Bertha Kariuki Nyagaki Final Thesis
Bertha Kariuki Nyagaki Final Thesis
Bertha Kariuki Nyagaki Final Thesis
PARASTATALS IN KENYA
METHODIST UNIVERSITY
AUGUST, 2022
DECLARATION
This thesis is my original work and has not been submitted for a degree award in any
University.
BUS-3-0546-1/2019
This thesis has been submitted for examination with our approval as University
supervisors
Jane Munga
ii
DEDICATION
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First, I wish to express my deep gratitude to Almighty God for being gracious and
merciful toward me which made it possible for me to accomplish this task. Second, I
wish to express my sincere appreciation for the support I received from the entire body of
academic staff in the Kenya Methodist University School of Business. Very special
thanks go to my supervisor Dr. Susan Nzioki for distinctive guidance, patience, insight
and availability for consultation. I also wish to express my gratitude to Jane Munga for
her words of counsel. Finally, I wish to thank all persons, who although not mentioned by
name here, provided valuable support during the period of study. My prayer is that God
iv
ABSTRACT
A key role of strategic management theory as well as research continues to be the
consistent improvement of institutional results. The idea and practices of strategic
management is therefore significant to privately-owned, public as well as community-
based organizations as all of them are formed to fulfill a certain need in the environment.
Government and its agencies the world continue to implement strategic management
practices with the ultimate intention of improving the success of service performance in
the delivery of public goods and services. The major intention for the Study was to
determine influence of strategic management practices on organizational performance, a
case study of commercial based parastatals in Kenya. More importantly the analysis deals
with the degree to which strategy evaluation impact organization performance; the level
to which environmental scanning influence organization performance; the level to which
strategy formulation influence organization performance; and analyzed the degree
strategy implementation influence organization performance in commercially based
parastatals in Kenya. The study may greatly contribute towards the running of
commercially based parastatals in Kenya. Terminations from the analysis aid them
towards the formulation as well as designing of effective plans for the identification and
tackling of concerns surrounding strategic management practices in order to realize
established desires and ensure relevancy in a dynamic and place commercially based
parastatals well towards better results going forward. The study was guided by a
descriptive research design. The target population was and targets 129 employees of
commercial based parastatals. Purposive sampling was adopted in this study; data was
collected using a closed ended questionnaire. Statistical Package for Social Sciences
(SPSS version 23.0) was used to run descriptive and inferential statistics. The result
indicated that, collectively environmental scanning has influences on organization
performance most, followed by strategy evaluation, strategy formulation and strategy
implementation. The study concludes that, predictors collectively influence organization
performance. The findings are to guide policy makers and managers in strategy
implementation. The study recommends that during strategy formulation the commercial
based parastatals should involve all stakeholders in the industry so as to create sense of
ownership. Commercial based parastatals should ensure involvement and participation of
all the levels of management in formulating strategies. Furthermore, the study proposes
future analyses on other external aspects such as the organizational setting and type of
industry to give a better aspect of these factors. This is because organization operations
are influenced by both internal and external environments.
v
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION ................................................................................................................ ii
DEDICATION ................................................................................................................... iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ................................................................................................. iv
ABSTRACT........................................................................................................................ v
TABLE OF CONTENTS................................................................................................... vi
LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................... viii
LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................... ix
ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS ........................................................................... x
CHAPTER ONE.......................................................................................................................... 1
INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Background of the Study ...............................................................................................1
1.2 Problem Statement .......................................................................................................10
1.3 General Objective of the Study ....................................................................................12
1.4 Hypothesis of the Study ...............................................................................................12
1.5 Significance of the Study .............................................................................................13
1.6 Scope of the Study .......................................................................................................13
1.7 Limitations of the Study...............................................................................................14
1.8 Definition of Key Terms ..............................................................................................15
CHAPTER TWO ...................................................................................................................... 16
LITERATURE REVIEW ....................................................................................................... 16
2.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................16
2.2 Theoretical Review ......................................................................................................16
2.3 Empirical Review.........................................................................................................20
2.4 Conceptual Framework ................................................................................................36
2.5 Research Gap ...............................................................................................................37
2.6 Operational Framework ...............................................................................................38
CHAPTER THREE .................................................................................................................. 39
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY .......................................................................................... 39
3.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................39
3.2. Research Design..........................................................................................................39
3.3. Target Population ........................................................................................................39
vi
3.4 Sampling Procedure .....................................................................................................40
3.5. Data Collection Instruments and Procedures ..............................................................41
3.6. Data Analysis ..............................................................................................................42
3.7. Validity of Instruments ...............................................................................................42
3.8 Reliability of Instruments ............................................................................................43
3.9. Research Ethics ...........................................................................................................43
CHAPTER FOUR ..................................................................................................................... 44
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS .................................................................................................. 44
4.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................44
4.2. Response Rate .............................................................................................................44
4.3 Reliability Analysis ......................................................................................................44
4.4 General Information of the Respondents .....................................................................45
4.5 Descriptive Analysis ....................................................................................................48
4.6 Hypothesis Testing.......................................................................................................66
CHAPTER FIVE....................................................................................................................... 72
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ...................................... 72
5.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................72
5.2 Summary of the Findings .............................................................................................72
5.3 Conclusions ..................................................................................................................79
5.4 Recommendations ........................................................................................................80
5.5 Suggestion for Further Studies.....................................................................................81
REFERENCES ............................................................................................................................ 82
APPENDICES
APPENDIX I: QUESTIONNAIRE .................................................................................. 91
APPENDIX II: A LIST OF COMMERCIAL BASED PARASTATALS IN KENYA ... 95
APPENDIX III: RESEARCH PERMIT ........................................................................... 97
APPENDIX IV: RESEARCH LICENSE ......................................................................... 98
vii
LIST OF TABLES
viii
LIST OF FIGURES
ix
ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS
HR Human Resource
x
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
market’s competitive nature, effective reactions as well as the market dynamics (Pearce
& Robinson, 2011). Critically, it’s a set of programs identified towards resolving an
problem. Since time, strategic management entails the creation, execution and assessment
execution of plans.
platforms as well as increased demands from clients, firms are compelled to react and
come up with plans making them competitive and successful going forward (Thompson,
et al.,2015). All these calls for the leadership to evaluate interrelated investment
to allocate resources effectively and strengthen their core competencies thus gain
competitive advantage.
Traditions around strategic management guide businesses and secure some business
advantage ought to be closely aligned to certain plans. This analysis looked into the
1
varied strategic management cultures like planning, collaborations, expansion plan, as
well as client relationship management. Activities around strategic planning deals with
remedying tasks with the aim of attaining both short and prolonged desires of an
institution. Its relevance in an institution may be found through the examination of the
connection among strategic management and the institutional results. Overall, strategic
full set of tasks, commitments and processes a company needs to undertake regarding to
its plan to secure a competitive edge and sustainability in a healthy market (Wheelan&
Hunger, 2002).
management. There is availability for a structure towards plan creation and adoption.
institutional effectiveness since a badly implemented plan could easily birth challenges.
strategic planning, there is need for them to have a deeper understanding of intuitive-
thinking in order to develop plans for austerity and formal systematic planning. This is an
activity that calls for institutions to come up with goals properly, define plans for the
attainment of objectives, and later establishing advanced strategies aimed at ensuring the
implementation of strategies (Mathinji & Waithaka, 2019). Within the context of this
2
analysis, strategic planning was indicated in terms of scenario planning as well as
al.,2014). There has been detailed instances of clear misunderstanding with regard to the
definition of strategy as well as strategic management; this has further affected the
awareness must be ensured to secure proper decision making that is anchored on the same
ethics.
According to Gica and Negrusa (2011) the relevance of having a strategic plan has gained
reorganization. Further, there has been an observation that strategic planners have
increased capability align with the immediate surroundings, show increased ability to
secure efficient human resource, exhibit increased job fulfillment levels and demonstrate
improved human labor retention. Strategic planning details the entire organization of
the focal point of institutions; with profitability in firms in major economies being largely
With regard to strategy formulation, this entails the creation of prolonged strategies for
3
institution’s strong and weak points (Wheelen& Hunger, 2008). Its processes entails
profiling the institution’s mission, outlining the attainable goals, establishing plans and
out plans across the institution through the creation of short and prolonged goals and
additionally obtaining the operational ideas from the business plan. It’s an activity that
aids the leadership during the determination of certain reactions needed within the critical
organs for executing the business plan (Pearce & Robinson, 2008).
organization attain a competitive edge over others within a dynamic setting through its
prolonged period(Johnson & Scholes, 2003). Further, strategy is the blueprint the
certain market and therefore able to compete with others, meeting clients demand and
therefore attaining positive business results, (Thompson & Strickland, 1999). It has also
plans of action and further distributing utilities crucial in the attainment of positive
results.
increased demands from clients, firms are compelled to react and come up with plans
making them competitive and successful going forward. All these calls for the leadership
4
to evaluate interrelated investment determinations undertaken before implementation.
The organizations are therefore able to allocate resources effectively and strengthen their
With regard to strategy formulation, this entails the creation of prolonged strategies for
institution’s strong and weak points (Wheelen& Hunger, 2008). Its processes entails
profiling the institution’s mission, outlining the attainable goals, establishing plans and
out plans across the institution through the creation of short and prolonged goals and
additionally obtaining the operational ideas from the business plan. It’s an activity that
aids the leadership during the determination of certain reactions needed within the critical
organs for executing the business plan (Pearce & Robinson, 2008).Hill and Jones(2013)
observe strategy evaluation and control being an activity that compares practical results
versus the set target. Strategy evaluation entails putting in place regulatory mechanisms
to persistently analyze, assess and offer information pertaining to the executed plans to
identify whether the set targets are being attained as well as the need for adjustments if
need be.
strategies have to be developed for businesses to gain competitive advantage over their
competitors. For this reason, performance is greatly viewed across many institutions
universally even for the nonprofit ones. Overtime, scholars and policy makers have made
(Ogollah, et al.,2011).
5
Strategic planning has been observed to have a productive result on strategic
management. There is availability for a structure towards plan creation and adoption.
institutional effectiveness since a badly implemented plan could easily birth challenges.
In order for leaderships to be able to undertake effective strategic planning, there is need
austerity and formal systematic planning. This is an activity that calls for institutions to
come up with goals properly, define plans for the attainment of objectives, and later
Within the context of this analysis, strategic planning was indicated in terms of scenario
survey; it remains among the few analysis exploring the connection among programs as
institutional results; therefore the existence of a positive and great connection was
identified among the application of strategic management prod rams and approaches
6
An analysis by Jenster and Søilen (2013), examining a number of firms in china
institutional result indicators. A difference exists among the varied plans and institutional
and are averagely crucial when it comes to institutional results compared to other
of strategic management towards institutional results and the manner if has affected the
corporate institutions.
The corporate performance of five Nigerian brewing companies that carry out strategic
strategic management, and make an effort to choose appropriate strategies that matches
Kachali (2014) lists weak internal control as a cause of poor organizational performance.
internal controls are slow in keeping up with the fast-paced modern corporate
Substandard mechanisms modeling together with poor incorporation into the supply
7
A survey conducted within the University of Nairobi and the existent campuses and
targeting the top leadership running the institution established that strategic monetary
integrations impacted the attainment of results across local public universities within
Kenya. Consequently, a proposal was advanced that leadership within these institutions
additionally, the universities must seek key association swith stakeholders to enhance
2014).
The State Corporation Act is an Act of parliament to make provision for the
establishment of state corporations and for control and regulation of state corporations. A
state corporation has perpetual succession; in its corporate name is capable of suing and 3
being sued and is capable of holding and alienating movable and immovable property.
The Kenya government forms state corporations to meet both commercial and social
goals. They exist for various reasons including: to correct market failure, to exploit social
marginal areas. According to the Guidelines on State Corporations from the Office of the
President, to date there are 176 operational State Corporations in Kenya. This study will
8
According to Wamalwa, (2013), government parastatals were originally created by
institutions and are categorized based on income ability, capacity and the ministry it is
reporting to. Further, they are classified depending on if they are in the financial industry,
Employment and development in Kenya contained in session paper No.4 which suggest
activities was done after independence with a principal focus on economic growth.
However, the creation of these enterprises has changed. Commercial state co-operations
are business that performs entrepreneurial and social activities seamlessly in order to
The State Corporations Act states that the role of a Board within government parastatals
statutes, the board of a parastatals is therefore the main driver in the management of the
the parastatals. The CEO (chief executive officer) of the parastatals the representative of
proposals; brief the relevant ministry on the running of parastatals; monitor very data and
9
publications concerned with the activities of parastatals and their audits; and supervise
Inspector-General (corporations) responsible for over sighting the state parastatals. The
Act further created a State Corporations Advisory Committee (SCAC) responsible for
results by an organization remains essential since lack of profits and reduced financial
strength puts an organization’s commitment to its mission, prolonged objective and its
Robertson (2011), identifies the key strategic management barriers to be fears, lack of
utilities, reduced global interactions and reduced efficiency among the personnel. Some
of the reasons why strategic management may fail to take off also include reduced
engagement with key players, failure of briefing key external players, lack of
comprehensive evaluation and timely feedback on the achievement of the strategic plan,
10
insufficient resources for strategic management, and failure to base the employees’ salary
Parastatals perform varied services that encompass training, maritime, education and
research (Presidential Task Force on Parastatal Reforms Report, 2014). Parastatals are
et al, 2020).
Previous empirical studies show the existence of a major positive connection between
challenges have increased the need for empirical information on the missions and
objectives of companies which is essential for decision making in addressing issues that
are likely to enhance organizational performance. It is against this back drop that this
11
1.3 General Objective of the Study
The general objective of this study was to determine influence of strategic management
Specific Objectives
i) To analyze the effect of environmental scanning on organization performance
organization performance.
organization performance.
organization performances.
organization performance.
12
1.5 Significance of the Study
The analysis identifies further study areas that could be exploited and additionally
interested areas. It will further aid scholars willing to conduct additional studies in similar
areas, acting as a reference point and guiding them in their work. The study findings may
be applied by the academia to advocate for workable strategic management practices. The
results of the study and recommendations assist the policy makers in developing policies
The proposals may be further utilized by administrations to create laws relevant to their
own strategic management practices in the commercial based parastatals, which guide
the country. The findings of this study are valuable to employees working in regulatory
13
1.7Limitations of the Study
The participants have always shown the habit of being suspicious of the investigator, with
some participants raising concern on the scope of information needed and its
consequences.
distancing and limitations of employees who report to the office. The study employed
assuring the participants on non-disclosure on any given information and its role was
14
1.8 Definition of Key Terms
Environmental In this study environmental scanning refers to activities
Scanning encompassing collection of information regarding
relationships and events in the external and internal
environment of an organization (Lerner, 2015)
15
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
This chapter presents literature review, particularly theoretical framework and conceptual
framework in addition to theories supporting this study. Literature have been derived
from existing theoretical literature, critique existing literature about strategic management
proposing ways to attain changes. They help explain and determine the reason for the
existence of a situation and foresee behaviors within specific conditions and offer
direction on the search for modifiable factors like knowledge and attitudes and guide the
development of interventions (Glanz et al., 2008). This study conforms to the following
theories Resource based Theory RBV (1959), Agency theory (1980), and Decision
Theory(1976).
The theory was a brainchild of by Penrose in 1959. It proposes that resources form an
institution’s pool of assets, based on the fact that theory covers assets of an institution as
resources positioning them well in terms of having a competitive edge; securing good
edge as the competences enable an institution maintain the competitive edge over
16
provides a platform for creating and sustaining a competitive edge that cannot be
Organization performance and competitive advantage rely on resources that have been
accumulated over time (Barney 1995). Resources that are rare, non-substitutable,
valuable and not easily initiated should be built by the organization in order to promote
efficiency and effectiveness (Hunt & Morgan, 1995) performance catalysis and related
resources should be identified in the organizational programs. RBT suggests that creation
resources together.
This theory is central to this study because the study focus objectives requires adequate
performance. According to Hooley et al. (1996) this theory has been adopted in the
analysis of strategic management practices. Organizations can therefore gain greater and
measured through customer satisfaction metrics. The importance of this theory to the
measurement of performance metrics in this study that includes profitability, sales growth
According to Mugera (2012) resource based theory has been continually used to explain
17
This theory has been relevant in a long period and is one of the leading management
theory that explains performance of an organization. The theory advances that internal
This theory explain the strategic management practices that is the independent variable of
this study and requires utilization of the available organizational resources organizations
organizations competitive edge. In the present study is therefore crucial to explore the
Agency Theory
Agency theory begins with the relationship between the owners of an organization who
delegates work to an agent who performs the work, also referred to as the principal-
agency problem (Lindqvist&Mijovski, 2013). The agency theory develops from the
and the agents or managers in enhancing the success of the organization (Omari, et al.,
2011). The theory underlines the basic conflict between the self-interest of managers and
owners whereby the owners have the control of the organization but the managers put up
According to Namazi (2012) the agency theory has been used in the past was also used to
attainment of the goal contingency. In managerial accounting it was used. The principle
18
is concerned with situations where an agent is engaged by a party (principal) to secure
This theory relates to this study because strategic management processes are
implemented by agents other than the principal. The theory therefore explains
relationship between the principal shareholders and the managers as agents and how their
performance.
Decision Theory
The theory concerns the manner human design judgment and the subsequent effect on
determining their decisions. These could take the form of probability. activities within a
decision process includes; determining the problem, followed by mining for critical data
regarding the problem and then production of possible solutions to the problem. From
there the next step is evaluation of the solutions to see which one fits best, followed by
identification of a plan for results of the solution and lastly, adoption of a solution settled
for. Well informed decisions help companies to prepare well before implementing a
decision and hence organizations can prepare for risks. Well informed decisions also aid
makers in situations which involve risk or uncertainty (Joyce, 1995). North (1968),
advanced that this theory offers a coherent context for selecting among a variety of plans
even when the implications from these actions remain unknown (Parmigiani, 2009). In its
classical construct, the Decision theory is based on choices individuals make among the
19
available options, which characteristically are expected consequences subject to
Ahmed and Omotunde (2012), outline four types of decision theories. The Causal
decision theory is based on the principle of rational choice which suggests that the result
of your choice arises from your decision.. This theory relates to this study because
Figure 2. 1
Theoretical Framework
Decision Theory
Strategy Formulation.
20
Environmental Scanning and Organization Performance
and institutional results within market setting in Nigeria; that was done by use of
Cancellieret al. (2014) analyzed the connection among institutional strategy and settings
complemented by the use of questionnaires. Data analysis was done by correlations and
ANOVA. Major findings from the analysis reveal prospector’s scanned information from
Asseret al. (2018) intended to determine the effect of dynamic environmental scan
design with the target population comprising of 55 of these parastatals; the final sample
analysis consisted of top leadership, finance Managers and human resource managers and
finance managers of every sampled parastatals. Findings from the analysis indicated
dynamic environmental scan traditions greatly and significant positively impacted results
21
and as a result parastatals responding to the changing and harsh settings possess a
mixed method was adopted in this study. Data collection was done using interview guide.
In Kenya, Ali and Wambua (2019) examined whether performance of Mandera County
design was adopted. The target population of the study constituted of 70 employees.
Descriptive and inferential statistics was used to establish the association between
organization performance and strategic management practices. The study concluded that
population of 881. The study revealed that management crisis is influenced by social
relation. However, this study revealed a weak relationship. The recommendation of the
study suggested that in the internal and external environment environmental scanning
22
suggested that assumptions, theories and traditions models are no longer valid. Central
ingredients of knowledge should be based on knowledge based theory of the firm. This is
because organization structure varies and no set of assumptions is valid in every situation.
case study of public commission in Kenya. The study established a positive relationship
between organizational performance and environmental scanning. The study found that
TVET, in Nairobi County. A descriptive research design was adopted in this study.
Intervention and descriptive approaches were used to analyze data. Findings revealed that
Wanjiku (2016) conducted a study among commercial banks inured to determine whether
the target population of the study. Questionnaires were used to explain the association
between prediction and criteria variables. The study established a positive relationship
23
Strategy Formulation and Organization Performance
workable recommendations that buttress justification of objectives and misses that enable
success.
Globally, public sector organizations still rely on strategic plans in the strategy formation
concluded that strategic planning approaches have been embraced by public sector
Seven empirical studies were examined by Andrews et al. (2011) to a certain the impact
the study established that organization performance is not influenced with internal
formation.
strategy formulation. The study was carried in UAE to find out whether organizational
approach was adopted in the study. Primary data was collected from employees in the
24
In conclusion, the study revealed that organization performance is influenced by strategy
industry in Nigeria. Quantitative approaches was relied upon in the study. The study
Maroa and Muturi (2015) sought to establish whether performance of flowers and firms
organization.
banking industry in Nigeria. Furthermore, Auka and Langat (2016) studied the
However, there was a weak association. Empirical evidence, reveal that strategy
Auka and Langat (2016) findings indicating strategic planning puts a positive impact
towards efficiency and system productivity interventions, although it does not impact on
efficiency, a negative impact by logical incrementalism exists. Despite this, carrying out
making, positively impacts the efficiency as well as the system productivity measures. In
totality, the finding imply that on their own or integrated with logical incrementalism,
25
Owich et al. (2018) conducted an analysis examining the effect of strategic formulation
towards institutional results on firms listed at the Nairobi Securities Exchange (NSE).
Upon data collection and analysis by suitable approaches; the research outcomes
indicated the institutional results being positively and greatly impacted by strategy
Njeru (2018) intended to determine the effect of dynamic environmental scan traditions
with the target population comprising of 55 of these parastatals; the final sample
analysis consisted of top leadership, finance Managers and human resource managers and
finance managers of every sampled parastatals. Findings from the analysis indicated
dynamic environmental scan traditions greatly and significant positively impacted results
and as a result parastatal responding to the changing and harsh settings possess a
strategic performance; with the main role of the analysis being advancing proposals to the
strategy formulation drivers. The analysis revealed strategy formulation drivers impact
strategic performance of mobile TELCOs within Nigeria. Focus on a firm’s goal together
with the prolonged intentions greatly and positively influence strategic performance.
26
Strategy Implementation and Organization Performance
institutional results; a study of DTB bank in Kenya, with use of interviewing guide and
strategic implementation and result at the bank. Findings showed that staff across
factors may be barriers impeding the execution process; the distractions can be
overwhelmed incase the leadership are discerning to the institution's current situation.
Somi (2017) sought out to establish the effect of strategy implementation towards results
the existence of a major connection among strategic evaluation and the results of these
parastatals. Further revealing the existence of a major connection among reward structure
Mathore (2016) analyzed the impact of strategy evaluation towards institutional results: a
study on the Star limited company. Its main intention was to the identify the effect of
research approach, with the study sample comprising of 200 employees within the Centre
Star Company across different departments; using a stratified random sampling manner
in selecting 60 out of the 200 workers to engage in the analysis. Findings from the survey
their goal, align functions to certain targets and sets common traditions as well as cause.
27
Given the fact that there is ever increasing complex and uncertainty of political
strategies entails potting strategies into practice, this includes delivering and planning of
According to Joyce and Drumaux (2014) is a concept that is universally accepted and
performance.
anticipated outcomes. Agencies in the public sector have adopted preparation of strategic
data employing regression and coefficient of correlation analysis: indicted the existence
forces aids in securing opportunities and eliminating risks, thereby promising better profit
margins.
28
In Turkey Chaimankong and Prasertsakul (2012) examined the relationship between
research design. The study collected data using 16 semi-structured; interviews and 134
survey responses. The data was analyzed using robust and moderated model of
regression. The qualitative data that was collected buttressed the quantitative data that
In Kenya, Magambo (2012) sought to analyze the challenges among public corporation
regarding strategy implementation. The study sought to establish these challenges as well
adopted. The study sampled a sample of 189 respondents. The personnel in charge of
planning were targeted in this study. The study findings revealed that the major challenge
results within IHLs in Kiambu. Results from the analysis pointed to the existence of a
strategic management and communication towards the results of IHLs. The conclusion
was that an institutional result was greatly impacted by supervision, regulation of plans,
utility distribution and communication. another finding was that strategic leadership had
29
Ouma(2016) analyzed association between expensive strategies and organization
insurance company performance. The study adopted a census technique. The study
expansion strategy.
A study by Kyalo (2015) a case study of KCB group Ltd, sought to establish whether
expansion strategy influence organization performance. A case study design was adopted
in this study. An interviews guide was use to collect primary data. Content analysis was
adopted in the data analysis. The study revealed that the bottom up approach used by
country. The study sought to establish the influence of cost leadership, focus and
differentiate strategy. A descriptive research design guided the study while questionnaires
were used in the data collection. Inferential and descriptive statistics was used in the data
analysis. The findings revealed that focus, cost leadership and differentiate strategy
influenced by the external environment. A sample of 54 staff was drawn from a target
population of 50 respondents. Primary data was relied upon in this study of which was
collected using questionnaires. Content analysis approach was used in the analysis of
qualitative data. The study findings revealed that implementation of customer focus
30
strategy is influenced by employee training. The study recommended that Equity Bank
focus strategy.
strategy implementation among tea firms in Kericho. The study sample size comprised of
In another, case study of KCB group, Kyalo (2015) sought to establish the relationship
used to collect data from senior management of the Bank. Majority of the respondents
innovation.
Abdalla (2015) analyzed the impact of strategy evaluation towards institutional results: a
study on the Star limited company. Its main intention was to the identify the effect of
research approach, with the study sample comprising of 200 employees within the Centre
Star Company across different departments; using a stratified random sampling manner
31
in selecting 60 out of the 200workers to engage in the analysis. Findings from the survey
their goal, align functions to certain targets and sets common traditions as well as cause.
greatly impacted institutional results. some minimal impact towards institutional results
was noted in the ability to properly indicate, assess results and relate rewards to results,
Several organizations do not give usable and meaningful strategy evaluative because of
the disconnect between organizational level and strategic decision making. They argue
that evaluation and learning efforts inform the decision making practices of an
organizational management concerning reasons that lead to the failure of meeting certain
formulate depends on strategic learning tool, this plays a significant role in strategy
A publication by Nyariki (2016) suggest that strategic evaluative is a critical tool that can
head to the right direction and adopt corrective actions that need to be taken. Therefore,
32
Somi (2017) sought to determine the relationship of organization performance and
adopted. The study had a population of 42 government owned entities. In order to select
42 managers purpose sampling was adopted. The study found a positive relationship
Nyariki (2016) analyzed the effect of strategy evaluation approaches towards attainment
of results at KCB bank. The study goal was to identify the key evaluation styles preferred
by KCB bank and to establish the effect of strategic evaluation styles towards the results.
The analysis adopted an interviewing guide for collection of data; with the collected data
being analyzed by application of content analysis approach. findings from the review
indicated that the strategy evaluation traditions common with the bank included bench
marking, accounting audits, balanced score card, job evaluations, accreditations and
Hieu and Nwachukwu (2019) summarized the strategy evaluation process and strategic
traditions as well as their role towards strategy implementation. The analysis explored
strategy evaluation process and strategic performance of mobile TELCOs within the
Nigerian market. It offered new knowledge on the impact of strategy evaluation process
towards the results of TELCOs in a young economy such like that of Nigeria. The results
reveal that TELCOs embrace a systematic manner to strategy evaluation bearing a major
Njeru (2015) assessed the relationship between organization performance and strategic
33
organizational performance. A cross-section regard design was adopted in the study. The
However, the study considered SMEs, while present study focuses on state owned
parastatals.
Organizational Performance
commitments in relation to the desired goals and set targets. It remains to be a critical
component of business strategy. There continues to be a debate on the exact meaning and
the dimensionality of it, without regard to its relevance as well as global utilization.
Existing publications from earlier reviews reveal the existence of several views
by comparing the desired results versus the real results. Dessler(2012) outlines
performance as a set of tasks, functional productivity and efficiency, their indication and
the resultant results achieved. Individual institutions craft suitable models for indicating
performance, creating a platform for assessing present as well as earlier results in relation
to the desired ones. The methodologies with respect to indicating performance align with
the manner the institution functions together with the key goals being desired (Akinyi,
34
2012). The area of focus in performance measurement, however, varies by organization
and time.
Institutions indicate performance applying various approaches like the approach Kaplan
sales growth: while the non-monetary component includes; client indications, internal
business perspective and growth indicators. A common prevailing role of investment and
institutional results
35
2.4 Conceptual Framework
Mugenda and Mugenda, (2006) advance that a conceptual framework is a hypothesized
design determining the item for analysis and the connection among the dependent
variable and the independent variables. In a study, it captures the connection among the
Figure 2. 2
Conceptual Framework
Independent Variables
Dependent Variable
Environmental
Scanning
Strategy
Formulation
Organization
Performance
Strategy
Implementation
Strategy Evaluation
36
2.5 Research Gap
Based on the literature review it is evident that numerous reviews have been done outside
organizational performance. It is also important to note that a lot of research in his area
has been conducted in United States of America and Brazil. Influence of strategic
The reviewed literature reveals that most of the studies that have focused on strategic
management practices and performance outcome have been carried out in developed
countries.
profit making parastatals. There is no study that has been carried in profit making
parastatals Nairobi County in Kenya; this study sets to establish about influence of
37
2.6 Operational Framework
Figure 2. 3
Operational Framework
Heterogeneity
Environmental Dynamic environment
Scanning
Competitive intensity
Hostile environment
Parameters
38
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1. Introduction
The present chapter explains the research method that was adopted in the study.
Specifically, it explains the study design, the study targets population and sample size;
sampling procedures; instrument reliability and validity data collection and analysis
of different experiences, altitudes and opinions, from a large sample of respondents. The
generated findings would represent the entire opinion of the targeted population (Orodho,
2009).Its suitability in this study is buttressed by the fact that it reveals the respondents
events that are of interest to the researcher. The study targets 33 commercial based
parastatals in Kenya. Respondents for the study were selected from the following
management positions namely; CEO’s, finance managers and human resource managers
39
Table 3. 1.
Target Population
Category Target population
(Employees)
CEOs 33
Human Resource Managers 33
Finance Managers 63
Total 129
Source: (HR Records, Regulatory Parastatals)
study, events, documents that can be used in a survey from which a researcher can collect
data from. In this study purposive sampling was used to select commercial based
The sample size was determined based on the following Yamane’s’ formula.
𝑵
n=𝟏+𝑵 𝒆 𝟐
Where by:
N is the population size, n is the sample size, and e is the level of precision.
40
Table 3. 2:
Sample Size
Target Population Sample Size
Proportion
CEOs 33/129*97 25
Total 97
Primary Data
The research instrument to be used for data collection was closed ended questionnaires. It
is assumed that the selected organization officials are involved in strategy management
Pretesting of the data collection instruments was performed in order to ascertain both data
reliability and validity. Pre-testing enables the investigator evaluate the effectiveness and
clarity of the study instruments and subsequent ease in application (Mugenda &
Mugenda, 2003). In undertaking the pretest, the investigator must organize and then
Participants involved in the pretest are required to peruse the draft questionnaire and
provide answers same as those of actual respondents; the investigator later seeks their
input pertaining to the nature of the questions and their relevance, using their feedback to
41
3.6. Data Analysis
Collected data rearranged and organized for scrutiny aimed at checking completion
awaiting the next phase of data entry. The questionnaires have codes, with each one
having a unique code to enable effective data entry. The data analysis was done by the
help of SPSS version 23. Data was analysed descriptively and presented applying
frequency tables.
Multiple linear regression analysis was also carried out using the following model.
Whereby;
𝑋1 = Environmental Scanning
𝑋2 = Strategy Formulation
𝑋3 = Strategy Implementation
𝑋4 = Strategy Evaluation
gather information that remains essential, can be transferred and finally reliable.
According to Kimberlin and Winterstein (2008) the validity of a study tool is affirmed by
meeting the set specifications. Validity was assured by sourcing for qualified advisory
from the lecturers offering supervision on the degree to which the questionnaires can be
used to collect data. They reviewed the items and further propose methods of enhancing
42
3.8 Reliability of Instruments
According to Kothari (2012) for a researcher to achieve validity and reliability has to pre-
test or pilot test the questionnaire using a sample of the respondents who have
characteristics similar to the target population. The test internal consistency the
researcher used Cronbach’s Alpha, reliability values should exceed a threshold of 0.7.
collected from KEMU and NACOSTI these are the relevant bodies to obtain research
to avert plagiarism prior to the data collection exercise. The consent of respondents was
sought, only respondents who accented participated in the study. Confidentiality was
ensured by assuring respondents that the information they give is confidential. Thirdly,
the respondents were assured that the information gathered is strictly for academic use
the participants were also assured that the findings of the study would be made available
to them.
43
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS ANDANALYSIS
4.1 Introduction
The fourth chapter details deductions obtained from analysis of collected data.
Additionally it captures the features of the participants as well as their views with regards
profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya. With regards to ensuring simplicity
during the presentation of data, the investigator opted for tables offering a summary of
County, Kenya. The targeted respondents were CEO’s, human resource and finance
managers in the commercial based parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya. 82 out of the 97
to draw responses from) were properly answered and submitted, giving it a desirable
validity. An ideal Alpha score ought to be 0.7, (Kothari, 2012). Based on illustrations
detailed below in table 4.1,reliability was ideal across the five scales since their scores
surpassed the desirable standard of 0.7 and above. Therefore, conclusion can be reached
44
Table 4.1
Reliability Analysis
Determinant No of items Cronbanch’s
Verdict
. 824
Environmental scanning 6 Reliable
. 753
Strategy development 9 Reliable
. 801
Strategy adoption 9 Reliable
. 762
Strategy assessment 6 Reliable
. 779
Organizational Results 5 Reliable
From the detailed Cronbach’s Alpha scores, there was consistent performance of the
data collection tool since the figures exceeded the ideal score of 0.7 and above.
schooling levels, duration of work and job description within the commercial based
parastatals in Nairobi.
The investigator intended to assess the gender distribution of participants. Deductions are
45
Table 4.2:
Male 46 56.1
Female 36 43.9
Total 82 100
From the deductions, male participants were the majority with 56.1% and the female
formed the remaining 43.9%. it means that commercial based parastatals in Nairobi
County greatly empower women even though the males took a larger share of the
workforce.
The analysis intended to determine age distributions of the participants. Deductions are
Table 4.3
Age Brackets of the Respondents
Age brackets Frequency Frequency
Total 82 100
46
A significant percentage of the participants fell in the 35-39 age bracket (34.1%).
Participants 30 years and below formed 24.4% of the population, between 40-44 years
were 17.1%. Age bracket above 45 years were 15.9%. The implication is that the most of
the top roles within commercial based parastatals in Nairobi County are taken up by those
Participants had to state their working durations at their current companies. Deductions
Table 4.4:
Working Experience in the Parastatals
Working Experience Frequency Frequency
Total 82 100
Deductions from table 4.4 indicate 42.7% of the participants had been in their positions in
their respective institutions for between 11 to 15 years, 24.4% had served their
institutions for less than 5 years while 15.9% have worked for their respective parastatals
between11-15years, 8.5% had served their institutions between 16-20years same as above
21 years. From these deductions, it was clear that the participants had served their
47
institutions long enough, thus well informed on the impact of strategic management
Education level
Study participants had to state personal highest schooling levels. Deductions are detailed
Table 4.5:
Education level
Education Level Frequency Frequency
Undergraduate 47 57.3
Masters 35 42.7
Total 82 100
From the deductions, 57.3% of the participants possessed a university degree, and 42.7%
had master’s degree. Thus, the conclusion is that the participants possessed more than
enough education for the interpretation and responses to the study goals extensively.
48
Organization Performance
Participants were required to state their affirmation levels based on the question with
Table 4.6:
Descriptive Statistics for Organization Performance
years
organizational performance
Findings from table 4.7 indicate that the significant group that had the highest mean of
4.59 and a SD of 0.64affirmed that in our organization has experienced increased annual
running expenditure over the last five years. Second in line was those affirming that over
49
the last five years your organization has been able to achieve its goals in relation to
that the number of employees has increased over the last five years with a mean of (4.51)
number of branches over the last 5 years at a mean of (4.31) and a standard debviation of
(0.75), and our organization has improved in the past five 5 years mean (4.56) and a SD
of (0.66).
Participants were required to state their affirmation levels based on the question with
50
Table 4.7
performance in the commercial parastatals. The analysis intended to prove this position.
Deductions from the table 4.8 below indicate the a significant group shows that the
performance. This was closely followed by the commercial based state parastatals takes
parastatal performance with a mean score of (4.54) and a standard deviation of (0.83),
51
and Hostile environment affects commercial based state parastatal performance at a mean
The deductions concur with Cancellier, et al.(2014) analysis reveal prospectors take into
conduct. In its entirety, scanning of data promises results compared to strategy indicated
environmental scan traditions greatly and significant positively impacted results and as a
result parastatals responding to the changing and harsh settings possess a competitive
and institutional results within a competitive market setting in Nigeria; that was done by
Cancellieret al. (2014) analyzed the connection among institutional strategy and settings
of medium firms within Brazil and further intended to examine the link between the
findings from the analysis reveal that prospectors take into account scanned information
52
from competition and technology, further accessing publications regularly compared to
those adopting a different manner of strategic conduct. In its entirety, scanning of data
Asser et al. (2018) intended to determine the effect of dynamic environmental scan
Findings from the analysis indicated dynamic environmental scan traditions greatly and
changing and harsh settings possess a competitive advantage and promise improved
results.
environmental scanning in Iranian public hospitals. A mixed method was adopted in this
study. Data collection was done using interview guide. The study revealed that strategic
proportional relation environmental scanning. The study also established that the exterior
scanning in assessing the exterior environmental factors (threats and opportunities) assists
organization’s profitability.
53
Influence of Strategy Formulation on Organization Performance
Participants were required to state their affirmation levels based on the question with
Table 4.8
Influence of Strategy Formulation on Organization Performance
N Mean Standard
deviation
The managers are actively involved in creating company 82
3.14 1.26
mission and vision
The managers act as change enabler or drivers in the 82
4.31 .91
company
The managers are actively involved in making major 82
4.39 1.39
decisions during the strategy formulation
Our organization uses an operating budget which 82
summarizes how managers are supposed to use company 4.36 .93
resources
Our organization has aligned its budget with the company 82
strategy through good communication, enhanced 4.54 .94
responsibility, and improved feedback flows
Our organization always makes decisions that are based on 82
the budget 4.25 1.08
54
Strategy formulation continues to be recognised as a feature mimpacting the
this position.. Findings from table 4.8 indicate that a significant group scoring the
highest mean of (4.54) and a SD of (0.94)affirmed agreed that their organization has
aligned its budget with the company strategy through good communication, enhanced
responsibility, and improved feedback flows. This was closely followed by our
organization uses an operating budget which profiles the manner leaderships ought to
Additionally, participants affirmed that the managers are actively involved in making
major decisions during the strategy formulation with a mean score of (4.39) and a SD of
(1.39), and the managers’ act as change enabler or drivers in the company at a mean score
The determinations concur with Owich et al. (2018) conducted an analysis examining the
effect of strategic formulation towards institutional results. Upon data collection and
analysis by suitable approaches; the research outcomes indicated the institutional results
being positively and greatly impacted by strategy formulation. Nwachukwu, et al. (2019)
the main role of the analysis being advancing proposals to the leadership of
multinationals within the telcos industry in Nigeria. Focus on a firm’s goal together with
A review by Babatunde and Adebisi (2012) found that the variation within an institution
55
positive influence in institutional results. Thus, utilization of strategic environmental
Cancellieret al. (2014) major findings from the analysis reveal prospectors take into
conduct. In its entirety, scanning of data promises results compared to strategy indicated
workable recommendations that buttress justification of objectives and misses that enable
and institutional results within a competitive market setting in Nigeria; that was done by
56
AlDhaheri et al (2020) examined whether organizational operations is influenced by
strategy formulation. The study was carried in UAE to find out whether organizational
approach was adopted in the study. Primary data was collected from employees in the
Nigeria. Quantitative approaches was relied upon in the study. Simple random sampling
was used to select 128 managers. The study established that strategic performance is
Maroa and Muturi (2015) sought to establish whether performance of flowers and firms
organization.
banking industry in Nigeria. Furthermore, Auka and Langat (2016) studied the
However, there was a weak association. Empirical evidence, reveal that strategy
57
Influence of Strategy Implementation on Organization Performance
Participants were required to state their affirmation levels based on the question with
Table 4.9
58
Strategy implementation continues to be recognized as a feature impacting organizational
Findings from table 4.9 indicate that a significant group scoring highest mean score of
(4.19) and a SD of (1.25) affirmed that our organization motivates its employees with
both monetary and non-monetary incentives to enhance their job performance. This was
closely followed by the company’s policy is properly communicated to the staff and is
makes particular decisions with a mean score of (3.60) and a SD of (1.07), and our
organization structure is aligned with the new strategies and with what the new strategies
The determinations concur with a study by Mathore (2016) examining the impact of
with use of interviewing guide and analysis by content analysis revealed the existence of
a positive association among strategic implementation and result at the bank. Findings
showed that staff across different departments have individual awareness on the
execution processes; execution factors may be barriers impeding the execution process;
the distractions can be overwhelmed incase the leadership are discerning to the
Somi (2017) sought out to establish the effect of strategy implementation towards results
59
revealedthe existence of a major connection among strategic evaluation and the results of
these parastatals. Further revealing the existence of a major connection among reward
institutional results; a study of DTB bank in Kenya, with use of interviewing guide and
strategic implementation and result at the bank. Findings showed that staff across
factors may be barriers impeding the execution process; the distractions can be
overwhelmed incase the leadership are discerning to the institution's current situation.
In Kenya, Ouma (2016) sought to analyze the challenges among public corporation
regarding strategy implementation. The study sought to establish these challenges as well
adopted. The study sampled a sample of 189 respondents. The personnel in charge of
planning were targeted in this study. The study findings revealed that the major challenge
Onserio (2018) studied the effect of strategy implementation towards institutional results
within IHLs in Kiambu. Results from the analysis pointed to the existence of a great
management and communication towards the results of IHLs. The conclusion was that an
60
distribution and communication. another finding was that strategic leadership had little
insurance company performance. The study adopted a census technique. The study
expansion strategy.
In another study by Ate (2018) a case study of KCB group Ltd, sought to establish
whether expansion strategy influence organization performance. The study revealed that
the bottom up approach used by KCB to implement the expansion strategy has
management practices among SMEs in Nairobi country. The findings revealed that focus,
strategy is influenced by the external environment. The study findings revealed that
recommended that Equity Bank Ltd should regularly conduct employee workshop to
firms in Kericho. The study findings revealed that organization performance is influenced
61
by all perspectives of strategy implementation that include quality performance, customer
Participants were required to state their affirmation levels based on the question with
62
Table 4.10
this position. Findings from table 4.10 indicate that a significant group scoring the
highest mean score of (3.60) and a SD of (1.07)Affirmed that the managers of our
organization make allowances for the unpredictable future and dynamic business
environment in the strategic plan. This was closely followed by the our organization has
63
in place strategies that are used to cope with unforeseen circumstances in the business
affirmed that Our organization emphasizes on market research focused on entering new
The determinations are in tandem with Abdalla (2015) findings from the survey indicated
strategy evaluation enables institutional guidance since it secures adherence to their goal,
align functions to certain targets and sets common traditions as well as cause.
greatly impacted institutional results. some minimal impact towards institutional results
was noted in the ability to properly indicate, assess results and relate rewards to results,
since it secures adherence to their goal, align functions to certain targets and sets
minimal impact towards institutional results was noted in the ability to properly
indicate, assess results and relate rewards to results, create a performance based tradition
According to Preskill and mark (2013) several organizations do not give usable and
and strategic decision making. They argue that evaluation and learning efforts inform the
64
A positive correlative between organization performance and strategy formulation in the
banking industry in Nigeria. Furthermore, Auka and Langat (2016) studied the
However, there was a weak association. Empirical evidence, reveal that strategy
Santura et al. (2017) strategy control and evaluative informs organizational management
concerning reasons that lead to the failure of meeting certain objectives and performance
learning tool, this plays a significant role in strategy implementation and formulate.
evaluative. Strategic evaluative is a critical tool that can be used to measure that strategic
adopt corrective actions that need to be taken. Therefore, there is need for managers to
adopted. The study had a population of 42 government owned entities. In order to select
42 managers purpose sampling was adopted. The study found a positive relationship
65
Nyariki (2016) analyzed the effect of strategy evaluation approaches towards attainment
of results at KCB bank. The study goal was to identify the key evaluation styles preferred
by KCB bank and to establish the effect of strategic evaluation styles towards the results.
The analysis adopted an interviewing guide for collection of data; with the collected data
being analyzed by application of content analysis approach. findings from the review
indicated that the strategy evaluation traditions common with the bank included bench
marking, accounting audits, balanced score card, job evaluations, client fulfillment
4.6Hypothesis Testing
This area captures determinations on regression, ANOVA as well as co-efficient of
determination.
66
Relationship Between Independent Variables
Table 4.11
Deductions from table 4.11 reveal the existence of a positive correlation among
significant 0.05 level, the strength is average, at 61.3 %. Further, the deductions reveal
performance in the commercial parastatals at significant 0.05 level, the strength is though
strong, at 42.3%. The findings continue to signify that there is a positive correlation
67
between strategy implementation and organization performance in the commercial
parastatals at significant 0.05 level, the strength is though average, at 47.7%. The findings
postulate that there is a strong positive correlation between strategy evaluation and
Table 4.12
Model Summary
Model Summary
Referring to table 4.12 the study establishes the R to be 0.388 implying that 38.8%, of
68
Table 4.13
Relationship between Independent Variables
ANOVAa
Sum of
Total 23.598 81
69
Table 4.84
Unstandardized Standardized
Coefficients Coefficients
implementation. Individual significance of the predictor variables was tested using t-test.
The findings reveal that Environmental scanning, Strategy evaluation, and Strategy
70
Where;
The findings reveal that environmental scanning, strategy formulation and strategy
71
CHAPTER FIVE
5.1 Introduction
The fifth chapter offers a presentation of the review summary, the terminations and the
proposals desired based on the deductions reached at as well as translations to the study.
Further, the investigator offers possible areas that may be explored for future studies. The
tail end of the chapter details he effects of policies and practices realized from the study
deductions.
has towards organizational results; the impact strategy adoption has towards
organizational results within profit making parastatals; and lastly the impact strategy
with the first intention of the review being to establish he impact of environmental
County, Kenya; focus was on the critical contribution of processes seeking to develop
the working platform and blueprint of an institution. Findings from the analysis of
descriptive statistics affirmed that entirely the processes that indicated strategic purpose
72
were greatly viewed to be critical and thus embraced across profit making parastatals in
Nairobi County, Kenya. Additionally, from analysis of the collected, it was deduced that
strategic purpose positively affected the results of these profit making parastatals in
Asser et al. (2018) intended to determine the effect of dynamic environmental scan
Managers and human resource managers and finance managers of every sampled
parastatals. Findings from the analysis indicated dynamic environmental scan traditions
greatly and significant positively impacted results and as a result parastatals responding
tothe changing and harsh settings possess a competitive advantage and promise improved
results.
suggested that assumptions, theories and traditions models are no longer valid. Central
ingredients of knowledge should be based on knowledge based theory of the firm. This is
because organization structure varies and no set of assumptions is valid in every situation.
performance and environmental scanning. The study found that higher growth rates are
73
that competitive advantage is enhanced by strategic partnerships. Furthermore, customer
With the second objective setting out to explore the impact of strategy development
towards the organizational result of profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya;
focus was on the significance of supervising both inside and outside aspects of the profit
making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya so as to enable proper decision making with
regards to the best strategic plans to adopt for improved results. from the descriptive
results of mean and standard deviation linked to strategy development, there was a
confirmation the desired pool of operational processes with regards to this variable are
being embraced in these profit making parastatals. there was demonstration from
statistical analysis showing that strategy development has a positive impact towards the
Asser et al (2018) concluded that participants in the analysis consisted of top leadership,
finance Managers and human resource managers and finance managers of every sampled
parastatal. Findings from the analysis indicated dynamic environmental scan traditions
greatly and significant positively impacted results and as a result parastatals responding
to the changing and harsh settings possess a competitive advantage and promise
improved results.
negative impact by logical incrementalism exists. Despite this, carrying out a key
74
positively impacts the efficiency as well as the system productivity measures. In totality,
the finding imply that on their own or integrated with logical incrementalism, positively
towards institutional results on firms listed at the Nairobi Securities Exchange (NSE).
Upon data collection and analysis by suitable approaches; the research outcomes
indicated the institutional results being positively and greatly impacted by strategy
banking industry in Nigeria. Furthermore, Auka and Langat (2016) studied the
However, there was a weak association. Empirical evidence, reveal that strategy
strategic performance; with the main role of the analysis being advancing proposals to the
ways to improve and maintain strategic performance based on the assessment of strategy
formulation drivers. The analysis revealed strategy formulation drivers impact strategic
performance of mobile TELCOs within Nigeria. Focus on a firm’s goal together with the
75
Strategy Implementation and Organization Performance
The third objective setting out to explore the impact of strategy development towards the
organizational result of profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya; focus was
fundamental for realizing positive results of a strategic plan within an institution. from
the mean and standard deviation scores, there was confirmation that entirely the
processes indicating strategy adoption were greatly viewed and further being embraced
and utilized by the profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya. Additionally,
analysis of the collected data with regards to the variable showed strategy adoption
positively impacted the results of profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya.
Onserio (2018) studied the effect of strategy implementation towards institutional results
within IHLs in Kiambu. Results from the analysis pointed to the existence of a great
management and communication towards the results of IHLs. The conclusion was that an
distribution and communication. another finding was that strategic leadership had little
Given the fact that there is ever increasing complex and uncertainty of political
strategies entails potting strategies into practice, this includes delivering and planning of
76
According to Joyce and Drumaux (2014) is a concept that is universally accepted and
the anticipated outcomes. Agencies in the public sector have adopted preparation of
research design. The study collected data using 16 semi-structured; interviews and 134
survey responses. The data was analyzed using robust and moderated model of
regression. The qualitative data that was collected buttressed the quantitative data that
with the third objective setting out to explore the impact of strategy development
towards the organizational result of profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya;
focus was on the importance of inclusive target setting, desirable traditions, results
purpose of the profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya. From descriptive
analysis, mean and standard deviation scores for strategy control largely affirmed that the
processes utilized in measuring the variable were greatly viewed and thus embraced and
77
applied within the profit making parastatals. from the analysis of inferential statistical,
there was a demonstration that strategy control had a positive impact towards the results
of these institutions.
Nyariki (2016) findings from the indicated that the strategy evaluation traditions common
with the bank included, client fulfillment questionnaires and the adoption of ICT. Hieu
and Nwachukwu (2019) summarized the strategy evaluation process and strategic
traditions as well as their role towards strategy implementation. The analysis explored
strategy evaluation process and strategic performance of mobile TELCOs within the
Nigerian market. It offered new knowledge on the impact of strategy evaluation process
towards the results of TELCOs in a young economy such like that of Nigeria. The results
reveal that TELCOs embrace a systematic manner to strategy evaluation bearing a major
Hieu and Nwachukwu (2019) summarized the strategy evaluation process and strategic
traditions as well as their role towards strategy implementation. The analysis explored
strategy evaluation process and strategic performance of mobile TELCOs within the
Nigerian market. It offered new knowledge on the impact of strategy evaluation process
towards the results of TELCOs in a young economy such like that of Nigeria. The results
reveal that TELCOs embrace a systematic manner to strategy evaluation bearing a major
banking industry in Nigeria. Furthermore, Auka and Langat (2016) studied the
78
relationship between performance of medium-sized enterprises and strategic planning.
However, there was a weak association. Empirical evidence, reveal that strategy
Njeru (2015) assessed the relationship between organization performance and strategic
organizational performance. A cross-section regard design was adopted in the study. The
However, the study considered SMEs, while present study focuses on state owned
parastatals.
5.3 Conclusions
with objective one setting out to explore the impact of environmental scanning towards
the organizational results of profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya; the
termination was environmental scanning had a positive impact towards the results of
The intention of the second objective was to establish the impact strategy development
has towards the organizational results of profit making parastatals in Nairobi County,
Kenya. Deductions from the analysis of data revealed strategy development impacted
results. Thus the investigator shows and comes to a conclusion that strategy development
had a positive influence towards the results of the profit making parastatals in Nairobi
County, Kenya.
79
Strategy Implementation and Organization Performance
The third objective intended to determine the impact strategy adoption has towards
organizational results of profit making parastatals in Nairobi County, Kenya. There was
management failing mainly during the implementation stage. The finding from the
parastatals. Thus there was a termination from a statistical point that strategy adoption
The intention of the last objective was to determine the impact of strategy
Nairobi County, Kenya. from analysis of the collected data, it was deduced that strategy
5.4 Recommendations
From the review, there is a proposal that in the processes of strategy development, these
profit making parastatal sought to include every crucial player internally and externally in
order to develop some feeling of ownership in the determinations reached at. additionally,
these institutions ought to carry out assessment of institutional and frequent monitoring
80
it is desirable that profit making parastatal establish sound and solid strategic master
plans properly articulated to the entire workforce. also, it is important that the workforce
is involved during the adoption process of strategies, enabling the institution secure long-
term preparedness and equally gain some edge over rivals in the sector.
it is also recommended that these profit making parastatal sought to utilize the feedback
from junior leaderships as well as heads of groups during the creation of strategy in order
to ensure the strategies report positive results and align with the entire goal of the
institution.
Lastly, there is a proposal that the profit making institutions ought to assess their strategic
desires and that the assessment ought to be done regularly since it enables the setting of
results, it failed in coming up with the ideal level an institution ought to utilize them.
Equally, the review failed to develop a manner of integrating the varied dimensions of
strategic management enablers’ mix. based on the above profile, the study proposes
studies to determine the ideal level or the strategic management enablers’ index for the
81
REFERENCES
AlDhaheri, F., Ameen, A.,& Isaac, O. (2020). The Influence of Strategy Formulation
(Vision, Mission, and Goals) on the Organizational Operations. Journal of critic
reviews 7(17). 1932-1943. https://doi.org/10.31838/jcr.07.17.240.
Andrews, R., Boyne, G., Law, J., &Walker, R. (2011) Strategy Implementation and
Public Service Performance. Administration and Society, 43(6) 643-
671https://doi.org/10.1177/0095399711412730.
Ansoff, H.I, Daniel, K, A.O. Lewis, Roxanne, H, &Rick, A. (2018). Implanting Strategic
Management, Springer. https://books.google.co.ke/books/.
82
Arasa, R., &K'Obonyo, P. (2012). The relationship between strategic planning and firm
performance. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 2(22), 201-
213.http://www.ijhssnet.com/journals/.
Asser, J. H., Waiganjo, E., &Njeru, A. (2018). Influence of dynamic environmental scan
practices on performance of commercial based state parastatals in Kenya, The
Strategic Journal of Business & ChangeManagement,5(3), 555-581,
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/525c/298b25b6a635ae2670833a6c7e401e083bdc
.pdf
Ate, D.O (2018). Implementation of expansion strategy at KCB group public limited
company, Kenya.[Master’s Thesis,University of Nairobi].
http://erepository.uonbi.ac.ke/bitstream/handle/11295/105026/
Auka, D.O. & Langat, J.C. (2016). Effects of Strategic Planning on Performance of
Medium Sized Enterprises in Nakuru Town. International Review of Management
and Business Research, 5(1), 188-
203.https://www.irmbrjournal.com/papers/1455102998.pdf
Azahari, R., M. Z., Mustafa, M., &Yusoff, R. Z. (2021). Strategic Planning and
Organizational Performance in the Public Sector: A Study of Local Government
in Aceh, Indonesia. The Social Sciences, 8(7), 902-
906.https://doi.org/10.13106/jafeb.2021.vol8.no7.0557
Barney, F. (1995). Strategic Positioning and Organizational Performance of the Top Five
Oil Companies in Kenya. [Unpublished Master’s Thesis,], University of Nairobi.
Cancellier, L.G., Junior, B.L., &Rossetto, C.R. (2014). Interaction between the
organizational strategy and the environment of small companies in Brazil,
JISTEM Journal of Information System. Technology. Management. 11 (3),17-22
,http://dx.doi.org/10.4301/S1807-17752014000300006.
83
Chepkwony, E. C. (2016). Influence of strategy implementation, evaluation and control
on organization performance at the Office of the Auditor General. [Unpublished
Master’s Thesis], University of Nairobi, Kenya.
Chijioke, N., Vu, H.M., &Olatunji, F. (2018). Influence of strategy formulation drivers
on strategic performance. Ekonomicko-manazerskespektrum.12(2), 15-
25.dx.doi.org/10.26552/ems.2018.2.15-25.
Dabara, D. I., Anthony, A. I., Gbenga, O. A. &Adeyanju, O. (2014). Decision Theory and
its Relevance to Real Estate Development Decisions. British Journal of
Economics, Management & Trade 4(12), 1861-
1869.http://www.strategicjournals.com/index.php/journal/article/view/2052
Glanz, K., B. K. Rimer, K. &Viswanath J. (2008). Health behavior and health education:
Theory, research, and practice. (4th ed). Wiley.
Hill, C. W., Jones, G. R., & Schilling, M. A. (2013). Strategic management: theory: an
integrated approach. Cengage Learning.
Hooley, G., Cox, T., Shipley, D., Fahy, J., Beracs, J., &Kolos, K. (1996). Foreign Direct
Investment in Hungary: Resource Acquisition and Domestic Competitive
Advantage. Journal of International Business Studies, 27(4), 683–
709.https://www.jstor.org/stable/155508?seq=1.
84
Jenatabadi, H. S. (2015). An Overview of Organizational Performance Index:
Definitions and Measurements.International Journal of Business and
Management, 8(18), 1-10. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2599439
Jenster, P., &Søilen, K. S. (2013). The Relationship between Strategic Planning and
Company Performance – A Chinese perspective. Journal of Intelligence Studies
in Business, 3(1). 15-30.http://www.diva-
portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2%3A668897&dswid=8541
Johnson, G., & Scholes, K. (2003). Exploring corporate strategy: Text and cases.
Prentice Hall.
Kaplan, R., & Norton, D.P. (1993). Putting the balanced scorecard to work. Harvard
Business Review, 71, 134-142.DOI:10.1016/B978-0-7506-7009-8.50023-9
85
Lindqvist, C., &Mijovski, D. (2013). Does agency theory or stewardship theory apply to
the venture capitalist-entrepreneur relationship?[Master’s Thesis.
GoteborgsUniversitet, Handelshogskolan]. http://hdl.handle.net/2077/33255
Matula, P.D., Kyalo, D.N., Mulwa, A.S. &Gichuhi, L. W (2018). Academic Research
Proposal Writing: Principles, Concepts and Structure. ART Press.
Meier, K., O'Toole, L., Boyne, G., & Walker, R. (2007). Strategic management and the
performance of public organizations: Testing venerable ideas against recent
theories. Journal of public administration research and theory,17(3) 357-377.
http://jpart.oxfordjournals.org/content/17/3/357.full.pdf
86
Mohajan, H. (2017). Two Criteria for Good Measurements in Research: Validity and
Reliability. Annals of SpiruHaret University 17(4),56-82.https://mpra.ub.uni-
muenchen.de/83458/.
Nedelea, S., &Paun, L. A. (2009). The importance of the Strategic Management process
in the Knowledge-Based Economy. Review of International Comparative
Management, 10(1), 95-105.RePEc: rom: rmcimn: v:10: y:2009: i:1: p:95-105.
Nwachukwu, C., Vu, H., &Fadeyi, O., (2018). Influence of strategy formulation drivers
on strategic performance, Ekonomicko-manazerskespektrum. 12(1), 15-25.
10.26552/ems.2018.2.15-25.
87
Odhiambo, l. (2015). Strategy implementation and performance of major tea factories in
Kericho County, Kenya. [Masters Thesis University of
Nairobi].http://erepository.uonbi.ac.ke/bitstream/handle/11295/93376/
Ogollah, K., Bolo, Z.A., &Ogutu, M. (2011). Strategy structure environment linkage and
corporate performance: A conceptual view. Prime Journals, 1(3), 101-
113.https://profiles.uonbi.ac.ke/kogollah/files/ogollah_et_al.pdf_-
_strategy_structure_environment_linkage4.pdf
Parmigiani, G., & Inoue, L. (2009).Decision theory: principles and approaches (Vol.
812). John Wiley & Sons.
88
Pearce, J.A. & Robinson, R.B. (2008). Strategic management formulation,
implementation and control, McGraw – Hill/Irwin.
Pourmohammadi, K., Bastani, P., Shojaei, P., Hatam, N., &Salehi, A. (2020). A
comprehensive environmental scanning and strategic analysis of Iranian Public
Hospitals: a prospective approach. BMC research notes, 13(1), 179-181.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s13104-020-05002-8.
Preskill, H., & Mack, K. (2013). Building a Strategic Learning and Evaluation System
for Your Organization,Foundation Strategy Group (FSG)
http://www.fsg.org/tabid/191/ArticleId/946/Default.aspx?srpush=true.
Saqib, S., & Rashid, S. (2013). Resource Based View of the Firm: The Nature of
Resources Required for Competitive Advantage. International Journal of
Management & Organizational Studies, 2(1). 92-
95https://www.iprjb.org/journals/index.php/IJSCM/article/view/1083
89
Somi, L. A. (2017). Influence of strategy implementation on performance of government
owned entities in Kenya. [Unpublished Master’s Thesis].United States
International University-Africa, Kenya.
Theodore H. P, Lauren, H, E., Obed, Q. P.,& Jason E(2013) Strategy Formulation and
Performance, Public Performance & Management Review, 36(4), 585-
615, DOI: 10.2753/PMR1530-9576360405
Thompson, A., & Strickland, A. (1999). Strategic Management: Concepts and cases.
McGraw Hill.
http://ir-library.ku.ac.ke/handle/123456789/7301.
Wheelan, T. & Hunger, D. (2002). Strategic management and policy (4thed.). Addison -
Wesley publishing company.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2014.04.010.
90
APPENDICES
APPENDIX I: QUESTIONNAIRE
The information provided will be only for academic purpose. Read carefully and give
appropriate answers by ticking or filling the blank spaces. The information will be
treated confident
2. By use of a tick ( ), please indicate the age category that applies for you.
a) Below 30 years [ ]
b) 30 – 34 years [ ]
c) 35 – 39 years [ ]
d) 40 – 44 years [ ]
e) 45 years and above [ ]
3. Working experience
5 years and below [ ]
6- 10 years [ ]
11-15 years [ ]
16- 20 years [ ]
21 years and over [ ]
4. Highest level of education
Diploma [ ]
Undergraduate [ ]
Masters [ ]
PHD [ ]
91
SECTION A: ENVIRONMENTAL SCANNING
Environmental scanning 1 2 3 4 5
Dynamic environment affects commercial based parastatal performance
Hostile environment affects commercial based state parastatal
performance
Competitive intensity affects commercial based state parastatal
performance
The commercial based state parastatals takes into consideration
dynamic environment
The commercial based state parastatal takes into consideration of
heterogeneity
In the dynamic environment prices of products and changes in taxes
6. To what extent do you agree with the following statements on influence of strategy
formulation on organization performance? Key: 5 strongly agrees, 4 agree, 3 undecided,
2 disagree, 1 strongly disagree (please put an X as appropriate).
Strategy formulation 1 2 3 4 5
The managers are actively involved in creating company mission and
vision
The managers act as change enabler or drivers in the company
The managers are actively involved in making major decisions during
the strategy formulation
Our organization uses an operating budget which summarizes how
managers are supposed to use company resources
Our organization has aligned its budget with the company strategy
through good communication, enhanced responsibility, and improved
feedback flows
Our organization always makes decisions that are based on the budget
92
The strategic decisions of this company are based on the prevailing
business environment context
Strategy Implementation 1 2 3 4 5
This company engages in a more democratic and participative way of
working by allowing employees to offer views and involving employees
more in making organizational decisions
All employees in our organization align their regular tasks with the overall
company strategy
93
SECTION D: STRATEGY EVALUATION
5. To what extent do you agree with the following statements on influence of strategy
evaluation on organization performance. Key: 5 strongly agree, 4 agree, 3 undecided, 2
disagree, 1 strongly disagree (please put an X as appropriate).
Strategy evaluation 1 2 3 4 5
Our organization regularly analyses its INTERNAL capabilities to
determine its strengths and weaknesses using tools of analysis such as
SWOT, PESTEL and Porter’s Five Factor
Our organization regularly analyses its EXTERNAL environment to
determine its opportunities and threats using tools of analysis such as
SWOT, PESTEL and Porter’s Five Factor
Our organization emphasizes on market research focused on entering
new markets
The managers of our organization make allowances for the
unpredictable future and dynamic business environment in the strategic
plan.
Our organization has in place strategies that are used to cope with
unforeseen circumstances in the business industry
Our organization has appropriate technology that helps manage the
changing business climates
11. To what extent do you agree with the following statements on organization
performance? Key: 5 strongly agrees, 4 agree, 3 undecided, 2 disagree, 1 strongly
disagree (please put an X as appropriate).
Organization Performance 1 2 3 4 5
The number of employees has increased over the last five years
94
APPENDIX II: A LIST OF COMMERCIAL BASED PARASTATALS INKENYA
1. New Kenya Co-operative Creameries
95
25. Kenyatta International Conference Centre
96
APPENDIX III: RESEARCH PERMIT
97
APPENDIX IV: RESEARCH LICENSE
98
THE SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION ACT, 2013
The Grant of Research Licenses is Guided by the Science, Technology and Innovation (Research Licensing)
Regulations, 2014
CONDITIONS
1. The License is valid for the proposed research, location and specified period
2. The License any rights thereunder are non-transferable
3. The Licensee shall inform the relevant County Director of Education, County Commissioner and
County Governor before commencement of the research
4. Excavation, filming and collection of specimens are subject to further necessary clearence from relevant
Government Agencies
5. The License does not give authority to tranfer research materials
6. NACOSTI may monitor and evaluate the licensed research project
7. The Licensee shall submit one hard copy and upload a soft copy of their final report (thesis) within one year
of completion of the research
8. NACOSTI reserves the right to modify the conditions of the License including cancellation without prior
notice
99