Surgery v10n3p95 en
Surgery v10n3p95 en
Surgery v10n3p95 en
1
Department of Internal Medicine and Clinical Pathology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Urmia University, Urmia,
Iran
2
Department of Medical Entomology and Vector Control, School of Public Health, Tehran University of Medical
Sciences, Tehran, Iran
3
Department of Clinical Science, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran
Corresponding Author:
Tel: +989141105054
Email: jvaderafinejad@gmail.com
Abstract
Introduction: Superficial cancers are one of the most common cancers in humans and animals. The use of maggot therapy as an
alternative treatment is expanding and has achieved great success in treating superficial. Maggot extracts and secretions have been
[ Downloaded from jsurgery.bums.ac.ir on 2024-07-03 ]
also demonstrated to have beneficial biological effects. The present study aimed to perform the first systematic review of the use of
maggot, as well as its secretions and extracts, in neoplasms.
Methods: In the current review study, online databases, such as Pub Med, Web of Science, Scopus, and Embase, were searched
to retrieve the published studies from 1985-2021. The used keywords were Maggot therapy, Larval therapy, Larval extract, Larval
secretions, Cancer, Neoplasm, and Tumor. Only research on the larvae of the order Diptera was included in the present study.
Results: Out of 387 screened papers, 9 articles met the proposed inclusion criteria. There were three articles on the use of maggot
debridement therapy in tumor lesions and six articles on the effect of maggot secretions and extract on neoplastic cells. Maggot
debridement therapy has been able to control the complications of skin tumors and breast cancer. Several studies have also reported
anti-tumor effects on larval extracts and secretions.
Conclusions: Maggots were able to improve the appearance of lesions and prevent further tumor growth that was progressing before
larval therapy. It seems that maggot therapy can be used to treat necrotic tumors; moreover, its extract and secretions can be used to
treat a wider range of cancers in humans and animals. Nonetheless, more studies are needed in non-progressive cancers to determine
the true effects of this method.
Citation: Ahmadnejad M, Rafinejad J, Tolouei M.Use of fly larva (Maggots) in Cancer Treatment: a systematic review.J Surg
Trauma.2022;10(3):95-102.
[ DOI: 10.32592/jsurgery.2022.10.3.101 ]
Received: December 30, 2021 Revised: March 19, 2022 Accepted: May 22, 2022
Ingenol mebutate (PEP005), and retinoids (Vitamin special centers in Iran for several years (14).
A analogs) are known as surface treatments used in The maggots have received the title of small
skin cancers (4). Moreover, malodorous and fungal nature surgeons by the debridement and removal of
lesions in advanced skin cancers are a challenge necrotic material (13). Maggots secrete substances
for medical staff. Surgical debridement, systemic that have antibiotic properties against Pseudomonas
antibiotics, and dressings are commonly used to aeruginosa, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus
treat this condition. However, the results are often aureus (15-16). In one experiment, the extract
unsatisfactory and, in some cases, contraindicated of L. sericata laurel was demonstrated to reduce
due to the possibility of bleeding and further tumor inflammatory mediators, such as IL-1β, IL-6,
invasion (5). Maggots (larvae) therapy can help TNF-α, and NFκB. In this study, the antioxidant
manage these complications. properties of larval extracts were proven by HO-
The larvae of flies (maggots) have long been used 1, SOD, GSH-Px, MPO, and MDA methods (17).
by the Mayan Indians, as well as some Spanish and Antiviral properties have also been exhibited for the
Greek tribes, for the treatment of human wounds. secretion and extract of Lucilia cuprina larvae (18).
The larvae were even used to heal soldiers' wounds In summary, maggots have the following therapeutic
during the Napoleonic Wars; nonetheless, with the properties: antibiotic, anti-biofilm, synergy with
[ DOI: 10.32592/jsurgery.2022.10.3.101 ]
to prove or disprove the possible effect of the irrelevant papers were deleted. Original articles and
order Diptera larvae on the treatment of neoplastic case reports on the use of maggot therapy or larval
lesions. Accordingly, a systematic review study secretions and extracts in lesions or neoplastic cells
was performed on the use of maggot therapy in published online were included in the study. The
cancerous lesions or maggots secretions and extracts articles containing at least English abstracts were
in neoplastic cells. included in the study since there are limited studies
and reports in some scattered areas and their minimal
Material and Methods information should not be lost. Only research on
The present systematic review was conducted based the larvae of the order Diptera was included in the
on the Cochrane protocol according to the PRISMA present study. The bias may be due to the lack of
guidelines (Figure 1). A query was conducted on access to articles published in non-English languages
international databases, such as PubMed, Scopus, and selective reporting within studies.
Web of Science, Embase, and Google Scholar (as
gray literature) for a 35-year period from 1 January Results
1986 to 10 November 2021. This period was A total of 387 articles were retried from the papers
selected due to the long history of larval therapy and published from 1991-2021. The highest number
the initial search. Search terms used were ("Maggot of articles was from Scopus (n=273), Web of
therapy" Or "Larval therapy" OR "Larval extract" Science (n=93), Embase (n=9), and Pambod (n=4),
Or "Larval secretions") And (Cancer OR Neoplasm respectively. Eight articles were identified from the
OR Tumor). The terms were searched in the topic, results of Google Scholar searches related to our
title, abstract, and keywords of published articles. topic. 68 duplicate papers were detected and deleted
[ Downloaded from jsurgery.bums.ac.ir on 2024-07-03 ]
Duplicate articles were removed using EndNote X8 using EndNote X8 software. Out of 319 articles left
(Thomson Reuters, Toronto, Canada). after the removal of duplicates, 74 articles remained
In the first stage, some unrelated articles were after reviewing the titles and abstracts, and finally,
deleted based on the title evaluation. In the second after a careful review of the criteria, 9 articles were
stage, the abstract of the articles was evaluated, and included in the present study (Figure 1).
[ DOI: 10.32592/jsurgery.2022.10.3.101 ]
The revision of nine eligible articles (Table 1) myiasis lived for 15 years (24). There have been
indicated that 11 cases of maggot debridement other reports of involuntary myiasis associated
therapy have been performed in human with skin neoplasms in humans.
proliferative lesions (SCC, Kaposi's Sarcoma, In all of these reports, tumors grew very slowly
and Endometrial adenocarcinoma metastasis) and (25-27). According to some scientists, studies on
horses (Melanoma, SCC, and Sarcoid). horse skin can be considered a model for human
These tumor lesions were located in the legs, chest, skin lesions (28). In one article, three uses of
head, and neck. One case of myiasis with breast maggot therapy on proliferative lesions in the
cancer yielded good results. Larvae extract has motor organs of horses were presented.
been also used in the treatment of mice hepatoma, A proliferative lesion in a horse with larval
and the effect of larvae extract on human leukemia therapy was completely healed. In the case of
cells and human lung cancer cells have been horse melanoma, debridement and granulation
investigated. tissue production were observed following maggot
Lucilia sericata larvae have been used in most therapy.
cases; nonetheless, Chrysomya megacephala and Nonetheless, maggot therapy in a chronic SCC
Phormia Regina larvae have been also used in did not have a positive effect on lesion healing
some cases. (29). In one study, maggot therapy with L. Sericata
Although we have high hopes that fly larvae can larvae was performed on four cases of equine
be effectively used in the treatment of neoplasms, sarcoid lesions (fibroblastic tumor).
limited studies are available on the effect of maggot In two of the horses, the results were satisfactory
therapy on these lesions (13,20). and caused the appearance of healthy skin; however,
[ Downloaded from jsurgery.bums.ac.ir on 2024-07-03 ]
Maggot therapy has been performed for a no positive results were observed in the other two
malodorous lesion caused by SCC in a human cases (30).
chest. In this case, the smell and appearance of the Larval secretions and extracts can also have anti-
wound improved after two rounds of larval therapy. tumor effects. In one study, the effect of two fatty
Pain in the area prevents the next larval therapy acids extracted from Chrysomya megacephala
(21). Larval therapy with L. Sericata for Kaposi larval extract was investigated using a colorimetric
Sarcoma reduces odor and infection, improves assay (MTT) and Sulforhodamine B (SRB) methods
blood flow, and prevents amputation. The author on human leukemia cells HL-60 and human lung
considers the use of larval therapy useful for the cancer cells A-549.
final stage of malignant wounds and recommends Both of these substances had an inhibitory effect
that more studies be conducted in this regard (5). on cancer cell growth, and HIV-1 integrase. ω-6
Maggot therapy was performed for a metastatic PUFA was the main active ingredient in these fatty
necrotic wound in the leg following malignant acids (31). The feeding of C. megacephala larval
adenocarcinoma of the endometrium. extract for 10 days to hepatoma-bearing mice
Conventional treatments before maggot therapy models reduced tumor complications.
failed to heal the wound. Larvae treatment removed The protein expressions of p38 mitogen-activated
[ DOI: 10.32592/jsurgery.2022.10.3.101 ]
the necrotic tissue on the wound and the granulation protein kinase (p38MAPK) and phosphorylated-
process appeared to have begun (22). p38MAPK (p-p38MAPK) in tumor tissues, as well
Larval therapy has been also used to treat skin as the levels of interleukin (IL)-1β, IL-6, tumor
tumors in the head and neck (23). necrosis factor (TNF)-α, and vascular endothelial
There have been cases, in whom skin cancers have growth factor (VEGF), were detected in tumors.
been associated with spontaneous myiasis. In one The antitumor mechanism of the C. megacephala
case, a person with fibroepithelial cell neoplasia of extract may be related to cytokines and activation
the breast (phyllodes) who had been associated with of the p38 MAPK signal pathway (32).
J Surg Trauma 2022;10(3):95-102 98
Rafinejad et al.
Table 1. Reports and research on the use of maggots in the treatment of cancer
5 Human Unknown Associated Myiasis Phyllodes Breast Lived for 15 years Kudchadkar
that maggot debridement therapy was sporadically treatment of cancers can be exerted via different
used in humans and animals. Due to the successful pathways. The amino acid 3-Guanidinopropionic
use of maggot therapy in the treatment of skin and acid (GPA) isolated from the secretions and extracts
superficial cancers, such as breast cancer (5,21– of L. sericata larvae, like its other analogs, can be
23), as well as the anti-tumor properties of extracts expected to have antitumor properties (33). The
and secretions of larvae in the laboratory (31-33), it substances secreted by maggots have proteolytic
seems that this natural treasure can be effective and properties and similar activity to trypsin, leucine
practical in the treatment of neoplasms, especially aminopeptidase, and carboxypeptidase. The
J Surg Trauma 2022;10(3):95-102 99
Use of fly larva (Maggots)
sterile methods of larvae preparation(37). Another Statistics, 2021. CA Cancer J Clin. 2021;71(1):7–
concern over larval therapy is the achievement 33. doi: 10.3322/caac.21654
of human and environmental standards in the 2. Leiter U, Eigentler T, Garbe C. Epidemiology
production and use of these larvae (38). One of the of skin cancer. In: Advances in Experimental
challenges in animals was the placement of larvae Medicine and Biology.NY: Springer; 2014. P. 120–
and toleration of dressing in restless horses, which 140. doi: 10.1016/b978-1-4377-1788-4.00005-8
is likely to be much less common in humans (30). 3. Rastrelli M, Tropea S, Rossi CR, Alaibac
Participants in the present study ( five humans and M. Melanoma: Epidemiology, risk factors,
seven horses) received maggot therapy. The H22 pathogenesis, diagnosis and classification. In Vivo
hepatoma-bearing mice models, Human leukemia (Brooklyn). 2014;28(6):1005–10011.
cells (HL-60), and Human lung cancer cells (A-549) 4. Cullen JK, Simmons JL, Parsons PG, Boyle
also participated in the study of the effects of the GM. Topical treatments for skin cancer. Libk. 153,
larval extract. Maggot therapy partially improved Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews. Elsevier B.V.;
the appearance of neoplastic lesions; moreover, the 2020:54–64. doi: 10.1016/j.addr.2019.11.002
larval extract inhibited tumor growth in mice and 5. Lin Y, Amin M, Donnelly AFW, Amar S. Maggot
neoplastic cells in the laboratory, compared to the Debridement Therapy of a Leg Wound From
[ DOI: 10.32592/jsurgery.2022.10.3.101 ]
Barriga D, Blanco J, Gómez L. Histological and clinical applications and future potential. Postgrad
Immunohistochemical Study of Wounds in Sheep Med J. 2007;83(1):409–413. doi: 10.1136/
Skin in Maggot Therapy by Using Protophormia pgmj.2006.055905
terraenovae (Diptera: Calliphoridae) Larvae. J 21. Jones M, Andrews A, Stephen T. A case history
Med Entomol. 2020;57(2):369–376. doi: 10.1093/ describing the use of sterile larvae (maggots)
jme/tjz185 in a malignant wound. world wide wounds.
13. Sherman RA, Hall MJR, Thomas S. Medicinal 1998;1(3):16–21.
maggots: An ancient remedy for some contemporary 22. Sealby N. The use of maggot therapy in
afflictions.Annu Rev Entomol.2000;45(1):55–81. the treatment of a malignant foot wound. Br J
doi: 10.1146/annurev.ento.45.1.55 Community Nurs. 2004;9(3):9–16. doi: 10.12968/
14. Mirabzadeh A, Ladani MJ, Imani B, Rosen bjcn.2004.9.sup1.12501
SAB, Sherman RA. Maggot therapy for wound 23. Reames MK, Christensen C, Luce EA. The Use
care in Iran: A case series of the first 28 patients. J of Maggots in Wound Debridement. Ann Plast Surg.
Wound Care. 2017;26(3):137–143. doi: 10.12968/ 1988;21(4):388–391. doi: 10.1097/00000637-
jowc.2017.26.3.137 198810000-00017
15. Nezakati E, Hasani MH, Zolfaghari P, Rashidan 24. Kudchadkar SJ, Chodankar SU, Amonkar D.
[ DOI: 10.32592/jsurgery.2022.10.3.101 ]
M, Sohrabi MB. Effects of Lucilia sericata A rare case of fungating phyllodes tumor of the
Maggot Therapy in Chronic Wound Treatment: A breast. MIMER Med J. 2018;2:(1):22-24 doi:
Randomized Clinical Trial. Chronic Wound Care 10.15713/ins.mmj.28
Manag Res.2020;7:11–17. doi: 10.2147/cwcmr. 25. Biswas S, McNerney P. Myiasis on a Giant
s248149 Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Scalp: A Case
16. Malekian A, Esmaeeli Djavid G, Akbarzadeh K, Report and Review of Relevant Literature. World
Soltandallal M, Rassi Y, Rafinejad J, et al. Efficacy J Oncol. 2016;7(2–3):34–39.
of Maggot Therapy on Staphylococcus aureus and doi: 10.14740/wjon966w
J Surg Trauma 2022;10(3):95-102 101
Use of fly larva (Maggots)
26. Wollina U. Massive scalp myiasis with bleeding 33. Bexfield A, Bond AE, Morgan C, Wagstaff
in a patient with multiple malignancies. Int Wound J, Newton RP, Ratcliffe NA, et al. Amino acid
J. 2010;7(4):297–299. doi: 10.1111/j.1742- derivatives from Lucilia sericata excretions/
481X.2010.00691.x secretions may contribute to the beneficial effects
27. Hawayek LH, Mutasim DF. Myiasis in a of maggot therapy via increased angiogenesis.
giant squamous cell carcinoma. J Am Acad Br J Dermatol. 2010;162(3):554–562. doi:
Dermatol. 2006;54(4):740–7411. doi: 10.1016/j. 10.1111/j.1365-2133.2009.09530.x
jaad.2005.07.012 34. Vistnes LM, Lee R, Ksander GA. Proteolytic
28. Harman RM, Theoret CL, Van de Walle GR. activity of blowfly larvae secretions in experimental
The Horse as a Model for the Study of Cutaneous burns. Surgery. 1981;90(5):835–341. doi:
Wound Healing. Adv Wound Care.2021;10(7);381- 10.1097/00006534-198205000-00122
399 doi: 10.1089/wound.2018.0883 35. van der Plas MJA, Dambrot C, Dogterom-
29. Lepage OM, Doumbia A, Perron-Lepage MF, Ballering HCM, Kruithof S, van Dissel JT,
Gangl M. The use of maggot debridement therapy Nibbering PH. Combinations of maggot excretions/
in 41 equids. Equine Vet J. 2012;44(43):120–125. secretions and antibiotics are effective against
doi: 10.1111/j.2042-3306.2012.00609.x Staphylococcus aureus biofilms and the bacteria
30. Ahmadnejad M, Tooloie M, Jarolmasjed S, derived therefrom. J Antimicrob Chemother.
Rafinejad J. Evaluation of Maggot Therapy Effects 2010;65(5):917–923. doi: 10.1093/jac/dkq042
on The Progression of Equine Sarcoid. Iran J Vet 36. Wang T yuan, Wang W, Li F fei, Chen Y chen,
Med. 202;15(4):1–19. Jiang D, Chen Y dong, et al. Maggot excretions/
31. Jun-Qing HY-FJ-L. Inhibitory effect of fatty secretions promote diabetic wound angiogenesis
[ Downloaded from jsurgery.bums.ac.ir on 2024-07-03 ]
acids from specifically-cultivated Chrysomya via miR18a/19a – TSP-1 axis. Diabetes Res Clin
megacephala( Fabricius)( Diptera: Calliphoridae) Pract. 2020;165(1):108–140. doi: 10.1016/j.
larvae on tumor cells and HIV-1 integrase in vitro diabres.2020.108140
and their ingredient analysis. Acta Entomol Sin. 37. Ahmadnejad M, Kaboudari A. Maggot therapy-
2008;51(2):137–142. related zoonotic diseases and modern larval
32. Zhang W, JIANG W, LAN X, ZHI G, LAN B, therapy solutions to ensure safety. J Zoonotic Dis.
JIAO A, et al. Exploration of the anti-tumor effects 2020;4(4):1–8.
and mechanisms of Chrysomya megacephala( Fab.) 38. Stadler F. The maggot therapy supply chain:
extracts in H22 hepatoma-bearing mice. Guangxi a review of the literature and practice. Med Vet
Med J. 2017;2(1):215–219. Entomol. 2020;34(1):1–9. doi: 10.1111/mve.12397
[ DOI: 10.32592/jsurgery.2022.10.3.101 ]
102
J Surg Trauma 2022;10(3):95-102