Running Head: Rubbersole Business Plan 1
Running Head: Rubbersole Business Plan 1
Running Head: Rubbersole Business Plan 1
Name
Institution Affiliation
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 2
Introduction
RubberSole is a national shoe retailer with more than 100 chains across the United
Kingdom and active online presence. Particularly, the company has shops in the city centers,
rails stations, and airports. The company has undergone significant expansion in the past year
which has led to open two stores per year. RubberSole deals with adult female footwear, adult
male footwear, children shoes, and accessories. They rely on constant innovation and product
design development to maintain market share in a very competitive market. The report will
recommend a strategy for RubberSole based on the assessment of the competitive environment,
analysis of the market trend, evaluation of the company’s financial position, an assessment of the
alternative and an analysis of the risks. From this analysis, the leadership of RubberSole should
be able to make informed decisions promoting further growth of their company and increasing
Market Analysis
The framework of pure competition suggests that the risk-adjusted rates of return should
be consistent across markets and the companies. However, various economists have established
that different markets can sustain different degrees of profitability based on the structure of the
market (Thompson, Peteraf, Gamble, & Strickland, 2016.). Michael Porter depicts a model that
outlines the influence of the market by five forces. The model is useful in developing an edge
over the competitors as well as understanding the market context in which RubberSole functions.
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 3
Supplier Power
A producer company needs raw materials such as supplies, labor, and components which
results in the relationship between suppliers and the buyer as well as between the industry and
the firm that generate the product. When the suppliers are powerful, they can have an influence
on the producing industry such as selling the products are increased price or extracting some
profits from the industry (Thompson et al. 2016). Rubbersole’s operations source stock of
branded footwear products from third parties overseas manufacturers from Portugal, China,
Brazil, Vietnam, Bangladesh, and India. Resultantly, the company does not rely on only one
supplier which makes it have control over the suppliers. Specifically, this approach reduces the
Buyer Power
A competitive industry with high prices and high downsizing of firms has a critical role
in the current economy. Customers are propelled to cut back on their expenditure with makes
them focus on cheap quality products (Thompson et al. 2016). Specifically, Rubbersole sales its
products at a lower price than its competitors which makes more customers focus on their
products to gain value for the money. Resultantly, customers have high buying power since the
company has lower-priced products than its competitors. According to the Five Forces analysis,
customers define the competitiveness of the business. In RubberSole’s case, the industry
environment and the business competitiveness contribute to the customers’ bargaining power.
Besides the low switching cost which makes it easy for the customers to buy various shoes, the
limited consumer size limits the individual forces on the firm (RubberSole, n.d).
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 4
Competitive Rivalry
In the classical framework, the competition among the rival companies propel the profits
to zero. However, competition is never perfect and the companies in the market are complex
passive price takers (Thompson et al. 2016). Resultantly, firms in the market strive for a
competitive advantage over their rivals. Specifically, competition defines how RubberSole
sustains its share of the footwear market in the United Kingdom. Based on the Five Force
assessment, the competition impacts the market setting as well as the performance of
RubberSole. The Five Force depicts a high external force that generates a significant force of
competitive rivalry in the case of RubberSole. The declined rate of market growth is significantly
due to the company’s concentration in one market position. In fact, this condition generates
pressure on RubberSole as the company competes for the UK market with other international as
well as locally based firms. Besides, international firms that have established stores in the United
Kingdom are aggressive in competing for market shares with RubberSole. Based on the factors
of the Five Force assessment, these external factors that generate significant competition requires
Threat of Substitution
According to the Five Forces assessment, substitute product comes from other industries.
Specifically, the threat of substitution exists when the demands of a product are affected by the
price alteration of the substitute product (Thompson et al. 2016). In fact, substitutes have a threat
to RubberSole’s performance as the main dealer in footwear products in the United Kingdom.
The existence of substitute causes a significant force against RubberSole since the buyers have a
various alternative to RubberSole’s products. Resultantly, the customer has a high chance of
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 5
considering substitutes because of the high performance of the substitutes when compared to
Both the threats of the existing companies as well as the possibility that new companies
may enter the market effects competition. Theoretically, any company should be entered and
exist an industry freely (Thompson et al. 2016). When there exist free entry and exist, the profits
are expected to be nominal. However, the market entails traits that safeguard the high-profit
margins of companies and limit more rivals from entering the industry. RuberSole has the most
cost efficiently degree of production where the unit cost of production as at minimal. The
existence of the minimum efficient scale develops a barrier to entry. Specifically, this prevents
Political Factors
United Kingdom approach to leave the EU in 2016 was projected to cause political
uncertainty and upheaval. Specifically, the most regions in the UK experienced political turmoil
with David Cameron, the British Prime Minister resigning afterward and most of the nations in
EU seeking to protect their interest in EU (Douglas & Gross, 2016). Specifically, this caused
uncertainty to international business who had operations in the UK. However, RubberSole
benefited from the weak pound which fell against the Euro since their operations were only
based in the UK. In fact, this approach causes some companies such as Primark to have
uncertainty in the UK business environment and financial market. Particularly, the threat of
Britain leaving EU had an adverse transactional effect on the profit margin of international
Economic Factors
UK is one of the established players in the shoe industry and among the strongest
economies in the European Union with sixth greatest GDP per capita in the context of
purchasing power (Datamonitor, 2010). The increase in value-added tax from 17.5% to 20%
(2010-2011) propelled retailers to increase prices and made the consumer be careful when
buying products (Government of UK, n.d). The increase in food prices, as well as the austerity
measures, have threatened the disposable income and increase the competition in the UK.
Furthermore, the pound currency has been depreciating against the Euro in recent times and it
has been projected to increase the cost of importation (FOX News, n.d). Since 2007, there has
been a decrease in the inflation rate which had a significant impact on the importation
competitiveness.
Social Factors
The most social trend that most retailing establishment in UK face is the rising obesity
and an aging population. National Health Service (NHS) terms the UK as the “fat man of
Europe” with nearly 65% of the British men and 54% of the women being overweight or obese
((NHS, 2015). It has been demonstrated that most obese women shoppers avoid shopping at
specific stores because of the lack of extra sizes and ranges. In fact, this is depicted by some
retailers such as the Topshop and Zara who do not have stock plus size ranges (FOX News, n.d).
However, the increasing incidence of obesity avail a significant gap in the market opportunity for
RubberSole to cater for plus size consumers. With nearly 50% of the UK population projected to
The existing trend depicts that the young and middle-aged generation (23-40 years) enjoy
changing their footwear on a regular basis based on the existing fashion. Besides, the consumer
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 7
behavior has been transitioning towards low-end of the market. While the mid-market products
decline in 2010, the private label products appeared to perform well. RubberSole present a high
growth as the company suits British ladies who enjoy purchasing “grab and go” such as sandals
and flats (RubberSole, n.d). However, UK expects to have a significant increase of the people
above the age of 50 by 2019 due to better health and lifestyle. In fact, the number of over 65
years old accounts for almost 30% of the UK population (FOX News, n.d). Statistics reveal that
the aging population has a significant relation to business opportunities as pension aged
consumer have sufficient income as they are employed full time for long and earn higher
disposable income than the young age. Surprisingly, 64% of people above the age of 50 buy
shoes online which depicts online shopping as a significant trend and opportunity (FOX News,
n.d).
Technological Factors
more competition for companies in the UK footwear retail as evidence with the uprising of
online pure-plays such as the Boohoo, Amazon, and Asos (Sustainable Business Report, n.d.)
These new distribution channels are opening competitive spaces because of their relative ease
and minimum cost of operation. Generally, the competition is fierce among the big companies
which have strong positions. Being a mid-market retailer, RubberSole will struggle with the
fierce competition due to the tendency of the consumer to buy international products.
RubberSole with its focus on website shopping causes a competition for international firms
Environmental Factors
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 8
The emerging trends that affect the UK footwear market entail the increasing
environmentally and ethically concern consumers who consistently demand companies to adopt
practices such as the use of recycled products and paper packaging. Rubbersole has already
launched products that environmentally friendly. The UK government has also pressured many
Legal Factors
One of the most legal factor impacting the footwear market in the UK is the inclusion of
the new Workplace Pension law that propels companies to contribute 3% to their staff’s
Strategic Alternatives
success and increase the bottom line. One of the strategies entails outsourcing from well-
established international companies. The footwear industry in the UK is fairly mature and a
downward fall in the size of the market is projected in the future. However, the decline rate is
likely to be slow and thus present an opportunity for RubberSole to restructure and adapt to the
UK environment. Besides, the changes in fashion are faster and more ad hoc through the
influence of celebrities and media on shoes which implies that the producers have to adapt to a
rapid turnover in shoe styles. Resultantly, outsourcing has increasingly taken place in a way that
the producers supply small quantities and ensure a time to market. Specifically, outsourcing has
been an ongoing trend for years. For instance, footwear companies such as Nike have relocated
some of their production to UK which provides the retailers in the UK an opportunity to grade up
and stay competitive. In order for RubberSole to sustain competition in the UK and share some
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 9
of its cost, it has to join with designers, colleagues and trade associates which is more effective
Another approach is to focus on the rising obesity and an aging population. NHS (2015)
terms the UK as the “fat man of Europe” with nearly 65% of the British men and 54% of the
women being overweight or obese. In 2015, the prevalence of diabetes in the UK was estimated
to be in the region of between 4.6% and 6.0%, representing about 3.2 million people (NHS,
2015). This is likely to rise over time, to an estimated 5 million by 2025. The increasing
incidence of obesity avail a significant gap in the market opportunity for RubberSole to cater for
plus size consumers. With nearly 50% of the UK population projected to be obese by 2050,
RuberSole should consider investing in plus size footwear. The number of over 65 years old
accounts for almost 30% of the UK population. Statistics reveal that the aging population has a
significant relation to business opportunities as pension aged consumer have sufficient income as
they are employed full time for long and earn higher disposable income than the young age.
Surprisingly, 64% of people above the age of 50 buy shoes online which depicts online shopping
Finally, an expansion into the Russian market will benefit RubberSole. Russia is one of
the fast-growing economies in Europe demonstrated by the 2018 World Cup and it is
transitioning towards more market based as well as international mix economy through the
facilitation of new business entrance (Euromonitor International, 2016). Although the recent
events involving Russia and Ukraine had a strong effect on foreign business, the nation imported
nearly USD$ 3 million of footwear. In 2015, the Russian footwear market grew 12% up to
USD$12 billion (APICCAPS, 2015). In social terms, the income distribution among the
population is quite uneven which makes the difference between low and high-income families
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 10
quite significant. However, foreign products are often socially perceived as quality products and
people are willing to pay more for them, in order to guarantee the quality and durability.
Strategic Choice
The most conservative scenario for RubberSole is a consistent decline in sales volume.
Based on the company’s participation in a competitive market that has limited barriers of the
entrance, the changing trends in fashion as well as technological improvement, the revenue has
declined in website use, male adult product, accessories and female adult range. However, there
is a revenue growth for the children products at 26%. The increase in revenue and growth rate
among children product is an extension of historical trends and RubberSole’s ability to use the
A strategic shift to enter into the Russian market appears to an excellent approach for
RubberSole to compensate to the sales decline and make business growth competitive
environment in the future. RubberSole can maximize its strength and opportunities as well as
minimize its weaknesses and threats in its approach to enter the Russian market. The company
should increase revenues by penetrating the Russian market and exploring its potential by using
the best know-how in shoes, its inherent quality, and brand. The use of low fixed costs can
rapidly expand the production and create economies of scale by ordering more from the suppliers
and achieving a lower price. When deciding to enter the Russian market, RubberSole should
choose to supply only the footwear, disregarding the uniforms and accessories segments, in order
to avoid competition on fields with poor competitive advantage. This will also diminish the tax
impact which will be charged on only one category of product. This could be a pilot strategy in
order to understand whether the market is receptive to additional product categories. Finally, the
company should make an extra effort in the customization field and start by offering the product
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 11
in the B2C segment, in order to take advantage of the willingness to spend more for comfort
footwear. This strategy will overcome the low-cost product dominance competing in quality and
avoid the bargaining power of B2C clients by presenting a new product which fulfills their
needs.
and their effect on the supply chain. One aspect of Key Performance indication is Return on
Equity. Particularly, this is the amount of net income returned as a percentage of shareholder’s
equity. ROE is popularly used to connect shareholders’ equity (balance sheet) to income
statement (net profit/loss). Besides representing the end outcome of structured financial ratio
assessment, REO has a contribution towards it popularity among financial analysts and
shareholders (Stowe, Robinson, Pinto, & McLeavy, 2002). The approach to calculate ROE is net
income divided by equity or profit margin × Total Asset Turnover × Financial leverage (Jang &
Tang, 2009). The profit margins present information regarding the ability of the company to
produce funds internally. A company that has poor margin is likely to be distressed while
improvement in the profit margin demonstrates a likely reduction in production cost factors as
well as the inventory costs or an increase in the price of the company’s product. Although it is
important to have high profit margin, the return earned by stockholders is affected by the stock
price. The asset turnover ratio provides knowledge regarding the quantity of sales produced for
every pound’s worth of assets. When the assets turnover ratio is low, it implies the increase in
productivity from the asset base. As such, a growth can happen due to high efficiency in
operation or sales increase which implies an improvement in the market condition for the
company’s products. Financial leverage signifies the company’s long-term debt levels. A high
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 12
leverage, demonstrated through past change in the percentage of total long-term debt to average
total assets can either be a negative or positive indication to the investors (Jang & Tang, 2009).
However, through the increase of external capital, a company that is in financial distress is likely
to be unable to produce enough internal funds. The product of profit margin and total assets
Another approach to assess a firm’s supply chain efficiency is through different formulas
regarding inventory. One way to judge a company’s supply chain efficiency is through
inventory turnover. Inventory turnover is how fast the company can turn over its inventory over a
one year period. If a company has a HIGH inventory turnover rate, this means the company has
low inventory, which could be good in a way because the company would spend less on storage
that would include rent, utilities and other costs (Jang & Tang, 2009). An item that only turns
over once in a year, has a lot higher carrying cost than an item that can be turned over several
times during the same period. High inventory turnover also is an indicator of strong sales.
Different industries will have very different turnover rates. For example, since RubberSole is in
footwear/apparel, the turnover rate needs to be higher due to fashions changing constantly. In
contrast, a car dealership would have quite a bit lower turnover rate because cars move a lot
slower than fashion items. However, a company does not want such a high turnover rate that
could lead to inadequate inventory to cover any future orders. A low inventory turnover may be
due to limited marketing campaigns and overstock. RubberSole’s inventory decreased from 2015
to 2016 when it went from 30814 to 28624 but from 2016 to 2017 in increased to 29663
(RubberSole Financial Analysis). To arrive at the turnover rate takes the gross margin dived by
the average inventory. RubberSole’s annual gross margin in 2017 was 76312 dollars; divide this
by the average inventory of the same period of 29663 and the turnover for the year 2017 is 2.573
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 13
(RubberSole financial analysis). This turnover rate is lower than the average turnover rate for
RubberSole due to their inventory buildup. A higher rate implies fewer funds directed to storage
of the inventory and old out of date inventory. Therefore, RubberSole has some work to increase
their inventory turnover ratio which can be achieved by getting rid some of their inventory
buildups.
Financial Analysis
DECISIONS
Price positioning before in-store prom otions Past decisions 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
PRICING v Market benchmarks Female adult range 0% 0% 0% 4.0% 5.0% 5.0% 6.0% 7.0%
Male adult range -5% -5% -5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5%
Children and Young Teenage 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0%
Accessories 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0%
On-line discounts 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10%
Shelf Space usage SKUs Female adult range 55.0% 55.0% 55.0% 55.0% 55.0% 55.0% 55.0% 55.0%
Male adult range 17.0% 17.0% 17.0% 17.0% 17.0% 17.0% 17.0% 17.0%
Children and Young Teenage 22.0% 22.0% 22.0% 22.0% 22.0% 22.0% 22.0% 22.0%
Accessories 6.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0% 6.0%
Marketing & merchandising
as % of previous year sales In store promotions 10.0% 10.0% 10.0% 10.0% 10.0% 10.0% 10.0% 10.0%
Web site advertising 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0%
Brand Advertising / Sponsorship 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0%
Store management Retail Staff hourly pay rate 11.00 11.13 11.24 11.50 11.50 11.50 11.50 11.50
Retail Staff training as % of work time 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0%
Number of New in-store coffee shop franchises 2 10 10 15 20 25 30 30
New store openings / closures 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 2
Forecasts Exchange Rate US$ to £ sterling 1.50 1.50 1.35 1.30 1.30 1.30 1.30 1.30
Long term interest rates 3.5% 3.5% 3.0% 4.0% 3.5% 3.5% 3.5% 3.5%
RubberSole is projected to be a healthy company. For the next five years, the company will
outperform its current industry standards. In order to calculate the outcome of the scenario it was
assumed that in the first year of partnership, RubberSole is going to supply a national firm in
Russia with the four products: female adult footwear; male adult footwear; children and young
teenage footwear and accessories. Hence, it is considered that RubberSole is not going to benefit
from any B2C sales, and the incremental revenues correspond only to the contract with Russian
Company.
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 15
4400
4300
4200
4100
4000
3900
3800
3700
3600
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Hence, according to this scenario, RubberSole is going to sell a total of 6393 thousand
pairs of footwear by 2022. The forecasted Net Present Value is 1 203 286€. Nevertheless, one
must pay special attention to import duties to Russian Federation (5.2%). Hence, the import duty
of +160 000 pairs (supplied in the 1st year) accounts for more than 35 000€ of total incremental
costs.
Gross Margin %
50%
49%
49%
48%
48%
47%
2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
In the next five years, both the gross merging is expected to increase drastically with 48%
for the first three years and increase to 49% in the following two years. Gross margin measures
the number of net sales over cost of goods sold in a percentage form. Gross margin is calculated
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 16
before interest expense and will show an increase because of greater efficiency. The drastic
increase is due to inventory buildup as the company establishes itself in the Russian market. As
the business progress into the new market, the gross margin is expected to rise to 49%. In fact,
this high rate implies that the funds spent on storage of the inventory and old out of date
inventory, so RubberSole will have little work to increase their inventory turnover ratio which
can be achieved by getting rid of some of their inventory buildups. Since inventories will be
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
RubberSole will realize a slight decrease in debt ratio from 53% in 2018 to 15% by 2022
which will help determine the Rate of Return on investment. Debt ratio measures the amount of
debt in the capital structure. As it can be seen from the above figure, the debt ratio will begin
decreasing after entering the Russian Market. Debt ratio will eventually decrease because of the
capital gains realized from the sale of excess assets. Specifically, this ratio will speak to the
ability of RubberSole to compensate shareholders for their financial risk. In 2017, the ROE was
at 54% which is very good for the industry and will decrease to 15% by 2022. The return on
assets which will also increase speaks to how RubberSole can leverage their assets to generate
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 17
return or revenue. Although RubberSole has limited operating capital and income, it has a
healthy ROE. Specifically, this will attract investors and trust from financial institutions for debt
servicing. According to the RubberSole’s case, the firm as the capability through current assets
to pay off all their bills and financial obligation. Projecting the future, RubberSole will achieve
growth by decreasing inventory and maximizing their return on equity. The company has the
financial leverage to push innovation and the ability to sustain growth. In monitoring of their
financial health and ratio trends, it can be assumed that RubberSole will continue to create
Risk Assessments
The significant risk is that the use of return on equity could mislead the financial
the alteration of accounting policy in the legal context. Besides, the more the financial leverage,
the high the ROE provided that the returns attained on the borrowed funds exceed the cost of
borrowing (Fama & French, 2012). However, the increase in the leverage beyond specific degree
may lead to an increase in RubberSole’s systematic risk. Besides, inflation has an adverse impact
on the profit margin which will likely reduce the ROE as well as the expected growth. In
instances where RubberSole assumes extra debt to extend to new international market, the
company may experience distress. The problems associated with long-term debts are focused
upon debt management. If the debt cannot allow funds to be properly allocated to operational
expenses, a default will be a likelihood. Since leverage involves large amounts of debt, cash flow
projections should be initiated to avoid default (Fama & French, 2012). The leverages are
intended to be a short-term investment as excess assets are sold and the associated capital gains
are sufficient to reduce the debt (Fama & French, 2012). The long-term investment is the
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 18
refocusing of RubberSole’s objectives that will allow the company to effectively compete in the
future. Therefore, a successful leverage depends upon whether management will reduce the debt
RubberSole is currently among the major players in the footwear market in the UK. For
them to sustain or grow their position they need to be committed to using financial and
operational tools to grow their revenue. As demonstrated in the report, there are various ways to
grow way revenue through a focus on ROA, ROE, and market capitalization while decreasing
tax and interest expense to increase the bottom line without significant philosophical changes.
The use of investment income and cash flow can attain capitalize acquisitions and capital
improvements without increasing debt expense. Growth in major foreign markets such as Asia
and Australia where economically the middle class is growing and can support the purchase of
footwear and fashion shoes. Besides, RubberSole can use social media to decrease marketing and
advertising dollars, along with maximizing political influence to gain foreign market share and
maximizing sponsorship opportunities such as the fashion shows to reach various market niches.
industry average are strong, based on profit margins, management efficiency of assets and equity
and market capitalization. RubberSole. needs to focus on an optimal capital structure, utilizing
both equity and debt structures to maximize net profits effectively while expanding into foreign
markets and maintaining current markets to remain a trusted brand leader in fashion footwear. In
focus on advanced design and product development to maintain their competitive advantage.
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 19
Maximizing their economical and minimizing their environmental impact will only strengthen
the brand.
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 20
References
Douglas, J., and Gross, J. (2016) ‘Brexit’ Sparks Political Turmoil across U.K.Wall Street
party-1466937187
Euromonitor International. (2016). Footwear in Russia. Accessed November 18. Retrieved from
http://fesrvsd.fe.unl.pt:2117/portal/analysis/tab
Fama, E.F., & French, K.R. (2012). Size, value, and momentum in international stock returns.
http://www.foxnews.com/printer_friendly_wires/2008Mar13/04675NikeChina00html>.
Inbound Logistics. n.d "Perfect Order Fulfillment: Getting it All Right. Retrieved from
<http://www.inboundlogistics.com/cms/article/perfect-order-fulfillment-getting-it-all-
right/>.
Jang, S., & Tang, C.H. (2009). Simultaneous impacts of international diversification and
347-368.
Johnson, G., Scholes, K., & Whittington, R. (2005). Exploring Corporate Strategy Text and
http://www.nhs.uk/Livewell/loseweight/Pages/statistics-and-causes-of-the-obesity-
epidemic-in-the-UK.aspx
RUBBERSOLE BUSINESS PLAN 21
Thompson, A. A., Peteraf, M. A., Gamble, J. E., and Strickland III, A. J. 2016. Crafting and
executing strategy: The quest for competitive advantage, concepts, and cases. New York,
McGraw-Hill education.