Challenges Before Corporate Social Responsibility in The Global Markets
Challenges Before Corporate Social Responsibility in The Global Markets
Challenges Before Corporate Social Responsibility in The Global Markets
Global Markets.
Abstarct
The current trend of globalization has brought a realisation among the firms that in order
to compete effectively in a competitive environment; they need clearly defined business
practises with a sound focus on the public interest in the markets . People are the greatest
assets for a company so it becomes essential to incorporate CSR initiatives at workplace
in the form of good human resource practices.In the current paper various areas affected
by CSR are discussed which include, environment ,trade unions, market place workplace
community etc. the special focus is on different types of challenges faced by Corporate
Social Responsibility. World Business Council for Sustainable Development has also
made ceretain recommendations and studies which have been of greaat value in
developing CSR initiatives.
The European Commission advocates CSR as “Being socially responsible means not only
fulfilling legal expectations, but also going beyond compliance and investing more into
human capital, the environment and relations with stakeholders.”
A variety of terms are used - sometimes interchangeably -- to talk about corporate social
responsibility (CSR): business ethics, corporate citizenship, corporate accountability,
sustainability. BSR defines corporate social responsibility as “achieving commercial
success in ways that honor ethical values and respect people, communities, and the
natural environment.”
We also say that CSR means addressing the legal, ethical, commercial and other
expectations society has for business, and making decisions that fairly balance the claims
of all key stakeholders. In its simplest terms it is: “what you do, how you do it, and when
and what you say.”
Eg
Columbia.
During the first half of the last century, certain companies and factories held child-care
on their properties for the young children of some of their working mothers.
In Colombia, businesses direct their social initiatives towards different stakeholders and
develop them in various regions. Initiatives may be directed at groups with a direct
relationship to the company, to outlying communities and, on occasion, to particular
communities in society at large
Challlangeds Columbia
Some challenges that must be faced in an agenda that seeks to deepen CSR in Colombia
are
One of the most revolutionary changes in capitalism over the last 50 years has been the
development of “conscience”. Private business, which is the hard core of this economic
system has realized and has been made to realize by several social, economic and
political forces, that has social obligations to fulfil, besides ensuring its own existence
through profitable activity. There is no denying the fact that part of this realization is not
genuine and takes the form of mere lip service, which is thought necessary to ensure the
survival of private enterprise. But it cannot be denied also that private business does
partly realize and recognize the hard reality that a privately owned firm cannot meet the
challenge of socialism and allied doctrines unless it sets its house in order changes its
outlook and is prepared to play its legitimate role as an organ of society. It will be useful
*Lecturers- Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Mnagement and Development 3
Studies.Lucknow
drpavneshkumar@yahoo.co.in, nupur_hrdm@rediffmail.com
here to go into some of the forces and factors, which have persuaded businessman to
consider their responsibilities and the conditions, which were favourable to the
development of business concern with social responsibilities. Some of the more
important among them are:
(a) The threat of public regulation of private ownership;
(b) The pressure of the labour movement;
(c) The development of moral values and social standards applicable to
businessmen;
(d) The development of business education and contacts with the government and
its problems;
(e) Recognition of human factors contributing to the long-term interests of
business;
(f) The development of a professional managerial class with a different
motivation and point of view due to the separation of ownership from
management in the corporate enterprise;
(g) The change in public opinion about the role of business in modern society;
(h) The increased complexity of the decision making processes in which many
persons participate and in which various points of view and diverse interests
are expressed.
While there is no denying the fact that business is an economic performance it is also true
that business is an organ of society and as such it must justify its continuance by fulfilling
its role and responsibilities to society. One may even go to the extent of asserting that a
business enterprise is a trust of the community, which must discharge its obligations
towards the various sections of the community. Some of the specific responsibilities of
business may be outlined as under:
It is very much understandable that corporate social responsibility is a peripheral issue for
any business. Customer satisfaction is where it begins and the bottom line is where it
ends. It is a myth to think that customer satisfaction is only about price and service. there
are important changes that are taking place worldwide.
Marketplace
What are the risk factors connected to the product that is manufactured ? Which are the
stakeholders about to boycott the company because of the service it provide? Just what
is the impact on society of the business, and how does the company future-proof what it
intends to do to go with the emerging trends rather than be caught out by them.
Workplace
The people are the greatest asset . It is also important to treat them like a great asset. Do
not ever erect barriers to their development based on prejudice Nurture their pride in the
company or simply burn their energy in every waking moment as they plan to migrate to
organization’s more family-friendly competitor.
CSR and HR
HR has a role in demonstrating the benefits of workplace practices that both reflect CSR
and at the same time, contribute to organisational efficiency and success. In order to do
this, HR needs to be familiar with the latest research on work practices and employee
performance and also the language of business. It requires HR to integrate CSR initiatives
through its roles as business partner, employee champion, administrative expert and
change agent. It also requires HR to be an organisational advocate in the community and
with other external stakeholders.
Trade unions
The following considers some of the challenges and opportunities for workers and
their trade unions The experience of workers and their trade unions is that, in the
end, their rights and interests are advanced or protected only through the proper
application of good laws and regulations or through their own self-organization for
such purposes as collective bargaining. Trade unionists know that paternalism is
no substitute for the proper role of government. Their experience is that regulatory
frameworks are needed to ensure that business activities are socially responsible.
The challenge for trade unionists is to prevent CSR from becoming a substitute
for the proper role of governments and trade unions. The opportunity for trade
unionists is to use CSR as a way of promoting a culture of legal compliance and
respect for standards as well as to promote good industrial relations and respect for
the role of trade unions.
Trade unionists have much experience in such approaches. They recognize both
common and competing interests with their employer. It should Trade unionists
recognize an interest in the sustainability of their employers, they also understand
that this kind of sustainability is not the same as is meant by “sustainable
development” in terms of society and the environment . It is now clear that many
CSR activities are having a substitute effect for the role of government and are
also substituting for genuine dialogue.
CSR and ILO
The ILO has much to contribute to the debate over the social responsibili
ties of business and to the CSR phenomenon. The most important contributions
that the ILO could make concern standards and standard-setting, as well as so-
cial dialogue and tripartite consultation. Thechallanges for the ILO will be to
resist adopting a management system approach to CSR and to protect its leading
and central role as a standard-setting organization for the world of work.
Government faces two connected but separate challenges in promoting CSR - certainly to
increase the sheer number of businesses engaged in CSR, but also to deepen that
engagement with CSR - into being something which inform all business activities instead
of simply being an afterthought or an add on to the businesses activities.
Community
If a company think that it has a divine right to operate as a business, it’s local
community may soon disabuse it of that notion. If you don't invest in the community, it
may not provide you with the suppliers, or the educated staff you need to operate. If you
don't build a positive relationship with the community, it may not be so supportive when
you need to expand.
Environment
“It must know that all those wealth does not belong to me; what belongs to me is the
right to an honourable livelihood ………. The rest of my wealth belongs to the community
and must be used for the welfare of the community.”
- Mahatama Gandhi
Corporate social responsibility in the present context means that the organization must be
aware of the responsibilities to the community and fulfill those responsibilities. It implies
that the focus of organization should not be limited to increasing shareholders value but
should be widened to take care of the needs of various other stakeholders of the company
to create long term value and for sustainable development. These stakeholders include
employees, community, local government, customers, shareholders etc.
The involvement of corporate in social and environmental issues can have an immensely
positive impact and contribute to the larger goals on sustainable development which is
vital for the nation as well the planet. As per recent World Business Council for
Sustainable Development Report, those fortune 500 companies which did not care for
CSR did not survive over a long period of time.
NTPC – Experience
NTPC has been a socially committed organization since its inception and has adopted a
systematic and visionary approach to address the issue of CSR. NTPC’s mission
statement includes –
“To be a responsible corporate citizen with thrust on environmental protection,
rehabilitation and asset utilization.”
NTPC has also formally expressed its support to global compact – a U.N, in------ for
encouraging and promoting good corporate practices and learning experiences in the
areas of human rights, labour and environment.
Based on NTPC’s experience some of the following action points can be considered for
implementation by the corporate world.
Make social corporate citizenship a core corporate value in an organization
Have a clear resource allocation for CSR
Evolve a community initiative strategy
Search for, identify and build partnerships with suitable partners
Provide not only funds but managerial skills, systems and training
Involve employees and families in implementing CSR programmes.
The term ‘emerging market’ was originally coined by IFC to describe a fairly narrow list
of middle-to-higher income economies among the developing countries, with stock
markets in which foreigners could buy securities. The term’s meaning has since
been expanded to include more or less all developing countries.
The evolution of CSR in these developing economies shows widely varying results.
Chambers, Chapple, Moon and Sullivan (2003) evaluate the extent of CSR penetration in
seven Asian countries (India, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, South
Korea and Thailand). Many researchers have hypothesized that CSR in emerging
economies is still in a very nascent stage and suitable mechanisms do not exist to ensure
that companies practise CSR with anything other than a charitable outlook .
According to Kemp(2001) –
“There are numerous obstacles to achieving corporate responsibility , particularly in
many developing countries where the institutions, standards and appeals system, which
give life to CSR in North America and Europe, are relatively weak.”
Chambers, Chapple, Moon and Sullivan (2003) measure the extent of CSR penetration
in the seven Asian companies and show that the mean value for the seven countries(even
including industrially advanced Japan) is just 41% compared to say a score of 98% for a
developed nation like the United Kingdom. However, there are exceptions to the mean
scores. India for example had an average CSR penetration of 72% compared to
Indonesia’s 24%. The concept of CSR as visualized in the emerging markets and the
developed countries have very different understanding.
As compared with the developed countries like US, CSR in developing countries is seen
as part of corporate philanthropy where corporations augment the social development to
*Lecturers- Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Mnagement and Development 9
Studies.Lucknow
drpavneshkumar@yahoo.co.in, nupur_hrdm@rediffmail.com
support the initiatives of the government. However in the US it is seen as a strategic tool
which helps the organizations to have a legitimate existence in the society. CSR is
considered inbuilt in the business existence of the traditional firms in the emerging
markets like India.However, trends in this regard are heartening with companies trying to
establish strategic alliances with the state and the civil society thus establishing the
presence of CSR as an institution in these markets.
As companies start to embrace CSR practices to a greater extent, it leads to changes in
production processes so that all environmental and societal norms are also satisfied even
thought they may not contribute to the profit maximizing objective of the firm. This will
mean that human rights agreements are also upheld taking into account the rights of the
localcommunities. CSR also leads to evolution of employee relations in the company in
such a way that employees become major stakeholders with definite decision making
powers especially in the area of formulation of CSR policy.
Emerging markets have been identified as a source of immense talent with the
rising levels of education. For example, the expertise of India in churning out
software professionals.
The high degree of public protests against the Coca Cola plant in Plachimada, Kerala,
India got international attention and also led to government intervention for closure of the
plant. The plant at Plachimada was alleged to have exploited the ground water
resources leading to drying up of wells and other natural water resources in the area.
The entire region which was a thriving agricultural land had to rely on water supplied by
tankers. Coca Cola was drawing 1.5 million liters/day from the common groundwater
resource. However due to inherent water scarcity the company is able to extract only
800,000 liters from the bore wells. The company drew water from the nearby villages to
compensate for the lack of availability.
The Coca Cola company had to deal with protests from the local community and
supporting environmental conservation groups. Adding to the water exploitation, Coca
Cola was accused of supplying poisonous waste as fertilizer to the local farmers. Tests
done by an independent agency on the behalf of BBC showed that
the sludge contained high levels of Lead and Cadmium
While the fundamentals of CSR remain the same everywhere, different emphases are
found in different parts of the world. The issues vary in nature and importance from
industry to industry and location to location. The social issues faced by an energy
company, for example, will be of a different magnitude compared to those faced by a
pharmaceutical company.So, the areas impacted by corporate social responsibility are
diverse and growing each time a company confronts a new challenge or crisis. They
include human rights, labour conditions, supplier relations, corruption and community
development.
Because there is no universal definition of CSR, there can be no 'one size fits all'
approach. No set of CSR progress indicators can suit all companies. To respond to the
varying needs of business in the most flexible way possible, the WBCSD has devised a
12-point navigator to guide companies through their social challenges and dilemmas.
The navigator is both a tool and a conceptual approach and should be applied in light of
each company's assessment of its own particular situation. It indicates direction and
demands vision, but does not dictate the speed of progress. It is flexible enough to
*Lecturers- Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Mnagement and Development 11
Studies.Lucknow
drpavneshkumar@yahoo.co.in, nupur_hrdm@rediffmail.com
respond to individual company challenges and dilemmas. The navigator emphasises that
the vigour with which a particular company pursues its vision on CSR is specific to that
company's individual situation.
The WBCSD navigator consists of 12 distinct reference points which can help a company
on its CSR journey.
CONCLISION
K.K. Sinha- Corporate Social Responsibility – NTPC Case ( Synergy ITS Journal
of IT and Mgmt.- Vol 2 nO. 1 Jan 2004)
CR –BIZ- VOL 1 March 2006.
A. Sahay- Corporate Social Responsibility: Aspects of Environmental
Managemrnt.( National Seminar on Management Challenges in the next Decade-
14th 15th May 2005, United Institute of Mnagement Naini ,Allhabad)
Pushpam Kumar- Corporatae Social Respomsibility: Assesment of Global and
Indian Trends and Prospects. (Paradigm Vol 7 No 1 January 2003).
Dr. B M Harshvardhan- Corporate Social Responsibility In Kalaidoscope( The
journal of Indian Management and Strategy, Volume 10,No. 3, July – Sep. 2005).
E refrences
http://www.responsiblepractice.com/english/introduction/
http://www.world-challenge.co.uk/company_responsibility.asp
http://www.bitc.org.uk/resources/viewpoint/challenge.html
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m4422/is_6_22/ai_n15950466
http://www.exed.hbs.edu/programs/csr/
http://www.csrwire.com/article.cgi/2434.html
http://www.axa.com/en/responsibility/challenges/assetmanagement/
http: //www.humanresourcemagazine.com