see people from school or church being
taken by ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement). Unless you
live through it, it’s hard to understand. Getting papers isn’t like paying
a parking ticket. I’ve always considered myself an American, but in
school and on my mission people made fun of me because I wasn’t
American “enough.” That would hurt me. But I’m not ashamed. I’m
eternally grateful my parents made our home reflect the parts of the
world they knew. I learned music, food, language, and my faith. Those
are a huge part of me. I want that for my daughters now.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
politically and historically painful as they work, worship, and parent
in the United States.
Julissa is twenty-eight years old and has been my hermana for over
a decade. She is the daughter of an Ecuadorian mother and Salvadorian father. Her father and older siblings arrived in the US as refugees
from El Salvador under temporary protected status (TPS). They had
traveled from Ecuador and stopped to live in Mexico before crossing
the border. Because none of Julissa’s older siblings were born in El Salvador, they did not qualify for temporary protected status with their
father and therefore had to cross without documentation. Her mother
crossed unauthorized months later with the help of Church contacts in
southern California. In the early 2000s, Julissa’s mother won the green
card lottery: an annual, preset number of visas issued to applicants from
selected countries. Through this, she was able to petition for herself and
then her children’s permanent residency.
On the night of my visit, Julissa agreed to go beyond her normal
hermana role. She decided to share with me her intimate experiences
growing up Mormon within an undocumented immigrant family in
the predominantly white suburbs of Salt Lake City as well as her current experiences as a Latina raising bicultural children in the Church.
Throughout our interview, I began to see how living in the United
States has required her to develop multicultural approaches in order to
navigate complicated social and religious environments. Julissa shared
some ways these intersections manifested in her upbringing:
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
7
2. “Facts and Statistics: Worldwide Statistics,” Newsroom, Sept. 1, 2018, https://
newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/facts-and-statistics.
3. Rebecca A. Smith and Susan E. Mannon, “‘Nibbling on the Margins of
Patriarchy’: Latina Immigrants in Northern Utah,” Ethnic and Racial Studies
33, no. 6 (2010): 986–1005; Ignacio M. García, “Finding a Mormon Identity
through Religion and Activism: A Personal Note on Constructing a Latino
Time and Place in the Mormon Narrative,” Journal of Mormon History 41,
no. 2 (2015): 69–90; Ignacio García, “Empowering Latino Saints to Transcend
Historical Racialism: A Bishop’s Tale,” in Decolonizing Mormonism: Approaching a Postcolonial Zion, edited by Joanna Brooks and Gina Colvin (Salt Lake
City: University of Utah Press, 2018), 1–360; Sujey Vega, “Hermanas interseccionales: Las latinas de LDS navegan por la fe, el liderazgo y la solidaridad
femenina,” Latino Studies 17, no. 1 (2019): 27–47.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
Julissa’s experiences mirror what many other Latina Mormon mothers
shared with me in anonymous interviews about living as immigrants
in mixed-status or undocumented families in the United States. She is
part of a large and underserved community within US Mormon spaces.
According to official statistics reported in December 2018, around
43 percent of global LDS Church membership identifies or has ties with
Latin American or Latinx heritage.2 Despite such a strong worldwide
presence, Mormon Latinx voices are vastly underexamined in Church
historical archives, Anglo-American LDS community dialogues, and
scholarly research, with a few exceptions.3 I know this because as a
white US citizen born into the Church, aside from the occasional faithpromoting story or Ensign article, I did not grow up hearing Latina or
migrant voices and histories highlighted in English-speaking congregations. It has been an ongoing process for me as a Church member
and academic researcher to begin to understand how these public narratives regarding members’ life experiences have stayed for the most
part, Anglo- and androcentric in nature. In the summer of 2018, I
interviewed over twenty practicing Latina Mormon mothers living in
Utah, Nevada, and southern California, all geographically considered
part of the “Mormon Corridor,” or areas where early Church members
historically settled and colonized. I was interested in the stories and
8
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
1. What is the historical role of Latinx inclusion and race relations in the
LDS Church?
2. How do immigrant Latina mothers construct their sense of belonging
in US Church communities?
3. How do Latina mothers choose to preserve their cultural values and
traditions in their faith practice and family relationships?
It is crucial for me as both an hermana and researcher to highlight the
voices of mothers who shared their stories with me, some doing so at
risk to their personal safety or social standing within Church circles.
My findings indicate that the majority of mothers often feel a strong
disconnect between Church public policy and doctrine—one that
encourages the protection of migrant families and cultural pluralism—
and their actual lived experiences with Anglo-American family and
Church members. Every woman interviewed expressed complex feelings of both belonging and marginalization, each recalling instances of
discrimination within US Church spaces due to their ethnic and racial
identity or legal status. These experiences heavily influenced mothers’
preferences for attending pan-ethnic Latinx congregations within the
created spaces of Spanish or Portuguese “wards.” This is majorly in
part due to the historical struggles Latinas, migrants, and women have
all faced since the inception of LDS missionary work both inside and
outside the US. This large and complex history expands well beyond
Salt Lake City Church headquarters. Strides for racial equity and inclusion within Mormon spaces, US Church member attitudes regarding
immigrant assimilation, and their individual migration experiences all
influenced interviewed mothers in their development of multicultural
social and parenting strategies. These approaches strive to navigate the
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
experiences of these women, all of whom had lived undocumented in
the United States for long periods, with about 45 percent who adjusted
their legal status at some point after arrival. Some questions I explored
in developing this research and the Institutional Review Board (IRB)
interview guide were:
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
9
overlaps of institutional oppression, transnational existence, and personal conceptualizations of identity and place.
Past scholarship has assessed how the LDS Church has struggled to
create inclusive and equitable spaces for people of color as well as
indigenous and immigrant communities.4 Although it now maintains
a larger international than domestic membership, the intersections of
religious practice, gender identity, and immigration history and politics are all important in contextualizing how Latina migrant mothers
experience and move within the body of the Church in the Mormon
Corridor and, more broadly, US society. Many of the challenges the
Church has faced both in the past and present in embracing and including underserved communities of color stem from doctrinal ideologies
created by Book of Mormon interpretations regarding race, pastoral
stewardship, and who has the authority to lead or speak for God.
The Book of Mormon perpetuates biblical beliefs that certain
ethnic or racial lineages are deemed more “worthy” or capable to lead
and preside over others.5 It recounts the story of one family unit that
divides itself between the descendants of two brothers, Nephi and
Laman. Laman and his family make divergent and “sinful” choices
4. Elise Boxer, “‘To Become White and Delightsome’: American Indians and
Mormon Identity” (PhD diss., Arizona State University, 2009); Hokulani K.
Aikau, A Chosen People, A Promised Land: Mormonism and Race in Hawai’i
(Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2012); W. Paul Reeve, Religion
of a Different Color: Race and the Mormon Struggle for Whiteness (New York:
Oxford University Press, 2015); Moroni Benally, “Decolonizing the Blossoming: Indigenous People’s Faith in a Colonizing Church,” Dialogue: A Journal of
Mormon Thought 50, no. 4 (2017): 71–188.
5. Armand L. Mauss, All Abraham’s Children: Changing Mormon Conceptions
of Race and Lineage (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2010).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
I. Mormon Histories of Latinx Inclusion
and Race Relations
10
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
6. 2 Nephi 5:21, 23–24.
7. Floyd A. O’Neill and Stanford J. Layton, “Of Pride and Politics: Brigham
Young as Indian Superintendent,” Utah Historical Quarterly 46, no. 3 (1978):
239–41.
8. Sylvester A. Johnson, “Accounting for Whiteness in Mormon Religion,”
Mormon Studies Review 3 (2016): 117–33.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
on their journey from Israel to the American continent, while Nephi
and his family obey God’s commands and continue down a righteous
path. This ultimately leads to a change in their physical appearances,
with light-skinned Nephites becoming more “white and delightsome”
and, over time, being given spiritual and physical stewardship by God
over the “rebellious, cursed” darker-skinned Lamanite tribe.6 Much
of the Book of Mormon text is spent relaying continued histories of
these two conflicting tribes, with skin color leveraged as a marker of
obedience and worthiness. Because Book of Mormon scripture clearly
states that Lamanites were of Abrahamic heritage, they were worthy
of some saving effort and fellowship. Wilford Woodruff, fourth president of the Church, viewed Anglo Mormonism as being tasked with
assisting those descended of Lamanite blood to “blossom” so that “they
would be filled with the power of God . . . and go forth to build the
New Jerusalem.”7 This scriptural narrative helps to contextualize the
dogmatic foundations that shaped early perceptions among Church
members regarding race and authority. Ultimately, because of the
commandment for lighter-skinned communities to “save” their darker
Lamanite brethren, they were privileged with increased status from the
structural inception of Mormonism.8
Official Church sponsorship of missionary work and colonization
of presumed “Lamanite”-dominant geographical areas in the American Southwest, Polynesia, Latin America, and the Caribbean began
shortly after Mormon settlement in the Western frontier in 1847.
Second Church president Brigham Young saw missionary efforts as a
continuation of Church founder Joseph Smith’s vision for gathering the
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
11
9. Max Perry Mueller, Race and the Making of the Mormon People (Chapel Hill:
University of North Carolina Press, 2017).
10. John Kincaid, “Extinguishing the Twin Relics of Barbaric Multiculturalism—Slavery and Polygamy—from American Federalism,” Publius: The
Journal of Federalism 33, no. 1 (2003): 75–92.
11. The Congressional Globe, Thirty-Eighth Congress, Second Session, Jan. 1865,
144.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
twelve tribes of Israel together in preparation for the Second Coming of
Christ.9 White Church members felt commanded to carry out the Book
of Mormon’s call to graft Lamanite descendants into the faith. While
efforts to include non-white peoples into the Church by proselytizing
were considered “progressive” by the standards of the mid-nineteenth
century, the grip of North American politics and racial attitudes on
early Mormon treatment of “Lamanite” descendants cannot be ignored
if we are to understand the contemporary placement and second-class
citizenship of Latinx migrants in US Church spaces.
I frequented many a Sunday School lesson growing up where I
was taught that the primary reason Utah was denied statehood for so
long was the misunderstanding Congress had regarding the practice of
polygamy. While this is generally true, polygamy was only one pillar
of the Republican Party’s concern for American “decency” during the
mid-nineteenth century. The Party was also concerned with the other
“twin relic of barbarism,” which was the practice of slavery.10 Congress
representative Justin Smith Morrill argued that Utah’s delayed entrance
was also because of the Church’s participation in indigenous people’s
enslavement and indentured servitude. Utah was the only known US
state to participate in state-sanctioned enslavement of indigenous peoples.11 Because Mormons were seen as propagators of this “barbarism”
on both fronts, along with accepting converts from outside Anglo
ethnic groups, Church members began to experience a racialization
that denoted them a degenerate breed of people who were losing their
12
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
12. W. Paul Reeve, “From Not White Enough to Too White: The Historical Evolution of a Mormon Race,” Sunstone Magazine (website), Jan. 1, 2015, https://
www.sunstonemagazine.com/from-not-white-enough-to-too-white-the
-historical-evolution-of-a-mormon-race/.
13. Sondra Jones, The Trial of Don Pedro León Luján: The Attack Against Indian
Slavery and the Mexican Traders in Utah (Salt Lake City: University of Utah
Press, 2000).
14. Andrés Reséndez, The Other Slavery: The Uncovered Story of Indian Enslavement in America (New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2016).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
holistic whiteness.12 To counter this and promote the Church as one
producing “an angelic, celestial people,” a previously hesitant Brigham
Young began encouraging Anglo members to buy indigenous slaves
from their captors as adoptees or house servants. He stated that God
permitted Mormons “to come here for this very purpose . . . [that] the
Lord could not have devised a better plan than to have put the saints
where they were to help bring about the redemption of the Lamanites
[and] also make them a white and delightsome people.” This was all
in order to “accomplish their redemption” in addition to serving as a
pathway to battle negative racialization directed at the Church from
outside groups.13
On top of attempting to ease fears of unbelonging within the Anglo
mainstream, Mormon settlers felt “white savior” pressures, as Andres
Reséndez explains, which were the driving motives for the passage of the
Act for the Relief of Indian Slaves and Prisoners in 1852. The law passed
by popular consensus in the Utah territory to allow Mormon settlers to
bypass the illegality of slavery within Mexican territorial lands. Church
leaders felt that by purchasing indigenous slaves “into their freedom”
from the horrendous conditions of illegal Mexican slave trades, they
were upholding their spiritual obligation to “save” Lamanites.14 The passage of the Act allowed for the Native enslavement to continue favoring
local Mormon labor markets, and additionally permitted Church leadership to continue encouraging conversion among enslaved Lamanite
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
13
15. Kate B. Carter, Heart Throbs of the West, vol. 4 (Salt Lake City: Daughters
of the Utah Pioneers, 1943).
16. Reséndez, The Other Slavery, 245.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
women and children by placing them in Anglo homes where they could
be “with the more favored portions of the human race.”15 Reséndez also
goes on to state that: “Mormons who adopted Indians had to strive to
erase their Native cultures. These pervasive attitudes prevented Indians from fully integrating into Mormon society. Mormons [had] never
anticipated keeping them as ‘indentures.’ . . . [T]heir impulses to help
in their redemption eased their transformation into owners and masters. In colonial times, Spanish missionaries had acquired Indians to
save their souls. In the nineteenth century, Mormons’ quest to redeem
Natives by purchasing them was not too different. Both ended up creating an underclass.”16
These scriptural and social contexts identify the ways in which
Lamanite identity was negotiated; people perceived as Lamanite ancestors should be saved through spiritual conversion as well as cultural
assimilation practices via Anglo member efforts. These contexts are
also what has made upward mobilization efforts so difficult for indigenous, migrant, or resource-poor members of the Church. They are
often seen as outliers, or as Others, whose stories within the context of
early Mormon history or current political dialogue may not meet the
expectations of the standard “faith-promoting” narrative that so many
leaders wish to propagate within missionary work and social dialogues.
Professor Ignacio García reaffirmed the importance of understanding
the breadth of these historical placements and constructs in a plenary
address to the Mormon History Association: “Too much of Mormon
historical studies still tell the story of the Other. This Other is voiceless
and mindless, too often we speak for them (as) it concerns the anxieties
of white Mormonism. . . . History provides a language and a protocol
with which to articulate thoughts and concerns. People who have history have a language that provides a sense of agency, of being in control
14
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
17. García, “Finding a Mormon Identity.”
18. Ibid.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
of their lives, or at least of being players within it.”17 García’s analysis
is particularly relevant to this discussion, as the majority of mothers
I interviewed shared experiences in which their Latina and Mormon
identities were in conflict with one another in regard to the attitudes of
Anglo-American membership. They expressed that US-born members’
ideas of faithfulness to the Church are often conflated with a willingness and loyalty to adhere to Anglo-American Church ideologies, and
they often felt their efforts to contribute to the kingdom of God were
marginalized by instances of discrimination or alienation, most likely
due to this lack of historical narrative within English-speaking congregations. They reported that this conflict often created an environment
of pressure and emotional distress that compounded their already complex negotiation between the Self and the Church. As Garcia further
argues, Latinx Mormons, “need their history—the chronicle of their
struggles, triumphs, and disappointments—to understand their place
in a religion that in the past has required placing and timing—in the
collective sense—to fit in.”18
Racialized hierarchy and differentiated levels of inclusion by race
maintain their historical grip in the modern Church as they continue
to influence organization, policy, and gendered social relations between
Anglo-American members on the one hand and communities of color
and migrants on the other. Given the Church’s complex history of domination, enslavement, servitude, and submission of “Lamanite” heritage
groups, I argue that being Latinx and Mormon has been problematic in
nature from the beginning. Consequently, the struggles Latinx communities have faced in Mormon histories have much larger implications
for contemporary social relations and membership than previously
acknowledged. It is essential that Church leaders and researchers who
work within the frameworks of Mormonism focus on decolonizing any
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
15
“crafted soliloquy” that minimizes the Anglo-American Church’s contribution to the oppression and marginalization of people of color.19
Aihwa Ong conducted one of the primary cases that investigated the
experience of non-white belonging within US Mormon spaces, specifically that of Cambodian refugees who converted to Mormonism in the
greater Oakland, California area.20 She evaluated how the Church provided economic and social stability to many in this particular migrant
group, many of whom were refugees fleeing genocide and war-torn
areas. She also recounted that while interviewees who attended the
Khmer-speaking wards reported increased economic opportunity and
spiritual belonging through Church membership, they also encountered many social and racial barriers with Anglo members as they
navigated their newfound religion. Ong writes: “The transnational
appeal of Mormonism has been the reaffirmation of patriarchal values
and discipline . . . that assimilates less successful people or impoverished immigrants to American values of strict morality, hard work,
and middle-class success. . . . Yet, Mormonism maintains a structure
of racial domination.”21 These findings are consistent with the Church’s
historical focus on grafting and incorporating migrant communities of
color as preached from the pulpit for decades, especially within Latinx
populations.22 The Book of Mormon’s alternate history appealed to
19. Octavio I. Romano-V, “Minorities, History and the Cultural Mystique,” El
Grito: A Journal of Contemporary Mexican-American Thought 1, no. 1 (1967):
5–11.
20. Aihwa Ong, Buddha Is Hiding: Refugees, Citizenship, and the New America
(Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003).
21. Ibid., 200–01.
22. Mark L. Grover, “The Maturing of the Oak: The Dynamics of LDS Growth
in Latin America,” Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 38, no. 2 (2005): 79.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
II. Assimilation and Latinx Belonging
in an Anglo-American Landscape
16
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
23. Michael O’Loughlin, “Competing for Hispanic Catholics: Secularism,
Other Faiths Battle for Souls,” Crux (website), July 2, 2015, https://cruxnow
.com/church/2015/07/02/competing-for-hispanic-catholics-secularism
-other-faiths-battle-for-souls/.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
many potential Latin American Church investigators, providing a theological narrative of God’s belonging and divine destiny for those living
in the Americas, one that existed outside of the legacies of genocide and
oppression inflicted by European settler colonialism and Catholicism.23
Assimilation, taught through a scriptural lens and propagated for many
years mostly by Anglo missionaries from the US Mormon Corridor,
was viewed as a natural and positive route to both inclusion and salvation. Aside from preaching to nonwhite populations, American Church
leadership emphasizes the promotion of a nuclear family structure. This
includes encouraging women to idealize motherhood and responsibility within the home. These perceptions reflect a larger historical lens of
how the Church has appealed to nonwhite populations, as this nuclear
family structure is prevalent in many parts of the world, including Latin
America.
However, many mothers reported that this expectation for converts to “graft” or assimilate themselves into the gospel often requires
nonwhite or immigrant members to adopt distinctly “white” Church
or family traditions. One mother, Ines, shared her experience with this
US Church cultural expectation. Ines came to the US from Guadalajara
when she was in elementary school. She converted at seventeen and was
able to adjust her legal status after marrying a Chicano citizen. Even at
Ines’s baptism, Church leadership involved were very aware of her legal
status. When she decided to serve a mission, she went domestically to
Idaho. The Church’s current protocol allows undocumented missionaries to perform their service domestically so service can occur without
compromising residency in the US. It was on her mission where she felt
the most insecure about her legal status and immigrant status and felt
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
17
24. Roberto G. Gonzales, Lives in Limbo: Undocumented and Coming of Age in
America (Oakland: University of California Press, 2016).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
pressured to acculturate to Anglo-American points of view. Ines shared
with me the following: “I was scared to share my status on my mission.
White members were really loving until they found out I didn’t have
papers. I was undocumented until I was married. Spanish wards accept
you and don’t judge based on legal status; we don’t have to hide. Right
now, my bishop is undocumented. He knows how it is. For me, I’m still
learning to live with all my identities. Too many American members
wanted me [to assimilate], but I’m glad I’ve held on to who I am.”
Ines’s words express how legal status may transform Anglo Church
members’ perceptions of their migrant co-worshipers, even if they first
appear “assimilated.” In Ines’s case, because she spoke English with
no discernable accent and presented as more güera, meaning she has
a lighter physical complexion, she wasn’t immediately targeted for
discrimination until her citizenship came into question. Her story
highlights how nonwhite Mormons experience differential levels of
inclusion and acceptance, heavily dependent on local attitudes. I argue
that instead of striving for this grafting, which participants felt has led
to erasure, US Mormons can better serve Latina migrant women by
amplifying their voices, thereby responding to many underserved communities’ need for “knowing and being known” in their intersectional
spheres of lived experience.24 All interviewees shared with me that
they wished their migrant experiences, “illegal” or otherwise, would
be treated with the same dignity, respect, and space migrant Mormon
pioneers are given in Church history narratives. It is valid that these
hermanas would ask: why are early Mormon (and mostly white) migration experiences viewed as more legitimate than theirs?
Previous scholarship has examined how the continued efforts to
“graft” nonwhite and/or immigrant members of the Church has created social division and tensions between Anglo and Latino leaders
18
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
25. Claudia L. Bushman, Contemporary Mormonism: Latter-day Saints in
Modern America (Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Publishing Group, 2006),
102–09.
26. Mark L. Grover, review of “In His Own Language”: Mormon Spanish
Speaking Congregations in the United States, by Jessie L. Embry, BYU Studies
Quarterly 38, no. 2 (1999): 211–14, available at https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu
/byusq/vol38/iss2/13/.
27. Emily Ann Gurnon, “The Dark Face of a White Church: Latinos and
Mormon Racism” (master’s thesis, University of California, Berkeley, 1993),
1–17; Emily Gurnon, “Minority Mormons: Latinos and Latter-day Saints,”
Christian Century 111, no. 5 (1994): 157–59.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
regarding stewardship of Latinx wards.25 This research addressed the
ever-increasing growth of Latinx membership as well as attempts to
dismantle pan-ethnic Latinx wards, opting for assimilation with local
English-speaking congregations. The dramatic drop in tithing and
member activity in those areas where Latinx wards were forced to
assimilate was profound, leading to Latinx wards being reinstated.26
Other research has found that American leadership often failed to
validate differing cultural expressions of faith, oftentimes minimizing
Latinx members’ efforts to contribute to worship sharing and practices.27 These histories and social contexts within Church history and US
congregations are important factors in why most mothers I spoke with
who attended majority Latinx congregations at the time of interviewing
believed it was an environment where they could feel safety, peace, and
community.
Another reason many Latina migrants reported a preference for
attending the Spanish- or Portuguese-speaking ward was to distance
themselves from the idealization of Anglo mothering expectations that
heavily influence US Church spaces. While many mothers came from
cultural backgrounds with rigid gender norms, most interviewees felt
that English-speaking ward communities were not understanding or
flexible with their specific circumstances. Some mothers worried that
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
19
I began noticing how my kids relate and do more activities with white
kids. I have a hard time with that. They didn’t keep the Mexican culture
the way I wanted. For example, I visited my dad the other day at his
(Latino) neighbor’s house. Right away they invited me to eat. See? That’s
my culture. We are very welcoming and attentive, we notice others. I
get embarrassed when my kids have friends over and don’t offer them
food! I’m hoping the older they get, the more they will take interest.
My daughter asked me to teach her more, so I’m happy about that. But,
I still wish we had done more.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
they could not achieve the “ideal” of being a stay-at-home mother like
many of their white counterparts. This was not financially possible due
to low wages or frequent labor exploitation because of their legal status.
Many chose instead to frame their sense of belonging through Church
ideologies, which emphasize the role of motherhood as sacred and
respected, additionally finding comfort in doctrine regarding eternal
families. Even though they agree with the Church’s doctrine on the eternal value of their roles as mothers, many did not want to feel obligated
or pressured to parent the same way as their Anglo Mormon peers.
Many expressed feeling better supported by other mothers in the Latinx
ward, who made space for their ideas or had shared interests. Mothers shared with me that this distance from the pressure of whiteness
allowed them to preserve cultural traditions and support one another
in handling the challenges their families faced.
Luisa was newlywed and pregnant when she and her husband
crossed the border from Mexico. After they converted to the Church
in New York City, a Mormon leader provided a way for her, along with
her immediate and extended family, to move to Utah. Luisa reported
she had her family attend the English-speaking ward while her children
were growing up because it was a mostly white area, and it seemed like
a good idea to help everyone adjust and fit in. While she expressed
nothing but pride and love for her children, she wished they had also
interacted with more Latinos by attending the Spanish-speaking ward.
During our time together, she told me:
20
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
28. Sharon Hays, The Cultural Contradictions of Motherhood (New Haven,
Conn.: Yale University Press, 1998).
29. Pamela Stone, Opting Out?: Why Women Really Quit Careers and Head
Home (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2008).
30. Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo and Ernestine Avila, “‘I’m Here, But I’m There’:
The Meanings of Latina Transnational Motherhood,” Gender and Society 11, no.
5 (1997): 548–71; Leisy J. Abrego, Sacrificing Families: Navigating Laws, Labor,
and Love Across Borders (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2014), 11;
Joanna Dreby, Everyday Illegal: When Policies Undermine Immigrant Families
(Oakland: University of California Press, 2015).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
Luisa’s experience highlights an important dilemma that Latina migrant
mothers face in the US: how to bring up children in your own culture
while preparing them to live and learn in another. In the Church as well
as US society, women are still expected to be the primary caregivers
and nurturers to their children. These expectations placed on women
to adequately nurture as well as parent through a dual cultural lens
while living with limited resources because of legal status adds layers
of stress to migrant mothers. Many leaders within Mormonism, much
like national policy makers, have rarely considered these realities when
assessing migrant social capital or economic outcomes.
Previous research on mothers in the US has analyzed the expectations of intensive mothering as a historically constructed ideology
that requires mothers to expend copious amounts of emotional and
physical labor in raising children.28 Much of this previous research used
middle-class, white citizen participants who shared similar parenting
opinions.29 Studies that have sought to understand Latina migrant
experiences have found that these expectations become compounded
when a migrant is parenting transnationally or raising bicultural children in the US.30 It is important to recognize here that these other
studies reveal a similar pattern of disparities to that which we see in
Mormonism. Immigrant mothers often feel a strong sense of obligation to remain connected to cultural, gendered norms of mothering
from their sending countries while also facing immense pressure to
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
21
31. Patricia Fernández-Kelly and Sara Curran, “Nicaraguans: Voices Lost,
Voices Found,” in Ethnicities: Children of Immigrants in America, edited by
Rubén G. Rumbaut and Alejandro Portes (Berkeley: University of California
Press, 2001), 127–56.; Elma I. Lorenzo-Blanco, Alan Meca, Jennifer B. Unger,
Andrea Romero, Melinda Gonzales-Backen, Brandy Piña-Watson, Miguel
Ángel Cano, et al., “Latino Parent Acculturation Stress: Longitudinal Effects
on Family Functioning and Youth Emotional and Behavioral Health,” Journal
of Family Psychology 30, no. 8 (2016): 966; Vicki Ruíz, From Out of the Shadows:
Mexican Women in Twentieth-Century America (New York: Oxford University
Press, 1998).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
assimilate to Anglo-American societal expectations.31 These disparities between Anglo cultural expectations for motherhood and Latina
mothers’ actual lived realities create a need for personalized relief and
validation, often found in Spanish- or Portuguese-speaking wards
where women can talk and worship with others in similar situations.
For most women though, simply worshipping with other mothers in
their native language is not enough.
Most Mormon leadership approaches and cultural values were created by middle-class white Americans. Many mothers I interviewed
felt that the multifaceted factors that shaped their undocumented
immigrant experiences were greatly oversimplified within US Church
conversations, which emphasize personal agency as the primary determining factor for economic and personal success in the US rather than
the support and access to resources that studies have demonstrated as
most important. This, layered on top of Mormonism’s historical racialization of worthiness and authority among Lamanite descendants,
can create a toxic emotional health environment for migrant mothers
trying to find their place. A few mothers shared traumatic incidents and
mental health concerns with me that they did not have the language
or space to speak about even among other Latinas or within Latinx
Church communities. One interviewee, Maria Dolores, told me her
experience of being pregnant when she traveled by foot from Ecuador to Mexico hoping to cross the border and join her husband and
22
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
We suffered because I didn’t have papers for a long time. I had to be
very strict with my children so we could stay safe, because of course
racism will always exist here. Our circumstances required us to become
strong. My children made me strong, and the Lord helped us survive.
I also feel I was very blessed [in the US]. I know their lives have more
opportunity. But I had to go through all of that [at the border] and
navigate the two cultures. . . . That was so much. Looking back, if I had
to do it all again, I’m not sure I would.
While almost all mothers interviewed heavily credited their faith
and the Church with getting them through hard times pre- and postmigration, I often wondered if increased emotional and social support
from Anglo leaders and more positive treatment from white membership might have positively affected the mental health, parenting, and
economic outcomes for mothers like Maria Dolores. I believe these
instances of isolation created by US Church spaces create a culture of
casual but distant acceptance, as shown in previous work on Latinx
paradigms within US Church spaces. Ignacio García emphasizes the
importance of remembering how histories of assimilation pressures
from Anglos on their Latinx counterparts have created inequalities
that make it difficult for underserved communities like migrant Latinas to advocate for personal and spiritual needs at an infrastructural
level. He writes: “Cultural whiteness; it remains entrenched in our
institutional memory, in our manuals, sometimes in our conference
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
other children already working in the US. During her crossing of the
US–Mexico border, she experienced and witnessed horrific violence.
Upon her arrival, she faced unstable housing situations and food scarcity during her first years in the US and saw no outlet to process her
trauma. She cites a loving bishop from the Spanish-speaking ward as
her advocate, expressing that loving Church leaders allowed her the
economic resources she needed to get through the transition period.
However, her negative experiences continue to trouble her. Maria Dolores cried softly as she relayed:
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
23
III. A Case for Multiculturalism as Resistance and Power
Navigating religious expectations in a bicultural parenting environment is not a new topic of interest in Latina migration studies, as many
gendered influences regarding womanhood are based in religious
influence.33 LDS Church doctrine has prioritized and reinforced the
idealization of traditional feminine roles and motherhood as a path
to salvation. Past Mormon women’s studies in the US have predominantly focused on the experiences of white American citizens in their
32. Ignacio M. García, “Thoughts on Latino Mormons, Their Afterlife, and the
Need for a New Historical Paradigm for Saints of Color,” Dialogue: A Journal
of Mormon Thought 50, no. 4 (2017): 1–29.
33. Patricia Arredondo, “Mujeres Latinas—Santas y Marquesas,” Cultural
Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology 8, no. 4 (2002): 308–19; Rachel
Hershberg and M. Brinton Lykes, “Redefining Family: Transnational Girls
Narrate Experiences of Parental Migration, Detention, and Deportation,”
Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung 14, no. 1 (2013): 14–35; Leah M. Sarat, Fire
in the Canyon: Religion, Migration, and the Mexican Dream (New York: New
York University Press, 2013).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
talks, and too often in the deep chambers of our minds and heart. . . .
[W]hite (members) rarely see beyond a superficial exoticism in the
lives of Latino Mormons. They will appreciate our culinary skills and
our quick feet, but not our history or our thoughts. And we will be left
with the notion that our white brothers and sisters like us, maybe even
love us—but nothing substantive will change.”32 It is because of these
infrastructural barriers that many mothers I interviewed developed
and employed multiculturalist strategies and approaches when navigating US Mormon spaces. This occurred not only as a mechanism for
survival but also created avenues to resist the underlying whiteness of
the institution. Enacting their personal agency, mothers’ multiculturalist attitudes allow them to preserve, treasure, and amplify their Latinx
identities and traditions within created Church spaces.
24
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
34. Catherine A Brekus, “Tanner Lecture: Mormon Women and the Problem
of Historical Agency,” Journal of Mormon History 37, no. 2 (2011): 58–87; Dorothy Allred Solomon, The Sisterhood: Inside the Lives of Mormon Women (New
York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007); Neylan McBaine, Women at Church: Magnifying LDS Women’s Local Impact (Salt Lake City: Greg Kofford Books, 2014);
Cory Crawford, “The Struggle for Female Authority in Biblical and Mormon
Theology,” Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 48, no. 2 (2015): 1–66;
Curtis G. Greenfield, Pauline Lytle, and F. Myron Hays, “Living the Divine
Divide: A Phenomenological Study of Mormon Mothers Who Are CareerProfessional Women,” Indo-Pacific Journal of Phenomenology 16, no. 1 (2016):
1–14; Neylan McBaine, “Roundtable: Mormon Women and the Anatomy of
Belonging,” Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 50, no. 1 (2017): 193–202.
35. Edward Flores, God’s Gangs: Barrio Ministry, Masculinity, and Gang Recovery (New York: New York University Press, 2014); Claudia Roesch, Macho
Men and Modern Women: Mexican Immigration, Social Experts and Changing Family Values in the 20th Century United States, Family Values and Social
Change, vol. 1 (Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 2015).
36. Tina U. Hancock, “Sin Papeles: Undocumented Mexicanas in the Rural
United States,” Affilia 22, no. 2 (2007):175–84; Sujey Vega, Latino Heartland:
Of Borders and Belonging in the Midwest (New York: New York University
Press, 2015).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
quest to find belonging in a patriarchal religious power structure.34
Many of those interviewed reported feeling expected to restrict their
energy to domestic spheres, religious belief, and child-rearing. Most
of these traditions encourage women to personify characteristics such
as self-sacrifice, family well-being, purity, and loyalty: qualities all
akin to the Catholic conception of the Virgin Mary many interviewees were familiar with. Although it is not always the case, previous
interviews have shown that many undocumented mothers form tightknit networks that provide a better sense of stability for their members
as they navigate parenting in a new country.35 Fictive kin networks
operate as a coping mechanism allowing Latina mothers to find ways
to acclimatize to American life by balancing complex identities, with
recent surveys indicating that multicultural and pluralistic attitudes are
becoming more and more common among Latina parents.36 The way
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
25
37. Peggy Levitt, “Religion as a Path to Civic Engagement,” Ethnic and Racial
Studies 31, no. 4 (2008): 766–91; Felipe Hinojosa, Latino Mennonites: Civil
Rights, Faith, and Evangelical Culture (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University
Press, 2014).
38. Jorge Iber, Hispanics in the Mormon Zion, 1912–1999 (College Station: Texas
A&M University Press, 2000).
39. Ibid., 19–39.
40. García, “Thoughts on Latino Mormons.”
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
these mothers choose to live their religious faith as well as outwardly
demonstrate it within church communities is important when considering not only how social networks form but also how mothers begin
to employ multicultural parenting strategies within them.37
Previous research has addressed the importance of utilizing multiculturalism in Church discourse and social interaction. Historian Jorge
Iber considered Utah, along with many other areas of the Mormon
Corridor, to be “lands that held great promise. . . . [Their] mines, railroads and beet fields held the hope of economic possibilities.”38 His
work explores how the Church addressed Latinx migration patterns
to Mormon-dominated areas in the early twentieth century, often
employing multicultural approaches in order to find common ground
and shared value systems with Spanish-speaking migrants. This not
only led to increased conversion to the Church but also maintained
some degree of ethnic peace between white members working alongside Latinx communities in blue-collar industries.39 The work is careful
to include, however, that the attitudes of many white members and
prevailing narratives of Lamanite history continued to create separation and segregation between the communities. Other previous studies
have addressed conflicts and pathways multiculturalist approaches have
had in influencing Latinx and Anglo relations in the Church ward and
stake infrastructures.40 These conflicts often manifested themselves in
the psychological or social stress Latina migrant mothers experienced
26
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
I feel you have the expectation being Latina, you can’t have your kids
talking back to you, you need to grab the chancla [sandal, sometimes
used to spank] or yell at them. For [white] Mormons, you don’t ever
grab the chancla. Yelling isn’t what the Lord would do. So you get both
sides. What should I do? I feel like I must find common ground, and
it’s difficult to not feel judged. I think also in terms of language. I want
my child to speak Spanish. I also want him to learn French and have his
African culture, especially because he’s so light-skinned. I don’t want
him to forget who he is or where he comes from.
Again, we see from Natalia’s experiences the overlap and intersection
of many worlds and the kinds of stressors that can create. All the mothers I interviewed, especially those married to white men, were very
cognizant of how race would be perceived in heavily white US spaces,
specifically in the Church. They also constantly must consider the layers
of their heritage, their culture, US culture, Anglo Church culture, feminine gender roles, and their own personal desires as individuals living
in multiple identities at once. Many interview participants felt better
supported in the Spanish- or Portuguese-speaking congregations, stating that they felt more encouraged in parenting their way, according
to their traditions rather than modeling their parenting choices after
Anglo perspectives. This is where the idea of developing and employing
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
when choosing how and when to employ multiculturalist approaches
within their households.
Natalia is a biracial convert from Argentina. Her mother is Congolese and immigrated to Argentina in her youth. When her father
passed away, the family moved to the eastern US, where Natalia met
Mormon missionaries. She ultimately moved to Utah, which she
described to me in our interview as a place with many more opportunities for undocumented members to find work and a future spouse.
Now married to an Anglo Church member, Natalia expressed some
of these multicultural ideas to me in her own parenting and religious
approaches:
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
27
I make sure we have our Brazilian customs here in the house. We speak
Portuguese, have Brazilian birthday parties, we keep our traditions. But
I know this is not my country. I know because of my color I’ve had some
negative experiences. I learned many years ago that I had to adapt to
how things are in American culture. Many bills are paid online. The
systems [are] different. . . . The school is different. I am so grateful I
have my Church community and children [who] helped me learn. I’m
able to listen and talk with my children because they are growing up
in a very different culture than I did.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
multiculturalism strategies becomes increasingly important as a means
to adapt to ever-changing political, social, and cultural circumstances,
both in and outside of US Church spaces.
It is in this space that we see how many mothers began to utilize
overlapping and intersecting identities for their advantage and personal mobilization in Church and US society. Most mothers reported
that they had to transform the pressure and their feelings of being
in-between two cultures into increased opportunities for learning,
exploring, and maximizing the potential for procuring economic and
social resources for their families. All mothers responded at one point
in our time together that it was essential to recognize the importance
of raising their children multiculturally for them to have the greatest
chance to be included in both American culture and that of their sending countries. Essentially, mothers reframed the negative narratives
Anglo social societies (Church communities included) projected onto
them to generate innovative approaches that bolstered their parenting and economic positioning. One great example of this is Fernanda.
Born and raised in Curitiba, Brazil, she and her now ex-husband moved
to the States with their children after a former missionary from Utah
helped sponsor them and provided them housing when they arrived.
Fernanda was reluctant to go to the English-speaking ward, not only
because of the language barrier but because she felt more supported in
raising her children in a multicultural environment. When asked about
how to balance this duality, she said:
28
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
In Chicago there were Mexicans and immigrants everywhere. I never
questioned my identity until I came to Utah. I started to ask, am I Mexican enough? Am I too Mexican? Do I look like I should? It was rough
for me to have that identity crisis, and then I wanted to overcompensate
for my ethnicity. So, I want my children to embrace all three sides,
especially at Church. They are American. They are Mexican. They are
Argentinian. I want my children to be proud of where they are from
even if they don’t ever live there. I don’t want others to question their
identities so much. I want my children to think their way of living is
something to be embraced.
Mothers like Cecilia cited that attendance in the Spanish-speaking ward
allowed them to not only obtain parental support in Relief Society or
from other migrant Church members but gave their children the opportunity to share space with other bicultural or multiracial children who
were facing the same things as 1.5- or second-generation immigrants.
This empowers mothers as they enjoy language retainment, engage in
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
Like Fernanda, many mothers’ parenting approaches were influenced
by their own upbringings but were also challenged by different technologies, classism, colorism, and racism from Anglo communities both
in and outside of the Church. Additionally, many expressed that they
struggled with the fear of how to raise kids who were not so “assimilated,” did not “become so white,” or become so frio (distanced or cold)
that they forgot their roots.
Mexican migrant Cecilia had to figure out how to maneuver parenthood as she experienced her own insecurities and growth as an
undocumented minority woman in the white, male-dominated Church
institution. Cecilia was brought from Mexico to Chicago, where her
family owned multiple bakeries and were very successful. After joining the Church, the family moved to Utah. Cecilia described how her
own migration experiences and questions of self-doubt with her identity have influenced her multiculturalist approaches to mothering her
two children, whose father is also an undocumented migrant, but from
Argentina.
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
29
I’m very proud of my culture! I want my children to love it. I took my
husband and kids to Church hoping they would learn Spanish and the
Latino mindset. My husband grew up seeing the negative stereotypes
but married into my family, and now he sees the beautiful too. He saw
that Latinos work hard. We come, we contribute, and we fight to tell
our story. I want my children to never feel ashamed of where we come
from. Now he understands in a way he couldn’t before. . . . Hopefully
my in-laws can [become] more open-minded too.
For mothers who expressed a desire to preserve their traditions like
Andrea, active measures to assert themselves and their children through
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
cultural activities and traditions that may not be otherwise celebrated,
and generally experience a greater sense of peace and belonging with
other Latinx members. Of course, mothers were also quick to tell me
some iteration of a phrase common in Church culture: “The Gospel is
perfect, but the people are not.” Mothers told me conflict was “bound” to
happen in pan-ethnic congregations where different countries’ cultures
or politics may conflict and members undergo personality clashes. But
overall, mothers felt more secure taking their children to pan-ethnic
spaces where they could better engage with a broadly Latinx heritage
and cultural environment not found in white, Anglo US Church spaces.
Andrea, another mother who spoke with me, was born in Costa
Rica to Peruvian parents who were already members of the Church.
After her parents arrived in the US, they separated shortly thereafter,
with her mother remarrying a Jewish Cuban man. She described how
living undocumented in a multicultural household affected her personal perspectives. Although at times it was incredibly difficult, she
felt it improved her worldview and made her a more Christlike and
spiritual person. She is now married to a white Church member, and
she told me it was a struggle with her in-laws to demonstrate the benefits of multicultural approaches in raising their grandchildren. It was
not until she brought her husband to the Spanish-speaking ward that
he was able to see why raising their children in a Latinx environment
was so important to her. She exclaimed:
30
Dialogue 53, no. 1, Spring 2020
41. Rhacel Salazar Parreñas, Servants of Globalization: Migration and Domestic
Work (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2015).
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
salient multiculturalism meant active participation in the Spanish- or
Portuguese-speaking wards, which better allowed them to implement
elements from each of their respective backgrounds to rear adaptable,
culturally aware American, Latinx, Mormon children. The more pressure mothers felt from Anglo Church society to “assimilate,” the more
motivated mothers appeared to be to take their children to dominantly
Latinx spaces. Fictive kin groups of mothers within the Church then
become not only spaces formed as a strategy for survival in the US but
are platforms in which these women can assert their personal agency
and power to resist the overreaches of white patriarchy within the
Church institution.
As immigration, gender, and religious politics are highly unlikely to
decrease in importance in our daily societal interactions, we must look
to subcommunities like Latina migrant Mormons, who tactically employ
multiculturalism as a form of resistance in the face of resource and
social capital scarcity for examples of adaptive parenting. Their efforts
are consistent with previous research that has discussed how small-scale
actions, sometimes called “weapons of the weak,” can alter community
experiences within an institution but do not risk threatening the overall power structure and, thereby, the benefits of group membership.41 I
believe it’s important to recognize why Latina migrants, along with other
underrepresented communities within Mormonism, have had to employ
these adaptive tactics in order to be recognized for their immense contributions and unseen labor given to the mainstream Church. Church
resources should be used to alleviate the disparities nonwhite/immigrant
communities currently face instead of furthering their marginalization.
I am acutely aware that Mormons have historically been a controversial, misunderstood community. Latina migrants who are deeply
underrepresented or similarly misunderstood in US society have been
able to find recognition and pathways to success within US Church
Romanello: Multiculturalism as Resistance
31
BRITTANY ROMANELLO {bromanel@asu.edu} is a sociocultural anthropology doctoral student at Arizona State University and current Maxwell Institute
for Religious Scholarship consultant. Her work centers on understanding what
intersectional impacts immigration policy, social justice, and gender have on
immigrant mothers’ domestic care decisions. She is additionally interested in
exploring how unprotected legal status may influence migrant mothers’ social
network development and resource accessibility within US religious contexts.
Her dissertation will document how Latina migrant mothers perceive and
negotiate personal and social belonging while navigating majority-Anglo US
Church spaces.
Downloaded from http://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/uip/dial/article-pdf/53/1/5/1264672/dialjmormthou.53.1.0005.pdf by guest on 17 January 2023
spaces. This should be recognized, as it has created an intense feeling of belonging and loyalty among many I interviewed. Loyalty from
the white US Church, though, has often required a cost from Latina
migrants—one that can compromise or erase identity and place by
succumbing to Anglo assimilation pressures. My hope in conducting
this study was to first and foremost amplify the diverse voices, circumstances, and contributions of Latina migrant mothers, many of whom
are women I grew up with and who mothered me. I remain passionate about authentically sharing their stories. My secondary but equally
important goal was to begin to lay a conversational foundation that
asks both the LDS Church institution and its Anglo US communities
to evaluate where it is succeeding or failing in assisting members who
face intersecting societal disadvantages. By understanding underserved
populations’ perspectives on what the US Church can and must do
better, we as a Church society can begin intentional action for structural
and sociocultural change. I believe that in doing so, the Church could
be a model for other influential religious and government bodies. Using
the immense resource capital within Mormonism’s (inter)national
political and social landscapes, we can pave the way for a more equitable and inclusive future. It is a long road that requires recognition and
reparation with the past and sincere preparation for the future. That, to
me, as both researcher and Church member, is the most effective and
purposeful way we can exemplify and create true reciprocity within our
religious societies and hermandades.