PCB Material Design Guide - Sierra Circuits - January 2021
PCB Material Design Guide - Sierra Circuits - January 2021
PCB Material Design Guide - Sierra Circuits - January 2021
PCB Material
Design Guide
Table of Contents
Section 1. Printed circuit board materials.................................... 4
1.1 Prepreg........................................................................... 4
1.2 Copper foil..................................................................... 4
1.3 Copper clad laminates................................................... 5
1.1 Prepreg
Copper foil on the outermost layer is the conductive medium through which electric
current flows. Copper traces on a PCB are made by selectively etching copper foil.
Traces (conductors or circuits) create the electrical connections on the PCB. In case
of multilayer PCBs, the electrical connections between the layers are made through
the holes that are drilled on the PCBs. Copper is deposited on the walls of these drilled
hoes. These holes establish electrical connection between the inner and outer layers.
4 www.protoexpress.com
www.protoexpress.com
1.3 Copper clad laminates (Core)
Cores are basically made up of prepregs and copper foils that have been laminated and
cured. A variety of materials with different thicknesses, epoxy properties, and types of
glass weave are available. The designer must define the desired combination that is
well suited for his/her application. The process of creating copper clad laminate begins
with glass fiber interwoven to make glass cloth, this cloth is impregnated in epoxy resin
and semi cured to make a ply of prepreg. Number of plies of prepreg are bonded to-
gether along with the copper foils on the outermost layers to make a laminate (copper
cladded laminate). Some commonly used prepregs are 1080, 7628, 2116, 2113, and
2165.
Glass transition temperature or Tg, is the temperature range in which a PCB substrate
transitions from a glassy, rigid state to a softened, deformable state as polymer chains
become more mobile. When the material cools back down, its properties return to their
original states. Tg is expressed in units of degrees Celsius (°C).
Below the Tg the substrates are hard. The substrates attain rubbery state between the
Tg and Tm (melting temperature) temperatures . At temperature greater than the melting
point (melting temperature) the materials transform from solid to viscous liquid. During
this phase the PCB material completely loses its shape.
2.1.2 Decomposition temperature (Td)
So choose a material that can work in a temperature range that’s higher than the Tg
but well below the Td. Most solder temperatures during PCB assembly are in the 200°C
to 250°C range, so make sure Td is higher than this (luckily, most materials have a Td
greater than 320°C).
6 www.protoexpress.com
2.1.3 Coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE)
The coefficient of thermal expansion or CTE, is the rate of expansion of a PCB material
as it heats up. CTE is expressed in parts per million (ppm) expanded for every degree
Celsius that it is heated.
As the material’s temperature rises past Tg, the CTE will rise as well.
The CTE of a substrate is usually much higher than copper, this can cause interconnec-
tion issues when a PCB gets heated.
The CTE along the X and Y axes are generally low – around 10 to 20 ppm per degree
Celsius. This is usually due to the woven glass that constrains the material in the X
and Y directions, and the CTE doesn’t change much even as the material’s temperature
increases above Tg.
So the material must expand in the Z direction. The CTE along the Z axis should be as
low as possible.
CTE is also useful to locate the Tg of a material by using a CTE curve. Plot a material’s
temperature versus displacement, then find the intercept of the two curves.
Most PCB dielectric materials have a thermal conductivity in the range of 0.3 to 0.6
W/M °C, which is quite low compared to copper, whose k is 386 W/M °C. Therefore,
more heat will be carried away quickly by copper plane layers in a PCB than by the
dielectric material.
It is the ratio of the electric permittivity of the material to the electric permittivity of
free space (i.e., vacuum). It is also known as relative permittivity. The Er for most PCB
materials is in the range between 2.5 and 4.5.
The dielectric constant varies with frequency and generally decreases as frequency
increases; some materials have less of a change in relative permittivity than others.
Materials suitable for high frequency applications are those whose dielectric con-
stant remains relatively the same over a wide frequency range–from a few 100MHz
to several GHz.
2.2.2 Dielectric loss tangent or dissipation factor (Tan δ or Df)
The loss tangent is the phase angle between the resistive and reactive currents in the
dielectric. The dielectric loss increases with increasing values of Df. Low values of Df
result in a fast substrate while large values result in a slow substrate. Df gives a
measure of the power loss in a dielectric material. Df is frequency dependent – higher
the frequency, higher the Df. Generally, lower the Dk of a PCB material, lower is the Df,
and flatter is the Df vs Frequency curve. The values range from 0.001 to 0.030.
8
Figure 4: Dielectric loss tangent
www.protoexpress.com
2.3 Mechanical properties
It is the ratio of the electric permittivity of the material to the electric permittivity of
It is a measure of the stiffness of a solid material or the amount of force required to
deform a material. It is defined as the ratio of the stress (force per unit area) along
an axis to the strain (ratio of deformation over initial length) along that axis in the
range of stress in which Hooke’s law holds i.e., the stress-strain curve is linear. It is
expressed as Pascals or pounds (force) per square-inch (psi).
2.3.2 Flexural strength or bend strength
It is a measure of a material’s maximum stress it can take before breaking, while being
pulled from both sides. Like tensile modulus, it is expressed as Pascals or pounds/
square-inch (psi).
www.protoexpress.com
Figure 5: Smooth copper (Source: Altium) Figure 6: Rough copper (Source: Altium)
10 www.protoexpress.com
When an alternative current is passing through a conductor, the varying magnetic fields
induce electric field (Eddy current). This induced electric field opposes the main current
that is flowing through the center of the conductor but strengthens the current that is
flowing outside on the outer surface of the conductor. As a result there is an increase in
current density on the conductor surface. This phenomenon is called skin effect.
The effective section of the conductor where most of the current flows (skin depth) can
be estimated with equation below:
Where,
ẟ is skin depth in meters
f is frequency in Hertz
μ is magnetic permeability
σ is electrical conductivity in Siemens per meter (S/m)
Skin depth in copper for different frequencies
1Hz 65.2 mm
1MHz 65 μm
1GHz
2.1μm
10GHz
0.65 μm
50GHz 0.29 μm
Skin depth effect reduces the effective cross section of the current carrying con-
ductor. For conductors with a rough profile, a low skin depth causes the current flow
through the contour of the material, this increases the length of the propagation path
as illustrated in the below figure.
12 www.protoexpress.com
In order to mitigate this effect it is always recommended to use low profile copper
with a good mechanical adhesion.
As you can see from the graph above, there’s a direct correlation between signal loss
and frequency. At the same time, we can also see that certain materials are less lossy
than others.
Below chart classifies the essential materials into various buckets based on the
signal loss properties.
13
Figure 10: PCB material categories
Normal-speed materials are the most common PCB materials—the FR-4 family. Their
dielectric constant (Dk) versus frequency response is not very flat and they have high-
er dielectric loss. Therefore, their suitability is limited to a few GHz digital/analog
applications. An example of this material is Isola 370HR.
Medium-speed materials have a flatter Dk versus frequency response curve, and have
a dielectric loss about half that for normal speed materials. These are suitable for up
to ~10GHz. An example of this material is Nelco N7000-2 HT.
These materials also have flatter Dk versus frequency response curves and low di-
electric loss. They also generate less unwanted electrical noise compared to other
materials. They are suitable for ~10 - 30 GHz applications. An example of this mate-
rial is Isola I-Speed.
Materials for RF/microwave applications have the flattest Dk versus frequency re-
sponse and the least dielectric loss. They are suitable for up to ~20GHz applications
and beyond. An example of this material is Isola Tachyon 100G.
14 www.protoexpress.com
4.5 PCB material options
Medium speed,
Isola FR370HR normal loss
16 www.protoexpress.com
Section 5: Copper foil selection
Below are a few properties that we need to consider while selecting copper foil.
Copper thickness: Typical thickness varies from 0.25 oz (0.3 mils) to 5 oz (7 mils)
Copper purity: It is the percentage of copper found in the copper foil. Electronic grade
copper foil has the purity of around 99.7%.
Copper-dielectric interface Profile: Low profile has lower signal copper losses at
high frequencies.
Electro-deposited copper: This type of copper has vertical grain structure and rough-
er surface. Electo-desposited copper is typically used in rigid PCBs.
Rolled copper: A type of copper, made very thin by processing between heavy rollers,
extensively used to produce flexible PCBs. Rolled copper has horizontal grain struc-
ture and a smoother surface which makes them ideal for rigid-flex and flex PCBs.
The physical parameters of an ED copper foil can be controlled with the addition
of organic additives into the plating bath. Certain additives – known as levelers –
can decrease the roughness of the surface. During the electrodeposition process,
the current density and electric field strength tend to be higher on the peaks of the
substrate which therefore tend to grow faster. This yields a rough surface. However,
some organic molecules are adsorbed preferentially on the peaks of a surface and
the deposition is therefore favoured on the valleys, yielding a product with a much
smoother profile.
18 www.protoexpress.com
Section 6: Choosing your PCB materials
Match coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE): CTE is the most critical thermal char-
acteristics for substrates. If the components of the substrates have different CTE,
they may expand at different rates during the fabrication process.
Opt for tight substrate weave: The Dk distribution in tight substrate weave will be
even.
Avoid FR4 for high-frequency applications: This is due to its high dielectric loss and
steeper Dk versus frequency response curve. (For frequencies less than 1 GHz)
Use lower moisture absorption materials: Moisture absorption is the ability of a PCB
material (copper in this case) to resist water absorption when immersed in water. It
is given by percentage increase in weight of a PCB material due to water absorption
under controlled conditions as per standard test methods. Most materials have mois-
ture absorption values in the range of 0.01% to 0.20%.
Application Materials
type
High speed Isola FR408 Isola Isola I -Tera Isola Astra Isola
materials HR I-Speed MT77 Tachyon
with pro- 100G
cessing
similar to
standard
FR-4
Polyimide N7000-2HT
boards
Advanced Rogers RO Rogers Rogers
Teflon 3000 series RT/Duroid ULTRALAM
boards series 2000
20 www.protoexpress.com
Section 7: Choosing HDI materials:
Key considerations
Choose a PCB material whose Tg is more than or equal to the maximum withstanding
temperature required for the PCB. For example, if operating temperature (Top) is 200
⁰C, choose a PCB material whose Tg >= 200 ⁰C.
The physical thickness of the PCB is important when considering the through hole
aspect ratio.
The physical thickness of a dielectric layer is important when considering the aspect
ratio of the microvia to be plated. The current standard aspect ratio for a microvia is
0.75:1.
For PCB material selection, another important consideration is the highest frequency
content of the signals of the electrical circuit of the PCB.
Along with these items, the dielectric constant of the material and the dissipation
factor, will also play vital roles in HDI PCB material selection, as was discussed in
earlier slides.
Dimensional stability: The material should be dimensionally stable; this also applies to
the non-HDI PCBs as well. All materials shrink and stretch to some extent during man-
ufacturing processes, and patterning must be scaled to compensate, which is not an
issue provided the material movement is predictable.
Machinability: The material must be easily machinable. For HDI that means it can be
laser drilled (Vaporization) without problems. Highly concentrated energy is directed in
a focused beam on a specific area, which is absorbed by the material until it vaporizes.
Epoxy resin is the most commonly used thermosetting resin and is the backbone of the
industry. Thanks to its relatively low cost, excellent adhesion (to the metal foils as well
as to itself), and good thermal, mechanical, and electrical properties.
Sierra Circuits recommends Isola 370HR for normal-speed HDI PCBs and I-Speed
and I-TeraMT40 materials for high-speed HDI PCBs.
Copyright Sierra Circuits Inc., 2021
21
Section 8: The PCB Material
Selector Tool
In order to help you determine what sort of material will best suit your design needs,
Sierra Circuits provides a list of materials with their most important properties.
To view the material options you will have to key in the data into the various fields
of our material selector tool.
In this field, the users can select the type of application/assembly. The user is
allowed to select both of these options.
22 www.protoexpress.com
2.Filter results by IPC and Slash number
The users can select the IPC standard applicable to their PCB in this section.
The drop-down “IPC number” lists the available IPC standards as shown in the below
image.
If the option “All” is selected from the drop-down, the user will get to see the complete
range of materials that are available.
The significance of these IPC standards is explained at the end of this section.
Once the IPC standard is selected, the user can select the corresponding slash
number (if any) of the selected IPC standard.
3.Material characteristics
Whether CAF resistant: If yes, the user can click on the “YES” button.
Conductive anodic filament, also called CAF, is a metallic filament that forms from an
electrochemical migration process and is known to cause PCB failures.
Select range for Tg ⁰C: The range of the Tg (glass transition temperature) can be set
by the available range 130 ⁰C to 280 ⁰C.
Dielectric constant and frequency: The frequency and the corresponding dielectric
constant range can be defined in this field. The dielectric constant here ranges from
2.17 to 10.20.
Loss tangent: The frequency and the corresponding loss tangent range can be de-
fined in this field. The loss tangent here ranges from 0.0005 to 0.0230.
The user can choose from the available family of the materials and manufacturers.
24 www.protoexpress.com
The next step is to hit the “Find Materials” button. The available materials for your
requirement will be displayed on your screen as shown below:
The users can shortlist the materials by selecting them and compare the properties of
the shortlisted materials by hitting the compare button.
IPC-4101: Specification for base materials for rigid and multi-layer boards
This standard covers the prerequisites for laminate or prepreg utilized for rigid or
multi-layer PCBs. The specification sheets are arranged by type of reinforcement,
resin system and/or construction. These specification sheets are provided with a
specification number for ordering purposes.
This standard covers the prerequisites for the substrates that are used in the fabrica-
tion of high speed/high frequency PCBs. This specification applies to material thick-
ness defined in the specification sheets as measured over the dielectric only.
IPC/JPCA-4104: This standard defines the specification for HDI and microvia
materials.
IPC-4204: This standard covers the specifications for flexible metal-clad substrates
that are used in fabrication of flexible PCBs.
Standard stack-up design is dependent on the number of signal layers present. For
standard PCB stack-up, key parameters include the number of layers, number of
ground and power planes, frequency of the circuit, the sequence of the layers, and
emission requirements. Some of the additional parameters include spacing between
the layers and a shielded or unshielded enclosure.
26 www.protoexpress.com
9.2 How to achieve best possible PCB stack-up design?
Whether it’s an HDI or a standard stack-up board, following certain guidelines in ac-
cordance with the application and its requirements is the best possible way to imple-
ment the PCB stack-up design. Here are a few pointers for your PCB stack-up design:
PCB stack-up is dependent on the number of signal layers present in the design.
Signal layers change in accordance with the application of the PCB. For instance,
high-speed signal or high-power applications may require a greater number of layers
compared to low-speed signal levels. The ground layers or planes are also considered
before designing the PCB stack-up. PCB designers should avoid mixing different sig-
nals on inner layers.
Ground layer is the plane of copper in the PCB that is connected to the ground con-
nection of the power supply. Power layer is a flat plane of copper in the PCB connect-
ed to the power supply and the ground. The purpose of using ground planes in your
PCB is to provide voltage/signal return paths and to reduce noise and signal interfer-
ence. Power planes are used to improve the decoupling ability of the circuits in the
PCB. It also provides the shorter return paths which improves the EMC performance.
Power planes have a larger current carrying capacity than the traces. This reduces the
operating temperature of the PCB.
Another key aspect of the stack-up design is the sequential layer arrangement. Ar-
ranging high-speed signal layers depending on the thickness of prepreg is one of the
key parameters that a designer must consider before routing. Placing signal layers
below the power plane will allow tight coupling.
For precise layer arrangement, keep a minimum distance between power and ground
plane. Other key parameters include, avoid placement of two signal layers adjacent to
each other, and build symmetric stack-up of the top and bottom layers.In sequential
lamination, try to limit the number of lamination steps as it becomes more expensive
and time consuming.
An important consideration for your PCB stack-up is the thickness of each signal
layer. This should be established in conjunction with determining thicknesses for pre-
preg and core(s). There are standard thicknesses, as well as other properties, for
different circuit board material types. Your process for selecting materials should
include these electrical, mechanical and thermal properties.
For instance, layers that require higher voltage will require thicker copper layer.
Proper material selection is important since materials will affect the electrical per-
formance of the signal traces. Following the guidelines provided in this design guide
enables you to choose the best possible PCB materials for your design.
28 www.protoexpress.com
Copyright Sierra Circuits Inc., 2021
29
Sierra Circuits
1108 West Evelyn Avenue
Sunnyvale, CA 94086
+1 (408) 735-7137
www.protoexpress.com
30
www.protoexpress.com