AMAF - ASEAN - Gender Mainstreaming Guidelines
AMAF - ASEAN - Gender Mainstreaming Guidelines
AMAF - ASEAN - Gender Mainstreaming Guidelines
11 October 2018
Ha Noi, Viet Nam
1
The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) was established on 8 August 1967.
The Member States of the Association are Brunei Darussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao
PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Viet Nam. The ASEAN
Secretariat is based in Jakarta, Indonesia.
The AMAF’S Approach to gender mainstreaming in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors
Jakarta: ASEAN Secretariat, 2018.
LIST OF ACRONYMS
2
ACW ASEAN Committee on Women
AMAF ASEAN Ministers Meeting on Agriculture and Forestry
AMS ASEAN Member States
ASCC ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community
ASEAN The Association of Southeast Asian Nations
ASOF ASEAN Senior Officials on Forestry
ASWGL ASEAN Sectoral Working Group on Livestock
ASWGC ASEAN Sectoral Working Group on Crops
ASWGFi ASEAN Sectoral Working Group on Fisheries
ATWGARD Agricultural Research and Development
AWGCC ASEAN Working Group on Climate Change
COP Conference of the Parties
CSA Climate Smart Agriculture
FAO The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
FES Friedrich- Ebert-Stiftung
FCPF Forest Carbon Partnership Facility
GSVC Gender-Sensitive Value Chain
HPA Hanoi Plan of Action
IDS Institute of Development Studies
NTFP Non-Timber Forest Product
R-PP Readiness Preparation Proposal
SPA Strategic Plan of Action
SSF Sustainable Small-Scale Fisheries
UN United Nations
UNFCCC UN Framework Convention on Climate Change
UNDRIP UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
VAP Vientiane Action Programme
WTO World Trade Organization
3
PREFACE
The AMAF’S Approach to gender mainstreaming in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors
were completed by the ASEAN Technical Working Group on Agricultural Research and
Development (ATWGARD), with support from the ASEAN Working Groups on Livestock,
Crops and Fisheries and ASEAN Senior Officials on Forestry (ASOF) and the ASEAN
Committee on Women (ACW).
AMAF’S Approach to gender mainstreaming in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors is
defined as public measures that apply a gender perspective which as a result affect the
behavior of different stakeholders (amongst other producers, farmers and regulators). The
gender policy covers key elements to be integrated into a set of policies and programs to
ensure women working in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors in ASEAN are
empowered.
Recognising that gender inequalities permeate the food, agriculture and forestry sectors and
that public policies and frameworks yield significant gendered impacts on the three sectors;
the AMAF’s Approach aim to set out recommendations that serve as reference guides for
AMS in their efforts to promote gender equality in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors.
The AMAF’s Approach is not intended to be a full or binding statement on gender. The
AMAF’s Approach will help increase AMSs’ awareness of the importance of gender policies
in the food, agriculture and forestry sector, with a view to stimulating the development of
best practices and enhancing cooperation between ASEAN Member States.
The AMAF’s Approach to gender mainstreaming in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors,
which are public document, will be a living reference as ATWGARD will update them
frequently to reflect any changes and development in ASEAN, and international/regional
best practices.
The AMAF’S Approach to gender mainstreaming in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors
were adopted by the ASEAN Ministers on Agriculture and Forestry (AMAF) at the 40 th AMAF
Meeting in 2018 in Ha Noi, Viet Nam.
4
Table of Contents
LIST OF ACRONYMS ................................................................................................... 2
PREFACE ....................................................................................................................... 4
1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................ 6
1.1. Gender Equality in ASEAN .......................................................................................... 6
1.2. Women in the food, agriculture and forestry sector in ASEAN .............................. 6
2. OBJECTIVES ............................................................................................................. 7
3. AMAF’S APPROACH TO GENDER MAINSTREAMING ........................................ 7
3.1. AMAF’s Statement of Policy ................................................................................... 7
3.2. Food, Agriculture and Forestry Cooperation in ASEAN ..................................... 8
3.2.1. Livestock .................................................................................................................... 8
3.2.2. Crop ........................................................................................................................... 10
3.2.3. Fisheries and aquaculture ................................................................................... 11
3.2.4. Forestry .................................................................................................................... 12
3.2.5. Climate change ....................................................................................................... 13
3.2.6. Food security and nutrition ................................................................................. 15
3.2.7. Integrating gender into food, agricultural and forestry value chains ...... 15
4. REGIONAL STRATEGY AND ACTION PLAN ................................................... 16
4.1. Mainstreaming gender in food, agriculture and forestry .................................. 16
4.2. Framework for a strategy for mainstreaming gender in food, agriculture and
forestry ................................................................................................................................ 17
4.2.1. Approach and advocacy ...................................................................................... 17
4.2.2. Capacity Building ................................................................................................... 17
4.2.3. Institutional Framework ....................................................................................... 18
4.2.4. Building and strengthening strategic partnership ........................................ 18
4.2.5. Information, Communication and Publicity .................................................... 18
4.2.6. Research, Innovation and technology ............................................................. 18
5. IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS .......................................................................... 19
REFERENCES ............................................................................................................. 19
Annex 1: Recommended gender intervention in sectoral SPAs ......................... 21
Strategic Plan for ASEAN Cooperation in Food, Agriculture and Forestry ................ 21
(2016- 2025)......................................................................................................................... 21
SPA for ASEAN Cooperation in Agricultural Research and Development ................. 22
2016-2020 ............................................................................................................................ 22
SPA on ASEAN Cooperation in Livestock ...................................................................... 23
2016-2020 ............................................................................................................................ 23
SPA on ASEAN Cooperation on Crops ........................................................................... 24
2016-2020 ............................................................................................................................ 24
SPA on ASEAN Cooperation in Fisheries....................................................................... 25
2016-2020 ............................................................................................................................ 25
SPA for ASEAN Cooperation in Forestry........................................................................ 26
2016-2025 ............................................................................................................................ 26
ASEAN Integrated Food Security (AIFS) Framework and Strategic Plan of Action .. 27
on Food Security in the ASEAN Region (2015- 2020) ................................................... 27
5
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1. Gender Equality in ASEAN
On the occasion of 31st ASEAN Summit in the Philippines, the Heads of States or
Governments of ASEAN has adopted the “ASEAN Declaration on the Gender-Responsive
Implementation of the ASEAN Community Vision 2025 and Sustainable Development
Goals”. They declared their commitment to ensure the realisation of a people-oriented and
people-centered ASEAN where all women and girls are able to reach the fullest of their
potentials.
As a result, with regional integration and a market capacity of more than 600 million people
representing vast opportunities, ASEAN countries’ governments should strengthen women’s
capacity, widen their accessibility and support their contribution towards the formal economic
sphere. An increasing level of formal economic participation will enable women to possess
equal access to resources, opportunities and facilities as their male counterparts which
would eventually bring about women’s empowerment and a narrowed gender gap.
In a recent study “Projected Gender Impact of the ASEAN Economic Community” conducted
by the UN Women Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific and the Friedrich- Ebert-Stiftung
(FES), in partnership with the ASEAN Secretariat, and with the support of the Australian
Government, the findings suggest that without targeted policy and programmatic
interventions, it is likely that large sectors of women will be excluded from the direct benefits
of the boost in trade, investment and skilled labor integration. The research finds that
liberalization measures will impact unevenly because of existing inequalities including based
on income, gender, geography, or ethnicity, access to resources and asset ownership will
limit women’s potential gains from trade.
Agriculture is a major export sector in six out of ten ASEAN Member States: Cambodia, Lao
PDR, Myanmar, Thailand, Indonesia, and Viet Nam. While the major agricultural dominant
countries are at varying stages of socio-economic development, there are remarkable
similarities in the constraints faced by women in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors.
Nearly 75 per cent of women in Cambodia are engaged in agriculture, 69 per cent of women
are agricultural workers in Myanmar, followed by 48 per cent in Viet Nam, and 51 per cent in
Lao PDR.
Despite growing industrialization, agriculture and agro product subsectors like livestock and
forestry largely employ women. Women participate at equal levels of the value chain but do
not necessarily reach the export level equally.
Since the food, agriculture and forestry sector is very vulnerable to climate variability and
6
climate change, from a gender perspective, women and youths are more vulnerable to
climate change. Women farmers face several challenges in moving beyond subsistence
level to access export markets in the ASEAN Member States. Rural poverty level is high and
women shoulder disproportionate amounts of physical workloads, both within households
and at the farm.
Despite women’s significant involvement in agriculture, land ownership and titling and
ownership of other productive assets remains largely with the men. Poor access to markets
and over dependence on middlemen makes it difficult for women to access outside markets
and receive a fair price for their products. Compounding this, is the fact that credit for
agricultural purposes is hard to access for women because their lack of asset ownership and
low education levels in some ASEAN Member States.
2. OBJECTIVES
The AMAF’s Approach to gender mainstreaming in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors
were developed to help ASEAN Member States:
The AMAF’S Approach to gender mainstreaming in the food, agriculture and forestry
sectors, is a non-binding endeavour to help in the process of building stronger gender
cooperation and integration in the region, by acting as common reference guide for future
cooperation to enhance gender equality in the food, agriculture and forestry sector in
ASEAN. The AMAF’s Approach takes into account regional and national contexts and
circumstances.
Acknowledging that gender equality and the empowerment of all women and girls are at the
center of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, and that gender equality is
recognised and affirmed as a precondition for the realisation of sustainable development,
AMAF reaffirmed the need to mainstream a gender perspective and analysis, which include
targeted actions and investments in the formulation and implementation of policies, plans
and programmes of all the food, agriculture and forestry sector in ASEAN. These are aligned
with the commitments laid out in the ASEAN Declaration on the Gender-Responsive
Implementation of the ASEAN Community Vision 2025.
AMAF further encouraged more investments to close resource gaps for achieving gender
equality and the empowerment of all women and girls.
AMAF agreed to promote women's equal access to and full participation in decision-making
bodies and mechanisms involved in the implementation of all goals and targets of the 2030
Agenda for Sustainable Development and Strategic Plan for ASEAN Cooperation in Food,
7
Agriculture and Forestry (2016-2025) including its policy, plan and programme formulation,
implementation, and monitoring and evaluation for the sub-sectors of livestock, crop,
fisheries and forestry.
AMAF strongly encouraged relevant ASEAN Sectoral Bodies to promote the implementation
of the AMAF’s Approach in relation to the food, agriculture and forestry sectors.
The overall gender issues that should to be considered in food, agriculture and forestry
sectors are:
3.2.1. Livestock
The livestock sub-sector makes important contribution to national output, employment and
food security in the ASEAN region though its relative importance varies across the ASEAN
Member States. Under ASEAN Cooperation in Food, Agriculture and Forestry, the ASEAN
Working Group on Livestock (ASWGL) was established to provide a mechanism to develop
ASEAN Standards in Livestock for Vaccines, Good Animal Husbandry Practices and other
related activities in the sub-sector. In ASEAN, the major livestock products are poultry and
pork. Although production growth has been rapid, the region as a whole is a net importer of
both meat and dairy products. Only Thailand is a significant net exporter of meat (primarily
poultry). In the case of meat, however, imports are only a small (around 5%) though
increasing fraction of the total consumption. The expansion of the livestock industry has also
resulted in higher imports of animal feed. Share of agriculture in national output is declining
in the more advanced AMS while the share of livestock within agriculture is increasing. While
intensive and larger scale production and processing are emerging in the more advanced
states, smallholder livestock still dominates in the less developed AMS where they play key
roles in poverty alleviation, food security and nutrition and gender equality.
It is estimated that approximately 50-85 percent of total livestock production in AMS can be
attributed to smallholders. The percentage varies among and between countries depending
on several factors. At the smallholder level, the production system is mainly subsistence or
small market oriented enterprises, which largely depends on household feed resources and
labour. The systems often have poor production. Women play an important role in feeding,
cleaning and management of livestock, especially pigs, backyard poultry and small
ruminants, apart from undertaking other routine day-to-day activities related to their
8
reproductive role in the household. Unlike many other regions, women in Southeast Asia are
also involved in retailing of livestock products, especially fresh meat. Men are mainly
involved in buying farm inputs, selling of livestock and livestock products, and managing
larger animals like cattle and buffalo. The involvement of men increases with the increasing
agricultural intensification and herd size.
Gender issues related to livestock throughout ASEAN are largely similar, with some variation
depending on culture and tradition. The main constraints that women face in the livestock
production and marketing system include, but are not limited to:
While women are involved in care of livestock, men are the ones generally invited to attend
trainings, talk with extension workers/decision makers etc. In the process, men have access
to knowledge and skills related to livestock that are usually not shared with the women,
resulting in poor transfer of knowledge and technologies. Low representation of women in
local social institutions and service delivery mechanisms of government and non-
governmental agencies also makes access to knowledge and services for rural women
difficult. Because of little or no ownership of land among women, it is difficult for them to
access credit, resulting in limited scope for scaling up and scaling out their activities. It
appears that women in Southeast Asia have more varied bargaining capacity in the market
depending on location, tradition and culture. However, in the case of market access, rural
women face a number of constraints due to their lower literacy level and marketing skills, as
well as limitations to move outside the house premises (customary practices that prevent
them to leave the house, poor driving skills). This needs to be addressed to enhance their
access as well as their bargaining power in the marketplace.
Men have greater control over the income and assets deriving from livestock than women,
resulting in reduced opportunities for women to gain economic independence within the
family. On some occasions, income received from livestock are misused by men, and do not
benefit the family. There is also a need to increase the involvement of women in decision
making, not only at the household but also at the community level. Enhanced decision
making choices would encourage the formation of a more conducive environment for women
to have equal choices to that of men. With the emergence/re-emergence of zoonotic
diseases, women are more at risk to diseases (e.g. brucellosis, tuberculosis) because of
closer association with livestock that are managed under poor bio-secure environments and
the handling/preparation of raw livestock products.
According to the FAO, there are seven categories of key challenges that smallholder farmers
and especially women farmers face: Access and control over natural resources; Distribution
of roles and responsibilities based on sex and age; Access to technologies, training and
extension services; Access to financial services; Access to markets; Participation and
decision-making power; Occupational health and safety (FAO 2013)
The SPA for ASEAN Cooperation in Livestock 2016-2020 Strategic Thrust 4: Support
9
smallholder livestock for poverty alleviation, improved nutrition, food security and gender
equality, includes some activities focusing on gender equality. The following gender issues
should be considered in accordance to the FAO seven categories of challenges when
formulating policies/programmes under the SPA for ASEAN Cooperation in Livestock 2016-
2020:
3.2.2. Crop
The ASEAN Sectoral Working Group on Crops (ASWGC) is one of subsidiary bodies under
SOM-AMAF that oversees the ASEAN Cooperation on Crop Sub-Sector. Having a goal to
promote the development in this sub-sector, the ASWGC has carried out activities and
projects in accordance with its strategic objectives, reflected in the Strategic Plan of Action
(SPA) on Crops. A number of activities/ projects have been successful implemented and
many are continuing through networking arrangement as well as supported by dialogue and
development partners. The scope of the ASWGC covers: i) policy framework, ii) intra-and-
extra-ASEAN trade in crops commodities, iii) plant pest and disease control, iv) standards
development and its promotion, v) environment protection in crops production, and vi) food
security, food safety and nutrition.
Women’s increasing role in food and crop systems positions them as an essential player and
partner in this process. In ASEAN, women comprise over 50% of agriculture labor force.
Women and men farmers have different roles related to crop production, but against a
backdrop of changing economic opportunities and environmental conditions, the gender
division of labour may change. Women and men farmers often have different criteria for
choosing crops and varieties and performing activities such as selecting seed, cultivating,
harvesting and processing. These criteria may be based on differences in taste, storage
characteristics, time required for food preparation, labour requirements and marketability.
Women also often lack secure tenure and resource rights, access to resources, such as
land, finance, information, extension services and technology. Closing the gender gap in
access to and use of productive resources and services would unlock the agricultural
productivity potential of women, increasing farm output substantially. Studies on the yield
gap between male and female farmers provide estimates of a gap of 20-30 per cent on
average, and most attribute this to lower input use by women. According to FAO estimates,
the productivity gains resulting from ensuring equal access to fertilizer, seeds and
agricultural tools for women, could raise total agricultural output in developing countries by
an estimated 2.5 to 4 per cent, thereby reducing the number of hungry people by between
100 million and 150 million (FAO, 2011)
10
The following gender issues should be considered when implementing the projects/activities
under the SPA for ASEAN Cooperation in Crop 2016-2020:
- Conduct gender analysis within all projects, programs and policies to assess
the implications and benefits of Climate Smart Agriculture (CSA) technologies
and practices on men and women.
- Provide specific support to women led SMEs and cooperatives to improve
productivity, technology and product quality, to meet global market standards
and increase competitiveness.
- Provide training to both women and men on CSA technologies and practices,
and gender awareness.
- Facilitate women’s access to land and credit through transforming laws and
local practices.
- Enhance the capacity of the women and men members of farmer
organization and institutions women and men farmers to engage with the
private sector.
The fisheries sector plays an important role in the economic development of the ASEAN
Member States. Six ASEAN Countries- Indonesia, Myanmar, Philippines, Viet Nam,
Thailand and Malaysia are among the world’s top fish producing countries, while four
countries- Indonesia, Philippines, Malaysia and Viet Nam are among the world’s top
seaweed producing countries. Approximately 60 million people are employed in fisheries-
related ancillary services such as boat manufacturing, fishing gear making, fish processing
and marketing. The per capita fish consumption (33.4 kg/y) in ASEAN region is remarkably
higher than the world’s average (19.2 kg/yr) and about 38% of animal protein consumed in
the region is derived from fish, which highlights the importance of fisheries in nutritional and
food security in the region. The ASEAN Sectoral Working Group on Fisheries (ASWGFi) is
tasked to oversee the identification, formulation, monitoring and reporting of fisheries
cooperation among AMS.
Acknowledging these gender issues the Sustainable Small-Scale Fisheries (SSF) Guidelines
include gender equity and equality as one of its 13 guiding principles and gender is also
considered in the more detailed section on responsible fisheries and sustainable
development (FAO 2015). The SSF Guideline recognizes that women and men’s fisheries
labor are often given different cultural and economic value, with women’s work often going
uncounted and not considered in fisheries governance, despite being vital to small-scale
fisheries. It also acknowledges the centrality of gender to other intersecting issues,
particularly human rights and well-being, food security, and climate change and it also
highlights how gender differences in power and decision making exist in small-scale
fisheries contexts and how those differences influence representative, fair, and sustainable
small-scale fisheries governance. Interventions which limit women’s role in fisheries and
aquaculture systems based on their reproductive and existing economic roles may actually
maintain a status quo which may be highly inequitable for rural and indigenous women.
The following gender issues should be considered when implementing the SPA for ASEAN
Cooperation in fisheries 2016-2020:
3.2.4. Forestry
Forests play an important role in the production of wood and other products and provide a
home to a diminishing, yet significant number of people in the sub-region and offer
employment in, among other things, production of furniture and other wood products,
protected area management, and plantation development. Forests are important for local,
indigenous and rural people as they provide foods, energy and shelters to millions of them in
ASEAN region.
The ASEAN Senior Officials on Forestry (ASOF) is responsible body for forestry cooperation
in ASEAN. ASOF has set up vision of cooperation of which “Forest resources are
sustainably managed at the landscape level to meet societal needs, both socio-economically
and culturally, of the present and future generations, and to contribute positively to
sustainable development”. The goal for the forestry sector in ASEAN is to “enhance
sustainable forest management for the continuous production of forest goods and services in
a balanced way and ensuring forest protection and conservation of biological diversity, as
well as optimise their utilisation, compatible with social and ecological sustainability.
Across Southeast Asia, 300 million people live in rural areas and up to 70 million people rely
on forests for their livelihoods, nutrition and food security. Men and women often differently
use and depend on non-wood forest products, with women often disproportionately relying
on these products. Women contribute to the forest sector in many ways, both formal and
informal, including through agroforestry, watershed management, tree improvement and
forest protection. Women make up a significant proportion of the labour force in forest
industries worldwide, especially in tree nursery work but also in activities ranging from
logging to wood processing. Although women contribute substantially to the forest sector,
their roles are not fully recognized or documented, and their wages and working conditions
are usually inferior to those of men. Moreover, women rarely have equal involvement to men
in the formulation, planning and implementation of forest policies. There are also gender
differentiated impacts of deforestation: for men, deforestation may lead to a loss of income,
while for women, it may increase their labour burden, especially in the time taken to gather
fuelwood.
The economic, social, cultural, political and legal settings can differentially affect the rights of
women and men to control forest resources and own land. Even where women have
ownership rights to forests, they may not have equal access to opportunities for forest-
generated income. Commonly, women may have access to NTFPs but not to wood
resources, which is often the domain of men and also the most commercially valuable
product in most forests. This gender differentiation has major implications for forest
management and also genderbased power structures in communities. A study conducted by
the World Bank found that giving women a bigger say in managing forest significantly
improved conservation outcomes (World Bank 2012).
Another important stakeholders are the indigenous communities living in forest areas who
12
depend on forest for their survival. World Bank estimates there are about 60 million forest
dependent indigenous peoples, which researchers believe is an underestimation (Tauli-
Corpuz, 2011). The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) fully
recognizes the importance of land, territories and resources for Indigenous Peoples. This is
further emphasized by the recognition of Indigenous Peoples right to Free Prior and
Informed Consent (FPIC) as requirement to safeguard our right over our land, territories and
resources and our right to self determination. Indigenous women are the most vulnerable to
climate change effects and the significance of their traditional knowledge, values and
practices, and the need to collectively build on what is left to foster community resilience,
both for the present and future generations.
The following gender issues should be considered when implementing the SPA for ASEAN
Cooperation in Forestry 2016-2025:
Southeast Asia is highly vulnerable to climate change as a large proportion of the population
and economic activity is concentrated along coastlines; the region is heavily reliant on
agriculture for livelihoods; there is a high dependence on natural resources and forestry; and
the level of extreme poverty remains high. Women in developing countries are particularly
vulnerable to climate change because they are highly dependent on local natural resources
for their livelihood. Women charged with securing water, food and fuel for cooking and
heating face the greatest challenges. Women experience unequal access to resources and
decision-making processes, with limited mobility in rural areas. It is thus important to identify
gender-sensitive strategies that respond to these crises for women.
13
Women and men have different access to the resources (land, credit, agricultural technology
etc.) to cope with the impacts of climate change: where women have fewer resources than
men, this increases their vulnerability and undermines their capacity to adapt to a changing
climate. Climate change adaptation and mitigation measures (for e.g. social protection
mechanisms, weather-based insurance schemes, seasonal climate forecasts and measures
related to forests or soil carbon storage) often do not address gender issues and specifically,
women’s constraints to participating in these measures. Women commonly face higher risks
in responding to natural hazards and greater burden from the impacts of climate change.
Although they have intimate local knowledge and are managers of common natural
resources, they are often left out of the picture when decisions on climate action are made.
Member States at the annual Conference of the Parties (COP23), convening from 6 – 17
November 2017 in Bonn, Germany, adopted a new roadmap to incorporate gender equality
and women’s empowerment in climate change discourse and actions. The creation of a
“Gender Action Plan” was agreed upon by the Parties at COP22, to bolster the role of
women in climate action. The aim of the Gender Action Plan is to ensure that women can
influence climate change decisions, and that women and men are represented equally in all
aspects of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), as a way to
increase its effectiveness. The Gender Action Plan sets out, in five priority areas, the
activities that will help achieve this objective.
ASEAN Working Group on Climate Change (AWGCC) was established to oversee the
implementation of the relevant action lines in the ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community (ASCC)
Blueprint. One of the objective of the ASCC Blueprint 2025 is to realise a resilient
community with enhanced capacity and capability to adapt and respond to social and
economic vulnerabilities, disasters, climate change as well as emerging threats, and
challenges.
The following gender issues should be considered when implementing the ASCC Blueprint
2025
14
3.2.6. Food security and nutrition
ASEAN has sought to ensure food security for the region, enhance agricultural productivity,
and maintain sustainability of natural resources. In recognition of the rapid changes in the
global market and their impacts on the agriculture and forestry sectors, as well as of the
structural changes within these sectors, as the result of industrialization, the Hanoi Plan of
Action (HPA) and its successor Vientiane Action Programme (VAP) on the Food, Agriculture
and Forestry Sectors, has called for “Enhance Food Security and Global Competitiveness of
ASEAN’s Food, Agriculture and Forestry Products through developing appropriate
technologies to increase productivity and by promoting intra- and extra-ASEAN trade and
greater private sector investment in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors ”.
Food and nutrition insecurity is a gender justice issue. Low status and lack of access to
resources mean that women and girls are the most disadvantaged by the inequitable global
economic processes that govern food systems and by global trends such as climate change.
Evidence shows strong correlations between gender inequality and food and nutrition
insecurity. Gender relations between and among men and women are important in
determining vulnerability to food insecurity and malnutrition. Gender discrimination in the
allocation of household resources, including those related to nutrition, may result in an
increased incidence of malnutrition among women and girls: this may be compounded in
times of crises. Greater vulnerability to food insecurity in times of crisis compounds the
problems of food insecurity
The analysis by Institute of Development Studies (IDS 2014), on Gender and Food Security
emphasizes that the need for those designing food and nutrition security policies and
programmes to go beyond a focus on the first pillar of ensuring the availability of food in poor
countries through ‘short-term’ strategies of food assistance and longer-term strategies
focused on boosting agricultural production, which are reliant on industrial models and trade
liberalisation. The ‘four pillars’ of food security – availability, access, utilisation and stability –
that were identified at the World Summit on Food Security in 2009 provide useful entry
points for a more comprehensive analysis of the problem of food insecurity and for
addressing thecurrent, insufficient, policy responses.
The following gender issues should be considered when implementing the ASEAN
integrated Food Security Framework SPA on Food Security 2015-2020:
3.2.7. Integrating gender into food, agricultural and forestry value chains
Closing the “gender gap” in agriculture can result in major production gains: the FAO report
on The State of Food and Agriculture 2010-2011 determined that women’s yields could grow
15
by 20–30 percent if the gender gap in accessing agricultural inputs were closed, an increase
that could raise total agricultural output in developing countries by 2.5–4 percent, which
could in turn reduce the number of food insecure people in the world by 12–17 percent
(FAO, 2011). Within this context, integrating gender considerations into the development of
agrifood value chains is not only necessary from a human rights perspective; it is also a
prerequisite to ensuring sustainable growth in areas of intervention.
Value chain programs designed with gender equitable principles can encompass both
competitiveness and gender equality and lead to poverty reduction. It is important to map
gender relations and roles along the value chain. The process is based on an accurate
understanding of existing gender relations in a specific country context and for specific food,
agriculture and forestry products. It should include mapping man’s and women’s
participation and benefits along the chain and identifying the factors that shape the gender
patterns in value chain operations. Gender dynamics are inextricably bound up with the
value chain development cycle: value chain efficiency is highly dependent on strong linkages
and positive collaboration among actors, and women are important stakeholders all along
value chains, though they are often invisible or overlooked.
The FAO Gender-Sensitive Value Chain (GSVC) Framework focuses on the individual level
and looks into the gender based constraints which are the underlying causes of value chain
inefficiency. The aim of GSVC is to identify gender based constrains at every node of the
value chain, such as participation in the chain, access to and control over productive
resrouces and access to and control over benefits (FAO 2016)
The following gender issues should be considered when integrating gender into agricultural
value chains:
There are important gender perspectives in all aspects of food, agriculture and forestry.
Gender inequalities in access to resources, including land, credit, extension services,
information and technology, must be taken into account in developing food, agriculture and
forestry policies, programmes and activities. Women make up a large number of the poor in
communities that are highly dependent on local natural resources for their livelihood and are
disproportionately vulnerable to and affected by climate change. Women in rural areas in
developing countries have the major responsibility for household water supply and energy
for cooking and heating, as well as for food security, and are negatively affected by drought,
uncertain rainfall and deforestation. Because of their roles, unequal access to resources and
16
limited mobility, women in many contexts are disproportionately affected by natural
disasters, such as floods, fires, and mudslides. It is important to identify gender-sensitive
strategies for responding to the environmental and humanitarian crises caused by climate
change.
ASEAN Member States should be encouraged to mainstream gender perspectives into their
national policies, action plans and other measures on sustainable development and climate
change, through carrying out systematic gender analysis, collecting and utilizing sex-
disaggregated data, establishing gender-sensitive indicators and benchmarks and
developing practical tools to support increased attention to gender perspectives.
Consultation with and participation of women in climate change initiatives should be
considered and the role of women’s groups and networks strengthened.
4.2. Framework for a strategy for mainstreaming gender in food, agriculture and
forestry
The gender mainstreaming approach in food, agriculture and forestry identifies the overall
strategic objective as: “To facilitate and promote resilience agricultural policies, structures
and programmes to promote gender equality towards sustainable development by 2025”.
The objective is to promote and advocate for gender equality in food, agriculture and forestry
policies, programmes, systems and structures at the regional and national levels. The
following activities may be considered:
The objective is to strengthen and build the capacity of policy makers, field workers and
farmers on appropriate approaches to integrating gender in agriculture and climate change.
The following activities may be considered:
17
- Support Member States to develop training modules on climate smart
agriculture and gender
- Support Member States to develop capacity for gender impact assessment
mechanisms.
- promote training of female agricultural extension agents
- Facilitate the development of gender-sensitive data bases and systems to
consolidate women’s knowledge and experience in sustainable resource use
and in particular on agricultural production systems
- Facilitate the capacity building of team of trainers/focal persons on climate
smart agriculture and gender.
The objective is to create and strengthen strategic partnerships and tripartite relations at
international and regional levels including public private partnerships. The following activities
may be considered:
18
The objective is to promote gender-equitable research supporting climate smart agricultural
technologies. The following activities may be considered:
5. IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS
The recommendations in the AMAF’s Approach serve as reference guides for AMS in their
efforts to promote gender equality in the food, agriculture and forestry sectors. SOM-AMAF,
with support from ATWGARD, ASWGL, ASWGC, ASWGFi, ASOF and other relevant
Working groups may accordingly be guided where relevant by the recommendations in the
AMAF’s Approach. The ATWGARD, in close coordination with the ASEAN Secretariat may
need to seek support from ASEAN partners and different stakeholders in the implementation
of the AMAF’s Approach as reference guides.
REFERENCES
19
Child Undernutrition: Global and Regional Exposures and Health Consequences.
The Lancet 371(9608):243–260
FAO. 2016. Developing gender-sensitive value chains – A guiding framework. Rome
FAO, 2013: CEDAW- Convention on the elimination of all forms of discrimination against
women. A tool for gender – sensitive agriculture and rural development policy and
programme formulation
FAO (2013) Understanding and integrating gender issues into livestock projects and
programmes: A checklist for practitioners.
FAO, 2012: How to mainstream gender in forestry
FAO, 2008 The World Bank and IFAD: Gender in Agriculture, Sourcebook
FAO, 2008: World Fish Center and World Bank: Small-scale capture fisheries – A global
overview with emphasis on developing countries: a preliminary report of the Big
Numbers Project. FAO and Worl dFish Center, Rome & Penang, 62 pages
Porter, M. (2006) Gender and fisheries: A global perspective. Paper presented at Global
Coasts: Gender, Fisheries and Contemporary Issues, International Symposium,
University of Tromso, Norway, June 2006
UN, 2010: UN Joint programmes integrating gender issues in food security, agriculture and
rural development
Tauli-Corpuz, Victoria. 2011. Indigenous women, climate change and forests. Baguio City,
Philippines: Tebtebba Foundation.
World Bank, World Development Report 2012: Gender Equality and Development,
Washington, DC, 2012
World Bank, Food and Agriculture Organization & International Fund for Agricultural
Development, 2009. Gender in agriculture source book
20
Annex 1: Recommended gender intervention in sectoral SPAs
The following SPAs were reviewed to formulate the recommendations for the approach.
21
ST5 Assist resource 5.5 Implement While considering the
constrained small competition policies to level playing field,
producers and SMEs to ensure a level playing there is need to
improve productivity, field for producers and consider gender equity
technology and product SMEs and to prevent issues as well.
quality, to meet global unfair exploitation by
market standards and large firms with market
increase power in
competitiveness in line integrated supply
with the ASEAN Policy chains.
Blueprint on SME
Development
ST6 Strengthen ASEAN joint 6.2 Present ASEAN Present ASEAN
approaches on common position on the common position on
international and issues affecting FAF the gender equality in
regional issues sector in regional and food, agriculture and
global fora forestry issues
affecting FAF sector in
regional and global
fora
ST7 Promote sustainable 7.3 Promote dialogue Promote regional
forest management with the private sector dialogue on gender
about improving quality issues in sustainable
& efficiency of the timber forest management
industry andprocessing
of other forest product
22
nutrition and equitable awareness of healthy advocating healthy
distribution diets diets and consuming
micronutrient-rich
foods
ST4 Increase Resilience to 4.1.1 Build the capacity Build their capacity to
Climate Change, of ATWGARD in integrate gender into
Natural Disasters and proposal writing to the proposals.
Other Shocks explore funding support
from the climate funds.
4.4 Integrate gender Build capacity to
issues into climate integrate gender into
friendly agriculture, the existing and new
fishery and forestry programs and policies.
practices to reduce the
higher vulnerability of
women to the social and
economic impact of
natural disasters and
climate change. (SPFAF
4.7)
ST6 Strengthen ASEAN joint 6.2 Present ASEAN Engagement of
approaches on common position on the ATWGARD to present
international and issues affecting FAF ASEAN common
regional issues sector in various position on the issues
Regional and affecting Gender and
International Fora FAF
23
security, nutrition, and improved nutrition and accessible to the poor,
gender equality gender equality especially women,
through micro-credit,
SME and other
programmes designed
for poverty alleviation.
24
ST6 Strengthen ASEAN 6.2 Present ASEAN Coordinating and
joint approaches on common position on the strengthening joint
international and issues affecting Crop positions on gender
regional issues sector in regional and issues at international
international fora and regional fora and
organizations
25
ST5 Assist resource 5.3.1 Ensure that Emphasize gender
constrained small national programs and issues while discussing
producers and SMEs policies on fisheries and social issues.
to improve aquaculture address
productivity, social, economic and
technology and environmental aspects of
product quality, to sustainable fisheries and
meet global market aquaculture to improve
standards and food security, livelihoods,
increase employment and poverty
competitiveness. alleviation
ST6 Strengthen ASEAN 6.2.1. Promote dialogue Include AMS common
joint approaches on among AMS to establish positions in gender
international and common positions on issues in fisheries.
regional issues Fisheries issues that
affecting the FAF impact the ASEAN
sector Region
26
forestry sector.
ST4 Increase resilience to 4.2. Enhancement of Facilitate cross-
climate change, natural Sharing Experiences learning among AMS in
disasters and other and Lessons Leaned. gender, forestry and
shocks climate change,
ASEAN Working Group
on social forestry
ST5 Assist resource 5.2. Enhancement of Adopt and articulate
constrained small ASEAN Joint ASEAN common
producers and SMEs to Approaches in positions on Gender
improve productivity, Addressing Regional and Forestry and
technology and product and International influence the outcomes
quality, to meet global Forestry Issues. of the deliberations at
market standards and international and
increase regional fora
competitiveness in line
with the ASEAN Policy
Blueprint on SME
Development;
ASEAN Integrated Food Security (AIFS) Framework and Strategic Plan of Action
on Food Security in the ASEAN Region (2015- 2020)
27
ST5 Encourage greater 5.1.1. Prepare Equal participation
investment in food and roadmaps for demand- women groups,
agri-based industry to oriented agri-based and cooperatives and
enhance food security food regional value SMEs in preparation of
chains the roadmap.
ST6 Identify and address 6.1.1. Conduct a study Study should also
emerging issues related on the long-term include section on
to food security implications of bio- social, gender
energy development implication.
and food security in
AMS.
ST7 Utilize Nutrition 7.1.1. Conduct regional This workshop should
Information to support workshops to integrate gender
evidence-based food identify/define key issues in nutrition.
security and agriculture nutrition information and
policies indicators,
collection/compilation
methodologies required
for regular food security
monitoring and policy
development
ST8 Identify policies, 8.1. Awareness and Participation of women
institutional and recognition on is critical in these
governance importance of nutrition awareness raising
mechanisms for by key stakeholders of activities.
nutrition-enhancing food, agriculture and
agriculture development forestry
in AMS
ST9 Develop and strengthen 9.1. Nutrition-enhancing Build capacity to
nutrition-enhancing food, agriculture and integrate gender into
food, agriculture and forestry policies and the Nutrition-
forestry programmes developed enhancing food,
policies/programs and and strengthened agriculture and forestry
build capacity for their policies and
implementation, programmes
monitoring and
evaluation
28