Subantaruupa Ni
Subantaruupa Ni
Subantaruupa Ni
(-- )
- himanshu.pota@gmail.com
Abstract
With a little help from Panini, a method is proposed that makes it easier to remember a couple of
hundred -tables than one simple -table. The process is entirely mechanical and is based on
going through a few simple steps repeatedly. To speak or write in a new language, one needs a small but
sufficiently large subset of the language at ones command. Doing one -table at a time, forgetting it,
and then doing it again, is a never ending process that all the Sanskrit learners know well. This limitation
can be overcome by mastering a large subset of the language rapidly. Sanskrit learners are very fortunate
that Panini has made it possible to bite, chew, swallow, and digest a huge chunk of Sanskrit language in
one go. Please try this method and if you dont succeed, then in the words of ,
,
Introduction
The motivation to write this note has been provided by the small booklet: - (-
- . Pundits who know
- ), , , ,
Paninis Ashtadhyayi understand what means and the method of learning Ashtadhayayi. For
someone trying to enter the Panini system on their own, unless the motivation is clear, the entry becomes
difficult. This note is to help students who know a little Sanskrit and want to understand the Panini system.
This note is also helpful if one wants to memorise the -tables quickly with a near perfect recall.
My understanding of Panini is through the following three excellent books from Sri Aurobindo Ashrama.
1. , , , ,
- .
-
2. - (-- ), , , ,
.
- , .
3. , , , ,
I am a beginner and this note is to share with other beginners the idea that even with a little effort one can
go very far, and having tasted a bit of Panini one can continue to enjoy the beauty of the Sanskrit language.
This note tries to give a simple description of what Panini was up to. Panini first collected all the Sanskrit
words in use, prepared three lists of (raw) words, , and (with a few thousand words
in each of the lists)and made about 4000 rules to derive all the Sanskrit words (numbering in hundred of
thousands), from the three lists of raw words.
To understand or benefit from - it is crucial that the process followed by Panini is understood
well. First were the millions of Sanskrit words, Panini observed them and saw some patterns and used those
The Beginning 2
patterns to formulate the 4000 rules. To learn and appreciate Panini one must observe Sanskrit words first,
try to identify patterns, and make rules to derive the words. These rules can then be compared with the rules
made by Panini to do the same derivation. It is very likely that one would come up with a few rules that are
identical to the rules made by Panini and this will open up the mind to soak in the rest of Panini. This simple
exercise will give an insight into the overall motivation and the philosophy behind - and from
then on the learning journey will be a joy. Let us start on that journey.
Fortunate for us beginners, we dont have to observe millions of Sanskrit words to understand the
philosophy, there are smaller groups of words that have sufficient variety to enable us to develop our obser-
vation powers and need only a small subset of the 4000 rules to complete the derivation process. We begin
with a group of words which are divided into 25 subgroups. The collection of the -tables of these 25
subgroups is the starting point. We observe the character of these tables and then explore the making of the
rules to derive these -tables starting from raw words. Let the beginner observe the tables, as Panini
would have done, make rules on their own, and then compare it with how Panini has done it. Who knows
some beginners might go on to better Panini!
The -tables in this document are given for one entry in each of the 25 subgroups in the list below. All
the words in a subgroup follow the same set of rules, i.e., to obtain tables for , , , and only
one set of rules is necessary.
Abbreviations , , ,
stand for , ,
, respectively. Some links in this
document link to the tables in the document itself (in most pdf browsers, Alt + left-arrow can be used to go
back); there are some links to very helpful external websites as well.
() ( ) Name, , , () ( ) Wise, , , ,
() ( ) Birth, , , , , () () Ram, , , ,
() () Water,
() () Creeper, , , ,
() () Curd, , () () Sun, , , , ,
() () Honey, , , , , , () () Idea, , , , ,
() ( ) World, , , , , () () River, , , , ,
() ( ) Mind, , , , , () () Saint, , , , ,
() () Light, , , , () () Cow, , ,
() () Fruit, , , , , () () Bride, ,
() () Victorious, , ,
() () Father, , ,
() ( ) Wise, , , , , () Doer, , , ,
()
() ( ) River, , , , () ( )
Self, , ,
() ( ) Eating One, , , , ,
The Beginning
Now we will briefly have a look at how to observe -tables and what are the normal patterns. We will
first consider a simple example to concentrate on the elementary process of putting a raw word and suffixes
to form new words.
holds the same place in learning - as held by hello world in learning
software programming languages. So let us start with
The First Task 3
( )
Good Calculator
m
eans one who can count well. When we use i n a sentence, we have to use an appropriate form
from the
-table. For example,
(One who counts well goes) (He is looking at
the one who counts well)
(She is talking with the one who counts well)
(Salutations to the one who counts well) (Bring a paper from the one who counts well)
(This is the paper of the one who counts well) (There are many qualities
in the one who counts well) The seven cases used here are called the nominative, accusative, instrumental,
dative, ablative, possessive, and locative respectively. These cases are used in most languages but because
the words dont change their form as they change in Sanskrit, these cases go unobserved. Also prepositions
are used in modern languages to indicate different cases instead of modifying the word itself as is seen in
the 21 forms in the
-table.
The Second Task 4
Three terms are used in describing the application of the 21 in the above table: , , and,
| The thing () before the
is called a ; the word before the following ,
which start with a vowel, , , , , ,
, are called
; for and the five
are called and for
and
are called .
The terms , , and, are created by Panini because it is easy to identify patterns based on these
groupings of the 21 | Please keep these groupings in mind as you work through remembering the
-tables. These three groups are colour coded.
)
( (First Cut)
Before we see Paninis solution let us observe the difference between the table one would obtain by using
the first rule, as shown above, and the actual -table. There are two forms in each of the five cells (1.2,
2.2. 7.1, 8.1, 8.1) and for our initial discussion we will concentrate only on the first form. The notation used
for each cell is n.m, where n 1, . . . , 7 (corresponding to ... ), and m 1, 2, 3 (corresponding to
singular, dual, and plural).
A few differences between the first cut -table
and the correct -table are:
1. Starting from the 1.1 entry (instead of ), the entries in 1.2, 1.3, 2.1, 2.2, 2.3 are very different.
2. The in the ending missing in 1.2, 2.2, 3.1, 4.1, 5.1, 6.1, 7.1, 6.2, 6.3, 7.2.
of is
is
3. The last of missing in 1.1, 2.1, 3.2, 3.3, 4.2, 4.3, 5.2, 5.3, 7.3.
With these observations we form three sets of cells called An , Bn , and Cn , where,
An = {1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 2.1, 2.2, 2.3},
Bn = {1.2, 2.2, 3.1, 4.1, 5.1, 6.1, 7.1, 6.2, 6.3, 7.2}, and
Cn = {1.1, 2.1, 3.2, 3.3, 4.2, 4.3, 5.2, 5.3, 7.3}.
Based on our observations we can now make the following rules:
1. Modify cells in An of the -table
with the corresponding cells in the )-table.
(
2. Drop in the of for cells in Bn and then add the entries in the -table.
for
3. Drop of cells in Cn and then add the entries in the -table.
Apply all the three rules above and see if you can get the correct -table below.
Your Task 5
)
() ( Name
(
)
-
()
-
()
-
- -
)
() ( Birth Water
() ()
- -
Your Task
1. Memorise the -table. Recite the correct table 2-3 times loudly, if possible in a rhythm.
2. Get a new 64-page exercise book. Reserve two pages for each of the following tables (one from each
item in the following list).
3. Using the raw word and the -table, write down the First Cut table.
4. Copy the correct table on that page below the First Cut table.
5. Highlight the cell entries that are different between the two tables and identify if there is a pattern
among the entries that differ.
6. Suggest rules to obtain the tables using the raw word + -table.
7. By observing the difference in tables try to memorise all the 25 tables.
Your Task 6
Curd
() () )
() ( Light
-
-
() () Honey
Fruit
() ()
() ( )
World
() ( )
Victorious
-
-
-
)
() ( Mind
() ( )
Intelligent
(1)
Your Task 7
() ( ) River () () Creeper
() ( )
The Eating One Sun
() ()
)
() ( Wise () () Idea
-
-
-
-
Ram
() () () () River
Your Task 8
() ()
Saint Father
() ()
() () Cow Doer
() ()
-
-
-
-
() () Bride )
() ( Self
9
The sutras used to derive the above tables are given below. The red part in the sutras is the The
description with the sutras below provide only hints on their applicability. After you memorise the above
25 tables use the following sutras to consolidate the memorised material.
A full derivation normally uses multiple sutras; to see this process please see books like ,
- , or visit http://lanover.com/lan/sanskrit/
, , ,
subanta.html that can be used to obtain a complete derivation of the entire -table. The site http://
avg-sanskrit.org/documents/ has many documents which have complete derivations of many words.
(1) 7-1-23
(2)
6-1-68
(3) 1-2-41
called
Sutra (3) says that a with only one letter like is
(4) 6-4-8
(5) 6-4-12
(6) 6-4-13
(7) 7-1-94
Sutra (7) is used to derive: ; sutra (7) brings in as an for and then sutra (4) make the
thus getting the form and
(8) 6-4-11
10
Sutra (8) is used to derive: | Sutra (8) is to make for all the words listed in the
sutra for all the positions while sutra (7) works only for {1.1}.
(9) 6-4-14
(10) 7-1-70
8-2-23
(11)
(12) 7-1-24
(13) 6-1-107
(14) 1-3-4
7-3-110
(15)
(16)
8-3-59
Sutra (16) is used to derive:
6-4-134
(17)
(18)
6-4-137
, because of b efore
Sutra (18) stops the dropping of in,
(19) 7-3-120
Sutra (19) is used to derive:
(20) 1-4-7
(21) 7-1-75
11
Sutra (21) tells that the final vowel in the words , , , and is replaced by from {3.1}
onwards when the starts with a vowel. This means that these -words take forms like the
words from {3.1} onwards; remember that the final disappears for {3.2, 3.3, 4.2, 4.3, 5.2, 5.3, 7.3}
(22) 7-1-12
7-3-105
(23)
(24)
7-1-73
Sutra (24) is used to derive:
(25) 7-3-111
(26) 7-3-113
(27) 7-3-112
(28) 1-4-3
Sutra (28) is a definition () sutra and says that the words that end in either or or are given
, some examples:
(29) 1-4-6
6-1-90
(30)
(31) 7-1-13
7-3-102
(32)
(33) 6-1-110
12
6-1-111
(34)
(35) 8-2-24
(36) 7-3-116
(37) 7-3-119
(38) 2-3-47
8-2-8
(39)
2-3-49
(40)
6-1-69
(41)
7-3-108
(42)
7-3-106
(43)
(44) 7-3-107
7-1-19
(45)
Sutra (45) is used to derive:
(46) 7-1-18
13
6-1-102
(47)
7-3-104
(48)
(49)
6-1-105
Sutra (49) stops the application of sutra (47) and results in says that this is not significant
for as sutra (47) would have given the same final result but there are situations where this sutra (49) is
needed. In the derivation of it is normally included to ensure that the right process is being followed.
7-3-109
(50)
7-1-20
(51)
are
,
Sutra (51) tells that for replaced by
1-1-42
(52)
7-1-72
(53)
(54) 6-4-10
(55)
8-3-58
here changes
Sutra (55) is a part of the w to
(56) 6-1-103
Sutra (56) is used to derive:
8-2-7
(57)
Sutra (57) is used to derive:
(58) 7-1-9
14
(59) 7-3-103
(60) 7-1-54
Sutra (60) applies to all the words with a vowel ending and makes the effective {6.3} for the vowel
ending words as i nstead Sutra (60) is used to derive: , , , , , ,
, ,
| After sutra (60), sutra (61) is applied to the words with the endings to get the final
form.
(61) 6-4-3
8-3-16
(62)
(63) 7-1-17
(64) 7-1-14
(65) 7-1-15
7-1-52
(66)
(67) 7-3-114
7-2-102
(68)
(69) 7-2-106
1-1-63
(70)
15
(71) 7-2-103
Sutra (71) says that b ecomes for the purposes of obtaining the -tables.
(72) 7-1-53
(73) 7-2-99
(74) 7-2-100
(75) 6-4-4
(76) 7-1-98
7-1-55
(77)
Sutra (77) is used to derive:
(78) 7-1-22
(79) 6-4-7
Sutra (79) is used to derive:
(80) 6-4-79
6-4-82
(81)
, ,
Sutra (81) is used to derive: Please note that
188 More 16
188 More
Like You
() () Eye
() ()
-
-
Husband
() ()
Great Intelligence
() ()
Friend
() ()
() () Intelligence
188 More 17
() () Prosperity () () Brahma
-
-
-
-
-
() () Woman () () Earth
- -
-
-
-
-
-
Friend
() () Man
() ()
-
Many
() () () () Sister
-
-
- -
- -
-
188 More 18
() () Mother Moon
() ()
Giver
() () () () Boat
-
-
-
- -
- -
-
Wealth
() () )
() ( East
Cow
() () () )
( Cloud
-
188 More 19
() () Speech
-
() ( ) Garland
-
-
(
() ) Praiseworthy
() ( ) Saffron
() ( )
Trader
-
() () Lizard
-
-
() ( )
Sovereign
-
-
() ( )
Wind
-
() ( )
Priest
188 More 20
() ( ) World () ( )
Great
() ( )
The Giving One
-
-
- () () Winter
-
() ( ) The Troubling One
-
-
-
-
() ( ) The Cooking One
Foot
() ()
() ( )
Great
- Heart
() ()
() ( )
Tooth
()
() Kind-hearted
-
188 More 21
() ( ) Firewood () ( )
Indra
-
)
() ( Youth
-
() ( ) Hunger
() ( )
Dog
)
() ( King
() ( )
Horse
)
() ( Indra
188 More 22
)
() ( Head
() )
( With Good Qualities
-
-
- )
() ( Traveller
)
() ( Smaller
)
() ( Day
-
-
)
() ( Greatness
-
-
-
)
() ( Imminent
-
)
() ( Temporary
-
188 More 23
() () Water () ( ) City
() () Splendour () ( ) Sky
() ( )
Pond
() ( ) Direction
-
-
() ( ) Voice () ( )
House
188 More 24
() ( )
Like You () ( )
Dislike
() ( )
Like You
() () Rain
-
-
() ( ) Night
)
() ( Learned
- - - -
- - - -
- - - -
--
-
() ( )
Like That
)
() ( Younger
-
() )
( Very Lustrous
188 More 25
() () Fairy )
() ( Better
)
() ( Brahma () ( )
Person
)
() ( Moon
)
() ( Arm
-
)
() ( Month
() () Light
-
188 More 26
() () Wish
() () Shoe
)
() ( Oblation
() () Lotus
() )
( Body
()
- -
-
-
- -
- -
-
() ( ) Standing
()
-
-
-
- -
Licking
() ()
- - -
188 More 27
() ( )
That
-
-
() ( ) This
- - -
( )
() ( ) That
() ( )
This
- -
-
-
-
() ( )
That
() () This
- - -
-
-
-
() ( )
This
() () This
-
-
- - -
-
- )
() ( That
-
() ( ) This
- - -
-
188 More 28
() ( )
What
() () This
() ( ) What
)
() ( This
-
() ( )
Who
() ( ) What
-
All
() ()
() () Who
() () All
() () Who
-
188 More 29
() ( ) Another
() () All
-
() ( )
You
() ( ) Other
-
() () Before
-
() ( ) You
-
-
-
() ( ) You () () Before
() ( )
Another
() () Before
188 More 30
-
, )
() -- (,
() ( ) Other
() ( ) Other
() () One
() ( )
Other
() () Two
() () Both
() () Three
Both
() ()
() ( ) Four
188 More 31
- -
- -
- -
-
-
() - (), ( )
80-90-100
-
() - ,
( , )
5-6-7
- -
- -
-
- -
-
-
-
( 103 ), ( 104 ), ( 105 ), ( 106 ),
() (107 ), ( 108 ), ( 109 ), ( 1010 ),
(1011 ), (1012 ), () (1013 ), ()
(10 ), ( 10 ), ( 10 ), ( 10 )|
14 15 16 17
() -
- ,
( , )
8-9-10
() () Descendant of Ishvaku
-
-
-
-
----
-
A name
() ()
-
() -- ( ) 20-30-40
-
-
-
-
Descendant of Uduloman
() ()
() -- () 50-60-70
----
188 More 32
Warrior
() ()
-
() () Old Age
Swift Antelope
() ()
- -
- - -
-
-
-
- -
-
- -
- --
() () Ageless
Jackal
() ()
- -
- -
- -
-
-
- () ( )
Eastern
- -
- -
Frog
() ()
)
() ( Western
A Name
() ()
188 More 33
() ( )
Northern
() ( ) United
() ( )
Following
()
() Having Good Feet
)
() ( Horizontally
() ( ) Sun
)
() ( Indra
() ( ) Bright
-
-
) -
() ( Sage
)
() ( Summer
188 More 34
-
() ()
Indra
() ( ) Horse
() ( ) Indra
() () One who Milks
)
Shukaacharya
() (
() () One who bears hatred
--
)
(
-
() ( )
Time
- -
- -
- -
-
-
() ( ) Door () ( ) Eastern
-
)
() ( Western
() () Flame
-
)
() ( Following
-
)
() ( Northern
() () Companion
-
)
() ( Horizontal
() () A Metre -
188 More 36
() ( ) Eastern -
-
-
-
- One with a good Ox
() ()
)
() ( Western
-
-
God
() ()
)
() ( Following
- -
- -
-
-
-
-
- -
-
)
() ( Northern - -
- -
-
)
() ( Horizontal
-
(Ordinals)
() (Ordinals)
,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
(Ordinals) 38
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
(Ordinals) 39
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
,
Word Index 40
Word Index
In the list below the first 25 words are in the order in which they are listed in the --
book. After that words with regular declension are organised in the Devanagari alphabetical order with
respect to their endings; this is followed by pronouns and then words for numbers; finally special words are
listed as per the book. Remember, in most pdf viewers Alt + left-arrow takes back after visiting
a link. The number to the left of the words is its -table number.
The words and comments in the list below are taken from various sources; mainly from the two books: -
- and .
() ( ) Name, , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , , , () () Father, , , ,
() () Birth, , , ; , ,
, , , , Doer, , , , ,
() ()
() () Water, except the fol- () () Ram, , , , , , , , , , -
lowing four, , , , and , , , , , , ,
, ,
, all have the , , , , , , , , , ,
same declension as , , , , , ,
() () Curd, , , and , , , , , ,
,
() () Honey, , , , () () Creeper, , , () () Self, , ,
, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
() ( ) World , , , , , () () Like You, ,
() () Mind, , , () () Sun, , , , , , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , , , , , , () () Protector of the
, , , , , , , , , , , , , Universe, , , , ,
, , , , , ,
() () Light, , , , , , , , () () Husband; and
, , - , , , , are irregular bases in . The
, compound words ending with
() () Fruit, , , , () () Idea, , , , however are declined like , e.g.,
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , , , , , ; , () () Friend
() ( ) Victorious , , etc., have two forms in () () Eye
() () Intelligent, , the singular of , , , and () () Clean, for
, , , , , and adjectives,
, , , , ,
() () River, , , the corresponding forms
, ; ,
, , , , , , , are used in , , , and
, , , , , , , ,
, , , , , , () () Great Intelligence
, , , , , () () Intelligence, ,
() () River, , , , , , , ,
, , () () Saint, , , , () () Prosperity;
() () The Eating One, , , , , , , , , - - , , ,
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , () () Cow, , , , ,
, , ,
() () Wise, , , () () Bride, , , , ,
Word Index 41
------ () () Lizard () ( ) Smaller
() () Wind, , , () () Greatness,
, , , (), , , , ,
() () Woman () () World; , , , ,
() () Friend , ---
() () Many, , , ,
, () ( ) Temporary
, ()
() With Good Quali-
() () Brahma, , , , ties, , ,
() () The Giving One, () ( ) Traveller
() () Earth , , , , ,
() () Day
() () Man ; ( () ( ) Imminent
() () Sister ) () () Water
() () Mother, , () () Splendour
() () Giver; , , , () ( ) The Troubling One, () ( ) Pond
, , etc., are used as adjec-
; () () Voice
tives and so they take forms in all () ( ) City,
three genders, here the () ( ) Sky
forms are given. () ( ) Direction
() () Wealth () ( ) The Cooking One, () ( ) House
() () Cow; , , , , , ,
() () Like You, ,
and words decline , , , , , , , , , ;
like the () and , , ; , ,
() forms, respectively; , ; ,
, , , , ;
----
() ( ) Like You
() () Moon () ( ) Night
() () Boat () ( ) Great () ( ) Like That
() ( ) East () () Great
() () Very Lustrous
() () Cloud, () ( ) Tooth () ( ) Dislike
but , , , and () () Winter () () Rain
form differently as they are de- () () Foot () () Learned; ,
rived from the () () Heart , , ,
() () Speech, , , () () Kind-hearted, ,
, , ,
, ; , , , , () ( ) Younger, ,
, , , , , , ,
() ( ) Firewood, , ,
- , , , ,
() () , ()
() () Hunger
() , () ( ) () () King; () () Fairy;
, () ()
() ()
() () ( ) Indra () () Brahma
() () Praiseworthy () ( ) Indra () () Moon, ,
() ( ) Trader () () Youth; , , , ,
() () Sovereign, , , , , ,
,
() ( ) Priest, ,
, () ( ) Dog () ( ) Month
, () ( ) Horse () ( ) Better
() () Garland () () Head () ( ) Person
() ( ) Saffron
Word Index 42
Useful Resources
Document Home
The latest copy of this document can be downloaded from http://sanskritdocuments.org/learning_
tools/SubantaRuupaNi.pdf, the LATEX file used to create the pdf is at: http://sanskritdocuments.
org/learning_tools/SubantaRuupaNi.tex. This document is housed with many other wonderful San-
skrit learning documents at: http://sanskritdocuments.org/learning_tools/.