Model and Similut
Model and Similut
Model and Similut
Module 6 : Lecture 1
DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS
(Part I)
Overview
Many practical flow problems of different nature can be solved by using equations
and analytical procedures, as discussed in the previous modules. However, solutions
of some real flow problems depend heavily on experimental data and the refinements
in the analysis are made, based on the measurements. Sometimes, the experimental
work in the laboratory is not only time-consuming, but also expensive. So, the
dimensional analysis is an important tool that helps in correlating analytical results
with experimental data for such unknown flow problems. Also, some dimensionless
parameters and scaling laws can be framed in order to predict the prototype behavior
from the measurements on the model. The important terms used in this module may
be defined as below;
Dimensional Analysis: The systematic procedure of identifying the variables in a
physical phenomena and correlating them to form a set of dimensionless group is
known as dimensional analysis.
Dimensional Homogeneity: If an equation truly expresses a proper relationship among
variables in a physical process, then it will be dimensionally homogeneous. The
equations are correct for any system of units and consequently each group of terms in
the equation must have the same dimensional representation. This is also known as
the law of dimensional homogeneity.
Dimensional variables: These are the quantities, which actually vary during a given
case and can be plotted against each other.
Dimensional constants: These are normally held constant during a given run. But,
they may vary from case to case.
Pure constants: They have no dimensions, but, while performing the mathematical
manipulation, they can arise.
1
dimensional variables, g , S0 and V0 are the dimensional constants and arises due
2
to mathematical manipulation and is the pure constant.
p 1
- Bernoullis equation for incompressible flow is written as, + V 2 + gz =
C . Here,
2
p is the pressure, V is the velocity, z is the distance, is the density and g is the
acceleration due to gravity. In this case, the dimensional variables are p, V and z , the
1
dimensional constants are g , and C and is the pure constant. Each term in this
2
equation including the constant has dimension of L2 T 2 and hence it is
dimensionally homogeneous.
Buckingham pi Theorem
The dimensional analysis for the experimental data of unknown flow problems leads
to some non-dimensional parameters. These dimensionless products are frequently
referred as pi terms. Based on the concept of dimensional homogeneity, these
dimensionless parameters may be grouped and expressed in functional forms. This
idea was explored by the famous scientist Edgar Buckingham (1867-1940) and the
theorem is named accordingly.
Buckingham pi theorem, states that if an equation involving k variables is
dimensionally homogeneous, then it can be reduced to a relationship among ( k r )
In Eq. (6.1.1), it should be ensured that the dimensions of the variables on the left side
of the equation are equal to the dimensions of any term on the right side of equation.
Now, it is possible to rearrange the above equation into a set of dimensionless
products (pi terms), so that
1 = ( 2 , 3 .........., k r ) (6.1.2)
Determination of pi Terms
Several methods can be used to form dimensionless products or pi terms that arise in
dimensional analysis. But, there is a systematic procedure called method of repeating
variables that allows in deciding the dimensionless and independent pi terms. For a
given problem, following distinct steps are followed.
Step I: List out all the variables that are involved in the problem. The variable is any
quantity including dimensional and non-dimensional constants in a physical situation
under investigation. Typically, these variables are those that are necessary to describe
the geometry of the system (diameter, length etc.), to define fluid properties
(density, viscosity etc.) and to indicate the external effects influencing the system
(force, pressure etc.). All the variables must be independent in nature so as to
minimize the number of variables required to describe the complete system.
Step II: Express each variable in terms of basic dimensions. Typically, for fluid
mechanics problems, the basic dimensions will be either M , L and T or F , L and T .
Dimensionally, these two sets are related through Newtons second law ( F = m.a ) so
that F = MLT 2 e.g. = ML3 or = FL4T 2 . It should be noted that these basic
dimensions should not be mixed.
Step III: Decide the required number of pi terms. It can be determined by using
Buckingham pi theorem which indicates that the number of pi terms is equal to
( k r ) , where k is the number of variables in the problem (determined from Step I)
Step IV: Amongst the original list of variables, select those variables that can be
combined to form pi terms. These are called as repeating variables. The required
number of repeating variables is equal to the number of reference dimensions. Each
repeating variable must be dimensionally independent of the others, i.e. they cannot
be combined themselves to form any dimensionless product. Since there is a
possibility of repeating variables to appear in more than one pi term, so dependent
variables should not be chosen as one of the repeating variable.
Step V: Essentially, the pi terms are formed by multiplying one of the non-repeating
variables by the product of the repeating variables each raised to an exponent that will
make the combination dimensionless. It usually takes the form of xi x1a x2b x3c where
Illustration of Pi Theorem
Let us consider the following example to illustrate the procedure of determining the
various steps in the pi theorem.
Example (Pressure drop in a pipe flow)
Consider a steady flow of an incompressible Newtonian fluid through a long,
smooth walled, horizontal circular pipe. It is required to measure the pressure drop per
unit length of the pipe and find the number of non-dimensional parameters involved
in the problem. Also, it is desired to know the functional relation among these
dimensionless parameters.
Step I: Let us express all the pertinent variables involved in the experimentation
of pressure drop per unit length ( pl ) of the pipe, in the following form;
pl =f ( D, , , V ) (6.1.3)
where, D is the pipe diameter, is the fluid density, is the viscosity of the fluid
and V is the mean velocity at which the fluid is flowing through the pipe.
Step II: Next step is to express all the variables in terms of basic dimensions i.e.
M , L and T . It then follows that
p=
l ML2T 2 ; D= L; = ML3 ; = ML1T 1 ; V= LT 1 (6.1.4)
Step III: Apply Buckingham theorem to decide the number of pi terms required. There
are five variables (including the dependent variable pl ) and three reference
=
dimensions. Since, k 5=
and r 3 , only two pi terms are required for this problem.
Step IV: The repeating variables to form pi terms, need to be selected from the list
D, , and V . It is to be noted that the dependent variable should not be used as
one of the repeating variable. Since, there are three reference dimensions involved, so
we need to select three repeating variable. These repeating variables should be
dimensionally independent, i.e. dimensionless product cannot be formed from this set.
In this case, D, and V may be chosen as the repeating variables.
Step V: Now, first pi term is formed between the dependent variable and the repeating
variables. It is written as,
1 =pl D a V b c (6.1.5)
Since, this combination need to be dimensionless, it follows that
( ML ) ( L ) ( LT ) ( ML )
b c
2
T 2 1 3
a
= M 0 L0T 0 (6.1.6)
The exponents a, b and c must be determined by equating the exponents for each of
the terms M , L and T i.e.
For M : 1 + c = 0
For L : 2 + a + b 3c =0 (6.1.7)
For T : 2 b =0
The solution of this algebraic equations gives a =
1; b =
2; c =
1 . Therefore,
p D
1 = l 2 (6.1.8)
V
The process is repeated for remaining non-repeating variables with other additional
variable ( ) so that,
2 = .D d .V e . f (6.1.9)
Since, this combination need to be dimensionless, it follows that
( ML T ) ( L ) ( LT ) ( ML )
e f
1 1 d 1 3
= M 0 L0T 0 (6.1.10)
=
1
pl D
=
( ML T ) (=
L)
2 2
M LT 0 0 0
V 2 ( ML )( LT )
2
3 1
(6.1.13)
=
2
=
( ML T ) ( L=
)
1 1
M LT 0 0 0
V D ( ML )( LT ) ( L )
3 1
Step VII: Finally, the result of dimensional analysis is expressed among the pi terms
as,
D pl 1
= = (6.1.14)
V 2
V D Re
It may be noted here that Re is the Reynolds number.
Remarks
- If the difference in the number of variables for a given problem and number of
reference dimensions is equal to unity, then only one Pi term is required to describe
the phenomena. Here, the functional relationship for the one Pi term is a constant
quantity and it is determined from the experiment.
1 =Constant (6.1.15)
- The problems involving two Pi terms can be described such that
1 = ( 2 ) (6.1.16)
Here, the functional relationship among the variables can then be determined by
varying 2 and measuring the corresponding values of 1 .
Module 6 : Lecture 2
DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS
(Part II)
Gravity force: m g g L3
Surface tension force: L
Compressibility force: Ev A Ev L2
The notations used in Eq. (6.2.1) are given in subsequent paragraph of this section. It
may be noted that the ratio of any two forces will be dimensionless. Since, inertia
forces are very important in fluid mechanics problems, the ratio of the inertia force to
each of the other forces listed above leads to fundamental dimensionless groups.
Some of them are defined as given below;
Reynolds number ( Re ) : It is defined as the ratio of inertia force to viscous force.
Mathematically,
VL VL
=
Re = (6.2.2)
where V is the velocity of the flow, L is the characteristics length, , and are
the density, dynamic viscosity and kinematic viscosity of the fluid respectively. If
Re is very small, there is an indication that the viscous forces are dominant compared
to inertia forces. Such types of flows are commonly referred to as creeping/viscous
flows. Conversely, for large Re , viscous forces are small compared to inertial effects
and such flow problems are characterized as inviscid analysis. This number is also
used to study the transition between the laminar and turbulent flow regimes.
Euler number ( Eu ) : In most of the aerodynamic model testing, the pressure data are
a times the pressure coefficient ( c p ) is a also common name which is defined by same
manner. In the study of cavitations phenomena, similar expressions are used where,
p is the difference in liquid stream pressure and liquid-vapour pressure. This
dimensional parameter is then called as cavitation number.
Froude number ( Fr ) : It is interpreted as the ratio of inertia force to gravity force.
force. Mathematically,
V 2 L
We = (6.2.5)
where V is the velocity of the flow, L is the characteristics length descriptive of the
flow field, is the density of the fluid and is the surface tension force. This
number is taken as an index of droplet formation and flow of thin film liquids in
which there is an interface between two fluids. The inertia force is dominant
compared to surface tension force when, We 1 (e.g. flow of water in a river).
effects in a fluid flow and is defined as the ratio of inertia force to compressibility
force. Mathematically,
V V V
M= = = (6.2.6)
c dp Ev
d
where V is the velocity of the flow, c is the local sonic speed, is the density of the
fluid and Ev is the bulk modulus. Sometimes, the square of the Mach number is
V 2
= =
Ca M 2
(6.2.7)
Ev
Both the numbers are predominantly used in problems in which fluid compressibility
is important. When, M a is relatively small (say, less than 0.3), the inertial forces
induced by fluid motion are sufficiently small to cause significant change in fluid
density. So, the compressibility of the fluid can be neglected. However, this number is
most commonly used parameter in compressible fluid flow problems, particularly in
the field of gas dynamics and aerodynamics.
Strouhal number ( St ) : It is a dimensionless parameter that is likely to be important in
In addition, there are few other dimensionless numbers that are of importance
in fluid mechanics. They are listed below;
Parameter Mathematical expression Qualitative definition Importance
cp Dissipation
Prandtl number Pr = Heat convection
k Conduction
V2 Kinetic energy
Eckert number Ec = Dissipation
c p T0 Enthalpy
cp Enthalpy
Specific heat ratio = Compressible flow
cv Internal energy
Wall roughness
Roughness ratio Turbulent rough walls
L Body length
( T ) g L3 2 Buoyancy
Grashof number Gr = Natural onvection
2 Viscosity
Tw Wall temperature
Temperature ratio Heat transfer
T0 Stream temperature
p p Static pressure
Pressure coefficient Cp = Hydrodynamics,
(1 2 ) V Dynamic pressure
2
Aerodynamics
L Lift force
Lift coefficient CL = Hydrodynamics,Aero
(1 2 ) A V 2 Dynamic force
dynamics
D Drag force
Drag coefficient CD = Hydrodynamics,
(1 2 ) A V 2 Dynamic force
Aero dynamics
Since this equation applies to any system, governed by same variables and if the
behavior of a particular prototype is described by Eq. (6.2.9), then a similar
relationship can be written for a model.
1m = ( 2 m , 3m ,.......... nm ) (6.2.10)
The form of the function remains the same as long as the same phenomenon is
involved in both the prototype and the model. Therefore, if the model is designed and
operated under following conditions,
2m = 2 ; 3m = 3 ............ and nm =n (6.2.11)
Then it follows that
1 =1m (6.2.12)
Eq. (6.2.12) is the desired prediction equation and indicates that the measured value
of 1m obtained with the model will be equal to the corresponding 1 for the
prototype as long as the other pi terms are equal. These are called model design
conditions / similarity requirements / modeling laws.
Flow Similarity
In order to achieve similarity between model and prototype behavior, all the
corresponding pi terms must be equated to satisfy the following conditions.
Geometric similarity: A model and prototype are geometric similar if and only if all
body dimensions in all three coordinates have the same linear-scale ratio. In order to
have geometric similarity between the model and prototype, the model and the
prototype should be of the same shape, all the linear dimensions of the model can be
related to corresponding dimensions of the prototype by a constant scale factor.
Usually, one or more of these pi terms will involve ratios of important lengths, which
are purely geometrical in nature.
Dynamic similarity: When two flows have force distributions such that identical types
of forces are parallel and are related in magnitude by a constant scale factor at all
corresponding points, then the flows are dynamic similar. For a model and prototype,
the dynamic similarity exists, when both of them have same length-scale ratio, time-
scale ratio and force-scale (or mass-scale ratio).
In order to have complete similarity between the model and prototype, all the
similarity flow conditions must be maintained. This will automatically follow if all
the important variables are included in the dimensional analysis and if all the
similarity requirements based on the resulting pi terms are satisfied. For example, in
compressible flows, the model and prototype should have same Reynolds number,
Mach number and specific heat ratio etc. If the flow is incompressible (without free
surface), then same Reynolds numbers for model and prototype can satisfy the
complete similarity.
Model scales
In a given problem, if there are two length variables l1 and l2 , the resulting
requirement based on the pi terms obtained from these variables is,
l1m l2 m
= = l (6.2.13)
l1 l2
This ratio is defined as the length scale. For true models, there will be only one
length scale and all lengths are fixed in accordance with this scale. There are other
V
model scales such as velocity scale m = v , density scale m = , viscosity
V
scale m = etc. Each of these scales needs to be defined for a given problem.
Distorted models
In order to achieve the complete dynamic similarity between geometrically similar
flows, it is necessary to reproduce the independent dimensionless groups so that
dependent parameters can also be duplicated (e.g. same Reynolds number between a
model and prototype is ensured for dynamically similar flows).
In many model studies, dynamic similarity may also lead to incomplete similarity
between the model and the prototype. If one or more of the similarity requirements
are not met, e.g. in Eq. 6.2.9, if 2 m 2 , then it follows that Eq. 6.2.12 will not be
satisfied i.e. 1 1m . It is a case of distorted model for which one or more of the
similar requirements are not satisfied. For example, in the study of free surface flows,
Vl V
both Reynolds number and Froude number are involved. Then,
gl
Froude number similarity requires,
Vm V
= (6.2.14)
g m lm gl
If the model and prototype are operated in the same gravitational field, then the
velocity scale becomes,
Vm lm
= = l (6.2.15)
V l