COVER
COVER
VOLUME 2
ENGINEERING DESIGN AND PROJECT
SUPERVISTION REPORT
PROFFESSIONAL INTERVIEW
Of Nairobi, 2007
DATE: 4/12/2013
COPYTable of Contents
ABBREVIATIONS 43
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 54
2. INTRODUCTION 65
2.3 Methodology 87
4.2 Access 16
Page |
2
4.5 Water supply 17
Inception 18
5.2 20
Page |
3
6.2 Activity No. 2: driveways, parking and pavement survey 3130
6.6 Activity No. 6: Environmental Impact and Social Impact Assessment 3332
Page |
4
6.7.15 Welding consumables 3938
Page |
5
fulfilmentS (Hons)
ABBREVIATIONS
BS British Standard
fy Yield strength
L length
M metres
Page |
8
Page |
9
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Page |
10
Page |
11
INTRODUCTION
Background Information
Towns and Cities all over the world metamorphose. This metamorphosis is shaped by many forces, which
are economic, social, physical/spatial, cultural, political, environmental and institutional in nature. The
changes bring about challenges and opportunities, which require innovative planning interventions
(Arthur Munyua Mwaura, 2006). Couch (1990) has noted that the exponential rate of urbanization due to
an ever-growing population exerts very powerful forces to urban residential areas, making them undergo
internal spatial restructuring in response to social and economic pressures. These socio-economic changes
create demand for land and the physical fabric inevitably leading to increased requisition for the
reorganization and the restructuring of the urban fabric. The rapid rate of urbanization is exerting very
powerful forces to urban residential neighborhoodsneighbourhoods, making them to require internal
spatial restructuring in response to social and economic pressures.
Property developers includes; government institutions, churches, employee’s welfare groups, cooperative
societies, banking institutions and private individuals. Upon completion your project is either leased or
sold. Retaining your development as an addition to your high growth portfolio and borrowing against its
end value to progress to bigger and better investments and/or development projects is undeniably the best
way to grow your portfolio and wealth over the long term.
Although there are a distinct setare distinct sets of complementary steps that every property developer
must follow in order to achieve the best possible outcome, the process is rarely completely linear. It is
important for the developer to remain flexible and have the capacity to problem solve and think on their
feet at all times, as at any point plans can change in terms of scope.
KAREN ENTERPRISES LIMITED, in making their land more productive and responsive to demand for
sustainable development, intended to develop a complete master plan of housing units in their Plot, LR
No. 209/4858/1, Kkileleshwa, along Ring Road-Kileleshwa.
Karen Enterprises Ltd, sort the services of Architects, Civil and Structural Engineers, Surveyors,
Environmental Experts, Quantity Surveyors, and Services Engineers to carry out planning, design and
construction supervision for the residential development.
Page |
12
Team composition
Scope of works
Having perused the Terms of Reference, tThe basic objectives of the assignment as understood by the
Consultant (M/s Otieno Odongo & Partners Consulting Engineers) include, but are not necessarily
limited to, the following:
Assessment of the sites to get acquainted with actual state of all the components of the proposed
development
Obtaining the drawings for the existing structure to be used to assess the proposed renovation on the
existing town house.
Visual inspection for stress signs in the existing structural elements to guide on the type of tests to be
prescribed for determining the structural soundness of the existing structure
Assessment of adequacy of support services like water supply, power supply, parking, and drainage
Page |
13
Assessment of the impact the proposed development may have on the neighbouring developments.
Assessment of the topographic, hydrologic and geotechnical conditions of the site and their surroundings
Seek hydrological and climate records to establish design parameters of drainage structures
Obtain relevant information from clients clients which, which may be used as a benchmark for
improvement on serviceability/functionality of the proposed development.
Prepare specifications and general specifications for structural and civil works
Construction supervision
Methodology
The proposed methodology was designed to facilitate a participatory approach in teamwork fashion,
within the framework of consultancy as guided by the Lead consultant which involves the client/facilities
users at all stages of planning, design and documentation to ensure that the end product is functional,
aesthetic satisfactory, cost effective in maintenance and appreciated and owned by the client/end user.
This approach will guarantee fulfilment of the RFP requirements within planned time and cost.
Interpret the clients brief and prepare a scheme that is appropriate to the needs, meet the budgetary targets
and can be efficiently managed by the client in the long run
Page |
14
Ensure that the project meets quality standards and good practice in buildings, civil/structural engineering
and services design and physical planning while responding effectively to environmental challenges
The main activities of the assignment, their content and duration, milestones (including approvals by the
Client and statutory approvals); and delivery dates of the reports.
Project description
The Site
The site is situated approximately 600m from Kkileleshwa police station round about, along Ring Road-K
kileleshwa; there is an existing town house to be renovated. The entire plot is approximately 0.7486 ha,
with predominantly red clay, and alluvial deposit at the area next to the Kirichwa Kumbwa Rriver.
Kileleshwa is a quiet, upper-middle income, leafy suburb west of Nairobi City. The landscape is a
mixture of aging, colonial houses built in the 1950’s and 1960’s and modern apartments and townhouses.
The Government holds quite a significant part of Kileleshwa. Most senior civil servants have been housed
in Kileleshwa in spacious bungalows and maisonettes.
The Neighbourhood
Page |
15
Kileleshwa site is neighbouring Kilimani, Hurlingham, and Lavington. At the border of Kileleshwa and
Kilimani lies State House, the official residence of the President.
Kileleshwa is predominantly a residential area. There are a few commercial buildings with owners having
to seek permission for a change of land use permit from the City Council.
Proposed Development
The owner, (KAREN ENTERPRISES LIMITED), wants to build 3, townhouses units, and renovate the
existing town house to match the proposed development on Plot, LR No. 209/4858/1.
As design requirements as per the Nairobi City Council planning and buildings standards, the following
approvals were sort:;
Submit architectural plan for approval and obtain provisional building permit.
Ground coverage of 35% and a plot ratio of 75% are maximum permissible ratios.
Application for change of use would be subject to negotiations between city council and physical planner.
Submit architectural plan for approval and obtain provisional building permit.
Submit and obtain structural plan approval and final building permit.
Submit all designs and drawings with copies of current practisingpracticing licenceslicenses for respective
professionals
Approval fees
Request and receive on-site inspection by the municipal authority after construction
Page |
16
Site Conditions
Soil Type
The soils in the project area are predominantly well-drained loams (red soil)thatsoil) that are deep. Some
few areas have poorly drained clay soils especially next to the Kirichwa Kumbwa River.
The excavations were done to a depth of between 1.5m and 1.7m, to relatively firm formation with
bearing capacity minimum 150kn/m2.
Topography
The site is generally gentle with elevations varying relatively high at the road sideroadside and slope
towards the river.
Environmental Characteristics
Climate
The climate of Kileleshwa compares with the Nairobi area region. The summary of Nairobi area climate
is as stated below;
Average annual rainfall varyrainfall varies from 700 mm to 1300mm studies from 1960 to 1990 (Franklin
J Opijah).
Mean minimum temperature range from 10oC to 25oC the lowest temperatures occur during months of
June, July and august.
Socio-environmental survey
A survey for the likely social and environmental impact assessment of the proposed works shall have on
the surrounding community and project area to be executed so that mitigation measures are incorporated
in the project. The neighborsneighbours shall be made aware of the available protection measures that
Page |
17
shall be employed to guard against construction dust and noise. On the other hand they shall also be made
aware of maximum achievable levels of protection beyond which they should be prepared for what is
beyond control.
The first step an environmental risk assessment was prepared for all construction activities and materials
likely to cause pollution identified in some form of a list. Then specific measures were prescribed to
mitigate risks related to construction activities:
To prevent erosion and run-off, minimize land disturbance and leave maximum vegetation cover.
Control dust through fine water sprays used to dampen down the site.
Screen the whole site to stop dust spreading, or alternatively, place fine mesh screening close to the dust
source.
Cover skips and trucks loaded with construction materials and continually damp down with low levels of
water.
Cover piles of building materials like cement, sand and other powders, regularly inspect for spillages, and
locate them where they will not be washed into waterways or drainage areas.
Use non-toxic paints, solvents and other hazardous materials wherever possible
Segregate, tightly cover and monitor toxic substances to prevent spills and possible site contamination.
Collect any wastewater generated from site activities in settlement tanks, screen, discharge the clean
water, and dispose of remaining sludge according to environmental regulations.
Use low sulphur diesel oil in all vehicle and equipment engines, and incorporate the latest specifications
of particulate filters and catalytic converters.
Reduce noise pollution through careful handling of materials; modern, quiet power tools, equipment and
generators; low impact technologies; and wall structures as sound shields.
Page |
18
Page |
19
THE MASTER PLAN
After the site handover to consultants, Otieno Odongo & Partners did a ttopographical survey for the site
clearly picking all the existing structures on the plot and plot boundaries. The Architect, M/s Mutizo
Menezes International, using the generated site plan, prepared the master plan for the scheme outlining
all the housing units and their areas, access roads, parking spaces and other developments as outlined in
the clients brief. The developed plan was shared among other consultants for adoption and any comments
there in. all other consultants developed their respective plans and details from the approved Architectural
Master Plan. The site being zone 4, city of Nairobi, the site location is largely residential, single dwelling
units, town houses, and apartment with maximum 4 storeys. The Architectural Master Plan, proposed 3
number, 4-bedroomed town houses, and renovation of the existing town house.
The four bedroomfour-bedroom unit was a compact design of approximately 324m2 (ground floor 195m2,
first floor 129m2) that maximizes on useable functional area, and adequate circulation area. The proposed
development respects the existing neighbourhood character through the massing and proportions of the
design that compliment the built form character and streetscape rhythm of Kileleshwa Ring road. The
design of the townhouses are 2-storey buildings, and is site responsive in planning, detail and massing and
therefore considered to satisfy the standards.
Guest bedroom furnished with both bathtub and shower area 20.7m2
Dinning 18.9m2
Page |
20
Double garage 34.4m2
Master bedroom furnished with both bathtub and shower area 45.97m2
Ground floor
Lounge:
Dining:
Guest Bedroom
Page |
21
Bathrooms
Kitchen
Windows
Remove existing mesh grill and window grill and replace to schedule
First floor
Cast new roof slab above the space and will be waterproofed
Page |
22
Wall surfaces both new and existing to be prepared to receive 2 coats of approved paint
Bathrooms
Bedroom
Roof
Existing faciafascia to be removed and replaced with new 225x25 one painted to approval.
Page |
23
Common parking
Landscaping
Guard house
Civil works
Page |
24
Page |
25
traffic access, parking conditions, utilities and services
Current Traffic
As the proposed development represents the net additional of only 3 further dwellings to the area, it is
highly likely that the well-established social and physical infrastructure of the area will have the capacity
to support the development. Furthermore, the proposed development will provide the opportunity for
additional population levels to help maintain existing social infrastructure.
The Kkileleshwa area consists of residential apartments, townhouses, and an international primary school,
Kenton. Only one matatu route runs through Kkileleshwa (route 48). Also taxis to city centre, restaurants
and super markets are available.
For mobility purpose and deliveries, and since the area as only one matatu route, motor cyclesmotorcycles
have been used though in small numbers. The area is less populated with high incomehigh-income
population hence less pedestrian traffic.
Access
The site can be accessed off Ring Road Kileleshwa, with 5m wide all weather road that leads directly to
the site. The proposed development maintained the 5m access, to accommodate the generated pedestrians
and vehicular traffic.
Page |
26
THE SITE
The existing parking is inadequate due to the additional development. The parking proposal allowed for
one garaged parking space with a tandem space per unit in the respective driveways. The parking was
carefully considered in respect to site layout to ensure the objectives of the standards were achieved.
The visitors parking was also design since the ring road Kkileleshwa at the location, do not have on street
parking.
Site services had been anticipated and allowed for in the planning of the development. Utilities and
services are provided for the public use for a fee. It includes; water supply, waste water management,
electricity and power supply.
Page |
27
Water supply
Existing network
There is existingdoes exist water connection from Nairobi water companyWater Company to the site.
The water supply is adequate for the new development.
The development creates additional wastewater to the existing waste waterwastewater and sanitation
infrastructure. There is existingdoes exist NCC sewer line along river Kirichwa Kumbwa River. All the
sewerage therefore is connected to the existing NCC sewer line.
The development generated additional runoffs and storm water, all the storm water therefore was directed
to the river Kirichwa Kumbwa River, through the storm water drainage channel.
The optimum waste collection system depend upon the quantities and characteristics of the wastes to be
collected, the haul distances between collection areas and the disposal sites, road and traffic conditions
and local cost factors, including labour cost and availability. Most of the waste at the development is
organic in nature. It is recommended that dustbin cubicles be provided in every housing unit for storage of
waste before collection for disposal by hired private contractorhired private contractor provide dustbin
cubicles in every housing unit for storage of waste before collection for disposal. Dandora municipal
dumping site receives solid waste from most parts of Nairobi.
Electricity Supply
There is existingdoes exist power connection from KPLC. However, an application will be submitted
made to The Kenya Ppower and Llighting Ccompany for connection upon completion of the new
developments.
Telecommunication services
Page |
28
There existing telephone lines, and connection will be applied to the development. However, serving the
new development with mobile phone system will be implemented as part of the additional communication
service.
Page |
29
inception and preliminary design
Inception
Upon commissioning for the consultancy services, the Managing Director of Otieno Odongo & partners
Consulting Engineers, Eng. Wilberforce J. Odhiambo and I attended a team briefing session with other
consultants under chair of Lead Consultant (architect), who had received instructions from client in order
to confirm details of the brief including the finally agreed upon scope of works, the budget and the
programme. In the meeting it was also agreed on mode of flow of information from the lead
consultant/client to other consultants and vice versa.
The client was expected to issue all information and data in their possession and authorize the consultants
to search for any required statutory information such as survey plans, records of existing structure,
topographical surveys, hydrological and climate records.
The arrangement resulted in a working relationship that facilitated design of an end product whichproduct
that met the client’s requirement within available funding.
The Inception Phase was used to complete the project set-up and the tools for the management and
execution of the project and the preparation of final project quality plan including survey and
investigation action plans which ensured timely completionplans that ensured timely completion and to
the required quality.
Based on the review of existing data, the field reconnaissance and discussions with the client, the initial
findings were summarized and presented in the Inception Report which, included:
Observations made by the Consultant during the review of existing documentation and during site
reconnaissance, including preliminary observations with regards to the topographical survey,
An updated implementation plan and staff assignment chart, including outputs and indicators, activities
and time schedule,
Page |
30
Revisions of the timing of submission of deliverables, and other scheduled submissions.
Below are the summery of the activities undertaken during inception stage:-: -
Prior to the commencement of services, one weekone-week mobilization period from Signing/Effective
Date of Contract was needed, during which the consultant assembled the proposed key personnel.
W.J Odhiambo Project civil Engineer oversee, conduct and review 4 months
design/ drawings as per specs
for civil works and
water demand and storage
Langat Zakayo Assistant engineer oversee, conduct and review
Structural design/ drawings as per specs
for structural works. Monitor 7 months
quality controls in works
Harun Njago Assistant engineer assistant engineer, civil, sewerage
civil and infrustructural work 4 months
G.O. Wayumba Land Surveyor Project Surveyor 1 month
Page |
31
Additionally, the Consultants initiated the compilation of all existing standards, studies and data relevant
for the design providing essential information for the refinement of the detailed work programme.
During this activity all relevant existing information were obtain to efficiently plan the execution of the
works.
The following data and documents were available and were acquired, for study by the project team:
All existing data were reviewed for consistency and completeness and on that basis, and together with the
field reconnaissance; the details of the required supplementary surveys and investigations to be carried
out by the Consultants were planned.
The review of the relevant existing data and documents included meetings with client and tenants on the
existing townhouse.
This activity was conducted as an extension of activity no. 2. A field reconnaissance of the site and their
infrastructure was undertaken by the Architect together with the Structural Engineer, civil engineer,
services engineer, the Surveyor and the Quantity SurveyorThe Architect together with the Structural
Engineer, Civil Engineer, Services Engineer, the Surveyor and the Quantity Surveyor, undertook a field
reconnaissance of the site and their infrastructure.
The main purpose of the field reconnaissance was to make a general assessment of the prevailing
conditions, in order to:
Provide a basis for refinement of the detailed work programme for the subsequent field investigations and
surveys;
Provide a basis for the identification and selection of design standards, for subsequent investigations in
respect of economic and technical feasibility.
Page |
32
With the above purpose in mind, the reconnaissance included an initial assessment of the following
aspects:
General condition of the development and infrastructure, including an assessment of the nature and cause
of any defects.
The field reconnaissance was carried out jointly with a representative from the Client, who was able to
provide useful historical information on the centre performance and special problems such as population,
structures insufficiency.
Trial pits within the site for the proposed works to establish type of soil to guide in design of the footing
of the building with design loading.
Inspection for failure indicators in existing building and their classification causes of which may be
avoided in the proposed new development.
Identifying type of structure whether load bearing or framed structure or a combination of the two
depending on size and soil types.
Assess the impact extension of the building may impose to the existing building.
Page |
33
Identifying laboratory for testing materials to be used for construction.
Preliminary structural layouts taking into account all inputs from client and architect at inception.
Issue of preliminary drawings to services engineers so that they may locate the services conduits
conveniently.
Issue of drawings for comments by architect/client before embarking on production of final drawings.
Preparation of layout of water supply and wastewater disposal features and structures
Provision of sufficient preliminary information on water and sanitation and approximate estimates based
on linear, superficial, cubic or similar basis regarding the works to enable consultant’s preliminary design
and cost report for the project to be approved.
Provision of sufficient water and sanitation information and data to enable other consultants to complete
their design works
The proposed developments required adequate and reliable water supply and effective waste
waterwastewater management. The design review established the adequacy of existing services,
expansion plans and enable consultant to define scope of works in the water supply and waste
waterwastewater management. The consultant therefore conducted the following review:
Page |
34
On water supply;
Assess adequacy or inadequacy of existing water supply source, factor in proposed development user
demand and determine storage and reticulation requirements.
Identify pipe sizes and routes of national/local authority water supply and reticulation, and assess their
adaptability as source of supply to the proposed works.
Identify services, manholes, water, water storage facilities, and pipe sizes and routes of water supply and
reticulation and assess their adaptability to the proposed works
Confirm procedures for obtaining statutory approvals for water supply connections and waste/foul water
disposal connection.
Assess the serviceability or lack of it of existing water supply/waste water reticulation system as guide to
class of exposure conditions whether severe or mild. This shall form a basis of selecting suitable pipe and
storage materials for the proposed works.
Assess quality of existing water supply for any localized pollution to guard against in the new works.
Confirm compatibility of the proposed new works to existing ones both horizontally and vertically
If no waste management system is in place assess the extent of the required provision.
Confirm procedures for connection and disposal of waste water when Municipal / Local Council Sewer
are in place.
Page |
35
Establish sizes and routes of sewer and storm water drainage pipes
Page |
36
The scope of work in this stage involved preparation of a sketch design showing spatial arrangements of
various spaces, physical form of buildings, structural concepts and services and equipment layouts and a
preliminary cost estimate. This package is presented to the client for approval and / or comment.
ARCHITECT
Page |
37
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
preparePrepare an approximate estimate of cost based on linear, superficial, cubic or similar
basis from outlined sketch proposals
adviseAdvise on design economies and on financial implications of alternative design and / or
materials use
Page |
38
With the soil on site being red clay stiff, and references to BS 8004, Table 1, the presumed
allowable bearing pressure is 150kn/m2
Survey information
The existing cadastral survey map was obtained from survey of Kenya.
Architectural sketch drawings
Existing building and site information records
Design:
structuralStructural type and form
Being a 2 storey2-storey building, and walls continuous, the preliminary form is slab and deep
beamsa slab and deep beam with masonry wall system.
Floor system
Foundation system
All load bearingload-bearing walls are founded on strip footing, and pad footings for columns
All load bearingload-bearing walls are founded on strip footing, and pad footings for columns
Deliverables
Drawings
Page |
39
Preliminary sizes of primary members only with reinforcing as kg/m3
Specifications
Reports
Cost estimate at that stage generally could not be on full element basis, as secondary elements were not
yet well defined.
Page |
40
Page |
41
Detailed Engineering Design
Following approval of preliminary design including attendance to any comments made by the client, I
prepared final design drawings. That illustrated the spaces and forms in the structure, dimensions,
materials and treatment of internal and external spaces. It incorporated the input of support consultants
and an updated cost estimate.
ARCHITECT
Page |
42
completeComplete detailed design incorporating work done by other consultants and
prepare all necessary production drawings with all details and specification necessary for
preparation of bill of quantities
submitSubmit to local authority for town planning consent and approval
drawDraw attention of client to any changes that may result from statutory requirements
STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENGINEER
developDevelop designs in collaboration with other consultants and prepare calculations,
drawings and specifications of the works to facilitate preparations of bills of quantities and
procurement of competitive tenders
consultConsult local and other authorities in connection with the structural design and
preparation and submission of typical details and calculations for approval
prepare designsPrepare designs, specifications and drawings necessary for the information
of contractors to enable them to carry out the works
preparePrepare details and calculations relating to the works
perPer bending schedules
To obtain all the design parameters, the following multidiscipline activities under
civil/structural field were undertaken:;
Activity No. 1: Topographical Surveys
Page |
43
Topographical Survey for reference during the implementation of the project was prepared,
the surveyor:
establishingEstablishing datum to which levels may be referred using modern survey
equipment related to national grid system (total station)
Picking necessary topographical data and features using appropriate CAD Software (civil 3d)
Producing accurate site / location plans with all existing structures, services, drainage structures (sizes,
slopes and flow direction) and any other features that may impact on the design.
Determine cross and general direction falls of plot for drainage use in the design of driveways and
parking with optimum cut and fills
Locate provision for storm water cut off, and any other drainage relief structures
Traffic analysis and forecasting to evaluate the required driveways and parking spaces
The services of ministry of roads were employed and the results from the test of the undisturbed sample
were relayed to us for structural consideration. The depths considered were up to 2m. The pad dimensions
used to evaluate bearing pressure was 1.2m by 1.2m, and the width of the strip footing was 0.6m.
Using Terzaghi’s bearing capacity theory the bearing pressures were computed and a minimum of
150kn/m2 safe bearing capacity was obtained.
Page |
44
Where;
The inventory and condition survey was undertaken in a systematic way using standard forms where the
condition was evaluated separately for the various elements of the structures such as drain channels,
protection works, and pipe work.
Taking account of both the structural condition and an assessment of the remaining life of the existing
drainage structure, a recommendation on the need for extension, repair and alternatively replacement
were made.
Hydrological investigations involved a more accurate and detailed study of available topographical maps,
hydrographical data and information pertinent to the project area, over and above that studied during
preliminary investigations stage.
Based on the above investigations, detailed hydrological and hydraulic analysis was conducted to
accurately assess the capacities of existing civil works and determine general drainage requirements
ensuring relief from excess run offs.
Page |
45
Identify suitable source of materials for use in the proposed development
preparePrepare for design team’s reference a report on proposed materials for use in the proposed project
reportReport the limitations to use of materials (if any) that may dictate certain design parameters
identifyIdentify and approve storage of materials to avoid mixing prior to designate proportioning
or materials quality deterioration
Advise on transportation that will eliminate segregation and spillage so as to reduce cost variations
arising from excessive wastage
Water Sources
Water for construction purposes was obtained from Nairobi Water Company,
Laboratory Testing
The detailed laboratory testinglaboratory-testing programme depended on the selected quality and
availability of construction materials.
The testing programme included the following tests carried out in accordance with BS standards:
• Flakiness
• Sieve analysis
siltSilt content
organicOrganic matter
Page |
46
Sieve analysis
Socio-environmental survey
A survey for the likely social and environmental impact assessment of the proposed works shall have on
the surrounding community and project area to be executed so that mitigation measures are incorporated
in the project. The neighborsneighbours were made aware of the available protection measures that would
be employed to guard against construction dust and noise. On the other hand they were also made aware
of maximum achievable levels of protection beyond which they should be prepared for what is beyond
control.
The first step was to prepare environmental risk assessments for all construction activities and identify
materials likely to cause pollution in some form of a list. Then specific measures shall be prescribed to
mitigate risks related to construction activities:
To prevent erosion and run-off, minimize land disturbance and leave maximum vegetation cover.
Control dust through fine water sprays used to dampen down the site.
Screen the whole site to stop dust spreading, or alternatively, place fine mesh screening close to the dust
source.
Cover skips and trucks loaded with construction materials and continually damp down with low levels of
water.
Cover piles of building materials like cement, sand and other powders, regularly inspect for spillages, and
locate them where they will not be washed into waterways or drainage areas.
Use non-toxic paints, solvents and other hazardous materials wherever possible
Segregate, tightly cover and monitor toxic substances to prevent spills and possible site contamination.
Collect any wastewater generated from site activities in settlement tanks, screen, discharge the clean
water, and dispose of remaining sludge according to environmental regulations.
Page |
47
Use low sulphur diesel oil in all vehicle and equipment engines, and incorporate the latest specifications
of particulate filters and catalytic converters.
Reduce noise pollution through careful handling of materials; modern, quiet power tools, equipment and
generators; low impact technologies; and wall structures as sound shields.
Page |
48
Detailed engineering design was based on the statutory requirements in effect at the site.
Inputs:
The structural analysis and design for the proposed three3 number 4-bedroom townhouses, For Karen
Enterprises Ltd, has been based on the Ultimate Limit State method. Factors of Safety as applied to
materials and loadings are as specified in the Standards and Codes of practice currently in use.
B.S 8004-Foundations
The ultimate limit state, which is concerned with the provision of adequate safety;
Page |
49
Ultimate limit serviceability limit states
state
Deflection Cracking
Objective Provision of structure should Cracking should not be
adequate not deflect so as such as to damage
safety to impair use of finishes or otherwise
structure impair usage
Loading Design Design service load
regime ultimate
Loads
Performance structure crack width should not
Limit should not Deflection should exceed 0.3mm generally
fail not exceed
specified limits
Robustness
In addition to providing a structure that is capable of carrying the design loads, the layout should be such
that damage to small areas of the structure or failure of single elemetselements will not lead to a major
collapse.
The code, BS 8110, requires that in all buildings the structural members should be linked together in the
following manner:
By internal ties in two directions approximately at right-angles, effectively continuous throughout their
length and anchored to the peripheral ties at each end (unless continuing as horizontal ties to columns or
walls);
By external column and wall ties anchored or tied horizontally into the structure at each floor and roof
level;
By continuous vertical ties from foundation to the roof level in all columns and walls carrying vertical
loads.
Structural system
Page |
50
Load bearing wall system of structure has been considered in the design with horizontal and vertical
(gravity) loading being transmitted to the bearing ground through masonry walls. Loading areLoads are
transmitted through beams and walls to the foundation strip footing. Staircases walls transmit loads from
the stairs and do not form part of lateral loading resisting system. Reinforced concrete pad foundations
and continuous wall footings will spread the loads to a safe bearing soil stratum.
Loadings
Dead load on the structure comprises of own weight of the designed structural elements, applied finishes
and permanent partitions.
Imposed (Live) Loading has been specially considered for each section of the structure depending on its
utility as specified in the current Codes.
No load reduction has been considered for columns and basesbases, as it will be insignificant depending
on the fact that the tallest building is only two 2 storeys tall.
To cater for lateral loadings 10% more loading on the walls and beams has been used in the design.
Foundations
Pad foundations have been used to spread the total loading coming from the columns and are optimally
sized to be in tune with red clay type of soils with Safe Bearing Capacity up to 150KN/m2
Strip footing has also been used for walls retaining the sub-structure compacted fills.
A blinding layer of class 15 concrete was laid after excavation to foundation levels to provide the desired
flat level.
Columns
Columns for the structure are circular reinforced concrete columns. The sizes relate to the height so that
slenderness is minimized and also depended on the anticipated intensity of loading. The columns were
designed to carry the axial loads. Column diameter used was 250mm.
Beams
Page |
51
Rectangular reinforced concrete beams have been used in the design. The depth and width of the beams
have been dictated by the loading, serviceability requirements and space functional parameters. The
beams were designed to carry moments related to their stiffness’s. sizesSizes adopted were 450x200mm
beams450x200mm beams.
Slabs
150mm Solid slabs form part of the structure that was designed to take superficial loading as well as
partition walls identified as line loads.
Staircase
These auxiliaries have been designed as slabs with dead load incremental due to sloping flights.
Consideration was also given to the possibility of crowding necessitating use of Imposed loading of 3
KN/m2.
Walls
All walls are masonry walls. Walls were used to retain fill in selected areas in substructure. Walls were
used as cladding/infill. Masonry walls were designed as load bearing. All walls arewere designed to be
reinforced with metal strips at every two courses and tied to the columns using the same to improve on
lateral stability.
Roofing
Timber trusses
Timber trusses are designed for spans up to 10 meters with intermediate supports. Bolted joints were used
to form stiff but designed as pinned joints. Timber purlins were designed to support roof cover and
imposed loading that the roof may be subjected to during maintenance. Their spacing was dictated by
limited deflection serviceability parameters. Trusses were also designed to carry ceiling finish.
Page |
52
The cover to the reinforcement
Quality of construction process and the first hours after casting of the concrete have a major influence
upon the subsequent durability of the structure.
The cover for protection against corrosion and fire was considered at the onset of design.
Durability and fire resistance requirements were considered at the onset of the design process because this
determine the grade of concrete, the cover, and the size of the members.
Concrete
Steel sections
Welding consumables
All welding consumables, including covered electrodes, wires, filler rods, and flux and shielding gases,
should have be class 42.
Page |
53
TENDER STAGE
Tender stage in public procurement has been sub-divided under four headings:-: -
Tender action
During this stage, iI produce tender documents i.ei.e. drawings, specifications and bills of quantities that
tally and describe adequately and accurately the quality and quantity of the works without any ambiguity
so that bidders were able to complete fairly and the client gets the best possible bargain in the market.
ARCHITECT
Page |
54
examineExamine bills for specialized works prepared by other consultants and ensure
that they tally with the main bill of quantities
provideProvide for submission to theto the client confidential cost estimates of the
works based upon priced bills of quantities
STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENGINEER
Prepare and specifications for specialized structural and civil works and any information
needed by the quantity surveyor for the main bills.
examineExamine tender documents to ensure consistency with structural and civil
designs and specifications
Tender Action
The consultants’ services included tender assistance,assistance; the following activities
were undertaken;
preparationPreparation of appropriate advertisements for contractors,
evaluationEvaluation of tenders
The exercise was conducted with the objective of enabling the client to procure, within their
public procurement regulations, contractor(s) who were operational and had the capacity to
deliver the project within time and budget also within allowable extensions and variations.
Tenders were evaluated and Maridadi Bbuilding contractors,Contractors were awarded the
contract to carry out construction of the development.
Page |
55
Page |
56
construction supervision
The objective of the supervision task was to ensure that in all works executed in the contract and materials
supplied meet the specified standards of quality and the programme of works adhere to the planned
schedules for the completion and commissioning of the project.
The construction stage did not involve the client on a day to dayday-to-day level, and the majority of
actions and responsibilities, lied with Design Team, Contractor, Subcontractors and Clerk of Works.
General
In order that the Client is guaranteed of a reliable product the Consultant in his effort to have the works
comply with specifications, ensured the procedures undertaken are relevant to the main tasks as listed
below namely:
Contract Administration
Quality Control
Reporting
Contract Administration
The Architect conducted monthly site meetings attended by all consultants, contractors and
subcontractors, client and stakeholders. During these meetings works were inspected, progress reviewed
and reports from all participants received. The project architect circulated minutes within one week after
the site meeting. The project architect monitored action being taken by various parties as recommended in
the site meetings and attended to issues related to civil/structural discipline to achieve interdisciplinary
harmony. Our administrationOur administration role was based on a complete understanding of the
contract and strict observance of all contractual conditions.
Drawings clarification
Page |
57
Shop drawing control systems
Documentation for processing extras and potential claims before Client releases final account payments
keeping the client posted on any instruction(s) that might have implication on the project final account
The project quality was achieved by a comprehensive quality control programmeA comprehensive quality
control programme assured the project quality. Below isare the steps whichsteps that were undertaken in
ensuring quality structural work wereworks were undertaken.
Field Inspections
Field Inspections was carried out to ensure that standards are met and all work is performed according to
the drawings and specifications. Inspections will covered the following:-: -
Construction workmanship
Installations of equipments
Environmentally safe disposal of surplus excavation spoil materials, and left overs
Page |
58
LIST OF ITEMS TO BE APPROVED IN SEQUENCE
Foundation level. The setting out and final excavated level for the bases should be approved by
engineerEngineer should approved the setting out and final excavated level for the bases.
The survey data should be jointly signed by contractor’s survey and consultant’s surveyor, and
confirmed as the actual site by the engineer.
All the sieve analysis tests results and other material tests should be availed to resident engineer’s
office for engineer’s comments before using the material on concrete mix for permanent works.
Hardcore fill and compaction should be approved by the engineerThe engineer should approved hard-
core fill and compaction before blinding.
Cutting, bending and steel fixing on site should be approved before erecting formwork.
All the approvals should be done by the engineerThe engineer should dodid all the approvals from
setting out to actual construction works.
1. Materials
Samples of all materials proposed to be used should be submitted and shall be tested, where required,
and receive his approval prior to being delivered in bulk upon the works.
Coarse Aggregates
Aggregates consist of sand, gravel, crushedand crushed rock. Preferred nominal maximum size of
coarse aggregate aresizes of coarse aggregate are 40mm, 20mm, 15mm, 10mmand 10mm. But for
this project use maximum coarse aggregate of 20mm.
Fine Aggregates
Page |
59
Grading of fine aggregates for concrete Class 20 to Class 40 shall comply with Grading Zone 2 or
Grading Zone 3.% fines should be < 3%.
Storage
Stored in such a manner that will preclude the inclusion of foreign materials.
Adequate stock of fine aggregate shall be maintained to ensure uniformity of moisture content when used.
Any fine aggregates which does not comply with the requirements of the specificationsaggregate that
does not comply with the requirements of the specifications shall be immediately removed from the site.
Cement
Contractor shall supply with each consignment of cement a copy of the manufacturer’s certificate
showing that each consignment has been tested and analyzedanalysed and conforms withto BS 12.
Storage
Stored in a water proofwaterproof shed on a raised floor at least 150mm above the surrounding ground.
Each consignment stored separately and used in order of delivery.Atdelivery. At time of use, cement shall
be free flowing and free of lumps.
The water used for the concrete shall be clean and free from impurities.
2. Reinforcement
Page |
60
Cutting and Bending
Bars should be Bbent accurately to the shapes and dimensions shown on the drawings and to BS 4466.
Fixing
Reinforcement should be secured against displacement outside the specified limits (. Clause 4.2, (fixing
reinforcement).
Slabs - 25mm
Beams - 30mm
Columns - 40mm
Bases - 50mm
Spacers, chairs should be used to maintain the reinforcement in its correct position.
Durable
Surface Condition
Free from mud, oil, paint retarders, loose rust, loose mild scales, grease or any other substance
which can be shown to effect adv ersely the steel or concrete chemically or reduce the
bond.
3. Formwork
Good
Page |
61
Sound
Construction
All forms shall be constructed so as to facilitate the accurate placing and proper compaction of the
concrete.
Timber forms shall be constructed of sound, well-seasoned timber of such quality and strength as will
ensure rigidity throughout the placing, ramming, vibration and setting of the concrete without visible
deflection or warping.
Constructed that they can be removed without shock, vibration or damage to the concrete.
Formwork for columns and small concrete sections shall be fitted with trap doors through which sawdust,
shavings and other debris can be removed.
For Minimum periods for formwork removal refer to Cclause 5.4, (formwork for concrete,) Ttable 5.1 of
the technical specifications.
Test on Concrete
Mixes classes; :-
Workability
All concrete shall be compacted by mechanical vibration, and workability shall be such as to facilitate
this.
Page |
62
5. Temperatures
The concrete placing temperatures and placed concrete temperatures should be recorded it should not
exceed 30 degrees as per the specs. This will assist in controlling the heat in concrete due to hydration.
Reporting:
I was maintaining the following records and reports pertaining structural works for purposes of
monitoring progress and keeping the client posted.
Site diary containing all occurrences on site such as lab our, deliveries, accidents, visitors and weather
conditions
Site instruction book to be completed by consultants upon issuing the same to contractor
The client approval was sought before any instruction with adverse impact on cost of the
project is issued
Page |
63
Update budget summary sheet which should identify any current degree of financial risk
ARCHITECT
hold periodic site meetings to ensure that the contractor complies with the terms of the
contract; prepare and circulate minutes and monitor action
advise client, in advance, implications of site instructions issued on budget and / or time
periodic inspection of building and construction works to ensure compliance with specification
attendance to queries from contractor and other consultants on all aspects of building and
construction works
CLERK OF WORKS
Page |
64
maintain site records
ensure that all materials comply with specification by conducting materials tests and
inspection
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
periodic inspection of civil and structural works to ensure compliance with specification and
quality control
attendance to queries from contractor and other consultants on all aspects of civil and
structural works
prepare financial appraisals of civil and structural works and expected final account
Page |
65
ELECTRICAL AND MECHANICAL ENGINEER
periodic inspection of electrical and mechanical works to ensure compliance with specification
attendance to queries from contractor and other consultants on all aspects of electrical and
mechanical works
prepare financial appraisals of electrical and mechanical works and expected final account
Page |
66
POST CONSTRUCTION SERVICES
At the end of supervision of construction, the project was practically complete and handed to the client.
We continued to undertake the following:
During that period we were available to monitor and manage any defect occurring due to faulty
workmanship or materials. A schedule of defects was prepared and issued to the contractor for attendance
during the six monthsix-month maintenance period. Upon attendance to defects and at expiry of the
maintenance period, we inspected and issue a “making good of defects” certificate and recommending
release of last payments.
Final Account
We prepare a final project account and obtain the contractor’s concurrence. The instruments employed
will include site records, variation orders and re-measurements.
As completion of the Contract works reaches near the end a complete set of “as built drawings” was
prepared using AutoCAD. aA set of working drawings was maintained giving a record of the actual
materials, alignments, levels, and dimension set captured as revisions during construction period. The “as
built drawings” captured positions of service lines located in walls, slabs ceilings, ducts for reference
during maintenance.
This set of drawings included those prepared by the Consultant as well as those prepared by the
contractor. The final set of “as built drawings” was prepared and kept on plastic base transparencies and
in electronic form and issued to the Client.
Page |
67
ARCHITECT
collate preparation of schedule of defects, making good defects and issue certificate of “ making good
defects” at appropriate times
collate preparation of “as built drawings” and hand over to client hard and soft copies
compile maintenance manual from consultants’ input and brief the client accordingly
preparation of schedule for defects for building and construction and certification of making good defects
CLERK OF WORKS
assistance to all consultants in preparing “as built drawings” by interpreting site records
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
complete all re measurements of civil and structural works and seek contractor’s concurrence
Preparation of schedule for defects for civil and structural works and certification of making good defects
Page |
68
prepare “as built drawings” of the structural and civil works of the proposed secondary schools
complete all re measurements of electrical and mechanical works and seek contractor’s concurrence
preparation of schedule for defects for electrical and mechanical works and certification of making good
defects
prepare “as built drawings” of the electrical and mechanical installations of the proposed secondary
schools
Page |
69
Page |
70