Rock Articles 8
Rock Articles 8
Rock Articles 8
Rock Articles
Issue No.8: Autumn 2012
Dear All, Age figures strongly in this Autumns Rock Articles: we bring you contenders for the titles of oldest rock art in Britain, in Spain, and in Australia, and we celebrate the 80th birthday of the King of the Rocks, Stan Beckensall. We are also pleased to include a report from Tertia Barnett recounting her experiences recording rock art the Swedish way. If you are inspired to try it yourself, just follow the links provided. On a less positive note we must report damage to two important British rock art panels, in West Yorkshire and Cumbria respectively. Thats all from me; enjoy the low winter sun on those cups and rings. Kate October 2012 kesharpe@live.co.uk Contents: New British Discoveries: Rombalds Moor ...............................................................................................1 British Rock Art News ...........................................................................................................................2 World Rock Art on the Web: international news and links ........................................................................4 Sun Burn: rock art recording in Sweden by Tertia Barnett ...........................................................................5 BRAG 2012: conference report from Mark Sapwell .....................................................................................8 Stanfest: celebrating Stan Beckensalls 80th birthday ..................................................................................9 Dates for your Diary: forthcoming conferences, day schools, and other events......................................... 11 Rock Art Reads: new and forthcoming publications ................................................................................. 12 Inspired by Rock Art: creative responses to cup and ring marks ............................................................. 12
If you have identified any new rock art and would like to feature your find here, please get in touch. Please note that grid references will not be included in Rock Articles. Finds should be reported to and verified by the relevant local authority HER officer.
Rivock 33. In moorland to E of Rivock plantation. Quarried rock with linear features and cup-like depressions.
Photo: Kate Sharpe Noah, Jonah, and Blakey deface Hanging Stones
Meanwhile, on Ilkley Moor in West Yorkshire the famous Hanging Stones have been subject to a nasty episode of grafitti involving a chisel, and resulting in 1cm deep carvings. Blakey has obliterated part of a cup and ring mark. Discussions will be held shortly between interested parties, agencies, and authorities to find ways to deal with the present incident, and to prevent similar attacks in the future.
-2-
CSI volunteers lead walk for the Festival of British Archaeology The sun shone as a team from CSI: Rombalds Moor led a walk across Ilkley Moor on Sunday 22nd July as part of the Council for British Archaeologys Festival of British Archaeology. This was an excellent opportunity for the team to share their knowledge and experiences. The walk took in just some of the many carved stones, and the early prehistoric enclosure at Backstone Beck. Members of the CSI team talked about the environment during the Late Neolithic/Early Bronze Age (the time when most of the stones were carved), discussed the different theories surrounding them, and demonstrated the techniques that they are using to make detailed records of each of the panels. The walk was a great success and promoted lots of interesting discussion about the carved rocks and the surrounding landscape. By July the CSI Field Agents had racked up a total of 731 hrs of fieldwork, 36 hrs of photography, and 62.5 hrs on paperwork. They had recorded 75%* of their target 446 panels, and identified 23 new ones, but the sad news is that 26 previously recorded panels have proved impossible to locate and must be considered lost. Read more about the latest CSI adventures on Rombalds Moor in the project blog at http://csirm.wordpress.com/ Photos: Louise Brown.
Early date confirmed for Gower reindeer In Rock Articles 6 (Oct 2011) we reported an exciting discovery made by Dr George Nash from the Department of Archaeology & Anthropology at Bristol University. George was exploring the rear section of Cathole Cave, a limestone cave that stands on the eastern side of an inland valley on the Gower Peninsula, South Wales when he spotted some scratched lines forming of a figure which looked like a side on view of a reindeer. The figure, measuring approximately 15 x 11cm, was engraved using a sharp pointed tool, probably flint, and carved by an artist using his or her right hand. The various engraved lines were cut into a flowstone surface. In April 2011 members of the NERCOpen University Uranium-series Facility extracted samples from the surface on which the engraving was located for Uranium Series dating. They also removed a sample from a section of flowstone that covered a section of the reindeer's muzzle. The minimum dates from the flowstone :
12,572 +/- 600 yrs BP (CH-10 GHS2); and 14,505 +/- 560 yrs BP (CAT11#4)
make this Britains earliest rock art. See also http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/ukwales-south-west-wales-18648683 Image: George Nash
-3-
Oldest rock art in Australia University of Southern Queensland archaeologist Bryce Barker says he has found the oldest piece of rock art in Australia and one of the oldest in the world: created 28,000 years ago in an Outback cave. The dating of one of the thousands of images in the Northern Territory rock shelter known as Nawarla Gabarnmang will be published in the next edition of the Journal of Archaeological Science. The rock art was made with charcoal, so radiocarbon dating has been used to determine its age. "It's the oldest unequivocally dated rock art in Australia" and among the oldest in the world, Barker said. Story published June 18 2012 at :http://news.yahoo.com/archaeologist-finds-oldestrock-art-australia-134339160.html Image credit: Nerja Cave Foundation
The oldest rock art in Spain Researchers have used refined dating techniques to get a more accurate determination of the age of symbols found in Spanish caves. One motif - a faint red dot - is said to be more than 40,000 years old. Dr Alistair Pike from Bristol University reports: "In Cantabria, [in] El Castillo, we find hand stencils that are formed by blowing paint against the hands pressed against the wall of a cave. We find one of these to date older than 37,300 years on 'The Panel of Hands', and very nearby there is a red disc made by a very similar technique that dates to older than 40,800 years. The team dated the paintings by examining the calcium carbonate (calcite) crusts that had formed on top. The oldest dates coincide with the first known immigration into Europe of modern humans. Before about 41,000 years ago it was the Neanderthals who dominated the continent, raising questions about who might have made the markings. If Homo sapiens were responsible then it means they engaged in the activity almost immediately upon their arrival in Europe. Co-author Joao Zilhao, a research professor at ICREA, University of Barcelona, said "There is a strong chance that these results imply Neanderthal authorship, but I will not say we have proven it because we haven't, and it cannot be proven at this time. Image: Pedro Saura Read more at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-18449711
Threat to painted rock shelters in South West India Some of Indias rock art heritage dating back to the Neolithic and period is facing threat from the granite lobby and needs to be saved, reports The Hindu. Visual art historian K.V. Subramanyam said the painted granite rock shelters in Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, discovered between 2009 and 2011, have priceless historical and archaeological value. In some places, the paintings are not of human forms, especially those in Ghattamadamangala. The ones found here are coded, and may have been used for communication, said the art historian. He appealed to the Archaeological Department to step in and save the paintings. See http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Bangalore/article2632274.ece Detail from a painted rock shelter, believed to date to 1200 - 200 BCE. Image: The Hindu.
-4-
Sudanese appeal for international salvage operation Sudans rich archaeological heritage (including rock art) is threatened by plans for a series of dams in areas including Kajbar, Shereiq, and Upper Atbara. The proposed dams will flood several regions along the Nile within three to six years. The Sudanese ministry for antiquities is appealing to the international archaeological community to conduct rescue operations. International experts met representatives from the ministry and the Dams Implementation Unit at the British Museum in London in May this year to share information and lay the foundations for a largescale rescue campaign reminiscent of the one mounted more than a decade ago when the Merowe Dam project was underway. Ironically, Sudanese cultural heritage may benefit from the political turmoil in countries such as Egypt, Syria, Iran and Iraq, as archaeologists prevented from working in these countries could be diverted to projects in Sudan. Full report by Emily Blake in http://www.theartnewspaper.com/conservation
Scandinavian traditions
There are two recognised prehistoric rock carving traditions in Scandinavia. These have discrete, but overlapping, distributions. The earlier carvings are most frequent in northern Norway and Sweden and are thought to have been created by hunter-gatherers between c.8000 and 1800 BC. These engravings are characterised by depictions of wild animals (particularly elks, reindeer and bears), aquatic creatures, including fish and whales, and human figures, some with skis or in boats. Many of the carvings are thought to depict shamanic experiences, myths and cosmological narratives. A different carving tradition predominates in southern Norway and southern Sweden, dating to the Nordic Bronze Age and Roman Iron Age (c.1800 BC- AD 400) and characterised by images of boats, cattle, warriors, sun symbols and cup marks. This southern rock art is thought to encapsulate a rich mythology and belief system relating to the daily journey of the sun and opposing forces of day and night, light and dark, life and death.
Hunter-gather carvings at Alta, Finnmark, northern Norway. Following a tradition that was established in the early 20th century, the engravings on a few selected panels are painted to make the rock art more visible for visitors, As far as we know the carvings were not painted in prehistory.
-5-
Bronze Age carvings at Fossum, Tanum, showing some of the main themes of the southern rock art tradition, including boats, warriors and sun symbolism. Carvings at selected sites are painted to improve visibility but, as with the northern carvings, it is unlikely that they were painted originally
-6-
Team work: painting the carvings with a chalk powder solution to prepare the panel for the archive photograph
During the field school, I worked with a small team to record one large panel (Balkan) the entire process took three long but very enjoyable days during which I got to know the carvings intimately. I had had some initial concerns about the recording methodology, not least because it incorporates a number of activities that we advise strongly against for British rock art: scrubbing, removing lichens, making rubbings and painting. However, the images in Scandinavia are more robust than in Britain, being carved into hard granite rather than our soft sandstones and schists. The rock surfaces in Norway and Sweden are exposed to more profound threats than a bit of human intervention; frost damage gouges out great chunks of rock every winter, while acid rain accelerates the rate at which the rock matrix deteriorates. These forces are difficult to combat. Regular recording provides extensive material for research and for detailed monitoring of the rate and nature of decay. Despite my initial doubts, the established methodology in Scandinavia works well for this purpose and generates very precise records, although the toolkit would benefit from the addition of 3D digital recording methods such as photogrammetry.
The rock art in Tanum attracts huge numbers of tourists every year and the images are often appropriated by local people for more contemporary uses such as decorating tee-shirts or to advertise local businesses. The significance of the carvings to local residents was apparent during the field school when a giant wooden sculpture of the sun horse, one of the most iconic symbols in Swedish rock art, was constructed in front of the museum. This effigy, created by a local artist, was to commemorate the 60th anniversary of the museum. For several days, people came from the surrounding area to admire the sculpture then, on our final evening, we ceremonially burnt it. However the gods did not seem too pleased with this sacrifice as it poured with rain the next day! So although I didnt go to Sweden for the sunshine, I did find a sun! My thanks to Gerhard Mistreu, Ellen Meijer, and all the staff and trainees at Undersls Museum for a fascinating week. Tak s!
Sun horse carving at Balkan, Tanum, after painting (image measures approx. 0.7m x 0.5m)
Sacrificing the sun horse in commemoration of the 60th anniversary of Undersls Museum (sculpture measures approx. 7m x 5m)
Further information: Undersls Museum and the Scandinavian Society for Prehistoric Art (including details of the field school): http://www.rockartscandinavia.se/
Vitlyke Museum, Tanum: http://www.vitlyckemuseum.se/Kultur_Default.aspx?id=45677 Swedish Rock Art research Archives: http://www.shfa.se/
-7-
-8-
Cups and Rings and Other Things: an 80th birthday tribute to Dr Stan Beckensall
Lord of the Rings, King of Rock, and Stan the man were just a few of the titles accorded to Dr Stan Beckensall by speakers gathered in his home town of Hexham in September. The event, organised secretly by Paul Frodsham and Aron Mazel, involved family, friends, and colleagues who came together for a public conference on rock art to celebrate the enormous contribution made by Stan to the study of carved stones over the last 50 years (see page 10). The presentations took the 130-strong audience on a tour of rock art from Northumberland to Australia and from Ireland to West Yorkshire. The Other Things included digital dancing figures from Italy, camels from Libya, and a very old Welsh reindeer. All the speakers reflected on the significant part Stan had played in inspiring their research, and paid tribute to his generosity, enthusiasm, and boundless energy. Stans love of verse was reflected in two poetic contributions which can be found along with photographs from the day on a dedicated Facebook website: http://www.facebook.com/pages/StanFest/368606793214627 The conference concluded with a presentation by Aron Mazel who awarded Stan the Old Bewick Order of Archaeological Recording, and the George Tate Medal for Rock Art Recording. A colourful birthday cake inspired by cup and ring motifs was made by Ann Macdonald.
Photos 1. Weve organized a surprise conference for your birthday!; 2. Stan receives his awards; 3. & 4. The awards; 5. The cup and ring birthday cake; 6. Cutting the cake: Aron, Stan and Paul; 7. The speakers. Back row: Clive Waddington, Elizabeth Shee Twohig, Keith Boughey, Stan Beckensall, Chris Chippendale, Paul Brown, Tertia Barnett, Kate Sharpe, George Nash, Robert Layton. Front row: Aron Mazel, Paul Frodsham. Photo credits: Marc Johnstone (1, 2, 6, 7) and Aron Mazel (3, 4, 5).
-9-
'People on the outside know Stan for all the talks he goes round giving to history societies, but they dont realise what an important contribution he has made to academic research Paul Frodsham, 2012
The Prehistoric Carved Rocks of Northumberland (1974) Life and Death in Prehistoric Northumberland (1976) Northumberland's Prehistoric Rock Carvings (1983) Rock Carvings of Northern Britain (August 1986) Prehistoric Motifs of Northumberland Vol. 1 (1991) Prehistoric Motifs of Northumberland Vol. 2 (1992) Cumbrian Prehistoric Rock Art (1992) Life and Death in the Prehistoric North (1994) Prehistoric Rock Art of County Durham, Swaledale and Wenselydale (1998) Prehistoric Rock Art in Northumberland (Oct 2001) British Prehistoric Rock Art (Aug 2002) Prehistoric Rock Art in Cumbria (Jun 2002) Prehistoric Northumberland (Mar 2003) The Prehistoric Rock Art of Kilmartin (2005) Circles in Stone: a British Prehistoric Mystery (Oct 2006) Prehistoric Rock Art in Britain (2008) Northumberlands Hidden History (2009) * Not exhaustive!
'Stan Beckensall has been one of the most patient and thorough recorders of British rock art, and his eye for the details of the individual carvings is as keen as his grasp of the countryside as a whole.' Richard Bradley, 1992.
- 10 -
21st October Archaeology in the Lake District 2012 (organised by the National Park), Keswick. Held at the Theatre by the Lake, Keswick. Fee: 12.50 (18.25 including lunch). Parking voucher 2.00. Includes presentation by Peter Style (UCLAN): Of Lions, Lambs, and Sleeping Sheep: Prehistoric Mountain Monuments and Rock Art in the Cumbrian Fells. For details and booking forms see: http://www.lakedistrict.gov.uk/learning/archaeology/archaeologyconference
5th November Movement and mobility in the Neolithic. Neolithic Studies Group Autumn Meeting To be held in the Stevenson lecture Theatre, the British Museum, London from 10.30am to 4.55pm. Fee: 10. For full details and booking form see: http://www.neolithic.org.uk/meetings/75/autumn-meeting-2012-movement-and-mobility-in-theneolithic
10th-11th November Scotland's Community Heritage Conference 2012 A weekend of talks, workshops and displays and the chance to meet like-minded people. Learn about active community archaeology projects such as those on Mull and North Uist; hear about architecture and designed landscape projects in Wanlockhead and Kingussie and find out about the work of volunteers in NTS Thistle Camps and in recording Perthshire's graveyards. Join guided walks on Sunday 11th to chat and network with fellow heritage enthusiasts and see the local sites. PayPal booking is available or you can download the booking form from the website. Prices are 15 per person (this includes lunch). For full details see: www.archaeologyscotland.org.uk/?q=node/2774 Phone: 0845 872 3333
10th November Archaeology in York Conference One-day conference will allow delegates to learn about some of the archaeological work that has been carried out in York during 2012. The subjects covered are diverse, from prehistoric landscapes to the railways in the 19th and 20th centuries. The conference is aimed at full-time archaeologists, members of community archaeology groups and history societies, students and members of the public who are interested in the heritage of this special city. Fee is 15. This includes tea, coffee and biscuits on arrival and in the afternoon and delegate pack. Lunch is not provided. For full details contact John Oxley at archaeology@york.gov.uk or phone 01904 551346.
21st November Archaeology Day School The West Yorkshire Archaeology Advisory Service is holding its thirteenth annual Archaeological Day School, returning to the spectacular venue of the Royal Armouries, Leeds. Representatives from WYAS will bring delegates up to date with the results of recent archaeological work in West Yorkshire, covering historic buildings, industrial archaeology and other excavations and fieldwork. The afternoon programme will cover recent work of the Portable Antiquities Scheme's West & South Yorkshire Finds Liaison Officer and work undertaken by Pontefract and District Archaeological Society on St Richard's Dominican Friary excavations. Back by popular demand is potter John Hudson, with an entertaining demonstration on historic pottery making. You can also register and buy tickets online by visiting the West Yorkshire Archaeology Advisory Service website: www.archaeology.wyjs.org.uk
20th April 2013 British Rock Art Group, Queens University, Belfast. BRAG goes to Belfast next year (see page 13). Email for information is brag2013@gmail.com
- 11 -
If you have created something rock art related and would like to share it with Rock Articles readers, drop me a line at
Stan on Stone by Clive Waddington A rare auld lad lives down the street Treads moor and mountain with his feet Spying stony symbols for us all to see Through rubbings, photos and poetry A teacher, writer and playwright he Through wit and art makes newsprint see His discoveries, descriptions, and photography Have left inspired for generations a legacy
- 12 -
- 13 -