Unit 6
Unit 6
UNIT-VI:
JUDICIARY SYSTEM IN INDIA
Introduction:
The judiciary is that branch of the government that interprets the law, settles disputes and
administers justice to all citizens. The judiciary is considered the watchdog of democracy, the
guardian of the Constitution and the Champion of the rights and liberties’. For democracy to
function effectively, it is imperative to have an impartial and independent judiciary. It protects
and interprets the constitution and settle the dispute between the centre and states.
On 26 January 1950, the Indian Constitution was written and it is world’s largest constitution
written. The constitution is the source of law in India and also the supreme law of India. Judicial
System of India consists of Supreme Court, High Court, District Court or Subordinate Court.
(3) The ability of the judiciary to maintain and independently run the judicial administration.
(4) The Judiciary must be made the guardian protector of the Constitution,
(5) The Judiciary must ensure full, fair and less- expensive opportunities to the people for
defending their rights and getting justice.
(6) The method of appointment of judges must be fair, systematic, effective and transparent.
(7) Method of removal of judges should be difficult and no single should have the power to
remove the judges.
(8) Judges must be paid high salaries, necessary allowances, good service conditions, and
appropriate retirement benefits.
By incorporating all these features in the judicial system, a well organised and independent
judiciary can be secured.
&&&&&
RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF KNOWLEDGE TECHNOLOGIES – A.P.
1. Supreme Court: It is the Apex court of the country and was constituted on 28th January
1950. It is the highest court of appeal and enjoys both original suits and appeals of High Court
judgments. The Supreme Court is comprised of the Chief Justice of India and 34 (including
CJI) other judges. Articles 124-147 of the Constitution of India lay down the authority of the
Supreme Court.
2. High Courts: High Courts are the highest judicial body at the State level. Article 214 lays
down the authority of High Courts. There are 25 High Courts in India. High Courts exercise
civil or criminal jurisdiction only if the subordinate courts in the State are not competent to try
the matters. High Courts may even take appeals from lower courts. High Court judges are
appointed by the President of India upon consultation with the Chief Justice of India, the Chief
Justice of the High Court and the Governor of the State.
RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF KNOWLEDGE TECHNOLOGIES – A.P.
3. District Courts: District Courts are established by the State Governments of India for every
district or group of districts based on the caseload and population density. District Courts are
under the direct administration of High Courts and are bound by High Court judgments. Every
district generally has two kinds of courts:
a. Civil Courts
b. Criminal Courts
District Courts are presided over by District Judges. Additional District Judges and Assistant
District Judges may be appointed based on the caseload. Appeals against District Court
judgments lie in the High Court.
4. Lok Adalats/Village Courts: these are subordinate courts at the village level which provide
a system for alternate dispute resolution in villages.
5. Tribunals: the Constitution provides the government with the power to set up special
Tribunals for the administration of specific matters such as tax cases, land cases, consumer
cases etc.
&&&&&
FUNCTIONS OF JUDICIARY
1. To Give Justice to the people: The first and foremost function of the judiciary is to give
justice to the people, whenever they may approach it. It awards punishment to those who after
trial are found guilty of violating the laws of the state or the rights of the people. The judiciary
fixes the quantity and quality of punishment to be given to the criminals. It decides all cases
involving grant of compensations to the citizens.
2. Interpretation and Application of Laws: One of the major functions of the judiciary is to
interpret and apply laws to specific cases. In the course of deciding the disputes that come
before it, the judges interpret and apply laws. Every law needs a proper interpretation for getting
applied to every specific case. This function is performed by the judges. The law meanswhat the
judges interpret it to mean.
3. Role in Law-making: The judiciary also plays a role in law-making. The decisions given
by the courts really determine the meaning, nature and scope of the laws passed by the
legislature. The interpretation of laws by the judiciary amounts to law-making as it is these
interpretations which really define the laws.
Moreover, ‘the judgements delivered by the higher courts, which are the Courts of Records,
are binding upon lower courts. The latter can decide the cases before them on the basis of the
decisions made by the higher courts. Judicial decisions constitute a source of law.
4. Equity Legislation: Where a law is silent or ambiguous, or appears to be inconsistent with
some other law of the land, the judges depend upon their sense of justice, fairness, impartiality,
honesty and wisdom for deciding the cases. Such decisions always involve law-making. It is
usually termed as equity legislation.
RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF KNOWLEDGE TECHNOLOGIES – A.P.
5. Protection of Rights: The judiciary has the supreme responsibility to safeguard the rights
of the people. A citizen has the right to seek the protection of the judiciary in case his rights
are violated or threatened to be violated by the government or by private organisations or fellow
citizens. In all such cases, it becomes the responsibility of the judiciary to protect his rights of
the people.
6. Guardian of the Constitution: The judiciary acts as the guardian of the Constitution. The
Constitution is the supreme law of the land and it is the responsibility of the judiciary to
interpret and protect it. For this purpose, the judiciary can conduct judicial review over any law
for determining as to whether or not it is in accordance with the letter and spirit of the
constitution. In case any law is found ultra vires (unconstitutional), it is rejected by the judiciary
and it becomes invalid for future. This power of the court is called the power of judicial review.
7. Power to get its Decisions and Judgements enforced: The judiciary has the power not only
to deliver judgements and decide disputes, but also to get these enforced. It can direct the
executive to carry out its decisions. It can summon any person and directly know the truth from
him.
8. Special Role in a Federation: In a federal system, the judiciary has to perform an
additionally important role as the guardian of the constitution and the arbiter of disputes
between the centre and states. It acts as an independent and impartial umpire between the
central government and state governments as well as among the states. All legal centre-state
disputes are settled by the judiciary.
9. Running of the Judicial Administration: The judiciary is not a department of the
government. It is independent of both the legislature and the executive. It is a separate and
independent organ with its own organisation and officials. It has the power to decide the nature
of judicial organisation in the state. It frames and enforces its own rules.
These govern the recruitment and working of the magistrates and other persons working in the
courts. It makes and enforces rules for the orderly and efficient conduct of judicial
administration.
10. Advisory Functions: Very often the courts are given the responsibility to give advisory
opinions to the rulers on any legal matter. For example, the President of India the power to
refer to the Supreme Court any question of law or fact which is of public importance.
11. To Conduct Judicial Inquiries: Judges are very often called upon to head Enquiry
Commissions constituted to enquire into some serious incidents resulting from the alleged
errors or omissions on the part of government or some public servants. Commissions of enquiry
headed by a single judge are also sometimes constituted for investigating important and
complicated issues and problems.
12. Miscellaneous Functions: The judiciary also performs several other functions such as the
appointment of certain local officials of the court, choosing of clerical and other employees.
Cases relating to grant of licenses, patents, and copy rights, the appointment of guardians and
trustees, the admission of wills, to appoint trustees to look after the property of the minors, to
RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF KNOWLEDGE TECHNOLOGIES – A.P.
settle the issues of successions of property and rights, issue of administrating the estates of
deceased persons, the appointment of receivers, naturalization of aliens, marriage and divorce
cases, election petitions etc.
&&&&&
THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
The Supreme Court is the apex court in India. The constitution says that the judgements of the
Supreme Court shall be binding on all other courts within the territory of India. The Supreme
Court decisions are final and can be modified only by the Supreme Court itself.
The origin of the Supreme Court in India can be traced back to the Regulating Act, 1773 during
the British regime. Under this provision this act the British Parliament established a Court of
India at Calcutta. It was not a federal in nature but a unified single court. After that eminent
members in the Constituent Assembly like Jawaharlal Nehru, Dr.B.R Ambedkar and Dr.
Rajendra Prasad played a significant role in finalising the draft on the Supreme Court. The
borrowed “Rules of Law” from Britain and “Judicial Review” from United States. They felt
the need of an integrated judicial system for the entire country.
The Supreme Court of India was inaugurated on January 28, 1950 at the chamber of the
Princess in the Parliamentary Building. Harilal J. Kania acted as the last Chief Justice of the
Federal Court and the first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court in India.
Part V of the Indian Constitution from Article-124 to 147 deals with the composition,
appointment, qualifications of judges, and powers and functions of the Supreme Court.
Normally those persons, who possess high moral integrity, constitutional expertise, legal
acumen, social outlook, impartial attitude etc, will assume various offices in the judiciary.
(d) Salary and Allowances
The Chief Justice of India (CJI) receives a monthly salary of ₹3,50,000 as of
September 2024. The salary structure for the CJI includes:
Basic pay
Pension
Gratuity
Dearness allowance (DA)
House rent allowance (HRA)
Other allowances
The salary structure and allowances of the CJI may change over time based
on government regulations and recommendations.
Here are the salaries of other judges in India:
Supreme Court Associate Judges: ₹3,25,000 per month
Chief Justice of a High Court: ₹2,50,000 per month
Other judges holding positions in High Courts: ₹2,25,000 per month
District and session judges: ₹1,44,000–₹2,24,000 per month
Judges in India receive a pension equivalent to 50% of their last drawn
salary.
(a) When the High Court has in an appeal reversed the order of acquittal of an accused person
and sentence him to death.
(b) When the High Court has withdrawn for trail before itself any case from any subordinate
court to its authority and has in such trial convicted the accused person and sentenced him to
death.
(iv) Special Appellate Jurisdiction: According to Article-136, the Supreme Court can itself
grant special leave to appeal from the judgements of any court or tribunal in the territory of
India.
(v) Revisory Jurisdiction: According to Article 137, the Supreme Court is empowered to
review any judgment or order made by it with a view to removing any mistake or error that
might have crept in the judgement or order.
(3) Court of Record:
According to Article 141, the Supreme Court acts as court of record which means that as a
Superior court its proceedings, acts, and judgements are kept in record for a perpetual memory
and further verification and reference. All the judgements and judicial proceedings of the
Supreme Court shall be treated as a model and guide to all other courts in hearing similar cases
in future.
fact of public importance. After such reference from the President, the Supreme Court may
report to the President its opinion there on.
(d) Quo-Warranto: It means ‘by what authority or warrant’. If the courts finds that a person is
holding a public office which is not entitled to hold that office. It is restricting that person from
acting in that office.
(e) Certiorari: It means ‘to be certified’ or ‘to be informed’. It is issued by a higher court to a
lower court for violate their jurisdiction.
(iii) It formulates necessary rules for proper maintenance of records and also for the purpose
of practice by the advocates in the country.
(iv) The Chief Justice of Supreme Court acts as the President of India for temporary period
under certain special circumstances.
(v) The Supreme Court, on the orders of the President, enquires on the conduct and behaviour
of the chairman and members of UPSC and SPSCs.
(vi) The Supreme Court Judges may be appointed as the head of special committees constituted
RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF KNOWLEDGE TECHNOLOGIES – A.P.
by the government.
(vii) It hears election disputes of the President and the Vice-President of India.
(viii) The Supreme Court timely provide guidelines to the Election Commission of India.
Conclusion: The study of the powers and functions of Supreme Court of India leads one to
conclude that it is one of the most powerful courts in the world. Being a single judiciary system
in India, Supreme Court is at the apex of the judicial system and has both original and appellate
jurisdiction and no appeals can be made against its decision.
INDEPENDENCE OF JUDICIARY- SUPREME COURT
Judiciary is a part of the democratic political structure of the country. The independency of
judiciary is safeguards the rights of individual and settles disputes in accordance with the law.
It ensures the democracy does not give way to individual or group dictatorship in order to able
to do all this, it is necessary that the judiciary is independent of any political pressure.
The constitution of India has made the following arrangements to maintain the independence
of the judiciary:
(A) Impartial Method of Appointment: Of all the methods of the appointments, the
appointment of the judges by the executive on the basis of fixed qualifications is considered
the best. According to Article-124 of the constitution of India, the judges of the Supreme Court
are appointed by the President out of the persons who fulfil the qualification mentioned in the
constitution. Apart from this, in the appointment of the Chief Justice, the President consults the
judges of the Supreme Court and the High Court and in the appointment of the judges, consults
the Chief Justice of India.
(B) Difficult Method to remove them from office: The judges can be removed from their
office only through impeachment for which both the houses of the Parliament have to pass a
resolution with 2/3 majority of the members present and voting and this has to be an absolute
majority of the total members. This is difficult method and ensures security to the judges.
(C) Long tenure of the judges: The Independency of Judiciary also depends on the long tenure
of the judges. The short tenure makes the judges feel insecure. In our country, the judges of
Supreme Court stay in their office up to 65 years of age and High Court up to 62 years of age,
whereas the government employees stay in their office up to 60 years of age.
(D) High Qualifications: Only a judge who is highly qualified can maintain his independence
and such a person does not become a puppet in the hands of lawyers. Article 124 (3), makes
mention of the Supreme Court.
(E) High Salaries: The judges must be paid high salaries so that they remain free from
economic worries. In India, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court gets a monthly salary of
Rs.1, 00,000 and other judges Rs.90, 000. Apart from this, they get many other facilities and
allowances. The salary of the judges cannot be reduced during their tenure except of financial
emergency time.
(F) No Practice after Retirement: The Constitution of India has also provided that a judge of
High Court or Supreme Court and that a judge after his retirement from the Supreme Court
RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF KNOWLEDGE TECHNOLOGIES – A.P.
(G) Special Privileges to Judges: Under Article 121 of the Constitution, it is especially
provided that the actions and decisions of the judges in their official capacity are immune from
criticism in the sense that no motives may be imputed to them. Even the Parliament cannot
discuss the conduct of the judges unless a substantive motion of impeachment is moved into
the house.
(H) Oath of House: While assuming their office the judges are administered an oath that they
shall discharge their duty without any fear and favour. So, oath also makes them to work
independently.
Judiciary enjoys a big importance in the eyes of the people because it acts as:
(1) The dispenser of Justice.
(2) Protector of the rights of the people.
(3) Guardian protector of the Constitution of the State.
(4) Arbiter of center-state disputes.
(5) Safeguard against Legislative and executive excesses.
(6) Check against arbitrary exercise of powers by the power-holders.
(7) Guardian of Rule of Law and Justice.
An independent judiciary is always considered to be the most essential part of every democratic
government worth its name. A government without judiciary is almost inconceivable. A
government without independent judiciary is always held to be an authoritarian government.
&&&&&
and High Court for the redressal of grievances on behalf of the victim or victims who were
incapable of approaching the court.
Under this new arrangement, a destitute citizen can file a writ petition even though a simple
letter written on the post card. This derives authenticity from the ‘right to be heard’ as implied
by Article 32 of our constitution. But the court has to ensure that the petitioner who approaches
the court with PIL, is acting bona-fide and not for personal gains, private profit, political or
other oblique considerations. The court should not allow this process to be abused by politicians
and others to delay legitimate administrative action or to gain a political objective.
&&&&&
THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF INDIA (AGI)
Article 76 of our constitution provided for the office of the Attorney General of India. The
Attorney General is the highest law officer of the union government. He is appointed by the
President of India. He holds the office during the pleasure of the President. He is entitled to all
privileges and immunities allowed to a Member of Parliament. When he attends sessions of the
House, he occupies a seat on the treasury government benches.
(a) Qualification
The Attorney General of India possess the same qualifications that are necessary for a judge of
the Supreme Court. They are as follows:
(i) He must be a citizen of India.
(ii) He must have served as a judge in some High Courts for a period of at least five years.
(iii) He must have served as an advocate in some High Courts for a period of at least ten years.
(iv) He must be a distinguished jurist in the opinion of the President.
(2) He performs such other functions of legal character that are assigned to him by the President
from time to time.
(3) He discharges the functions conferred on him by the constitution or any other laws.
(4) He appears in any court of law on behalf of the union government in all cases.
(5) He represents the government in any reference made by the President to the Supreme Court.
At present there are 24 High Courts in India. Out of them, four are the common High Courts.
Delhi is the only Union Territory that has a High Court of its own. The other union territories
fall under the jurisdiction of different state high courts. The union Parliament can extend or
exclude the jurisdiction of a high court to any union territory.
(a) Composition
Every High Court shall consist of a Chief Justice and some other judges. Our constitution does
not specify the exact strength of High Court judges. The President determines the strength of a
High Court and appoint them from time to time depending upon its workload. Besides, the
President has the power to appoint additional judges for a temporary period not exceeding two
years as an acting judge, where a permanent judge of a High Court is temporary absent or
unable to perform his duties. Such judges hold office until the permanent judge resumes his
office.
(e) Tenure
The constitution has not prescribed minimum age for the appointment of the judges of High
Court. They have fixed tenure. They hold the office till reaching the age of retirement. The
present retirement age is 62 years. So, once appointed, the Chief Justice and other judges shall
continue in office till they attain 62 years of age.
is necessary for the imposition of death sentences by the District Sessions Judge. It also hears
cases involving the interpretation of the Constitution.
(e) It appoints its administrative staff and determines the salaries and allowances and other
conditions of the personnel working in subordinate courts.
(f) it is empowered to withdraw any case involving the interpretation of the constitution and
dispose of the case itself.
(g) The High Court is the highest court of justice in the state. All other courts and tribunals
(except military court and tribunals) in the state function under the direct supervision and
control of the State High Court.
(ii) The Chief Justice of the High Court acts as the Governor on the direction of the President
tentatively whenever the vacancy arises in that office.
(iii) The High Court can admit Public Interest Litigation (PIL) like Supreme Court of India.
&&&&&
STATE ADVOCATE GENERAL
Every State in Indian Union shall have an Advocate General, an official corresponding to the
Attorney-General of India. He performs similar functions for the state that of the Attorney-
General of India. He is the highest law officer in the state.
(a) Qualification and Appointment
The Advocate General is appointed by the Governor of the state under the Article 165 of the
Constitution. A person to be appointed as Advocate General must possess the following
qualifications:
(i) He must be a citizen of India.
(ii) He must have served as a judge in some High Courts for a period of at least 5 years.
(iii) He must have served as an advocate in some High Courts for a period of at least ten years.
(b) Tenure
The Constitution of India did not mention the tenure of Advocate General. He holds office
during the pleasure of the Governor.
The Constitution does not contain the procedure and grounds for removal of Advocate General.
He may be removed by the Governor. He may also quit his office by submitting his resignation
to the Governor. Conventionally, he resigns when the government resigns or is replaced, as he
is appointed on the advice of the government.
(9) He sits in the Treasury Benches in the House (s) of the state.
&&&&&