Chapter Five Grade 12
Chapter Five Grade 12
Chapter Five Grade 12
UNIT FIVE
5. ISSUES IN SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT III
CHALLENGES OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
5.1. Multiple faces of poverty and implication to development
5.1.1. Concepts of Poverty
Poverty is generally considered to be a measure of deficiency of the basic needs that a person,
household or community required to meet as a basic standard of living. This deficiency can be
measured either in terms of a lack of resources such as income, assets, capabilities (e.g. skills,
knowledge, technology or both). Basically, poverty could be divided into two much known
division; absolute and relative poverty.
Absolute poverty:- is when household income is below a certain level, which makes it
impossible for the person or family to meet basic needs of life including food, shelter, safe
drinking water, education, healthcare, etc.
In this state of poverty, even if the country is growing economically, it has no effect on people
living below the poverty line. Absolute poverty compares households based on a set of income
level and this level varies from country to country depending on its overall economic conditions.
Relative poverty: - is when households receive 50% less than average household incomes, so
they do have some money but still not enough money to afford anything above the basic need.
This type of poverty is, on the other hand, changeable depending on the economic growth of the
country.
Relative poverty is sometimes described as “relative deficiency” because the people
falling under this category are not living in total poverty, but they are not enjoying the
same standard of life as everyone else in the country. It can be expressed in terms of
having internet, clean clothes, a safe home (a healthy environment, free from abuse or
neglect), or even education.
Relative poverty can also be permanent, meaning that certain families have absolutely no
chance of enjoying the same standards of living as other people in the same society
currently have access to. They are basically “trapped” in a low relative income box.
When the relative approach is used to measure poverty, there is another concept that needs to be
explored, namely, persistent poverty. This is when households receive 50 or 60% less income
than average incomes every 2 out of 3 years. Since long-term poverty has more impactful
consequences on economic and social conditions, persistent poverty is an important concept to
bear in mind. There are also other measures of the dimensions of poverty and their indicators
used in different researches works (Table 5.1).
[1]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
[2]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
[3]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
Therefore, a sole focus on destruction, poverty and people as victims provides only a partial
reading of war. But it has outlined the political, economic and social dimensions of conflict
which are likely to have an impact on chronic poverty. Moreover, the protracted, collapsed-state
conflicts are likely to lead to intergenerational exclusion and chronic poverty.
[4]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
Globalization, thus, has many benefits and disadvantages and they are here to stay. Basically, the
developed world has benefited from globalization, as they can sell more goods and products to
on the global South.
5.2.2. Globalization and Developing Countries
Globalization in the developing countries is manifested in the following three important fields
such as economic and trade processes, education and health systems and culture effects.
Economic and Trade Processes Field: Globalization helps developing countries to deal with the
rest of the world to increase their economic growth, solving the poverty problems in their
country. In the past, developing countries were not able to tap on the world economy due to trade
barriers. They cannot share the same economic growth that developed countries had. However,
with globalization the World Bank and International Management encourage developing
countries to go through market reforms and radical changes through large loans. Many
developing nations began to take steps to open their markets by removing tariffs and free up their
economies. The developed countries were able to invest in the developing nations, creating job
opportunities for the people. For example, rapid growth in India and China has caused world
poverty to decrease. However, countries in Africa still have the highest poverty rates, in fact, the
rural areas of China which do not tap on global markets also suffer greatly from such high
poverty. On the other hand, developed countries set up their companies and industries to the
developing nations to take advantages of low wages and this causing pollution in countries with
poor regulation of pollution. Furthermore, setting up companies and factories in the developing
nations by developed countries affect badly to the economy of the developed countries and
increase unemployment.
Education and Health Systems: Globalization contributed to develop the health and education
systems in the developing countries. We can clearly see that education has increased in recent
years, because globalization has a catalyst to the jobs that require higher skills set. This demand
allowed people to gain higher education. Health and education are basic objectives to improve
any nations, and there are strong relationships between economic growth and health and
education systems.
Through growth in economic, living standards and life expectancy for the developing nations
certainly get better. With more fortunes poor nations are able to supply good health care services
and sanitation to their people. In addition, the government of developing countries can provide
more money for health and education to the poor, which led to decrease the rates of illiteracy.
This is seen in many developing countries whose illiteracy rate fell down recently. It is truth that,
living standards and life expectancy of developing countries increase through economic gains
from globalization. An important drawback of globalization is, globalized competition has forced
many minds skilled workers where highly educated and qualified professionals, such as
scientists, doctors, engineers and IT specialists, migrate to developed countries to benefit from
the higher wages and greater lifestyle prospects for themselves and their children. This leads to
decrease skills labor in the developing countries.
[5]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
Culture Effects: Globalization affected the developing countries culture in various ways. Not
few cultural traits have been enormously changed through globalization, as the people are simply
imitating others cultures like America and European countries. On the other hand, many
developing countries extreme dependence and emphasis to globalization might lead to destroying
of their own culture, tradition, identity, customs and even their languages. It was witnessed in
some Arab countries (Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Jordan) their cultures have been affected
negatively. A kind of clothes they wear and a sort behavior they show are totally changed.
Furthermore, globalization leads to disappearance of many words and expressions from local
languages because many people use English and French words. In addition, great changes have
taken place in the family life, young people are trying to leave their families and live alone when
they get 18 years old. As a result, the extended family tends to become smaller than before.
These kinds of changes are also observed in many urban areas of Ethiopia. Figure 5.2 shows the
main actors, processes they follow and benefits of globalization.
5.2.3. Advantages of Globalization
1. Globalization increases free trade: Globalization has increased the free trade between
countries. The increased capital liquidity has allowed investors in well developed nations to
invest in developing countries. Huge corporations from developed nations have great flexibility
to operate in other countries.
2. Global mass media ties the world together: The increased flow of communication has
allowed global mass media to tie the world together. Besides, global mass media has allowed
vital information to be shared between corporations and individuals around the world.
Globalization has also contributed to greater speed and ease of transporting goods and people.
3. Eradicates Cultural Barriers: Countries joining together economically, through politics and
education have reduced and can even eradicate cultural barriers, and increase the global village
effect. Globalization has proven to be the medium for the spread of democratic ideals to well
developed nations and greater independence to developing countries in the Global South.
4. Reduction of War: Reduction of war between well developed nations is probably one of the
primary benefits of globalization.
The following is a list of benefit that could be gained from globalization, both by the countries of
global south and north.
Increased free trade between nations,
Increased liquidity of capital allowing investors in developed nations to invest in
developing nations,
Corporations have greater flexibility to operate across borders,
Global mass media ties the world together,
Increased flow of communications allows vital information to be shared between
individuals and corporations around the world,
Greater ease and speed of transportation of goods and people,
Reduction of cultural barriers increases the global village effect,
[6]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
[7]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
The idea of inequality is both very simple and very complex. At one level it is the simplest of all
ideas and has moved people with an immediate appeal hardly matched by any other concept. At
the same time, is a very complex notion that has been the subject of much research outputs by
philosophers, statisticians, political theorists, sociologists and economists. From the ancient
period to the present, theories have seen trade as a key instrument in determining the trend of
regional and country economic inequality. Both the convergence and divergence hypotheses take
it into account with their distinct assumptions and methodologies. The available evidence on
trends in global economic inequality comes mainly from two types of studies. Studies of the first
type have been concerned with empirically testing the catching up or convergence hypothesis.
This states that less developed countries and regions should be expected to grow faster than more
developed ones.
The hypothesis clearly refers to what we have called inter-country inequality and proposes that
we should expect this to decline over time. Three main arguments have been advanced in support
of the hypothesis.
First, the latecomers into the world of modern economic growth enjoy an advantage
because they can simply adopt and exploit technologies, which the pioneers had to
develop through their own efforts.
Second, assumption reflects there are diminishing returns to inputs factor. This implies
less developed economies have an advantage of low production cost because of low labor
wage and the price of other factor input. Thus, for equivalent rates of investment, the less
developed economies should be able to achieve higher growth.
Third, the shift of large amounts of labor from farm to industry boosts labor productivity
in general. The importance of this source of productivity growth, however, declines with
development as productivity tends to equalize across sectors and activities, and fewer and
fewer workers remain in low-productivity
Nevertheless, widening income inequality is the defining challenge of our time. In advanced
economies, the gap between the rich and poor is at its highest level in decades. Inequality trends
have been more mixed in emerging markets and developing countries. Thus, the Second view
investigates the divergent trends in inequality developments across advanced economies and
developing countries, with a particular focus on the poor and the middle class. The pro-divergent
notion primarily highlighted the rationale for this divergence as the countries' current experience.
They practically demonstrate a diverging pattern of inequality. The following are some of the
evidences that support the greater divergent pattern of inequality.
Inequality has been exacerbated by technological development and the associated
increase in skill, as well as the collapse of various labor market institutions in both
advanced economies and developing countries.
The growing skill premiums are related with expanding income inequalities in advanced
nations, whereas financial deepening is associated with rising inequality in developing
countries.
5.3.2. Cause and effect of trade imbalance
[8]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
An important indicator of regional and national inequality is measuring the trade balance. A trade
imbalance occurs when the cost of a country's imports exceeds the cost of its exports. It is one
approach to measure international commerce, and it's also known as a negative trade balance. A
country's trade deficit may be calculated by subtracting the entire value of its exports from the
total value of its imports. The major causes and effect of this imbalance are stated below.
Causes: A trade imbalance happens when a country does not produce what it requires and must
borrow from other countries to pay for imports. This is referred to as a current account deficit. A
trade deficit also occurs when companies manufacture goods in other countries. The raw
materials for manufacturing that are shipped overseas for factory production count as an export.
The finished manufactured goods are counted as imports when they're shipped back to the
country. The imports are subtracted from the country's gross domestic product even though the
earnings may benefit the company's stock price, and the taxes may increase the country's revenue
stream.
Effects: A trade can enhance a country's standard of living since citizens can access a broader
range of goods and services at a lower cost. It can also reduce the threat of inflation since it
creates lower prices. However, a trade imbalance may result in more job outsourcing to foreign
countries over time. As a country imports more goods than it buys domestically, then the home
country may create fewer jobs in certain industries. At the same time, foreign companies will
likely hire new workers to keep up with the demand for their exports.
[9]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
capita income. Inequalities in non-income dimensions of welfare are also high, particularly
between men and women and between regions, and have remained persistent over time.
Furthermore, although income inequalities are typically more of an urban phenomenon, asset
based and capability-based inequalities in fact tend to be higher in rural than urban areas. In
countries where there is a significant initial income difference, economic growth is less effective
at alleviating poverty. Economic expansion and inequality reduction must go hand in hand to
significantly reduce poverty. Figure 5.3, which is based on data from the World Bank gathered
between 2011 and 2018, shows the level of inequality in a chosen number of sub-Saharan
African countries. According to the data, a country's index value rises when levels of economic
disparity among its citizens’ decline.
Take for example; countries like S. Africa and Guinea as cases, the inequality that exists in these
countries. A Gini coefficient of 0 reflects perfect equality, where all income or wealth values are
the same, while a Gini coefficient of 1 (or 100%) reflects maximal inequality among values
5.3.4. The Widening current global imbalance
Measures of inequality based on GINI coefficients of gross and net incomes have increased
substantially since 1990 in most of the developed world (see figure 5.8). Inequality, on average,
has remained stable in developing countries, although at a much higher level than observed in
advanced economies. However, there are large disparities across developing countries, with Asia
and Eastern Europe experiencing marked increases in inequality, and countries in Latin America
exhibiting notable declines (although the region remains the most unequal in the world).
During 1990–2012, market income inequality in advanced economies increased by an average of
50 GINI points compared to a 3 GINI point increase in the net GINI coefficient.
5.4. Corruption
5.4.1. The Concept of Corruption
Currently critical geography examines corruption as an objective collection of deviant actions
predominantly affecting states, particularly in the Global South. It also illustrates how corruption
explanations get politicized and interrelated with material, and geographical power regimes. For
instance, urban informality is regarded as a significant linked issue in both the North and South.
The term corruption involves a wide range of behaviors differing in their causes and effects in
different spatiotemporal contexts. Corruption may be defined in different ways, occurs in
varying levels of severity, and takes various forms in time and space, depending on local political
cultures and institutional frameworks. There is no one single definition of corruption that can be
applied to all circumstances, for example, corruption can be petty or large-scale, systemic or
occasional, implicit or explicit, committed by individuals. Similarly, corruption defined as the
abuse of entrusted power for private gain. It also more commonly defined as evil, a disastrous
personal failing. Legally, however, judicial systems punish acts, not character. In this view,
corruption is a source of injustice and inequality. Corruption is simultaneously a political,
economic, legal, and moral phenomenon. The relationship between corruption and economic
growth has been debated. Many studies have found evidence that corruption has harmful effects
[10]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
on economic growth. Corruption shows a negative correlation with economic growth after
controlling for institutional efficiency. Furthermore, corruption causes uncertainty for investors
and raises investment risk in nations with high levels of corruption.
5.4.2. Types of corruption
Corruption can be categorized in various dimensions to facilitate the understanding of how
corruption affects economic performance. The concept includes three broad categories of human
action; bribery, theft of public assets, and patronage.
Bribery is the most familiar among corrupt processes. It consists of payments by individuals or
firms to public officials in order to influence administrative decisions under their responsibility.
Bribery covers a wide range of administrative decisions, determined by the scope of government
regulations and activity. It frequently overlaps with the other two corruption categories through
the collusion of briber and bribe.
Theft of public assets can occur as unilateral embezzlement by public officials or through the
collusion of public officials and private agents. Apart from the illegal transfer of real or financial
public assets at below-market prices, it includes evasion of taxes and other legal payments to the
public sector, as well as diversion of public funds from their intended use into private pockets.
Corruption in the form of patronage (sometimes called favoritism, nepotism, clienteles)
consists of the preferential treatment of firms and/or individuals by public officials regarding the
compliance with government rules for the allocation of government contracts or transfer
payments. The private sector counterpart consists of “special favors” in the form of financial
rewards or professional opportunities granted to the public official involved.
Another distinction is that an act of corruption, which can be characterized by the value of the
transaction concerned. Although this is a continuous variable, the analytical distinction usually
made is between low value (“petty”) and large value (“grand”) corruption. Typically, the larger
the value of the corrupt transaction, the higher the position in the public hierarchy of the public
official(s) involved.
Various combinations of the characteristics detailed above have given rise to specific types of
corruption. Thus, systematic theft at a grand scale by high public officials is called
“kleptocracy”, while systematic patronage with large stakes has been labelled “crony capitalism”
or “government capture”. “Kick-backs” describe acts of bribery that involve theft of public assets
or patronage.
5.4.3. Geography of Corruption
Corruption has got a geographical essence because social processes are always distributed
unevenly across space. The causes, nature, and consequences of corruption differ from place to
place, depending on the context of historical, cultural, legal and political organization. The
incidence of corruption is difficult to determine empirically because its committers are often
adept at keeping it hidden.
[11]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
Analyses of corruption in different regional contexts rely heavily on the corruption indicator of
Transparency International, which is a global nongovernmental organization dedicated to
monitoring and combatting public and private sector corruption.
The group is involved in a variety of tangled activities, including measuring corruption, exposing
inexcusable cases, offering advice to companies to minimize corruption, and developing tools for
combatting it. The organizations produce annual corruption report with Corruption Perceptions
Index (CPI) of government misconduct, issued since 1995. The CPI is a composite
indicator based on surveys and interviews with public and private sector officials in each country
and expert assessments by 13 sources, including the different global, regional and national
organizations. A minimum of three of these units contributed to the assessment of corruption in
each country. Scores were normalized on an ordinal scale of zero (most corrupt) to 100 (least
corrupt).
Table 5.3 provides an overview of how the magnitude of corruption varies over the world. Only
a very small number of countries (including Canada, Singapore, Australia, and New Zealand)
have relatively uncorrupt governments, with CPI numbers of 80 or higher; however, this groups
comprises a minuscule 1.7% of the world’s population. A secondary tier of slightly corrupt states
(indices of 60–79), including several European countries, the United States, Japan, Botswana,
Israel, Taiwan, and the United Arab Emirates) includes an additional one eighth of the planet.
Moderately corrupt governments (scores of 40–59) include a diverse array of European, African,
Middle Eastern, and a few Asian states such as South Korea. By far the largest group almost
three-fourths of humanity consists of very corrupt governments: 82 states with scores ranging
between 20 and 39 account for more than 5.2 billion people. By this measure, corruption is the
norm in most societies in the world. Finally, a small group of 14 states with scores below 20 may
be said to be extremely corrupt; this group includes “failed states” such as Somalia, Afghanistan,
and Yemen, which are incapable of delivering basic public services as well as several with long
histories of extreme poverty (Haiti), war (Iraq), and totalitarian governments (Uzbekistan,
Turkmenistan, and North Korea). Fortunately, this group includes less than 2% of the world’s
population.
Table 5.3. The world’s population distribution by degree of state corruption, 2016
Level of corruption Corruption index Population % of world pop
(million)
[12]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
Types of Globalization
Financial globalization: It is the rise of a global economy with international monetary
exchanges. When a stock market faces a decline, it negatively influences other markets and the
economy as a whole.
Economic globalization: It is the evolution of trade systems inside transnational organizations
such as NGOs.
Cultural globalization: It is the interpenetration of world cultures that, as an outcome, involves
adopting national principles and beliefs of other countries by losing their originality.
Political globalization: It refers to the development of international organizations like the UN or
WHO and other bodies operating at a global level.
Technological globalization: It is the method that interconnected people worldwide due to the
power of the digital world.
Geographic globalization: It is the new organization of different areas of the world where it is
possible to travel the world without restrictions.
Sociological globalization: The interconnection of events and consequences results in cultural
diffusion and mixing of different societies.
Ecological globalization: It is the idea of viewing planet Earth as a singular global entity.
Advantages of Globalization
There are wide-ranging benefits to globalization. We are going to discuss the pros of
globalization below:
New Markets
Knowledge and Technology
Global Relations
Economic Growth
Risk Division
Choice and Competition
There are limits to, how a local business can grow. Globalization makes businesses enter various
new markets, giving them exponential growth. There are several factors to consider when
entering international markets. In modern globalization, e-commerce plays an important role.
Businesses can list their products on these platforms. E-commerce platforms have an immediate
display of a product, which is beneficial for the end user.
[13]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
[15]
FOR GRADE 12TH GEOGRAPHY CHAPTER FIVE CHAPTER FIVE
The world cannot abandon globalization. Despite the challenges, companies give priority to
learning a new culture and language, hiring local staff, and investing in their target country. By
taking these steps, companies earn a gigantic profit after managing all the risks. International
organizations play an important role in globalization. There are many advantages to
globalization. Still, it comes with consequences too. The internet turned the world into a global
village. So globalization cannot be stopped. It’s better to adapt and survive in this new world.
[16]