Time Saving Design Aids
Time Saving Design Aids
Time Saving Design Aids
The following example illustrates the design methods presented in ACI 318-05 and IBC 2003. Unless
otherwise noted, all referenced table, figure, and equation numbers are from these books. The example
presented here is for Two-Way Post-Tensioned Design.
Loads:
Framing Dead Load = selfweight
Superrimposed Dead Load = 25 psf partitions, M/E, misc.
Live Load = 40 psf residential
2 hour fire-rating
Materials:
Concrete: Normal weight 150 pcf
f'c = 5,000 psi
f'ci = 3,000 psi
Loading
DL = Selfweight = (8in)(150 pcf) = 100 psf
SIDL = 25 psf
LLo = 40 psf
KLL = 1
LL = 0.83 LLo = 33 psf
Interior bay: AT = (25 ft)(30 ft) = 750 ft2
KLL = 1
LL = 0.80 LLo = 32 psf
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 2 of 9
Tendon profile:
Parabolic shape;
For a layout with spans of similar length, the tendons will be typically be located at the highest
allowable point at the interior columns, the lowest possible point at the midspans, and the neutral
axis at the anchor locations. This provides the maximum drape for load-balancing.
Neutral
Axis
A B C D
L1 L2 L3
wb = 0.75 wDL = 0.75 (100 psf)(25 ft) = 1,875 plf = 1.875 k/ft
For this example, continue the force required for the end spans into the interior span and check the
amount of load that will be balanced:
wb/wDL = 94%; This value is less than 100%; acceptable for this design.
Interior Span
ftop = [(-101ft-k + 65ft-k)(12)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= -135 - 221 = -356 psi compression < 0.60 f'ci = 1800 psi ok
fbot = [(101ft-k - 65ft-k)(12)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= 135 - 221 = -86 psi compression < 0.60 f'ci = 1800 psi ok
End Span
ftop = [(-172ft-k + 110ft-k)(12)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= -232 - 221 = -453 psi compression < 0.60 f'ci = 1800 psi ok
fbot = [(172ft-k - 110ft-k)(12)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= 232 - 221 = 11 psi tension < 3√f'ci = 164 psi ok
Support Stresses
ftop = (+MDL - Mbal)/S - P/A
fbot = (-MDL + Mbal)/S - P/A
Interior Span
ftop = [(-101ft-k - 27ft-k+ 65ft-k)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= -236 - 221 = -457 psi compression < 0.45 f'c = 2250 psi ok
fbot = [(101ft-k + 27ft-k - 65ft-k)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= 236 - 221 = 15 psi tension < 6√f'c = 424 psi ok
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 7 of 9
End Span
ftop = [(-172ft-k - 45ft-k + 110ft-k)(12)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= -401 - 221 = -622 psi compression < 0.45 f'c = 2250 psi ok
fbot = [(172ft-k + 45ft-k - 110ft-k)(12)(1000)]/(3200 in3) - 221psi
= 401 - 221 = 180 psi tension < 6√f'c = 424 psi ok
Support Stresses
ftop = (+MDL + MLL - Mbal)/S - P/A
fbot = (-MDL - MLL + Mbal)/S - P/A
Ultimate Strength
At midspan: Mu = 1.2 (172ft-k) + 1.6 (45ft-k) + 1.0 (10.5 ft-k) = 289 ft-k
At support: Mu = 1.2 (-240ft-k) + 1.6 (-64ft-k) + 1.0 (21 ft-k) = -370 ft-k
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 8 of 9
Determine minimum bonded reinforcement: to see if acceptable for ultimate strength design.
Interior supports:
Acf = max. (8in)[(30ft + 27ft)/2, 25ft]*12
As, min = 0.00075(2,736 in2)
= 2.05 in2
= 11 - #4 Top (2.20 in2)
Exterior supports:
Acf = max. (8in)[(27ft/2), 25ft]*12
As, min = 0.00075(2,400 in2)
= 1.80 in2
= 9 - #4 Top (1.80 in2)
Must span a minimum of 1/6 the clear span on each side of support (ACI 18.9.4.2)
At least 4 bars required in each direction (ACI 18.9.3.3)
Place top bars within 1.5h away from the face of the support on each side (ACI 18.9.3.3)
= 1.5 (8 in)
= 12 in
Maximum bar spacing is 12” (ACI 18.9.3.3)
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 9 of 9
At supports
d = 8” - 3/4 ” - 1/4” = 7”
fps = 184,000psi + 1634(7”) = 195,438psi
a = [(2.20 in2)(60 ksi) + (3.06 in2)(195ksi)]/[(0.85)(5ksi)(25ft*12)] = 0.57
ϕMn = 0.9 [(2.20 in2)(60 ksi) + (3.06 in2)(195ksi)][7” - (0.57)/2]/12
= 0.9 (728k)(6.72in)/12
= 367 ft-k < 370ft-k Reinforcement for ultimate strength requirements governs
When reinforcement is provided to meet ultimate strength requirements, the minimum lengths must also
conform to the provision of ACI 318-05 Chapter 12. (ACI 18.9.4.3)
This is a simplified hand calculation for a post-tensioned two-way plate design. A detailed example can be
found in the PCA Notes on ACI 318-05 Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete.
The following example illustrates the Example Building
design methods
TIME SAVING DESIGNpresented
AIDS in the article Page 1 of 12
“Timesaving Design Aids for Reinforced Below is a partial plan of a typical floor in a
Concrete,
Two-Way PartSlabs 2: Two-way Slabs,” by cast-in-place reinforced concrete building. In
David A. Fanella, which appeared in the this example, an interior strip of a flat
October 2001 edition of Structural plate infloor
The following example illustrates the design methods presented system
the PCA is designed
book “Simplified and- detailed
Design
Reinforced magazine.
Engineer Unless
Concrete Buildings otherwise
of Moderate for third
Size and Height” the edition.
effectsUnless
of gravity
otherwiseloads
noted, according
all
referenced table, figure, and equation
noted, all referenced table, figure, and numbers are from that book.
to ACI 318-99.
equation
Example numbers
Building are from that article.
Below is a partial plan of a typical floor in a cast-in-place reinforced concrete building. In this example,
an interior strip of a flat plate floor system is designed and detailed for the effects of gravity loads
according to ACI 318-05.
Design strip
24c-0s
Design Data
Materials
• Concrete: normal weight (150 pcf), 3/4-in. maximum aggregate, f’c = 4,000 psi
• Mild reinforcing steel: Grade 60 (fy = 60,000 psi)
Loads
• Superimposed dead loads = 30 psf
• Live load = 50 psf
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 2 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
From Fig. 4-3, minimum thickness h per ACI Table 9.5(c) = ln/30 = 8.9 in.
Use Fig. 1-8 to determine h based on shear requirements at interior column assuming a 9 in. slab:
A = 24 x 20 = 480 ft2
Since all requirements are satisfied, the Direct Design Method can be used.
Division of the total panel moment Mo into negative and positive moments, and then column and middle
strip moments, involves the direct application of the moment coefficients in Table 4-2.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 3 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
*
Column strip width b = (20 x 12)/2 = 120 in.
*
Middle strip width b = (24 x 12) – 120 = 168 in.
**
Use average d = 9 – 1.25 = 7.75 in.
†
As = Mu /4d where Mu is in ft-kips and d is in inches
‡
Min. As = 0.0018bh = 0.0162b; Max. s = 2h = 18 in. or 18 in. (Sect. 13.3.2)
+
For maximum spacing:120/18 = 6.7 spaces, say 8 bars
168/18 = 9.3 spaces, say 11 bars
Check slab reinforcement at exterior column for moment transfer between slab and column.
b1 /b2 = 0.86
*The provisions of Sect. 13.5.3.3 may be utilized; however, they are not in this example.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 4 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
Provide the required 7-No. 4 bars by concentrating 7 of the column strip bars (11-No. 4) within the 47 in.
slab width over the column.
For 7-No. 4 within 47 in. width: 47/7 = 6.7 in. < 18 in. O.K.
For 4-No. 4 within 120 – 47 = 73 in. width: 73/4 = 18.25 in. > 18 in.
Add 1 additional bar on each side of the 47 in. strip; the spacing becomes 73/6 = 12.2 in. < 18 in. O.K.
Reinforcement details at this location are shown in the figure on the next page.
Check the combined shear stress at the inside face of the critical transfer section.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 5 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
vu = Vu + γ vMu
Ac J/c
= 64.0 kips
When the end span moments are determined from the Direct Design Method, the fraction of unbalanced
moment transferred by eccentricity of shear must be 0.3Mo = 0.3 x 248.5 = 74.6 ft-kips (Sect. 13.6.3.6).
γv = 1 – γf = 1 – 0.62 = 0.38
c2 /c1 = 1.0
c1 /d = 20/7.75 = 2.58
bo /d = (2b1 + b2)/d
βc =1
9” slab is OK
Reinforcement Details
The figures below show the reinforcement details for the column and middle strips. The bar lengths are
determined from Fig. 13.3.8 of ACI 318-05.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 6 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
The PCA computer program pcaSlab can be used to expedite the design of different slab systems.
The program covers wide range of two-way slab systems and can be used for more complex slab layouts.
The output of the program for the slab in the example is shown in the following pages.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 7 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
Z X
Frame: Engineer:
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 8 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
Frame: Engineer:
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 9 of 12
Two-Way Slabs
oooooo o o
oooooooo oo ooooo oo
oo oo o oo oo
oooo oo o oo oo
oooooo oo oooooo oooooo
oooo oo oo oo oo oo
oo oo oo oo oo oo
oooooooo oo o oo oo oo oo
oooooo ooo ooooo o ooooo
=============================================================================
pcaSlab V1.10 (TM)
A Computer Program for Analysis and Design of Slab Systems
=============================================================================
Copyright © 2000-2003, Portland Cement Association
All rights reserved
=============================================================================================
[2] DESIGN RESULTS
=============================================================================================
Top Reinforcement:
==================
Units: Width (ft), Mmax (k-ft), Xmax (ft), As (in^2), Sp (in)
Span Strip Zone Width Mmax Xmax AsMin AsMax SpReq AsReq Bars
---- ------ ------ -------- ------------ -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------
1 Column Left 10.00 8.40 0.833 1.836 14.631 12.000 0.277 10-#4
Middle 10.00 0.00 9.917 0.000 14.631 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 10.00 138.22 19.000 1.836 14.631 4.800 4.801 25-#4
Middle Left 14.00 -0.00 0.833 2.570 20.483 12.923 0.000 13-#4
Middle 14.00 0.00 9.917 0.000 20.483 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 14.00 46.08 19.000 2.570 20.483 12.923 1.535 13-#4
2 Column Left 10.00 118.88 1.000 1.836 14.631 4.800 4.097 25-#4
Middle 10.00 0.00 10.000 0.000 14.631 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 10.00 118.88 19.000 1.836 14.631 4.800 4.097 25-#4
Middle Left 14.00 39.63 1.000 2.570 20.483 12.923 1.318 13-#4
Middle 14.00 0.00 10.000 0.000 20.483 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 14.00 39.63 19.000 2.570 20.483 12.923 1.318 13-#4
3 Column Left 10.00 138.22 1.000 1.836 14.631 4.800 4.801 25-#4
Middle 10.00 0.00 10.083 0.000 14.631 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 10.00 8.40 19.167 1.836 14.631 12.000 0.277 10-#4
Middle Left 14.00 46.08 1.000 2.570 20.483 12.923 1.535 13-#4
Middle 14.00 0.00 10.083 0.000 20.483 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 14.00 -0.00 19.167 2.570 20.483 12.923 0.000 13-#4
Two-Way Slabs
2 Column 13-#4 6.94 12-#4 4.60 --- 13-#4 6.94 12-#4 4.60
Middle 13-#4 6.87 --- --- 13-#4 6.87 ---
3 Column 13-#4 7.00 12-#4 4.63 --- 5-#4 6.83 5-#4 4.47
Middle 13-#4 6.12 --- --- 13-#4 4.83 ---
Bottom Reinforcement:
=====================
Units: Width (ft), Mmax (k-ft), Xmax (ft), As (in^2), Sp (in)
Span Strip Width Mmax Xmax AsMin AsMax SpReq AsReq Bars
---- ------ -------- ------------ -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------
1 Column 10.00 91.95 8.299 1.836 14.631 7.500 3.134 16-#4
Middle 14.00 61.30 8.299 2.570 20.483 12.923 2.051 13-#4
Flexural Capacity:
==================
Units: From, To (ft), As (in^2), PhiMn (k-ft)
Span Strip From To AsTop AsBot PhiMn- PhiMn+
---- ------ --------- --------- ----- ----- ------------ ------------
1 Column 0.000 0.833 2.00 3.20 -59.43 93.81
0.833 3.467 2.00 3.20 -59.43 93.81
3.467 4.467 1.00 3.20 -30.04 93.81
4.467 5.829 1.00 3.20 -30.04 93.81
5.829 6.829 0.00 3.20 0.00 93.81
6.829 7.192 0.00 3.20 0.00 93.81
7.192 10.000 0.00 3.20 0.00 93.81
10.000 12.642 0.00 3.20 0.00 93.81
12.642 13.005 0.00 3.20 0.00 93.81
13.005 14.005 0.00 3.20 0.00 93.81
14.005 15.366 2.60 3.20 -76.74 93.81
15.366 16.366 2.60 3.20 -76.74 93.81
16.366 19.000 5.00 3.20 -143.60 93.81
19.000 20.000 5.00 3.20 -143.60 93.81
Middle 0.000 0.833 2.60 1.40 -77.38 42.06
0.833 3.000 2.60 1.40 -77.38 42.06
3.000 3.831 2.60 1.40 -77.38 42.06
3.831 4.000 0.00 1.40 0.00 42.06
4.000 4.831 0.00 2.60 0.00 77.38
4.831 7.192 0.00 2.60 0.00 77.38
7.192 10.000 0.00 2.60 0.00 77.38
10.000 12.642 0.00 2.60 0.00 77.38
12.642 13.883 0.00 2.60 0.00 77.38
13.883 14.883 0.00 2.60 0.00 77.38
14.883 16.000 2.60 2.60 -77.38 77.38
16.000 17.000 2.60 1.40 -77.38 42.06
17.000 19.000 2.60 1.40 -77.38 42.06
19.000 20.000 2.60 1.40 -77.38 42.06
Two-Way Slabs
Two-Way Slabs
Maximum Deflections:
====================
Units: Dz (in)
__________Frame____________ _______Column Strip________ ________Middle Strip_______
Span Dz(DEAD) Dz(LIVE) Dz(TOTAL) Dz(DEAD) Dz(LIVE) Dz(TOTAL) Dz(DEAD) Dz(LIVE) Dz(TOTAL)
---- -------- -------- --------- -------- -------- --------- -------- -------- ---------
1 -0.084 -0.043 -0.127 -0.149 -0.076 -0.225 -0.038 -0.019 -0.057
2 -0.025 -0.016 -0.042 -0.041 -0.026 -0.067 -0.014 -0.009 -0.023
3 -0.084 -0.043 -0.127 -0.149 -0.076 -0.225 -0.038 -0.019 -0.057
Material Takeoff:
=================
Reinforcement in the Direction of Analysis
------------------------------------------
Top Steel: 775.080 lb = 0.538 lb/ft^2
Bottom Steel: 1010.016 lb = 0.701 lb/ft^2
Stirrup: 0.000 lb = 0.000 lb/ft^2
Total steel: 1785.096 lb = 1.240 lb/ft^2
Concrete Volume: 1020.000 ft^3 = 0.708 ft^3/ft^2
The following example illustrates the Example Building
design methods presented in the article
“Timesaving
TIME SAVINGDesign Aids for Reinforced
DESIGN AIDS Below is a partial plan of a typical Page 1 offloor
6 in a
Concrete, Part 1: Beams and One-way cast-in-place reinforced concrete building.
Slabs,”
Beams by David A.Slabs
and One-Way Fanella, which The floor framing consists of wide-module
appeared in the August 2001 edition of joists and beams. In this example, the
Structural Engineer magazine. Unless beamsin are designed and detailed
The following example illustrates the design methods presented the PCA book “Simplified Design - for the
otherwise noted, Buildings
Reinforced Concrete all referenced
of Moderatetable, combined
Size and Height” effects
third edition. Unlessof gravitynoted,
otherwise andall lateral
referenced table, figure, and equation
figure, and equation numbers are from numbers are from that book.
(wind) loads according to ACI 318-99.
that article.
Example Building
Below is a partial plan of a typical floor in a cast-in-place reinforced concrete building. The floor framing
consists of wide-module joists and beams. In this example, the beams are designed and detailed for the
combined effects of gravity and lateral (wind) loads according to ACI 318-05.
Design Data
Materials
• Concrete: normal weight (150 pcf), 3/4 - in. maximum aggregate, f’c = 4,000 psi
• Mild reinforcing steel: Grade 60 (fy = 60,000 psi)
Loads
• Joists (16 + 41/2 x 6 + 66) = 76.6 psf
• Superimposed dead loads = 30 psf
• Live load = 100 psf
• Wind loads: per ASCE 7-02
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 2 of 6
⎛ 15 ⎞
L =LO ⎜ 0.25 + ⎟
⎜ K LLAT ⎟⎠
⎝
From Figure C4 of ASCE 7-02, KLL = live load element factor = 2 for interior beams
⎛ 15 ⎞
L = LO ⎜ 0.25 + ⎟ = 0.59LO
⎝ 1, 950 ⎠
Since the beams support only one floor, L shall not be less than 0.50LO.
= 250.8 psf
Factored reactions per ACI Sect. 8.3 (see Figs. 2-3 through 2-7):
= 8.15 x 28.252/16
= 406.5 ft-kips
= 8.15 x 28.252/14
= 464.6 ft-kips
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 3 of 6
= 8.15 x 28.1252/10
= 644.7 ft-kips
= 8.15 x 282/16
= 399.4 ft-kips
= 8.15 x 28.25/2
= 115.1 kips
= 1.15 x 115.1
= 132.4 kips
Mw = ± 90.3 ft-kips
Vw = 6.0 kips
Per ACI Table 9.5(a), minimum thickness = l/18.5 = (30 x 12)/18.5 = 19.5 in.
Since joists are 20.5 in. deep, use 20.5-in. depth for the beams for formwork economy.
With d = 20.5 – 2.5 = 18 in., solving for b using maximum Mu along span (note: gravity moment combination
governs):
bd2 = 20Mu
This implies that using a 36-in. wide beam, ρ will be greater than 0.5ρmax.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 4 of 6
Check minimum width based on ρ = ρmax (see Chapter 3 of the PCA publication Simplified Design of
Reinforced Concrete Buildings of Moderate Size and Height for derivation):
bd2 = 14.6Mu
Required Reinforcement
Beam moments along the span are summarized in the table below.
Required reinforcement, is summarized in the table below. Tables 3-2 and 3-3 are utilized to ensure that
the number of bars chosen conforms to the code requirements for cover and spacing.
For example, at the exterior negative location in the end span, the required As = Mu/4d = 445.7/(4 x 18) =
6.19 in.2 Eight No. 8 bars provides 6.32 in.2. From Table 3-2, the minimum number of No. 8 bars for a 36-
in. wide beam is 5. Similarly, from Table 3-3, the maximum number of No. 8 bars is 16. Therefore, 8-No. 8
bars are adequate.
= 120.2 kips
From Table 3-8, No. 5 U-stirrups at d/3 provides φVs = 84 kips > 58.7 kips. Length over which stirrups are
required = [120.2 – (61.5/2)]/8.15 = 11 ft from face of support.
Reinforcement Details
The figure below shows the reinforcement details for the beam. The bar lengths are computed from
Fig. 8-3 of the PCA publication Simplified Design of Reinforced Concrete Buildings of Moderate Size and
Height. In lieu of computing the bar lengths in accordance with ACI Sects. 12.10 through 12.12, 2-No. 5
bars are provided within the center portion of the span to account for any variations in required bar
lengths due to wind effects. For overall economy, it may be worthwhile to forego the No. 5 bars and
determine the actual bar lengths per the above ACI sections.
Since the beams are part of the primary lateral-load-resisting system, ACI Sect. 12.11.2 requires that at
least one-fourth of the positive moment reinforcement extend into the support and be anchored to devel-
op fy in tension at the face of the support.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 1 of 9
Columns
The following examples illustrate the design methods presented in the PCA book “Simplified Design -
Reinforced Concrete Buildings of Moderate Size and Height” third edition. Unless otherwise noted, all
referenced table, figure, and equation numbers are from that book. The examples presented here are
for columns.
Example 1
In this example, an interior column at the 1st floor level of a 7-story building is designed for the effects
of gravity loads. Structural walls resist lateral loads, and the frame is nonsway.
Materials
• Concrete: normal weight (150 pcf), 3/4-in. maximum aggregate, f’c = 4,000 psi
• Mild reinforcing steel: Grade 60 (fy = 60,000 psi)
Loads
• Floor framing dead load = 90 psf
• Superimposed dead loads = 30 psf
• Live load = 100 psf (floor), 20 psf (roof)
Building Data
• Typical interior bay = 30 ft x 30 ft
• Story height = 12 ft-0 in.
The table below contains a summary of the axial loads due to gravity. The total factored load Pu is com-
puted in accordance with Sect. 9.2.1, and includes an estimate for the weight of the column. Live load
reduction is determined from ASCE 7-02. Moments due to gravity loads are negligible.
Use Fig. 5-1 to determine a preliminary size for the tied column at the 1st floor level.
Assuming a reinforcement ratio ρg = 0.020, for Pu = 1,326 kips, a 24” x 24” column is required.
Columns
Since the column is part of a nonsway frame, slenderness effects can be neglected when the unsupported
column length is less than or equal to 12h, where h is the column dimension (ACI 318-05 Sect. 10.12.2).
12h = 12 x 24 = 288 in. = 24 ft > 12 ft story height, which is greater than the unsupported length of the
column. Therefore, slenderness effects can be neglected.
3-No. 11 bars can be accommodated on the face of a 24-in. wide column with normal lap splices and
No. 4 ties.
According to Sect. 7.10.5.1, No. 4 ties are required when No. 11 longitudinal bars are used.
According to Sect. 7.10.5.2, spacing of ties shall not exceed the least of:
Since the clear space between longitudinal bars > 6 in., cross-ties are required per ACI 318-05 Sect.
7.10.5.3.
See ACI 318-05 Sect. 7.8 for additional special reinforcement details for columns.
Check clear spacing of longitudinal bars: See Sect. 7.8 for additional special
reinforcement details for columns.
Columns
8-No. 11
24s
24s
Example 2
In this example, a simplified interaction diagram is constructed for an 18 in. x 18 in. tied column rein-
forced with 8-No. 9 Grade 60 bars (ρg = 8/182 = 0.0247). Concrete compressive strength = 4 ksi.
Use the simplified equations to determine the 5 points on the interaction diagram.
= 809 kips
• Point 2 (fst = 0)
Layer 1:
d1
1 - C2 = 1 - 1(1) = 0
d1
Layer 2:
d2 ⎛ ⎞
1 - C2 = 1 - 1 ⎜ 9.00 ⎟ = 0.42
d1 ⎝15.56 ⎠
Layer 3:
d3 ⎛ ⎞
1 - C2 = 1 - 1 ⎜ 9.00 ⎟ = 0.84
d1 ⎝15.56 ⎠
Since 1 – C2 (d3 /d1) > 0.69, the steel in layer 3 has yielded.
U g ( fy 0.85 fcc )] Since 1 – C2 (d3 /d1) > 0.69, the steel in
layer 3 has yielded.
0.56 u 18 2 [( 0.85 u 4 )
0.0247 (60 (0.85 u 4 ))] Therefore, set 1 – C2 (d3Page
/d1)4 of=9 0.69 to
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS
871 kips ensure that the stress in the bars in
Columns layer 3 is equal to 60 ksi.
1.5s (typ.)
d3 = 2.44s
18s
No. 3 tie
d2 = 9.00s
3-No. 9
d1 = 15.56s
18s
2-No. 9
3-No. 9
Therefore, set 1 – C2 (d3 /d1) = 0.69 to ensure that the stress in the bars in layer 3 is equal to 60 ksi.
⎡ n ⎛ di ⎞⎤
φPn = φ ⎢C1d1b + 87 ∑ A ⎜1 − C
si 2 ⎟⎥
d1 ⎠⎦
⎣ i=1 ⎝
+ 87[(3 x 0) + (2 x 0.42)
+ (3 x 0.69)]}
= 691 kips
⎡ n ⎛ di ⎞⎛ h ⎞⎤
φMn = φ ⎢0.5C1d1b(h − C 3d1 ) + 87 ∑ A ⎜1 − C
si 2 ⎟⎜ − di ⎟⎥ /12
d1 ⎠⎝ 2 ⎠⎦
⎣ i=1 ⎝
x (18-0.85 x 15.56)
+ 87[(3 x 0) (9 - 15.56)
+ (2 x 0.42) (9 - 9)
= 169 ft - kips
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 5 of 9
Columns
Layer 1:
d1
1 - C2 = 1 - 1.35 (1) = -0.35
d1
Layer 2:
d2 ⎛ 9.00 ⎞
1 - C2 = 1 - 1.35 ⎜ ⎟ = 0.22
d1 ⎝15.56 ⎠
Layer 3:
d3 ⎛ 2.44 ⎞
1 - C2 = 1 - 1.35 ⎜ ⎟ = -0.79, Use 0.69
d1 ⎝15.56 ⎠
⎡ n ⎛ di ⎞⎤
φPn = φ ⎢C1d1b + 87 ∑ A ⎜1 − C
si 2 ⎟⎥
d1 ⎠⎦
⎣ i=1 ⎝
+ (3 x 0.69)]}
= 472 ft - kips
⎡ n ⎛ di ⎞⎛ h ⎞⎤
φMn = φ ⎢0.5C1d1b(h − C 3d1 ) + 87 ∑ A ⎜1 − C
si 2 ⎟⎜ − di ⎟⎥ /12
d1 ⎠⎝ 2 ⎠⎦
⎣ i=1 ⎝
+ (2 x 0.23) (9 - 9)
= 230 ft - kips
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 6 of 9
Columns
Layer 1:
d1
1 - C2 = 1 - 1.69 (1) = -0.69
d1
Layer 2:
d2 ⎛ 9.00 ⎞
1 - C2 = 1 - 1.69 ⎜ ⎟ = 0.02
d1 ⎝15.56 ⎠
Layer 3:
d3 ⎛ 2.44 ⎞
1 - C2 = 1 - 1.69 ⎜ ⎟ = 0.74, Use 0.69
d1 ⎝15.56 ⎠
⎡ n ⎛ di ⎞⎤
φPn = φ ⎢C1d1b + 87 ∑ A ⎜1 − C
si 2 ⎟⎥
d1 ⎠⎦
⎣ i=1 ⎝
+ (3 x 0.69)]}
= 312 kips
⎡ n ⎛ di ⎞⎛ h ⎞⎤
φMn = φ ⎢0.5C1d1b(h − C 3d1 ) + 87 ∑ A ⎜1 − C
si 2 ⎟⎜ − di ⎟⎥ /12
d1 ⎠⎝ 2 ⎠⎦
⎣ i=1 ⎝
+ (2 x 0.02) (9 - 9)
= 260 ft - kips
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 7 of 9
Columns
fs1 = Esεs1
= 29,000 x (-0.0087) = -251.4 ksi > -60 ksi, use fs1 = -60 ksi
fs2 = Esεs2
= 29,000 x (-0.0038) = -108.8 ksi > -60 ksi, use fs2 = -60 ksi
fs3 = Esεs2
Cc = 0.85f’cab
= 0.85 x 4 x (0.85 x 4) x 18
= 208 kips
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 8 of 9
Columns
= 98.4 ft - kips
⎛h ⎞ ⎛18 ⎞
Mns2 = Ts2 ⎜ − d2 ⎟ = (-120)⎜ − 9⎟ /12
⎝2 ⎠ ⎝2 ⎠
=0
⎛h ⎞ ⎛18 ⎞
Mns3 = Cs3 ⎜ − d3 ⎟ = 102⎜ − 2.44 ⎟ /12
⎝2 ⎠ ⎝2 ⎠
= 55.8 ft - kips
3
Mn = 0.5Cc (h − a) + ∑M nsi = [0.5 × 208 × (18 − 3.4 )] /12 + 154.2
i=1
= 280.7 ft - kips
Compare simplified interaction diagram to interaction diagram generated from the PCA computer program
pcaColumn.
The comparison is shown on the next page. As can be seen from the figure, the comparison between the
exact (black line) and simplified (red line) interaction diagrams is very good.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 9 of 9
Columns
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 1 of 22
Moment Redistribution
A 3-span continuous beam has center-to-center span lengths of 30 ft-0 in. The beam is 20 in. by 28 in.
and all columns are 20 in. by 20 in. In this example, the beam is designed for flexure using moment
redistribution.
Design Data
Materials
x Concrete: normal weight (150 pcf), f’c = 4,000 psi
x Mild reinforcing steel: Grade 60 (fy = 60,000 psi)
Loads
x Superimposed dead load = 3.5 kips/ft
x Live load = 2.75 kips/ft
Moment Redistribution
*Permitted to increase or decrease negative moments by not more than 1000ε t ≤ 20% per ACI 8.4.1.
Redistribution of negative moments is permitted only when ε t ≥ 0.0075 (ACI 8.4.3).
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 3 of 22
Moment Redistribution
Adjustments of moments
In this example, it is decided to reduce the negative moment at the first interior support and accept the
corresponding increase in the positive moment in the end span. It is also decided that the negative
moments at the exterior supports will not be adjusted.
The following calculations illustrate the adjustment of the moments for Load Case II.
Negative moment at first interior support = −674.8 ft-kips with an allowable redistribution factor = 8.0%
(see above table).
Reduction to moment = −674.8 × 0.08 = −54.0 ft-kips
Adjusted negative moment = −674.8 − (−54.0) = −620.8 ft-kips
Increase in positive moment in end span:
For Load Case II, negative moment at exterior support = −357.8 ft-kips
− 620.8 + (− 357.8)
Midspan ordinate on line from exterior support to interior support = = −489.3 ft-kips
2
2
2
Moment due to uniform load = wu l n / 8 = 9.3 × 28.33 / 8 = 933.0 ft-kips
Adjusted positive moment at midspan = 933.0 + (−489.3) = 443.7 ft-kips
Similar calculations can be performed for the other load cases.
Required Provided
Mu Load
Location
(ft-kips) Case
As (in.2) ρ Bars ρ
Exterior
-390.1 III 3.64 0.0071 4-No. 9 0.0079
negative
Interior
-620.8 II 6.06 0.0119 6-No. 9 0.0118
negative
Interior
Positive 390.2 IV 3.64 0.0072 4-No. 9 0.0079
span
Moment Redistribution
Z
Y X
pcaBeam v1.50. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Project: 6052.01
Moment Redistribution
CASE: EQ
CASE: Wind
CASE: Live
3500 3500 3500
CASE: Dead
CASE: SELF
pcaBeam v1.50. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Project: 6052.01
Moment Redistribution
160.0 150.87
144.09
132.91
Shear Diagram - kip
-132.91
-150.87 -144.09
-160.0
-495.63 -495.63
Moment Diagram - k-ft
LEGEND:
Envelope (Non-Redist.)
389.71
454.06 454.06
800.0
pcaBeam v1.50. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Project: 6052.01
Moment Redistribution
160.0
143.58 148.22
135.21
Shear Diagram - kip
-143.58 -135.21
-148.22
-160.0
-800.0
-719.74-672.40 -672.40-719.74
-495.63 -495.63
Moment Diagram - k-ft
LEGEND:
Envelope (Redist.)
800.0
pcaBeam v1.50. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Project: 6052.01
Moment Redistribution
3-#9(105.9)
3-#9(105.9)
2-#9(78.0)
3-#9(96.7)
3-#9(96.7)
2-#9(78.0)
2-#9(122.2)
3-#9(159.6)
3-#9(150.5)
3-#9(150.5)
3-#9(159.6)
2-#9(122.2)
3-#9(360.0)c
3-#9(360.0)c
3-#9(360.0)c
2-#9(222.4)
2-#9(205.8)
2-#9(222.4)
Flexural Reinforcement
pcaBeam v1.50. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Project: 6052.01
Moment Redistribution
-800.0
Moment Capacity - k-ft
LEGEND:
Envelope Curve
Capacity Curve
Support Centerline
Face of Support
800.0
pcaBeam v1.50. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Project: 6052.01
Moment Redistribution
=============================================================================
pcaBeam v1.50 (TM)
A Computer Program for Analysis, Design, and Investigation of
Reinforced Concrete Continuous Beam and One-Way Slab Systems
=============================================================================
Copyright © 1992-2005, Portland Cement Association
All rights reserved
=============================================================================================
[1] INPUT ECHO
=============================================================================================
General Information:
====================
File name: C:\Data\Time Saving Design Aid\Moment redistribution example.slb
Project: 6052.01
Frame: Moment Redistribution Engineer: DAF
Code: ACI 318-02 Mode: Design Reinforcement Database: ASTM A615
Number of supports = 4
Floor System: One-Way/Beam
Material Properties:
====================
Slabs|Beams Columns
------------ ------------
wc = 150 150 lb/ft3
f'c = 4 4 ksi
Ec = 3834.3 3834.3 ksi
fr = 0.47434 0.47434 ksi
Reinforcement Database:
===============
Units: Db (in), Ab (in^2), Wb (lb/ft)
Size Db Ab Wb Size Db Ab Wb
---- -------- -------- -------- ---- -------- -------- --------
#3 0.38 0.11 0.38 #4 0.50 0.20 0.67
#5 0.63 0.31 1.04 #6 0.75 0.44 1.50
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 11 of 22
Moment Redistribution
Span Data:
==========
Slabs: L1, wL, wR (ft); t, Hmin (in)
Span Loc L1 t wL wR Hmin
---- ---- -------- -------- -------- -------- --------
1 Int 30.000 0.00 0.833 0.833 0.00
2 Int 30.000 0.00 0.833 0.833 0.00
3 Int 30.000 0.00 0.833 0.833 0.00
Support Data:
=============
Columns: c1a, c2a, c1b, c2b (in); Ha, Hb (ft)
Supp c1a c2a Ha c1b c2b Hb Red%
---- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- ----
1 20.00 20.00 12.000 20.00 20.00 12.000 100
2 20.00 20.00 12.000 20.00 20.00 12.000 100
3 20.00 20.00 12.000 20.00 20.00 12.000 100
4 20.00 20.00 12.000 20.00 20.00 12.000 100
Load Data:
==========
Load Cases and Combinations:
Case SELF Dead Live Wind EQ
Type DEAD DEAD LIVE LATERAL LATERAL
U1 1.200 1.200 1.600 0.000 0.000
Span Loads:
Span Case Wa La Wb Lb
---- -------- ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
Line Loads - Wa | Wb (lb/ft), La | Lb (ft):
1 Dead 3500 0 3500 30
2 Dead 3500 0 3500 30
3 Dead 3500 0 3500 30
1 Live 2750 0 2750 30
2 Live 2750 0 2750 30
3 Live 2750 0 2750 30
Moment Redistribution
3 Live 0 0
4 Live 0 0
Reinforcement Criteria:
=======================
_____Top bars___ ___Bottom bars__ ____Stirrups____
Min Max Min Max Min Max
------- ------- ------- ------- ------- -------
Slabs and Ribs:
Bar Size #5 #8 #5 #8
Bar spacing 1.00 18.00 1.00 18.00 in
Reinf ratio 0.14 5.00 0.14 5.00 %
Cover 1.50 1.50 in
Top bars have 12 in of concrete below them.
Beams:
Bar Size #9 #9 #9 #9 #3 #5
Bar spacing 1.00 18.00 1.00 18.00 6.00 18.00 in
Reinf ratio 0.14 5.00 0.14 5.00 %
Cover 1.50 1.50 in
Top bars have 12 in of concrete below them.
=============================================================================================
[2] DESIGN RESULTS
=============================================================================================
Top Reinforcement:
==================
Units: Width (ft), Mmax (k-ft), Xmax (ft), As (in^2), Sp (in)
Span Zone Width Mmax Xmax AsMin AsMax SpReq AsReq Bars
---- ------ -------- ------------ -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------
1 Left 1.67 386.19 0.833 1.729 9.369 5.206 3.520 4-#9
Middle 1.67 0.00 15.000 0.000 9.369 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 1.67 599.46 29.167 1.729 9.369 3.123 5.686 6-#9
Bottom Reinforcement:
=====================
Units: Width (ft), Mmax (k-ft), Xmax (ft), As (in^2), Sp (in)
Span Width Mmax Xmax AsMin AsMax SpReq AsReq Bars
---- -------- ------------ -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------
1 1.67 487.21 14.433 1.729 9.369 3.904 4.522 5-#9
Moment Redistribution
Flexural Capacity:
==================
Units: From, To (ft), As (in^2), PhiMn (k-ft)
Span From To AsTop AsBot PhiMn- PhiMn+
---- --------- --------- ----- ----- ------------ ------------
1 0.000 0.833 4.00 3.00 -435.08 332.27
0.833 2.320 4.00 3.00 -435.08 332.27
2.320 5.270 2.00 3.00 -225.48 332.27
5.270 6.003 2.00 3.00 -225.48 332.27
6.003 6.501 0.00 3.00 0.00 332.27
6.501 8.765 0.00 3.00 0.00 332.27
8.765 10.184 0.00 5.00 0.00 533.93
10.184 10.750 0.00 5.00 0.00 533.93
10.750 15.000 0.00 5.00 0.00 533.93
15.000 16.698 0.00 5.00 0.00 533.93
16.698 19.250 0.00 5.00 0.00 533.93
19.250 20.311 0.00 5.00 0.00 533.93
20.311 21.175 0.00 3.00 0.00 332.27
21.175 22.650 0.00 3.00 0.00 332.27
22.650 23.806 3.00 3.00 -332.27 332.27
23.806 27.126 3.00 3.00 -332.27 332.27
27.126 29.167 6.00 3.00 -628.80 332.27
29.167 30.000 6.00 3.00 -628.80 332.27
Moment Redistribution
Maximum Deflections:
====================
Units: Dz (in)
Span Dz(DEAD) Dz(LIVE) Dz(TOTAL)
---- -------- -------- ---------
1 -0.248 -0.204 -0.452
2 -0.171 -0.155 -0.326
3 -0.248 -0.204 -0.452
Material Takeoff:
=================
Reinforcement in the Direction of Analysis
------------------------------------------
Top Bars: 1098.5 lb <=> 12.21 lb/ft <=> 7.323 lb/ft^2
Bottom Bars: 1286.7 lb <=> 14.30 lb/ft <=> 8.578 lb/ft^2
Stirrups: 1354.2 lb <=> 15.05 lb/ft <=> 9.028 lb/ft^2
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 15 of 22
Moment Redistribution
=============================================================================================
[6] REDISTRIBUTED SEGMENTAL MOMENT AND SHEAR - ENVELOPES
=============================================================================================
Span x (ft) M- (k-ft) Comb M+ (k-ft) Comb V- (kip) Comb V+ (kip) Comb
---- -------- ------------ ---- ------------ ---- ------------ ---- ------------ ----
1 0.000 -495.63 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 135.21 U1
0.208 -467.67 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 133.27 U1
0.417 -440.10 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 131.34 U1
0.625 -412.94 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 129.40 U1
0.833 -386.19 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 127.46 U1
0.833 -386.19 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 127.46 U1
1.117 -350.45 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 124.83 U1
1.400 -315.45 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 122.19 U1
1.683 -281.21 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 119.56 U1
1.967 -247.70 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 116.92 U1
2.250 -214.95 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 114.29 U1
2.533 -182.94 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 111.65 U1
2.817 -151.68 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 109.02 U1
3.100 -121.17 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 106.38 U1
3.383 -91.40 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 103.75 U1
3.667 -62.38 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 101.11 U1
3.950 -34.10 U1 8.87 U1 0.00 U1 98.48 U1
4.233 -6.58 U1 21.69 U1 0.00 U1 95.84 U1
4.517 0.00 U1 37.72 U1 0.00 U1 93.21 U1
4.800 0.00 U1 62.50 U1 0.00 U1 90.57 U1
5.083 0.00 U1 86.53 U1 0.00 U1 87.94 U1
5.367 0.00 U1 109.82 U1 0.00 U1 85.30 U1
5.650 0.00 U1 132.36 U1 0.00 U1 82.67 U1
5.933 0.00 U1 154.15 U1 0.00 U1 80.03 U1
6.217 0.00 U1 175.19 U1 0.00 U1 77.40 U1
6.500 0.00 U1 195.49 U1 0.00 U1 74.76 U1
6.783 0.00 U1 215.05 U1 0.00 U1 72.13 U1
7.067 0.00 U1 233.85 U1 0.00 U1 69.49 U1
7.350 0.00 U1 251.91 U1 0.00 U1 66.86 U1
7.633 0.00 U1 269.23 U1 0.00 U1 64.22 U1
7.917 0.00 U1 285.79 U1 0.00 U1 61.59 U1
8.200 0.00 U1 301.61 U1 0.00 U1 58.95 U1
8.483 0.00 U1 316.75 U1 0.00 U1 56.32 U1
8.767 0.00 U1 332.34 U1 0.00 U1 53.68 U1
9.050 0.00 U1 347.17 U1 0.00 U1 51.05 U1
9.333 0.00 U1 361.26 U1 0.00 U1 48.41 U1
9.617 0.00 U1 374.61 U1 0.00 U1 45.78 U1
9.900 0.00 U1 387.20 U1 0.00 U1 43.14 U1
10.183 0.00 U1 399.05 U1 0.00 U1 40.51 U1
10.467 0.00 U1 410.16 U1 0.00 U1 37.87 U1
10.750 0.00 U1 420.51 U1 0.00 U1 35.24 U1
11.033 0.00 U1 430.12 U1 0.00 U1 32.60 U1
11.317 0.00 U1 438.99 U1 0.00 U1 29.97 U1
11.600 0.00 U1 447.10 U1 0.00 U1 27.33 U1
11.883 0.00 U1 454.47 U1 0.00 U1 24.70 U1
12.167 0.00 U1 461.10 U1 0.00 U1 22.06 U1
12.450 0.00 U1 466.97 U1 0.00 U1 19.43 U1
12.733 0.00 U1 472.10 U1 0.00 U1 16.79 U1
13.017 0.00 U1 476.49 U1 0.00 U1 14.16 U1
13.300 0.00 U1 480.12 U1 0.00 U1 11.52 U1
13.583 0.00 U1 483.02 U1 -1.26 U1 8.89 U1
13.867 0.00 U1 485.16 U1 -2.65 U1 6.25 U1
14.150 0.00 U1 486.56 U1 -4.04 U1 3.62 U1
14.433 0.00 U1 487.21 U1 -5.42 U1 0.98 U1
14.717 0.00 U1 487.11 U1 -6.81 U1 0.00 U1
15.000 0.00 U1 486.27 U1 -8.72 U1 0.00 U1
15.283 0.00 U1 484.68 U1 -11.36 U1 0.00 U1
15.567 0.00 U1 482.35 U1 -13.99 U1 0.00 U1
15.850 0.00 U1 479.26 U1 -16.63 U1 0.00 U1
16.133 0.00 U1 475.44 U1 -19.26 U1 0.00 U1
16.417 0.00 U1 470.86 U1 -21.90 U1 0.00 U1
16.700 0.00 U1 465.54 U1 -24.53 U1 0.00 U1
16.983 0.00 U1 459.47 U1 -27.17 U1 0.00 U1
17.267 0.00 U1 452.66 U1 -29.80 U1 0.00 U1
17.550 0.00 U1 445.09 U1 -32.44 U1 0.00 U1
17.833 0.00 U1 436.79 U1 -35.07 U1 0.00 U1
18.117 0.00 U1 427.73 U1 -37.71 U1 0.00 U1
18.400 0.00 U1 417.93 U1 -40.34 U1 0.00 U1
18.683 0.00 U1 407.38 U1 -42.98 U1 0.00 U1
18.967 0.00 U1 396.09 U1 -45.61 U1 0.00 U1
19.250 0.00 U1 384.05 U1 -48.25 U1 0.00 U1
19.533 0.00 U1 371.26 U1 -50.88 U1 0.00 U1
19.817 0.00 U1 357.73 U1 -53.52 U1 0.00 U1
20.100 0.00 U1 343.44 U1 -56.15 U1 0.00 U1
20.383 0.00 U1 328.42 U1 -58.79 U1 0.00 U1
20.667 0.00 U1 312.64 U1 -61.42 U1 0.00 U1
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 16 of 22
Moment Redistribution
Moment Redistribution
Moment Redistribution
Moment Redistribution
=============================================================================================
[6a] NON-REDISTRIBUTED SEGMENTAL MOMENT AND SHEAR - ENVELOPES
=============================================================================================
Span x (ft) M- (k-ft) Comb M+ (k-ft) Comb V- (kip) Comb V+ (kip) Comb
---- -------- ------------ ---- ------------ ---- ------------ ---- ------------ ----
1 0.000 -495.63 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 132.91 U1
0.208 -468.14 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 130.98 U1
0.417 -441.06 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 129.04 U1
0.625 -414.38 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 127.10 U1
0.833 -388.10 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 125.16 U1
0.833 -388.10 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 125.16 U1
1.117 -353.01 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 122.53 U1
1.400 -318.67 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 119.89 U1
1.683 -285.07 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 117.26 U1
1.967 -252.22 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 114.62 U1
2.250 -220.12 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 111.99 U1
2.533 -188.76 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 109.35 U1
2.817 -158.15 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 106.72 U1
3.100 -128.29 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 104.08 U1
3.383 -99.17 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 101.45 U1
3.667 -70.80 U1 0.00 U1 0.00 U1 98.81 U1
3.950 -43.18 U1 2.23 U1 0.00 U1 96.18 U1
4.233 -16.30 U1 14.58 U1 0.00 U1 93.54 U1
4.517 0.00 U1 26.53 U1 0.00 U1 90.91 U1
4.800 0.00 U1 49.79 U1 0.00 U1 88.27 U1
5.083 0.00 U1 73.07 U1 0.00 U1 85.64 U1
5.367 0.00 U1 95.61 U1 0.00 U1 83.00 U1
5.650 0.00 U1 117.39 U1 0.00 U1 80.37 U1
5.933 0.00 U1 138.44 U1 0.00 U1 77.73 U1
6.217 0.00 U1 158.73 U1 0.00 U1 75.10 U1
6.500 0.00 U1 178.28 U1 0.00 U1 72.46 U1
6.783 0.00 U1 197.09 U1 0.00 U1 69.83 U1
7.067 0.00 U1 215.14 U1 0.00 U1 67.19 U1
7.350 0.00 U1 232.45 U1 0.00 U1 64.56 U1
7.633 0.00 U1 249.02 U1 0.00 U1 61.92 U1
7.917 0.00 U1 265.17 U1 0.00 U1 59.29 U1
8.200 0.00 U1 281.59 U1 0.00 U1 56.65 U1
8.483 0.00 U1 297.27 U1 0.00 U1 54.02 U1
8.767 0.00 U1 312.20 U1 0.00 U1 51.38 U1
9.050 0.00 U1 326.39 U1 0.00 U1 48.75 U1
9.333 0.00 U1 339.83 U1 0.00 U1 46.11 U1
9.617 0.00 U1 352.52 U1 0.00 U1 43.48 U1
9.900 0.00 U1 364.46 U1 0.00 U1 40.84 U1
10.183 0.00 U1 375.66 U1 0.00 U1 38.21 U1
10.467 0.00 U1 386.12 U1 0.00 U1 35.57 U1
10.750 0.00 U1 395.82 U1 0.00 U1 32.94 U1
11.033 0.00 U1 404.78 U1 0.00 U1 30.30 U1
11.317 0.00 U1 412.99 U1 0.00 U1 27.67 U1
11.600 0.00 U1 420.46 U1 0.00 U1 25.03 U1
11.883 0.00 U1 427.18 U1 0.00 U1 22.40 U1
12.167 0.00 U1 433.15 U1 0.00 U1 19.76 U1
12.450 0.00 U1 438.38 U1 0.00 U1 17.13 U1
12.733 0.00 U1 442.86 U1 0.00 U1 14.49 U1
13.017 0.00 U1 446.59 U1 -0.16 U1 11.86 U1
13.300 0.00 U1 449.58 U1 -1.55 U1 9.22 U1
13.583 0.00 U1 451.82 U1 -2.94 U1 6.59 U1
13.867 0.00 U1 453.31 U1 -4.33 U1 3.95 U1
14.150 0.00 U1 454.06 U1 -5.72 U1 1.32 U1
14.433 0.00 U1 454.06 U1 -7.10 U1 0.00 U1
14.717 0.00 U1 453.31 U1 -8.73 U1 0.00 U1
15.000 0.00 U1 451.82 U1 -11.37 U1 0.00 U1
15.283 0.00 U1 449.58 U1 -14.00 U1 0.00 U1
15.567 0.00 U1 446.59 U1 -16.64 U1 0.00 U1
15.850 0.00 U1 442.86 U1 -19.27 U1 0.00 U1
16.133 0.00 U1 438.38 U1 -21.91 U1 0.00 U1
16.417 0.00 U1 433.15 U1 -24.54 U1 0.00 U1
16.700 0.00 U1 427.18 U1 -27.18 U1 0.00 U1
16.983 0.00 U1 420.46 U1 -29.81 U1 0.00 U1
17.267 0.00 U1 413.00 U1 -32.45 U1 0.00 U1
17.550 0.00 U1 404.79 U1 -35.08 U1 0.00 U1
17.833 0.00 U1 395.83 U1 -37.72 U1 0.00 U1
18.117 0.00 U1 386.12 U1 -40.35 U1 0.00 U1
18.400 0.00 U1 375.67 U1 -42.99 U1 0.00 U1
18.683 0.00 U1 364.47 U1 -45.62 U1 0.00 U1
18.967 0.00 U1 352.53 U1 -48.26 U1 0.00 U1
19.250 0.00 U1 339.83 U1 -50.89 U1 0.00 U1
19.533 0.00 U1 326.40 U1 -53.53 U1 0.00 U1
19.817 0.00 U1 312.21 U1 -56.16 U1 0.00 U1
20.100 0.00 U1 297.28 U1 -58.80 U1 0.00 U1
20.383 0.00 U1 281.60 U1 -61.43 U1 0.00 U1
20.667 0.00 U1 265.18 U1 -64.07 U1 0.00 U1
20.950 0.00 U1 248.00 U1 -66.70 U1 0.00 U1
21.233 0.00 U1 230.09 U1 -69.34 U1 0.00 U1
21.517 0.00 U1 211.42 U1 -71.97 U1 0.00 U1
21.800 0.00 U1 192.01 U1 -74.61 U1 0.00 U1
22.083 -0.72 U1 171.85 U1 -77.24 U1 0.00 U1
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 20 of 22
Moment Redistribution
Moment Redistribution
Moment Redistribution
Torsion Design
The following example illustrates the design methods presented in the PCA book “Simplified Design -
Reinforced Concrete Buildings of Moderate Size and Height” third edition. Unless otherwise noted, all
referenced table, figure, and equation numbers are from that book.
Example Building
Below is a partial plan of a typical floor in a cast-in-place reinforced building. In this example, beam CD is
designed and detailed for the combined effects of flexure, shear, and torsion according to ACI 318-05.
Design Data
Materials
x Concrete: normal weight (150 pcf), f’c = 4,000 psi
x Mild reinforcing steel: Grade 60 (fy = 60,000 psi)
Loads
x Dead load of joists = 77 psf
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 2 of 22
Torsion Design
Since beam CD is part of an indeterminate framing system in which redistribution of internal forces can
occur following torsional cracking, the maximum factored torsional moment Tu at the critical section
located at a distance d from the face of the support can be determined from the following:
2
⎛ Acp ⎞
Tu = φ4 fc' ⎜ ⎟
⎜ pcp ⎟
⎝ ⎠
This type of torsion is referred to as compatibility torsion, the magnitude of which is greater than the
factored torsional moment Tu, min below which torsional effects can be neglected, where
2
⎛ Acp ⎞
Tu,min = φ fc' ⎜ ⎟
⎜ pcp ⎟
⎝ ⎠
Since the beams and joists are cast monolithically, Acp and pcp for beam CD can include a portion of the
adjoining slab. The effective width be of the overhanging flange must conform to 13.2.4:
The torsional properties of the beam ignoring the overhanging flange are the following:
Acp = (20.5 × 24 ) = 492 in.2
It is assumed that the torsional loading on beam CD is uniformly distributed along the span.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 3 of 22
Torsion Design
This framing system satisfies the conditions for analysis by the coefficients of 8.3.3, as illustrated in
Figure 2-2. Thus, use Figures 2-3, 2-4, and 2-7 to determine the maximum positive moment, negative
moment, and shear force in an interior span:
2
⎛ 22 ⎞
2 3.9 × ⎜ 24 − ⎟
w l ⎝ 12 ⎠
Mu+ = u n = = 119.8 ft-kips
16 16
wu l n2 16
Mu− = = 119.8 × = 174.3 ft-kips
11 11
wu ln
Vu = = 43.2 kips
2
2 2
⎛ Vu ⎞ ⎛ Tp ⎞
⎜ ⎟ +⎜ u h ⎟ ≤ φ⎛⎜ Vc + 8 fc' ⎞⎟
⎜b d⎟ ⎜ 1.7A2 ⎟ ⎜b d ⎟
⎝ w ⎠ ⎝ oh ⎠ ⎝ w ⎠
Using an average d = 20.5 − 2.5 = 18.0 in., the factored shear force at the critical section located at
a distance d from the face of the support is Vu = 37.4 kips. Also, the nominal shear strength provided by
the concrete is Vc = 2 fc' bw d .
Therefore,
2 2
⎛ 37,400 ⎞ ⎛ 43 .0 × 12,000 × 75 ⎞
⎜ ⎟ +⎜ ⎟ = 207 psi < 0.75 × (2 + 8 ) 4,000 = 474 psi , OK.
⎝ 24 × 18 ⎠ ⎝ 1.7 × 348 .5 2 ⎠
Torsion Design
θ = 45 °
Therefore,
= =
(
Av Vu − φVc 37,400 − 0.75 × 2 4000 × 24 × 18
=
)
37, 400 − 40,983
<0
s φfyv d 0.75 × 60,000 × 18 0.75 × 60,000 × 18
No transverse reinforcement for shear is required because Vu < φVc . However, since Vu > 0.5φVc ,
minimum area of transverse reinforcement shall be provided per ACI 11.5.6.1.
' bw 24
= 0.75 fc = 0.75 4,000 = 0.019 in.2/in.
fyv 60,000
Av A in.2 / in.
+ 2 t = 0 + 2legs × 0.019 = 0.038 in.2/in. > 0.020 in.2/in. OK.
s s leg
Assuming No. 4 closed stirrups (area per leg = 0.2 in.2), the required spacing s at the critical section =
0.2/0.019 = 10.5 in. < 9.0 in.
Provide No. 4 closed stirrups spaced at 9 in. on center at the critical section. In view of the shear and
torsion distribution along the span length, this same reinforcement and spacing can be provided from the
face of the support to a distance bt + d = 24 + 18 = 42 in. = 3.5 ft past the location where it is no longer
required.
⎛ A ⎞ ⎛ fyv ⎞
⎟ cot 2 θ = 0.019 × 75 × ⎛⎜ 60 ⎞⎟ × cot 2 45 ° = 1.43 in.2
Al = ⎜ t ⎟ph ⎜
⎝ s ⎠ ⎜⎝ fyl ⎟
⎠ ⎝ 60 ⎠
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 5 of 22
Torsion Design
5 4,000 × 492 ⎛ 60 ⎞ 2 2
Al ,min = − ⎜ 0.019 × 75 × ⎟ = 1.17 in. < Al = 1.43in.
60,000 ⎝ 60 ⎠
Location Mu As = Mu / 4d
(ft-kips) (in.2)
Use 1-No. 5 bar on each side (area = 0.31 in.2 ≅ 0.36 in.2, bar diameter = 0.625 in. > 0.042 s = 0.38 in.).
This bar distribution satisfies the maximum spacing requirement, since the spacing ≅ (20.5 – 3 – 1)/2 =
8.25 in. < 12 in. Distribute the remaining steel required for torsion evenly between the top and bottom of
the section; thus, 0.5[1.43 – (2 × 0.31)] = 0.41 in.2 will be added to the area of steel that is required for
flexure at both the top and bottom of the section.
x Face of support
Total top steel required = 2.42 + 0.41 = 2.83 in.2
For 4000-psi concrete, minimum As = 200bw d / fy = 1.44 in.2
Provide 3-No. 9 bars ( As = 3.00 in.2) at top of section. This satisfies both minimum and maximum spacing
requirements for bars in a single layer (see Tables 3-2 and 3-3).
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 6 of 22
Torsion Design
x Midspan
Total bottom steel required = 1.66 + 0.41 = 2.07 in.2
Provide 3-No. 8 bars ( As = 2.37 in.2) at bottom of section. This satisfies both minimum and maximum
spacing requirements for bars in a single layer (see Tables 3-2 and 3-3).
It can be shown that the section is tensioned-controlled.
Reinforcement Details
According to the provisions for structural integrity in 7.13, at least one-sixth of the tension
reinforcement required for negative moment at the support, but not less than 2 bars, and one-quarter of
the positive moment reinforcement at midspan, but not less than 2 bars, must be continuous and tied
with closed stirrups having not less than 135-deg hooks around the continuous top bars. Thus, at least 2
of the 3-No. 9 top bars must be made continuous or spliced with a Class A splice or a mechanical or
welded splice satisfying 12.14.3 at midspan, and at least 2 of the 3-No. 8 bottom bars must be made
continuous or spliced with a Class A splice or a mechanical or welded splice satisfying 12.14.3 over the
supports. No. 4 closed stirrups spaced at 9 in. on center can also be used wherever torsion and shear
reinforcement is not required.
One of the 3-No. 9 bars at the top of the section can be theoretically cutoff at the location where the
factored bending moment is equal to the design moment strength of the section based on a total area of
steel equal to the area of 2-No. 9 bars ( As = 2.00 in.2) minus the area of steel that is required for
torsion (0.41 in.2). Thus, with As = 2.00 – 0.41 = 1.59 in.2, φMn = 125 ft-kips. The distance x from the
face of the support to where the factored bending moment Mu = 125 ft-kips is obtained by summing
moments about the section at this location:
3.9 2
x − 43.2x + 174.3 = 125
2
Solution of this equation gives x = 1.2 ft. The 1-No. 9 bar must extend a distance d = 18 in. or 12 db =
12 × 1 .128 = 13.5 in. beyond the distance x. Thus, from the face of the support, the total bar length must
be at least equal to 1.2 + (18/12) = 2.7 ft. Also, the bars must extend a full development length l d beyond
the face of the support. The development length for the No. 9 bar can be determined as follows:
⎛ ⎞
⎜ ⎟
⎜ ⎟
3 fy αβγλ ⎟
ld =⎜ db
⎜ 40 ⎛ c +K ⎞ ⎟
⎜ fc' ⎜ tr ⎟⎟
⎜ ⎜ db ⎟ ⎟
⎝ ⎝ ⎠⎠
Torsion Design
⎧ 1.128
⎪ 2 + 0.5 + 1.5 = 2.6 in. (governs )
c = spacing or cover dimension = ⎪⎨
⎪ 24 − 2(1.5 + 0.5 ) − 1.128
⎪ = 4.7in.
⎩ 2×2
= 0 (conservative)
c + Ktr 2.6 + 0
= = 2.3 < 2.5
db 1.128
Therefore,
The following figure shows the reinforcement details for beam CD.
For comparison, output form pcaBeam program is also included on the following pages.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 8 of 22
Torsion Design
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 9 of 22
Torsion Design
Z
Y X
pcaBeam v1.51. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Torsion Design
CASE: EQ
CASE: Wind
CASE: Live
1712 1712 1712 1712 1712
CASE: Dead
CASE: SELF
pcaBeam v1.51. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Torsion Design
700.0
601.94 601.94 601.94 601.94 601.94
Torsion Diagram - k-ft
Envelope
-160.62 -160.62
250.0
pcaBeam v1.51. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Torsion Design
0.05
1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5
LEGEND:
Demand - (Av+2At)/s
Demand - At/s
Demand - Av/s
Demand - Al
Provided - (Av+2At)/s
Provided - Al
Support Centerline
Face of Support
7.0 Critical Section
pcaBeam v1.51. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
Torsion Design
32-#4@8.4
32-#4@8.4
32-#4@8.4
32-#4@8.4
32-#4@8.4
Transverse Reinforcement
pcaBeam v1.51. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
1-#9(64.2)
2-#8(288.0)c 2-#9(98.8)
1-#8(36.0)
2-#9(99.7)
1-#9(64.2)
1-#9(64.2)
2-#8(288.0)c 2-#9(98.8)
1-#8(36.0)
2-#9(98.8)
1-#9(64.2)
1-#9(64.2)
2-#8(288.0)c 2-#9(98.8)
1-#8(36.0)
2-#9(98.8)
Engineer: DAF
1-#9(64.2)
pcaBeam v1.51. Licensed to: Portland Cement Association. License ID: 12345-7654321-4-2D2DE-25900
1-#9(64.2)
2-#8(288.0)c 2-#9(99.7)
1-#8(36.0)
2-#9(98.8)
1-#9(64.2)
Flexural Reinforcement
Page 14 of 22
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 15 of 22
Torsion Design
=============================================================================
pcaBeam v1.51 (TM)
A Computer Program for Analysis, Design, and Investigation of
Reinforced Concrete Continuous Beam and One-Way Slab Systems
=============================================================================
Copyright © 1992-2005, Portland Cement Association
All rights reserved
=============================================================================================
[1] INPUT ECHO
=============================================================================================
General Information:
====================
File name: C:\Data\Time Saving Design Aid\Torsion example.slb
Project: Torsion Example
Frame: Exterior Engineer: DAF
Code: ACI 318-02 Mode: Design Reinforcement Database: ASTM A615
Number of supports = 6
Floor System: One-Way/Beam
Material Properties:
====================
Slabs|Beams Columns
------------ ------------
wc = 150 150 lb/ft3
f'c = 4 4 ksi
Ec = 3834.3 3834.3 ksi
fr = 0.47434 0.47434 ksi
Reinforcement Database:
===============
Units: Db (in), Ab (in^2), Wb (lb/ft)
Size Db Ab Wb Size Db Ab Wb
---- -------- -------- -------- ---- -------- -------- --------
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 16 of 22
Torsion Design
Span Data:
==========
Slabs: L1, wL, wR (ft); t, bEff, Hmin (in)
Span Loc L1 t wL wR bEff Hmin
---- ---- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- --------
1 Int 24.000 0.00 1.000 1.000 24.00 0.00
2 Int 24.000 0.00 1.000 1.000 24.00 0.00
3 Int 24.000 0.00 1.000 1.000 24.00 0.00
4 Int 24.000 0.00 1.000 1.000 24.00 0.00
5 Int 24.000 0.00 1.000 1.000 24.00 0.00
Support Data:
=============
Columns: c1a, c2a, c1b, c2b (in); Ha, Hb (ft)
Supp c1a c2a Ha c1b c2b Hb Red%
---- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- ----
1 22.00 22.00 12.000 22.00 22.00 12.000 100
2 22.00 22.00 12.000 22.00 22.00 12.000 100
3 22.00 22.00 12.000 22.00 22.00 12.000 100
4 22.00 22.00 12.000 22.00 22.00 12.000 100
5 22.00 22.00 12.000 22.00 22.00 12.000 100
6 22.00 22.00 12.000 22.00 22.00 12.000 100
Load Data:
==========
Load Cases and Combinations:
Case SELF Dead Live Wind EQ
Type DEAD DEAD LIVE LATERAL LATERAL
U1 1.400 1.400 0.000 0.000 0.000
U2 1.200 1.200 1.600 0.000 0.000
U3 1.200 1.200 1.600 0.800 0.000
U4 1.200 1.200 1.600 -0.800 0.000
U5 1.200 1.200 1.000 1.600 0.000
U6 1.200 1.200 1.000 -1.600 0.000
U7 0.900 0.900 0.000 1.600 0.000
U8 0.900 0.900 0.000 -1.600 0.000
U9 1.200 1.200 1.000 0.000 1.000
U10 1.200 1.200 1.000 0.000 -1.000
U11 0.900 0.900 0.000 0.000 1.000
U12 0.900 0.900 0.000 0.000 -1.000
Span Loads:
Span Case Wa La Wb Lb
---- -------- ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
Line Loads - Wa | Wb (lb/ft), La | Lb (ft):
1 Dead 1712 0 1712 24
2 Dead 1712 0 1712 24
3 Dead 1712 0 1712 24
4 Dead 1712 0 1712 24
5 Dead 1712 0 1712 24
1 Live 800 0 800 24
2 Live 800 0 800 24
3 Live 800 0 800 24
4 Live 800 0 800 24
5 Live 800 0 800 24
Line Torque - Wa | Wb (k-ft/ft), La | Lb (ft):
1 Dead 35.83 0 35.83 24
2 Dead 35.83 0 35.83 24
3 Dead 35.83 0 35.83 24
4 Dead 35.83 0 35.83 24
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 17 of 22
Torsion Design
Reinforcement Criteria:
=======================
_____Top bars___ ___Bottom bars__ ____Stirrups____
Min Max Min Max Min Max
------- ------- ------- ------- ------- -------
Slabs and Ribs:
Bar Size #5 #8 #5 #8
Bar spacing 1.00 18.00 1.00 18.00 in
Reinf ratio 0.14 5.00 0.14 5.00 %
Cover 1.50 1.50 in
Top bars have 12 in of concrete below them.
Beams:
Bar Size #9 #9 #8 #8 #4 #4
Bar spacing 1.00 18.00 1.00 18.00 6.00 18.00 in
Reinf ratio 0.14 5.00 0.14 5.00 %
Cover 2.00 2.00 in
Top bars have 12 in of concrete below them.
=============================================================================================
[2] DESIGN RESULTS
=============================================================================================
Top Reinforcement:
==================
Units: Width (ft), Mmax (k-ft), Xmax (ft), As (in^2), Sp (in)
Span Zone Width Mmax Xmax AsMin AsMax SpReq AsReq Bars
---- ------ -------- ------------ -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------
1 Left 2.00 120.12 0.917 1.435 7.775 9.808 1.537 3-#9 *5
Middle 2.00 0.00 12.000 0.000 7.775 0.000 0.000 ---
Right 2.00 161.22 23.083 1.435 7.775 9.808 2.087 3-#9
Torsion Design
Bottom Reinforcement:
=====================
Units: Width (ft), Mmax (k-ft), Xmax (ft), As (in^2), Sp (in)
Span Width Mmax Xmax AsMin AsMax SpReq AsReq Bars
---- -------- ------------ -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------
1 2.00 107.14 11.626 1.440 7.803 9.854 1.361 3-#8 *5
Flexural Capacity:
==================
Units: From, To (ft), As (in^2), PhiMn (k-ft)
Span From To AsTop AsBot PhiMn- PhiMn+
---- --------- --------- ----- ----- ------------ ------------
1 0.000 0.917 3.00 1.58 -234.00 127.40
0.917 3.391 3.00 1.58 -234.00 127.40
3.391 5.351 2.00 1.58 -159.31 127.40
5.351 6.273 2.00 1.58 -159.31 127.40
6.273 8.232 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
8.232 8.675 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
8.675 10.125 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
10.125 11.487 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
11.487 11.766 0.00 2.37 0.00 188.01
11.766 12.000 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
12.000 13.127 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
13.127 15.325 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
15.325 15.690 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
15.690 18.351 0.00 1.58 0.00 127.40
18.351 18.649 2.00 1.58 -159.31 127.40
18.649 21.310 2.00 1.58 -159.31 127.40
21.310 23.083 3.00 1.58 -234.00 127.40
23.083 24.000 3.00 1.58 -234.00 127.40
Torsion Design
2 2.411 5.151 29.98 43.00 0.200 2.41 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
5.151 7.891 21.45 43.00 0.194 5.15 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
7.891 10.630 12.92 43.00 0.190 7.89 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
10.630 13.370 4.39 43.00 0.188 10.63 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4 *5
13.370 16.109 12.68 43.00 0.190 16.11 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
16.109 18.849 21.21 43.00 0.194 18.85 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
18.849 21.589 29.74 43.00 0.200 21.59 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
3 2.411 5.151 29.86 43.00 0.200 2.41 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
5.151 7.891 21.33 43.00 0.194 5.15 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
7.891 10.630 12.80 43.00 0.190 7.89 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
10.630 13.370 4.27 43.00 0.188 10.63 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4 *5
13.370 16.109 12.80 43.00 0.190 16.11 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
16.109 18.849 21.33 43.00 0.194 18.85 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
TIME SAVING DESIGN AID Page 20 of 22
Torsion Design
18.849 21.589 29.86 43.00 0.200 21.59 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
4 2.411 5.151 29.74 43.00 0.200 2.41 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
5.151 7.891 21.21 43.00 0.194 5.15 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
7.891 10.630 12.68 43.00 0.190 7.89 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
10.630 13.370 4.39 43.00 0.188 13.37 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4 *5
13.370 16.109 12.92 43.00 0.190 16.11 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
16.109 18.849 21.45 43.00 0.194 18.85 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
18.849 21.589 29.98 43.00 0.200 21.59 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
5 2.411 5.151 31.43 43.00 0.201 2.41 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
5.151 7.891 22.90 43.00 0.195 5.15 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
7.891 10.630 14.37 43.00 0.190 7.89 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
10.630 13.370 5.84 43.00 0.188 10.63 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4 *5
13.370 16.109 11.23 43.00 0.189 16.11 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
16.109 18.849 19.76 43.00 0.193 18.85 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
18.849 21.589 28.29 43.00 0.199 21.59 U1/All 0.0000 0.0194 0.0387 *4
NOTES:
*4 - Design torsional moment reduced to PhiTcr due to compatibility torsion.
*5 - Minimum transverse (stirrup) reinforcement required.
Torsion Design
Beam shear and torsion transverse reinforcement capacity in terms of provided and required area:
Units: Start, End, Xu (ft), Sp (in), A(v+2t)/s (in^2/in)
Vu (kip), Tu (k-ft), vf (ksi)
___________________Provided__________________ _______________________Required________________________
Span Start End A(v+2t) Sp A(v+2t)/s Xu Vu Tu Case/Patt vf A(v+2t)/s
---- -------- -------- -------- -------- --------- -------- -------- -------- --------- -------- ---------
1 0.000 1.167 ----- ----- ------ 0.00 45.99 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0451 *4
1.167 11.875 0.400 8.39 0.0477 2.41 28.29 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
11.875 12.125 0.400 8.39 0.0477 12.12 1.96 6.25 U1/All 0.03 0.0000 *2
12.125 22.833 0.400 8.39 0.0477 21.59 31.43 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
22.833 24.000 ----- ----- ------ 24.00 49.43 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0494 *4
2 0.000 1.167 ----- ----- ------ 0.00 48.09 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0477 *4
1.167 11.875 0.400 8.39 0.0477 2.41 29.98 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
11.875 12.125 0.400 8.39 0.0477 11.88 0.51 6.25 U1/All 0.03 0.0000 *2
12.125 22.833 0.400 8.39 0.0477 21.59 29.74 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
22.833 24.000 ----- ----- ------ 24.00 47.88 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0474 *4
3 0.000 1.167 ----- ----- ------ 0.00 47.98 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0476 *4
1.167 11.875 0.400 8.39 0.0477 2.41 29.86 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
11.875 12.125 0.400 8.39 0.0477 11.88 0.39 6.25 U1/All 0.03 0.0000 *2
12.125 22.833 0.400 8.39 0.0477 21.59 29.86 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
22.833 24.000 ----- ----- ------ 24.00 47.98 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0476 *4
4 0.000 1.167 ----- ----- ------ 0.00 47.88 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0474 *4
1.167 11.875 0.400 8.39 0.0477 2.41 29.74 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
11.875 12.125 0.400 8.39 0.0477 12.12 0.51 6.25 U1/All 0.03 0.0000 *2
12.125 22.833 0.400 8.39 0.0477 21.59 29.98 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
22.833 24.000 ----- ----- ------ 24.00 48.09 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0477 *4
5 0.000 1.167 ----- ----- ------ 0.00 49.43 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0494 *4
1.167 11.875 0.400 8.39 0.0477 2.41 31.43 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
11.875 12.125 0.400 8.39 0.0477 11.88 1.96 6.25 U1/All 0.03 0.0000 *2
12.125 22.833 0.400 8.39 0.0477 21.59 28.29 43.00 U1/All 0.20 0.0387 *4 *5
22.833 24.000 ----- ----- ------ 24.00 45.99 43.00 U2/All 0.22 0.0451 *4
NOTES:
*2 - Torsion ignored (Tu < PhiTcr/4).
*4 - Design torsional moment reduced to PhiTcr due to compatibility torsion.
*5 - Minimum transverse (stirrup) reinforcement required.
Beam torsion longitudinal reinforcement capacity in terms of provided and required area:
Units: Start, End, Xu (ft), Al (in^2), Tu (kip)
_________Provided_________ _____________Required_______________
Span Start End Al Xu Tu Case/Patt Al
---- -------- -------- -------- -------- -------- --------- --------
1 0.000 1.167 ----- 0.00 43.00 U2/All 1.452 *4
1.167 11.875 6.320 11.63 18.74 U1/All 1.843 *4 *5
11.875 12.125 ----- 11.88 6.25 U1/All 0.000 *2
12.125 22.833 6.320 12.37 18.74 U1/All 1.843 *4 *5
22.833 24.000 ----- 22.83 43.00 U2/All 1.452 *4
Torsion Design
Maximum Deflections:
====================
Units: Dz (in)
Span Dz(DEAD) Dz(LIVE) Dz(TOTAL)
---- -------- -------- ---------
1 -0.067 -0.053 -0.120
2 -0.057 -0.033 -0.090
3 -0.058 -0.035 -0.092
4 -0.057 -0.033 -0.090
5 -0.067 -0.053 -0.120
Material Takeoff:
=================
Reinforcement in the Direction of Analysis
------------------------------------------
Top Bars: 742.8 lb <=> 6.19 lb/ft <=> 3.095 lb/ft^2
Bottom Bars: 680.9 lb <=> 5.67 lb/ft <=> 2.837 lb/ft^2
Torsion Bars: 2776.7 lb <=> 23.14 lb/ft <=> 11.569 lb/ft^2
Stirrups: 2057.4 lb <=> 17.15 lb/ft <=> 8.573 lb/ft^2
Total Steel: 6257.7 lb <=> 52.15 lb/ft <=> 26.074 lb/ft^2
Concrete: 410.0 ft^3 <=> 3.42 ft^3/ft <=> 1.708 ft^3/ft^2
The following example illustrates the Materials
design methods
TIME SAVING DESIGNpresented
AIDS in the article Concrete: normal weight Page (1501 ofpcf),
6 ¾-in.
“Timesaving Design Aids for Reinforced maximum aggregate, f?c = 4,000 psi
Walls
Concrete, Part 3: Columns and Walls,” by Mild reinforcing steel: Grade 60 (fy =
David A. Fanella, which appeared in the 60,000 psi)
November 2001 edition of Structural
The following example illustrate the design methods presented in the PCA book “Simplified Design -
Reinforced Concrete
Engineer Buildings
magazine. of Moderate
Unless Size and Height” third edition. Unless otherwise noted, all
otherwise Loads
referenced table, figure, and equation numbers are from that book. The example presented here is for
noted,
Walls. all referenced table, figure, and Total roof dead load = 122 psf
equation numbers are from that article. Total floor dead load = 142 psf
Examples for columns are available on our Web page: www.cement.org/buildings.
The example presented here is for walls. Live load = 100 psf (floor), 20 psf (roof)
Design Data
Wind loads: per ASCE 7-98
In this example,
Examples the 8-in. thick
for columns are wall below, which
available on ouris part of a 5-story building, is designed and detailed for
gravity loads and the wind forces shown.
Web page: www.portcement.org/buildings. Building Data
Materials
Tributary floor area to wall = 300 ft2
• Concrete: normal weight (150 pcf), 3/4-in. maximum aggregate, f’c = 4,000 psi
Design Data
• Mild reinforcing steel: Grade 60 (fy = 60,000 psi)
InLoads
this example, the 8-in. thick wall below,
• Total roof
which dead load
is part of =a122 psf
5-story building, is
• Total floor dead load = 142 psf
designed and detailed for gravity loads
• Live load = 100 psf (floor), 20 psf (roof)
and the wind forces shown.
• Wind loads: per ASCE 7-02
Building Data
• Tributary floor area to wall = 300 ft2
11.3 k
15?-0I 4 @ 12?-0I = 48?-0I
22.0 k
21.1 k
19.9 k
20.5 k
20?-8I
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 2 of 6
Walls
From Table 6-5, for an 8-in. thick wall, φVc = 7.3 x 20.67 = 150.9 kips
Since Vu > φVc , provide horizontal shear reinforcement from Table 6-4.
For No. 4 bars @ 18”, φVs = 4.8 kips/ft > 0.04 kips/ft
However, minimum wall reinforcement per Table 6-3 for an 8 in. wall is No. 4 @ 10”
ρl = 0.0025 + 0.5 (2.5 - hw/lw) (ρt - 0.0025) where hw/lw = 63/20.67 = 3.1
Since φVc /2 = 150.9/2 = 75.4 kips < Vu = 118.9 kips < φVc = 150.9 kips,
use No. 4 @ 10” for the horizontal and vertical reinforcement in the 2nd story.
Since φVc /2 = 75.4 kips < Vu = 87.0 < Vc = 150.9 kips use No. 4 @ 10” for the horizontal and vertical rein-
forcement in the 3rd story.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 3 of 6
Walls
Vu at 4th story= 1.6(11.3 + 22.0) = 53.3 kips < φVc / 2 = 75.4 kips
For 8” wall, use No. 3 @ 11” vertical reinforcement and No. 4 @ 12” horizontial reinforcement.
Summary of reinforcement
• Vertical bars
• Horizontal bars
* Spacing of vertical bars reduced from 11 in. to 10 in. so that the bars in the 3rd story can be spliced
U = 0.9D + 1.6W
Mu = 1.6[(11.3 x 63) + (22.0 x 51) + (21.1 x 39) + (19.9 x 27) + (20.5 x 15)] = 5,603 ft-kips
Walls
⎛ A ⎞ fy ⎛ 4.96 ⎞ 60
ω = ⎜ st ⎟ = ⎜ ⎟ = 0.0375
⎝ l wh ⎠ fc′ ⎝ 248 × 8 ⎠ 4
⎛ P ⎞ 305
α =⎜ u ⎟= = 0.0384
⎝ l whfc ⎠ 248 × 8 × 4
′
c ω +α 0.0375 + 0.0384
= = = 0.0952
l w 2ω + 0.85β1 (2 × 0.0375) + (0.85 × 0.85)
⎡ ⎛ Pu ⎞⎛ c ⎞⎤
φMn = φ ⎢0.5Astfy l w ⎜⎜1 + ⎟⎟⎜1 − ⎟⎥ =
⎢⎣ ⎝ Astfy ⎠⎝ l w ⎠⎥⎦
⎡
= 0.9⎢(0.5 × 4.96 × 60 × 248)
⎣
⎛ 305 ⎞ ⎤
× ⎜1 + ⎟(1 − 0.0952)⎥
⎝ 4.96 × 60 ⎠ ⎦
Therefore, increase amount of vertical reinforcement for moment strength. It can be shown that No. 5 @
10” (φMn = 6,307 ft-kips) is adequate.
ω = 0.0375
239
α = = 0.0301
248 × 8 × 4
c 0.0375 + 0.0301
= = 0.0848
l w (2 × 0.0375) + (0.85 × 0.85)
⎡ ⎛ 239 ⎞ ⎤
φMn = 0.9 ⎢(0.5 × 4.96 × 60 × 248)⎜1 + ⎟(1 − 0.0848)⎥
⎣ ⎝ 4.96 × 60 ⎠ ⎦
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 5 of 6
Walls
⎛ 2.69 ⎞ 60
ω =⎜ ⎟ = 0.0203
⎝ 248 × 8 ⎠ 4
117
α= = 0.0147
248 × 8 × 4
c 0.0203 + 0.0147
= = 0.0459
l w (2 × 0.0203) + (0.85 × 0.85)
⎡ ⎤
φMn = 0.9 ⎢(0.5 × 2.69 × 60 × 248) × ⎛⎜1 + 117 ⎞
⎟(1 − 0.0459)⎥
⎣ ⎝ 2.69 × 60 ⎠ ⎦
= 29,643 in. - kips
The required shear reinforcement is adequate for moment strength, except in the 1st story.
For comparison purposes, the PCA computer program pcaColumn was utilized to determine the adequacy of
the wall in the 1st story. As can be seen from the figure, the wall is adequate with No. 4 @ 10”.
TIME SAVING DESIGN AIDS Page 6 of 6
Walls