SMS Book 1
SMS Book 1
SMS Book 1
Safety management
system basics
Contents
Introduction
01
Why SMS?
01
02
04
05
05
07
08
09
Safety assurance
11
Safety promotion
15
16
17
18
19
References 25
2014 Civil Aviation Safety Authority. First published July 2012; fully revised December 2014 (2nd edition)
For further information visit www.casa.gov.au/sms
This work is copyright. You may download, display, print and reproduce this material in unaltered form only (retaining this notice) for your
personal, non-commercial use or use within your organisation. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, all other
rights are reserved. Requests for further authorisation should be directed to: Safety Promotion, Civil Aviation Safety Authority, GPO Box 2005
Canberra ACT 2601, or email safetypromotion@casa.gov.au
This kit is for information purposes only. It should not be used as the sole source of information and should be used in the context of other
authoritative sources.
The case studies featuring Bush Aviation and Training and Outback Maintenance Services are entirely fictitious. Any resemblance to actual
organisations and/or persons is purely coincidental.
01
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Introduction
This resource kit contains advisory material for
aviation operators and organisations. It provides
guidance on, or best practice examples of, various
safety management system (SMS) elements for you
to consider when you are implementing or updating
your SMS.
This kit is designed for small to medium-sized air
operators certificate (AOC) holders involved in
regular public transport operations, as well as for
approved maintenance organisations, but other
aviation organisations may also find it useful.
The broad principles apply to all operators and
organisations. The structure and content of an
SMS will essentially be the same for them all.
However, the detail will need to reflect the size and
complexity of the specific organisation, as well as
the risks unique to its location and operation. SMS
is scalable, so your system needs to reflect what
you do, your specific risks, and what you are doing
about them. Above all, the way you manage safety
needs to be systematic.
There are eight booklets in the SMS for Aviation
a practical guide resource kit.
This booklet:
1. Safety management system basics
and booklets 28
2. Safety policy and objectives
3. Safety risk management
4. Safety assurance
5. Safety promotion
6. Human factors
7. SMS for small, non-complex organisations
8. SMS in practice.
Why SMS?
Dr Tony Barrell, a former CEO of the UK Health
and Safety Executives Offshore Safety Division,
(the offshore petroleum safety regulator), who led
the development of the regulatory response to the
1988 Piper Alpha disaster, in which 167 men died,
observed:
02
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
03
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Evaluation Criteria
Sydney
Melbourne
Staff are satisfied with the way management Staff have little confidence that
management are serious about
address safety issues.
safety.
Safety reporting culture A total of 48 safety hazard reports are
submitted over the eight-month period. This
suggests staff confidence and commitment
to safety.
Positive action on
safety issues resulting
in some operational
cost savings
Based on a study conducted at the Sydney and Melbourne operational bases of Kendall Airlines by Edkins, G.D. (1998).
The INDICATE safety program: A method to proactively improve airline safety performance. Safety Science, 30: 275-295.
This story shows the vital role safety culture plays in the safety and operational
success of an organisation.
A small to medium-sized operator on a limited budget does not have to spend large
amounts of money to improve its safety culture.
In fact, implementing safety management programs will help to improve
operational safety, reducing inefficiencies and leading to reduced operating costs.
04
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Direct costs
There are obvious, easily measured, on-the-spot
costs. These mostly relate to physical damage,
and include things such as rectifying or replacing
equipment, or compensating for property damage
or injuries.
For example, the direct cost of damage from a
propeller strike on a light twin aircraft may range
from A$15,000 to $20,000 for overhaul and
engine strips. Recovery and clean-up costs for a
20-seat regional turbo prop aircraft are estimated
at $200,000 per aircraft.
Indirect costs
Indirect costs are usually higher than direct costs,
but are sometimes not as obvious and are often
delayed. Even a minor incident will incur a range
of indirect costs. These costs include:
Loss of business and damage to the reputation
of an organisation
Legal and damage claims
Increased insurance premiums
Loss of staff productivity
Recovery and clean-up
Cost of internal investigations
Loss of use of equipment
Cost of short-term replacement equipment.
As well as the direct costs of $15-20,000 in the
propeller strike on a light twin aircraft example
mentioned previously, indirect costs for aircraft
cross hire, rescue and ferry activities could add a
further $20,000.
The above figures suggest that an SMS is likely
to produce a number of business benefits, the
most obvious being a reduction in accidents
and incidents, and in the longer term a reduced
insurance rate. An effective SMS will also help
to create a more positive working environment,
resulting in better productivity and morale.
05
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
06
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
FLEXIBLE CULTURE
An organisation can
adapt in the face of hightempo operations or certain
kinds of danger - often shifting
from the conventional
hierarchical mode to a
flatter mode.
LEARNING
CULTURE
An organisation must
possess the willingness and
the competence to draw the
right conclusions from its safety
information system and
be willing to implement
major reforms.
JUST CULTURE
There is an
atmosphere of trust.
People are encouraged
(even rewarded) for providing
essential safety-related information,
but they are also clear about
where the line must be drawn
between acceptable
and unacceptable
behaviour.
INFORMED
CULTURE
Those who manage
and operate the system
have current knowledge
about the human, technical,
organisational and
environmental factors that
determine the safety of
the system
as a whole.
REPORTING CULTURE
An organisational climate
in which people are prepared
to report their errors and
near-misses.
07
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
ICAO framework
components of
an SMS
Safety assurance
Safety promotion.
As an ICAO member of the international state
safety program, Australia has added a number of
elements to the fundamental ICAO framework.
These include:
Managing contractors (third-party interfaces).
See booklet 2, page 10
The SMS implementation plan
See booklet 2, pages 30-31
Internal safety investigation
See booklet 4, pages 2-3
Flight data analysis program (if required).
The two key words here are safety and
management.
Safety: is the state in which the probability of harm
to persons or property is reduced to, and maintained
at, a level which is as low as reasonably practicable
(ALARP) through a continuing process of hazard
identification and reduction.
Management: requires planning, resourcing,
directing and controlling.
08
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Safety objectives
09
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
SMS implementation
1. Identifying hazards
2. Assessing risks and mitigating their potential to
cause harm.
To determine what controls you use to mitigate
risk, you apply the ALARP (as low as reasonably
practicable) principle. In other words, you mitigate
the risk to the point where the cost grossly
outweighs the benefit. However, while it has been
used for some time in risk mitigation, there are
limitations to the ALARP principle.
Risk management is simply a careful examination
of what could cause harm, so that you can weigh
up whether you have taken enough precautions, or
should do more to prevent harm.
Identifying hazards
A hazard is anything which may cause harm
to people, or damage to aircraft, equipment or
structures. Examples of aviation hazards are: bad
weather, mountainous terrain, wildlife activity near
an aerodrome, FOD, contaminated fuel, poor
workshop lighting and fatigue. You have to identify
and manage organisational hazards so they do not
compromise the safety of your operation.
Generally, the hazard exists now: while the risk
associated with that hazard might occur in the
future. A large number of white ibis at the landfill
centre adjacent to the aerodrome is a present
hazardthey are sizable birds. The future risk is
that if they are involved in a bird strike, they could
cause engine failure and an aircraft crash.
10
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Risk assessment
Risk is the chance (likelihood), high or low, that
somebody could be harmed by various hazards,
together with an indication of how serious
(consequence) the harm could be.
Dont overcomplicate the process. Many aviation
organisations know their hazards well and the
necessary control measures are easy to apply. If
you run a small organisation and you are confident
you understand what is involved, you can do the
assessment yourself.
Equipment, procedures,
organisation, eg.
Hazard
Identification
Risk analysis
probability
Risk analysis
severity
Risk assessment
and tolerability
Risk control/
mitigation
11
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
3. Safety assurance
Safety assurance involves establishing a
systematic process for assessing and recording an
organisations safety performance. This includes
activities such as internal safety investigation,
management of change, monitoring, analysis and
continuous improvement.
Organisational factor
Poor safety culture
Workplace condition
Fatigue
Unsafe act
Fails to report in sick,
misses NOTAM
Defences
12
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
13
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Hazards
Accident
According to the Swiss cheese model, some of the
holes in defences are due to errors (active failures)
made by employees who are typically on the
front line.
Other holes in the defences are caused by
organisational factors (latent conditions), or other
error-producing conditions in the workplace.
The Swiss cheese example suggests that no
defences are perfect. However, the critical task
in maintaining safety is to find the holes in the
defences, and build stronger and better layers of
defence.
The following airline safety incident illustrates the
Swiss cheese model:
14
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
15
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
4. Safety promotion
Under the ICAO SMS structure, safety promotion
is divided into two elements: safety communication
and safety training.
Effective safety promotion and training foster
awareness and understanding of the SMS
throughout the organisation, helping to create a
positive safety culture.
Safety training provides skills and knowledge, as
well as raising awareness of risk issues.
Safety communication sets the tone for individual
behaviour, giving a sense of purpose to safety
efforts. You need strong lines of communication at
all stages of your SMS implementation. Maintaining
your SMS requires ongoing communicationfrom
reporting to raising awareness of safety issues.
Both activities help the organisation to adopt a
culture that goes beyond merely avoiding accidents
or reducing the number of incidents. It becomes
more about doing the right thing at the right
time in response to both normal and emergency
situations. Safety communications and training
help to foster safety best practice.
16
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Toolkit
Index of toolkit items
Jargon busters abbreviations,
acronyms and definitions
References
18
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Booklet 1 Basics
Jargon busters
References.
19
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Jargon bustersabbreviations,
acronyms and definitions
Abbreviations
A
AC
Advisory circular
ALAR
Approach-and-landing accident
reduction
ALARP
ERP
ALoS
ESB
AME
AOC
AQF
B
BITRE
F
FAA
FDA
FDAP
FMAQ
FRMS
FTO
G
GAPAN Guild of Air Pilots and Air Navigators
CAAP
CAIR
CAO
CAP
CASA
CASR
ICAM
CDM
ICAO
CEO
IFR
CRM
IRM
CRMI
IRS
CRMIE
ISO
GIHRE
H
HF
Human factors
HMI
Human-machine interface
20
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
RPT
RRM
LAME
LOE
SAG
LOFT
SLA
LOS
SM
Safety manager
LOSA
SMM
SMS
SSAA
SOP
SRB
SSP
SWI
M
MEDA
MOS
Manual of standards
MOSA
MoU
Memorandum of understanding
N
NTS
O
OH&S
P
POH
Q
QA
Quality assurance
QMS
T
TEM
TNA
U
UT
University of Texas
V
VFR
W
WHS
21
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
Definitions
Accident: an occurrence associated with the
operation of an aircraft which takes place between
the time any person boards the aircraft with
intention of flight until such time as all such persons
have disembarked, in which:
a person is fatally or seriously injured1 as a
result of:
-- being in the aircraft, or
Notes
1. For statistical uniformity only, an injury resulting in death within
thirty days of the date of the accident is classified as a fatal injury
by ICAO
2. An aircraft is considered to be missing when the official search
has been terminated and wreckage has not been located.
22
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
23
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
24
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
25
SMS1 | Safety management system basics
References
CASA regulations and advisory
material
Civil Aviation Advisory Publication (CAAP) SMS-1(0)
2009 .
Civil Aviation Safety Regulation (CASR) Part 99
alcohol and other drugs.
Safety Behaviours: Human Factors for Pilots.
Civil Aviation Safety Authority, Australia. (2009).
Safety Behaviours: Human Factors for Engineers.
Civil Aviation Safety Authority, Australia.
(2013).
ICAO publications
Human factors, management and organization.
Human Factors Digest No. 10 ICAO, Montreal,
Canada. (1993).
ICAO Annex 19 Safety Management 1st edition.
ICAO Safety Management Manual (Document 9859)
3rd edition 2013.
Further reading
The INDICATE safety program: A method to
proactively improve airline safety performance.
Edkins, G.D. Safety Science, 30: pp 275-295. (1998).
What life raft? Edkins, G. D. Qantas Flight Safety,
Issue 2: Spring, pp5-9. Qantas Airways. Sydney,
(2001).
Safety at the Sharp End: a Guide to
Non-technical skills. Flin, R; OConnor,
P & Crichton, M. Ashgate (2008).
Culture at Work in Aviation and Medicine: National,
Organizational and Professional Influences.
Helmreich, R.L and Merritt, AC. Ashgate (1998).
Safety culture and human error in the aviation
industry: In search of perfection. Hudson, P.T.W.
in B. Hayward & A. Lowe (eds.) Aviation Resource
Management. Ashgate, UK. (2000).
Human Error. Reason, J. Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge (1992).
Managing the Risks of Organisational Accidents.
Reason, J. Ashgate, Aldershot, UK. (1997).
Managing Maintenance Error: a Practical Guide.
Reason, J & Hobbs, A. Ashgate (2003).
A Human Error Approach To Aviation Accident
Analysis: The Human Factors Analysis &
Classification System. Wiegmann, DA & Shappell,
SA. Ashgate (2003).
Follow CASA on
CASAbriefing
@CASAbriefing
www.casa.gov.au/sms