CBHE Infoday 2024 Call
CBHE Infoday 2024 Call
CBHE Infoday 2024 Call
30 November 2023
How to prepare a competitive project proposal? Award criteria, tips and lessons learnt.
2
Objectives
Modernisation
HEIs & HE
systems
Cooperation /
Regional Societal impact
integration
CBHE
Governance Accessibility
Innovation
3
Regions eligible for CBHE
Western Balkans (Region 1) Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo*, Montenegro
South-Mediterranean countries (Region 3) Algeria, Egypt, Israel*, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Morocco, Palestine*, Syria**, Tunisia
Asia (Region 5a) Bangladesh, Bhutan, Cambodia, China, DPR Korea, India, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Maldives, Mongolia, Myanmar, Nepal, Pakistan,
Philippines, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Vietnam
Cook Islands, Fiji, Kiribati, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Nauru, Niue, Palau, Papua New Guinea, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Timor-Leste, Tonga,
Pacific (Region 8a)
Tuvalu, Vanuatu
Angola, Benin, Botswana, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cameroon, Cabo Verde, Central African Republic, Chad, Comoros, Congo, Congo - Democratic
Republic of the, Côte d’Ivoire, Djibouti, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Eswatini, Ethiopia, Gabon, Gambia, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Kenya,
Sub-Saharan Africa (Region 9 )
Lesotho, Liberia, Madagascar, Malawi, Mali, Mauritania, Mauritius, Mozambique, Namibia, Niger, Nigeria, Rwanda, Sao Tome and Principe,
Senegal, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, Somalia, South Africa, South Sudan, Sudan, Tanzania, Togo, Uganda, Zambia, Zimbabwe
Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, Panama, Paraguay,
Latin America (Region 10)
Peru, Uruguay and Venezuela
Antigua & Barbuda, Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Cuba, Dominica, Dominican Republic, Grenada, Guyana, Haiti, Jamaica, St Kitts and Nevis, St
Caribbean (Region 11)
Lucia, St Vincent & Grenadines, Suriname, Trinidad & Tobago
4
CBHE main features
• Overarching &
Priorities
regional context
5
Overarching priorities
6
Three Strands:
Strand 1: Fostering access to cooperation in higher
education
▪ Projects can last 24 or 36 months
▪ Funding between EUR 200.000 and EUR 400.000 per project
Strand 2: Partnerships for transformation in higher
education
▪ Projects can last 24 or 36 months
▪ Funding between EUR 400.000 and EUR 800.000 per project
Strand 3: Structural reform projects
▪ Projects can last 36 or 48 months
▪ Funding between EUR 600.000 and EUR 1.000.000 per project
▪ Involvement of the Ministry
7
Three types of CBHE projects
National projects Multi-country regional Multi-country cross-
projects regional projects
HEIs from one third HEIs from several HEIs from countries not
country not associated to countries not associated to the
the Erasmus+ associated to the Erasmus+ Programme
Programme Erasmus+ Programme belonging to several
from Regions
one Region
8
Strand 1
Fostering access to cooperation in higher education
Facilitate access to newcomers
First step for participating organisations to enhance and increase means to reach out to
people with fewer opportunities
Target groups:
10
Strand 3
Structural reform projects
11
Who can participate?
12
News in 2024 call for proposals
Simplification
Eligibility criteria
▪ When?
Publication: 28 November 2023
Deadline: 8 February 2024
Applicants are highly recommended to submit proposals as early as possible and at least 48 hours
prior to the call deadline.
Erasmus+ CBHE 2024 promotion activities
21
CBHE 2022 & 2023 - % of selected projects per Strand
2022 2023
Applications received 620 790
Applications selected 145 159
40
70
40
Russian Federation (Region 4)
19 Asia (Region 5)
36
30 Central Asia (Region 6)
30 15
Middle East (Region 7)
20
21 11 Pacific (Region 8)
19
7 15 Sub-Saharan Africa (Region 9 )
10
1 7
9 8 Latin America (Region 10)
1 6
0 Caribbean (Region 11)
Digital
transformation
27%
Sustainable growth
and jobs
39%
Governance, peace,
security and human
development
8%
Integration of
migrants Green deal
4% 22%
CBHE 2022 & 2023 - Top Coordinator countries
30
28
25
23 23
20
17
15
15
10
10
8 8 8 8
6 6 6 6 6
5 5 5
5 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
0
CBHE 2022 & 2023 - Top Partner countries
200
183
180
160
140
120 115
104
100
82
77
80 72 70
65
60 59
60 52 50 50
47
40 40 39 38 37 36
40 35 34 31
30 30 29 28 27 26 26 26
25 25
20
0
Purpose and priorities
Purpose
Focus on the needs of the third countries not
associated to the E+ programme
sectors level
Individuals:
students, staff, Innovative learning and
learners in teaching methods
general
Reform of governance and
Bodies management systems and
responsible for structures at institutional
Active engagement with the
HE at local and business world and with
level
national level research
Strand 3. Structural reform projects
Promoting reforms and innovation of HE system
HEIs
Mutual learning Increase capacities
National Promote inclusive Identify synergies
between public of bodies in charge
Ministry for Higher Education with ongoing EU
authorities of the of Higher
Target groups
systems initiatives
higher countries involved Education
education (HE)
Research
institutions
Other relevant Efficient and Foster common Introduction of
Foster national
authorities and ownership
effective policy regional strategies funding
stakeholders in making in Higher Education mechanisms
the field of HE
Overarching priorities – example of topics
Governance, peace,
Digital Integration of Sustainable growth
Green Deal security and human
transformation migrants and jobs
development
• environmental • digital technology • access to • health and well • entrepreneurship
challenges • business education to being • uptake of STEAM
• biodiversity digitalisation migrants • public policies skills
• agri-food value • digital economy • recognition of • protection of • prevent brain
chains • artificial degrees and human rights drain
• climate intelligence credentials • peace and • links with labour
awareness, • digital skills and • support for security market
sustainability and pedagogy academic, social, • respect for • address school
resilience • distance learning physical and diversity dropouts
• green and psychological
• tolerance
efficient energy development
• gender equality
• sustainable
transport
Points to consider when
writing a proposal in HE
What is a successful application ?
34
A competitive application…
35
What are we looking for ?
A task refers to any activity that has a definite outcome associated with it
Deliverables are the final products/results of your project, those justifying spending public
money to fund the project
Impact is spreading (dissemination) and use (exploitation) of your results during and
after project, including beyond the original consortium
Communication is everything you do to inform about and get attention to your project
during the project period
Innovation in higher education
43
Relevance of the project
Award criteria
Purpose
• Relevant to objectives and activities of CBHE and specificities of the Strand,
• Adequate response to current needs of the target country(ies) or Region(s) and of the target groups,
• The extent to which the proposal addresses the EU overarching priorities.
Objectives
• Based on a sound needs analysis; clearly defined, specific, measurable, achievable, realistic,
• They address issues relevant to the participating organisations and development strategies for higher
education in the eligible third countries not associated to the Programme.
EU added value
• The proposal demonstrates that similar results could not be achieved without the cooperation of HEIs
from the EU Member States or third countries associated to the Programme and without the EU
funding
1. Relevance
Coherence
• Consistency between project objectives, methodology, activities and the budget proposed,
• Coherent and comprehensive set of appropriate activities to meet the identified needs and the expected results.
Methodology
•The logic of the intervention is of good quality, planned outputs and outcomes are coherent and feasible, and key
assumptions and risks have been clearly identified.
Work plan
•Quality and effectiveness of the work plan are in line with their objectives and the deliverables,
•The relation between the resources and the expected results is adequate and the work plan is realistic, with well-defined
activities, time-lines, clear deliverables and milestones.
Budget
•Cost efficiency and appropriate financial resources for a successful implementation of the project,
•The estimated budget is neither overestimated nor underestimated.
Quality control
•Control measures (continuous quality evaluation, peer reviews, benchmarking activities, mitigating actions etc.) and
quality indicators ensure a project implementation of high quality.
Environmental sustainability
•The project is designed in an eco-friendly way.
2.1.1 Concept and methodology
• Clarify your methodology for the different project activities in view of
demonstrating it is appropriate to the objectives and feasible:
• Which target groups will be involved
• Explain why the chosen methodology would be the most appropriate for your
planned goals
• Illustrate how it supports the capacity building process and the third country’s
ownership of results
2.1.2 Project Management, Quality Assurance and
monitoring
• You must insert the Logical Framework Matrix (LFM), that is a document to
be downloaded separately. You need to complete it and copy/paste in this
section.
Ensure coherence in LFM intervention
logic
Indicators must be
targeted in terms of
quantity and time !
2.1.3 Project teams, staff, experts
• Watch the % of Staff Costs: if it takes more than half of the budget, reconsider it !
• For countries participating to the capacity building action since decades, we strongly
encourage the acquisition of specialised equipment
• Remember that CBHE action does NOT finance long mobilities (more than one semester)
neither of students nor of staff
▪ Anticipation capacities
Deliverable:
Accredited Master
Milestone:
Ministry’s feed-back
Tasks:
Preparation of the
accreditation file of
the new Master for Milestones
submission to the occur before
Ministry deliverables
Tasks, milestones and deliverables
For curriculum development proposals
Deliverable:
New textbooks
developed and used
Milestone: by the students
Peer-review within the
consortium
Task: Preparation of the
new textbooks:
- Mixed groups of teachers, each
dealing with a subject; Milestones
- Collection of teaching materials occur before
- Workshops led by an expert; deliverables
- Team work in the different groups;
- Preparation of case studies;
Tasks, milestones and deliverables
For proposals creating a new service/structure/center
Deliverable:
Center established
and running
Milestone:
Official decision of the
University Council
Task: establishing the new
Definition of the mission, center
allocated staff, operating
budget and procedures of
the new center Milestones
occur before
deliverables
Work Packages
• They are the building blocks of the proposal: a correct identification of WPs
makes the project manageable and efficient
• On average, between 6 and 12
• A WP devoted to Quality Assurance is possible, but not compulsory, this
aspect can be dealt within the WP Management
• A WP devoted to Preparation/Preparatory measures is admissible, but not
compulsory
• Dissemination activities and Sustainibility measures can be grouped in one
single WP or form two different WPs
• Creating a single WP gathering all travels and mobilities NOT Recommended
Within a Work Package
• Duration: from M 8 to M 24 means there are NO activities and no milestones
in this WP after months 24, and all deliverable are due by M 24.
• There are 3 distinct sections: Tasks, Milestones and Deliverables: avoid
identical wording, and same date in the 3 sections
Ex: Task: Establishing the training format, collecting case studies… (M 4-8)
Milestone: Dates and Agenda of the training event agreed and displayed (M 9)
Deliverable: Training Workshop for Nigerian academic staff (M 11)
• Indicate credits:
➢ The total n° of credits for the Study Programme
(ECTS or other systems)
➢ The n° of credits for each new/updated course
Avoid discrepancies in different sections
• For the global timetable, pay attention to use the correct chart:
❖ the first one, with Months, is only for projects of 2 years
❖ the second one, with Quarters, is for projects of more than 2 years
New/updated curricula have to be taught in year 3
at the latest
Project management Quality Assurance Communication Report(s) of external
handbook Plan with interim
Plan/Strategy expert(s) for QA
report
Kick-off Meeting
Reports to the or other
Agency linked with
a payment consortium
meetings
Examples of deliverables
WP Preparatory Measures (NOT compulsory)
Surveys of
stakeholders Needs analysis
Updated Report(s) Inclusion Strategy
(students,
industries, NGOs)
possibly before possibly before by the end of Before starting At the start of
interim report interim report year 2 with students the new degree
Examples of deliverables
WP Development –‘Higher Education Reform’ proposals
change in
services/platforms guidelines,
legislation,
at national/country national
introduction of
level strategies, papers
new policies
Examples of deliverables
WP Dissemination
Website of the
project + links in Dissemination Video clips Report on Promotion
each institutional Plan/Strategy dissemination Social media Final
material activities
website activities conference
Management
•Solid arrangements are foreseen,
•Timelines, governance structures, collaboration arrangements and responsibilities well defined and realistic.
Composition
• Appropriate mix of organisations with the necessary competences relevant to the objectives of the proposal and to
the specificities of the Strand,
• most appropriate and diverse range of non-academic partners.
Tasks
•Roles and tasks are assigned on the basis of the specific know-how, profiles and experience of each partner.
Collaboration
•Effective mechanisms to ensure efficient collaboration, communication and conflict resolution between the partner
organisations and any other relevant stakeholders.
Commitment
•The contribution from the project partners is significant, pertinent and complementary,
• the proposal demonstrates the partners’ involvement, commitment and ownership of the project’s specific objectives
and results, in particular from the third countries not associated to the Programme.
2.2 Partnership and cooperation arrangements
Exploitation
• How the outcomes of the project will be used by the partners and other stakeholders; how multiplier effects
will be ensured and it provides means to measure exploitation within the project funding time and after.
Dissemination
• Clear and efficient plan for the dissemination of results, appropriate activities and their timing, tools and
channels to be spread effectively to all relevant stakeholders and non-participating audience, reaching out
and attracting relevant stakeholders to the outcomes within and after the project’s funding time.
Impact
• Tangible impact on its target groups and relevant stakeholders at local, national or regional level,
• Measures, goals and indicators to monitor progress and assess the expected impact at individual,
institutional and systemic level.
Open access
• Materials, documents and media produced freely available and promoted through open licenses and
without disproportionate limitations.
Sustainability
• How the project results will be sustained financially and institutionally and how the local ownership will be
ensured.
Communication vs Dissemination
✓ Be as explicit as possible:
name publications/conferences, expected dates,
types and size of audiences
Impact
Maximasing impact Impact and timing
• On involved institutions ❑ Short term changes in:
knowledge, skills, aspirations,
modernisation of HEIs and reform
attitudes, awareness
of HE sector
• On economy ❑ Medium term changes in:
Development of third countries, behaviour, practices, procedures,
creation of jobs values, decision making
• On society
❑Long term changes in:
On public policies and civils society policies, legislation, economy,
society, technology, environment
Detailed Budget Table
Insert the beneficiaries (BE) and the WPs
Rates to be used for
Volunteers
You find them in the
following Communications
of the European
Commission:
→ Volunteers. See
C(2019) 2646
What can be improved concerning budget
Explicit Rigorous
•do not take anything for granted; do •the application is the basis on which
not assume experts will always your project will be implemented; it
understand; avoid abbreviations or is also the cornerstone of your
explain them the 1st time partnership commitment
Focused Complete
•stick to what is asked •ensure you have followed all the
instructions and that the proposal
fulfils all the mandatory
requirements
Finally
• Involve all your partners from the beginning, including their hierarchies
82
83
Thank you
EACEA-EPLUS-CBHE@ec.europa.eu
Unless otherwise noted the reuse of this presentation is authorised under the CC BY 4.0 license. For any use or reproduction of elements that are
not owned by the EU, permission may need to be sought directly from the respective right holders.
Slide xx: element concerned, source: e.g. Fotolia.com; Slide xx: element concerned, source: e.g. iStock.com