Montinola v. PNB

Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Republic of the Philippines

SUPREME COURT
Manila
EN BANC
G.R. No. L-!"# $eb%ua%& "' #()#
ENR*+UE P. MONT*NOLA' plaintiff-appellant'
,s.
T-E P-*L*PP*NE NAT*ONAL BAN.' ET AL.' /efen/ants-appellees.
+ui0ano' Rosete an/ Lucena fo% appellant.
Secon/ Assistant Co%po%ate Counsel -ila%ion U. 1a%encio fo% appellee Philippine National
Ban2.
Office of the Solicito% Gene%al $eli3 Bautista An4elo an/ Solicito% Au4usto M. Luciano
fo% appellee P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is O%iental.
MONTEMA6OR' 1.7
*n Au4ust' #(89' En%i:ue P. Montinola file/ a co5plaint in the Cou%t of $i%st *nstance of
Manila a4ainst the Philippine National Ban2 an/ the P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is
O%iental to collect the su5 of P#;;';;;' the a5ount of Chec2 No. #<! issue/ on Ma& '
#(8 b& the P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is O%iental to Ma%iano =. Ra5os an/
suppose/l& in/o%se/ to Montinola. Afte% hea%in4' the cou%t %en/e%e/ a /ecision /is5issin4
the co5plaint >ith costs a4ainst plaintiff-appellant. Montinola has appeale/ f%o5 that
/ecision /i%ectl& to this Cou%t inas5uch as the a5ount in cont%o,e%s& e3cee/s P);';;;.
The%e is no /ispute as to the follo>in4 facts. *n Ap%il an/ Ma&' #(8' Ubal/o ?. La&a
>as the P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is O%iental. As such P%o,incial T%easu%e% he >as e3
officio a4ent of the Philippine National Ban2 b%anch in the p%o,ince. Ma%iano =. Ra5os
>o%2e/ un/e% hi5 as assistant a4ent in the ban2 b%anch afo%e5entione/. *n Ap%il of that
&ea% #(8' the cu%%enc& bein4 use/ in Min/anao' pa%ticula%l& Misa5is O%iental an/
Lanao >hich ha/ not &et been occupie/ b& the 1apanese in,a/in4 fo%ces' >as the
e5e%4enc& cu%%enc& >hich ha/ been issue/ since 1anua%&' #(8 b& the Min/anao
E5e%4enc& Cu%%enc& Boa%/ b& autho%it& of the late P%esi/ent +ue@on.
About Ap%il "' #(8' th%u the %eco55en/ation of P%o,incial T%easu%e% La&a' his
assistant a4ent M. =. Ra5os >as in/ucte/ into the Unite/ States A%5e/ $o%ces in the $a%
East AUSA$$EB as /isbu%sin4 office% of an a%5& /i,ision. As such /isbu%sin4 office%' M.
=. Ra5os on Ap%il <;' #(8' >ent to the nei4hbo%in4 P%o,ince Lanao to p%ocu%e a cash
a/,ance in the a5ount of P!;;';;; fo% the use of the USA$$E in Ca4a&an /e Misa5is.
Pe/%o Enca%nacion' P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Lanao /i/ not ha,e that a5ount in cash. So'
he 4a,e Ra5os P<;;';;; in e5e%4enc& notes an/ a chec2 fo% P);;';;;. On Ma& ' #(8
Ra5os >ent to the office of P%o,incial T%easu%e% La&a at Misa5is O%iental to encash the
chec2 fo% P);;';;; >hich he ha/ %ecei,e/ f%o5 the P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Lanao. La&a
/i/ not ha,e enou4h cash to co,e% the chec2 so he 4a,e Ra5os P8;;';;; in e5e%4enc&
notes an/ a chec2 No. #<! fo% P#;;';;; /%a>n on the Philippine National Ban2.
Acco%/in4 to La&a he ha/ p%e,iousl& /eposite/ P);;';;; e5e%4enc& notes in the
Philippine National Ban2 b%anch in Cebu an/ he e3pecte/ to ha,e the chec2 issue/ b&
hi5 cashe/ in Cebu a4ainst sai/ /eposit.
Ra5os ha/ no oppo%tunit& to cash the chec2 because in the e,enin4 of the sa5e /a& the
chec2 >as issue/ to hi5' the 1apanese fo%ces ente%e/ the capital of Misa5is O%iental' an/
on 1une #;' #(8' the USA$$E fo%ces to >hich he >as attache/ su%%en/e%e/. Ra5os >as
5a/e a p%isone% of >a% until $eb%ua%& #' #(8<' afte% >hich' he >as %elease/ an/ he
%esu5e/ his status as a ci,ilian.
About the last /a&s of ?ece5be%' #(88 o% the fi%st /a&s of 1anua%&' #(8)' M. =. Ra5os
alle4e/l& in/o%se/ this chec2 No. #<! to En%i:ue P. Montinola. The ci%cu5stances an/
con/itions un/e% >hich the ne4otiation o% t%ansfe% >as 5a/e a%e in cont%o,e%s&.
Acco%/in4 to MontinolaCs ,e%sion' so5eti5e in 1une' #(88' Ra5os' nee/in4 5one& >ith
>hich to bu& foo/stuffs an/ 5e/icine' offe%e/ to sell hi5 the chec2D to be su%e that it >as
4enuine an/ ne4otiable' Montinola' acco5panie/ b& his a4ents an/ b& Ra5os hi5self'
>ent to see P%esi/ent Ca%5ona of the Philippine National Ban2 in Manila about sai/
chec2D that afte% e3a5inin4 it P%esi/ent Ca%5ona tol/ hi5 that it >as ne4otiable but that
he shoul/ not let the 1apanese catch hi5 >ith it because possession of the sa5e >oul/
in/icate that he >as still >aitin4 fo% the %etu%n of the A5e%icans to the PhilippinesD that he
an/ Ra5os finall& a4%ee/ to the sale of the chec2 fo% P!);';;; 1apanese 5ilita%& notes'
pa&able in install5entsD that of this a5ount' P8);';;; >as pai/ to Ra5os in 1apanese
5ilita%& notes in fi,e install5ents' an/ the balance of P8;;';;; >as pai/ in 2in/' na5el&'
fou% bottles of sulphatia sole' each bottle containin4 #';;; tablets' an/ each tablet ,alue/
at P#;;D that upon pa&5ent of the full p%ice' M. =. Ra5os /ul& in/o%se/ the chec2 to
hi5. This in/o%se5ent >hich no> appea%s on the bac2 of the /ocu5ent is /esc%ibe/ in
/etail b& t%ial cou%t as follo>s7
The en/o%se5ent no> appea%in4 at the bac2 of the chec2 Asee E3hibit A-#B 5a& be
/esc%ibe/ as follo>s7 The >oo/s' Epa& to the o%/e% ofE F in %ubbe% sta5p an/ in ,iolet
colo% a%e place/ about one inch f%o5 the top. This is follo>e/ b& the >o%/s EEn%i:ue P.
MontinolaE in t&pe>%itin4 >hich is app%o3i5atel& )G! an inch belo> the sta5pe/ >o%/s
Epa& to the o%/e% ofE. Belo> EEn%i:ue P. MontinolaE' in t&pe>%itin4 a%e >o%/s an/ fi4u%es
also in t&pe>%itin4' E)#9 *sabel St%eetE an/ about HG! of an inch the%ef%o5' the e/4es of
the chec2 appea% to ha,e been bu%ne/' but the%e a%e >o%/s sta5pe/ appa%entl& in %ubbe%
sta5p >hich' acco%/in4 to Montinola' a%e a facsi5ile of the si4natu%e of Ra5os. The%e is
a si4natu%e >hich appa%entl& %ea/s EM. =. Ra5osE also in 4%een in2 but 5a/e in
han/>%itin4.E
To the abo,e /esc%iption >e 5a& a// that the na5e of M. =. Ra5os is han/ p%inte/ in
4%een in2' un/e% the si4natu%e. Acco%/in4 to Montinola' he as2e/ Ra5os to han/ p%int it
because Ra5osC si4natu%e >as not clea%.
Ra5os in his tu%n tol/ the cou%t that the a4%ee5ent bet>een hi5self an/ Montinola
%e4a%/in4 the t%ansfe% of the chec2 >as that he >as sellin4 onl& P<;';;; of the chec2 an/
fo% this %eason' at the bac2 of the /ocu5ent he >%ote in lon4han/ the follo>in47
Pa& to the o%/e% of En%i:ue P. Montinola P<;';;; onl&. The balance to be /eposite/ in the
Philippine National Ban2 to the c%e/it of M. =. Ra5os.
Ra5os fu%the% sai/ that in e3chan4e fo% this assi4n5ent of P<;';;; Montinola >oul/ pa&
hi5 P(;';;; in 1apanese 5ilita%& notes but that Montinola 4a,e hi5 onl& t>o chec2s of
P;';;; an/ P)';;;' lea,in4 a balance unpai/ of P8)';;;. *n this he >as co%%obo%ate/
b& Att&. Si5eon Ra5os 1%. >ho tol/ the cou%t that the a4%ee5ent bet>een Ra5os an/
Montinola >as that the latte%' fo% the sale to hi5 of P<;';;; of the chec2' >as to pa&
Ra5os P(;';;; in 1apanese 5ilita%& notesD that >hen the fi%st chec2 fo% P;';;; >as
issue/ b& Montinola' he ASi5eonB p%epa%e/ a /ocu5ent e,i/encin4 sai/ pa&5ent of
P;';;;D that >hen the secon/ chec2 fo% P)';;; >as issue/ b& Montinola' he ASi5eonB
p%epa%e/ anothe% /ocu5ent >ith t>o copies' one fo% Montinola an/ the othe% fo% Ra5os'
both si4ne/ b& Montinola an/ M. =. Ra5os' e,i/encin4 sai/ pa&5ent' >ith the
un/e%stan/in4 that the balance of P8)';;; >oul/ be pai/ in a fe> /a&s.
The in/o%se5ent o% >%itin4 /esc%ibe/ b& M. =. Ra5os >hich ha/ been >%itten b& hi5 at
the bac2 of the chec2' E3hibit A' /oes not no> appea% at the bac2 of sai/ chec2. Ihat
appea%s the%eon is the in/ose5ent testifie/ to b& Montinola an/ /esc%ibe/ b& the t%ial
cou%t as %ep%o/uce/ abo,e. Befo%e 4oin4 into a /iscussion of the 5e%its of the ,e%sion
4i,en b& Ra5os an/ Montinola as to the in/o%se5ent o% >%itin4 at the bac2 of the chec2'
it is >ell to 4i,e a fu%the% /esc%iption of it as >e shall late%.
Ihen Montinola file/ his co5plaint in #(89 he state/ the%ein that the chec2 ha/ been
lost' an/ so in lieu the%eof he file/ a suppose/ photostic cop&. -o>e,e%' at the t%ial' he
p%esente/ the chec2 itself an/ ha/ its face 5a%2e/ E3hibit A an/ the bac2 the%eof E3hibit
A-#. But the chec2 is ba/l& 5utilate/' bottle/' to%n an/ pa%tl& bu%ne/' an/ its con/ition
can best be app%eciate/ b& seein4 it. Rou4hl&' it 5a& be state/ that loo2in4 at the face of
the chec2 AE3hibit AB >e see that the left thi%/ po%tion of the pape% has been cut off
pe%pen/icula%l& an/ se,e%e/ f%o5 the %e5ainin4 G< po%tionD a t%ian4ula% po%tion of the
uppe% %i4ht han/ co%ne% of sai/ %e5ainin4 G< po%tion has been si5ila%l& cut off an/
se,e%e/' an/ to 2eep an/ attach this t%ian4ula% po%tion an/ the %ectan4ula% HG< po%tion to
the %est of the /ocu5ent' the enti%e chec2 is paste/ on both si/es >ith cellophaneD the
e/4es of the se,e%e/ po%tions as >ell as of the %e5ainin4 5a0o% po%tion' >he%e cut bea%
t%aces of bu%nin4 an/ sea%in4D the%e is a bi4 blot >ith in/elible in2 about the %i4ht 5i//le
po%tion' >hich see5s to ha,e penet%ate/ to the bac2 of the chec2 AE3hibit A-#B' >hich
bac2 bea%s a la%4e% s5ea% %i4ht un/e% the blot' but not blac2 an/ sha%p as the blot itselfD
finall&' all this tea%in4' bu%nin4' blottin4 an/ s5ea%in4 an/ pastin4 of the chec2 %en/e%s it
/ifficult if not i5possible to %ea/ so5e of the >o%/s an/ fi4u%es on the chec2.
*n e3planation of the 5utilation of the chec2 Montinola tol/ the cou%t that se,e%al 5onths
afte% in/o%sin4 an/ /eli,e%in4 the chec2 to hi5' Ra5os /e5an/e/ the %etu%n of the chec2
to hi5' th%eatenin4 Montinola >ith bo/il& ha%5' e,en /eath b& hi5self o% his 4ue%%illa
fo%ces if he /i/ not %etu%n sai/ chec2' an/ that in o%/e% to 0ustif& the non-/eli,e%& of the
/ocu5ent an/ to /iscou%a4e Ra5os f%o5 4ettin4 it bac2' he AMontinolaB ha/ to %eso%t to
the 5utilation of the /ocu5ent.
As to >hat >as %eall& >%itten at the bac2 of the chec2 >hich Montinola clai5s to be a full
in/o%se5ent of the chec2' >e a4%ee >ith t%ial cou%t that the o%i4inal >%itin4 of Ra5os on
the bac2 of the chec2 >as to the effect that he >as assi4nin4 onl& P<;';;; of the ,alue of
the /ocu5ent an/ that he >as inst%uctin4 the ban2 to /eposit to his c%e/it the balance.
This >%itin4 >as in so5e 5&ste%ious >a& oblite%ate/' an/ in its place >as place/ the
p%esent in/o%se5ent appea%in4 the%eon. Sai/ p%esent in/o%se5ent occupies a 4oo/ po%tion
of the bac2 of the chec2. *t has al%ea/& been /esc%ibe/ in /etail. As to ho> sai/ p%esent
in/o%se5ent ca5e to be >%itten' the ci%cu5stances su%%oun/in4 its p%epa%ation' the
suppose/ pa%ticipation of M. =. Ra5os in it an/ the >%itin4 o%i4inall& appea%in4 on the
%e,e%se si/e of the chec2' E3hibit A-#' >e :uote >ith app%o,al >hat the t%ial cou%t
p%esi/e/ o,e% b& 1u/4e Con%a/o =. Sanche@' in its >ell-p%epa%e/ /ecision' sa&s on these
points7
The alle4e/l& in/o%se5ent7 EPa& to the o%/e% of En%i:ue P. Montinola the a5ount of
P<;';;; onl&. The balance to be /eposite/ to the c%e/it of M. =. Ra5osE' si4ne/ b& M. =.
Ra5os-acco%/in4 to the latte%-/oes not no> appea% at the bac2 of the chec2. A /iffe%ent
in/o%se5ent' as afo%esai/' no> appea%s.
-a/ Montinola %eall& pai/ in full the su5 of P!);';;; in 1apanese Milita%& Notes as
consi/e%ation fo% the chec2J The follo>in4 obse%,ations a%e in point7
AaB Acco%/in4 to plaintiffCs >itness G%e4o%io A. Co%ta/o' the o,al line in ,iolet' enclosin4
EP.E of the >o%/s EEn%i:ue P. MontinolaE an/ the line in the fo%5 of cane han/le c%ossin4
the >o%/ Est%eetE in the >o%/s an/ fi4u%es E)#9 *sabel St%eetE in the en/o%se5ent E3hibit
A-# EunusualE to hi5' an/ that as fa% as he coul/ %e5e5be% this >%itin4 /i/ not appea% on
the inst%u5ent an/ he ha/ no 2no>le/4e as to ho> it happene/ to be the%e. Ob,iousl&
Co%ta/o ha/ no %ecollection as to ho> such 5a%2s e,e% >e%e sta5pe/ at the bac2 of the
chec2.
AbB A4ain Co%ta/o' spea2in4 of the en/o%se5ent as it no> appea%s at the bac2 of the
chec2 AE3h. A-#B state/ that Ra5os t&pe>%ote these >o%/s outsi/e of the p%e5ises of
Montinola' that is' a nea%b& house. Montinola' on the othe% han/' testifie/ that Ra5os
t&pe>%ote the >o%/s EEn%i:ue P. Montinola )#9 *sabel St%eetE' in his o>n house.
Spea2in4 of the %ubbe% sta5p use/ at the bac2 of the chec2 an/ >hich p%o/uce/ the
>o%/s Epa& to the o%/e% ofE' Co%ta/o state/ that >hen he ACo%ta/oB' Ata/e%o' Montinola
an/ Ra5os %etu%ne/ in 4%oup to the house of Montinola' the %ubbe% sta5p >as al%ea/& in
the house of Montinola' an/ it >as on the table of the uppe% floo% of the house' to4ethe%
>ith the sta5p pa/ use/ to sta5p the sa5e. Montinola' on the othe% han/' testifie/ that
Ra5os ca%%ie/ in his poc2et the sai/ %ubbe% sta5p as >ell as the in2 pa/' an/ sta5pe/ it
in his house.
The unusuall& bi4 space occupie/ b& the in/o%se5ent on the bac2 of the chec2 an/ the
/isc%epancies in the ,e%sions of Montinola an/ his >itness Co%ta/o 0ust note/' c%eate
/oubts as to >hethe% o% not %eall& Ra5os 5a/e the in/o%se5ent as it no> appea%s at the
bac2 of E3hibit A. One thin4 /ifficult to un/e%stan/ is >h& Ra5os shoul/ 4o into the
labo%ious tas2 of placin4 the %ubbe% sta5p EPa& to the o%/e% ofE an/ afte%>a%/s 5o,e to
the t&pe>%ite% an/ >%ite the >o%/s EEn%i:ue P. MontinolaE Ean/ E)#9 *sabel St%eetE' an/
finall& si4n his na5e too fa% belo> the 5ain in/o%se5ent.
AcB Anothe% ci%cu5stances >hich bea%s hea,il& upon the clai5 of plaintiff Montinola that
he ac:ui%e/ the full ,alue of the chec2 an/ pai/ the full consi/e%ation the%efo% is the
p%esent con/ition of sai/ chec2. *t is no> so unclean an/ /iscolo%e/D it is paste/ in
cellophane' bottle/ >ith in2 on both si/es to%n th%ee pa%ts' an/ >ith po%tions the%eof
bu%ne/-all /one b& plaintiff' the alle4e/ o>ne% the%eof.
The acts /one b& the ,e%& plaintiff on a /ocu5ent so i5po%tant an/ ,aluable to hi5' an/
>hich acco%/in4 to hi5 in,ol,es his life sa,in4s' app%o3i5ate intentional cancellation.
The onl& %eason a/,ance/ b& plaintiff as to >h& to%e chec2' bu%ne/ the to%n e/4es an/
bottle/ out the %e4ist%ation at the bac2' is foun/ in the follo>in47 That Ra5os ca5e to his
house' a%5e/ >ith a %e,ol,e%' th%eatene/ his life an/ /e5an/e/ f%o5 hi5 the %etu%n of the
chec2D that >hen he info%5e/ Ra5os that he /i/ not ha,e it in the house' but in so5e
/eposit outsi/e the%eof an/ that Ra5os p%o5ise/ to %etu%n the ne3t /a&D that the sa5e
ni4ht he to%e the chec2 into th%ee pa%ts' bu%ne/ the si/es >ith a pa%%afin can/le to sho>
t%aces of bu%nin4D an/ that upon the %etu%n of Ra5os the ne3t /a& he sho>e/ the t>o pa%ts
of the chec2' the t%ian4le on the %i4ht uppe% pa%t an/ the to%n piece on the left pa%t' an/
upon seein4 the con/ition the%eof Ra5os /i/ not bothe% to 4et the chec2 bac2. -e also
sai/ that he place/ the blots in in/elible in2 to p%e,ent Ra5os F if he >oul/ be fo%ce/ to
su%%en/e% the 5i//le pa%t of the chec2 F f%o5 seein4 that it >as %e4iste%e/ in the Gene%al
Au/itin4 Office.
Conce/in4 at the 5o5ent these facts to be t%ue' the :uestion is7 Ih& shoul/ Montinola
be af%ai/ of Ra5osJ Montinola clai5s that Ra5os >ent the%e about Ap%il' #(8)' that is'
/u%in4 libe%ation. *f he belie,e/ he >as stan/in4 b& his %i4hts' he coul/ ha,e ,e%& >ell
sou4ht police p%otection o% t%ansfe%%e/ to so5e place >he%e Ra5os coul/ not bothe% hi5.
An/ then' %eall& Ra5os /i/ not ha,e an&thin4 5o%e to /o >ith this chec2 fo% the %eason
that Montinola ha/ obtaine/ in full the a5ount the%eof' the%e coul/ not be an& %eason >h&
Ra5os shoul/ ha,e th%eatene/ Montinola as state/ b& the latte%. Un/e% the ci%cu5stances'
the 5ost lo4ical conclusion is that Ra5os >ante/ the chec2 at all costs because
Montinola /i/ not ac:ui%e the chec2 to such an e3tent that it bo%/e%s on intentional
cancellation the%eof Asee Sections ##(-#< Ne4otiable *nst%u5ents La>B the%e is %oo5 to
belie,e that Montinola /i/ not ha,e so 5uch in,est5ents in that chec2 as to a/opte/ an
E>hat /o * ca%eJE attitu/e.
An/ the%e is the ci%cu5stance of the alle4e/ loss of the chec2. At the ti5e of the filin4 of
the co5plaint the chec2 >as alle4e/l& lost' so 5uch so that a photostatic cop& the%eof
>as 5e%el& attache/ to the co5plaint Asee pa%a4%aph 9 of the co5plaintB. 6et' /u%in4 the
t%ial the o%i4inal chec2 E3hibit A >as p%o/uce/ in cou%t.
But a co5pa%ison bet>een the photostatic cop& an/ the o%i4inal chec2 %e,eals
/isc%epancies bet>een the t>o. The con/ition of the chec2 as it >as p%o/uce/ is such that
it >as pa%tiall& bu%ne/' pa%tiall& blotte/' ba/l& 5utilate/' /iscolo%e/ an/ paste/ >ith
cellophane. Ihat is >o%se is that MontinolaCs e3cuse as to ho> it >as lost' that it >as
5i3e/ up >ith househol/ effects is not plausible' consi/e%in4 the fact that it in,ol,es his
life sa,in4s' an/ that befo%e the alle4e/ loss' he too2 e3t%e5e pains an/ p%ecautions to
sa,e the chec2 f%o5 the possible %a,a4es of the >a%' ha/ it photo4%aphe/' %e4iste%e/ sai/
chec2 >ith the Gene%al Au/itin4 Office an/ he 2ne> that Ra5os' since libe%ation' >as
hot afte% the possession of that chec2.
A/B *t see5s that Montinola >as not so su%e as to >hat he ha/ testifie/ to in %efe%ence to
the consi/e%ation he pai/ fo% the chec2. *n cou%t he testifie/ that he pai/ P8);';;; in cash
f%o5 1une to ?ece5be% #(88' an/ P8;;';;; >o%th of sulphatia@ole in 1anua%& #(8) to
co5plete the alle4e/ consi/e%ation of P!);';;;. Ihen Montinola testifie/ this >a& in
cou%t' ob,iousl& he o,e%loo2e/ a lette% he >%ote to the p%o,incial t%easu%e% of Ca4a&an'
O%iental Misa5is' /ate/ Ma& #' #(89' E3hibit < the %eco%/. *n that lette% E3hibit <'
Montinola tol/ P%o,incial T%easu%e% Eli@al/e of Misa5is O%iental that ERa5os en/o%se/
it A%efe%%in4 to chec2B to 5e fo% 4oo/s in 2in/' 5e/icine' etc.' %ecei,e/ b& hi5 fo% the use
of the 4ue%%illas.E *n sai/ lette% E3hibit <' Montinola /i/ not 5ention the cash that he pai/
fo% the chec2.
$%o5 the fo%e4oin4 the cou%t conclu/es that plaintiff Montinola ca5e into the possession
of the chec2 in :uestion about the en/ of ?ece5be% #(88 b& %eason of the fact that M. =.
Ra5os sol/ to hi5 P<;';;; of the face ,alue the%eof in consi/e%ation of the su5 of
P(;';;; 1apanese 5one&' of >hich onl& one-half o% P8)';;; Ain 1apanese 5one&B >as
actuall& pai/ b& sai/ plaintiff to Ra5os. AR. on A.' pp. <#-<<D B%ief of Appellee' pp. #8-
;.B
At the be4innin4 of this /ecision' >e state/ that as P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is
O%iental' Ubal/o ?. La&a >as e3 officio a4ent of the Philippine National Ban2 b%anch in
that p%o,ince. On the face of the chec2 AE3h. AB >e no> fin/ the >o%/s in pa%enthesis
EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E un/e% the si4natu%e of La&a' pu%po%te/l& sho>in4 that he
issue/ the chec2 as a4ent of the Philippine National Ban2. *t this is t%ue' then the ban2 is
not onl& /%a>ee but also a /%a>e% of the chec2' an/ Montinola e,i/entl& is t%&in4 to hol/
the Philippine National Ban2 liable in that capacit& of /%a>e%' because as /%a>ee alone'
inas5uch as the ban2 has not &et accepte/ o% ce%tifie/ the chec2' it 5a& &et a,oi/
pa&5ent.
La&a' testif&in4 in cou%t' state/ that he issue/ the chec2 onl& as P%o,incial T%easu%e%' an/
that the >o%/s in pa%enthesis EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E no> appea%in4 un/e% his
si4natu%e /i/ not appea% on the chec2 >hen he issue/ the sa5e. *n this he >as
co%%obo%ate/ b& the pa&ee M. =. Ra5os >ho e:uall& assu%e/ the cou%t that >hen he
%ecei,e/ the chec2 an/ then /eli,e%e/ it to Montinola' those >o%/s /i/ not appea% un/e%
the si4natu%e of Ubal/o ?. La&a. Ie a4ain :uote >ith app%o,al the pe%tinent po%tion of
the t%ial cou%tCs /ecision7
The :uestion is %e/uce/ to >hethe% o% not the >o%/s' EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E >e%e
a//e/ afte% La&a ha/ issue/ the chec2. *n a st%ai4htfo%>a%/ 5anne% an/ >ithout
,acillation La&a positi,el& testifie/ that the chec2 E3hibit A >as issue/ b& hi5 in his
capacit& as P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is O%iental an/ that the >o%/s EA4ent' Phil.
National Ban2E >hich no> appea% on the chec2 E3hibit A >e%e not t&pe>%itten belo> his
si4natu%e >hen he si4ne/ the sai/ chec2 an/ /eli,e%e/ the sa5e to Ra5os. La&a assu%e/
the cou%t that the%e coul/ not be an& 5ista2e as to this. $o%' acco%/in4 to La&a' >hen he
issue/ chec2 in his capacit& as a4ent of the Misa5is O%iental a4enc& of the Philippine
National Ban2 the sai/ chec2 5ust be counte%si4ne/ b& the cashie% of the sai/ a4enc& F
not b& the p%o,incial au/ito%. -e also testifie/ that the sai/ chec2 >as issue/ b& hi5 in
his capacit& as p%o,incial t%easu%e% of Misa5is O%iental an/ that is >h& the sa5e >as
counte%si4ne/ b& P%o,incial Au/ito% $lo%es. The P%o,incial Au/ito% at that ti5e ha/ no
connection in an& capacit& >ith the Misa5is O%iental a4enc& of the Philippine National
Ban2. Plaintiff Montinola on the othe% han/ testifie/ that >hen he %ecei,e/ the chec2
E3hibit A it al%ea/& bo%e the >o%/s EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E belo> the si4natu%e of
La&a an/ the p%inte/ >o%/s EP%o,incial T%easu%e%E.
Afte% consi/e%in4 the testi5on& of the one an/ the othe%' the cou%t fin/s that the
p%epon/e%ance of the e,i/ence suppo%ts La&aCs testi5on&. *n the fi%st place' his testi5on&
>as co%%obo%ate/ b& the pa&ee M. =. Ra5os. But >hat %en/e%s 5o%e p%obable the
testi5on& of La&a an/ Ra5os is the fact that the 5one& fo% >hich the chec2 >as issue/
>as e3p%essl& fo% the use of the USA$$E of >hich Ra5os >as then /isbu%sin4 office%' so
5uch so that upon the /eli,e%& of the P8;;';;; in e5e%4enc& notes an/ the P#;;';;;
chec2 to Ra5os' La&a c%e/ite/ his /eposito%& accounts as p%o,incial t%easu%e% >ith the
co%%espon/in4 c%e/it ent%&. *n the no%5al cou%se of e,ents the chec2 coul/ not ha,e been
issue/ b& the ban2' an/ this is bo%ne b& the fact that the si4natu%e of La&a >as
counte%si4ne/ b& the p%o,incial au/ito%' not the ban2 cashie%. An/ then' too the%e is the
ci%cu5stance that this chec2 >as issue/ b& the p%o,incial t%easu%e% of Lanao to Ra5os
>ho %e:uisitione/ the sai/ fun/s in his capacit& as /isbu%sin4 office% of the USA$$E. The
chec2' E3hibit A is not >hat >e 5a& te%5 in business pa%lance' Ece%tifie/ chec2E o%
Ecashie%Cs chec2.E
Besi/es' at the ti5e the chec2 >as issue/' La&a al%ea/& 2ne> that Cebu an/ Manila >e%e
al%ea/& occupie/. -e coul/ not ha,e the%efo%e issue/ the chec2-as a ban2 e5plo&ee-
pa&able at the cent%al office of the Philippine National Ban2.
Upon the fo%e4oin4 ci%cu5stances the cou%t conclu/es that the >o%/s EA4ent' Phil.
National Ban2C belo> the si4natu%e of Ubal/o ?. La&a an/ the p%inte/ >o%/s EP%o,incial
T%easu%e%E >e%e a//e/ in the chec2 afte% the sa5e >as issue/ b& the P%o,incial T%easu%e%
of Misa5is O%iental.
$%o5 all the fo%e4oin4' >e 5a& safel& conclu/e as >e /o that the >o%/s EA4ent' Phil.
National Ban2E no> appea%in4 on the face of the chec2 AE3h. AB >e%e a//e/ o% place/ in
the inst%u5ent afte% it >as issue/ b& P%o,incial T%easu%e% La&a to M. =. Ra5os. The%e is
no %eason 2no>n to us >h& P%o,incial T%easu%e% La&a shoul/ issue the chec2 AE3h. AB as
a4ent of the Philippine National Ban2. Sai/ chec2 fo% P#;;';;; >as issue/ to co5plete
the pa&5ent of the othe% chec2 fo% P);;';;; issue/ b& the P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Lanao
to Ra5os' as pa%t of the a/,ance fun/s fo% the USA$$E in Ca4a&an /e Misa5is. The
balance of P8;;';;; in cash >as pai/ to Ra5os b& La&a f%o5 the fun/s' not of the ban2
but of the P%o,incial T%easu%&. Sai/ USA$$E >e%e bein4 finance/ not b& the Ban2 but b&
the Go,e%n5ent an/' p%esu5abl&' one of the %easons fo% the issuance of the e5e%4enc&
notes in Min/anao >as fo% this pu%pose. As al%ea/& state/' acco%/in4 to P%o,incial
T%easu%e% La&a' upon %ecei,in4 a %elati,el& consi/e%able a5ount of these e5e%4enc&
notes fo% his office' he /eposite/ P);;';;; of sai/ cu%%enc& in the Philippine National
Ban2 b%anch in Cebu' an/ that in issuin4 the chec2 AE3h. AB' he e3pecte/ to ha,e it
cashe/ at sai/ Cebu ban2 b%anch a4ainst his /eposit of P);;';;;.
The lo4ical conclusion' the%efo%e' is that the chec2 >as issue/ b& La&a onl& as P%o,incial
T%easu%e% an/ as an official of the Go,e%n5ent >hich >as un/e% obli4ation to p%o,i/e the
USA$$E >ith a/,ance fun/s' an/ not b& the Philippine National Ban2 >hich has no such
obli4ation. The ,e%& Anne3 C' 5a/e pa%t of plaintiffCs co5plaint' an/ late% int%o/uce/ in
e,i/ence fo% hi5 as E3hibit E states that La&a issue/ the chec2 Ein his capacit& as
P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is O%ientalE' ob,iousl&' not as a4ent of the Ban2.
No>' /i/ M. =. Ra5os a// o% place those >o%/s belo> the si4natu%e of La&a befo%e
t%ansfe%%in4 the chec2 to MontinolaJ Let us bea% in 5in/ that Ra5os befo%e his in/uction
into the USA$$E ha/ been >o%2in4 as assistant of T%easu%e% La&a as e3-officio a4ent of
the Misa5is O%iental b%anch of the Philippine National Ban2. Natu%all&' Ra5os 5ust
ha,e 2no>n the p%oce/u%e follo>e/ the%e as to the issuance of chec2s' na5el&' that >hen
a chec2 is issue/ b& the P%o,incial T%easu%e% as such' it is counte%si4ne/ b& the P%o,incial
Au/ito% as >as /one on the chec2 AE3hibit AB' but that if the P%o,incial T%easu%e% issues a
chec2 as a4ent of the Philippine National Ban2' the chec2 is counte%si4ne/ not b& the
P%o,incial Au/ito% >ho has nothin4 to /o >ith the ban2' but b& the ban2 cashie%' >hich
>as not /one in this case. *t is not li2el&' the%efo%e' that Ra5os ha/ 5a/e the inse%tion of
the >o%/s EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E afte% he %ecei,e/ the chec2' because he shoul/
ha,e %eali@e/ that follo>in4 the p%actice al%ea/& /esc%ibe/' the chec2 ha,in4 been issue/
b& La&a as P%o,incial T%easu%e%' an/ not as a4ent of the ban2' an/ since the chec2 bea%s
the counte%si4natu%e not of the Ban2 cashie% of the P%o,incial Au/ito%' the a//ition of the
>o%/s EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E coul/ not chan4e the status an/ %esponsibilit& of the
ban2. *t is the%efo%e 5o%e lo4ical to belie,e an/ to fin/ that the a//ition of those >o%/s
>as 5a/e afte% the chec2 ha/ been t%ansfe%%e/ b& Ra5os to Montinola. Mo%eo,e%' the%e
a%e othe% facts an/ ci%cu5stances in,ol,e/ in the case >hich suppo%t this ,ie>. Refe%%in4
to the 5i5eo4%aphe/ %eco%/ on appeal file/ b& the plaintiff-appellant' >e fin/ that in
t%ansc%ibin4 an/ cop&in4 the chec2' pa%ticula%l& the face of it AE3hibit AB in the
co5plaint' the >o%/s EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E no> appea%in4 on the face of the
chec2 un/e% the si4natu%e of the P%o,incial T%easu%e%' is 5issin4. Unless the plaintiff in
5a2in4 this cop& o% t%ansc%iption in the co5plaint co55itte/ a se%ious o5ission >hich is
/ecisi,e as fa% as the ban2 is conce%ne/' the infe%ence is' that at the ti5e the co5plaint
>as file/' sai/ ph%ase /i/ not appea% on the face of the chec2. That p%obabl& >as the
%eason >h& the ban2 in its 5otion to /is5iss /ate/ Septe5be% ' #(89' conten/e/ that if
the chec2 in :uestion ha/ been issue/ b& the p%o,incial t%easu%e% in his capacit& as a4ent
of the Philippine National Ban2' sai/ t%easu%e% >oul/ ha,e place/ belo> his si4natu%e the
>o%/s EA4ent of the Philippine National Ban2E. The plaintiff because of the alle4e/ loss
of the chec2' alle4e/l& attache/ to the co5plaint a photostatic cop& of sai/ chec2 an/
5a%2e/ it as Anne3 A. But in t%ansc%ibin4 an/ cop&in4 sai/ Anne3 A in his co5plaint' the
ph%ase EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E /oes not appea% un/e% the si4natu%e of the p%o,incial
t%easu%e%. Ie t%ie/ to ,e%if& this /isc%epanc& b& 4oin4 o,e% the o%i4inal %eco%/s of the
Cou%t of $i%st *nstance so as to co5pa%e the cop& of Anne3 A in the co5plaint' >ith the
o%i4inal Anne3 A' the photostatic cop&' but sai/ o%i4inal Anne3 A appea%s to be 5issin4
f%o5 the %eco%/. -o> it /isappea%e/ is not e3plaine/. Of cou%se' no> >e ha,e in the list
of e3hibit a photostatic cop& 5a%2e/ Anne3 A an/ E3hibit B' but acco%/in4 to the
5anifestation of counsel fo% the plaintiff /ate/ Octobe% #)' #(8!' sai/ photostatic cop&
no> 5a%2e/ Anne3 A an/ E3hibit B >as sub5itte/ on Octobe% #)' #(8!' in co5pliance
>ith the ,e%bal o%/e% of the t%ial cou%t. *t is the%efo%e e,i/ent that the Anne3 A no>
a,ailable is not the sa5e o%i4inal Anne3 A attache/ to the co5plaint in #(89.
The%e is one othe% ci%cu5stance' i5po%tant an/ >o%th nothin4. *f Anne3 A also 5a%2e/
E3hibit B is the photostatic cop& of the o%i4inal chec2 No. #<! pa%ticula%l& the face
the%eof AE3hibit AB' then sai/ photostatic cop& shoul/ be a faithful an/ accu%ate
%ep%o/uction of the chec2' pa%ticula%l& of the ph%ase EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E no>
appea%in4 un/e% the si4natu%e of the P%o,incial T%easu%e% on the face of the o%i4inal chec2
AE3hibit AB. But a 5inute e3a5ination of an/ co5pa%ison bet>een Anne3 A' the
photostatic cop& also 5a%2e/ E3hibit B an/ the face of the chec2' E3hibit A' especiall&
>ith the ai/ of a han/lens' sho> notable /iffe%ences an/ /isc%epancies. $o% instance' on
E3hibit A' the lette% A of the >o%/ EA4entE is to>a%/ the %i4ht of the tail of the be4innin4
lette% of the si4natu%e of Ubal/o ?. La&aD this sa5e lette% EAE ho>e,e% in E3hibit B is
/i%ectl& un/e% sai/ tail.
The lette% ENE of the >o%/ ENationalE on E3hibit A is un/e%neath the space bet>een
EP%o,incialE an/ ET%easu%e%ED but the sa5e lette% ENE is /i%ectl& un/e% the lette% E*E of the
>o%/ EP%o,incialE in E3hibit B.
The fi%st lette% EaE of the >o%/ ENationalE is un/e% ETE of the >o%/ ET%easu%e%E in E3hibit
AD but the sa5e lette% EaE in E3hibit EBE is 0ust belo> the space bet>een the >o%/s
EP%o,incialE an/ ET%easu%e%E.
The lette% E2E of the >o%/ EBan2E in E3hibit A is afte% the 4%een pe%pen/icula% bo%/e% line
nea% the lo>e% %i4ht han/ co%ne% of the e/4e of the chec2 AE3h. ABD this sa5e lette% E2E
ho>e,e%' on E3hibit B is on the ,e%& bo%/e% line itself o% e,en befo%e sai/ bo%/e% line.
The closin4 pa%enthesis EBE on E3hibit A is a little fa% f%o5 the pe%pen/icula% 4%een bo%/e%
line an/ appea%s to be /ouble instea/ of one sin4le lineD this sa5e EBE on E3hibit B
appea%s in a sin4le line an/ is %elati,el& nea%e% to the bo%/e% line.
The%e a%e othe% notable /isc%epancies bet>een the chec2 Anne3 A an/ the photostatic
cop&' E3hibit B' as %e4a%/s the %elati,e position of the ph%ase EA4ent' Phil. National
Ban2E' >ith the title P%o,incial T%easu%e%' 4i,in4 4%oun/ to the /oubt that E3hibit B is a
photostatic cop& of the chec2 AE3hibit AB.
Ie then ha,e the follo>in4 facts. E3hibit A >as issue/ b& La&a in his capacit& as
P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is O%iental as /%a>e% on the Philippine National Ban2 as
/%a>ee. Ra5os sol/ P<;';;; of the chec2 to En%i:ue P. Montinola fo% P(;';;; 1apanese
5ilita%& notes' of >hich onl& P8)';;; >as pai/ b& Montinola. The >%itin4 5a/e b&
Ra5os at the bac2 of the chec2 >as an inst%uction to the ban2 to pa& P<;';;; to
Montinola an/ to /eposit the balance to his ARa5osB c%e/it. This >%itin4 >as oblite%ate/
an/ in its place >e no> ha,e the suppose/ in/o%se5ent appea%in4 on the bac2 of the
chec2 AE3h. A-#B.
At the ti5e of the t%ansfe% of this chec2 AE3h. AB to Montinola about the last /a&s of
?ece5be%' #(88' o% the fi%st /a&s of 1anua%&' #(8)' the chec2 >hich' bein4 a ne4otiable
inst%u5ent' >as pa&able on /e5an/' >as lon4 o,e%/ue b& about K &ea%s. *t 5a&
the%efo%e be consi/e%e/' e,en then' a stable chec2. Of cou%se' Montinola clai5s that about
1une' #(88 >hen Ra5os suppose/l& app%oache/ hi5 fo% the pu%pose of ne4otiatin4 the
chec2' he AMontinolaB consulte/ P%esi/ent Ca%5ona of the Philippine National Ban2 >ho
assu%e/ hi5 that the chec2 >as 4oo/ an/ ne4otiable. -o>e,e%' P%esi/ent Ca%5ona on the
>itness stan/ flatl& /enie/ MontinolaCs clai5 an/ assu%e/ the cou%t that the fi%st ti5e that
he sa> Montinola >as afte% the Philippine National Ban2' of >hich he >as P%esi/ent'
%eopene/' afte% libe%ation' a%oun/ Au4ust o% Septe5be%' #(8)' an/ that >hen sho>n the
chec2 he tol/ Montinola that it >as stale. M. =. Ra5os also tol/ the cou%t that it is not
t%ue that he e,e% >ent >ith Montinola to see P%esi/ent Ca%5ona about the chec2 in #(88.
On the basis of the facts abo,e %elate/ the%e a%e se,e%al %easons >h& the co5plaint of
Montinola cannot p%ospe%. The inse%tion of the >o%/s EA4ent' Phil. National Ban2E >hich
con,e%ts the ban2 f%o5 a 5e%e /%a>ee to a /%a>e% an/ the%efo%e chan4es its liabilit&'
constitutes a 5ate%ial alte%ation of the inst%u5ent >ithout the consent of the pa%ties liable
the%eon' an/ so /ischa%4es the inst%u5ent. ASection #8 of the Ne4otiable *nst%u5ents
La>B. The chec2 >as not le4all& ne4otiate/ >ithin the 5eanin4 of the Ne4otiable
*nst%u5ents La>. Section < of the sa5e la> p%o,i/es that Ethe in/o%se5ent 5ust be an
in/o%se5ent of the enti%e inst%u5ent. An in/o%se5ent >hich pu%po%ts to t%ansfe% to the
in/o%see a pa%t onl& of the a5ount pa&able' . . . Aas in this caseB /oes not ope%ate as a
ne4otiation of the inst%u5ent.E Montinola 5a& the%efo%e not be %e4a%/e/ as an in/o%see.
At 5ost he 5a& be %e4a%/e/ as a 5e%e assi4nee of the P<;';;; sol/ to hi5 b& Ra5os' in
>hich case' as such assi4nee' he is sub0ect to all /efenses a,ailable to the /%a>e%
P%o,incial T%easu%e% of Misa5is O%iental an/ a4ainst Ra5os. Neithe% can Montinola be
consi/e%e/ as a hol/e% in /ue cou%se because section ) of sai/ la> /efines a hol/e% in
/ue cou%se as a hol/e% >ho has ta2en the inst%u5ent un/e% ce%tain con/itions' one of
>hich is that he beca5e the hol/e% befo%e it >as o,e%/ue. Ihen Montinola %ecei,e/ the
chec2' it >as lon4 o,e%/ue. An/' Montinola is not e,en a hol/e% because section #(# of
the sa5e la> /efines hol/e% as the pa&ee o% in/o%see of a bill o% note an/ Montinola is not
a pa&ee. Neithe% is he an in/o%see fo% as al%ea/& state/' at 5ost he can be consi/e%e/ onl&
as assi4nee. Neithe% coul/ it be sai/ that he too2 it in 4oo/ faith. As al%ea/& state/' he has
not pai/ the full a5ount of P(;';;; fo% >hich Ra5os sol/ hi5 P<;';;; of the ,alue of
the chec2. *n the secon/ place' as >as state/ b& the t%ial cou%t in its /ecision' Montinola
speculate/ on the chec2 an/ too2 a chance on its bein4 pai/ afte% the >a%. Montinola 5ust
ha,e 2no>n that at the ti5e the chec2 >as issue/ in Ma&' #(8' the 5one& ci%culatin4 in
Min/anao an/ the =isa&as >as onl& the e5e%4enc& notes an/ that the chec2 >as inten/e/
to be pa&able in that cu%%enc&. Also' he shoul/ ha,e 2no>n that a chec2 fo% such a la%4e
a5ount of P#;;';;; coul/ not ha,e been issue/ to Ra5os in his p%i,ate capacit& but
%athe% in his capacit& as /isbu%sin4 office% of the USA$$E' an/ that at the ti5e that
Ra5os sol/ a pa%t of the chec2 to hi5' Ra5os >as no lon4e% connecte/ >ith the
USA$$E but al%ea/& a ci,ilian >ho nee/e/ the 5one& onl& fo% hi5self an/ his fa5il&.
As al%ea/& state/' as a 5e%e assi4nee Montinola is sub0ect to all the /efenses a,ailable
a4ainst assi4no% Ra5os. An/' Ra5os ha/ he %etaine/ the chec2 5a& not no> collect its
,alue because it ha/ been issue/ to hi5 as /isbu%sin4 office%. As obse%,e/ b& the t%ial
cou%t' the chec2 >as issue/ to M. =. Ra5os not as a pe%son but M. =. Ra5os as the
/isbu%sin4 office% of the USA$$E. The%efo%e' he ha/ no %i4ht to in/o%se it pe%sonall& to
plaintiff. *t >as ne4otiate/ in b%each of t%ust' hence he t%ansfe%%e/ nothin4 to the plaintiff.
*n ,ie> of all the fo%e4oin4' fin/in4 no %e,e%sible e%%o% in the /ecision appeale/ f%o5' the
sa5e is he%eb& affi%5e/ >ith costs.
*n the p%a&e% fo% %elief containe/ at the en/ of the b%ief fo% the Philippine National Ban2
/ate/ Septe5be% 9' #(8(' >e fin/ this p%a&e%7
*t is also %espectfull& p%a&e/ that this -ono%able Cou%t %efe% the chec2' E3hibit A' to the
Cit& $iscalCs Office fo% app%op%iate c%i5inal action a4ainst the plaintiff-appellant if the
facts so >a%%ant.
Subse:uentl&' in a petition si4ne/ b& plaintiff-appellant En%i:ue P. Montinola /ate/
$eb%ua%& 9' #();' he as2e/ this Cou%t to allo> hi5 to >ith/%a> the o%i4inal chec2 AE3h.
AB fo% hi5 to 2eep' e3p%essin4 his >illin4ness to sub5it it to the cou%t >hene,e% nee/e/
fo% e3a5ination an/ ,e%ification. The ban2 on Ma%ch ' #(); oppose/ the sai/ petition on
the 4%oun/ that inas5uch as the appellantCs cause of action in this case is base/ on the
sai/ chec2' it is absolutel& necessa%& fo% the cou%t to e3a5ine the o%i4inal in o%/e% to see
the actual alte%ations suppose/l& 5a/e the%eon' an/ that shoul/ this Cou%t 4%ant the
p%a&e% containe/ in the ban2Cs b%ief that the chec2 be late% %efe%%e/ to the cit& fiscal fo%
app%op%iate action' sai/ chec2 5a& no lon4e% be a,ailable if the appellant is allo>e/ to
>ith/%a> sai/ /ocu5ent. *n ,ie> of sai/ opposition this Cou%t %esolution of Ma%ch "'
#();' /enie/ sai/ petition fo% >ith/%a>al.
Actin4 upon the petition containe/ in the ban2Cs b%ief al%ea/& 5entione/' once the
/ecision beco5es final' let the Cle%2 of Cou%t t%ans5it to the cit& fiscal the chec2 AE3h.
AB to4ethe% >ith all pe%tinent pape%s an/ /ocu5ents in this case' fo% an& action he 5a&
/ee5 p%ope% in the p%e5ises.
Mo%an' C.1.' Pa%as' $e%ia' Pablo' Ben4@on' Pa/illa' Tua@on' Re&es an/ Bautista An4elo'
11.' concu%.

You might also like