Capstone Project Research Paper
Capstone Project Research Paper
Capstone Project Research Paper
Mitchell Barker
Mrs. Wilson
4/27/18
Thesis: Aquaponics is far more effective and prosperous than traditional aquaculture and
I. What is Aquaponics
V. Aquaponics
A. Can be scaled to be effective in multi-million dollar operations all the way to backyard
family operation
VII. Cost saving benefits of aquaponics, no fertilizer cost and less tank maintenance
VIII. Common practices of aquaponics, common species involved and growing scenarios
Mitchell Barker 1
In a world of billions, there is an unspoken hunt to find better ways to feed this large and
and aquaculture both produce harmful trash as a side effect, but these two farming techniques,
when combined, counteract the bad chemicals and convert them into benefits. Aquaponics is far
more effective and prosperous than traditional fish farming and hydroponics because each aids
Growing plants and fish have been around for decades, but the practice of combining the
two is new to the farming world. Aquaponics is the practice of combining aquaculture and
hydroponics in a controlled environment. The process of combining the two has been around
since ancient villages began to grow plants in small bodies of water such as rice farms in Asia or
chinampas in Mexico (“Aquaponics: a Brief History”). At the time of the settlers, their growing
processes were in a pond or lake like setting in which the plants didn't grow directly into the
water which took away the benefits of combining the two. The benefits of aquaponics wasn't
discovered until the past few decades, and since, the practice has grown exponentially. Fish
waste provides nutrients for plants which then filter the water while utilizing the nutrients
(“What Is Aquaponics”). Aquaponics not only eliminates the drawbacks of each other, it also
significantly reduces the drawbacks of traditional soil farming. With aquaponics, there are no
weeds or soil-borne illnesses to battle, a significant decrease in pesticide and fertilizer use, and
no physical strain of planting. One of the biggest advantages of aquaponics is the ability to grow
food in urban environments, so the food gets to markets and the tables of families much sooner.
food production. Fish farming can be conducted in many different ways including the cage
Mitchell Barker 3
system, man made outdoor pond, or indoor tanks, which is the most complex and costly (“Fish
environment. When conducted properly, hydroponics can be even more efficient than traditional
farming and requires no cultivation of land preparation. Hydroponics is very versatile because it
can be applied in a variety of settings which makes it so useful in the farming industry. Many
companies have seen the potential of hydroponics and have set up greenhouses with a
hydroponic system capable of growing millions of plants a one time. Many people living in the
city set up hydroponics in their basement to give them the opportunity to grow plants despite
having a lack of soil space. When growing plants in water, they have to be supplied with
nutrients that can be normally found in the soil, which is one downfall to hydroponics. Plant
supetance is another problem, because there is a limited number of plants that can prosper in an
all water environment. When plants and fish are combined into the same growing system, fish
produce natural fertilizers in their feces, which is the food plants need to prosper. The fish
growing tanks must be cleaned to avoid a build up feces, when not combined with hydroponics
system, to maintain a healthy environment for the fish. When there is a proper balance of fish to
plants, the two balance each other out; the plants will naturally use the fish fertilizer which acts
to purify the water all while growing using a natural organic fertilizer.
One of the key contributors in aquaponics are microbes, which are nitrifying bacteria,
that convert ammonia from fish waste into nitrites and then nitrates (“What Is Aquaponics”).
Plants absorb nitrogen in the the form of nitrates, which makes these microbes so important.
Nitrogen is vital to plants because it is a major component of chlorophyll, in which plants use
sunlight energy and convert it into energy in the form of sugars. Just like humans, plants need
proteins which without them plants would wither and die. Solid fish waste is turned into
vermicompost, and this is used as food by the plant (“What Is Aquaponics”). In just the
traditional hydroponics system, growers must purchase expensive fertilizers that can be applied
to the plants, but when combined with plants, growers can avoid this costly procedure. When
conducting only an aquaculture system, water must be discharged at a rate of 10-20 percent of
the total tank volume daily, due to the high amount of ammonia which is a result of fish feces
(“What Is Aquaponics”). This uses a lot of water to maintain the tanks especially in facilities
where there is thousands and thousands of gallons used everyday. In a properly set up
aquaculture setup, there is little cleaning or emptying required, because the plants help to purify
and clean the tank. Aquaponics is proven to be more efficient and healthy, not just for the fish
One fact of farming that upsets many is the practice of killing deer and rabbits to keep
them out of fields and gardens, and in many states, the state government will issue permits to
farmers to harvest deer year round in order to reduce crop damage. In an aquaculture system
there is no battle with wildlife, no need to build fences, and no need to kill animals
unnecessarily, which is a huge benefit to ecosystems. Also, insects are very hard on crops and
gardens which leads to many people using pesticides and chemicals to reduce crop damage.
These pesticides are designed to kill, and many times can be dangerous to humans and animals,
especially when family pets have access to fields or gardens. With an aquaponics system there is
no exposure to insects, so the need to spray and use harmful chemicals is non-existent.
Furthermore, when plants are grown outdoors, there is always a risk of a natural event destroying
a years crop. If a large storm came through a region destroying a years worth of crops and
damaging the fields, it would take a significant hit on the community’s economy and could result
Mitchell Barker 5
in a price increase for crops. This leads to insecurity and instability in the food market because
it's impossible to know when a storm or cold weather will come through and cause problems
with crop production. When an indoor aquaponics system is in effect, there is no worry of this
because the plants are in a controlled environment and safe from the elements. One of the
biggest benefits is the fact that people can raise not only crops, but also fish at the same time, so
One of the biggest advantages to aquaponics is that it's scalable, so it can be effective in a
backyard or basement environment, but it can also be effective in a large warehouse setting. The
reason plants can grow indoors is due to the grower’s ability to replicate artificial light through
UV lights. These special UV lights can be purchased in a variety of sizes and ordered off the
internet for a highly affordable price. Farmers who grow food on a large scale often live in rural
areas with hundreds and hundreds of acres, which means the grower could be hours and possibly
days from the market where the products will be sold. This means that produce may not be fresh
by the time it hits the market and could get even worse by the time it hits a family’s table. With
aquaponics, the plants can be grown in confined cities where farmland cannot be found. This
allows growers to get food to the markets much fresher and safer because they spend less time
sitting out. For those people who want an even fresher meal they can set up their own small
scale aquaponics system in their basement or garage, and supply their family with fish and
vegetables right from the growing system. According to the Huffington Post, fresh food contains
more nutrients, hydration, healthful fats, and enzymes which is why keeping food fresh is so
crucial. This gives people the ability to grow their own food, and ensure the safety and
freshness, despite the size of their yard. Aquaponics offers people an advantage that has never
Cost is a major factor in the reason aquaponics is taking off at the rate it is. When
growers get to combine fish farming and hydroponics into one system is carries many cost
saving benefits. One of the most expensive aspects of soil farming is the soil upkeep and heavy
equipment that it requires. On large farms, they use equipment that is up to half a million dollars
and may have multiple pieces at this cost. Keeping fuel and maintenance on this equipment can
cost farmers a lot of money and lead to them raising their prices. In a fish farming setup, there is
far less equipment required, but filters and water clarification equipment can still be costly. This
fact is why aquaponics is most economical because with the plants being implemented into the
system, the water clarification is all natural and far cheaper. Fertilizer is another major cost point
of farming; past the initial cost of purchasing the fertilizer, farmers spend days putting it on their
fields. In addition, many people have a problem with the thought of fertilizer on their crops and
feeding their children something that has been grown inorganically. With hydroponics, growers
still have to fertilize the plants and use fertilizers that are not organic. When a grower combines
fish farming in with hydroponics, users get a system that requires no fertilizer or inorganic
method of plant food because the plants use the fish by products to fuel themselves (“What is
Aquaponics?” ). This is one reason that aquaponics is far more effective, safe, and more
Many people are unaware of how effective fish farming can be, and just how many
different fish can be grown in a person’s own backyard. The most common fish species to be
grown are catfish and tilapia, but even fish like salmon can be raised in a fish farming
operation(“What Is Aquaponics”). Many people have set up a small scale aquaponics system as
another income source, and have realized that is a great income source. Many of these growers,
both on small and large scales, have began to realize that adding the plant growing aspect to fish
Mitchell Barker 7
farming is much more effective. “According to the United Nations Food and Agriculture
Organization- aquaculture has grown three times faster compared to land based
agriculture”(“Fish Farms”). People all around the world are turning to non traditional methods
of income, which has led to a major increase in aquaponics internationally. Research gathered
by VoucherBin shows more people than ever are turning towards non-traditional income.
“Research by VoucherBin.co.uk suggests that more of us than ever before are seeking additional
income through a home based business - or aiming to give up the 9-5 schedule for good”
(“Aquaponics: a Brief History”). Many fear that raising plants will be to difficult or costly, but
in reality plants in an aquaponics system are extremely low maintenance. This is thanks to no
weeds or insects to battle, unlike a soil based growing environment. When growing plants in an
aquaponic environment, there's no reason to worry about fertilizer because the plants feed
themselves using the fish by products. When set up correctly aquaponics has the potential to be
extremely beneficial to the environment and change the way we farm forever.
Many people try to help third world countries by giving them wells to water their crops
and animals. While watering crops, lots of water will be wasted, and plants will need a large
supply of water to survive especially in hot climates such as those in much of Africa. When
raising animals it takes many to feed a family and a farm animal, such as a cow needs gallons of
water daily to survive. Aquaponics would be hard to run in a community with low water supply
because circulating fresh water in daily would be impossible. Fish would be a great way to
supply food because communities can save water from not watering livestock, and the fish
supply a great diet for people. If people in these undeveloped nations can grow plants in an
aquaponic setup, then they will not have to recirculate the water because the plants will act as a
natural cleaner. Another benefit to growing plants in an aquaponic setup it that they can save
Mitchell Barker 8
water from watering crops because there is no wasted water in aquaponics, since the plants grow
directly in the water. This water from the fish tank has natural plant food in the form of nitrogen
rich fish feces which aids significantly in plant growth. This natural fertilizer is important
because when conducting normal soil based agriculture, these growers would not be able to
afford fertilizer. Even in a hydroponic growing set up, the plants would need fertilizer to grow,
so this is another example of why aquaponics is far more efficient and beneficial. Many
developing countries have already turned towards aquaponics such as the Island of Barbados.
“The Caribbean island of Barbados created an initiative to start aquaponics systems at home,
with revenue generated by selling produce to tourists in an effort to reduce growing dependence
Many don't understand the how farmers grow and raise plants in the same environment
and how it works. Despite what many think, growing the two together is not a challenge and
actually helps the grower. One of the many benefits of aquaponics is its versatility and ability to
be instituted in a variety of sizes. Some backyard growers will raise fish in just a small watering
trough of a 100 gallons, which works just fine, and some industrial growers have tanks that are
capable of holding thousands of gallons. Tank size is not important as long as the grower
determines the proper proportion of fish to plants, so that the grower can yield the full benefits of
the combination. Plants can be set up in a variety of ways around the tank to allow constant
water circulation easily from the tank to growing medium. If someone is looking for a cheap and
very effective set-up, plants can be grown in floating trays on top of the water or trays just above
the water that lets water flow through the planting medium and then flow back down into the
tank with the help of gravity. These setups require no expensive pumps or planting medium so it
can easily be used in all budgets. Some of these inexpensive set-ups are being designed to help
Mitchell Barker 9
developing nations such as the aquaponics setup made in Bangladesh by a college professor to
help suffering communities. “In Bangladesh, a team led by Professor Dr. M.A. Salam at the
plans for a low-cost aquaponics system to provide chemical-free produce and fish”
The future of farming is here and spreading rapidly across the country. Many people are
unaware of the possibility to combine aquaculture and hydroponics, and just how beneficial it is.
Anyone would agree both fish farming and hydroponics are extremely beneficial and innovative
farming techniques, but it is undeniable that aquaponics is far more efficient and prosperous than
either being instituted alone. The advantages are endless, but the main ones are how much
combining the two practices saves the grower money, reduces work by eliminating the need to
fertilize the crops, and drastically reduces the amount of water farmers will have to use daily.
The ability to grow crops, using aquaponics, in a variety of settings and areas gives communities
the ability to grow produce and fish much fresher and safer than ever before. With such an
environmental concern in the world during the past few decades, aquaponics fits perfectly due to
is environmentally friendly conservation of water and reduction of fertilizer use. For those who
want to help people living in undeveloped nations, aquaponics is the way to do so. People can
now supply plants and meat to these communities with a much more economical and reasonable
plan than ever before. Aquaponics is clearly the farming of the future.
Mitchell Barker 10
Works Cited
“Fish Farms.” Fish Farms | Fish Farming Information and Resources | Farms.com,
Seidenberg, Casey. “Why Fresh Food Is Better than Frozen.” The Washington Post, WP
www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/wellness/why-fresh-food-is-better-than-frozen/2012/0
Mitchell Barker 11
7/17/gJQAYsukrW_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.2ac41ef936a3.
www.permaculture.co.uk/articles/aquaponics-farming-fish.
“What Is Aquaponics.” The Aquaponic Source, The Aquaponic Source , 1 Jan. 2018,
www.theaquaponicsource.com/what-is-aquaponics/.
home.howstuffworks.com/lawn-garden/professional-landscaping/what-is-
aquaponics.htm.