The Egyptian Placer Deposits - International Nuclear
The Egyptian Placer Deposits - International Nuclear
The Egyptian Placer Deposits - International Nuclear
Second Arab Conference on the Peaceful Uses of Atomic Energy, Cairo 5 - 9 Nov. 1994 AAEA
/0,04c /0,06
i / 6 , 0 4 j ^ j - j j i l j ^ J \ • M^1 / 0 , 4 8 LfLe. CJ-JJL
6,31
l 9 8 , 6 4 ^^Lfe J J ^ J ^ J I JOJL-O ^ J ^ A - J J ^ j ^ l i L ^ J I j ^ J ^ J I ^ J J J I ^ > j • .• <?1
Abstract
Extensive black sands placer deposits are discontinuously distributed
along the northern Mediterranean coastal plain of the Nile Delta as well
as Sinai Peninsula i.e. in the coastal stretch between Abu Qir town to the
west and Rafah city on the eastern Egyptian Frontiers. These sediments
contain strategic and economic heavy minerals which are required for
the industrial exploitation whether for nuclear industry or other metal-
lurgical and engineering industries. The mentioned deposits comprise
huge reserves of the six heavy economic minerals which include mona-
zite, zircon, rutile, ilmenite, magnetite, and garnet.
191
The first three economic minerals namely monazite, zircon, and
rutile contain uranium, thorium, zirconium, hafnium, titanium as well as
rare earth elements, thus monazite, which is a rare earths-thorium
anhydrous orthophosphate assays 0.48% U3O8, 6.04% Th O2, and
61.31% RE2O3. Egyptian beach zircon which is a zirconium silicate
mineral contain 67.06% (Zr+Hf) O2. Traces of uranium assays from
0.04% to 0.11%. U3O8, while its thorium content varies from 0.02% to
1.19% Th O2. The beach rutile is almost a puretitanium dioxide
assaying up to 98.64% TiO2- Therefore, the geological reserves of the
nuclear materials were estimated to reveal enormous reserves.
In the light of these data, the Nuclear Materials Authority has
established a plant for the exploitation of the Egyptian placer deposits at
Rosetta area to produce monazite, zircon, and rutile concentrates. The
monazite concentrate will be processed for the production of uranium,
thorium, and rare earth oxides cakes, while zirconium, hafnium,
uranium, and thorium oxides could be extracted from the zircon
concentrate. Titanium dioxide for nuclear industry and paints could be
produced from the rutile concentrate. In the mean time zircon as a
mineral would be used in ceramic industry whereas rutile as a mineral
would be used in welding rods industry. Besides, the rare earth oxides
cake could be used in ferro-silicon alloys.
1- Introduction
The Egyptian black sands placer deposits on the Mediterranean
Coastal Plain contain many mineral species as they have been derived
from igneous and metamorphic rocks [1]. Many studies were carried
out dealing with the mineralogical composition, grain size distribution,
origin of the sediments as well as their economic considerations [1 to
25]. The mineral constituents include six heavy economic minerals;
namely magnetite, ilmenite, monazite, zircon, rutile and garnet.
Monazite, zircon and rutile minerals do contain a number of elements
necessary for the nuclear industry e.g. uranium, thorium, zirconium,
hafnium, titanium and rare earths elements. Thus, the evaluation of these
raw materials in the Egyptian blacksands placerdeposits would be
calculated on the basis of the reserves of monazite, zircon and rutile
mineral content in four localities along the Mediterranean Coastal Plain;
namely Rosetta, Baltim, Damietta and north Sinai.
192
2- Geology
Since the Late Miocene [26] and before the completion of the High
Dam in May 1964, the River Nile was discharging huge quantities of
sediments during the annual flood seasons in the Mediterranean Sea.
These sediments were the final products of the disintegrated materials
from the two main drainage areas of the Nile Basin which cover an area
of about 3,000,000 km 2 i.e. The Equatorial Plateau (igneous rocks) and
the Ethiopian Plateau (metamorphic rocks).
The River Nile poured its load in the Mediterranean Sea either by
the to-day Rosetta and Damietta distributaries (Fig. 1 ) or through the
seven old extinct Nile Branches.
Ball [27] described the courses and the outpourings of the seven old
extinct Nile Distributaries and stated that the outpourings were located
in the coastal plain area that extend between Idku openning and El
Farama east of Port Said (Fig.2). In other words, the black sands
deposits are distributed along the Mediterranean Coastal Plain in the
sector extending between Abu Qir town to the west and Rafah city on
the Eastern Egyptian frontiers (Fig. 1).These sediments are now present
either as beach deposits or in the form of coastal plain sand dunes. The
high grade black sands are associated with the outpourings of the Nile
Distributaries whether the present or the extinct ones. The reserve
estimation of monazite, zircon and rutile
minerals will be carried out at the two locality related to the to-day
Rosetta and Damietta promontories and two other locality related to the
extinct Sebbenytic and Pelusaic estuaries. The study will include both
beach sediments as well as coastal plain sand dune£.
3- Reserves Estimation
The four chosen localities for geological reserve evaluation for
monazite, zircon and rutile are considered to be the principal black
sands deposits. The first locality is on both sides of Rosetta promontory.
It extends from Idku Lake outlet to El Burrullus Lake openning. This
stretch is about 70 km long and its width varies from about 200 m to
about 5000 m with an average width of about 800 m. The area is
characterized mainly by beach deposits except west Rosetta outpouring
sector which has coastal plain sand dunes. The depth of the black sands
in this area reaches about 9m. Beyond this depth, the sand fraction
decreases to be less than 40% while the clay fraction constitutes the
193
major percentage. Above the mentioned depth, the sand fraction
generally exceeds 60% of the sediments.
The second locality is the coastal plain sand dune belt in which the
heavy minerals content reaches up to about 35% and covers the area
from Burg El Burrullus village eastward to El Gharbia Main Drainage, a
stretch of about 15 km long and average width of about 800m. The
height of the sand dunes in this area reaches up to 15m, however, an
average height of 5m will be considered. Assuming that the beach
sediments under the sand dunes reach about 10m depth, the thickness of
the deposit in this area will be considered as 1 5m.
The third locality is the north western part of El Manzalla Lake and
the beach area just east of Damietta outpouring. The depth of this
deposit will be 10 m and the area is about 30 km2. This area is
characterized by a series of parallel sand bars called "Barr" trending
generally northwest and are separated by longitudinal lagoons called
"Tawal". The mechanism of formation of these parallel sand bars was
attributed by Said [281 and Hamama [291 to be the result of the
accretion of the bottom sediments of the continental shelf by the wave
action and the continuous accumulation of these sands till the sand bar
became exposed on the surface of the sea water leaving a longitudinal
lagoon behind it.
The last locality is the north Sinai coastal plain sector which extends
between the eastern openning of El Bardawiel Lake at El Zaraniq in the
west and El Arish town in the east. This stretch is about 20 km in length
and about 500 m width It is characterized by beach deposits lined from
the south by north Sinai sand dune belt [30]. The depth of the deposit
in this area is about 10 m.
In order to estimate the reserves of the black sands in the four
localities and consequently the monazite, zircon and rutile mineral
content, the apparent specific gravity of the dry sand used in the
calculations must be 1.7 g/cm3 [31]. Also, the average frequencies of
each of the monazite, zircon, and rutile minerals in the Egyptian black
sands will be considered as 0.02%, 0.22% and 0.12% respectively.
Due to the fact that Egyptian beach monazite almost belongs to one
variety, its uranium and thorium contents do not vary greatly, on the
otherhand, the uranium and thorium contents of zircon show great
variation due to the presence of several varieties of beach zircon. The
194
existence of uranium and thorium in zircon is either due to defects in
zircon structure or to inclusions of radioactive minerals like
uranothorite. The coloured, cloudy, zoned (inclusions) and metamict
zircon varieties contain more uranium and thorium than the colorless
water-clear zircon varieties [32, 33, 34, 35 & 36]. Therefore, the
different varieties of the Egyptian beach zircons were separated on the
basis of their mass magnetic susceptibility. The obtained fractions were
analyzed for their uranium and thorium contents. The U3O8, Th O2 and
the frequency of each fraction were calculated and tabulated in table
(1). From these values the average content was found to be 0.06% U3O8
and 0.04% Th O 2 .
195
TABLE II: AVERAGE CONTENTS OF THE NUCLEAR RAW
MATERIALS IN MONAZ1TE, ZIRCON AND RUTILE.
4- Discussion
The extensive Egyptian black sands placer deposits exhibit vast
reserves of monazite, zircon and rutile beside magnetite, ilmenite and
garnet minerals. The former three minerals have nuclear importance
due to their content of nuclear raw materials. Monazite which is a rare
earths-thorium anhydrous orthopliosphate contains uranium, thorium,
196
titanium and rare earth elements. Zircon is mainly a zirconium silicate
mineral with uranium, thorium, hafnium, titanium, and rare earth
elements in minor quantities. Rutile mineral is essentially a titanium
dioxide assaying up to 98.64% TiC>2 but some rutile varieties contain
Nb and/or Ta due to similarities of their ionic radii [37]. Therefore, their
reserves in the black sands were calculated and were found to be
enermous quantities.
Different previous studies have dealt with the reserves of the heavy
economic minerals in Rosetta and Damietta localities either in the top
meter, in 12m depth or 20m depth. El Shazly [38] estimated the
economic mineral reserves, the monazite reserves and both the U3O8
and Th O2 reserves in east Damietta locality as well as east Rosetta
locality to a depth of 20m. (Table4). About 707 million ton of heavy
economic minerals were estimated in 1.6 km2 in Abu Khashaba beach
to a depth of 12m [39]. Another estimate in an area of 8.25 km2 to
20m depth in the same locality exhibit 30.5 million ton of heavy
economic minerals containing 113,000 ton monazite, 354,000 ton
zircon and 220,000 ton rutile [40].Moreover,EBASCO [41] estimated
37,200,000 ton heavy economic minerals in 12 km 2 to 20m depth in
east Rosetta beach and 5,400,000 ton heavy economic minerals in about
5 km 2 at west Rosetta locality to a depth of about 20m.
5- Industrial Exploitation
The industrial exploitation of these deposits will now be discussed
on the basis of three alternatives of production capacities. Proposed
capacities include 10 m3/h, 100m3/h, and 1000 m3/h of dry sands. At
the same time, the daily working hours could be 8, 16 or 24. In case of
8 working hours per day, the used tonnages of raw black sands in a year
and consequently the produced tonnages of monazite, zircon and rutile
concentrates as well as the calculated quantities of nuclear elements are
shown in table V. If the working hours per day were doubled or tripled
i.e. 16 or 24 hour per day the maximum exploited raw black sands in a
198
year the produced monazite, zircon and rutile and the expected nuclear
raw materials will be two or three times as the given figures in table V
respectively.
10 m 3 /h 100 m 3 /h 1000 m 3 /h
(ton) (ton) (ton)
An Hour 17 170 1.700
8 Hours 136 1,360 13,600
A Year 40,800 408,000 4,080,000
MONAZITE 8.16 81.60 816
ZIRCON 89.76 897.60 8,976
RUTILE 48.96 489.60 4,896
u3o8 0.093 0.930 9.302
ThO 2 0.529 5.288 52.877
(Zr + HF) O2 60.193 601.931 6,019,306
TiO 2 48.353 483,529 4,835,290
RE 2 O 3 5.030 50,298 502,982
199
Acknowledgement
The author is deeply indepted to Prof. Dr. N.T. El Hazek, President
of the Nuclear Materials Authority for his kind advice and critical
reading the manuscript. The fruitful advices of Prof. Dr. Mamdouh A.
Hassan are greatly appreciated.
References
[I] HIGAZY, R.A., & NAGUIB, A.G., The study of the Egyptian
monazite-bearing black SHUKRI, N.M., Q,J,G,S, Vol. 105, pp. 511-
534 (1950).
12] SHUKRI, N.M., Mineral analysis tables of some Nile sediments, Bull.
De l'lnst. Fouad I De Deserte, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 39-67 (1951).
[3] HILMY, M.E.,. J. Sed, Petro., Vol. 21, pp. 109-120 (1951).
[4] SHUKRI, N.M. & PHILLIP, G., Bull. De l'lnst. D'Egypte, Vol. 37,
No. 2, pp. 377-394 (1955).
[5] SHUKRI, N.M. & PHILLIP, G., The geology of the Mediterranean
Coast between Rosetta and Bardia, Part 111 (Pleistocene sediments
mineral analysis Bull. De l'lnst. D'Egypte, Vol. 37, No. 2, pp. 445-
464 (1955).
[6] HIGAZY, R.A. & NAGUIB, A.G.,Black sands, Geneva, Proc. Sec.
UN Int. Conf. on the peaceful uses of Atomic Energy, Vol. 2, pp.
658-662 (1958).
[7] SHUKRI, N.M., & PHILLIP, G., The mineralogy of some recent
deposits in the , Bull. Fac, Sci., No. 35, pp. 73-85 (1961).
[8] MESHREF, W.M., Mineralogical and radiometric study for black
sand deposits on the Mediterranean Coast, M.Sc. Thesis, Fac. Sci.,
Ain Shams Univ., Cairo (1962).
[91 SOL1MAN, S.M., Primary structures in a part of the Nile Delta sand
beach, Proc. 6th Int. Sed. Cong., Devel. Sed., Deltaic and Shallow
Marine Sed., pp. 376-384 (1964).
[10] WASSEF, S. N., Correlation of the sedimentation conditions of the
Mediterranean beach of Damietta to the Suez Canal by heavy minerals
and isotopic applications, M.Sc. Thesis, Fac. Sci., Ain Shams Univ.,
Cairo (1964).
[II] HAMMOUD, N.M.S., Concentration of monazite from Egyptian
black sands, employing industrial techniques, M.Sc. Thesis, Fac.
Sci., Cairo Univ., Cairo, (1966).
200
[12] MIKAIL, M.A., Distribution and sedimentation of ilmenite in black
sands, west Rosetta, M.Sc. Thesis, Fac. Sci., Cairo Univ. (1971).
[13] HAMMOUD, N.M.S., Physical and chemical properties of some
Egyptian beach economic minerals in relation to their
concentration problems, Ph.D. Thesis, Fac. Sci., Cairo Univ., Cairo
(1973).
[14] WASSEF, S.N., Distribution of monazite in the black sands of
Rosetta and Damietta and its conditions of sedimentation Ph.D.,
Fac. Sci., Ain Shams Univ., Cairo (1973).
[15] MELEIK, M.L., FOUAD, K.M., WASSEF, S.N., AMMAR, A.A., &
DABBOUR, G.A., Aerial and ground radiometry in relation to the
sedimentation of radioactive minerals of the Damietta beach sands,
Egypt, Econ. Geol., Vol. 73, pp. 1738-1748 (1978).
[16] DABBOUR, G.A., Geological and mineralogical studies on rutile in
the black sand deposits from the Egyptian Mediterranean Coast,
Ph.D. Thesis, Fac. Sci.7 Cairo Univ., Cairo (1980).
[17] EL SHAZLY, E.M., EL SOKKARY, A.A., & DABBOUR, G.A.,
Physical properties of beach zircon from the Mediterranean Coast,
Egypt, Part 1: Grain size, shape and roundness, Egypt. J. Geol., Vol.
25, No. 1-2, pp. 95-111 (1 981 ).
[18] EL SHAZLY, E.M., EL SOKKARY, A.A., & DABBOUR, G.A.,
Distribution of beach zircon along the Mediterranean Coast, Egypt,
Egypt. J. Geol., Vol. 25, No. 1-2, pp. 113-122 (1981).
[19] EL SHAZLY, E.M., EL SOKKARY, A.A., & DABBOUR, G.A.,
Physical properties of beach zircon from the Mediterranean Coast,
Egypt, Part 11: Radioactivity, magnetic susceptibility, and
fluorescence, Egypt. J. Geol., Vol. 25, Ni, 1-2, pp. 123-130 (1981).
[20] AMMAR, A.A., WASSEF, S.N., MELEIK, M.L., FOUAD, K.M., &
DABBOUR, G.A., Remote surface and laboratory detection of
radioactive minerals of Rosetta black sand beach deposits, Egypt.
Int. J. Remote Sensing, Vol. 4, No. 4, pp. 739-754 (1983).
[21] MOHAMED, N. Sedimentological studies of the Quaternary
sediments in some boreholes, northeastern coast of Sinai, ARE,
M.Sc. Thesis, Fac. Sci., Alex. Univ., Egypt (1987).
[22] MORSY, A.M., DABBOUR, G.A., & MOHAMED, E.F.,
Sedimentologic and mineralogic studies on the coastal zone
sediments, north Sinai, Proc. 2nd Conf. Geol. Sinai, Develop.
Ismailia, pp. 65-72 (1989).
201
[23] DABBOUR, G.A., MORSY, M.A. and KAMEL, A.F., Radioactivity
and heavy economic minerals of some Quaternary sediments at El
Arish beach, north Sinai, Egypt. Annals Geol. Surve. Egyt, Vol. 16,
pp. 51-56, (1986-1990).
[24] DABOUS, A.A., DABBOUR, G.A., & DAWOOD, Y.H., Signature
of grain size parameters on the beach sediments, north Sinai, Egypt,
Bull. Sci. Ain Shams Univ., Vol. 30, pp. 445-459 (1992).
[25] DABOUS, A.A., DABBOUR, G.A., & DAWOOD, Y.H., Heavy
minerals content and radioactivity of the black sands, north Sinai,
Egypt, Accepted in the Egypt. Mineral. Vol. 4, (1993).
[26] SAID, R., The geological evolution of the River Nile, Springer-
Verlag, New York, Heidelberg, Berlin (1981).
[27] BALL, J., Egypt in the classical geographers, Survey and Mines
Dept. Cairo, (1942).
[28] SAID, R., Remarks on geomorphology of the deltaic coast between
Rosetta and Port Said, Bull. Soc. Geography of Egypt., Vol. 31, pp.
115-125 (1958).
[29] HAMAMA, H.H.E., Types and distribution of sediments and
landforms in the deltaic zone between Ras El Barr and Port Said,
M.Sc. Thesis, Fac. Sci., Mansoura Univ., El Mansoura, Egypt
(1978).
[30] MISSAK, R.A. & ATTIA, S.H., on the sand dunes of Sinai
Peninsula, Egypt, Egypt. J. Geol. Vol. 27, No. 1-2, pp. 1-22
(1983).
[31] DABBOUR, G.A., Heavy minerals content in relation to the
apparent specific gravity of the Egyptian black sands, Mans. Sci.
Bull., Special Issue, pp. 212 - 220 (1991).
[32] ZAGHLOUL, Z.M., Notes on the occurrence of uranothorite and
radioactive zircon in the black sands of Rosetta, Egypt, Egypt. J.
Geol., Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 89-91 (1960).
[33] GINDY, A.R., Radioactivity in monazite, zircon, and radioactive
black grains in black sands of Rosetta, Economic Geol., Vol. 56,
pp. 436-441 (1961).
[34] SILVER, L.T., & DEUTSCH, S., Uranium-lead isotopic variation in
zircon, a case study, J. Geol., Vol. 71, pp. 721-758 (1963).
[35] EL HINNAWI, E.E., Mineralogical and geochemical studies on
Egyptian (UAR) black sands, Beitrage Zur Mineralogie und
Petrographie, Vol. 9, pp. 519-532 (1964).
202
[36] STEIGER, P.H. & WASSERBURG, G.J., Systematic in Pb 2 0 8 -
Th 232 Rb 207 u235 a n d Pb 206 u238 s y s t ems, J. Res., Vol. 71, pp.
6065-6090 (1966).
[37] DEER, W.A., HOWIE, R.A. & ZUSSMAN, J., An Introduction to
the rockforming minerals, The English Language Book Society
and Longman, (1978).
[38] EL SHAZLY, E.M., Thorium resources in the United Arab
Republic and their possible utilization, Pannel on utilization of Th
in Power Reactors, IAEA, Vienna, pp. 186-198 (1966).
[39] KAMEL, O.A., RASMY, A.H., KHALIL, A., & BAKIR, R.,
Mineralogical analysis and evaluation of black sands at eastern part
of east side Nile section, Abu Khashaba area, Rosetta Egypt, Annals
Geol. Surv. Egypt, Vol. Ill, pp. 227 - 247 (1973).
[40] ANWAR, Y.M. & EL BOUSIELY, A.M., Subsurface studies of the
blacksand deposits at Rosetta Nile Mouth, Egypt, Bull. Fac. Sci.,
Alex. Univ., Egypt, Vol. 10, pp. 141-150 (1972).
[41] EBASCO Services Incorporated, Geelip Team, Evaluation of
proposed program for development of mineral deposits of
Egyptian Black Sands Company, Cairo, Five Years, Planning
organization (1964).
203
io oo' " yftf
A c
00 H E D i TEN R A K E AN SEA
i y£> Dan
Ho»«tluJ
3* \ Jl*
00
{
\ BO*
\
1
I\ \
1
\
JCAIHO
30*
30 J\ Q 10 *0 (0 \a 100 Km bo'
oo"
(
30 0 0 ' 31*00' 3f00' 3
*00' —
3t
MEDITERRANEAN SEA
Bolbtling •* Buco4ic
mouth .^ mouth w
Canopic fs-y* <mouh
mouth / \ •
/
3d'
7
YH*liopli» 30°
204