Epse 516 Journal
Epse 516 Journal
Epse 516 Journal
R & R JOURNAL
2
Reflection # 1
(week 2)
R & R JOURNAL
grow up to become adults with LD, ADHD, ASD and giftedness. How true! And yet,
most adults would shy away from being called gifted. When we think about adult
discomfort with this label, maybe we should think about how it affects children
when we attach it to them... Taking this model into practice might cause teachers to
create assignments and programs that encourage and develop the kind of leadership
that Sternberg describes in his model. A leader in accordance to Sternbergs (2005)
WICS model is wise, intelligent and creative. We need to teach and encourage
students in our classrooms to generate ideas, assess the quality of their ideas and
find ways to practically implement decisions (Sternberg, R. J., 2003b; cited in Miller,
A., 2012). It is definitely worthwhile to get students thinking about what their
gifts/talents will mean for them as they enter adulthood, also.
Inquiry Project
From my own questions about Jordan and the idea of giftedness there, and
the reading from this week, I am considering investigating how schools in Jordan
define giftedness for my inquiry project. I am eventually going to return to Jordan to
work and help in improving our special education programs and would like to learn
more about this area of special education and whether it exists in our schools.
I was thinking of possibly sending a survey to different principals and vice
principles of schools in Jordan (maybe the survey we took in class last week? And a
few questions that ask for elaborations). I will have to limit the inquiry to include
schools that offer special ed. Services (mainly private schools, that have adopted
international curriculums alongside the Jordanian high-school curriculum).
R & R JOURNAL
What I would like to gain from this, is a general idea of how schools define
giftedness, and what they have to offer children who are gifted, if they offer anything
at all. I think that would be very interesting. You are right to start with the question
of how schools define giftedness since you said there is no one word for this in
Arabic that would convey the concept. It might be interesting to analyze how the
definitions schools give you, link to the services they provide to students.
R & R JOURNAL
5
Response #1
(Week 2)
A couple of my preconceptions
R & R JOURNAL
New ideas!!
In my opinion this article
should urge educators to
learn about the values of
the nonmainstream
populations of their
students in order to be
able to assess more
This article pushed me to expand my thinking beyond
giftedness as differing from culture to culture. The article
of nonmainstream populations (from lower socioeconomic status) defining and understanding giftedness in
a way which differs from mainstream teachers. It showed
that these differing definitions might lead to
nonmainstream students being excluded form special
programs due to them not fitting into the definition of
R & R JOURNAL
Tamara, Im sorry Ive messed up all your neat graphics and diagrams by inserting
comments! I like that you chose an alternate way to represent your thinking on
these issues and the complexity with which youve started to theorize about the lack
of gifted labels in Jordan. I think your project idea would be very interesting.
R & R JOURNAL
Reflection #2
(Week 3)
Building on class discussion
What would it be like if individuals in charge of creating programs to support
children with giftedness approached the task with a postpositivist perspective??
This is a question that was running through my mind last week after the class
discussion of the Peterson (1999) article. Most of the discussion revolved around
the definitions of giftedness presented in the paper and the use of inappropriate
labels to coin the nonmainstream cultures. But little discussion took place on how to
solve the issues the papers raised with regards to individuals being overlooked
when recommendations for giftedness programs were being made.
The method of inquiry used in the article was a postpositivist mode of
inquiry. This is the first time that I had come across research conducted in such a
manner and I was very intrigued by it. The first thing that came to mind was how
could this mode of inquiry be used in a way that is functional and practical (nonresearch related way)? As it is explained in the Peterson (1999) article, the general
focus of postpositivism is understanding rather than justifying. If professionals in
the field of giftedness approached the issue, in each school/district/province (Im
not quite sure how things work) with an open mind, looking to learn about the
population of students that attend the schools and their cultural beliefs and values
and with a willingness to change and adapt maybe then more suitable criteria can
be formulated in order to include students of all different backgrounds, and to
create a giftedness program that supports all of the different needs of the students.
R & R JOURNAL
In the real world there are many restrictions and personal prejudices that
would get in the way of implementing a mode of inquiry such as the one I just
suggested, but again I say what if?? And saying so is often the pathway into change
I wonder, what would happen if we aimed to form gifted programs that were
perfectly representative of the cultural diversity in our population? We would then
be forced to come up with appropriate criteria for seeking out gifted learners that
related to their cultural contexts.
Exactly! And the ultimate goal is to help teach these children reach their
fullest potential and turn into successful gifted adults, imagine the great outcomes
multi-cultural and diverse societies will get a new generation which appreciates
differences and fosters appreciation for different abilities and gifts, that does not
judge or eliminate those who are not following the status quo a world with no
conflict and hierarchies. I may sound like a nave idealist and I am aware that we
are very far from achieving any of this but sometimes what ifs are the way we
create realities. I agree!
R & R JOURNAL
10
Response #2
(Week 3)
Article 1
Gross, M.U.M. 2002. Play Partner or Sure Shelter: What gifted children look for in
friendship. SENG Newsletter, 2(2).
Article 2
Robinson, N.M., Reis, S.M., Neihart, M., & Moon, S.M. 2002. Social and emotional
issues facing gifted and talented students: What have learned and what
should we do now? In Neihart, M., Reis, S.M., Robinson, N.M., & Moon, S.M.
(Eds.). In The social and emotional development of gifted children: What do we
know? (pp. 267-288). Waco, TX: Prufrock Press, Inc.
One recurring theme in the discussions we had with the children last week
was the issue of being bored in class due to the topics addressed being, as one
student put it; a review of a review of a review etc. Moreover, the children were
expressing how they tended to learn at a faster rate than their same aged peers. This
often led to them being frustrated in class, because they were sitting through a
break down of a topic that they have already mastered. The Robinson (2002)
chapter describes this issue as being part of the bigger problem of an ill-fitting
learning environment for the individual. It was a little shocking that most if not all
the students we talked to felt this way. The children seemed to express their
happiest moment as those when they were pulled out of class or in a special after
school class in which they were interacting with peers of the same intellectual
abilities and being presented with more challenging tasks.
R & R JOURNAL
11
R & R JOURNAL
12
R & R JOURNAL
13
Reflection #3
(Week 5)
Sociocultural World view: People behave, and are perceived differently in
different social contexts. What a person is depends on the social environment.
(EPSE 516 Week 4 Lecture slides)
Looking at this statement and considering schools as the social environment
one could argue that different labels exist in the same way all around the world.
Consider what schools around the world are designed to do; they teach
children information they need in order to become successful adults in their society,
they tackle different subject areas through set curricula and tasks, they have preset
expectations of their students. All schools require children to be able to read, write
and comprehend information they are given. Yes the methods in which information
is being presented may differ slightly or even greatly, but the ultimate goal is that
the students be ready for university, and later on the work force. Students
knowledge is tested and quantified using formal assessments all around the world.
The information students are being presented with may differ but the mode of
learning and the outcome expected is the same. All students who attend schools are
expected to learn certain things that help them grow into adults who can participate
actively in society.
Following this train of thought might lead to one saying that LDs look the same all
around the world. A student who is given a label of LD in Canada might travel to a
school half way around the world and still have the same problems. Most probably,
yes.
R & R JOURNAL
14
I know that I am making a broad assumption. I have been exposed to the Jordanian
education system, the British education system, the American education system and
now the Canadian education system, and although there might be some small
cultural differences in definitions the broader more general characteristics of
different special needs seem to be the same. So you are in a position to do a bit of
generalizing, with your experience! What is really interesting is that you find it
possible to generalize between Jordanian schools and the others as the rest one
would expect to be sort of Western in orientation. I should have been more specific
here and said private Jordanian schools as there is a great discrepancy between
private schools and public schools. Most private Jordanian schools offer a different
alongside the Jordanian curriculum and they adopt western ideologies and
implement them within the school. This could explain how although there is no
literal translation for the word gifted the concept still exists in our schools. Thats
really interesting. I would love to visit those schools!
Globalization might be blurring the lines a little, and unifying cultures in a way that
is very subtle yet undeniable. Schools from different parts of the world are now able
to adopt different high school programs (IB, GCSEs etc.) that they were unable to do
in the past. Accordingly, I am making a big assumption here, but one could say that
within the environmental context of schools and education systems, existing labels
may well be more globalized in a sense. In which case one would say people are a
certain way and that does not change (at least within the educational context). Or
that school systems around the world are designed on a similar succeed/fail
R & R JOURNAL
15
R & R JOURNAL
16
Response # 3
(Week 5)
Gallagher, S.A. 1998. The road to critical thinking: The Perry scheme and meaningful
differentiation. NASSP Bulletin, 82 (595), 12-20
Benefits of PBL
Drawbacks of PBL
classroom.
context.
students.
investigation.
R & R JOURNAL
17
faster rate.
students.
R & R JOURNAL
18
Reflection #4
(Week 6)
Inquiry Project:
There might be a slight chance that I may need to change my inquiry project.
I have only had 1 school send back the survey and questionnaire. I have sent out an
email to the other schools that approved taking part and I am waiting to hear back
from them. If I do not hear back by the weekend I will be forced to change my
project.
I have thought of 2 topics I could look into:
1.
2.
R & R JOURNAL
19
Please let me know what you think. It is just my personal bias, but I would be
so interested to learn about the Jordanian teachers perspectives. If you felt
you could actually get the information from them in time to work sense of it
and pull it all together, that is. However, I will not judge you negatively if you
decide to go with the autism/gifted topic You have to do whatever feels
best and most manageable for you.
R & R JOURNAL
20
R & R JOURNAL
21
Response #4
(Week 6)
Winebrenner & Brulles Webinar on Cluster Grouping Model Pt1 and Pt2
Useful
Hesitant
(pretest/alternate work)
or more work.
R & R JOURNAL
22
already know, you should save the
revision until after the pretest;
otherwise the very bright kids might
memorize everything from the review
and feed it back on the pretest, so you
couldnt be sure if they knew it before or
just memorized it during the review.
Ah! That makes sense then.
Extension Menu:
Good point.
R & R JOURNAL
This was one idea that I truly feel
strongly about, especially after talking to
the children who visited us at the start of
the course. Most, if not all the students
expressed how they really disliked
having to help other students in their
grade learn something that they
themselves had mastered a long time
ago. And it is for this very reason that, as
Winebrenner & Brulles point out, many
gifted children are actually not very good
at teaching their peers; they are not
wanting to be doing it and thus they may
be impatient and skip over key steps. Its
not really beneficial for anyone!
23
R & R JOURNAL
24
Reflection #5
(Week 7)
1.
Carly it was great how Carly was able to adapt an activity that is
typically used with children who are gifted and used it with her students
in order to foster creativity. We all signed up for this Masters degree in
hopes that we can transfer what we learn to our work Carly was able to
do just that. The activity in itself made me nervous (I wanted to be
creative because I felt like I had to) reflecting on how that felt for me
will make me stop and think about how to make students feel like their
work is what is precious, no matter what level (specially for those who
struggle more), the important thing is the effort and making a connection
to the task. It is so good for us to experience this from time to time, isnt
it? (absolutely!)
2.
R & R JOURNAL
3.
25
Lisa It was, in a way, shocking to see how little support is offered to
students with the dual exceptionalities of Gifted and LD. And it seems that
even the programs that are out there are aimed more at raising
awareness than at helping the students through their education.
Moreover, those programs that are aimed at helping students
academically seem to be put in the hands of one individual who is in
charge and needs to perform tasks that no one individual can do on their
own (I believe you are one of these individuals? On paper, yes, but
remember there are gifted contact teachers at each school who do a lot of
great work with students and their teaching colleagues. I dont have to do
it all on my own, thankfully! ) (I am glad you are not alone in the
trenches!) A great topic for an inquiry!
4.
Ali I truly admire how Ali has been using our Cohort not only to benefit
her work but also to help her understand more about her son and be able
to support him better. I am personally very interested in her topic as I
work mainly with children with autism and even with this course find it
confusing to differentiate between high functioning autism and
giftedness I think I might need to dig in deeper and do some research
myself! Well sometimes they go together so the answer may be that you
cant differentiate between them because they are both happening in the
same person at the same time!
5.
Darran Darrans work only further highlights how some groups maybe
left out when it comes to referrals for giftedness. His activity is a great one
to use in the classroom to get children to look at things from a different
perspective!
R & R JOURNAL
26
R & R JOURNAL
27
Response #5
(Week 7)
Colangelo, N., Assouline, S. G., & Gross, M. U. M. (Eds.). 2004. A nation deceived: How
schools hold back America's brightest students, Vol. II. Iowa City, IA: Belin &
Blank International Center for Gifted Education and Talent Development.
Assertions about accelerations and conflicting popular opinions or beliefs:
1. It is commonly believed that students who skip grades due to their
giftedness suffer at a socio-emotional level. This report contradicts these
beliefs. They state that should students be accelerated at a suitable rate, with
the right amount of support, the likelihood of socio-emotional issues arising
are slim to none. They also comment on how holding back students who feel
like they do not fit within their age group may be more damaging than
helping them move up grades and be surrounded by peers who share the
same interests. I personally think that students should be involved in
making this decision, as they are the best when it comes to making
judgments regarding where they fit in. great point. Although the adults can
help with long-range perspective, whereas a child may not have the full
picture of how acceleration may affect their decisions in the long term. yes I
completely agree adults should help the student make an informed
decision or at the very least take their opinion into consideration. The
students we spoke to in our earlier classes seemed to be very aware of their
strengths and weaknesses and also of the peers they preferred being
around. The authors also suggest strategies that may decrease the likelihood
of grade skipping causing any trauma to the student, these include:
R & R JOURNAL
28
R & R JOURNAL
29
Reflection #6 & #7
(Week 8 & 9)
R & R JOURNAL
30
Kate also presented a great and easy way to get students to set goals and selfevaluate. And the best part about it is that you can apply these strategies with any
student not only gifted learners.
I was extremely nervous presenting about Jordanian schools last week
partly because I was excited to share what I had learnt and a little bit about my
experiences, but mostly because I did not want to send the wrong message about
Jordan. I love Jordan, not only because it is where I was born and raised, but also
because it has so much to offer. Although we are behind in inclusive education and
special education programs, our schools offer some of the best educational
opportunities in the Middle East (private schools). Our public schools are also good
when it come to educating students through the Jordanian national curriculum, but
students who take this path are more limited with regards as to higher education
options. They tend to only be able to go to universities in Jordan and some in other
Middle-Eastern countries.
I am proud of what our schools have accomplished so for and I look forward to
hopefully playing a great part in the changes that are to come (in the not so far
future! Fingers crossed ). They will be lucky to have you! And I think you left many
of us with a desire to come and visit you there! It was so enriching to have you share
with us about a very different cultural setting for education. Thank you.
Tamara, you were thoughtful in your responses and showed strong engagement
with many of the topics/activities/discussions through your journal writing. 26/30
L-1 25/30
R & R JOURNAL
31