Bcga Code of Practice 36 Cryogenic Liquid Storage at Users' Premises
Bcga Code of Practice 36 Cryogenic Liquid Storage at Users' Premises
Bcga Code of Practice 36 Cryogenic Liquid Storage at Users' Premises
Revision 2: 2013
ISSN 0260-4809
For the assistance of users, references are given, either in the text or
Appendices, to publications such as British, European and
International Standards and Codes of Practice, and current
legislation that may be applicable but no representation or warranty
can be given that these references are complete or current.
1 INTRODUCTION 2
2 SCOPE 2
8 TRAINING 26
8.1 Training of personnel 26
8.2 Emergency procedures 26
9 REFERENCES * 27
Appendixes:
Appendix 1 Hazards from asphyxiation. 31
Appendix 2 Hazards from oxygen enrichment. 32
Appendix 3 Minimum safety distances. 33
Appendix 4 Plan view of liquid transfer area access apron and tanker 41
standing area.
Appendix 5 “Burns” due to very cold liquefied gases. 42
Appendix 6 Guidance for assessment of ventilation requirements. 44
System
Relevant Fluid
Danger
Examination These terms are defined in the Pressure Systems Safety Regulations
(7).
User
Protective
Device
Owner
Access Apron Indicates an area between the tank or fill point and a tanker where the
process operating controls on both tank and tanker are accessible to the
operator during filling/discharging.
Competent The competent person should have such practical and theoretical
Person knowledge and actual experience of the type of plant which he has to
examine as will enable him to detect defects or weaknesses, which it
is the purpose of the examination to discover, and to assess their
importance in relation to the strength and function of the plant.
Equivalent levels of knowledge and experience are also required for
competent persons engaged in the writing or certifying of Written
Schemes of Examination.
Cryogenic For the purpose of this document cryogenic liquid is liquid oxygen,
liquid nitrogen, helium and argon.
Liquid Transfer Indicates an area adjacent to the tank or fill point which surrounds the
Area tanker, when the latter is in the filling/discharging position, and which
includes the access apron.
1
BCGA CODE OF PRACTICE 36
BULK CRYOGENIC LIQUID STORAGE AT USERS’ PREMISES
1. INTRODUCTION
The objective of the BCGA Code of Practice is to make reference where applicable to UK
legislation and British Standards where these apply to cryogenic air gas systems and to take
into account the specific practices of the UK industrial gas companies particularly in relation to
safety distances.
This Code of Practice is based generally on the European Industrial Gases Association (EIGA)
Document 115 (30), Storage of cryogenic air gases at users’ premises, but in some instances
gives more detailed requirements for the UK especially for tanks below 2,000 Litres. The
British Compressed Gases Association (BCGA) is grateful for the active help and co-operation
of the Health and Safety Executive (HSE). With the permission of EIGA, sections of the EIGA
Document have also been duplicated.
The BCGA wishes to acknowledge the work done by the EIGA committee that prepared EIGA
Document 115 (30).
The storage of cryogenic gases in the liquid state under pressure at users' premises not only
provides an efficient way of storing gas, but improves safety when used in conjunction with a
distribution system by eliminating the need for cylinder handling. However, the particular
properties of cryogenic gases necessitate certain precautions to be taken and certain rules to
be followed.
This document is intended for the guidance of those persons directly associated with the
design, operation and maintenance of bulk liquid storage installations. It does not claim to
cover the subject completely but gives advice and should be used with sound engineering
judgment.
BCGA has also published Leaflet 12 (48), Liquid gas storage tanks: Your responsibilities,
which is a simple user guide that advises users and owners of liquid gas storage tanks on their
legal responsibilities and duty of care to ensure that the equipment is maintained and operated
safely.
All new storage installations shall comply with this Code of Practice.
2. SCOPE
A cryogenic liquid storage system installation on a users’ premises is defined for the purposes
of this Code of Practice as the installed static liquid storage tank together with the control
equipment and safety devices, vaporising equipment, the storage location, access apron and the
liquid transfer area.
This document applies to static, vacuum insulated, tanks with an individual water capacity up
to 125,000 litres operating at pressures greater than 0.5 bar above atmospheric pressure
designed to store cryogenic liquids.
2
This document may also be used as guidance for installations in excess of 125,000 litres
including multiple tanks operating as a single tank; applicable regulations may impose
different safety distances and legal requirements e.g. The Control of Major Accident Hazards
Regulations (COMAH) (6), see also HSE HSG 191 (15), Emergency Planning for major
accidents.
For cylinder filling depots operated by gas suppliers, individual tank storage capacity is
normally less than 125,000 litres. In such cases BCGA Code of Practice (CP) 20 (32) Bulk
liquid oxygen storage at production sites, and BCGA CP 22 (33) Bulk liquid argon or nitrogen
storage at production sites, should only apply to these systems when the tank is connected to a
manufacturing plant. However the minimum safety distances, the provision for periodic
inspection, testing and examination and the liquid transfer area specified in this Code of
Practice may be applied.
(ii) The storage of compressed gas cylinders. Refer to BCGA Guidance Note
(GN) 02 (44).
The BCGA have published the following Codes of Practice for liquefied gas systems not
covered by this Code:
Codes produced by other associations should be consulted for installations that include gases
not covered by the scope of this document nor detailed in the above references. Examples
include Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG) and Hydrogen.
3.1 General
Gaseous oxygen, nitrogen, argon and helium are colourless, odourless and tasteless.
Nitrogen, argon and helium are non-toxic but asphyxiant.
Oxygen is not toxic; it is slightly denser than air. It is not a flammable gas but
vigorously supports combustion. Breathing pure oxygen at atmospheric pressure is
not dangerous although exposure for several hours may cause temporary functional
disorders to the lungs.
3
The following documents should be taken into consideration:
BCGA GN11 (45) Use of gases in the workplace. The management of risks
associated with reduced oxygen atmospheres.
EIGA Doc 4 (26) Fire hazards of oxygen and oxygen enriched atmospheres
The physical properties of nitrogen, argon, oxygen and helium are given in Table 1:
Liquid density at 1.013 bar and boiling 0.8 1.39 1.14 0.1
temperature kg/l
Cold oxygen, nitrogen and argon vapours are heavier than air and may accumulate in
pits and trenches.
3.3 Precautions
The properties of oxygen, nitrogen, argon, and helium justify the following special
precautions:
Nitrogen, argon and helium will act as asphyxiants by displacing the oxygen from the
atmosphere.
The hazards from oxygen enrichment or deficiency are explained in the BCGA /
EIGA documents detailed in Section 3.1.
4
Good ventilation shall always be provided in places where liquid cryogenic gases are
stored, used and / or transferred.
A risk assessment in accordance with the Confined Spaces Regulations (3) should be
made where the use or leakage of these gases could affect the safety and health of
persons in a confined space.
Severe damage to the skin may be caused by contact with liquid cryogenic gases, and
their cold gases or with uninsulated pipes or receptacles containing liquid cryogenic
gases. For this reason appropriate personal protective equipment, including gloves
and eye protection, shall be worn when handling equipment in liquid cryogenic gases
service.
All the safety aspects of handling cryogenic liquid cannot be covered adequately in this
Code of Practice. The reader is therefore referred to the British Cryoengineering
Society, Cryogenic Safety Manual (49), for further information.
Ambient air may condense on uninsulated pipes and vessels containing liquid
nitrogen and helium causing local oxygen enrichment of the atmosphere. Insulating
materials should be chosen bearing in mind that oxygen enrichment may occur.
3.7.3 Cleaning
Before putting equipment into service with oxygen, either for the first time
or following maintenance, it is essential that all surfaces which may come
into contact with an oxygen enriched environment are "clean for oxygen
service", which means: dry and free from any loose or virtually loose
5
constituents, such as slag, rust, weld residues, blasting materials and entirely
free from hydrocarbons or other materials incompatible with oxygen.
The maintenance and assembly of equipment for oxygen shall be carried out
under clean, oil free conditions. All tools and protective clothing (such as
overalls, gloves and footwear) shall be clean and free of grease and oil,
where gloves are not used, clean hands are essential.
It is important that all traces of degreasing agents are removed from the
system prior to commissioning with oxygen. Some agents, such as
halogenated solvents, may be non-flammable in air, but can explode in
oxygen enriched atmospheres or in liquid oxygen. Where the user or
installer is unsure of the cleaning process to be used specialist cleaning
companies should be employed. These companies should also take the
responsibility for the supply of appropriately registered chemicals and the
safe and legal disposal of used cleaning agents.
Nitrogen, argon, and helium do not react with oil or grease, but it is good
practice to apply a high standard of cleanliness, although not as stringent as
those required for oxygen installations.
BS IEC 60877 (24) Code of Practice for procedures for ensuring the
cleanliness of industrial process, measurement and
control equipment for oxygen service.
Metals suitable for cryogenic liquid service include 9 % nickel steel, 18/8 stainless steel
and other austenitic stainless steels, copper and its alloys and aluminium alloys.
PTFE is the most widely used plastic material for sealing purposes in cryogenic service
but other reinforced plastics are also used. For further information on materials see BS
5429 (18), Code of Practice for safe operation of small-scale storage facilities for
cryogenic liquids.
Oxygen is within the scope of The Dangerous Substances and Explosive Atmospheres
Regulations (DSEAR) (8) and requires a risk assessment in accordance with these
regulations. Guidance on DSEAR Risk Assessment is available in BCGA GN 13 (46).
For electrical equipment, see the safety distance diagram for oxygen storage in
Appendix 3.
7
4. LAYOUT AND DESIGN FEATURES
4.1 General
The installation shall be sited to minimise risk to personnel, local population and
property. Consideration should be given to the location of any potentially hazardous
processes in the vicinity, which could jeopardise the integrity of the storage installation.
An installation may, because of its size or strategic location, come within the scope of
specific planning controls. If so, the siting of any proposed installation shall be
discussed and agreed with the local authority and appropriate sections of the Health and
Safety Executive.
Tanks containing a gas at a pressure of less than 0.5 bar above atmospheric pressure are
not covered by the Pressure Equipment Regulations (5). However, in order to comply
with regulation 4 of The Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations (4), the
tank should be properly designed and properly constructed from suitable material so as
to prevent danger. This is best guaranteed by adherence to a recognised design standard
for this type of tank and its intended use.
Where appropriate, tanks shall be designed to withstand wind loads in accordance with
the appropriate design codes e.g. BS EN 1991 (17), Eurocode 1. Actions on structures.
General actions. Wind actions.
4.2.1 Materials
All components shall be constructed from materials compatible with the
liquefied gas in service, and with the temperature and pressure conditions to
which they will be subjected.
All materials of construction for tanks which may be used for oxygen
service shall be oxygen compatible, including all insulation, getters, piping,
valves, gaskets, seals and instruments.
8
EIGA Document 24 (27), Vacuum insulated cryogenic storage tank systems
pressure protection devices, provides a code of practice for pressure
protection devices for static cryogenic vacuum insulated storage tanks.
For sizing the relieving capacity of pressure relief devices all operational
conditions shall be considered including:
(d) Any other foreseeable source of energy input into the vessel i.e.
fire, pump recycle systems.
At least one online pressure relief valve (or combination of small relief
valves) shall have a capacity and set-point that will prevent the pressure
within the vessel exceeding the maximum allowable working pressure in
accordance with the applicable vessel design code. The combined capacity
of all online relief devices shall be sufficient to prevent the test pressure of
the tank being exceeded, in the event of loss of vacuum combined with the
pressure-build up system failing in the open position.
The relieving devices shall be designed to operate effectively across the full
range of working temperatures.
Due consideration shall be given to the direction of any relief device vent so
that it does not affect the safety of personnel or equipment. Consideration
shall also be given to the ease of access to the three-way change over valves
for operation when a relief device is discharging.
Outer jackets need not be designed to a pressure vessel design standard, but
they shall be capable of withstanding full vacuum.
Outer jackets shall be fitted with a device to relieve pressure increase in the
event of a leak from the inner vessel. The device shall be set to open at a
pressure of not more than 0.5 bar. The discharge area of the pressure relief
device shall be not less than 0.34 mm2 per litre capacity of the inner vessel
but not less than 10 mm diameter.
4.2.3 Markings
The tank shall be marked in accordance with the requirements set out in
paragraph 3.3 of schedule 2 of the Pressure Equipment Regulations (5). The
safe operating limits should be readily accessible.
(a) Any point on the storage system where in normal operation leakage or
spillage can occur (e.g. hose couplings, including those on extended
fill lines, relief valve vents, etc), or
(ii) Protect the installation from the effects of thermal radiation or jet
flame impingement from fire hazards.
The minimum safety distances given in this Code of Practice are based on experience
and calculations of minor release. The minimum safety distances given are not
intended to protect against catastrophic failure of the liquid storage vessel. Previous
operating history, the protective devices fitted, material properties and the mode of
vessel construction support this philosophy.
The distances given in Appendix 3 are intended to protect the storage installation as
well as personnel and the environment. They are considered to give protection against
risks involved, according to practical experience, in the normal operation of storage
installations, covered by this Code of Practice.
10
These distances correspond to well established practice and are derived from
operational experience within Europe and the USA. They relate to over hundreds of
thousands of tank years in service.
Shorter distances may be used if a site specific risk assessment in line with EIGA
methodology (using HSE fatality rates) indicates an acceptable level of risk.
Consideration shall be given for provision to divert any spillage towards the safest
available area.
The distance between the installation and the exposure around the ends of the
segregation walls should be equal to or greater than the separation distance given in
Appendix 3.
Care must be taken to ensure that good ventilation is retained. Where access is required
for maintenance, a minimum clearance of 0.6 metres shall be maintained between the
barrier or wall and the installation to allow free access and egress from the enclosure. It
is recommended that walls should not be constructed on more than two sides of the
installation. Where this is unavoidable a risk assessment shall be conducted.
When gas is not being withdrawn, pressure within the tank will gradually increase to
the point where the relief valve will lift. Although the rate of gas discharge is small,
precautions shall be taken to avoid the build up of dangerous atmospheres.
Storage installations should be situated in the open air in a well-ventilated position and
where there is no risk of damage by passing vehicles.
Storage tanks should be at the same level as the tanker parking area to enable the
operator/driver to control the transfer operations.
(a) The exhaust of the vessel pressure relief devices and the vents are
piped away to a fixed safe external location, or
(b) the installation is within an enclosed space of adequate size such that
using the calculation in Appendix 6, the release of gas will not result
in an atmosphere with an oxygen concentration outside the limits of
19.5 % and 23.5 %.
11
Consideration shall be given for the tank to be vented in an emergency and during
filling. This may be achieved by the use of the try-cock / vent exhaust in which case
they shall be piped away to a fixed safe external location that is visible from the fill
connection.
NOTE: (a) and (b) only provide protection against risks presented by releases from the
tank and not through the use of the product.
A road tanker, when in position for filling from or discharging to the fill connection,
should be in the open air. Tanker operators shall have easy access to and from the fill
connection.
The formula in Appendix 6 may still be used to calculate the effects of minor
leakages, e.g. from try-cock or thermal relief valves.
Consideration shall also be given to the use of oxygen monitors where ventilation
arrangements are poor and it is not practical to increase natural ventilation or install
forced ventilation.
(iv) Below ground level as far as is practicable away from normal work
locations.
Tanks of a capacity greater than 2,000 litres shall not be located where natural air
ventilation is inhibited, unless they are subjected to a suitable and sufficient risk
assessment. Examples of locations where such risk assessments are required are:
(C) Below ground level or where there are pits, ditches and other ground
depressions.
12
incorporates a warning alarm shall be considered. The following provides
some guidance on the selection of appropriate equipment.
Detector displays and warning signs shall be sited so that they are clearly
visible to personnel before entering the affected area.
The slope of the ground shall be such as to allow surface water run off.
13
4.4.4 Position of gas vents
Vents, including those of safety relief devices, shall vent to a safe place in
the open and comply with the safety distances shown in Appendix 3. They
shall be directed so as not to impinge on personnel, occupied buildings and
structural steelwork.
Oxygen vents shall be so positioned that the flow from them cannot mix
with that from flammable gas or liquid vents.
All vent systems shall be adequately supported to cope with loads created
during discharge.
Vapour clouds from releases are generally low lying (typically below waist
height). Such vapour clouds may be quite extensive depending on weather
conditions and persons working below ground or at low level in the vicinity
may be at risk.
(i) BCGA Technical Report 1 (41), A method for estimating the off-
site risks from bulk storage of liquefied oxygen.
14
A road tanker, when in position for filling from or discharging to the
installation, shall be in the open air and not be in a walled enclosure from
which the escape of liquid or heavy vapour is restricted. Tankers should have
easy access to and from the installation at all times.
The installation shall be protected from vehicular damage that could result in
product release.
The liquid transfer area should normally be located adjacent to the fill
coupling of the installation and be positioned in such a way that it facilitates
the movement of the tanker in the case of an emergency. Extended fill lines
should be avoided if possible. Unless the tank is specifically designed for
remote filling, suitable ‘repeater’ gauges and valves should be installed at the
extended fill point. The length of extended filling lines should be kept to a
minimum.
The road tanker transfer area for oxygen installations shall be made of
concrete or any other suitable non-porous non-combustible material. This
also includes any expansion joints.
Personnel and equipment should be protected from any oxygen pump fire by
means of barriers or suitable shielding. Openings used for access and / or free
or forced ventilation shall lead to a place where there is free escape for cold
vapour and where there will be no accumulation of combustible material,
liable to form a hazard.
15
Consideration shall also be given in the design of the installation to facilitate
the periodic testing of the pressure relief devices. (See Section 6.1.2).
Installation design shall ensure that the risk of pressure relief and vent line
blockage is minimised, and that intended purge and vent operations can be
safely and effectively carried out.
(ii) have only one means of isolation between the tank and the
atmosphere (such as liquid filling lines),
to prevent any large spillage of liquid should the primary isolating valve fail.
4.4.12 Couplings
In certain cases, filling the incorrect fluid into a tank may create an unsafe
condition; therefore liquid fill connections should be different for the
product categories detailed in Table 2.
Nitrogen / Argon
Oxygen / Medical Oxygen
Helium
Table 2: Product Categories
4.4.14 Fencing
Fencing is required to prevent access of unauthorised persons, where other
means are not provided.
16
On controlled sites with sufficient supervision fencing is optional.
Where fencing is provided and access around the tank is required for
maintenance, the minimum clearance between the fence and the installation
shall be 0.6 m to allow free access and escape from inside the enclosure.
For ‘open’ fences, the safety distances given in Appendix 3 will apply
regardless of the position of the fence.
Timber or other readily combustible materials shall not be used for fencing
around oxygen tanks.
Any gates should be outward opening and wide enough to provide for an easy
access and exit of personnel.
4.4.15 Vaporisers
Vaporisers may be an integral part of the tank assembly, or may be added as
part of the installation.
Vaporisers shall be adequately sized for the off-take rate specified by the
customer. Where necessary a device to restrict the flow to the maximum flow
capacity of the vaporisers shall be installed.
4.4.16 Foundations
The tank supplier will provide indicative foundation requirements but it is the
responsibility of the user to ensure the tank foundation is designed to safely
withstand the weight of the tank and its contents plus other possible loads
resulting from wind, snow, earthquake etc.
5.2 Personnel
The installation shall be so designed that authorised persons shall have easy access to
and exit from the operating area of the installation at all times.
18
5.3 Access to installation controls
Filling connections and equipment controls shall be located in such a way that easy
access to them is provided.
Filling connections and equipment controls should be located in close proximity to each
other and in such a way that tanker controls and indicators are visible and easily
accessible from the tanker operator’s position.
(ii) NO SMOKING *
19
Potential Cryogenic Oxidising No naked No Smoking No
Asphyxiating Liquid Substance flames Unauthorised
Atmosphere Access
These signs shall comply with The Health and Safety (Safety Signs and
Signals) Regulations (2) and with BS ISO 7010 (19), Graphical symbols.
Safety colours and safety signs. Registered safety signs.
20
(i) The product name shall be followed by the appropriate ‘E’
number as detailed in Table 3:
(iii) A mark identifying the batch or lot from which the gas came.
The letter “L” shall precede this mark, unless it is clearly
distinguishable from other markings.
21
Where a pneumatic pressure test is specified, nitrogen or dry oil-free air shall
be used as the test medium. The pressure in the system shall be increased
gradually up to the test pressure. Pneumatic pressure testing is potentially
hazardous and should be carried out in accordance with HSE Guidance Note
GS4 (14), Safety requirements for pressure testing.
Any defects found during the testing shall be rectified in an approved manner
and the system then retested.
A leak and function test shall be carried out in accordance with HSE Guidance
Note GS4 (14) and at a pressure in accordance with the applicable code or
regulation.
Pressure tests / leak tests shall be witnessed by a competent person and a test
certificate signed and issued. Such certificates shall be kept for future
reference.
Where relief devices are adjustable, tamper proof devices shall be fitted.
6.4 Commissioning
Prior to first fill checks shall be carried out to ensure the suitability of the installation
for commissioning.
(i) The appropriate pressure and leak tests have been carried out and
documented.
(ii) A check has been made that the installation conforms to the process
and instrumentation diagram.
22
(iii) A visual check has been made to ensure that back-feed from the
system into the container, e.g. from high-pressure gas cylinders, is not
possible.
(iv) A check has been made that liquefied gas cannot become trapped in
any part of the system not protected by thermal relief devices or reach parts
of the system not designed for low temperature use.
(v) A check has been made that the correct safety devices are fitted.
(vi) A check has been made that all warning and identification labels are
clearly displayed and that they are correct for the product being stored.
In addition, procedures shall be in place to ensure the following significant risks are
addressed:
(d) Noise.
6.5 Handover
The owner or the installer shall be responsible for the handover to the user.
23
(iii) The provision of a contact address and emergency telephone number
should the user have any questions about his installation.
(b) A Safety Data Sheet, which gives information in accordance with the
requirements of the Chemicals (Hazard Information and Packaging for
Supply) Regulations (10) and the European regulation on the Registration,
Evaluation, Authorisation and restriction of Chemicals (REACH) (12) and
which deals with the prevention of accidents arising from the uncontrolled
escape of product from the installation.
(i) Ensure that the user understands his responsibilities under the
PSSR (7) and has made arrangements for them to be fulfilled.
(ii) Establish and agree with the user procedures for the safe filling
of the tank.
When a tank is to be filled for the first time, the following checks shall be
made in addition to those required in Section 6.4:
(a) Check that all appropriate documentation for the particular tank
and accessories is available.
The tank shall be cooled down and filled according to the manufacturer’s
recommendations. Steps should be taken to avoid uncontrolled pressure rise
due to rapid liquid evaporation.
Measuring and control devices shall be checked for correct operation and
adjusted where appropriate.
A check should be made for leaks on all pipework and fittings and remedial
action taken where necessary.
24
EIGA Document 151 (31), Prevention of excessive pressure during filling of
cryogenic vessels, provides guidance to the filler / owner of either
transportable or static cryogenic tanks, detailing the systems and procedures
that can be used to prevent them being over pressurized, during filling.
The instructions shall define the safe operating limits of the system and
include the necessary safety information relating to the product and the
installation.
For the convenience of the operator the supplier may colour code or identify
by other means the hand wheels of these valves which are to be shut in an
emergency. These valves should normally be:
(i) Feed and return valves to and from the pressure build up
vaporiser.
The number of valves will vary, depending on the type of the installation.
Storage tanks are required to be rigorously inspected and approved by the Competent
Person during manufacture and thereafter be periodically endorsed by the Competent
Person as being fit for continued service. BCGA CP 25 (35), Revalidation of
cryogenic static storage tanks, provides guidelines for the periodic revalidation of
25
cryogenic liquid storage tanks which can be incorporated into either the Written
Schemes of Examination under the PSSR (7), or company maintenance and inspection
programmes.
BCGA Leaflet 11 (47), Safety checks for vacuum insulated storage tanks, provides a
simple user guide to daily safety checks which should be carried out on vacuum
insulated storage tanks.
BCGA Leaflet 12 (48) is a simple user guide that advises users and owners of liquid
gas storage tanks on their legal responsibilities and duty of care to ensure that the
equipment is maintained and operated safely.
8. TRAINING
Training shall be arranged to cover those aspects and potential hazards that the
particular operator is likely to encounter.
In addition individuals shall receive specific training in the activities for which they
are employed.
It is recommended that the training be carried out under a formalised system and that
records be kept of the training given and, where possible, some indication of the
results obtained, in order to show if further training is required.
The training programme should make provision for refresher courses on a periodic
basis.
(iv) Isolate the source of gases, if appropriate and where safely possible.
(v) Evacuate all persons from the affected area and seal it off.
(vi) Alert the public to possible hazards from vapour clouds and evacuate
when necessary.
After the liquid spillage has been isolated, oxygen enrichment / depletion checks should
be carried out in any enclosed areas where the vapour cloud may have entered. This
includes basements, pits and confined spaces.
9. REFERENCES
2. SI 1996 No. 341 The Health & Safety (Safety Signs and Signals). Regulations
1996.
4. SI 1998 No. 2306 The Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations
1998.
6. SI 1999 No. 743 The Control of Major Accident Hazards Regulations 1999
(COMAH).
9. SI 2005 No. 1541 The Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.
10. SI 2009 No. 716 The Chemicals (Hazard Information and Packaging for
Supply) Regulations 2009. (CHIP 4)
13. HSE L136 DSEAR Approved Code of Practice and guidance. Control
and mitigation measures.
15. HSE HSG 191 Emergency Planning for major accidents. COMAH
Regulations 1999.
19. BS ISO 7010 Graphical symbols. Safety colours and safety signs.
Registered safety signs.
20. BS 7786 Specification for unsintered PTFE tapes for general use.
24. BS IEC 60877 Procedures for ensuring the cleanliness of industrial process-
measurement and control equipment in oxygen service.
26. EIGA Document Fire hazards of oxygen and oxygen enriched atmospheres.
No. 04
27. EIGA Document Vacuum insulated cryogenic storage tank systems pressure
No. 24 protection devices.
33. BCGA Code of Bulk liquid argon or nitrogen storage at production sites.
Practice 22
34. BCGA Code of Application of the Pressure Systems Safety Regulations 2000
Practice 23 to industrial and medical pressure systems installed at user
premises.
36. BCGA Code of Bulk liquid carbon dioxide storage at users’ premises.
Practice 26
37. BCGA Code of Transportable vacuum insulated containers of not more than
Practice 27 1000 litres volume.
38. BCGA Code of The safe use of liquid nitrogen dewars up to 50 Litres
Practice 30
41. BCGA Technical A method for estimating the off-site risks from bulk storage of
Report 1 liquefied oxygen.
42. BCGA Technical The probability of fatality in oxygen enriched atmospheres due
Report 2 to spillage of liquid oxygen.
43. BCGA Technical Replacement substances for the cleaning of oxygen system
Report 3 components.
44. BCGA Guidance Guidance for the storage of gas cylinders in the workplace.
Note 2
47. BCGA Leaflet 11 Safety checks for vacuum insulated storage tanks.
UK Legislation www.legislation.gov.uk
30
APPENDIX 1
Sheet 1 of 1
HAZARDS FROM ASPHYXIATION
Nitrogen and argon may produce local oxygen-deficient atmospheres, which will produce
asphyxia if breathed. This is especially true in confined spaces.
Atmospheres containing less than 18 % oxygen are potentially dangerous and entry into
atmospheres containing less than 19.5 % is not recommended.
Atmospheres containing less than 10 % oxygen can cause brain damage and death.
Asphyxia due to oxygen deficiency is often rapid with no prior warning to the victim. A
general indication of what is liable to happen in oxygen deficient atmospheres is given in Table
4. It should be appreciated that the reactions of some individuals can be very different from
those shown.
.
Oxygen Content Effects and Symptoms
(Vol %) (at atmospheric pressure)
The victim may well not be aware of the asphyxia. If any of the following symptoms appear in
situations where asphyxia is possible and breathing apparatus is not in use, immediately move
the affected person to the open air, following up with artificial respiration if necessary.
Attempts to rescue affected persons from confined spaces or where oxygen deficient
atmospheres may be present should only be made by persons trained in the use of breathing
apparatus and confined space entry procedures.
31
APPENDIX 2
Sheet 1 of 1
Oxygen reacts with most elements. The initiation, speed, vigour and extent of these reactions
depend in particular upon:
Reaction mechanism
The mechanism of these reactions is complicated and depends, among other things, upon the
nature of the substances concerned, their physical state, geometric configuration, concentration
and manner of ignition. This too influences the speed of reaction, which can vary from slow
combustion to an explosion.
Combustibility of materials
Oxygen enrichment of the atmosphere, even by a few percent, considerably increases the risk
of fire. Materials which do not burn in air, including fireproofing materials, may burn
vigorously or even spontaneously in enriched air.
Combustion characteristics
Materials ignite more easily and sparks which would normally be regarded as harmless can
cause fire. The resulting flames are much hotter and are propagated at much greater speed.
Oil and grease are particularly hazardous in the presence of oxygen as they ignite
spontaneously and burn with explosive violence. They should NEVER be used to lubricate
oxygen or enriched air equipment. Special lubricants with which oxygen can be used under
certain conditions are available.
Smoking
Burning accidents, that occur, are often started by the lighting of a cigarette. Therefore it is
impossible to over-emphasise the danger of smoking in oxygen-enriched atmospheres or where
oxygen enrichment can occur. In all such areas smoking shall be forbidden.
32
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 1 of 8
MINIMUM SAFETY DISTANCES
Explanatory notes
The following descriptors are used in the safety distance diagrams, with examples of the risks.
Descriptors Liquid oxygen Liquid inert gases
Large wooden Spontaneous combustion from Thermal radiation from fire.
structures, timber yards leaking product.
etc. Thermal radiation from fire.
Fuel gas vent pipes. Spontaneous combustion from Thermal radiation from fire.
leaking product.
Thermal radiation from fire.
33
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 2 of 8
Vehicle parking areas. Spontaneous combustion from Ventilator and air conditioning
leaking product. intakes – oxygen deficient
Ventilator and air conditioning atmosphere from leaking
intakes – oxygen enriched product, danger to personnel.
atmosphere from leaking Embrittlement of equipment.
product, increased fire risk, Reduced visibility from major
danger to personnel. product release.
Embrittlement of equipment. Accessibility to the tank
Reduced visibility from major controls.
product release.
Accessibility to the tank
controls.
Pits, ducts & surface Spontaneous combustion from Oxygen deficient atmosphere
water drains (untrapped). leaking product. from leaking product, danger
Openings of systems Oxygen enriched atmosphere to personnel.
below ground level. from leaking product, Embrittlement of equipment.
increased fire risk, danger to
personnel.
Embrittlement of equipment.
34
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 3 of 8
Flammable gas cylinder Spontaneous combustion from Thermal radiation from fire.
storage. leaking product. Embrittlement of equipment.
Thermal radiation from fire.
Embrittlement of equipment.
Bulk flammable liquid Spontaneous combustion from Thermal radiation from fire.
storage up to 4 tonnes. leaking product. Embrittlement of equipment.
Thermal radiation from fire.
Embrittlement of equipment.
Areas where open flames, Spontaneous combustion from Oxygen deficient atmosphere
smoking etc are leaking product. from leaking product, danger
permitted. Oxygen enriched atmosphere to personnel.
from leaking product,
increased fire risk, danger to
personnel.
35
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 4 of 8
Distances in metres
Large wooden structures, Areas where open Small stocks of combustible Non-flammable gas Bulk flammable liquid
L.P.G. storage up to
timber yards etc. flames, smoking etc material, site huts, cylinder storage storage up to 4 tonnes *
4 tonnes *
are permitted. work sheds etc.
3 3 1 7.5
5 7.5
5 6
Flanges, unions in pipelines containing
Fuel gas vent pipes. flammable gases or liquids.
4 1
Openings, windows and escape Places of public Railway Lines. Public Roads. Property Boundaries. Vehicle Parking Areas.
routes from buildings & areas assembly.
where employees and visitors are
likely to congregate.
NOTE: Assumed maximum oxygen liquid phase pipework diameter DN 15 (1/2″ nominal bore) and
flammable gas / liquid pipe up to DN25 (1″ nominal bore).
* For LPG or flammable liquid tanks above 4 tonnes a risk assessment shall be carried out to
establish the safe separation distance.
36
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 5 of 8
Distance between oxygen tanks from 2,000 litres to 20,000 litres water capacity
and typical hazards.
Distances in metres
Large wooden structures, Areas where open Small stocks of combustible Non-flammable gas Bulk flammable liquid
L.P.G. storage up to
timber yards etc. flames, smoking etc material, site huts, cylinder storage storage up to 4 tonnes *
4 tonnes *
are permitted. work sheds etc.
5 5 1 7.5
15 7.5
5 6
Flanges, unions in pipelines containing
Fuel gas vent pipes. flammable gases or liquids.
5
5
7 5
10 10 5 5
Openings, windows and escape Places of public Railway Lines. Public Roads. Property Boundaries. Vehicle Parking Areas.
routes from buildings & areas assembly.
where employees and visitors are
likely to congregate.
NOTE: Assumed maximum oxygen liquid phase pipework diameter DN 40 (1½″ nominal bore) and
flammable gas / liquid pipe up to DN25 (1″ nominal bore).
* For LPG or flammable liquid tanks above 4 tonnes a risk assessment shall be carried out to
establish the safe separation distance.
37
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 6 of 8
Distance between oxygen tanks from 20,000 litres up to 125,000 litres water capacity
and typical hazards.
Distances in metres
Large wooden structures, Areas where open Small stocks of combustible Non-flammable gas Bulk flammable liquid
L.P.G. storage up to
timber yards etc. flames, smoking etc material, site huts, cylinder storage storage up to 4 tonnes *
4 tonnes *
are permitted. work sheds etc.
8 8 1 7.5
15 7.5
8 6
Flanges, unions in pipelines containing
Fuel gas vent pipes. flammable gases or liquids.
6
8
8 8
15 15 8 8
Openings, windows and escape Places of public Railway Lines. Public Roads. Property Boundaries. Vehicle Parking Areas.
routes from buildings & areas assembly.
where employees and visitors are
likely to congregate.
NOTE: Assumed maximum oxygen liquid phase pipework diameter DN 40 (1½″ nominal bore) and
flammable gas / liquid pipe up to DN25 (1″ nominal bore).
* For LPG or flammable liquid tanks above 4 tonnes a risk assessment shall be carried out to
establish the safe separation distance.
38
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 7 of 8
Distance between nitrogen, argon and helium tanks up to 2,000 litres water capacity
and typical hazards.
Distances in metres
Large wooden structures, Areas where open Small stocks of combustible Non-flammable gas Bulk flammable liquid
L.P.G. storage up to
timber yards etc. flames, smoking etc material, site huts, cylinder storage storage up to 4 tonnes *
4 tonnes *
are permitted. work sheds etc.
1 1 1 3
1 3
1 1
Flanges, unions in pipelines containing
Fuel gas vent pipes. flammable gases or liquids.
1 1
Openings, windows and escape Places of public Railway Lines. Public Roads. Property Boundaries. Vehicle Parking Areas.
routes from buildings & areas assembly.
where employees and visitors are
likely to congregate.
NOTE: Assumed maximum liquid phase pipework diameter DN 15 (1/2″ nominal bore) and
flammable gas / liquid pipe up to DN25 (1″ nominal bore).
* For LPG or flammable liquid tanks above 4 tonnes a risk assessment shall be carried out to
establish the safe separation distance.
39
APPENDIX 3
Sheet 8 of 8
Distance between nitrogen, argon and helium tanks from 2,000 litres to 125,000 litres
water capacity and typical hazards.
Distances in metres
Large wooden structures, Areas where open Small stocks of combustible Non-flammable gas Bulk flammable liquid
L.P.G. storage up to
timber yards etc. flames, smoking etc material, site huts, cylinder storage storage up to 4 tonnes *
4 tonnes *
are permitted. work sheds etc.
3 3 1 3
3 3
3 3
Flanges, unions in pipelines containing
Fuel gas vent pipes. flammable gases or liquids.
1
3
3 3
3 5 5 3
Openings, windows and escape Places of public Railway Lines. Public Roads. Property Boundaries. Vehicle Parking Areas.
routes from buildings & areas assembly.
where employees and visitors are
likely to congregate.
NOTE: Assumed maximum liquid phase pipework diameter DN 50 (2″ nominal bore) and
flammable gas / liquid pipe up to DN25 (1″ nominal bore).
* For LPG or flammable liquid tanks above 4 tonnes a risk assessment shall be carried out to
establish the safe separation distance.
40
APPENDIX 4
Sheet 1 of 1
41
APPENDIX 5
Sheet 1 of 2
The temperature of liquefied gases varies. The boiling points, i.e. the temperatures at which the
liquefied gas vaporises, are detailed in Table 5.
Oxygen -183 oC
Argon -186 oC
Nitrogen -196 oC
Helium -269 oC
The effect of extreme cold on tissue is to destroy it, a similar end result to that of heat exposure,
and in like fashion the amount of cold and the duration of contact is crucial. The destruction of
tissue is not so immediately obvious as in the case of burns, since pain is absent in the frozen
stage, and the tissue, although rigid, keeps its normal shape and is not obviously destroyed.
Pain and destruction becomes more apparent as thawing occurs. Those who have had mild
frostbite of fingers or toes will have some idea of the pain on re-warming.
Prevention of contact with very cold liquids is quite vital and those who work in this field must
be aware of the hazard.
Skin effects
Liquid, vapour, or low-temperature gas can produce effects on the skin, which will vary in
severity with temperature and the length of exposure. Naked or insufficiently protected parts of
the body coming into contact with uninsulated pipes or vessels may stick fast by virtue of the
freezing of moisture and flesh may be torn in removal. The wearing of wet clothing should be
avoided.
Continued exposure of naked flesh to cold atmospheres can result in frostbite. There usually is
sufficient warning by local pain whilst the freezing action is taking place. Re-warming with
lukewarm water at 42 oC to 44 oC (107 oF to 111 oF) is generally sufficient safeguard against
injury.
Whilst transient and short exposure produces discomfort in breathing, prolonged inhalation of
vapour or cold gas, whether respirable or not, can produce serious effects on the lungs.
42
APPENDIX 5
Sheet 2 of 2
Flush the affected areas of skin with copious quantities of tepid water, but do not apply any
form of direct heat, e.g. hot water, room heaters, etc. Move casualty to a warm place (about
22 °C; (295 K)). If medical attention is not immediately available, arrange for the casualty to
be transported to hospital without delay.
(ii) Continue to flush the affected areas of skin with copious quantities of tepid
water.
(iii) Protect frozen parts with bulky, dry, sterile dressings. Do not apply too tightly
so as to cause restriction of blood circulation.
(v) Ensure ambulance crew or hospital is advised of details of accident and first
aid treatment already administered.
(vi) Smoking and alcoholic beverages reduce the blood supply to the affected part
and should be avoided.
NOTE: The above text has been reproduced with the permission of the British
Cryoengineering Society from its “Cryogenics Safety Manual” (49).
43
APPENDIX 6
Sheet 1 of 3
The type of ventilation depends on a multitude of factors such as type of location, gas type,
possible leaks, application etc.
Ventilation can be natural or provided by forced ventilation. The design criterion is the
number of air changes per hour.
In locations above ground level with no special ventilation openings, natural ventilation
provides typically 1 change per hour. This is not the case of buildings with windows sealed
with tight seals. For underground rooms with small windows 0.4 changes per hour can be
considered as an average value.
For handling (storing, filling, withdrawal, etc.) transportable cryogenic vessels with non-
flammable, non-toxic contents in locations above ground level, natural ventilation is
generally sufficient, provided that the room is large enough or that the outdoor area is not
enclosed by walls etc. An assessment should be conducted to confirm the ventilation is
adequate.
An indoor location should have ventilation openings with a total area of 1 % of the ground
area. The openings should be positioned diagonally across the room. The density of the gas
should also be taken into consideration (the main opening at the highest point of the location
for gases lighter than air, or at ground level for gases heavier than air).
For more than 2 changes per hour a forced ventilation system is necessary. Different
regulations may recommend or require for different situations a specific number of air
changes per hour, e.g. 5, 10, 20 etc.
In typical situations the number of air changes can be calculated assuming a certain leakage
rate from the vessel pipework and a homogeneous distribution of gas, using the following
formula:
-t
m
0.21n 1- e
C t = 0.21 + − 0.21
L + n
Vr
Vr × 0.21 × n
C∞ = approximately.
L + (Vr × n )
44
APPENDIX 6
Sheet 2 of 3
Where:
Ct = Oxygen concentration after defined time
C∞ = Oxygen concentration after long periods (days)
L = Gas release rate, m3/h
Vr = The volume of free air in the room, m3
n = The number of air changes per hour
t = Time gas has flowed in hours
e = 2.72
m = Vr
L + n Vr
This appendix considers the “worst case” scenario where the entire contents of the vessel are
lost to the room immediately. The resulting oxygen concentration in the room may then be
calculated from the following formula:
100 x Vo
Cox =
VR
Where:
Cox = Resulting oxygen concentration, %
VR = The volume of free air in the workplace, m3 (volume of workplace less
volume of solid objects)
VO = The volume of oxygen, m3
For oxygen:
VO = 0.21 (VR - Vg) + Vg
45
APPENDIX 6
Sheet 3 of 3
Worked example
Calculate the oxygen concentration resulting from spilling 50 litres of liquid oxygen into a
room of 300 m3 volume:
VR = Room volume
= 300 m3
Vg = Gas release from vaporised liquid
= 50
x 842
1000
= 42 m3
Vo = Volume of oxygen
= 0.21 (VR - Vg) + Vg
= 0.21 x (300 - 42) + 42
= 96.2 m³
Cox = 100 x Vo
VR
= 100 x 96.2
300
= 32.1 %
46
British Compressed Gases Association
www.bcga.co.uk
47