Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 496 views

    Primary vs. Secondary Sources On Tejeros Convention (1897

    Uploaded by

    Achilles Gabriel Aninipot
    The document summarizes and compares a primary source and secondary source on the Tejeros Convention of 1897. The primary source is Santiago Alvarez's memoirs, which focuses only on the events of the convention itself. The secondary source, written by Teodoro Agoncillo, provides more context by mentioning events before and after the convention, as well as key figures and locations involved. While the primary source only discusses what happened at the convention, the secondary source presents a more complex narrative surrounding the convention.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Primary vs. Secondary Sources On Tejeros Convention (1897

    Uploaded by

    Achilles Gabriel Aninipot
    496 views13 pages
    The document summarizes and compares a primary source and secondary source on the Tejeros Convention of 1897. The primary source is Santiago Alvarez's memoirs, which focuses only on the events of the convention itself. The secondary source, written by Teodoro Agoncillo, provides more context by mentioning events before and after the convention, as well as key figures and locations involved. While the primary source only discusses what happened at the convention, the secondary source presents a more complex narrative surrounding the convention.

    Original Description:

    asd

    Original Title

    CREDIBLE_ANALYSIS__1_.pptx

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document summarizes and compares a primary source and secondary source on the Tejeros Convention of 1897. The primary source is Santiago Alvarez's memoirs, which focuses only on the events of the convention itself. The secondary source, written by Teodoro Agoncillo, provides more context by mentioning events before and after the convention, as well as key figures and locations involved. While the primary source only discusses what happened at the convention, the secondary source presents a more complex narrative surrounding the convention.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    496 views13 pages

    Primary vs. Secondary Sources On Tejeros Convention (1897

    Uploaded by

    Achilles Gabriel Aninipot
    The document summarizes and compares a primary source and secondary source on the Tejeros Convention of 1897. The primary source is Santiago Alvarez's memoirs, which focuses only on the events of the convention itself. The secondary source, written by Teodoro Agoncillo, provides more context by mentioning events before and after the convention, as well as key figures and locations involved. While the primary source only discusses what happened at the convention, the secondary source presents a more complex narrative surrounding the convention.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    You are on page 1of 13

    Primary vs.

    Secondary
    Sources on Tejeros
    Convention (1897)
    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ TEODORO
    “MEMOIRS OF A AGONCILLO’S
    GENERAL” “REVOLT OF THE
    MASS”
    AUTHOR’S
    BACKGROUN
    D
    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE
    GENERAL” MASS”

    • BORN: July 25, 1872 • BORN: November 9, 1912


    • WHERE: Cavite, Philippines • WHERE: Lemery, Batangas, Philippines
    • DIED: October 30, 1930 • DIED: January 14, 1985
    • WHERE: San Pablo, Laguna, Philippines • WHERE: San Pablo, Laguna, Philippines
    • Was a son of the revolutionary leader • He renowned as Filipino historian and
    Mariano Alvarez. national scientist.
    • He became Captain General of the • He wrote more than 20 books and a lot
    Magdiwang forces and fought with more articles about the history of the
    distinction against Spain in the battles of Philippines.
    1896-1807 • He was one of the “Ten Outstanding Young
    • He was a revolutionary general a founder Men (TOYM)”, of the Junior Chamber of
    and honorary president of the first the Philippines in 1963.
    directorate of the Nationalista Party also • He was conferred as a National Scientist in
    known as “KIDLAT NG APOY” (LIGHTING 1985.
    OF FIRE). • He was “Distinguished Scholar of the
    • He was a member of the Katipunan University of the Philippines” in 1968.
    Secret Society.
    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE MASS”
    GENERAL”
    Works Works

    - The Katipunan and the - The Revolt of the Masses: The Story
    Toledo Revolution: Memoirs of of Bonifacio and the Katipunan (mainly a
    a General. biography of Andres Bonifacio, 1956)
    - Recalling the Toledo - Malolos: The Crisis of the Republic
    Revolution: Memoirs of a Filipino (sequel to Revolt of the Masses which
    General. discusses the events from Biak-na-Bato
    to the end of the Philippine–American
    War, 1960)
    - The Fateful Years: Japan's Adventure
    in the Philippines (Philippine history
    during World War II, two volumes, 1965)
    - History of the Filipino People (eight
    editions: 1960, 1967, 1970, 1973, 1977,
    1984, 1986, 1990)
    WHEN WAS THE ACCOUNT WRITTEN?
    SECONDARY SOURCE:
    PRIMARY SOURCES : TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A MASS”
    GENERAL”

    Published: Published:

    1920 1956
    In Sampaguita, a tagalog weekly College of Liberal Arts of the
    and translated in english by Paula
    Carolina Malay.
    University of the Philippines

    https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/3613857-the-katipuna
    n-and-the-revolution https://kyoto-seas.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/490306.pdf
    MENTION OF DATE(S)
    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE
    GENERAL” MASS”

    March 25, 1897 January 2, 1897


    The assembly at Tejeros was finally Bonifacio wrote from San Francisco de
    convened. Malabon to his uncle in law Mariano
    Alvarez.
    March 27, 1897
    Eyewitness spied what happened March 22, 1897
    during the night of March 26,1897 Aguinaldo's Birthday and
    Magdalo soldiers leaded by Emilio
    Aguinaldo Faced Spaniards in Salitran
    (a Bario between Imus and
    Dasmariñas).
    MENTION OF PLACE
    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A GENERAL” TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE MASS”

    Cavite
    Noveleta
    San Francisco de Malabon
    Naik
    Cavite Kawit
    Santa Cruz de Malabon Maragondon
    Mountains of montalban
    Mariquina
    Zapote
    Imus
    Morong
    San Juan del Monte
    Salitran
    Tanza
    KEY PERSONALITIES
    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE
    GENERAL” MASS”

    • Supremo Andres Bonifacio- • Supremo Andres Bonifacio-


    • Emilio Aguinaldo • Emilio Aguinaldo
    • Daniel Tirona- Break the meeting rules • Daniel Tirona- Breakt the meeting rules
    and insulted the elected Jose del and insulted the elected Jose del Rosario
    Rosario • Pres. Baldomero Aguinaldo- leader of
    • Pres. Baldomero Aguinaldo- leader of Magdalo
    Magdalo
    • Santiago V. Alvarez (Magdiwang)
    • Maraino Alvarez
    SEQUENCING
    PRIMARY SOURCES :
    OF EVENTS
    SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE
    GENERAL” MASS”
    • The Tejeros Convention was the • Katipunan in Cavite divide into 2 factions:
    meeting held on March 22, 1897 Magdalo and Magdiwang
    between the Magdiwang and Magdalo
    factions of the Katipunan at San • Bonifacio invited by Magdiwang to visit
    Francisco de Malabon, Cavite. Cavite.
    • Misunderstanding exist between 2 rebel
    • Misunderstanding arise between groups.
    Andres Bonifacio and Daniel Tirono.
    • Convention assembly in Imus.
    • Those elected in Tejeros convention
    knelt before the crucifix. • Eleccion happened
    • Magdalo troops guard the oath-taking • Bonifacio sent a letter to Mariano Alvarez
    ceremonies inside the parish in Tanza. his uncle in law and Emilo Jacinto.
    DIFFERENCES BETWEEN 2 ACCOUNTS
    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:
    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE
    GENERAL” MASS”

    Agoncillo covers up what happened before


    the Tejeros convention happened. Also
    The events that is given by Alvarez is more Agoncillo mentioned some different
    on how the election goes and what significant battle before the Tejeros
    happened during the election day in convention happened. He is pinpointing
    Tejeros. Also in the given event, Alvarez some of important events that took place
    doesn't mention any event that happened before or prior to Tejeros convention. Unlike
    after the election was done. the events that is Alvarez has given,
    Agoncillo's events has a different significant
    dates also. He is just not pinpointing the
    event in Tejeros convention but also the
    events before the Tejeros convention.
    ANALYSIS OF THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN 2 ACCOUNTS

    PRIMARY SOURCES : SECONDARY SOURCE:


    SANTIAGO ALVAREZ’ “MEMOIRS OF A TEODORO AGONCILLO’S “REVOLT OF THE
    GENERAL” MASS”

    • The text from this source is short than • It was more complex than the primary
    the secondary source. source because it tell what are the things
    happen before, during and after the
    • The author is one of the member in assembly.
    tejeros convention and I think is bias
    because he only give his own perspection • Also, the author made a lot of
    about his experience and the group accomplishment where he never been bias
    where he belonged. Yet, the author is upon writing because he doesn’t belong in
    the eyewitness. any group in in the context.

    • Secondary source is more reliable.


    Group 1
    BSN1-C

    KAELA MERYL ESPAÑA


    YEE MARIE DOVE RODRIGUEZ
    JOED HILLARY TE
    JENSEN CAÑETE
    CHRISTIAN REX VILLEGAS
    KATE DE LA PUERTA
    MARY GRACELLE PERALTA
    RO-ANN MAE DONDONAY

    You might also like