Unit: 2.2. Illness: Content
Unit: 2.2. Illness: Content
Unit: 2.2. Illness: Content
1. Medicalization
1
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Positive Consequences
With everything being medicalized, some people have a better chance functioning
well in society.
If they are really shy, they will be diagnosed with Anxiety Disorder, and will be
medicated to interact efficiently in society.
People are no longer depressed, disoriented because of medical intervention, for
example anorexia.
It can really improve the self-esteem of some individuals.
Negative Consequences
Example:
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)
A child with a different learning size will be accused of having a learning disability
or having ADHD.
By transforming all of these differences into pathologies, it will diminish our
tolerance for and appreciation of the diversity of human life.
Eventually every person will be labelled as sick.
Old Age is being medicalized.
Medicalization has brainwashed people into thinking that somethings aren’t normal
when really they are.
As people age they are pushed to take all of these medications to stay young and feel
good, when it should be acceptable to age.
Child Birth
Childbirth used to have been done in a hospital under drugs. Now woman have many
options on how they would like to give birth.
Disabilities went from medical problem to societal problem.
Medicalization plays a huge role in todays society.
2
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
One can be ill/suffer from disease without adopting the sick role
Illness/disease involves suffering, but does not require complaint
Disease may exist without subjectively experienced symptoms, e.g. cancer in
remission
3
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Mechanical causes:
Exposure to chronic friction and other mechanical forces may result in
crushing, tearing, sprains, dislocation.
Absences or insufficiency or excess of a factor necessary to health:
Chemical factors, nutritional factors, lack of parts and structure, chromosomal
factors and immunological factors.
Social causes:
Poverty, Smoking, abuse of drug and alcohol.
Stages of illness
According to Suchman (1979), he describe five Stages of illness
Stage I : Experiencing symptoms
Stage II : Assuming the sick role
Stage III : Medical care contact
Stage IV : Assuming a dependent role
Stage V : Achieving recovery and rehabilitation
4
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Sick role
Behaviour & obligations expected from a sick person.
Rights and Obligations
The Theory outlined two rights of a sick person and two obligations:
Rights:
1. The sick person is exempt from normal social roles.
2. The sick person is not responsible for their condition.
Obligations:
1. The sick person should try to get well.
2. The sick person should seek technically competent help and cooperate with
the physician.
Rights
5
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Criticisms
Rejecting the sick role.
This model assumes that the individual voluntarily accepts the sick role.
Individual may not comply with expectations of the sick role, may not give up social
obligations, may resist dependency, may avoid public sick role if their illness is
stigmatised.
Individual may not accept 'passive patient' role.
Doctor Patient Relationship
Going to see doctor may be the end of a process of help seeking behaviour.
This model assumes 'ideal' patient and 'ideal' doctor roles.
Differential treatment of patient, and differential doctor patient relationship-
variations depend on social class, gender and ethnicity.
Blaming The Sick
'Rights' do not always apply.
Sometimes individuals are held responsible for their illness, i.e. illness associated with
sufferers lifestyle.
In stigmatised illness sufferer is often not accepted as legitimately sick.
Chronic Illness
Model fits acute illness (measles, appendicitis, relatively short term conditions).
Does not fit chronic/long-term/permanent illness as easily, getting well not an
expectation with chronic conditions such as blindness, diabetes.
In chronic illness acting the sick role is less appropriate and less functional for both
individual and social system.
Chronically ill patients are often encouraged to be independent.
Medical sociology has long had an interest in the study of illness experience and
especially of chronic illness.
The public health and demographic reasons for this are not hard to find.
6
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
In the last 40 to 50 years most developed countries (and now many ‘developing’ nations)
have undergone a ‘demographic transition’.
A decline in mortality at all ages, but especially in infancy and early adulthood, has led to
an increase in average life expectancy from birth and (in the presence of low fertility
rates) an ageing population.
Today the majority of men and women can expect to live into old age.
As deaths from infections have declined and as a greater proportion of the population
comprises the elderly, those disorders associated with adult and later life have grown in
prominence.
Many of these are chronic disorders, such as arthritis, stroke, dementia, Parkinson’s
disease and some forms of heart disease and cancer
Impact of Chronic Illness and Disability
Age ,
Gender,
Relationship
Stress,
Life style
Social Stigma
5. Stigma
'Stigma' has been defined as an attribute that is deeply discrediting, and the
stigmatized individual is one who is not accepted and not accorded the respect and
regard of his peers, one who is disqualified from full social acceptances (Goffman,
1963).
Stigma is typically a social process, experienced or anticipated, characterized by
exclusion, rejection, blame, or devaluation that results from experience, perception, or
reasonable anticipation of an adverse social judgment about a person or group. Stigma
refers to unfavourable attitudes and beliefs directed toward someone or something,
which may be broadly grouped as:
Goffman also describes three main groups of stigmatized individuals.
Firstly, those with physical deformities,
Secondly, those with blemishes of character (mental ill), and
Thirdly, those with tribal stigma (Race).
Process of Stigma
7
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Types of Stigma
Felt Stigma:
It refers to the negative attitudes the community adopts towards those with a
stigmatized condition.
Internalised Stigma (Self Stigma):
It refers to the way people, who are the sufferers, feel themselves. This usually is due
to reduced self-esteem, feeling hopelessness and feeling of guilt or blame by self.
Enacted Stigma:
It means actual occurrence of discrimination such as divorce, denying access to public
services or performed negative behaviour of people or community to the person
affected by leprosy.
Consequences of Stigma
Loss of employment
Loss of housing
Rejection by family
Being ostracized by community
Denied schooling
Denied marriage
Restrictions on movement
Physical and verbal abuse and threats
Interferes with disease prevention and treatment services
8
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
9
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
treatments, technical help and medical equipment. This is also only for those
individuals who were literate, so called modern, well-off people influenced others and
sensitized like these.
In 1986, the Indian government established the Rehabilitation Council of India (RCI).
Following year, the Mental Health Act was also implemented.
Persons with Disabilities Act 1995
1990s
India witnessed drastic changes in the final decade of the last millennium within its
disability sector.
In the year 1995, the Parliament enacted the PwDs Acts along with signing of
Proclamation of Equality Rights & Full Participation of People with Disabilities in the
Asian & Pacific Region.
Immediately after that, PwDs were provided with a reservation of 3% in government
services and educational institutions.
In the Year 2016
The Disability Acts was thoroughly rectified.
In fact, in earlier Acts there were only 7 types of disabilities included, but in new
Acts all left out disabilities have been counted and in total there are 21 types of
disabilities that have been included.
As of now, there are plenty of Indian organisations for persons with disabilities,
both government and non-government, throughout the country that support the rights
and causes of PwDs. They have been doing great work to promote equal opportunities
for the differently abled and help them lead dignified lives in the modern society.
The Indian government has also enacted initiatives such as the Accessible India
Campaign to make public spaces and transportation barrier-free for persons with
disabilities.
The 21 Disabilities are:
1. Blindness 12. Chronic Neurological conditions
2. Low-vision 13. Specific Learning Disabilities
3. Leprosy Cured persons 14. Multiple Sclerosis
4. Hearing Impairment 15. Speech and Language disability
(deaf and hard of hearing) 16. Thalassemia
5. Locomotor Disability 17. Hemophilia
6. Dwarfism 18. Sickle Cell disease
7. Intellectual Disability 19. Multiple Disabilities including deaf and
8. Mental Illness blindness
9. Autism Spectrum Disorder 20. Acid Attack victim
10. Cerebral Palsy 21. Parkinson's disease
11. Muscular Dystrophy
Persons with "benchmark disabilities" are defined as those certified to have at least
40%of the disabilities specified above.
10
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Bus Concessions
Niramaya Health Insurance
To provide affordable Health Insurance to persons with Autism, Cerebral
Palsy, Mental Retardation & Multiple Disabilities
ADIP SCHEME (scheme of assistance to disabled persons for purchase / fitting of
aids/appliances)
Disability Pension
Scholarship for education
Incentive award for marriage between disabled and non-disabled
One time Grant from Social Welfare Department to by artificial limbs
11
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
12
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
13
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Four Quadrants
1. High-level wellness in a favourable environment
E.g., A person who implements healthy life-style behaviours and has the
biopsychosocialspiritual resources to support this life-style.
2. Emergent high-level wellness in an unfavourable environment
E.g., A woman who has the knowledge to implement healthy life-style practices but
does not implement adequate self-care practices because of family responsibilities,
job demands, or other factors.
3. Protected poor health in a favourable environment
E.g., An ill person whose needs are met by the health care system and who has access
to appropriate medications, diet, and health care instruction.
4. Poor health in an unfavourable environment
Poor health due to unfavourable environment.
E.g., A young child who is starving in a drought ridden country.
14
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Modifying Factors
Demographic variables - Demographic variables include age, sex, race, and ethnicity.
Example:
Infant does not perceive the importance of a healthy diet; an adolescent may
perceive peer approval as more important than family approval and as a
consequence may participate in hazardous activities or adopt unhealthy eating and
sleeping patterns.
Sociopsychologic variables - Social pressure or influence from peers or other
reference groups (e.g., self-help or vocational groups) may encourage preventive
health behaviours even when individual motivation is low. Expectations of others may
motivate people.
Example:
Not to drive an automobile after drinking alcohol.
Structural variables - Knowledge about the target disease and prior contact with it
are structural variables that are presumed to influence preventive behaviour.
Cues to action- Cues can be either internal or external.
Internal cues include feelings of fatigue, uncomfortable symptoms, or
thoughts about the condition of an ill person who is close.
External cues are mass media campaigns, advice from others, reminder
postcard from a physician or dentist, illness of family member or friend,
newspaper or magazine article.
15
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
Likelihood of action
The likelihood of a person's taking recommended preventive, health action depends
on the perceived benefits of the action minus the perceived barriers to the action.
Perceived benefits of the action - Examples include refraining from smoking
to prevent lung cancer, and eating nutritious foods and avoiding snacks to
maintain weight.
Perceived barriers to action - Examples include cost, inconvenience,
unpleasantness, and lifestyle changes.
8. Quality of Life
Quality of Life
Quality of life is the general wellbeing of an individual or society, experiencing the
standard of health, comfort and happiness and it is a highly subjective measure.
Quality of life is important to everyone, particularly health.
The WHO defines Quality of Life as an individual's perception of their position in
life in the context of the culture and value systems in which they live and in relation
to their goals, expectations, standards and concerns (WHO, 1995).
16
Unit: II.2. Illness Sociology for Health Sciences
This definition considers the person's physical and psychological health, social
relationships, personal beliefs, environment and their relationship to salient features of
their environment.
Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQoL)
The concept of health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and its determinants have
evolved since the 1980s, to encompass those aspects of overall quality of life, that can
be clearly shown to affect health, either physical or mental.
On the individual level, HRQOL includes physical and mental health perceptions and
their correlates, including health risks and conditions, functional status, social support,
and socioeconomic status.
On the community level, HRQOL includes community-level resources, conditions,
policies, and practices that influence a population’s health perceptions and functional
status.
The Centre for Disease Control and Prevention, USA, in the year 2000, defined the
health-related quality of life as “An individual’s or group’s perceived physical and
mental health over time”, which covers broad domains including physical,
psychological, economic, spiritual and social wellbeing.
Measuring the HRQOL can bridge boundaries between disciplines and among social,
mental, and medical services.
Measurement Tools such as;
o World Health Organization Quality of Life (WHOQOL-BREF)
o Short Form-36 (SF-36)
o Psychological General Well-Being Index (PGWBI)
o Disease specific instrument
Domains of Health Status
Four essential domains should be included in all HRQoL instruments:
Physical functioning
Psychological functioning
Social functioning
General health perception
Factors affecting health related quality of life
It is a multi-domain concept which represents the patient’s general perception
of the effect of illness and treatment on various aspects of life such as physical,
psychological, and social.
Some other aspects also can be predicted to affect HRQOL like - economical,
disease symptoms, adverse drug reactions, patient-education, disease-treatment
given to the patient
17