Excessive Heat Is The Killer
Excessive Heat Is The Killer
Excessive Heat Is The Killer
Killer!
When it comes to causes of Diesel Cylinder Head Failure, Excessive Heat is the Demon you
are chasing. Diesel engines are High Compression Engines, with high compression comes
high temperatures.
Cylinder Heads only crack when they have become too hot. The “cracking” of the cylinder
head is not the cause but only the end result. To successfully return a vehicle to reliable
service the cause of this “excessive heat” must be located and remedied, or the replaced
cylinder head will most likely re-fail within 3-12 months time. Causing you & your customer to
question the result.
The poor old cylinder head wears the blame too often, when in fact the part that has actually
“broken” is not to blame but the systems surrounding it are usually at fault instead. The
cylinder head effectively becomes a “heat sink” and “sucks up” all this excessive heat to the
point where it can no longer with stand it and it gives way, leading to an expensive repair job.
All parts fail for a reason, and this reason or reasons need to be identified to be sure of a
successful re-instatement of the vehicle into service.
There are three main systems, which can be a source of “excessive heat” for the Diesel
Cylinder Head. (This is assuming the bottom end of the engine is in good operational
condition, as we are discussing cylinder heads in this editorial)
Those three systems are: Cooling System, Fuel Delivery System and Exhaust System.
We need to investigate each of these systems in detail to ensure they are operating with in
their original design parameters set by the vehicle manufacturer.
Cooling System: This is the first system that usually gets the attention. Areas to consider
are.
• Radiator (some vehicles have more than one radiator, they all need to be cleaned
or replaced. Just flushing is not that effective)
• All coolant hoses should be checked for deterioration, integrity, perishing and of
coarse leaks.
• New and existing thermostats should be tested for correct operation.
• Viscous fans and/or electric fans should also be checked for correct operation. Just
because it’s spinning doesn’t mean it’s drawing the correct airflow.
• Obstructions, debris blockage of radiator air flow.
• Heater cores, if the radiator was blocked good chance the heater core is
compromised as well. Some vehicles such as people movers etc. have
exceptionally detailed heater and cooling hose systems, which can present trouble
with air locks. Be sure you have released any trapped air with in the system.
• Correct levels and types of “anti-freeze” and “inhibitor” and employed. Electrolysis
(electric mice) and cavitation are extremely destructive also.
• Contaminated cooling systems (scale and rust build up) this will directly affect the
ability of the cooling system to expel or radiate heat from the engine.
• Common Rail & Direct Injection Diesels. The latest technology engines (Common
Rail) atomize the fuel finer than it has ever been atomized before. This is how they
achieve so much power from small engine displacements. The finer the fuel
atomization the more complete the combustion, more complete the combustion more
efficiency and more power. However some of these Common Rail engines can
generate up to 30,000psi at the injector nozzle at W.O.T (Wide Open Throttle). High
pressure creates high temperature in the returning fuel to the fuel tank. This can lead
to very hot fuel with in the fuel tanks. This once cooled can create condensation with in
the fuel tank, contaminating the fuel with even more water. Water cannot be
compressed, so if it were to reach the injectors at these pressures it can and does
cause some real damage to the internals of the fuel injector. Cracked and melted
pistons, cracked cylinder heads, failed head gaskets; all can result from improper fuel
delivery.
Exhaust System: The exhaust system includes any, Turbos, EGRs (Exhaust Gas
Recirculation) EGR Coolers, Mufflers, D.P.F (Diesel Particulate Filter), Pre CATS and
Exhaust Pipes themselves.
• Turbos. Make sure the turbo is not over boosting due to blocked MAP sensors or
stuck Waste Gates. MAP sensors are commonly used to detect turbo boost and send
a signal to the ECU, which then controls the amount of boost the turbo should be
providing. If it is blocked with “EGR Gunk”, no or little manifold pressure is detected
and the turbo is told to boost up. May sound like fun, but is not good for the long-term
health of the engine. Couple with this a possible faulty injector or two, result very high
EGT.
• EGR. Exhaust Gas Recirculation Valve is another of these parts, which become
blocked and jammed with “EGR Gunk” (Mixture of carbon and oil mist) The EGR
system is there for a reason, not just annoyance. As the name suggests the recycle
some of the exhaust gases back around into the inlet manifold to be scavenged. This
helps reduce combustion temperature so the diesel engine does not produce so much
or no NOx gases. When a diesel combustion temperature reaches approx. 2400
degrees Celsius, it starts to produce NOx gas; this is frowned upon these days for all
our sakes. The EGR helps reduce this combustion temperature so as not to have this
undesirable effect. The irony is that a faulty EGR valve or system can cause a diesel
engine to run inefficiently and cause more pollution and have a detrimental effect on
the engines performance and reliability. It is a common practice these days (out of
economy and convenience) to “block” these EGR systems off with a simple “blanking
plate” method. This will have an effect on the EGT of the engine as it looses the
designed effect of lowering combustion temperatures.
• EGR Coolers. EGR Coolers are as the name suggests related to and part of the EGR
system. They are found on most Direct Injection and Common Rail Diesel engines
today. They consist of a small radiator situated inside the EGR pipe running between
the exhaust and the intake manifold. Their job is to cool the exhaust gases traveling to
the intake. This is done with coolant from the cooling system. Problem with these is
that sometimes the cooler cracks internally and allows coolant to be sucked from the
cooling system and ultimately leading to an over heat situation. These should always
be pressure tested regardless of the age of the EGR Cooler itself. One of the leading
causes of EGR Cooler failure is again our old friend “High EGTs”. The high EGT can
boil the coolant with in the cooler causing it to swell and crack.
• Mufflers. A blocked or collapsing muffler will cause excessive “back pressure”. Quite
simply if the engine can not expel its hot exhaust gases they are going to back up and
cause failure of turbos and cylinder heads. It is the same if the vehicle has a bent or
damaged exhaust pipe, same result.
• Diesel Particulate Filters, DPF. Found in many late model diesel engine vehicles.
Just as the name suggests they filter “Particulates” from the emitted exhaust gases
before they enter the atmosphere. These heavy particulates are not good for us air
breathing animals, nor are the NOx gases mentioned earlier. These DPF filters are
cleaned by the engines ECU controlling either an increased fuel delivery or by directly
injecting fuel into the catalyst at a set parameter so as to burn off build up with in the
filter. This is only meant to happen with in certain requirements of vehicle operation,
such as road speed. However vehicles which have lived a life of low speed travel can
end up with blocked DPFs. This has an environmental as well as a mechanical
disadvantage. Again affecting the EGTs.
Summary.
The poor cylinder head gets the blame far too often when in fact it is the
surrounding systems the cause the true failure. If these systems are not
thoroughly inspected and tested for correct operation, the most likely out come
will be the continued premature failure of the replaced cylinder head and its
associated components. Find the root of the “Excessive Heat” and you will
solve your problems. There is no such thing as a “Cheap Diesel Repair”
because they often will not fix the real problem.