Voltage-Source Active Power Filter Based On Multilevel Converter and Ultracapacitor DC Link
Voltage-Source Active Power Filter Based On Multilevel Converter and Ultracapacitor DC Link
Voltage-Source Active Power Filter Based On Multilevel Converter and Ultracapacitor DC Link
Abstract—A new topology for active power filters (APF) using All these reasons have created many research works on the
an 81-level converter is analyzed. Each phase of the converter is topic of PWM modulation [2]–[5].
composed of four three-state converters, all of them connected to Multilevel inverters [6]–[8] can work as amplitude modula-
the same capacitor dc link voltage and their output connected in
series through output transformers. The main advantages of this tion and PWM, and this fact makes the outputs of the converter
kind of converter are the negligible harmonic distortion obtained very much cleaner. This way of operation allows having almost
and the very low switching frequency operation. The single-phase perfect currents, and very good voltage waveforms, eliminating
equivalent circuit is analyzed and their governing equations most of the undesirable harmonics. The series connection of
derived. The dc link voltage control, based on manipulating the several bridges allows to work with much higher voltages
converter’s voltage phase, is analyzed together with the circuit’s
characteristics that determine the capability to draw or deliver [1], [9], [10], and the stepped voltage waveforms eliminate the
active and reactive current. Simulation results for this application voltage stress in associated equipment, such as transformers.
are compared with conventional pulsewidth-modulated (PWM) Moreover, the bridges of each converter work at a very low
converters, showing that this filter can compensate load current switching frequency, which allows working with low speed
harmonics, keeping better-quality sinusoidal currents from the semiconductors, and low switching frequency losses [11].
source. The simulated configuration uses a 1-F ultracapacitor in
the dc link, making it possible to store energy and deliver it during The objective of this paper is to show the performance
short voltage dips. This is achieved by applying a modulation advantages of a multilevel converter used as an APF. The filter
control to maintain a stable ac voltage during dc voltage drops. is used to compensate a contaminating load with small power
A prototype of the filter was implemented and tested, and the factor and to feed the load during voltage dips. The results are
obtained current waveforms showed to be as good as expected. compared with conventional PWM modulators working at a
Index Terms—Active filters, multilevel systems. switching frequency of 10 kHz.
Fig. 1. Main components of a four-stage 81-level multiconverter. (a) Individual voltage sources for each module. (b) One single voltage source for all modules,
and series connection via output transformers.
Fig. 2. (a) Shunt APF using PWM techniques. (b) Shunt APF using a multilevel inverter.
angles and/or the dc voltage. Each H bridge can produce three voltage rating. For scaling the output voltage at the ac side, the
different voltage levels: +Vdc, −Vdc, and zero. Topology transformers’ turn ratios are scaled in power of 3, and the one
1) consists of separated dc sources for each module and direct located at the bottom in Fig. 1(b) has the highest voltage ratio
series connection at the ac side; topology 2) uses a single dc (a:27) and works at the lowest switching frequency (equal to the
source for all modules and the series ac connection is interfaced main frequency). The converter connected to this transformer
by scaling transformers. While working as an active filter, is called the Main Converter because it manages most of the
although the converter’s steady state active power is zero, the reactive power. The ratings of the transformers are from bottom
active power of each individual module may be different from (Main Converter) to top: 0.675, 0.225, 0.075, and 0.025 pu.
zero. Therefore, the topology 2) was used because it avoids
the need for isolated energy-balancing devices if capacitors are
III. APF C ONFIGURATION
used as individual dc storage devices. In this case, a single
capacitor for all the three phases is used at the dc link for tempo- Fig. 2(a) shows a typical configuration for a shunt APF using
rary energy storage instead of four floating capacitors for each PWM strategy. The source is feeding a contaminating load,
phase, which represents a great simplification in the design of such as a power rectifier. The APF, connected in parallel, injects
the APF. Besides, all the power transistors operate at the same the harmonic currents to the load and the power system sees a
ORTÚZAR et al.: VOLTAGE-SOURCE APF BASED ON MULTILEVEL CONVERTER AND ULTRACAPACITOR DC LINK 479
Fig. 4. Phase diagrams of voltages and currents, where ILine = IL . (a) Reactive power control. (b) Active power control. (c) General control.
Fig. 5. Active (Id ) and reactive (Iq ) currents supplied by the source at the filter node.
Fig. 7. Currents waveforms from simulation. (a) Source current and scaled voltage. (b) Load current. (c) Filter current.
smoothing reactor LS = 40 mH. This represents a dc load of As can be seen in Fig. 7, the source currents are perfectly
approximately 50 kW. sinusoidal and with unity power factor. In addition, the load cur-
A voltage dip is simulated at T = 0.2 s, with a duration of rents are completely fed by the filter during the voltage dip. This
0.4 s. During this period, the load was fed from the filter’s demonstrates that this kind of multiconverter works perfectly as
capacitor and a sinusoidal voltage of nominal amplitude is a voltage dip proof filter, delivering near-sinusoidal voltages.
maintained at the filter’s output. Fig. 8 shows details of voltages and currents during the
Fig. 7 shows a plot of the (a) source voltage (VS ) and current experiment. When the source goes offline, the filter starts
(IS ), (b) load current (IL ), and (c) filter current (IF ) during the delivering all the current consumed by the load.
simulation. The source voltage (scaled) allows appreciating the Fig. 9 shows the (a) source voltage, (b) dc link capacitor
power factor from the source. During the voltage dip (between voltage, and (c) capacitor current. It is clear that when the
T = 0.2 s and T = 0.6 s), there is no current flowing from the source goes offline, the capacitor starts delivering all the active
mains for obvious reasons. power, depressing its voltage. The ultracapacitor voltage drop
482 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 53, NO. 2, APRIL 2006
Fig. 8. Detail of (a) voltages, (b) load currents, and (c) filter current when the fault occurs.
Fig. 9. Detail of (a) source voltage, (b) capacitor current, and (c) capacitor voltage.
represents the energy supplied by the capacitor during the voltage levels at the inverter terminals. The source voltage
voltage dip. After the voltage from the source is reestablished, is 110 V fn, and the dc capacitor voltage reference at the
the control modifies the filter’s voltage angle to inject active APF is set to 146 V to achieve a nominal voltage at the
power to the filter and recover the capacitor’s voltage level. inverter terminals under steady state. The line impedance is
ZL = 1.43 + j4.4 Ω, and rectifier (nonlinear load) output dc
load RD = 27 Ω plus a smoothing reactor LS = 65 mH. The
V. E XPERIMENTAL R ESULTS
equivalent power load is 2.5 kW.
Fig. 10 shows an experimental inverter like the one in Fig. 11 shows a detail of the (a) source voltage VS , (b) source
Fig. 1(b), which was implemented for testing. The transformer current IS , (c) filter current IF , and (d) load current IL . It is
ratios are scaled in power of 3, yielding a total of 81 different easy to see that the source current waveform has almost no
ORTÚZAR et al.: VOLTAGE-SOURCE APF BASED ON MULTILEVEL CONVERTER AND ULTRACAPACITOR DC LINK 483
Fig. 11. Detail of source, filter, and load current (10 A/div), and source voltage (100 V/div).
harmonic content and is practically in phase with the source voltage distortion is generated when the filter has to compensate
voltage while the filter delivers all of the harmonic content. harmonic currents of high di/dt. Therefore, transformers of
The waveforms in Fig. 12 present the transient behavior of low leakage inductance should be used. This distortion and the
the filter. During the connection of a load, the control takes a lagging angle of the filter’s voltage are shown in Fig. 13.
couple of cycles to reach steady state. In case of disconnection,
the time is a little longer because of the arc of the switch being
VI. C ONCLUSION
used to extinguish.
Although this is a voltage-source inverter, small parasitic A four-stage 81-level inverter using three-state “H” convert-
inductors are unavoidably present in series to the inverter ers was analyzed, simulated, and tested for use as an APF.
terminals because of the transformer’s leakage inductances. It has been shown that some of the advantages of this kind
Anyway, this is not at all bad, because it helps filtering the of converter compared with conventional PWM converters are
dv/dt of the small voltage steps of the converter, avoiding lower commutation frequency and better quality of voltage
current peaks if the load has a voltage-source characteristic and current waveforms. Some of the drawbacks are higher
(i.e., capacitors). The drawback of these inductances is that a semiconductor count and extra transformers needed.
484 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 53, NO. 2, APRIL 2006
Fig. 12. Transient response. Capacitor voltage (20 V/div); filter, load, and source currents (10 A/div).
Fig. 13. Filter voltage distortion detail. Source and filter voltages (100 V/div); source and load currents (10 A/div).
A simple control scheme has been used, which consists of capacitor, is used. Even a UPS capability could be implemented
modifying the filter’s voltage angle while maintaining nominal if devices of higher energy storage capacity (such as batteries)
voltage amplitude. This control scheme allows to easily modify are used at the dc link terminals. In such a case, a current
the amount of active power transferred to or from the filter and sensor and some changes to the control system would have to
thus control the dc capacitor voltage. Nevertheless, a control be implemented.
system for this kind of filter would have to incorporate adaptive
features to adapt to changes in the line parameters. R EFERENCES
The proposed filter, compensating a contaminating load, [1] L. M. Tolbert and F. Z. Peng, “Multilevel converters for large electric
was simulated, including a voltage dip during the experiment. drives,” in Proc. APEC, Anaheim, CA, Feb. 15–19, 1998, pp. 530–536.
Simulation waveforms showed that source currents were always [2] H. Akagi, “The state-of-the-art power electronics in Japan,” IEEE Trans.
Power Electron., vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 345–356, Mar. 1998.
sinusoidal and with high power factor, while the voltage at the [3] B. Bose, “Power electronics and motion control—Technology status and
load terminals were sinusoidal at all times. recent trends,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 902–909,
A prototype of the proposed inverter was constructed and Sep./Oct. 1993.
[4] D. Chung, J. Kim, and S. Sul, “Unified voltage modulation technique for
operated as an APF. The experiment showed that this kind of real time three-phase power conversion,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 34,
equipment behaves perfectly if operated within its capabili- no. 2, pp. 374–380, Mar./Apr. 1998.
ties, delivering all current harmonics consumed by the load, [5] J. Holtz and B. Beyer, “Fast current trajectory tracking control based on
synchronous optimal pulse width modulation,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl.,
responding and stabilizing quickly to transient changes in vol. 31, no. 5, pp. 1110–1120, Sep./Oct. 1995.
the load. Moreover, the experiments showed remarkably good [6] A. Draou, M. Benghanen, and A. Tahri, “Multilevel converters and VAR
quality current and voltage waveforms, without the usual high compensation,” in Power Electronics Handbook, M. H. Rashid, Ed. New
York: Academic, 2001, ch. 25, pp. 615–622.
frequency content present in PWM inverters. It was also shown [7] F. Z. Peng, “A generalized multilevel inverter topology with self
that the transformer’s characteristics could distort the voltage voltage balancing,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 37, no. 2, pp. 611–618,
signals if the leakage inductances are significative. Mar./Apr. 2001.
[8] J. Dixon and L. Morán, “Multilevel inverter, based on multi-stage con-
The proposed APF can work perfectly as a voltage dip nection of three-level converters, scaled in power of three,” in Proc. IEEE
protection if a relatively high capacitance device, like an ultra- IECON, Sevilla, Spain, Nov. 2002, pp. 886–891, CD-ROM.
ORTÚZAR et al.: VOLTAGE-SOURCE APF BASED ON MULTILEVEL CONVERTER AND ULTRACAPACITOR DC LINK 485
[9] N. P. Schibli, T. Nguyen, and A. C. Rufer, “A three-phase multilevel con- Juan W. Dixon (M’90–SM’95) was born in Santi-
verter for high-power induction motors,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., ago, Chile. He received the Electrical Engineering
vol. 13, no. 5, pp. 978–986, Sep. 1998. Professional degree from the University of Chile,
[10] M. D. Manjrekar, P. Steimer, and T. A. Lipo, “Hybrid multilevel conver- Santiago, Chile, in 1977, and the M.-Eng. and Ph.D.
sion system: A competitive solution for high power applications,” in Proc. degrees in electrical engineering from McGill Uni-
IEEE IAS, 1999, pp. 1520–1527. versity, Montreal, PQ, Canada, in 1986 and 1988,
[11] M. D. Manjrekar and T. A. Lipo, “A hybrid multilevel topology for drive respectively.
applications,” in Proc. APEC, 1998, pp. 523–529. Since 1979, he has been with the Universidad
[12] J. Rodriguez, J. Lai, and F. Z. Peng, “Multilevel inverters: A survey of Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile, working in the
topologies, controls and applications,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 49, areas of power electronics, electric traction, elec-
no. 4, pp. 724–736, Aug. 2002. tric power generation, and electrical machines. He
[13] Power Electronics Simulations, User Manual, Vancouver, Canada: Pow- is currently a Professor at the Department of Electrical Engineering. His
ersim Technologies. PSIM Version 4.1. [Online]. Available: http://www. research interests include new technologies for electric vehicles, machine
powersimtech.com drives, frequency changers, high-power rectifiers, multilevel inverters, static
VAr compensators, and active power filters.