Tia For W & M Ventures
Tia For W & M Ventures
Tia For W & M Ventures
i
7.7 Tenth (10th) Year Traffic Condition with Development ................................................................... 29
8.0 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION............................................................................................... 30
8.1 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 30
8.2 Recommendation.............................................................................................................................. 31
ii
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
W & M Ventures in their quest to help reduce the soaring housing deficits in the Greater Accra
region of Ghana as well as provide office space for organizations which seeks to establish their
offices in the Greater Accra Region intend to construct a four-storey mix use apartment at La
Bawleshie. The mixed-use structure will have sixteen (16) units’ studio apartments, office spaces,
retail spaces, stores, restaurants and underground car parking spaces.
In compliance with the traffic impact regulations of Town and Country Planning Department, a
Transport Impact Assessment (TIA) is required for this new development. This traffic impact
assessment seeks to identify and address all the possible and/or anticipated impact that generated
traffic from the proposed development, could have on the road network within the project corridor.
Traffic studies were conducted on the existing road network within the project corridor of the
proposed development to determine the base year transport characteristics within the project
corridor.
The generation rates and factors from the land use rates from the Institution of Transportation
(ITE) were used in the analysis to estimate the traffic generation and parking indices required for
the proposed development. From the assessment of the traffic flows, the maximum number of
traffic generated by the proposed development during the peak period is 34 vehicle trips per hour.
This traffic was distributed along the existing road network within the project corridor and an
impact assessment was undertaken on the various links and intersections.
From the assessment of the critical intersections within the project corridor, it was realized that
there will be minimal impact of the traffic generated by the proposed development on the
intersections. There were minimal changes in the ICU performance levels in the base year with
development, fifth year (with development) and tenth year (with development).
It is anticipated that the changes occurred because the intersections already have high-capacity
levels.
From the assessment of the parking demands and provisions for the proposed development, it was
deduced that the parking demand required during peak periods are 82 parking spaces. The total
1
number of parking spaces, which have been provided in the proposed development, will be 160
parking spaces.
This implies that, the parking lots provided by the proposed development are about 95% more than
parking requirements for the full operations of the proposed development. 5 extra parking spaces
are needed to meet the parking demands during the peak periods. After projecting the parking
demand for ten years, the parking space provided will still be adequate for the full operations of
the proposed development during the peak hours.
2
1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
ILLKO Engineering Limited is contracted to carryout traffic impact assessment on a four storey
multi-purpose building intended to be constructed at La Bawleshie, in the La Nkwantang district
in the Greater Region of Ghana.
The developers of the proposed facility intend to help reduce the soaring housing deficits in the
greater Accra region of Ghana as well as, provide office spaces for organizations which seek to
establish their offices in the enclave.
This Multi-Purpose Structure will comprise of studio apartments, offices, stores, restaurant and
underground car parking spaces. The proposed structure will be located at the heart of East Legon
opposite the East Legon KFC premises. It is about 15minutes drive from both Accra mall and
University of Ghana.
According to DUR’s TIA manual, any structure with more than 1,000m2 GLA and 10 residential
units for apartments warranting an in-depth impact assessment. The proposed four storey structure
has a Gross Leasable Area of 3,729.79m2 including16 units, hence this justifies the demand of
traffic impact assessment report for the proposed development.
In compliance with the traffic impact regulations of Town and Country Planning Department,
Transport Impact Assessment (TIA) is required for this new development. The developers of the
proposed facility has therefore commissioned a Transportation and Highway Engineering
Consultant, to undertake a TIA for the proposed development.
3
1.2 Objectives
The objective of this assignment is to assess the transport impact of the proposed development on
the existing road network within the corridor and suggest mitigating measures to any transport
problems that may be identified and/or anticipated and whose impact will be detrimental to the
existing road network.
4
2.0 PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
The proposed Structure will be sited on plot number A4 at La Bawleshie in between Trinity
Avenue Road and Lagos Avenue Road directly opposite East legon KFC premises in the La
Nkwantang district in the Greater Accra Region.
The proposed development will have a total gross area of 3,729.79m2. The proposed project is a
four (4) Storey multi-purpose structure which comprises of offices, studio apartments, retail
spaces, stores, restaurant and underground car parks. Below is the breakdown of the various
components in the proposed structure.
FLOOR Utilization
Basement Car Port
Ground Floor Reception & Retail Space
First Floor Office Space & Restaurant
Restaurants 116
Stores 45
5
fig. 1:
fig. 2:
6
fig. 3:
fig. 4
7
fig. 5
fig. 6
8
fig. 7
fig. 8
9
3.0 THE EXISTING SITE CONDITION
3.1 Existing Site Use
The site for the proposed structure currently being occupied by a single storey residential
apartment which will be demolished to pave way for the proposed structure.
The land use in the vicinity is predominantly residential with few commercial buildings within.
Some of the commercial land uses includes offices, churches, schools, shops, hotel facilities, banks
etc.
The proposed site is surrounded on the east and south by Trinity Avenue Road and Lagos Avenue
Road respectively. It is also surrounded on the north and west by residential apartments.
10
Fig. 10: proposed site layout
Roads considered to be within the catchment area with respect to the traffic assessment are;
The Lagos Avenue Road is single carriage road with asphaltic surface. The road is in a good
condition with relatively moderate traffic volumes.
Trinity Avenue Road is a single carriage asphaltic road which links Lagos Avenue Road to La
Bawleshie Road. The road is in a good condition, with relatively moderate traffic volumes.
11
La Bawleshie main Road is a single carriage asphaltic road which links the N4 (Atomic Juntion)
to the Boundary Road at the American House junction. The road is in a good condition, with
relatively moderate traffic volumes.
2.3.2 Intersections
With respect to the catchment area three main intersections were considered as critical for traffic
studies and analysis. Two of the intersections are three-legged junctions, while the other is a four-
legged intersection. With respect to this study the intersections will be labeled as Intersection One
(1), Intersection Two (2) and Intersection Three (3) as indicated in the figure below.
12
The first intersection is a three-legged intersection where the Trinity Avenue Road intersect the
Lagos Avenue Road.
The second Intersection is three-legged intersection linking the Lagos Avenue Road to Mensah
wood Avenue Road. The intersection is not signalized.
13
Fig 13: second intersection
The third intersection considered as critical for the studies, is a four-legged signalized intersection. The
node is where Trinity Avenue Road crosses the La Bawleshie road.
14
4.0 IMPACT ASSESSMENT APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY
4.1 Impact Assessment Approach
For any project to warrant traffic impact assessment (TIA) the institution of highway and
transportation traffic impact assessment guidelines stipulates that traffic to and from the
development should exceed 10% of the two-way traffic flow on the adjoining road, there be 100
trips in/out combined in the peak hour there should be 100 on-site parking spaces and the facility
should have a Gross Floor Area in excess of 1000 square meters among others.
This assessment adopted the theoretical approach to determine the parking needs and other traffic
characteristics of the proposed development, reviewed the access requirement and assessed it
impacts on the adjoining roads.
Junction turning movement data were collected on adjoining roads of the proposed development.
The peak hour traffic volumes at identified critical intersections were determined from the turning
movement counts, and then used in capacity analysis to assess the projects impacts and determine
mitigation measures. The institute of transportation manual was used to determine and assess the
parking requirements and the generated trips of the proposed development.
The peak hour traffic volumes were then used in the junction capacity analysis and network
modelling of the proposed development synchro 11 traffic software was used to carry out the
analysis.
Turning Movement count Intersections One (1), Two (2) & Three (3)
16
4.3 Traffic Growth
The location of the project is an already developed area comprising offices, shops and mostly
residential facilities. Based on the consultant’s calculations, an annual traffic growth rate of 2%
has been applied generally to junction and link volumes.
In applying the different trip generation rates for these land uses from the ITE, a total of Thirty-
Four (34) vehicle trips were estimated to be generated by the facility during the peak hour period.
17
5.0 PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT ACCESS
Two main Accesses will be provided for the proposed structure. The first access will be on the
Trinity Avenue Road which will serves as the entry to the development. The second access is
directly along the Lagos Avenue Road which will serve as exit for vehicles from the structure.
Separate access will be provided for pedestrians who will be accessing the structure from both
Trinity Avenue Road and Lagos Avenue Road. As shown in the block plan below;
ENTRY
However, to ensure safety of road users, traffic wardens should be engaged to assist road users
accessing and exiting the premises. Traffic Management Plan should be implemented to ensure
optimum safety of all road users and since the structure is sited close to an intersection.
18
6.0 ASSESSMENT OF PARKING DEMANDS AND PROVISIONS BY THE
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
Generated Parking
Description/ITE Code GFA
Requirement
19
6.3 Parking Provisions of the Proposed Development
The minimum number of parking spaces required for the operations of the proposed development
during the peak hours is eighty-two (82) parking lots. The space provided in the underground car
park and the ground floor can accommodate 160 cars. This implies that the parking lots provided
for the proposed development are about 95% of the parking requirements for the full operations of
the proposed development. At a worst-case scenario that will rarely occur, the parking demand
was projected over a period of ten (10) years at a rate of 3.5%. The parking demand for the
projected period was estimated as 111 parking spaces. The parking lots provided for the proposed
development is about 44% more than the parking requirement for the projected period. This
implies that the parking provision for the proposed development is adequate.
20
7.0 TRAFFIC IMPACT ANALYSIS
7.1 General
According to the Institute of Highways and Transportation (IHT) Traffic Impact Assessment
guidelines, an impact is significant when:
Threshold values of traffic to and from the development exceeds 10% (5% when traffic congestion
exists) of the two-way traffic flow on the adjoining road,
By these stipulated thresholds, the proposed four storey may be said to have no significant impact
on traffic because it is expected to generate 34 trips (in and out) and parking demand of 82 lots
during the peak hour period.
However, the proposed development has a Gross Leasable Area of 3,729.79m2 which exceeds the
1,000m2 GLA, therefore warranting an in-depth impact assessment. Additionally, from the DUR’s
TIA manual, multi-unit residence more than 10 units demands for TIA report. The proposed
development has 16 units of studio apartments which justifies demand for a TIA report for the
proposed development.
Traffic operations for each intersection were evaluated based on their calculated level of service
(LOS). This was undertaken using the Intersection Capacity Utilization (ICU) methodology. This
methodology was applied using Synchro/Sim traffic 11 (traffic modelling software package).
The ICU tells how much reserve capacity is available or how the intersection is over capacity. It
does not predict delay, but it can be used to predict how often an intersection will experience
congestion. It is important to note that ICU is primarily used for signalized intersections but can
21
also be used on signalized intersections to determine the capacity utilization if the intersection
were to be signalized.
LOS is a qualitative measure of traffic operating whereby a letter grade, from A (least capacity
utilization/ delay) to H (most capacity utilization/delay), is assigned. These grades associated with
driving. The table below show the ICU range associated with each LOS category for signalized
and unsignalized intersections.
Intersection Capacity
LOS Utilization (ICU %) LOS Description
22
The intersection is 9% or greater over capacity and
could experience congestion periods of over 120
>109 minutes per day. Long queues are common.
H
Motorists may be choosing alternate routes, if they
exist, or making fewer trips during peak hour.
(Unacceptable)
Existing intersection traffic volume manual count of training movement volumes of the existing
junction was recorded. The traffic counts on ground are as shown below.
The peak hour volumes (PHV) are the most essential; therefore, both the AM and PM are required.
Traffic surveys for the weekday and weekend were conducted from which the morning and
evening peaks were obtained. Of these, the weekday PM peak was found to be the worst so was
used for the traffic model. The existing turning movement volumes at the peak hour are shown for
each of the assessed junctions in the figures below.
23
7.3.1 Senario One: Base year without the development
Intersection one (1) without development Intersection two (2) without development
24
7.3.2 Senario Two: Base year with the development
Intersection Two (2) with the development Intersection two (2) with the development
25
7.3.3 Senario Three: Fifth year with the development
Intersection one(1) - fifth year with development Intersection(2) - fifth year with development
26
7.3.4 Senario Three: Tenth year with the development
27
7.4 Existing Traffic without Development
Table 12: The existing traffic scenario was modelled, and the results are shown below.
The above table shows output results of traffic characteristics at the study intersections without the
development in place. Intersection One (1) recorded an ICU LOS C which indicates that the
intersection a relatively low traffic capacity. The intersection two (2) recorded ICU LOS C which
also indicates that intersection a relatively low traffic capacity as well. Intersection three (3)
recorded ICU LOS F, which indicates that the intersection has achieved its maximum capacity.
Table 13: The existing traffic with the development in place was also modelled and the results
are shown below;
The above table shows output results of traffic characteristics at the study intersections with the
development in place. Intersection One (1) recorded an ICU LOS D which indicates that the
intersection experienced a drop, nevertheless it is minimal since the intersection already had a high
ICU% of 73.0%. The intersection two (2) and three (3) maintained their ICU LOS of C and F
respectively, but there was minimal increase in their ICU LOS.
28
7.6 Fifth (5th) Year Traffic Condition with Development
Table 14: The development’s traffic was modelled with the 5th year traffic and the results are
shown below;
In the 5th year with the development, all the intersections maintained their ICU LOS, however
there were deterioration in the ICU% at all the three intersections.
The development’s traffic was modelled with the 10th year traffic and the results are shown below;
10th year with the development, all the three intersections experienced drops in the ICU LOS and
ICU percentages. However, with appropriate safety schemes, the deteriorations will be controlled.
29
8.0 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
8.1 Conclusion
The following conclusions have been drawn from the above analysis:
➢ Traffic survey for the weekday and weekend were conducted from which the morning and
evening peaks were obtained. Of these, the weekday PM peaks was found to be the worst
so was used for the traffic model.
➢ The proposed development shall generate Thirty-Four (34) vehicles trips during the peak
period which will be distributed on the existing road infrastructure within the project
corridor.
➢ The parking demand for the proposed development shall have a total parking of Eighty-
Two (82) parking spaces for the full operation of the proposed development. The total
parking lots provided in the engineering drawings are One Hundred and Sixty (160) lots
for the proposed facility. This implies that the parking spaces provided by the proposed
development are about 95% more than the parking requirements for the full operations of
the proposed development.
➢ From the capacity analysis of the access to the proposed development, it was identified that
the access provisions for the proposed development shall not have any significant impact
on the current state of the road network if recommendations are adhered to.
From the assessment of the intersections within the project corridor, it was identified that:
➢ There were minimal changes at the intersections in the ICU performance levels in the base
year with development, fifth year (with development) and tenth year (with development).
It is anticipated that the changes occurred because the intersections already have high-
capacity levels.
30
8.2 Recommendation
31
Reference
3. Institute of Highways and Transportation (1994), IHT Guidelines for Traffic Impact
assessment.
32
33
Appendix
Traffic Modelling Results
i
Existing Traffic Condition
ii
Base Year with Development Traffic Condition
iii
5th Year with Development Traffic Condition
iv
10th Year with Development Traffic Condition