7435-Article Text-26912-1-10-20230907
7435-Article Text-26912-1-10-20230907
7435-Article Text-26912-1-10-20230907
Abstract
The purpose of this research was to study the relationship between entrepreneurial
orientation, innovation and financial performance, through the mediating role of absorptive
capacity and technological innovation capability. The study used a quantitative research
method to collect data via questionnaire from the executive officers of 156 startup
organizations in Thailand. Respondents were selected using a simple random sampling method
and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The results demonstrate that entrepreneurship
orientation is a variable directly and significantly correlated with innovation and financial
performance. However, it was found that entrepreneurship orientation does not correlate
indirectly with innovation or financial performance via the mediation of absorptive capacity
and technological innovation capacity. The results of the study can enable startup businesses in
Thailand to create and pay attention to the behavior of entrepreneurship orientation to improve
the organization’s innovation and financial performance.
1
Ms. Sirinthra Sungthong is currently working as a lecturer in the Faculty of Management Sciences, Phuket
Rajabhat University, Phuket, Thailand. She obtained a M.B.A. in General Management of Ramkhamhaeng
University, Thailand. She also is a Ph.D. Candidate of the Graduate Study in Innovation Management and
Business Development Program, Walailak University, Thailand.
2*
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Somnuk Aujirapongpan (corresponding author) is currently working as a lecturer in the
School of Accountancy and Finance, Walailak University, Thailand. He obtained a Ph.D. in Technopreneurship
and Innovation Management from Chulalongkorn University, Thailand. Email: asomnuk@wu.ac.th
3
Dr. Kanokwan Meesook is currently working as a lecturer in the School of Accountancy and Finance,
Walailak University, Thailand. She obtained a Ph.D. in Regional and Rural Development Planning from Asian
Institute of Technology, Thailand.
includes the capacity to be aware of the needs through marketing and technology (Sarsah et
of both the market and customers, and to meet al., 2020). The second dimension is the
those needs through innovation (Mohd Noor realized absorptive capability involving
et al., 2017). This capacity is an important knowledge transformation and exploitation,
feature in shaping organizational growth and making changes in products and production
adaptation to environmental changes (Covin (Sarsah et al., 2020). Hence, it can be
and Miller, 2014; Lumpkin and Dess, 1996). concluded that absorptive capacity is
It is a key feature in shaping organizational composed of the following four components.
growth and adaptation to environmental Firstly, acquisition shows the ability of the
changes (Covin and Miller, 2014; Lumpkin company to identify and acquire external
and Dess, 1996) by inventing a variety of knowledge which is important to the company
innovations and enhancing the organization’s (Lau and Lo, 2019). Secondly, assimilation
capacities to respond to environmental fluctu- represents the ability to interpret, analyze and
ations (Nguyen et al., 2021). Entrepreneurial understand external knowledge (Engelen et
orientation is therefore considered as a strate- al., 2014). Thirdly, transformation improves
gic resource of the organization in increasing company practices in order to promote the
the efficiency of finance and innovation fusion of existing and new knowledge to
(Usman and Mat, 2017; Tang et al., 2015). develop a new business model based on the
Thus, the first hypothesis of the study is new knowledge set (Makhloufi et al., 2021).
presented as follows: Finally, exploitation illustrates the ability
Hypotheses 1 (H1): Entrepreneurial needed to take advantage of the knowledge set
orientation positively affects innovation and for commercial goals.
financial performance. The nature of entrepreneurial orientation
encourages organizations to consider new
Absorptive Capacity (AC) ideas, engage in creative investments, accept
high risks, and work proactively (Aljanabi,
In the face of a highly dynamic business 2017). It also supports the absorptive capacity
environment, organizations are not only of the organization to acquire external
building their own knowledge within the knowledge (Aljanabi, 2017). Entrepreneurial
organization, but also absorbing external orientation may be more effective if the
knowledge to foster innovation and improve organization has knowledge acquisition and
productivity (Lau and Lo, 2019). Absorptive exploitation capabilities to increase its inno-
capacity is a dynamic ability embedded in vation capabilities (Sciascia et al., 2014).
organizational practices and culture. It is the Meanwhile, the absorptive capability acts as a
capacity to produce and use the knowledge mechanism to acquire and assimilate only
required to develop other competences, such relevant and necessary knowledge, with that
as production, sales, and marketing (Zahra knowledge then transformed into valuable
and George, 2002). outputs (Hodgkinson et al., 2012). Especially
Numerous previous studies have in startup businesses, which are characterized
classified absorptive capacity as a cognitive by starting the business from a small point but
ability (Andersén, 2012; Andersén and Kask, a capacity to grow rapidly, or gradually, while
2012; Martinkenaite, 2012; Tseng et al., also being a business which arises from ideas
2011). The absorption and use of external to solve everyday problems. A startup busi-
knowledge (Aljanabi, 2017) as described by ness can also arise from seeing business
Zahra and George (2002) divided the opportunities that no one has ever thought of
structure of absorbency into two dimensions. or implemented before (The Stock Exchange
The first dimension represents the potential of Thailand, 2016). Absorption capability
absorptive capability related to knowledge plays a crucial role as a startup business
acquisition and assimilation in order to requires external research and instruction
distribute that knowledge to the company from customers, competitors and stakeholders
Exploring the Relationship Between Entrepreneurial Orientation, Innovation and Financial Performance
Absorptive
Capacity
Innovation and
Entrepreneurial Financial
Orientation Performance
Technological
Innovation
Capability
Also, some studies revealed that technologi- under the condition of determining the
cal innovation has positive impacts, since it minimum sample size for the structural
can improve competitiveness, financial effi- equation model analysis of Hair et al. (2010)
ciency and innovation (Rahim and with latent variables of less than or equal to 7,
Zainuddin,2016). This leads to the third and each latent variable being measured from
hypothesis as follows. more than 3 observed variables, states a mini-
Hypotheses 3 (H3): Technological inno- mum sample size of 150. Data collection from
vation capability mediates the relationship a sample of the study population involved
between entrepreneurial orientation and surveying corporate executives using a simple
innovation and financial performance. random sampling method. For this, a random-
ized table of numbers that listed the entire
Based on theoretical review and hypoth- population was used. Data collection for this
esis development, the study has a research study was conducted with a complete sample
framework as shown in Figure 1. of 156 organizations, meeting the minimum
sample size specified.
METHODOLOGY
Survey Instrument
Sample and Data Collection
The instrument used in this study was a
The sample used in this study was questionnaire derived from the literature
collected from a population of 467 Startup review which passed examination by experts
organizations in Thailand (Startup Thailand to determine the consistency index of the
Ecosystem, 2022). The recommended number questionnaire using the IOC (Index of Item
Exploring the Relationship Between Entrepreneurial Orientation, Innovation and Financial Performance
Objective Congruence) value. Part 1 of the analysis (CFA) to verify the validity of the
questionnaire dealt with the personal data of hypothesis test.
the respondents utilizing a single-choice Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) is a
answer form. Part 2 collected data relating to method of statistical analysis used to test a set
the features of Entrepreneurial Orientation of variables in a study to determine whether
which demonstrates behavior innovativeness, or not the causal relationship structure is as
risk taking, proactiveness, autonomy and defined in the assumed model. It is possible to
competitive aggressiveness. Part 3 collected examine multiple relationships at the same
data about the features of Absorptive Capacity time, while some variables in a structure may
which are characterized by acquisition, be both latent and observed variables, such
assimilation, transformation and exploitation. that researchers can answer research ques-
Part 4 of the questionnaire collected data tions, understand the purpose of the research,
about technological innovation capability, and apply statistics effectively. Therefore,
and process innovation capability. Techno- SEM is suitable for this study (Songsraboon,
logical innovation capability relates to 2018).
product innovation capability, the processes
used to differentiate a product, such as RESULTS
developing a new product and improving an
existing one. Meanwhile, process innovation Demographic and Descriptive Statistics
capability involves using production technol-
ogy to develop innovation capability. Part 4 The subjects in the study, as shown in
also considered the strategic use of these Table 1, consisted of 71.80% chief executive
technologies to promote new techniques, pro- officers and 29.20% business owners. The
cesses and methods in manufacturing. Part 5 majority of respondents were male (65.40%)
of the questionnaire collected data on the while only 34.60% were female. Around
variables affecting organizational perfor- 57.70% of respondents were between the ages
mance in the dimension of innovation and of 31 and 40, 38.50% were between the ages
financial performance. of 41 and 50, 3.20% were 30 years of age or
In part 2 – 5, the questionnaire utilized a less, and 0.60% were between the ages of 51
5-level Likert Scale, while the questionnaire’s and 60. The vast majority of the subjects ran
reliability was tested via the Internal Con- a startup company in the areas of AgriTech,
sistency Method and Cronbach’s Alpha FoodTech, Business Service, or Online
Coefficient. Marketing. However, a sizeable minority of
them, accounting for approximately 26.90%
Data Analysis of the total, ran a startup company in the areas
of IndustryTech, HealthTech, GovTech &
Analysis of part 1 of the questionnaire EdTech, PropertyTech & UrbanTech, or
involved descriptive statistics, including FinTech & TravelTech respectively. The
frequency and percentage, to analyze personal majority of the subjects had been in business
data of respondents. for 5 years or less (64.10%), while a smaller
Parts 2-5 of the questionnaire which used number had experience of 6-10 years
a Likert rating scale, were also analyzed via (32.70%), or 11-15 years (3.20%).
descriptive statistics, namely the mean and
standard deviation. Inferential statistics were Measurement Model
used to study the linear structural equation
model (SEM) via the M-Plus program accord- Confirmatory Factor Analysis was used
ing to the conceptual model which was in this study to evaluate the measurement
constructed with covariance-based SEM (CB- tools in order to reduce measurement errors.
SEM) to study the relationship between the In the present study, there were four key
variables by applying it to confirmatory factor factors: Entrepreneurial Orientation (EO),
Sirinthra Sungthong, Somnuk Aujirapongpan, and Kanokwan Meesook
Absorptive Capacity (AC), Technological four elements is shown in Table 2. There were
Innovation Capability (TIC) and Innovation five indicator questions relating to EO, AC,
and Financial Performance (IFP). The and IFR, and three indicator questions relating
measurement model was tested, and X2 = to IEP. The results show that the standard
222.359 with a determined p-value of less weight value of EO was between 0.540 and
than 0.001. The df value was 127, X2/df is 0.700, while the standard weight value of AC
1.75, while the acceptable range for X2/df is was between 0.500 and 0.967, the standard
between 1 and 3 (Hair et al., 2014, p. 668). weight value of TIC was between 0.766 and
Also, SRMR = 0.072, which was less than 0.915, and the standard weight value of IFP
0.08, was within the acceptable range was between 0.619 and 0.731. Cronbach’s
(Hensler et al., 2015). The CFI value was Alpha values ranged between 0.700 and
0.943, while the TLI value is 0.932, both of 0.920, all of which were not less than 0.700,
which were higher than 0.9 (Bollen, 2015). indicating that the variable has good
The index value of RMSEA = 0.069, precision. Construct Reliability (CR) values
indicating that the model corresponds to the were between 0.700 and 0.921, all of which
data, as this value should be between 0.03 and were not less than 0.700, indicating that all
0.08. It can be concluded that the model is indicator questions had good structural
consistent with the empirical data. reliability (Carmines & Zeller, 1988; Hair et
The confirmation factor analysis of the al., 2014).
Table 2 (continued)
The organization has a good mechanism for 0.915
technology transfer from research to product
development.
The organization has technological 0.849
capabilities that enable efficient
manufacturing of products/services.
Innovation and Financial Performance 4.209 0.406 0.700 0.700
(IFP)
Sales have consistently increased as a result of 0.632
new technological products and services or
improved products.
The profits have consistently increased as a 0.619
result of new technological products and
services or improved products.
The number of products/commercial services 0.731
have increased compared to the past 5 years.
The correlation test for all variables is Structural Equation Modelling (SEM)
shown in Table 3. At the .001 level, there was Results
a statistically significant relationship in the
same direction. Also, the values of the Direct Effect
Pearson correlation coefficient were between
0.334 and 0.492, all of which were less than The statical results, X2 = 223.209,
0.70, showing that there was no multicollin- p-value < 0.001, df = 128, X2/df = 1.74,
earity problem with the components. In SRMR = 0.075, CFI = 0.943, TLI = 0.932 and
addition, the verification of discriminant RMSEA = 0.069 were used to find the correla-
validity by comparing the √AVE value of each tion of the model and the empirical data. The
variable with the correlation coefficient of effects of entrepreneurial orientation and
other variables (Fornell &Larcker, 1981) innovation and financial performance were
shows that the √AVE values for all variables analyzed, and direct effects (DE) illustrated in
displayed in italics diagonally were higher Table 4. The results indicate that EO has a
than the correlation coefficients among the positive influence on IFP (= 0.529, p-value
variables. This indicates that indicator ques- 0.01); hence, Hypothesis 1 (H1) was
tions possessed discriminant validity, result- accepted. In addition, the findings show that
ing in the correlation of all variables and the EO also positively affects AC (β = 0.567,
empirical data, while they could also be said p-value < 0.001). However, AC and TIC did
to be reliable, valid and suitable to be used in not have any impact on IFP (β = 0.071, β
testing the hypotheses. = 0.053 respectively, p-value > 0.05). The
Exploring the Relationship Between Entrepreneurial Orientation, Innovation and Financial Performance
Agency (NIA), Office of The Permanent Sec- EO and IFP in startups in Thailand. This is
retary, and Digital Economy Promotion because the business sector still lacks an
Agency (DEPA), should establish policies to understanding of startups and is unaware of
promote the education system in Thailand in the importance of technological innovation.
line with the ever-evolving Startup business In developed countries, the structures of
context by supporting knowledge-building startups clearly rely on technology to find
activities such as training and the exchange of better solutions or new services for customers,
business experiences. Startups are always that are designed to be used without limits,
there to enable organizations to absorb and allowing the company to grow rapidly.
order new knowledge from outside, as well as However, in this study, it was found that EO
to build an understanding of the structure of directly affects TIC, where EO affects TIC by
the startup business that relies on technologi- 40.8%, This is because having entrepreneur-
cal advances. To recognize the importance of ship orientation provides the organization
TIC building to meet the changing needs of with opportunities to adapt itself to technolog-
the market, such as successful startups in ical change, develop new products, and use
developed countries. new technologies to respond to needs now and
The findings in this study also show that in the future (Aljanabi, 2017). As a result,
absorptive capacity does not function as a startups in Thailand must be aware of the use
mediator between EO and IFP in startup of technology and innovation in enhancing
businesses in Thailand. This can be explained business value to achieve business success
by the fact that the education system in (SME Bank, 2017).
Thailand is still not aligned with ongoing Although the findings in this study show
developments in business. Also, entrepre- that absorptive capacity and technological
neurs in Thailand do not absorb and instruct innovation capability do not mediate EO and
external knowledge to establish new business, IFP, the results confirm that both absorptive
which is a significant impediment that makes capacity and technological innovation
it difficult for startups to succeed. However, capability are dependent variables directly
the results in this study found that EO has affected by EO. Therefore, these findings can
direct effects on absorptive capacity, where be added to the academic concepts, and they
EO affects AC by 29.8%, reflecting that can be more fully implemented in startups. It
organizations with entrepreneurship orienta- can be concluded that entrepreneurship
tion will be able to better develop their orientation is a key part of an organization’s
absorptive capacity. This is because entrepre- ability to grow and adapt to new situations. It
neurship orientation is a strategy which leads is also a key strategic resource for increasing
an organization to proactively work when an innovation and financial performance. EO
opportunity arises, and it can be used also improves the organization’s ability to
creatively in business change, including absorb new knowledge from outside sources
managing risks and uncertainties, in order to and properly apply it to its existing
achieve organizational goals (Anderson and knowledge. EO not only helps the organiza-
Ronteau, 2017). With entrepreneurship orien- tion adapt itself to technological change, but
tation, an organization is able to anticipate the EO also encourages the organization to
demands of the market and customers and develop products and make use of new
respond to those needs by using new technological procedures to better meet the
innovations (Mohd Noor et al., 2017). Entre- needs of the market.
preneurship orientation is a strategy that
enhances the organization’s ability to better CONCLUSION
absorb new knowledge from outside (Cui et
al., 2018). In the present study, the correlations
Further, the findings of this study between entrepreneurship orientation, inno-
revealed that TIC does not mediate between vation and financial performance, absorptive
Exploring the Relationship Between Entrepreneurial Orientation, Innovation and Financial Performance
capacity, and technological innovation capa- population There were a total of 156 com-
bility, were tested. The relationships between pleted questionnaires utilized for analysis.
the antecedents that affect startup innovation According to the conditions for determining
and financial performance in Thailand were the minimum sample size for the analysis of
investigated using the correlations of direct the structural equation model (Hair et al.,
and indirect variables. The results demon- 2010), the minimum sample size was deemed
strate that entrepreneurship orientation is a to be 150. The obtained test was therefore in
variable directly and significantly correlated accordance with the specified minimum
with innovation and financial performance, sample size. However, the sample used as
absorptive capacity, and technological inno- data for the analysis may still be considered
vation capability. The findings in this study too small. Due to the limitation in the
also confirm that entrepreneurship orientation disclosure of startup information to third
helps the organization to increase innovation parties, many startups are quite concerned
and financial performance and gain, absorb, about maintaining business secrets. This may
and apply external knowledge to create new be a factor that causes the results of the study
internal knowledge. In addition, entrepreneur- to find that the variables are not related.
ship orientation gives the organization a Therefore, in future studies, researchers
technological innovation capability that should pay greater attention to clarifying
allows it to react to unanticipated technologi- reasons and benefits for collecting data for use
cal changes, create new products, and apply in studying startups and may focus on
new technological techniques to suit both studying other business organizations that can
present and future needs. disclose financial and management infor-
However, it was found that entrepreneur- mation to the public, such as those listed on
ship orientation does not have an indirect the stock exchange. This will allow the
correlation with innovation and financial researcher to obtain accurate and sufficient
performance, via the mediation of absorptive information for use in analyzing the study
capacity and technological innovation results.
capacity. This result did not support the
hypotheses. This can be explained by the fact ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
that entrepreneurship orientation enables the
organization to increase innovation and This research was approved by the
financial performance without relying on the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of the
acquisition, assimilation, and exploitation of human research ethics committee of Nakhon-
external knowledge. It also does not require ratchasima College (NMCEC-0012/2565).
the ability to adapt to unexpected technologi- Assoc. Prof. Dr. Somnuk Aujirapongpan is a
cal changes, develop new products, or use corresponding author in this article. Dr.
new technological procedures in order to meet Kanokwan Meesook is also a co-correspond-
market demands. ing author.