Online Copy of the WP 9440 of 2024 Chandramohan

E-FILING NO - EF-HCK-2024-023261
BEFORE THE HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

WP(C) No ................................ Of Year 2024
95.01 KERALA CONSERVATION OF PADDY LAND AND WET LANDS ACT 2008
PETITIONER(S)
1. CHANDRA MOHAN
VS
RESPONDENT(S)
1. STATE OF KERALA
AND OTHERS
MEMORANDUM OF WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
FILING NATURE : URGENT

FEES PAID & STATUS - 272 (SUCCESS)
C.F : 100 UNDER SCHEDULE II ARTICLE 11 (L) (III) OF THE KERALA COURT FEES AND SUIT VALUATION ACT
SERVED ON
GOVERNMENT PLEADER
FILED BY
1. ADV VARUGHESE M EASO

2. VIVEK VARGHESE P.J.
3. JAYAKUMAR N.
4. BENNY T.
Sd/-
E-VERIFIED
ADV VARUGHESE M EASO(K-374.H/2000)
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
WP(C) No ............................... Of Year 2024
PETITIONER : CHANDRA MOHAN
V/S
RESPONDENT : STATE OF KERALA AND OTHERS
INDEX
SL Title Description Page Nos

1 Synopsis Synopsis 1-5
2 Statement Of Facts Statement Of Facts 6-32
3 Affidavit Affidavit 33
True copy of Sale Deed No.2033/97 of SRO Thiruvalla dt.14/07/97
4 Exhibit P1 34-39
executed by Bhaskaran and others in favour of Chandra Mohan
True copy of Sale Deed No.1527/2001 of SRO Thiruvalla
5 Exhibit P2 dt.31/05/01 executed by Pennamma and others in favour of 40-45
Chandra Mohan
6 Exhibit P3 46-49
dt.31/05/01 executed by Divakaran in favour of Chandra Mohan
7 Exhibit P4 dt.10/06/99 executed by Mariamma Kurian in favour of Chandra 50-54
Mohan
True copy of the land tax receipt dated 05/12/2023 issued by the 2
8 Exhibit P5 55
nd respondent Village officer, Thiruvalla
True copy of the minutes No A3 – 3189/1999 dated 10/11/1999
9 Exhibit P6 56-57
prepared the office of the 3rd respondent
10 Exhibit P7 True copy of the letter No B/3152/2015 dated 01/06/2015 58-59
11 Exhibit P8 True copy of the report No C2 – 912/14 dated 04/06/2015 60-61
True copy of the request by the petitioner to the 4 th respondent
12 Exhibit P9 62-63
dated 07/01/2014
13 Exhibit P10 True copy of the request to the 3 rd respondent dated 05/01/2015 64-66
True copy of the judgment dated 04/02/2015 in WP © No
14 Exhibit P11 67-71
3262/2015 of this Hon’ble Court
True copy of the representation dated 20/02/2015 submitted by the
15 Exhibit P12 72
petitioner to the 3 rd respondent
True copy of the relevant page of the draft data bank notification
16 Exhibit P13 73
attested by the 5 th respondent
True copy of the letter No KBT 26/2014-15 dated 13/03/2015 issued
17 Exhibit P14 74
by the 5th respondent to the 3rd respondent
18 Exhibit P15 True copy of the order No A3 -766/2015 dated 18/04/2015 75-77
True copy of the Judgment dated 24/07/2020 in WP © No 34997 of
2019 of this Hon’ble Court
True copy of the statement of facts prepared by the 5th respondent
for the Writ Petition, WP © No 34997 of 2019
True copy of the Kerala gazette Vol IX dated 21/01/2020 contain
the draft master plan for the Thiruvalla Town prepared by the
Department of Town and Country planning department along with
readable copy of relevant page
22 Exhibit P19 True copy of the Master plan for Thiruvalla Town-2031 88
True copy of the KSREC Report No A172/2015/ KSREC/
004650/2022 dated 19/05/2022
True copy of Order No.A6- 1292/19/KD is dt.03/01/2020 of the 3rd
respondent related to the property of one Varghese John
True copy of the Order No A6-1228/2019 K Dis dated 13/01/2022 to
25 Exhibit P22 100
one Mr.Gigi Joseph Vattacheril
True copy of the Order No B2-1578/2022/K Dis dated 18/07/2022 to
26 Exhibit P22 (a) 101
one Mr. Gigi Joseph Vattacheril
True copy of the Letter No A6-1292/19 dated 09/12/2019 to one Mr.
27 Exhibit P22 (b) 102
Varghese John
True copy of the Order No A6 -4056/2019 dated 22/02/2021 to one
28 Exhibit P23 103
Mr.Saju Kabeer, Planthara House
True copy of the Order No A6-4056/2019/KDis dated 14/06/2021 to
29 Exhibit P23 (a) 104-105
one Mr.Saju Kabeer, Planthara House
True copy of the Order No B2-4627/2021/KDis dated 30/07/2021 to
30 Exhibit P23 (b) 106
one Mr.Saju Kabeer, Planthara House
True copy of the 3rd respondent had issued a letter A- 5600/2019
31 Exhibit P24 107-108
dated 13/04/2021 to the Advocate of the General, Ernakulam
True copy of the Revision Petition without Annexures dated 14 th
32 Exhibit P25 109-121
day of December, 2020 submitted by the petitioner
True copy of the order dated 24/08/2020 in W P © No 16203/2020
33 Exhibit P26 122-124
of this Hon’ble Court
True copy of the counter affidavit filed by the respondents in WP ©
34 Exhibit P27 125-130
No 16203/ 2020
True copy of the Judgment of this Honorable Court dated
35 Exhibit P28 131-138
25/10/2022 in WP © No 16203 of 2020
True copy of the affidavit filed by the petitioner dated 10/11/2023
36 Exhibit P29 139-145
before the 1st respondent
True copy of the order of this Honorable Court dated 13/12/2023 in
37 Exhibit P30 146-148
I A No 1/2023 in W P (c) No 16203 of 2020
True copy of the order No.GO (Rt) No 488/2024/RD dated
38 Exhibit P31 149-151
07/02/2024 issued by the 7th respondent
True copy of the Gazette notification for final data bank TP No
39 Exhibit P32 152-153
15750/19 dated 17/02/2021
True copy of the MASTER PLAN FOR THIRUVALLA MUNICIPAL
40 Exhibit P33 TOWN availed from the website of the department of Local Self- 154
Government under state of Kerala
True photo of the specific area of Block No 222 is also availed from
41 Exhibit P34 the website of the department of Local Self-Government under 155
state of Kerala
42 Vakalatnama Vakalatnama 156
Sd/-
E-VERIFIED
ADV VARUGHESE M EASO
K-374.H/2000
1 WP(C) 9440/2024
I/
BEFORE THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM
WP (C). NO. of 2024
Chandra Mohan Petitioner
Vs.
State of Kerala & others Respondents
SYNOPSIS
A. Petitioner is the owner in possession and enjoyment of 56.65 Ares of
dry land in Re Sy. 222/2, 16.19 Ares, 14.38 and 20.63 Ares in Sy. No
222/1 in Resurvey Block No 219 in Thandepper 14623 in Thiruvalla
VIllage; and are lying adjacent to the Main Central Road in Thjruvalla
municipal town, vide Exhibit P1, P2, P3 and P4 Sale Deeds. During
1999, the petitioner and other nearby land owners had given a portion
of their land in consensus with the government /Exhibit P6) for the
development of Thiruvalla bypass on condition that they will be
permitted to fill the property up to the road level. On the basis Of

Exhibit P6, the 3rd respondent had permitted the petitioner to use the
property for the purpose other than paddy oultivatfon and to fill the
land referred in Exhibit Pl to P5, up to the then proposed bypass road
level, by using red earth and municipal waste in the year of 2001 itself.
8. The 3rd respondent RDO vide ExhiELP7 submitted a report to the

District Collector wherein recommending to grand permission to
develop the land belongs to the people including the petitioner, and
District Collector submitted Exhibit P8 report to the government
recommending such permission. Thereafter, during 2014, petitioner

2 WP(C) 9440/2024
had submitted Exhibit P9 to get corrections in the Basic Tax Register
and also Exhibit Plo under dause 6 of the KLU order to the 3rd
respondent. But the same were not considered by the respondents and
thus aggrieved he had filed WP© No 3262 of 2015 and this Hon'ble
Court Exhibit Pllordered that the Exhibit Plo has to be considered on

the basis of the legal principles laid down by this Honourable Court in
various judgments. Thereafter the petitioner had submitted Exhibit P12

representation before RDO, who in turn conducted a hearing and
assured the petitioner that he will issue orders on Exhibit P 9 and 10
after availing the report from the 5th respondent.
C. Thereafter the 3rd respondent had obtained Exhibit P14 report from the
5th respondent that certifying the property is rot a paddy or wet land
as per records of the Exhibit P13 Data Bank ratification and also on
the basis of their local level inspection. The petitioner was highly
aggrieved on the non consideration of his applications by the statutory

officers of the state and the petitioner had again approached this
Honourable Court through a Writ Petition WP© No 34997 of 2019. But
the respondents were not filed any counter affidavit and the petitioner
had submitted the application under Right to Information Act and
obtained the rote file and the orders passed by the 3rd respondent on
previous applications Exhibit P9 and Plo. Hence it is revealed that the

3rd respondent had passed Exhibit P15 order dated 18/04/2015 and the
same was against the factual status of the fend and also the legal
position declared by this Hon Court.

3 WP(C) 9440/2024
D. It is clearly evidentfrom Exhibit P13 Draft DATA BANK, P14 report and
P20 KSREC report that the property comprised in Exhibit Pl to P4 are

`Converted land' prior to enactment of Kerala Conservation of Paddy
land and wet land Act 2008. But the 3rd respondent has failed to
consider the factual and legal issues and issued the Exhibit P15. The
petitioner had preferred the statutory Revision Petition before the lst
respondent as per Exhibit P25. These all facts were observed by this
Honourable Court in Exhibit P29 and directed the lst respondent to
consider and pass appropriate orders in the pending Revision Petition
Exhibit P25 against the Exhibit P15. But the lst respondent had not
considered the contentions from the petitioner and the 7th respondent
had rejected the Exhibit 25 statutory Revision Petition submitted before
the lst respondent State Government under Rule 14 of the Kerala Land
Utilization Order and issued the Exhibit P31 order without considering
the facts and also as well as the legal dictums laid down by the
Honourable Supreme Court of India as well as this Honourable Court.
The lst respondent had purposefully ignored the specific directions

issued by this Honourable Court in Exhibit Pll, P26, P28 and also in
Exhibit P30. Hence aggrieved this Memorandum of Writ Petition (Civil)
is filed.
DATES AND EVENTS
14/07/1997Execution of Sale Deed No.2033/97 (Exhibit P1)
10/06/1999Execution of Sale Deed No.1444/99 of SRO llruvalla(Exhibit P4)
10/11/1999 Minutes No A3 -3189/1999 (Exhibit P6)

4 WP(C) 9440/2024
31/05/2001 Execution of Sale Deed No.1527/01 of SRO Thiruvalla

(Exhibit P2)
31/05/2001 Execution of Sale Deed No.1526/01 of SRO Tiruvalla

(Exhibit P3)
07/01/2014 Request to the 4th respondent (Exhibit P9)
05/01/2015 Request to the 3rdrespondent (Exhibit Plo)
04/02/2015 Judgment in WP © No 3262/2015 by this Hon'ble Court

(Exhibit Pll)
20/02/2015 Representation (Exhibit P12)
13/03/2015 Letter No KBT 26/2014-15 by the 5th respondent to the

3rd respondent (Exhibit P14)
18/04/2015 Order No A 3 -766/2015 of the 3rd respondent (Exhibit P15).
01/06/2015 Letter No 8/3152/2015 RDO, Thiruvalla to District Collector

(Exhibit P7)
04/06/2016 Report No C2 -912/14 of the District Collector, Pathanamthitta

to the Principal Secretary, Revenue (8) Dept., Secretariat,
Thiruvananthapuram (Exhibit P8)
14/06/2019 Land tax receipt by Village officer, Thiruvalla. (Exhibit P5)
21/01/2020 Kerala gazette Vol IX contain the draft master plan for the
Thiruvalla Town prepared by the Department of Town and
Country planning department along with readable copy of
relevant page(Exhibit P18).
04/02/2020 Statement of facts prepared by the 5th respondent

in WP © No 34997 of 2019 (Exhibit P17)
5 WP(C) 9440/2024
21/07/2020 Resolution No 20 of Thiruvalla Municipal Council(Exhibit P20).
24/07/2020 Judgment in WP © No 34997 of 2019 of this Hon'ble Court

(Exhibit P16).
Statutes referred to:
1. Kerala conservation of paddy land and wet land Act, 2008

2. Kerala land Tax Act 1961.
3. Kerala Land utilisation order 1967.
4. Constitution of India
Dated this the 5th day of March, 2024. ìr±T,- `

Varughese M Easo (V-446)
Counsel for Petitioner
6 WP(C) 9440/2024
7 WP(C) 9440/2024
8 WP(C) 9440/2024
9 WP(C) 9440/2024
10 WP(C) 9440/2024
11 WP(C) 9440/2024
12 WP(C) 9440/2024
13 WP(C) 9440/2024
14 WP(C) 9440/2024
15 WP(C) 9440/2024
16 WP(C) 9440/2024
17 WP(C) 9440/2024
18 WP(C) 9440/2024
19 WP(C) 9440/2024
20 WP(C) 9440/2024
21 WP(C) 9440/2024
22 WP(C) 9440/2024
23 WP(C) 9440/2024
24 WP(C) 9440/2024
25 WP(C) 9440/2024
26 WP(C) 9440/2024
27 WP(C) 9440/2024
28 WP(C) 9440/2024
29 WP(C) 9440/2024
30 WP(C) 9440/2024
31 WP(C) 9440/2024
32 WP(C) 9440/2024
33 WP(C) 9440/2024
33
BEFORE THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM
WP (C). No. of 2024

Vs.
State of Kerala & others Respondents
AFFIDAVIT
I, Chandra Mohan, aged 71 years, S/o. Krishna Pillai, Chandrima

House, Podiyadi P.O., Thiruvalla Thaluk, Pathanamthitta District; do
hereby solemnly affirm and state as follows:
1. I am the petitioner in the above writ petition (Civil) and I am
conversant with the fads of the case.
2. This Hon'ble court may be pleased to allow the prayers in the writ
Petition (Civil), as otherwise the petitioner will be put to irreparable injury,
loss and hardship. The exhibits produced along with the Writ Petition
(Civil) are true copies of original documents.
3. All the averments in the writ petition (Civil) may be considered and
as part and parcel of this affidavit.
4. I have not earlier filed any Petitions in respect of the relief sought
for.
What is stated above are true and correct.
Dated this the 05th day of March, 2024.

Chandra Mohan
DEPONENT
Solemnly affirmed and signed before me by the deponent who is

personally known to me on this the 05th day of March, 2024 in my
at Ernakulam
Varughese M
ADVOCATE
34 WP(C) 9440/2024
.J¥9£
35 WP(C) 9440/2024
C
36 WP(C) 9440/2024
*. 51 'r2tap Qfl rfd isl9> I i C} c> r* I ~ 9 c> rd6*zBO I,i,5„O

'
r2ulca6~aig§1ocJic>Ù5c>>c5rrtlds
ruL. flo \ c\ T
~Qfl'lJJ3ri, cS > r2rt),I '3 , 3o G,2J r2r3 a
''iJ:' ¥=c, 6i,r)ce>rThiTaDr"ij°f+TOTS
. . c]~| g| e> r" =j rT2n c*
r"ra3
a 6ta3 rlt ac , tra
EiEEiiiiEMiia
6 }' rco , es ut> aeu .....i.```l
igrcolrapcrvou2ct?]c2)r¥u
6,6+ cE= 6>
a 63r, a €ul 933 3 rflcae` r2rarli3r» i~
a D= czr3rl
"`%acu
`10C)c>Gf2Cnor5J
a=2
37 WP(C) 9440/2024
. !# Xrm
2000Rs.
o r3~ 9o GJ /ir3 a 7r€l a5±V rJ`rT<try~n a3 vac) aJJj

1561,) rtcu,U 3 c) c> c> o
~ un ,. '`. %±jrfl_~,:fltT>=5+_'oapf!
cj f\ L2! ..2Jl cT*3=i, 99fvJo3)cqr3+rngal9gvciooo.a
3 6yyt .i__ }ra'j|
;::nr,|£i=J:fT£=~i?nJaQff=1
=rf,3u==J:?a€!£ou£,af=J
rrolallr€la53rtT|]`c"3alrT,rm»
\
ul a s fyJa 3 I rr> ftJ,jic=,L£=£fl

The?:tiff.'£
=u'frir±;;f?Tgflo dlf{1,2r3r=c:=;),,`r`r2rapLu.CPG3"
ra =,;uL=j=jL=Tu6`,coco5,r;jL=;~r3:,uL:,L=£fl;ro,
A . _L_
r~Sll ;±i:+`;Ji;;i\.j`;_:.;,:,j`'::~ffie#rodr
co Gr,c?, a:e#LHriL;;a5":i``,.;'='ijin~:a±c3Lrrty`rrty
r2i=?g'¥ragT='.?i;=j:=i:I;:,:fajap:rfu=
• .I: `. '=
@,(alral # `,,
I,,1J^`'',?cs:= rrr;`l r=~b> F2n..c

ch
.ra_rrr) ife
38 WP(C) 9440/2024
<=_:~+=a:i:':*'_::p±jb,`==\^fa~rT',:`:,,`=J;ggrbgne:,ich±®ich`
•1 i i _/`
6`~, '',i?,I J `'==l,i/` <r;`.~J,=`'\,`T:.:.':,.:`:`,`:LJ'+`jL,':i~::Lrf2radii=='s3al3*±

r).ii±|__fì`:L'`+rTao
yJJ,ae9)
C"a
r3,i(ul
g=rT:lraJm
,przr)
is. pe
39 WP(C) 9440/2024
c=_J\~
ThiTis+Ire true copy of dcoument produced and marked

•..... `.
40 WP(C) 9440/2024
..i,i
®
\àlfu,ul0%2¥=:a,'ur€,':Orgin@©ut®'*%OlsJ€ro#Julti
® ^
•.::.;:::,.,.:::..:..:..::,..:...:.i.I.::i.:.:',.:i;::;![:i:.
.....fì!:.i:1:::`:.ì`:...`,....i.`.:..:`;`=,,`.``,````:;.:`,..:`:.::`:::.`..i;`.:.:`.i`,...:`:.`.`
3a,*Vbf|Le9inr=\jbG3ac==:2£:::.`jcul
Culck5 Eie 9,
raied);~,~ale
crty_o6brh
rTh ' rtn
ibe_tstr¥ir~J>ff
grT¥a3:TifeptalJ;b5EL@±
ro)a
6lY_DiLcoa3
rxp®i=,riLds(
rfu.tyoa:q\anrisaplyrrmrbr"vb
::==:. `: i_i: liI rJ
II '
enN„ a . .ifeuli
1:\
41 WP(C) 9440/2024
.raTag| GhorooJ. to
N a .. Ll a& ui^ ?,.i
+ q. . 5. . j2ooj
ewhtl `.oniaca
4,!dL,. loot,
arm'.....S..i?"a.=
mlcolAt*t):onto9co®
Oifro6Ouej cO6"' qero"
amacoco6dbQ2)6o :..i;:ì=f.J`\,.``.``...,.
"6covy6o .\. ,i:..+:=: ,.....,...,., ;. u
utoo,gr®oco6tcacp/I,aòuLofLse
® 9` ` ilt rngprQJ\Qjho.) c_er``~S
a CLI ee J2al2
cooQ.oo®o£°3#.aotru?.I....®1cob \uLl ~
coqoaptwu,is:rfe,o¥9rfu8ue3oouacoico.
a9a>ooo a@®3ol®e6toF6mmm
_ in aun®fa
c3 a` ` a]"r=t=Drq,` Qj i a ` c``>/\i=:z2<Tajhl
cbofQal<alQs2±l±
'.:*.....Ltul
a ruuè€rrtyJin ~
:i=`:::ii::i:=:.:i;::r`:;:
`. , I `
© .6ul
Och'd9g.9`..
:;¥.; a. r`s\ ~\a`rul arffaq c2è; ¢^^^+\^^ ,,,,
L±eamaake r. .'
42 WP(C) 9440/2024
Onge3)
•#roan%E=fgrdiJJh
9ftN\ib®5±®,ifealtrycD
',,.,`,911.
:.,*rf:etfro.`.
i"ih .\
43 WP(C) 9440/2024
: :i , :=J

cmv`,rh@ . LbN{wtry
:=L_3
44 WP(C) 9440/2024
iiERÈ `, ,_`
HE=i
rij»ralrrmo .,
:::::i:::
dirhJ
Ji.=§u=j:jiLj6~FTf:rd rtj
a s'a;`+`Tt G3 rwi i{ xp
:::f:
`..\..::.ii.,`..`:`...:`.:.':.`.ì),`.`.:J:;;:i:`:;',_:.to.
`;;iTb:?..,....`..`..ì::i__
cif rfu\® MEffif ahap'.

•:€f..fi:
`\ ¢` . ,.'
45 WP(C) 9440/2024
EX]HBIT PR
a# Ong€£ )
This js the true copy Of doc

in the above case a§
46 WP(C) 9440/2024
47 WP(C) 9440/2024
48 WP(C) 9440/2024
®
®
®
®
49 WP(C) 9440/2024
®
®
i
50 WP(C) 9440/2024
OJBB 0J0858
'igff£_=:£9an3RE3ftcoF#_alse
if£#&agr##5=ife,alr*ul6la2# I
9oconb
_::i`:=.`.:I::`:`::i:::::
5brat
mco rfe,
::i;..ii::.,:.,.:..,:::..,,:.,i:;:`;:`;i..:.i.:;.,;;::`:`:!f`::,i=:.:.';:?.,..;:::,:.`.:::ì``::.::J':...::::;:..;`;;`..::u:i:
ccend3
' . I ,^ '1
c2Ja,iqTcp.dsL=36al*aTria.,
EF
:a*;#?'3+9j±gct=J|T=edfi;6#:_°o"3 I I _ '',I I_.__Il. I'afa,.
£afi?i:T63aal3alg+=_±a:f:a.:4:'ianA3#:?:¥±4iig;,
CXJ_ ,, ' . _ , _ ,_ A .... _ .. _ I

>ca,6se%8+
=.c©J©C,A
_`.:ii`::Li.::.:i:==:i:::.i:ii::iii:;::
h2rolal?mc95r5rt
N(CyirfrJ~jmr~kv~ou
._Li_____.==__..ed
51 WP(C) 9440/2024
ay.I) als3#
S.T
fo'&\QJ)(ai>
If
t5aJ/rT3frvl6ieJonedk
qD`rfA rd s,Q'.76in
•`
~.b<, I tf
mlftyaougg in,6"u
`. ````=`.1``.`:``._
ruto"cO&dbQay6®Te~¥
colon: ausp_ud@6chcB)ao
I .'' . .~=.` ,,,i. |ng
., r, , r,i,, t, +t+,L.A.
rat fs'6m
9rf}toqo/ e} ±rrJ. thaaL.I+ci k^dA . I
\ , J3) a . rb r .,
apaax>®o aae6chl6)ch6io€6mtml@on
a.i,onmu
•2.`.`
Qgr42J. C*QJ +.rdc,

+ul flvej th c¢ra`cJ)
9 ~ _Qgiv furrf`
mr,6i|t@'to'hiorknl'rfu6,L`tar`D
®e* Sst±Th G>fty®.h` cl>ro \LL

CeDfort.rot C2)S|± CheDciJgo
_3©`16t&q]Esr>QoNgp/
+rinQ&#%rdAlap.o&VJ4:©=
Oj^tr`1ffng:
i,3T€¥¥.a:
:.or;)plgQS
•.t.a .,.. `r.." ,|JtÒ!
c=c),,fa,.„4j,jmaL=::.t'i,6¢t';
co(r2jrloi'ui'! (ljgBli:I L oìì,4. dr ,i .,,. „
i.J)a""Col •j",b.,Qf2=
ul cope, ap*fu4" 9ng*: ®giiou9tsQ¢ carfe

Oti5T^ftyLJpr~
'JX •.__.__. . `_1
52 WP(C) 9440/2024
OJBB 0J0859
c:,=flal#5?#°difflr#,a;:fled`co2¥~es?#g#:
a5ds, A.1
•f_:::¥:,:?i:..:..**`.:`,i:5t,..:i:.::::...i;`::::;.::::..:.,.:`::;..ì::S:f`
=ET : A I ,ì ±_,^^_i.f2,I(derf u,E2®
(:I ±1> |J I C, , , + ` 1~\, .r _

EN
::.::i:,:=::i::::`,_,:i:::=i::,:::::::I:i:i:::ii
\
;, 'c\O.`
=T+==:=====.i:_if`
53 WP(C) 9440/2024
rrty±dlr"fa OJBB 0J0860
apae)atr"rhacatrrty
alJc=J1
<a=,> , EJ , =2bjbfg..caei=T=
rJJ5g3: jlJ151G©ratr2J
r€l,"J aal ~ng
6T=1?FrT^cber
:::::;::.ti:..:i.i; 63r3ui>a3oG31CP£
ap3e>£cr)sr"e>rf\cal
r6`c=J&±se9an
ii'apalcul Gfa "i I
.::::`:`:`.`.:::i:`::i::::::::;:i
9blc„3md±2(A %,u``:,;:;,i;;`£:9:i;c,t.,~:;:Lt:?:it:`h£€£;N;5o..`}`6;:2#o473
``L;iy`;,[{L,,",+5t:`.``.,t`LL\`:;;ir,.t\:`L;,:;a¥;€%:f'j.
ELctct±trctry ;:;:,:``'j``
:`., :9 :::.,*f:1
FEi¥:i:,::`!:1,ì"L`:i`1:`Jtt"
54 WP(C) 9440/2024
55 WP(C) 9440/2024
E¥+ . i)9
cda]®g codcood
e|On3OuuOOucotQid3]edu
®oulcou
EElg! :ulcomo®1§ ®oulco-mmu6 : KL03051107518/2023
cooqtBou:col®oi" onlcg!a-: ®leeoJRl
®6n3Cedd mmJd 10415 t3rommj®lal cfu®o 63ScB6>1Q2>colmv ®tro|®V
92mo 9ul gE!mo @ch rfu3Eaogat oulc®®ooco6mcA

coslouoomGmlcB]®1 coo3Q]6dae I1440 2023-2024 6nrca®d96]1222, co6neGq]6 mo: 10415
dhsIC&hd9.: {1440 rLJ§o®Ooono®6)s QJlou®6veua
edEulco {182 1 ) al®c®ocir.ct, ®rfflullag ®tfuo3. al(gl®®1ed, m§onl6)ei

ol®led, 6icnsocao oul®s!ca-
{T\;d6j" & tT\j6nr coo, QiltTpeormo, ®®0
I ) I, 31 m®d` 10 oEi.al., mlcuo
)2, 50 moo, 65 ngj.®1.` mlalo
ys2, 6 Ou®6, 50 ngj.di„ coiQjo
ys, 6 mod, mleio
6}cfro Qjl(ia;fld6REo:94 tui®d. 25 ti}!u.al.
d3]drfldcEb 6)®091eJegl ®oaou6ntl {9`S 2023-2024

cd3ffl®mlu)l d3]sl%ndinuleJlco {95{9
ca©6)rfu gB {3261
c®ct QJIQJolal ©dJ]®oo €326l (oQioQ2Jl®(ore)192ee(To&@ coQal(ue}16)®o(TTr ©ul) 2023 (u)1(r`)oou6 ®o(r\)o 05 eelcDanlQ»3co g2c(TT)
alou(r\)a oujlchal aJ "lcg!e9-db6mces)led q]ends on.2il®lc86}mo.
ouneio:®leeQJRl
®1q2)®1:05/12/2023
=ou,°dimcofl:::ruom*#::8floqa#;=:e##eD£°a.Qgco:Tm#°::d=#:0:®Tc:R3mu::.chqun¥3:.fovQ@Scoed3enofnmu-maonm®"andch%ndmlorty
QR ctB,3oL)u (.`)udb3o3 @ajcD.mu ®onflcol@a3 en®u)1to,®oldbco Qoq] rucema))qi(m®e6"
GovBmment Of Kerala - Revoniio I)Bprrtmezit

56 WP(C) 9440/2024
10 .11.1999 .
ee .11 . , 9g in DI§cars§
REENrfuRA
8¥-pass RCun
.ts. a.G.frnomas. iteviEnpe

ifeifuvel±a presidBB over the meeting.
ffitA, din. &zseela -c4ary Kuruvilla, utuaicipal
Chai€pe[sau, e atza trEe land cltcers participated 18 the rree-ting.
me detailed actenaac]cE i6 giveB celcri;
'rml€isal
thalrrm,
3 , sri. Abraham Vazghsse. `ra[nsildar.givla.
4. KariREamzEhl &ikunarso, Vice! thaLrmaa
Strl I .fu "f]'armat€O CoHqctLi3r
se John, head Oiener a CouQciilor

" A.K. Hair, Land otyner
9. " George C.Varghese, Asst.Exja.£ngr. PcO{R)
10." a.V.Abranarty Land otoner
_a
11." I.J. Jltha, land earner
12." Muraleedbarap.G.M., Land owrler
q3."
`14. "A.AI. Kuruvilla,
itoharlaJcumal , hand
I.anaOwner
owner
15. " A. GQpakumar, Village ufficer, fl`rla.

16. " P.a. t:rtonias, Reweexue Pivisional L}fficer
ie*******
Ab the otitse€, ReveRAe Divisional uf±icer informed that sanction

for 'Jniruvalla By. -pass road. Phase-I(tlaz:huvangadicnira t,a Y€4CA) is
assured by the tton'ble i!rfuBister for P„D provided t.he required land
is relinquished oy the la]d owaeSs free of cost. ingi[]eels of
miruvalla t{oads Sub £ìvision naRre suomitced a project report. for
=.::.Sfu:?a?e:E.,:?.:=grmsata:dct±=:t®:£€#:;;:s¥Frportie:ntt°th::eia.n-;Gis".
provided by the land cMmers free of cost.
All persor)a atterfed the meeting i3greed that. construction of
a byxpass road is essential fior the develapment of thlruvalla and
::Its:i°£fr°ck:€±co°:st¥c¥:a:o¥f:Cb;:;gase:t:::a:nThi£::Gel:.:nggn.
unanimously putfo£€h a condition that: they will su[render t.tie
port.ion eothBg in the alignment for a 15 InEt.re wide road if and
I(conta. . 2. )
57 WP(C) 9440/2024
~ bevenQe ]2[ RE ...` .

to
The concerned.
K/yfj/rl/9lRl
uLirdth EL crmul a-pb honyut

ho wPCc)
dreck
58 WP(C) 9440/2024
.. 4`r-
eTLin_ P4
q.1 CDo.6"1- /3152/15 0onmja oulChlrffl6mds 63ocmTcrou, `
cO|©8qu%'
Fax & Phone : 04692601202

E.Mail .. rdo.tvla@,gH±
Date : 01-06-2015
OQJCT)j3 CullQJlrH6rr)di 63oQfficro6 ,
cO1®8QJ%.
`® gflgo d3,a d9,-s6

ulchmoam§
....2
59 WP(C) 9440/2024
- Ji8E-
Peyz
€9co3cHgl cruoar)al®ja3ro>led Egg cT7lEii6mof) 6]6)6"ulooulcr>u (BTaQjcojc23gg cTunejo
(gTaou]Oa8crooQjl Qjls8 6],d3]Os8da5)8QIocT8 mlel 9sac9,o8 coq2?ooocojl. Epcol6)in co8s6tmu

6>mco3Q]Q27o8 troo®dg]9±6m cr]1®ao cotmu atlejQJlan%otoTo>colmoco8 cool Cud)colcnj-
GgB9erTn@cfi®30, coat. 6>inol G8BcO6nnGQ§®3O OilEL6eno8 cO1®8Ou8!O Q8aacrolcHO
engr QOErlcr)j6m93O Qq83O flfl@d±s±cLjlif chaa]ro]8dbcD]8O colc@3Chg!O 03cfocrutcHOEfl
gn®86]s 9§Qti[`mqDQ;leJ3eg ofle]ou8o Ep 61qulQ2;lot Gocold9, goa2Jl cT7ld3,colcoJls8ag

coo6rT)®. @3§06>co `qJ3cdiulof.dn co)©co8aJ.6coflQ)86)s Ofe]Q]3o Gocold3,Qoonfl crf}acoro)1 EE
cO06mc.. Goacfflo coq]P6a}ro>s crflcQp:a o c6nlo6p]a|jcolco3 Q] (TT7
G)aJttD calacr78orfflgfl51%.; e99 atlcDi?a]Tonmu
all§3ggco°. Egg tn]orLr>al®jcoTCDlcoB

oatlm8 cQj6rfel agivls-8®6kyflcof7
co3mcolcDoed fucffl67al
cot)6)cO 8.6)6)6"QJocro°
00)coldsou
cgH
60 WP(C) 9440/2024
L=s`
lib -i _ fi82=
ièeChme
2di - a? 8L-_ Fn
\, and:.cTrfu-2rgifi2|14
c+,8€,`S`ngo, -.LoncTj.eels
eelejoc6T,®cgji€, colfrj` col 04,06JZ®JE

q€L`,
tul®r@coo®ls.
©1edcolided Gxro©sol,
OQicrife t6T3l] ) Qi®]rf,
®Cro©sol€cnga,
ataBQlcT>crtyod®O.
cnd,
Qncano:- Q6> cttl cocoa Qnrfuon" -®l®Ch@ ®ocathcolco ®Chena Gffl Qfls
__i.--I -I-I ù'¢
coen®Qiases ofl6QJoon
o3taolam -_rra^, ,~._ ___ -- aae®ast
cuteh cold3>Q82cmofcrf cog cmof
Cnin6"
q€dco ,-
ch3-29i2ireoi4 coond} d3>co®.
set end 30.03.15 ale g9® areQd)crtyled
d3rdGha alfD aeecq

dsrfuca tr
amQjca fLi©1cpen¢ljif
__..`..„„j2 04.04.2016aB
v¥.uiE,ziij.ace 8flgr
85Iep t8D®Sgas
%cng*%chaeHed==ee±®ul®=¥¥=O-i-`=ri£4u=scoqm%®*.
(dicoscmlap Qjedrf @esdae ®"cro,)
04o42oi5 ed fist® 6cQ>3coeel@a ®1onco©aeca ooonl a@eda@a®edonff

apEcq!ed cocrolched qutlco (5) ©daec% ®1®Oues c-ji2icae QtiQj?ca6need GnoQfflcri`ds
Onajijer, (6) @daeQfo Oleidods crundndd3Sap6neLdi`r `.rf: €,i:3`ûl``d\t"=\iu ' fo 'i. ~ : ~TL`:L|`'.'L
1491860
GOVEFiNM.F:NT nE: 17[n ^ . A
61 WP(C) 9440/2024
- fa# - P8fz
. I.j}ni&`,i-La 6,utcr`jjcd.c¥uf` ir,n.afi;c:,~j533ic,',:„ @a2mg| a®1 (cohiau) enl€ co&r[apeen©ees
.-Ss@crtrfu``con|ted fa±cacgiv Gil,,i tDc{Tj QìaeQi®,t;b,n,cs ®cadao 6")Jjj. iàii I)GE±Jflvm a-caajG 15 eddfo
®Scr. G3C,11cC};a`J'rj.`ni Cr)1ce3co6).-d3@1cr]3ds st cùn|co° 6)tfjs|: I:nd,asicoi=tac.roe Imrf.*
:ìedceD8ro6>®crco eecolc9u cflG,co®`-ds3ed one"Gf,., ì?1a±|er, crcoGjo (c7jlajo) ®6q21S col.`. `-ut?,
6)ds\S `|}%m6r¥)`colcf)a ¢tn6C6@®l cr)s!so6)aqrafii3GiT)° arc,e`tj.ffic6,G5it~,js en®Qjc,8jQ.
edep dsegiv
I
Qgesaeo : aealcD 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 o@crDIQiqpes aledrddined.
ca®gRE.s. JZ##Egf £
a 1 a f: 1 GOVERNMENl. OF KEFIALA
62 WP(C) 9440/2024
Frc,in,
Chandramohan
fy
S/ o Krishnapillai
Chandrimayil
Naduvile muri
Podlyadi
Pathanmthitta .
.TO,
The Thahsildar
Thiruvalla Taluk
Pathanmthitta .
®
Sir'
I an the absolute owner of 233 cents (94.25 ares)of land comprised in Re sy
® no.222/1 and 222/2 of Thiruvalla Village which was purchased by me as per
sale deed no.1526/2011,1527/20ll,1444/2010 and 2033/97 of SRO
Thiruvalla. The copy of the sale deed are produced herewith.
Though as per the village records the land is shown as "nilam" the nature of
the land was garden land in the year 1990 itself to which the provision of
Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet land Act 2008 is not applicable.
I have earlier made an application to know about the nature of my land in the
Data Bank entry and to issue me a certiricate regarding the same. I have come
0 to -understand that the village officer has conducted an inspection and I
understand that he has submitted an report stating that my land is not flt for
agricultural cultivation and that the adjacent land is also a garden land . The
copy of the letter by the ofrice of agricultural field office, Thiruvalla to prove
that the aforesaid land are garderi land is also produced herewith. When I
applied for possession certificate with the village office, I had been given a
digitally signed possession certiricate bearing no.9574054 dated 26,12`2014

63 WP(C) 9440/2024
Jf5=
Showing my property as "wet lan(i" as per the classification. My property lies.
under the Thanderpcr no. 10415 of Thiruvalla Village ofrice. It is also
submitted that the adjacent lands are also garden land as per the land bank.
register,
Under these circumstances I humbly request you to take necessary steps to
record that the land referred to above will not come within the purview of
Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet land Act 2008 and issue necessary
a direction to make necessary changes in the BTR and issue necessary certificate
to the said effect.
Dated this the 7th day of January, 2014
Chnadramohan.
0 dan-d'inark-e-d
Advorcate,
64 WP(C) 9440/2024
., Q\D
.
From, _ qz=:
Chandranohan, S/o REshnapillai,
Chandrima, Podiyadi.P.O, Thiluvalla.
To,
The Revenue Divisional Officer,
Thiruvalla.
Sub: Filing of application urider clause 6 of the Land utilization order.
® Ref: I. Data Bank in respect of pl.operties in sy No. 222/I and 222/2 of
Thiruvalla Village.
2. My request dated 7.1.2015 to the Tahasildar, Thiruvalla.
Kind and esteemed attention is invited to the subject and reference above
I am the registered holder of properties having an extent of 56.65 Ares in Sy.

No. 222/2, 16.19 Ares, 14.38 Ares, and 20.63 Ares respectively in Sy No.
222/I of Thiruvalla Village. As per the Data Bank prepared by the Revenue
Department the above lands were shown as reclaimed nilam with year of
reclamation as 25 years back. The above lands are in no way comes within
the purview of Act, 28 of 2008. Moreover the land was reclaimed 25 years
back and continues to be purayidam. By virtue of the decision reported in
Praveen Vs Land Revenue Commissioner reported in 2010(2) KLT 617, the
following principles were laid down by the Hon'ble High Court at para 15
" 15. It is true that if it is a paddy land or wet land, the provisions contained in
the Land Utilization Order has no application after the coming into force of
the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Land Act, 2008, namely,
with effect from 12.8.2008. But still it is open to dispute as to whether a
particular land is a paddy land or wet land or whether it is a land cultivated

with other food crops. Therefore, if an application is made under the Land
Utilization Order on the plea that the land in question is not a paddy land or
wet land, but cultivated with other food crops, necessarily before non suiting
the applicant, a fmding has to be entered as to whether the application is
sustainable under the Land Utilization Order and it will be depending upon
65 WP(C) 9440/2024
EZREIT Plo
OngeQ )
that, finding ,a§ to whether the land in question ill respec`t of which an
application has been made for permission is a land cultivated with food crops ..
other than paddy, or it is a wet land. If the authority before whom the
application made is satisfied on due enquiry and based on materials on record

that the land is one cultivated with food crops other than paddy or a wet land,
such application has to be processed in terms of the pi.ovisions contained in
the Land ullization Order. On the other hand, if the authority finds that it is
a paddy land or wet land, the application has to be rejected whereupon it is
for the party aggrieved to challenge the same in appropriate proceedings. Or,
on the other`hand, if he accepts the finding, then it is still open to him to
submit an application under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet
®
Land Act, 2008 for necessary permission before appropriate auriority in
0 wh'ich event, the said application will be processed in terms of the provisions
contained therein. The question as to whether it is a paddy land or wet land is
to be adjudged based on materials ctn record including the revenue record, if
any. It is true` that mere description of the property on the revenue record by
itself may not be conclusive and may not estopp a party from producing
materials to show otherwise. This being an assessment of the factual position
regarding the nature of the land, necessarily, it involves adjudication by the
concerned authority on the given set of facts and materials produced and one
or other factor by itself may not lbe conclusive; but a decision has to be
rendered taking into consideration the materials available on record.
Therefore, if an application is made under the Kerala Land Utilization Order,

the sane is not liable to be dismissed before an enquiry is held by the
concerned authority under the Act and a finding is entered that the land in
respect of whieh the application is made is a paddy land or a wet land. What
ousts the jurisdiction of the authority under the Land Utilization Order is
based on the finding as to whether it is a paddy land or wet land. If it is a
paddy land or wet land, necessarily, it stands outside the jurisdiction of that
authority in processing the application further or in granting any permission
sought for: On the other hand, if it is held that it is not a paddy land or wet
land, but cultivated with crops other than paddy, necessarily, the authority
ùnder the Land Utilization Order will have to process the application in terms
of the provisions contained therein and dispose of the sane."

66 WP(C) 9440/2024
FEE
Oagng )
In view of the Above it is submitted that there is no legal bar for granting
permission under clause 6 of the KLU Order. It is submitted that I wanted to

deve.lop the land further since a new bypass had come near the property®
Therefore permission under clause 6 may be granted for developing the
above land.
a 51.2015
This is the true copy Of do( arid riarked

in the abcIve`case as'Exhi
Advocate
•C
67 WP(C) 9440/2024
_ G5av 6:Lot PLL

IN THE IIIGH COURT OF KERALAAT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.R.RAMACHANDRA MENON
WEDNESDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2015/15TH MAGHA,1936
WP(C).No. 3262 of 2015 (G)
PETITIONER :
CHANDRAMOHAN, AGED 59 YEARS,

S/O.KRISHNA PILLAl, CHANDRIMA, PODIYADI P.O.,
THIRuVALLA.
BY ADV. SRI.S.NIDHEESH
RESPONDENT :
a+ ,,,,,.,` ~ i
1. THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER,

THIRuVALLA€89 101.
2. THE TAHSILDAR,
TALUK OFFICE, THIRUVALLAto89101.
R1 & R2 BY SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRl. K.C. VINCENT
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAV!NG COIVIE UP FOR ADMISSION

oN o4ro22oi5, THE couRT ON THE SAME DAy DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
bp
~.
68 WP(C) 9440/2024
.. fi,... `
P " I 2
P.R. RAMACHANDRA MENON, J.
,
W.P.(C) No.3262 of 2015
I ,, I I,
Dated this the 4th day of February, 2015
JUDGMENT
The petitioner is stated as owner of the properties having an
extent of 56.65 Ares in Sy No.222/2,16,19 Ares,14.38 Ares and
20.63 Ares in Sy. No.222/1 of Thiruvalla Village. According to the
petitioner, the said lands are 'i,either 'paddy lands', nor 'wet
lands' as defined under Section 2 (xii) or 2 (xviii) of Act 28 of
2008, though they have been described as 'Nilam' in the revenue
records. It is stated that in the Draft Data Bank published by the
respondents, the properties of the petitioner are not included as
paddy lands or wet lands. Though the petitioner has approached
the first respondent by filing Ext.P7 representation under Clause
6 of the Kerala Land Utilization Order,. seeking permission to use
® the lands for other purposes than agricultural purpose, the same
is still to be considered, which made the petitioner to approach
this Court by filing the present writ petition.
2. Heard the learned Govelnment Pleader as well.
:'.
69 WP(C) 9440/2024
•.. Ji3.
W.P.(C) No.3262 of 2015 2
P"/3
3. The law has been declared as per the decision rendered
in JafarKhan Vs. K.A. Kochumarakkar & Ors. [2012 (1) KHC
523] that the provisions of the Conservation of Kerala paddy
land and Wet land Act are applicable only in respect of the land
which were lying as 'paddy land' or 'wet land' as on the date of
commencement of the 'Act'. It has been further asserted by
another learned Judge of this Ct)urt in Asharaf K.K. And Ors
Vs. Eramala Grama Panchayath and Ors (2012 (3) KLT
323) that if the land is not included in the Data Bank Register
prepared under the Act, it cannot be classified as 'paddy land' or

'wet land'. It has been declared by a Division Bench of this Court
in Praveen Vs. Land Revenue Commissioner (2010 (2) l{LT
617) that, if the property conc'`=rned is not a paddy land or wet
land, the application if any preferred, is to be considered under
the relevant provisions of the Kerala Land Utilization Order, so as
® to enable the party concerned t:o make use of the property for
other appropriate purpose, It has been further made clear by a
Division Bench of this Court in Suni[ Vs. Killimangalam
Panchal 5th Ward Nellulpadaka Samooham (2012 (4) KLT
511) that the land reclaimed Prior to the commencement of the
q.
70 WP(C) 9440/2024
W.P.(C) No.3262 of 2015
5¢ P"I+
relevant Act can be made use of, even for 'Industrial purpose'
4. In the said circumstances, the first respondent is
directed to consider and pass appropriate orders on Ext,P7 in the
light of the observations made by this Court in the decisions cited
supra and also after obtaining a report from the Agricultural
Officer. This shall be done after giving an opportunity of hearing
to the petitioner, at the earliest, at any rate, within 'two months'
from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
Petitioner shall produce a copy of this judgment, along with
copy of the writ petition, before the first respondent, for further
steps.
The writ petition is disposed of.
s}\/
P.R. RAMACHANDRA MENON,
JUDGE
SP
®
V
71 WP(C) 9440/2024
WP(C).No. 3262 of 2015 (G)

"`r/
.. f7..,f
ALEiEjRE
PETITIONER(S)' EXHIBITS
EXT.P1 : TRUE COPY OF THE SALE DEED DATED 14nr/1997.
EXT,P2: TRUE COPY 0F THE SALE DEED DATED 10/6/1999
EXT.P3: TRUE COPY OF THE SALE DEED DATED 31/5/2001.
EXT.P4: TRUE COPY OF THE SALE DEED DATED 31/5/2001.
EXT.P5: TRUE COPY OF THE DATA BANK DETAILS.
EXT.P6: TRUE COPY OF THE REQUEST TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT

DATED 7/1/2014.
EXT.P7: TRUE COPY OF THE REQUEST TO THE IST RESPONDENT

DATED 5/1/2015.
RESPONDENT(S). ExlllBITS NIL.
IITF\UE COPYII
EE
PA. TO JUDGE
bp
RIEzi
®
72 WP(C) 9440/2024
&Lul- P,a
EElil-
From
alicT3caociococT8
al(cT31ca
6)OJOSICQ)Osl all. 63
col®8Ch%.
OQicoj3 OulChlcfl6med
63 c>Qfflcro: col©3oug!.
coGi,
col©3Qig!o QIJ1€g!gffled cnd)6)cP gso(i`mcoon)lai3o ce>©o co5l©8QicQ;taJ8o egg ol(roa}ec2|
222/2, 222/ 1 ed6]csy§ ul8©on>lseBr3ed agrfl§° 6]eioued 6>alq=)3cmcolcT>° c3Qi6ingl 6roocin3
ci\)adcstl2] amc3cHce]£lon51cT3c3aed col®3Q]ocT)a 96neocB,ocoTo)cog 6)cEbc] 6ne° 6TCDc)ciB 6T2iaLo3oo
cD6]di§ €d3,©90 6]6]Ooecff.OsO>1Q2>led wp(c) NO.3 262 Gce,ci\>1ed cL®cT>1cE]5>-cOcT]8db3
elc]ocD>1 QlilcL51 g6nsoQ2>l§3ggcoo6m: c3aed QlilcDl (oid3,c>©o cLi3®coj`so 6]E]Qled 6>p]qp8c\nD
colcD° coiDonci@jaoQ2> €aed cT]scLS`cEbc¢ ce]c>E2]coocacT\>o ce>3so6)co coslcocro)l©aoco)l
g!corcD©Qioce,6iT]c, cnd)CTT)a coc>9°aQ>oon51 cor@Q3old3]g]1cfas>3cm8.
20-02-2015
cO1©3QJg!
999Sdsoo:
1. 612lcLo3aocT)6)d¥§ 6)6)aLoecffi)OScolon)86)S goro)®QIJ16)c8} a3ce.Ocfj\ g9 Ccoc)6)Sodio
Qoc>so©Odso3Cm8.
nu<i Yh-th cj5ptrr\ q+-Pta 'T`%ti±7

W @ Cc)
drocut
73 WP(C) 9440/2024
Ezii €LunP ,3
a 5 a,a
J2 g £€.5? a 5€
1
£ €.i.:i
%
:i i. !e
+?5 ?iT?:g
C' Q!
E
111111:
Ce Ce` .ii a
aa 8
€ € aq9
a C,
ii
ut aC,
i%>j
I.9.
iJE
a a aa
e> a
E i ! E 0<C>
aa.8
® Ivat',
t^Cn 00,V1
a
XLL]
'0
cOce a r, 0\
a€ n
#=.
C>®®
€ S
®
€
® ae iin to
e9 n
•ri `€ 5a i.5|e
2 €=§
¥ g €C'
S
2i
i
Zaàa6a)
•;
ii::\ ii: i
c8
LEa aiii 0'8 aun
Ii+
E
ij
i+i: :ii?
i
5.
I
tit .¥.t:'`:....: `
.i£.:z
a ®cO
¢ ±.i+?
Z a r`
_#'5 Z r'
ctn un0\
ija 0
_aCQZ ur\
0\ aun,
CU
0L^
CVCN
C\ ' 1 \kJf.f£
® r`r. 00
a¢I \/
£ C.r r` rr)r\ Ch
rlr ¢r Cr
r^ e `\:1I.I,I::/i:G`•=.,`,,
7£Lft: hahp¥3tr fi &£' P13 \=|+,i¢+`tc`J`

74 WP(C) 9440/2024
?\|t
. 6.ce,.6ml.9n 26/2Oi4-15
EZI=I- frLir -P '/
d3>5cffll GChcT8
I 3/03/2015
€iulalcoed
cola(colcfucd g] odd ad\edcu]° 63oQdlcv\]cB
d3]5a211 Gchch
cO1©3QJ8!.
croDd3bdentDoal.
c31 oChcDj3 ciLJlonlcE]6med 6]ocrfltroG}
coto3Ch8!,
in)a}
cana£]QD>O : iG®l alicT3cac>aoch, al(crfla. 6]Qios`02>Osl Qnco>ed 6]alcooco cy]ha6Br3ed
d3]c}doffla3d3>co® a]©Qicoj6gr3cdcco° 9oJ®cn)ooflcEE)3cmcolcrjJ a3T@ cD8acol
das>Oon}l eniQ03. a3d3>©a 6]6]Of>a3dsoc>scoldrled QOQDed 6Dalcoc'cO
cocinJCEhfflaD86)s oya®cD]Q216rr) cflesiod§° crocadrflcfso8cTDco° croo6r2ICTutLif
co3alcD : coo a®3-766/ 15 6t2lQO8. C)ChcDj3 c\lJIChcE16rDed 63oaJflcro036)§
o5-oa-2ol 5 6)al cB]a]ro:
c3aed d3>06mlgfl®lcfso3cTv) (ald3>o©o |G61. al(cT]cac)QocDCT5, al|cTfla, @aJoslcoogl
oD36)s cTunE2io €cD©ts° cEb6ne° 6enlocaDj6)cH§3 cit)d€Q[ 222/2, 222/ 1 n®crfuQla2flaJ8 6)ul§
56. 65 @\©d, 1 6. 1 9 .gl©d. 2o. 63 @[Dd a®aT5] crfu65r3ed d5]®s°cu>ogo6Dio©]1ed cT5ldborzD3

ul3©Oflsaoap5l c®6M6]dHs3orcDlco51@1d=>3cm3. c®crDoed =colch cL®cB]€oc®o 5o
6)cro€q?09: 'coldbcm cTunEHaocojl cB]o6ro6)dTs3cm3. 5` cmE2IorzD16)cP Qlsdso3QJc®o
ec]ocu)3o ul516roro)oo° cwhs8o ora6m: 6)cods)3o, a,1gda5)a 6)cod=)a Qisda5]oen51 cocalco°
_atco3cfioofl dB]06m3crD\8. g2co° o¢)d3.€c3c©o 20 6>ce]og!corcDled dg]3s8coal8 d3boeio
db5dffl 6]alqpocol5l©1das>8cro alco3cfr cv`miaoco5l ora€cDic£16morcDled c36T2IocaDj6]al§1®1

da;)3cTD8. S\ oucro°co3QlilcD° acaDjcooDa}rcD3 ce]351 6)6)6n]alocit)° €c)c)c\L)a cL16ml cDscTT)3
6]d3,06rra©ldae8cTTJ3.
g2 9 oleslod§° qr@deco>36>s @r@oloflEud=>oofl cr`mddidas)3cTD3.
99E!Sdsoo
1. ce]®s° cu>09oonlo83il6)cP cLld3]dcff
c9fu` rd; ou 6~ c" ot fit . P`}

h~ed.i trycc).
twtrcJi
75 WP(C) 9440/2024
\` r|+iyRExpL
rffl6rr)(Cr?u630rffill{rooi6)SmS`~JS1(,iba.ìr.7
EEI=IE(!il
a : ao. Gcj73<ife}Eof.)
®a,cQ,tj,^, : 1 8.o4.2C `, 5
6"rLO}. Gca>®90 6)6)of)Cd3®osfo}}6)S 04.02.20156)a

WP(C)2262/ 15(G) mo,r+kBlcn)}6)s arosl(unom(oTo)îds 9(oToi®ou
medce,}On®u cru06"mvutngu'
Crulalm: 1)icol.alinec®oof>nd,ajicBTfa@uloslchosltTu®dfane]eeGulding±.
2)6"Of>2. cd3,©90 6t6tQ{teda36ios®lcQj}6ts o4.o2 2o 1 56tEu .
ae¥5?:a#4dyfr WP(C)No.3262/ 15(G) tTto.g<oro>©Quj.

3) @iroicolco6>oBe]8 ridiedtuu ®ooj]d\crvd, ®1®}ones®j®s
l 9.03.20156)fl KBT26/14t5 coo.olGtlo@5.
4)®1®}ougoulcg!£63onD1{r\)oxps09.04.20156)f2J197/15mo.
#stTh,®On9T#ffio@g.
`g:Tg:%i#fe;i£%aT:nflg:®%ra,:':a::tlsut„,::t,To9nap%rde2r°6t36::
* * * + * , * , . * * * .. . * .......
Oubou(1undbo8d)6)a QJlccoQ)®o®1 mldb(ore)a(TT)colmu t8ram}a®1®Vce6)OCQ)1 6`ms}itnio

ch€s}aelde ms}ounceja}olce/led alpel®®1ed d9,brfl'6malng£ Ddbnd ic®a\. alineG®oof7nd
go ifeo®6oej®colct tgTaGalce,a± "aidaldl®}m7i. co,iso6t® sl rulc"cDtoro>1de
6"co}. Cd9>®90 6)'6)of)Gd}6)os®1®1ct WP(C)3262/15 mo. Gdinou}o nj]®ct
6ialGD®1§i99®06mu, ;a ©yDculdbg±®1cmed ®1®aouB! OnnG%gfu 63OAalty\jd O}6Ljom>l®0
olpg]o®§U ei@6aod>@1®®1de ayocalcfag±®1at al®o®®cold±oa(in onej6or3uO
co6ald9"dhmocQ) icol. aline6Q)oar)6)r$ 9sq](Tuj]®co)1f2J}o 6j6)ceDQJco(oro>1eJ]o d33®o
di®2QJQJleJ}o 9ef cnleJ6oiBo8 ¢Toco]!.m}.. toTasltrunom @icrilc8,}®1 ®gB1"olej}o
®6rfeGq]® ®eBl"01E2]}O cOIE2jo @ygcQtl G®6u6jtls}trmtlQ2tl§}98 sl tTunej6BT308
.67al®6®orfe Gootuled mltTT7}o tcTo©o@lalv r®o.trul.Gootujled n®mju.oe)rfo.rujl.all.
6"1ctoulocol6>o§ ®}nBQico(oro' coQjm)omlco67}(in coooul6>n3 gs®2oucotoro)o®1
rml®1 6Ialg}}(irT)®]o QJ®fffl6engo®1 dibQgdl g2fio6tco m®1cooQ2)1 d3]1sdrs)}{m®}o
Ouaof4dboEu(01ro) 6)oug£6)d}6)§}6rT3odb}m)®}®06)6TT)(in , oulGRIg3u 63ornalm)a
(irunEial®1Gcoococo ms(ore)1 ol6tiod§U 6taldJ®l©1drst}(TT)a. dhiso6t®
atg6W)ondm(oro>1mo®1 ®qpoood36>1®l®1d>6>}tTT7 db®5 6ou806nlo8folej}o sl Qlmuuco}

mlejo tcTg®1§06mu c©ou67eds}turo>1®l®1dB67}m®V ooonu oun€s!gu3U 63ondimj@ olGedQ®5
6talcojv®1®1cD6tim7}. sl oulrffl®trm>1de 6"oft!, 6ce]®90 6t6iof)cdsoos®1®1de
anGalcefld3,n6 aj]Qjde 6talQ2Uiu® sl WP(C)3262/1.5 mo. Gc9,"1de 04.02.2015de oulu)1
al|o6>eds!di2n§ie9®96mv. culcD1®i9s ialoucoi@Ou76ueuo al}Ou6ts Gal®d36timi}.
3). The law has been declared as per the decislon rendered ln
Jdfdr'Khan.K.A.Kochumarakkar & Ors ( 2012(1)KHC 523) that the provlslons of the
"C\onservatlon of Kerala paddy land and.Wet land Act are applicable only in
.respect of the land whlch were lylng as ` paddy land' or `wet land' as on the date
of commencement of the Àct'. It has been further asserted by another le.arned
Judge of this Court ln Asharaf.K.K. And Ors Vs. Ercimala Grama Panchciyath and
Ors (201.2(3),K+T 323) that lf the land ls not Included ln the Data Bank Register
.iI
76 WP(C) 9440/2024
es=g=Qrbe^d.u:dertheAct,Tfa±
REliTt.I." .
___: `'Fir::b;?::tD=j:i:ntbb_ec!aaslfledasc

h:;S£.,=sn,odnee:Igiro:,:oe=2;,C:;I:t,DS:±tBbeencc:aQS'::e=;
ShQL+,
Padc,y
v,:uh=_y lona' or .wet
=r°:T.jssioner(=oiuo=9X::+e.
1, ,_._
7n;iF=itb::fnti=?::g==cu:tv:iipf_ay_v=oennairto==.t|
r:;et:;t':fodjjs/t::s:::i':aKt:::/:fL:::::ef€"ed"oha^
:;S#o:s:(has;g^;2ih::TaK:£r7n::SiSn;;pi,a:=g±:*torfov:=cb±Pe:nayêv^£.e:snan;o=rLno:j==t=
concernec/ ro mJ~'' •:I u FJac]Cfy ll`5r`,.:
J=S;eetha^°:rtab:y=Lpa:on%U=:;:;Qotr=±b::°±;:a==pbsreoopa=Q:o:aeShb=:nJe~=;tndhdd¥:':rhis
S:#mSidckne:r=^:C.SSt§bh;y=dLP;eon,§u=:Ub=:a;:;Zfn::r=±_:§::a=:fpbsre°=hpa:::°Q:i:ae:;±pb=fs=:tndhdd¥:Ss
itr=oûiL=rdte°r,bseoacs°:oS'aQ=^;~5_LP=ndd%r'a;:i
;;se;;;=T:df::a::RE;5e;:po;;p::hh:y§d=o;seosein::::;fn:;:;e:ano:::oS:aoee::;£eSva::£=:;:cfcp:a:;n`:;:h:;:h;v;Haas=
u,?n°tf;eevsea:df°cr,:#m=.:+:;Ira:°ptu=poCs°e'>
t!:ftpff:t,p:h=.:Qe;Piuftih*.i.;hC.c:ad::eSfoec:dp§aaRE;;;;:h:na;::p!:=::a;u;o:p=:rfhaf
• i:r,t:hhfiu:t§§;jfos§:ni:r:ee:t:;:poor;:£^:t:h_r':g'`:±pg;:onof°n°;::Sriu:i:oefpih°ai£:r:§na°fga±:P:ye;p:;pgSSc§tr:Sp¢;
.of th|:Iuud`:=:nct.
w:tp.et:::=fo:::::P.rf:£ur==p=n%:=:rtfh:Srf!ue:gst==:
etp¥=:o:h::;®ep.rf:£u::=p=ncd°epn:;::;f;;rf;:e°::t±tdaat:on°:r:te::Pectop°p;yt:t::te:e
;=£0%n::£.,2a015i:i:#
3SS£RE%£#;f]gs:3;2:RE;b:m£:®=:_S%:efaef#§§§
.d\ I a
. ®no'\ A ,.
¥£®F®toapeeed®.A
:::i:_.==:::::::::II:i:::;::i:i:i:::i::::`:i`::.::::I::::1;::::
.:::::,:;:I;:::::::::::::::I::::;i::::::::i::::.::::=:::i;:::::::::::::::i::.::.:::::``:::;i¥:iig¥
U®.1o\A,~. _
c?:%¥ig;7g%=8£+gj rfufs;:OS:vr;::;.a:;£ck¥O£:sd;':¥c:9#O:1::
cB,&ngn 63OOL}
ddeddund ®®rdin
arfua.ul tlu .
77 WP(C) 9440/2024
2oo§talaco
dr @ ,s
qu GrLIJ{o)Ob"()ds' `| I.A."8t.|jl@8 ,|oof: , ,+J.
;OnooDOorb't3®OuiT;?`j`srmfty'.i'q]pito)c06`;``\t,``'``,
~Thcac 25f.,jrfmin
'm^,+i:
oTo)oftt5 ___ , ^
crl)©l¢to
_` „
mioerrjfDIGor,ou,(o
`, „„.„5d„",I±mrmunrfu
,``.:u"frolq}o EEMEEEEEEEEi
oJ)G.;es83` r>3orif}1rrut`,.I ~.
T,?!o to,!rffi`163orrdlmuoledmlmar>ej6!aicicaefudetlodsloaco.®s`(8onoo6"cit=.
tlcfrodsstttl®1CcOOculfa®1a!o 6)6)ou®`r3i4ina6rie®1OcD
A~~.
.v~,±ù,,t±do 6>6>Ou®!r2¢6O ®7a..sdrinu.
` _ Ù I erot|Ot.ia,
u 1 LJ ' t=
(,Jlg26moulman>1mo®1
iiocDI QJIGe!g3U 63orrdlouo!o uetcokeoae]® rm?asou)' 63ounlmjo^^
®9Ooot06)163ru)
63tl! (£thfhlf`^ ie`1 _
c®ou@tls2cobn§!eg~cfo®sU erujoo 6"08fol6trti
IvJvlulÌu061
]0_ ~+ù u,ùJ(Ow 6"otBbl6)r(i
sorl^n°)rv` `1ul _1__
ttrroGodd9]soommej6ueoa
`.`.w.uuìiuej6enoo mlejb an®Q2tl totcim.®06mv
. G'fio6u6jtls.òro)1Qul§aee@iJ
_a~y„ ,iiùii.I;u`jilj ig(a)l¢r8..,')
; oum',Cereyoa°#::de ,:i:`3: _¥e!®oce6)1 at®1Gcooi|ng®ict )
cfo|s06t®> ®i®!Ou# 6t676Tudiotru cOOoulorfe e®}Qjco6coelejocD1 : rml®„
6)alg!rm®!o Gooon oulco,oum6)co ®!?®mu ouo6mlee6 iruou)o(r)io
Q®6to®a8£®a®O®slcolalencamlc&coam®1mvtorama®@lEu@1c06i!rm®tlGejc96>06rri'
WP(C) ru®o®1cs,d3Ejl ico®1co!m®u 6>Qjeg6truoGo mj®cQjcou 6}Qjaeo 6tcs,§1
dblsd96)arm eo ialc;@coo mlce3co!rm®)1mu corr)!®®1 mctco>!m)d` ruo®1onl®1rfu
irucoum6aeu6d}6tio g3ejd9flo®colap3o 9s®oco!o 6t6)onatoouin.1¢caoan
6::::::°gr!o°un::e,::s,fir:%:,::I inN,:: ®:#::®:®!m®# db!S06)a n]®o®®co

rfe 9aJ®1CQ)0®1 6"co!. Gd9]®90 6)6)nJ)6)c66)OS®1®}6)S 04.02 20]56)a WP(C)
•3S£%natm=nn=o`£S®o:S=an£§*XS£;S_=`©:o%ds°co2n2±°n=53=®¥P(Cs)n
oulnaJ®colctcoslmupomaocdso6ne®}®o®JafarKhanVsKAKochuMarakkar&
Ors(201?(I)KHC' 523 )ancol®1ct Gd8,®§5 6jrr7dsoucDct ®t6mldcos ouo®enen
ml®®o\mleJQjldsoum6coog±oPaddyland63owetland63ongcoJ1§!9L®ou®Vcol
:::®rfe°:Ucoa::u®§:mu°coal%oOu®%#nga ®rfeng:3S T::gon®mat:n%:°

®6ml@cos rruo®eeon mlQ2t®o {atd8.o®o ®qpoooccol comula
oule26moalmowlmocejlmedd3,loo;1§!aedb®sVcou"6"08g,1ctae€uldanomjI]erenca
:i:`::::i::::::::=::::::::;::::::::::i:i::i:;`::i:::::::i:::`:
®"1@cos ouo®coig±on colQ2j®o 2008 ialco>o®o mJ®ccoo®1di rDlmao anco!®®1
® Qioc6u86ne®06mvr®m)!rfuo.6m3m3.
`2o63aped?2:2;2coctal®®£§T::#5£%Oum¥erou:Cfa::;:#co;:3/1:8:¥®§®'T6®ul;@g®®i
mJ!alm 0 tatc6.o®o ou®®fanelt§29e®!o WP(C) Gd9.mulct Ext P7 ,anocQjl
Ouofotlnal§39g®3®o®co€ulou®g£1®1®!®omlaluggcolmoffl89rm©oi.A`rm`
9orU)©"Od93}rm3
78 WP(C) 9440/2024
- frf- 2hitry -P ,6
IN T[m HIGH cOuRT OF KERALA AT ERNAK(}ILziM
PRESENT
TEIE IIONouRABu= i4R. -USTICE ALEXANI>ER THOMzrs
m]:DA¥, THE 24TH I]Ar oF Iul,I 2o2o / 2NI> SRAVENA, ig42
WP(C) .No.34997 0F 2019(Y)
pEIIIIom/S :
CHANI)RA MOHAN, ZIGEI) 63 YEARS, S/O KRISHNA PII,IAI,
cHAI>Eum, poDIAI>I. p.a, THIRITVAI,LA TAI,uK,
pATHANAiorHITTzi I)ISTRlcT, plN-68911o .
BY Ays.
® SRI .VARUGRESE M EASO
SRI.VIVEK VARGEESE P...
REsrormENI/s
1 TI]E I]ISTRlcT col[LECTOR, pATHANanHITTA

clvlL STATION , pATHANAnorHITTA . p . o ,
PATHENAMTHITTA DISTRICT , PIN-689645 .
THE VIIilAGE OFFICER,

THIRUVAI.IA VII.LACE , THIRUVAI.LIL . P . 0 ,
pATHANAirml]ITTA I]ISTRlcT, plN-6891ol.
THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER,

RD0 OFFICE , THIRtJV?I,IA , THIROvAI,IA . P . 0 ,
pATIIANAiorHITTA DlsTRlcT , PIN-68 91o 1.
THE TAISIIiDAR,
THZIIiuK OFFICE , THIRtJVAI,IA, THIRIJVAI.I,A . P . 0 ,
pATENanlllTTA DlsTRlcT, PIN-6891ol .
TEIE I,oczil, LEVEI, MONITORING cormlTTEE,

REPRESENTEI) BY ITS CONVENOR,ZIGRICULTURAI. OFFICER,
THIRUVAI,IA KRISHIBEIAVAN , ZIvtJMBHAGAM,
THIRt7vAI.In. P.o, PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRlcT, plN -689101.
STATE OF KERAIA, REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAI.

SECRETAYR,DEPAR"ENT OF REVENUE,
SECRETARIAT , THIRtJVANANTHAPURZ\M-6 9 5 0 01 .
OTtrR PRESENT :
SRI. SAIGI JAcOB pAIATTr, sR.GOvT.PLEADER
TIIIS WRIT PETITION (CIVII.) HAVING CchE UP FOR ADMISSION 0N

24.07.2020, THE cOuRT ON THE sAeE Day I]EI.IVERED THE FOI,I,OwlprG:
79 WP(C) 9440/2024
i-',`. .J__
: :2 : :
ALEXANDER THOMAS, J.
W.P(C).No.34997 0f 2019
Dated this the 24th day of July, 2o2o.
OMEN
The prayers in the above Writ Petition (Civil) are as follows:
i) Issl!e a u)ri±_ Of niandamus or other appropriate u]rit,

order or call for the records Of entry Of 'u)ei-land' in the
Bqsic Tax .Register maintained by the and responderit
related to the Exhibit Pl to P4 properties.
ii) Iss¥e_uJr|l of mapdamus Erecting the let respondent to

cqprf or the records relating to the -Exhibit P9 alnd Plo and
allou]. these appttcatione ujithout insisting to comply the
provisions Of 2oi8 amendment in the -rierala
Co.psepration Of Pnddy land and u)et land Act, after
aife`rqing. an oppgrtuntty tp the petitioner f lr hedrring
\!!ithin the time frame to be fixed bu this Honourable
Cburt.
iii) Issue any other appropriate u]hi, order or direction also

may be granted to meet out justiee under the
circumstances Of the above case, and
iv) Cost of this proceedings. ®

2. Heard Sri.Varughese M.Easo, leaned counsel
appearing for the petitioner and Sri.Saigi Jacob Palatty, 1eamed
Senior Government Pleader appearing for the respondents.
3. Sri.Vamghese M.Easo, leaned counsel appearing for
thepetitionerwouldsubmitonthebasisofinstructionsofhisparty
that leave may be granted to the petitioner to withdraw the Writ
Petition with liberty file a fresh Writ Petition after making

80 WP(C) 9440/2024
P,t/3
. fa.-
: :3 : :
lJP(C) .No.34997 0F 2019(I)
comprehensive pleading regarding the factual grounds, etc.
Liberty is accorded to the petitioner to work out his remedies in the
hanner known to law.
With the said liberty, the above Writ Petition (Civil) will
stand dismissed as withdrawn.
®
Sd/-
AIEXANDERTHOMAS,
Judge.
bkn/-
®
81 WP(C) 9440/2024
t,,6/,
::4::
WP|C) .No.34997 0F 2019(Y)
APPENDIX
PETITI0NER' S/S EXHIBITfi
EXHIBIT P1 TRUE copy oF sam DEEI] No.2o33/97 or

SRO TIRtJVAIiLA I)I .14/07/97 .
EXHIBIT P2 TRIJE COPY 0F SALE DEED NO.1527/01 0F

SR0 THIRUVAIIIA I)I. 31/05/01.
EXHIBIT P3 TRtJE COPY 0F SALE DEED NO.1526/01 0F

SR0 THIRtJVAI.ILA DT. 31/05/01. ®
EXHIBIT E>4 TRtJE COPY OF SAIJE DEED NO.1444/99 0F
ee SR0 TIRUVAI-IA DT .10/06/99 .

EXHIBIT P5 TRUE ,COPY OF TIRE LAND TAX RECEIPT
DATED 14/06/2019 BY THE VII,IAGE
OFFICER,THIRUVAI.LA.
EXHIBIT P6 TRUE COPY OF THE MINUTES N0 A3-

389/1999 HELD 0N 10/11/1999
EXHIBIT P7 TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER N0 a/3152/2015

DATED 01/06/2015 BY RDO,THIRUVAI,IA TO
I)ISTRICT C0Iil.ECTOR.
EXHIBIT P8 TRUE COPY 0F THE REPORT N0 C2-912/14

DATED 04/06/2015 0F
COI,LECTOR , pATHZINrmH I I TA
THE
TO
DISTRICT
THE
®
PRINCIPAI,
sECRETARy , REVENUE (a) I]EPT . sECRETjmlAT ,
THIRuvAENTHApuRm4
EXHIBIT P9 TRUE COPY OF THE REQUEST TO TI]E 4TH

RE§PONI)ENT DATED 07/01/2014 BY THE
PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT Plo TRUE COPY 0F TRE REQUEST T0 The 3RE

RESPONDENT DATED 05/01/2015 BY THE
PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT Pll TRUE copy OF THE ruDenENT DATED

04/02/2015 IN WP(C)NO.3262/2015 0F
THIS HON'BIE COURT.
82 WP(C) 9440/2024
-``` S -
f,6/5-
::5::
llp(a) .No.34997 0F 2019(I)
EXHIBIT P12 TRtJE COPY OF TIIE RE PRE SENTAT I ON

DT . 20/02/15
EXHIBIT P13 TRt]E copy OF THE RELEVANT PACE OF I>Am

BANK NOIIFICATION .
EXHIBIT P14 TRUE COPY 0F THE I,ETTER NO.KBT

26/2014-15 I)ATED 13/03/2015 ISSUED BY
THE 5 TH RE SPONDENT TO THE 3RI)
RESPONDENT .
®
Tmh=:;3inaestE#°BFTy°S£6°Cumen(,
Atw~ re/erred
In the above case
ADVOCATE
®
83 WP(C) 9440/2024
I {{} pfl" =jfti`q€ /I? c{Jd.i,hh3/2Sao.
rifi tlf f iJ gp/ ity)Dd art)a/ i;`+rj) I \Ijt:]J£¢i Juf `3 J 9£ì

`Sd,s)3ti]anir.Le:j':;rf;%';;I;:"'J£::::J
i+JrnrJ n.hif ;9ral £# c7f tyf f l&$8¢3f itJ ri;¢n}rfu ed 9 nalriiG{al `
~J fa±`1I iTrf `^{ if `f.rf rf)r/ ®;i;,i{3 r~;i.csc> c25if uljp,a
Sraul`+ cn,J®2¢ult~ r56`Gr /hiapal edjLfejc28o eri.rtt 3.
•J ¢1 f. c,.)
rd cr\,J cnr)crr`]b F`, cheal fd!! cj`.EELg Ò
Fr\¢r`.cer} / jiìn3at &j |}#< ,rke€£ ,fit,4 iELrcBcal C'`CF}3Off)Of
Cì\ S} rTif@ rtnGàl# r`,a . C\) rtLe€_) c=:fro/ r3£ff fuL'(

'` ingnal2m ` cfT+i c`y6ftyof\. rfuna=t.,ted .3.rEal n<~}acnd. jnal y„
Iy`kejtl::~rd 9_a =:+ al_rn al a onin.ae P3#p I RA{

Ont4 £aiS QJc4 dhig i rc) E3&3 a . ,xp ri}rtS ryr® a£Ùs `S+3 .Tr^v
''.jl 1'4G/t?` r?..i 11 {>|rrd rt,/,Qf\1J

r' flrtyLL €Jcb cTm 3 c3£` c3/ r/ `9 t5 _ ftiìgr a lair) '3`y+:lco( a,£|
i€ri`so i c A £ùg tnga) rt, a+i?. ,) ±}j +al , c``~ ,ii cr75`j 9 g~j ¢ifrE .
' \jf:\, c¥if e.T..] .i rT^`>
`..'ti_gr
`j (3)
±~A, ` jt t,fj3c,]O p3gr . {=kyf5
r`; :i Lz3¢LAfTt`:'!| ca
ik`,\ÈE|
c5't t
p i.t:, r.„
•,
3`:th c`,1 rT>,`2., c\It`C`,\,.3qT,®t
=~ijJ=al,.3`,JjJ}4'rli,I;.,i
•., 1.,i ) 1 +,ì 3cì` i:.±+jp cdi r..., _i ` Gn `r .
EL=
r` `\rfe`'\ i I ri,\if` GJ `+j*g3 `,,i ck+ \t"'`s ` rJt. ¢`'9 3J. f`lcBll}
*iql
84 WP(C) 9440/2024
/
r¥fir;„ ]U r` \hj<, €```bo \q=2, €ìf§'\ ::,,i C, 3'. G`(+ . c.ii! `*|pr#±I`
i,.` ,,;fyi ;r
'\=j,|iL}`t€\.\`=*)Srfur`^|~€J(u~\!iG^v.Q`¢`J$2J(j`¢,„d
jS{|£¢èneJ 9,_Ja=J `nlal ` u```:ni±\34' l`Lr3 n^"

~ I ill c3j) `<+dihji`ffe& ,`2.±j€.i L±..en\t'. c}`cij€cf.ut3QL); ,
I `` ` _I I ci}dr¢i#dritJCiqBJs
~\3` `:.i:,,¥~`,\ '\i=\ sàa\\, 3aj\R ITJ`Ò jqu
C\ruLn al `Stw`\,,a)*_ haled ,a c=."ap +`~:, jcmj c.L`C~=>fl,JR `` fry?J 3
+;`lTSI Q i~too L`ù.3isT `ctjrfu . I `b r@ f9?j`\ sO {3j5~)c.ìI,d

`\.:f,'cJ'`+JdltaurLr?+5'¢i`)~di r=fai.cT``3.
E
f2i`,it\ iaowul S'13Jrfu I. tin+i i, i
¢^JL}`\` A,)Q\J ' ,it+H:} fib G&j ~,u3u rngj.qs f{ h_t£\JJts lTfi} .
I_in_?.I?.P=T#.€.po_p_yoLdg.c.um\epr
markedAa#%r#BgTEa/%Ofe[r;a
in bh© a®ch,ve case

ADV06,ATE
LHL=
#2,
1~1
`` e* ._i±,fu,fty
*`
•.rfu
a*
th
iI
85 WP(C) 9440/2024
_RE=
(i:4`. utPI8
1`.:.
jife[EL9©,REENEN#drS!&§'¥rm
ELng ffiThed© alaedi gBffiaffi!£ ifejffi rm
ffispenffiREig as REaeife I`t{ `.,, a:.'` \..r'.I.:I,il~'t'
J'?!t
GAZE.'I`TE
tnatt,1ch`J :.ilcJ. n.Janil .nml`l..liu+3`|tà.mtl;..u I ni`
#ELffELELgsffiffi!ES ffi# ifeRERE"REFT#
J"a:u'`1J,.|,ta`+,
3:.i,''.!l:;::.;:,::,:iJ,
0.I+"
#ga6 ELifea }t
EL trffi :l,i=`,`.I,.nti,.,I"'i`l` as REisffi &ima
\BREF fiife a
i,,.,!.`1
iiiiii= ` .I_ ___ __ =' i __ ,_
ffiffi i#
ff!## #FffiifeRE rfuffiB#S#ffifeffiREffiifeffi ffi ffiffi isicl`ll:lntL('u,i
:ltiltlls
!1 ife ifeb#
RE
iiRI#ffiBed Fffif *#a #ffigerffiENffi &g flts!
gasRE€ieeBg*tyt th#ENffi tis i ffiiffisg Bfi Fh* .Ail
sasasftyma¢ 5¥heaffiasi fifeffilev!aidaRE seavB ife ffi!inedi qEife
l"ed"
eniaerunre £Sii€REBffi REffi ife Biuleryra +fry g# ti[6flHti®EL REffiifetl!ca ffiRI® REIN+nefRE#iferarmtifi RI!! #ca { 4 i4£gg;i:;!±
ifeREifeF a#rfu.%,¥H ,i thanmamEaned&F hiENjiflffiife pe ffi&B rf fflrfe REifi.REj a§,matt EN ft@±i:iRil#H8 fficterid tif ife6giv
ifewiREffiifeung ffifti}&, ffitiiai¥a*ingivena fi!RE"n ifeRE«ife Eifeffii giv# fry ifeaaumne ifeftyEmRE fixp ffi ife
ifeREg th#ceS€ ft®ltiae ©g #seff evffiue S§fi, #&glff5 alatH Eaid en± ffiichs se#€#@rea Bserffiffigiv a hSn¢ £±»nas!sa ng Rna
RE itth! fr RE ifetrtl #teiaRi#es me! i&ieeaisflae qu i!ifeen
ire ire !angriE fe# #caif!E¢fro 3enfa aifespest ts^ mangrmRE
er ifemeius ffigivi ff!REi!«e thgt !ee#ife] ifei!rmmap RRERE kk. '. `
FTrs. !EffiHfty tgiv.ra trasi!:!ffiiH ifeaca i lflcaifeis 9ffro ffi€ffgFjffl

REeeae i BSndifettEL
&"twtrcami!m! qf ENIst #Sffl§fflfi grfflffi#ffit graagS
"©t "±¥4SorS laraiai*ed tap enS Hue ttff&#ng ®FTBas¢"
ffiunifeffipeffiffl giv gffi# ifeffibeifeff FTftyR 5aflaaif RE, via 6 hagie© ffiELELth*ri
ffi#mtim tat 4 ijffiENfigg a#3 ife %fe esae; !g;gsayiFb
m&* thmee ft#fl! #en# 3fi#I *ffRE th Sij #edS
E!qapff #* rmrsb %4ffll# mifisff, ffi!r!fife * aenitifeffittffise!©
erRE ca ife
ase¢ g%&grfi ES it life¢¢L {B thffi ffiftySfaREffi! ad¢difj¢# esfffi
ife„ «rm!iREiS#thffi* th¢ed i th#+SRE, ixpasati fry ife I `'1 ,,,. ru,"h?.,``,„
"5IBsaed Rrtyiffi*l(fa ©fieaF, iE!£n¥fii«Iiayifeprsamss REsa! :L'}..tjl, Brm,,E'
®ffi t#fi ade¥tl ae !v#
??,
86 WP(C) 9440/2024
fa f?,8rz
1`'`
t ,..+.\i.\ :..\..`1,:1
;.!_`L, ``` .` .`.,` ` .........
•J'',.1,.I,.1\ i .,.,.+. J
¥REin"rfuLELrfu us#TNfff i##,k Eca!ur#lxB
'! +.i.I ,. i. i apifexrfu#±ismsarifemagiv9RTgffREgivgJ;ifeEN
'.,.ti.'., '. \ .., `.: ,.... \.'`````+`.``.= ``.` .. I. "utwilbcha ¥e!¥calab ce:Lfle!!s #eden 9ENS atralev HEN
rmrmi #med ffaeiREma ifefledna!; tENgffiaS
app ifeairtygr5riL±i:gritiaRE riffigivPe ffigiv te#EH3prRErm'
&Nife ifeifro 5 ff EffGti¥
ffi¥e#apFffiri rfuvel rfuEmedi ©¢es aaemrm rty~aegiv, ffi¢
EEEEERE E!EELREmEREEEEEHE= , EREEEREH EEill ` =t`.I:`n^`.i,.` .I.:..i.`,``,I. ```.`,..
`=,: ...:. :: ,.. i v ....., I,.`):i.I ``,a,..\..`

+i.. ,'+. ` A.`1 J.a`. `' +.\=en` T` €} ffi es#unpr itav&#RE ifei Eha vermitft ffiREier Pife ire
•`+~ ..,... ``` :i +T`..' .a,I +h+ .`. .t.*rt rming;Susi twraq grmipgribffi«g fry gife #lenfr*pfts ifeiaiffirit of
`.,``.,. `"'i ',` .' lti ...`{ ..... ``tl ThbeB!#H£Lf flm *H±gr## gr# Eha LfrSdE EEiftnifeng rfu!ae
`n. u¢.. '.,.I .,I .i.`, I..=\` .I,t.N' .,., T .a O,tt`.î unae!!!ife ## aae fty"tff 8ifB± ff "untlffl REgoie#ENB4
iibii¢gffiffi qrmsch Sffi,ire ELng` BRE4 apfty £VIgr ffiserfuS
REife feffiaiarfui±Iirigiv us dea!::ffii®if iferminrfu#
HE±RE EL ERE EHRERE EREHs
` ..."',.,...... i,..' ; ,,, I `.. ,`tl` ,I,` `:1'
mREEEEEEi EHEE
seifelan!aifeiE;eneschiagrE aaaiha¥ mi dr tr& ifeftrmjffi :. :.` l..` .,.. ` .... "t ,,... P..,` I.,?.,.I,
.\ ,,,.. `1.I.®. ^.J.:|u` 1,.1 .`.,. =`.u.` 0`: \ ,..`` L`,:,'`,`..,a,I,I I'i,,=tJ ...., l
8JEE5E
SF*rm ifeFsaffi#dir@ ffi*ggRB #jftmgha¥ifeghi
:.. . :`..`` i:i`.v..`n :ìor:`.. .èt}1.
.... :.``. ` ,.`' 1,..`` ```,'.``.`.` aefangffl 8#rmffi mffigrth
asre!i!aird ¢usae ifuapfiaifengrm raHRERE REifeasgr ifets fraeB givuthlfi#fr©© lit imlg "#ffig©ffi8 se`¥beRE¥
givaefiq:RTflE, \Asei *menaapifeffiiE ELfi apvefithffi
iairsFngriHffias&haurgivqu!t RE di rfus! istrmiciprl g)en# di
```..`1` .I:.. ". :*'t,i.'i.'= ...A .....,. I.`.,
ffiENhi£[*4 as pe¢r as€ngree~ SRI4¥ a!F #RE #erS# farms Hdi
aeffixpRE A HREW`
iff`!!eeiHrife fflaiaewiig aa:fi ffiiffi €chae ire ty ed` ffiffi
fiesmaroffia !Fia!rsaurauns{B!ap ai;eiaire miam±af% ifeinjg][ap
appqp appemaars±Bgr ale;i)aschi HHaepiiHHRE ±»!Eiparmp rfepe fr ae# ng€ iha ffianfi rfufro%REff Elietl Ag al#ffl Red fen
asS¢bisea*# nI ©edffii" giv`^ft ti4ftyif ed'aeaw#diesrfe
ang¢trfe¢!E fty# ife® grdREi# aliimg©E ®jF#is ifeuiae fit th# iacaex
I,|`g T,..'. ,I .i.:I,. ì.!.'`.``l." i ,..... 'J .`,I
mcaaH#,"fraeur. ©#tgivatRERE# aeimarm ifeftytr isRE err th¢. fifroaffxpas f es:nrm#:il lan i haenHa^
meffiaedi I rfu##g dire ffti§twffitffiiifeRT xpjesSxp&Saae

*`r,L```1IL'L.I.,`. stq±r peiue±iiiea miienBmcaes rm lffiff givffi fty*` gowirmEflifealE
ie #*ffl¢feg ffi tryre 'ife!!a!rmngpt ¥ifeimm'ffiil@ ifife»*€givife`6 nxpi

®
chffiEgrngas aeThng
mtppealines ff S!+pe&aus erfriafang ffievgB!* #ftfalti j#AV drEN
ctLHgivrmffi japisife>
ELifefr ¥ grRIat eeffi wh ire ife'Ou ifeiae!! edrse fiflife m# givtsl§£t¥i`dr ed€ REighe }ti rfug exREedffi
ENdusffi aS# ed^ #fi seapvyne .ìu,r,.`
ffigiv •er ifeffiiBaffi

maEffieriH enack!#S ti'fsi©rm 'idl
Esexi
esRE = ifegivrfu%!ifeHngafsifegrmffic©ffi \`.` '. ' ' . .' ` EEEERE`
ffiae^ asks Siee!&grffiwg ¢ xpfis it"t

fanill
87 WP(C) 9440/2024
25= EL
l\roed coov Of relevant Dart Of Exhibit P18/2 /Daae 691
Exhibit P18/2
THIRUVALIA MUNICIPAL COuNCIL
Notification of Publications Of Draft Master Plan for Thiruvalla Town under Section
36(4) of the Kerafa Tow and Country Planning Act 20916
(ActNo. 9 of 2016)
No. TP32362016 3rd January, 2020
It is hereby notified that the Draft Master Plan for Thiruvalla Town prepared by the
Municipal Council of /Thiruvalla in respect of the Local Planning Area consisting of
the whole area of Thiruvalla Municipality with boundaries as described hereunder
North : Payipad Grama panchayat
East : Kaviyoor Grama Panchayat
South: Kuttoor Grama Panchayat
West : Peringara Grama anchayat

Nedumpram Garama Panchayat
has been published in the official website 'wwwthiruvallamunicipality.in of the

Municipal Council of Thiruvalla, as per /section 36(4) of the Kerala Town and
Country Planning Act, 2016(Act No.9 of 2016).
® A copy of the /draft Master Plan is also kept for inspection by the public
during office hours at the office of the Municipal Council of IThiruvalla.
Any person interested in the plan may communicate in writing to the

Secretary, Thiruvalla Municipality, any objection or suggestion relating thereto
within 60 days from the date of publication of Notice in the Official Gazette.
Sd/ Sd/
Secretary Chairman
This is the true typed copy of Page No.69 (Exhibit P18/2).
Advocate
fa#£';#'gjREo;rg:::v;;::t;
anmG.boroc.Se `. ,Dvoc^tE
.a,,'`, `
88 WP(C) 9440/2024
41. p,q
iiiiii
H
I : I ltÌ` ll```` i :^`:A E E REl ffiREHHREREHillffiHREREREffi
I,i eyffi(-:,I
89 WP(C) 9440/2024
©
eao8 in)dco]d Government of Kerala E+G+ `
. oon3(pan in)3oucolaa3Q| fu®|al
eedeov~try~WdBd. Planning a Economic Affairs Department
Korala State Remote Sensing &
P28
AodenpsehcafllOouflpe
`fTgiv cqi]0g rule.dy ®nlfl8, ed©|nlmmnJ3©® 69sO33 Ewironment Centre
'C' Block, Vihe €havan, "rovanathapuram695033
an]owl _ 0471 2301167, 0471 2302268
KSREC phe : 047i.23Oiie7, 047i2sOz268
no3a.co: 0471 2300624 Fax: 047i.2ma.
aoaowh clirectorksrec@yahoo in Small: djiectork.rec®ehooìn
No.A172/2015/KSREC/004650/22 19/05/2022
To
The Agricultural Officer
Krishi bhavan. Thiruval la
Pathanamthitta Di strict
Sir.
Sub: Request for satellite data infomation Reg.

Ref: Your letter no. KBT17/2223 dated 16/04/2022 for land use/ co`'er
change detection report and maps of the survey plots 222/I. 222/.2.
222/42 and 222/44 in Thiru\'alla village. Thiru\.alla taluk of
Pathanamth itta district.
As requested I am here with forwarding the report and remarks on the subject
with conies of supporting documents.
Thanking You
Yours Faithfu]l}'
(`_\
IRECTOR
Chellan no. KL001447832202223M.16/04/2022,1500/

90 WP(C) 9440/2024
` No.A172/2015/KSREC/004650/22
REPORT 0N LANDUSE CHANGE

p2®(+
The Kerala State Remote Sensing & Environmem Centre (KSREC). the state nodal
agenc.v for remote sensing applications under Department of Planning and Economic Affairs.
Thiru`.ananthapuram had received a reqiiest from the Agricultural Officer. Krishibhavan.
Thiruvalla letter no. KBTl 7/2223 dated 16/04/2022 for land use/ cover change detection
report and maps ot` the survey plots 222/I. 222/2. 222/42 and 222/J4 in Thii.uvalla village.
Thiruàlla taluk of Pathanamthitta district. KSREC had examined the sur`'e}' plot mentioned
in the letter with all a\'ailable Indian Remote Sensing satellite (IRS) data in the Centre as well
as online open soiirce data available in public domain and reporting the following.
LOCATION OF THE STUDY AREA
District Pathanamthitta
Taluk Thiruvalla
Village Thiruvalla
Sur`.ev No 222/I. 222/2` 222/42 and 222/44 (Fig. I )
THIRL)`.uL^ ` ll1^GE. St`R` £` `ro: 222/ 1` Z22fz, 3Z2.42, 2Z2i4.

in..rmthie(. mdi.lr. 1+ir"ul TIIill
EZH
dy/
JI,
`L_, `
"'R"#
ì * a .co leo 20.
*"|^|\rmrTT, i
FIGURE I. LOCATION OF THE SURVEY PLOT

91 WP(C) 9440/2024
No.A172/2015/KSREC/004650/22
P2o/3
The survey plots 222/I. 222/2. 222/42 and 222;'44 in Thiruvalla village. Thinivalla
taluk ot. Pathanamthitta district was vectorised and located in the Survey. of India Toposheet
number 58C/I I of 1967 in I :50.000 scale. using Ground Control Points. The survey. plot lies
between 9°2±'45.485"N to 9°22'50.808"N latitude and 76°34'33.402"E to 76°34'41.115"E
longitude.
DATA USED FOR CHANGE ANALYSIS
The location of the survey plot maps provided is identified in all available data sets
using Remote Sensing (RS) and Geographical Information system (GIS). The boundaries of
the survey plot mentioned in the. request were draun from the cadastral shects pertaining to
the area.
Thc` following data sets were used for the analysis. The month and year of the satellite data
used is mentioned in the respective maps provided for the survey number.
I. TopoMap Year 1967 (58C/I I Survey of India)

2. Cadastral Map Year 1940 {Survey and land Records)
3. FMB Survey & Land Records
4. Satellite data Year 2011 (Google Earth)
AN.ALYSIS
High resolution orthorei`tified Indian Remote sensing satellite data products were
used for georetèrencing the cadastral maps pertaining to the survey plot and change
detection in land use and land cover ot` the site. Figure 2 shows the cadastral map ot` the plot
super imposed over Indian Remote Sensing satellite dataCartosatI. Figures is the plot
map superimposed / georeferenccd with LISS IV MX of IRS data. These imageries show the
spatial reference of plots in ground.

92 WP(C) 9440/2024
• N.a.A172/2015/KSREC/004650/22
P2tol7
93 WP(C) 9440/2024
No.A172/2015/KSREC/004650/22
P2D/sI
F'lGURE ~ 4. SURVEY PLOT GEOREFERENCED WITH 201 I SATELLITF. I)ATA
FIGURE 5. SURVEY PLOT GEOREFERENCED WITH 2013 SATELLITE DATA

94 WP(C) 9440/2024
• No.A172/2015/KSREC/004650/22
P2JD)6
FIGURE 6. SURVEY PLOT GEOREFERENCED WITH 2016 SATELLITE DATA
flGURE 6. SURVEY PLOT GEOREFERENCED WITH 2021 SATELLITE DATA
SURVEY NUMBER 222/1 and 222re
As per the toposheet ol` 1967. the survey plots 222/I and 222/2 were observed under
padd}` land. The plots bordered by a road in west side were observed as fallow land with
vegetation and scattered trees in the data of 14/11/2011 (Fig.4). The same landuse practices
were continued in the data of 22/12/2013 (Fig: 5}. The data of 01/01/2016 (Fig. 6) and
21 `03/2021 (Fig: 7) shows a new road in east side of the plots .

95 WP(C) 9440/2024
No.A172/2015/KSREC/cO4650/22
P2ral7
SURVEY NUMBER 222/42 and 222/44
As per the toposheet of 1967. the siilvey plots 222/42 and 222/44 w.ere observed
under padd} land. The plots were obser`'ed as I.allow land with vegetation in the data of
14,;11/2011 (Fig.4). The same landuse practlces were continued in the data of 22/12/2013
(Fig: 5) and 01/01/2016 (Fig. 6). The 21/03/2021 (Fig: 7) dan show.s a linear feature
represents road/construction in northsouth direction.
LIMITATIONS
This repor( is prepared based on the observations from the available satellite data of
ditT.erent }'ears without physical veriflcation. Particularly the data of 2008 was not a` ailable.
OBSERVATIONS & CONCLUSION
The anal}'sis has been carried out from all available data sets of toposheet (1967) and
di ftèrent satellite data sets of 2011. 2013` 2016 and 2021 for the sur`'ey plots.
As per the toposheet o+.1967. the sur`'ey plots 222r'l and 222/2 were obscr`.ed under
paddy land. The plots bordered by a road in uest side \`,as observed as fallow land with
\'egetation and scattered trees in 2011 data. The same landuse practices were conlinued in the
data ot`2013. The data of 2016 and 2021 shows a new road in east side of the plots .
As per the toposheet of 1967. the survey plots 222,/42 and 222/44 were observed
under padd}r land. The plots were observed as fallow. land with vegetation in the data of year
loll. =013 and 2016. The 2021 data shows a linear feature represents road/construction in
northsouth direction.
_`+i
Dr. S. Jane Mithra "iINqHnH
Scientist` KSREC KSREC
96 WP(C) 9440/2024
.... '.`
ti'.,+ -J3,-
:t®a2Ou_¥OTer¥vdb:dbuso!@smsalsudb®O
(rLr7Oe3@ : GOuO.Qilm®u Gu7Ocojap 6iQO.O®.Q®mjv )
£Lin <p_21
mo.afl6-1292/19/6)da,.onlmuu.
®o|co)®| .. 03-01 -2020
oulaffiQ2)o..-2018@ej Gdb®e®coctou®ed ®6RE1®cosouo®d"6m(G@Gco®D
ml®®o - mleJo/®6REldcoso rflm)16m6)in QJlg6To)oulmo

6)alqp6)also(oT® e}®1co)!6)s cojeoQlou6®1cQjon)o com}Q]ol3U
ms;prTri, -
g(ore)©ouodb3tm®--in)o6njc#cole]u.
in)aalm:- 1)|col.ou6%1crJ ceBo6n6, Gce,091®slQ2>1flocQt e®indcov,
®3dbaGq£®l, ®l®2QJS!®}67S (eraGuldRE.
2)d3]6rml63orLo6lmJ6,®1®!oue!cQj!6>s20.05.20196)a
KBT29/2019-20coo.olGtlods
3) ®1®aous! OulGsj83u 63Oof]1OuO!6ts 16.o7.2oig6tej 228/19
coo.olGtlo@§v
4)20186ieJ cdb®9 6lmctouQ2)ct ®6RE1@cos "o®csffi6m
(G@®o)®D ml®a}6or3g}o al§68T392o.
*+*+,**,
cO1®aQJes ®Oei}dsolds ©l©}Q.ev Qjlc8}e=1ds, 66"Od36u 222ed cO667On mmjfo

2ict 9066>tl§®3O Oulceeat G®6udb9nde Onlao Q®mu G®6u6itgs}cOIQ2jl§3ee®2®OQj
22.45ap@ @}alQ2)!6)s ouJ@oQJou!®1CQ)Omo Q]®!co!m®1cr)ocojl ouialrD (1) irudbo®o
co€uldanl±ns3g2g®06rT7u.
coGrLjdrmooumu-®!Qiled Q®d3.Geuoo 20oudQsocolct d3]2s2coct ch9dro®}99

QJbdrm6mg" ®!n3coltloeJl8l®|os coocoaldbo®eowosu d9]}sl® 3 o}old3,g}99 63©}
6)dJ>51Sou!o sl 67d3>§1sGcoosu caldmv 700 cul6co6u g®|cooQ|2m eR6im)muju cQjo®umju
@ffi 63®a ialo@®uLamoejQ2to dfa06m6ttlsam®O®3O sl 6idb§1scolfrj- e2ejdbuisldbu d3,6m
d9mm" QJo§@ d3>6mdbsom" el@12in§agg®iao®ao sl mmElcolccoosu Galdrm3g£
cru®alal ouou-®}oulct 63®} 6)alGisoto almuao 4 mlej 6)dbslsQJ!o mml®1
6)ale)|mcoo®}o sl auneio dg,6aa]l®uce6V com!G®ogBb®eso6>®rm}o oubQjmuo®1cfro
lalouJomb"8gSloueJcol6)rfl63®}Qjcoo6)6)6"alomuucooouuml6calco}m®o®2o
coculd3ffioQlmuu®ioulcmos- cal®m mleiowlds o©d3]Geooo 30QJ6cfl®ocQ)1
6)mctdb6as±1Q2)18!06)CQ)in)3o ou}alm (2) |ddbo®o d3>6rdil 63ocoal"® o|ctlo®§V
6)alQ#®l§}exp®06mu. mlejQjlct at!®cojls®o®1 dbo6m6>tls2mi cocald"oQjmuu®a
al®1oudcom6>tls!ow}rm®u ®}ejo ml6>©09!colm- ®s"G®o alo®1mml®lcfro
ichco-m6mGgo 96TT3od3>}ouond muoou5®®1fflo6)Q)in)!o ouo906"oEB>1ed `mle[o
mld3,coo ul}®Q2jlso' Qomu G®ou6>tls}col®l®1co!on sl onejo onogo6"08blds
mlm.3o6391ouodastoou}m®06t6rT]m)U26.12.2018de.-dalfamialoG@otilce,®ejml®alcefl6m
ou®1®1 GQ2Joo)colct ®1®!®omo®s}*n§2~ee?o,®}o db6rml 63oul]a)co6 olGtlo6§V
6)ala2)u®1s!6n3v. . h -`
`,1:-.i:.`-::'.I.
97 WP(C) 9440/2024
-EZ=
cocr]coflooucou®! coi©}orgr 6>6i6"rLjomju cooonfaonoo- oni®t,
6)alq¥!m®o®}o sl Qlcou" ru)0806"08blct `mleio mlco,cou ul2®Q2)ls'®ocQj`
6®6u6>tls}col®1§ie£®o®!o sl Qjmju®3ouldi 15 ou@rflowlcov G®ed tojo®®6g±6ì
oj!d"enu6 mlctces>3rm®o®io sl Qjouv®! 20086>fl Gd3>®e 6tmdsrL'tp)Of
®RE16cos ouo®ce"6rTJml®®o cnsfande ou®!m®1mv ®3n6alv mld9,toT®1®®3t\!}~\
C6"OuJ!6)tl§1§!eg®o®ao coGatd9"oououu®!oulco- ou®°ldro 6>rrjdscfr,jr±
e2S!06>®mJao oulGe}au 63oal]1cru@, ®1®}oug ou|alm (3) iedd33o®o olGflo¢is
6)al®V®1§3gig®06mu,
92® d3>0®doeJ®colct mlrm}o 17112019ds msowl® o~ij[]e

al®1G0t)Ou)mcQJlct coGchd"oCuouu®}QIlds Jessus Voice room mJoaeJsrDco,lxps
icho@®Uiomocoooa iatou6cole]2ou®!m®o®!o sl cooglmu e2Euc6U,t`slt-ruls,1 r,_':isr=
db6md3flnd runmlou ge2®o®" coGulceE]oQimuu®2ouled 20 ou®rmo iuloQjrj23^_j€
QJbcefl6mua(Tunl®16)alq2)2m®o®}o€6"ocL]b67tlsl§3gfcoo6mu
co6oQ2)oulej ®eel"6 ul®1Gooou)13]®1ct cnlm72o sl @!alQ2Ja6ts co!oQDrulE\: I

cD166mQ2)13]®led coruod3>®®aEig®ocDl icoco®1ds6itl§®1fnoed anGdrouo
ouof®2oul®rE ou®omcoJ@oQJ®}ef mu®aldr al}®Qjls®oQD o6lmu@6>Qj mmjfo
222/226mam!o®ateJ®e81m?@iruifeo®®}99m!oQ2toulej®o®co663milmv6,00,Oooz'-
®}al r®m)®1rru @2®laDa6ts m6o®oulejQ2)1ct 14.11.2014, 31.03.2018, 3004201C
®1®®ld3791ct cru®droo@ d3>oeiom3mjb®®o®l Qi®}owlcDls}ae oudcocr7ouu d>;sl
do>6rr)col6)ejs!owV ar®@ 63m)1mu .10,89,000/- ( rucov ejd9flcol ren6ndru¢Toì
62rfaal®froolj2jl®o} òidi ngimj dbonce6>1ct mlo"®13]1saEe®2o anicL,dfo"`'
muj@oouou!rorlQ2)omo Qj®!Gco6rT3 22.45angd Qjouu®}oulm- ar®6tcfro 2,44,48,050,',(fi. `T
Gdboslfnodsrucolmoeujejd9flcolcoo¢j6cucoloo6REocD1®colaunndru®U®tdi®o(aro
®!rLJ mAO®rulej dJ]6TT)coocee)1®1§!9g®3.ao6iTU).
20186ter cd3i®9 6>matou®ds ®6RE1@cos ouo®ce"6m (G@@u)®D also 12(9i

iuldbo®omji@oououb®1®omocom3or€1®Vd36)3rmcoculdREd3,91ed20.23®3tt»de4047
ou6i® oulouu®6®1®!ee®io, ®indmjltloejl9n®1de mjj]l®1 6Ialg}on®!®6Qu
@}®l®}6>S onJ@oQJrub®1cojomo com!oueld367}rm®lmv an®6icfu mbo®oulejco36>s 3(1°;A
co°lm)u g29socd3®6ne®26n3V coialdbo®o anGuldrmoQjmuu®j!ouocoj 22 45co,\fi
ruou-®!oul6)rB an®6)db co!oQ2joulej®o® 2,44,480,050/- ®!atQj}6>s COO/o a©QD
73,34415/-®!at (a®g!dicol®!mv ejcoflcol ®!tlcol moejoQ3J1®col mom!91
ru®1Cr)6T"-®!d ®O|®o) 13.12.20T96)fl KL 011746114201920M mou® 6)aleJorfo
ialdJ>o®o ®1®}onfi in)6"u isdiol®1ct 63s3drol anouct 6)alejorfo

rLf)Oae®Oco®1®1§2g2g®06rru).
®1®}ouft db6rflJl 630rmlmud, QJIG#gEu 630QJ]a]oud rformlrH®!6)S olGtio(d5`
ialdbo®QJ3o e2® rfuo®boejQ2)colct mlm3o msoru>1qu ouul®lcooocDm®}6isQ2j}o
anslmmomcolct ou3alm (4) 6)a al§colofl ou!oummd33u6 inddbo®ou!c,
mjj@oQjru!@1mQ2jocDo anco}ouol®ucooou!m®06)6mm)U G6"ou)66)tl5l§!g2£
mjocoal©!,coled QIlcesgBU c®oudbglds colelo Qomu c®ou6>tls!owlcojls}9g®3o
coo806"08blds mlejo/®6ml6coSo a®ml6en6)in oule26rooalrr)L
6)alq2)6)tlsoowco}®o® coculd3floorm)u®}Qil6)n§ in)i@oouQI!,®1®omo com!QJr31f2]`
®06>9Qilutld36>!oialce]o®o9toTo)®QIoc6>}m}.
98 WP(C) 9440/2024
ir,. . -
mfais
-±' i,2,/3,
coGulcBfloQlmju®!6"1.gn.an®d
ù,L,®,uoD2Hu`Liì uto7! 6"l.81.an®® |rLJdbo®o `mleJo'Q®m3o Ou0906"08blct mleJo
/®"q®cOSo runmlen®o oule26rooato?o 6)alg6)tlsoco®oco>®oeJ!o al!ou6>s
Gal@col§299 ml6"couujmdbceo6is 2018oa Gce,®9 6tcodsou®>at ®6REldcos
ouo®ce"6m(c@Gco®Dml®®o QJdb}tl- 27(ao), Gd3>®9 6)mdscuQ2Jct ®6REldcos
ouo®ce2flen) (G@GO)®Dal§o 12(9) a®mlouQ)1oEu Qi!,ouondbch |drdbo®o
muJ@oouout}®1co)oono com3oual3-9co®Qjoam anGdenoououu®!oul6>r@
oucoffl@gQi}d3]ed. oud6)ou coou©, QLntmuudi@"o a®onlou go86)tls3colq2J1§!gg
mj66iou mj-6>Se]- 9®®06>sotlo 82e8sccOO 6>alQ2-)-®l®lcom
mjl@oQioubcol®omcolmv eem3aof mctc9,3m ououu®} in)o6"muu)l± Qjnan6med
al3QJ6)S Cal®ce613m}.
i ®Oeiadrov ®1®3QJee
S!G6nJoas ®1®'ru%
34 6"OcOco6nectl® mo.1
222
10441 I
5 o oud6>on mmuda3T®6>dbonfrouco%6moOui@OOuoub®1Q2iomocom}QI @1e] chouu®1d an ombo®QJleJ©rDd63mlmu(oudcomorugcd@tl®s)m©6>d3]mbo®QJIELit8T@sQJodJ€)1®®2e](mbo®QJleJQ2J36)S
222/21 ,
6
22.45no6 I
7
22.45 en®6
`8
10,89,000/- I
9
2,44,48,o5o/- I-J1I
10-
73,34,415/- I
6"m-comdbo8
com2®®1 mctd3367ed§ OuOu-cO]Oulct 3ooo al®3©ico coslQ2jlds dh!s}®ct

Qilouu®166m®ieg 6tdbslso ml`6anl®ud36>}maid"o also 12(9) ialdbo®®}gf
adieu-coS®u€co6TT3coo6m-..
oualrLJco2gg Of®e]oeJ}dbto€d56)o co6REldcos6eecri)ccoo cQJo6)®o®3oulcu
®!alceaoQj®}toTo>}Qjondalosls;otoroi®06mv).
m6ocp)ateJ cr)1cm®13in§!eg®1ct ©!n6cs,oejido6"ej6colds G@Gcoto>1
Ou®3cO}dbc®O coulorfu® muo@QJle]®Oc®O iuoco®led67ed§Oct cO©l®O®
a)1®dsolej}gre®}cacosqpudro!ouochcocalcefld3]n86"ocu6tir`mcooQ2tl®1co3o
99 WP(C) 9440/2024
4) e®ds CD16"n5UJmce.9a6)s
ioocoQ2jlct6iq]soct Oudb!#
J-
„
Q®6ro8331ej!o
27(Q®9atoudb}al
QJlocoleJ2gg
(ii)iuldbo®O
__,i.-i`:?dy_
e20
Ei!orffi\!;ct
9coiorif
`:
O@Oces>6>#}m~.
Gdsoe 6mdecuQife ®6mflfrosouo®d"6m (Gee07®DmlQ2jao Qidb}al 27 mjl
(2),(3),(4) r®rmlQJ |aldsoon3o also 12(10),(11), also (13) inddbo®ou!o
mjJ@oonQJ!®1®omo anm2onfa @!®lQ2)!6ts Q"®!®"ccomicru6®®ocof
@!cr)1d9,!®1 ®l§6>tls}owl oua¥cong§ onomu6ldsGod 9ow®Of mdsGdb6rr3®2o
uts}g3ondfro® co®1o5 anm}mJ6onoQjl ooum!,a G®6uc6,9~;Of
ac9oou©}Gco6n3®2®06n},
irLjmJv``t)a® rrunELìip} ITttocao6m irLiQjdcoco6ueu8d9d ,@OtT;}f `®-T
fr.dec8>am®ife ®a"' g20 9couteej mrfunicucrjca,ua rLj!66Ep®jou!r,
rLJJt]ie2]13666TT306)®m)
rLJoeJle]ts}G6neo6)Q2JmT ch6"O®cOu @Ou|dfo§01,
at6Tguo®cait# OmitAc=nl cabrfl]1 @Orolmud,
AI Jiji ^^ ^q~à ^QllG&g±
1-_ +
®Ocofro6 a®m)1ou®
Qj®}6cO6ne®06rT-7'.
mJopadro®o®l
ul®lcco°cOu;:st~i°ti
ru®1Gcooommsm7Til 6in^.i`
(`, 1 Qj®u)1m)U 6gBo6n8, G£ \

GaELaa
®}dbfflGq8®1.rul.63.,
aldfadedu: 1) g=1g;o d3,gceu,'sd,

®!ow d3>co-coQr)loo)
2)®nnfnJlctG?q,?n®2ou.€,f(oulqrj?òaQTh!^®ccovfnedd=;m2\rm?.._ilury;
tuc9.dtlu g2o co>o®6oflcQ)enDlct ej@6®oGco6ry3®06mv )
3)QilG%aeu630ridiou6,€cfoocQ)1|trlo(ouJ@oouqu,®1®Ocooou®!ow!rm@}D^'
ouo6"coucole]oulou®6¢T306a[]ooomo.10ctcQ)Loooulcl)1
G®6u6ttls}cco6TT3cho6mu.)
4)c6>6cml630rLdiou®,®1®}OrRl
5)6tmuidfa§ol,io)o®ru6TniocDoro)u,'®1®}ou#®2a)1mJltloeJ19n
6)runouu.onD6.@„®1®!Qjs}(slorou-®!mjo6"mucul3]apcoo®o
®gB1"®@ajg!on®1cDva!n8al:®ridco)6ruoej6!ol®®ououV
@alQ#®1§3C6TT30rwhonugoq]}or©3€(ore)6n3®06mv)
7) db®!®ct ut®ct
Tmh==:SthaestE%eH%3TY°Paao,Cumem
AÎ+IEJ{ttHr re /e rre cJ
In trie above case
ADVOCATE
100 WP(C) 9440/2024
101 WP(C) 9440/2024
102 WP(C) 9440/2024
_--_-`
®oi®®| : og-12--2019
m6"ud3,9dfa'sd
coi®ioue!.
icol, oudu)almu- cgao6nd

cchogl®sl®1elo®GDiul(ore)-
®'dbeJGq8®l
a-- @1®peLm* ,
oJlrEiQ2Jo,.- 20186)eJ cce]®9 6)mchou®ed co6RE16(OTZF)s muo®cenl6m
(c@@u)®D ml®a]o'- @}®1®!6)s (T\)J@oouQJb®l®omo

@Tam3Qlol®Vd]6>}tm®V-(ruo6"m'a)|e]u.
tru}alm:- QJlcs}g5 63oaditT\j6, ®1®}Q]ee®}6ts 16.07.2olg6tej 228/19
coo.olcq]od§u.
®l®ious! . QJIGs!g31ct c6"od>6t-222ed mjd6tou mo. 21ed 9o86]tl§

22.45@T©d ououu®iat6irfl mui@oorQlb®1®omo ou®}tuTZF>3rmcolmo®1, cdb®g
6)mctQJ®ed ®6REld(orotsmuo®co]9±6m c@oco®l also 12(9) iuldbo®o sl
ou(ruu®}oul6>n§ en©6>db mbocQjoulel®D!6>s 30% tBTgap! ( 22,45 x
10,89,000=2,44,48,050) 73,34A15/- ®}ru (a®9!al(oro)1®!mu ejd"(oyo)1 ®}tl(oro)1
moEiioof®(ore)l coom}8n al®1co6rm. to}o...0 0©29-800-88 rig)in coldog4dbtoro>1ed
isrfflolco)led 63s}cesn comued aleion3 g20 63onI]qouled Qoog3®ocdro6ne®06TTu7-.
- . ouanurfeg&?6/co2couael
t.\
`*-i+ I:nat:k':;any a;d#:;em,;Gn;
In the above case

ADVOCATE
103 WP(C) 9440/2024
a}fl®(m`
toìQ~esoctmaouit#,o¥t8on#®8norfeqrQ@9msuls"ife®° 22.022o"
F¥+.p ~
23
a,rl>®:i38t|`:u1,\:,+::}:;::ùt`|`;'`:nfg;°;:::0%3`:£mQg:®££#®£)t:'!p#£:®Qmdi
(\f\,f,,14®`,(, w,.' _
?::)b;:::j`\:lou,I;';jt".J\2\"u"~`wn
.\
_::::::i:_i:I:::::::i:::::::=::::::::::i_:::::1::::::::::;:_:::;::::;:::;::::::::::::`:::::::::::I:1`::'
I,I
0;3i:di%d%,:£:iji¥j;`:;§`:::6;1:OqcoS::?j#£n;%®3ca£Q:cO:?o°?:ty€#:fuQ:;¥®n:fl?%t;:`;2::8;:%€£Q£,
agivdi
n I bu`d;l':>`#.: ca;rt3{{#;'#tov{;n\t3d%%`;`:Joan;:Lug;83.:%t%®®n?o diqumut tilo{òCo{oQoc>canl¢i}6
i®::¥1ifn!),ca:Jgn:!;aj*g`3:,::;`ch@(,
(.
•,:2I :'''2
mw"ouilnfl?`thimtda®oflnlmtB
ii/olr{uog8co,cl`f\(`6,(ì'JtioNu,
.,JS.i
n \co>(.8Ri 1)±.~A`:¥t.:?in:iR%(ì
#£`%&;`;?`{:%uofv;(i(T„on|(a(URN
tr\L
104 WP(C) 9440/2024
€JK+ . P 2 3 CqJ
/,-,
mlQrueeorumdoulTnnfflT#oorunq,rrvQ@Smsulsltde®o
mo.cO6,405672Oi976tdb.Oulrfu diap®1 : 14-06.202i
didi®O :- 2#n']%@%:®cdy¥fl:6|¥0%mgco##:@#fl#tr%T%o&#alr9t£%es:#' #n®ey%s
qualm.. ;}'#nflfa#fudeo%£6d#?#n3#qs3'3Pt€2%8og®erT #2:¢mtlo|#lo%o®fond§¥.

34t,1270.i3£oer2o®fl¢Rfv#2£8#tg#vdimo.%ca6mapfoflfs OuO®d"6m tG@Ou"ij
tTtl® ®6ungo al36ongo.
®1@ruRl ®oetd9oldi owlQ"g m®Rlgildi ®6"odi# z22di ffl ou66tru mo. ig/1 de@tg§3rti@m
ol.3oco6 Q®1 ruloRIg o®6udbgldi 'mlejo' a®rfu o®6u6)fg§owl®1§399m,06)6mmo
fuo6mlg3!oruuo6colmo®1 sl 6®1Q)@s mJ@orilnl6®1Qtomo coro"01co6)6m6)®mo coruuo66)tl3
noalm(1)iulcfoo®Otco®rucas4maidan4j-jl§!a9®06rri.
®1QruRl nJloRl# 630ru]flfroQ6)s qualm (2) nloq]06§ trLidbo®o cooalofmaoou" sl "1®Rlg3l®er
:4s7£3on::nfl&g£## tchmc%:®; mide#°%rong&3£ndi®::o%#n%mi&##®#;

co,06m6)id§m sl @®1 GrtoriD ml®qfled rmlml 6talfpammoQ)o nd6ml®1®oow 63Q d9>sQnl
dboen6)at§trrimoQ)orutGes#®orfla\mcanlGtloca§càl"1§aeemoerti.
.moonJdinJo"".}rm6)r# ru)ooo6"oco,16)fi 99§sdro6cou8 ocfo®g 6)m®8ou®®8

®6RE1®coshoo®drm6mo@ou7®1al§o4(out)toice]o®o6igJlruocaol®1§3eemo6m-.
. 9P ..cfuQ®60eJQ)colco8 m'lmo msan'l® mmeicu®1ouooum®1di coorddrmo(TunEuo

.,de®'Q)1sinaom®o®1onl®16tal®j!m®oQjloouo®6®o®1§}eeaDo6rff.
82nd®id¥almnd®3nsmu##g#`ndrfu£6®o°®#&ndca«%Qo®:%:6®#®nd#eech°#£:06®:n7|nsB®do®#
m!o®chej®jled rro®d36to6 rfeoejod3,oei6coglat futQml® rudoumdi inddbo®o oq mi6ofu 82at6)at§
G®1did)di ®fi? 63mldi 4,oo.ooo/-Qul ngoQinnff mlon®1en§39gQo sl aBdb talrfuo®o oi.3ocoa3
an®ndc"oQ®1dididi co®cfo 5.28,ooo/-Qal m6o®chfl cfo6mdsoocool®1§399q}®06r\i
coondd3"oQ®1q}6ts ch"166mo 2o.23corned rfut"od9,®oeto Qfl8oultloeJIGl iuloouoof mrol®1
&al@3#%°£o®#°coS:ulqbdiSg£Ssi2&%chgo:2o2,'#k6L°o°o';92:o5:2nog3°2%`#®#o°#ntul%§o£€
®1QruRlm)ortilsrfflol®1ds63§coQruQcolcom)cat)aleJoaannog3®oc6ol®1s36r#,
maRlul#8#goum%°®ridsqqu:Q@S #°s##SoT£*Qn):di 8° £°®®ndJg®dig:#o®#trno° m6S®#®:
a-
("J@Oruru6mlQ)omo cofl2nJ@1d3ooQirman6ionì.I¥ ¢6itiou)iaio® "ornal®6mulds sl 6®1Q6ts
mjj@Oniru!®1Q>Omocoq}ruold6idb06n!®0@9tmfu®lapwdbo®09trm®nJodrin.
-:-:--::,--::-:-::i:::-:::::::-;i:i-::::i:-:-:::--I:-;::.:::::::::-;i-::ii-:ii:::::i:::::;:-:;;:i:i::-::-:i::.:-;:::I:::i-:-:::--:s:::I::-:::-:::-:--::-:-
105 WP(C) 9440/2024
P-2-3@>/2i
"#an¥±#seav§ogsngongng#diiT®alife®:£n#JELcgivdbftngivmfm:,}EL?£&rfe£'-"
2'%*%fi:a(#%#j8#3esal#03£to6Pldtwrf8Dtde®6roexn4edouowquflee€i3®j©¢crof§(ì-ù
„ %;¥=n3e±ouch:nfu#isT£S£###3£%§:edt#®gisowm3gso;=®:rfe #€:`REftcu:£
rLJchRE ®#at€oal##£j£#oELffi££Tt2¥%:,¥*ur+:3S®5
2'%no?afesngi%#®'ffitt#ca®#&dyTco#£i%#ngeco3at,
3!dbjf,tll6ioAatm](a,®lque!
4rfemutchiferi#ELRE##!+i¥iifefty¥::+Jrtyi?TBK'5i
#nAnEL;cO'#*#n'ouan#J#|%desrfu¥::`Jdlt?,8w'5?"`ft3
i;no.Ttfroed.6] ®lque!
6j d>,6et8¥aa aoed
106 WP(C) 9440/2024
e*+.P23@J
c®6ii ®Of7tr\>1ed@O® 6)S msaJsudina}o t
Qr)Oadiancol®db.c®Oa[crov
6TLJ12-4627/2021/6)db.ouJ|owu enflrortilitso|ov|2:o2i.
Oulchi®O:- cdb©g Otmfa Oroch cO6mnacos {r\>Oceflrm7 cO1®aio 2008-27(QO) Ond9>}edu iuldboco {roj
@oQJ rLJb®1®o®o ammaQI@la]u 9omonio®®1aB oJdb}edu 27(mjl) ialdbo©o msalsldbto tT\)fl
db®1e] 9(oro]®Qiae>]trrmu - {ruo6nimif|±V.
tT\i2alo:- iode©9 tT\>de®Od Ooimat (OJl) Qita,}all6>O§ 15/12/2Oi8 - ®Eu tTu.9.(aJl) tr>tnl@ 85/2Oi8 OOu
coal in(nid alleB6rz»ooj(T)a.
2. 6"of.I. ®l®3QJRl (r\ton- dbeLdbvso3®s 14/o6/2o2i-6>Eu o€)6-co56/2oig/6>tQ>.tu)1(ru- (T}tnl6 msoj
slidba}o.
3. ®1®:}c>ie) ®sei±pd§ froortff cTede!a]ia_ 2qfnz/2o2i- ed a7r@o(i71tfu®l± tnj6nu utòjlaajat
Oev§®Dfl5 & muvae2i
ala7izDmo®1§ gatgofted ®1©}Qls ®oei}da6>1ed ®1®!oies nJlcgFled c6Bjou}5 mtnid 222 - ed ®6ne
oti6 mtTrd 14743 - ed oltru®6]q tT>mia ig/1 -edotl§ 1.3o a]r®6mvjv Qlm}®3QIled (nj}®g!# old36>o®tu>3co,u@
|arabo®o mlaJo) (TuicooJ Qlb®1®omo @ram}QJ@ld}®}(mDlmoofl (ru}alco (1) QJlg6moul(7) |uldbo©o |col(ruog82
fo6nfld ao)(in cEbdmil 6nJof)a. ®1©2oues ooicoai colQildi6med areadioud D}mio6]db aaooo 6 - ed araculdhai
(r\)adq]l=jl§}eg®}o, @r®®aDled odbog 6>med rLiuned ®GREndcos (Tuoodam6m ol®ato 2oo8 Qife}tlv 27 (o€))
irLJdbooo (rueou Qib®1oomo @Bm}Qicte]}o sl mlco)oo 27 ((T\)I) Qjdbaitl- iuldboq>o msalsld3>(e (rurldbold]6>ofl3
ml®c@cole])o (ru}aj(T) (2) iuldbo©o 9®ro>®ojonfl§}§9®06mu. QJle6rz»onjmo 6)alq±)oG]so(oT5) e!01on}}6)s (T\}I@oou
Qlb®1oiomo com!orfiLE 9®ro>®QJoa2) sl ca(Tuled {T\7}alo (3) ialdbo®o ®1®3oJs} ®oeJ3d}6i oomJ} mrdQ]®©
tT\iouu aofQIlrfl4at old]6>o@ru>3dhcfi {n)adalleJ139g!®06Tfi.
51 (ruoaf)al®barm)led (T\)}alm (1) asaco®l ai§6RECA 12(11), i3{i) iuldbrml}o 1961 - 6iei 8db®g e}ml
db}®i an©dbv5 5,6,6 (ag)) ag)(ml oJdb}ch}dbo3 iaJce>O®on3o (ru]al(r) (3) (Tu6ru- (u}loJlrQ±rri) old}6}o@(u)}dso8
irLjcho®o sl in)66)Qi comJa ig/1 - ch6>qrs 1.3o @©8m} QJqti®}onl®r@ mlda>3col 3.25/- ®}aJ o©ofl rLJico6 ml66m
ia cLiouv qii®*ftyapo <T\joqumifle] oinJ®o ®6meoed©16>o3 ol®o®din} ctfuoecole+2o
tTugjl6]an§olcosltT\mommld],]®1aengt)olei3oITtruiinon~Q-i6t5fro~o(T)-oms-ffl5~nl3-®*din56--hoR"©aria.--our
mb! niJIoflaarmaB ©©normio}os tT\]}alm (2) gco®oJ16}n3 tntTroio colo>arlo}ao (ruof)1coo ®®6ii6teds}oro)1
(T\)oce]aiboq]s}coiouom}o (Tuiai(D (i), in)}alm (2) iuldrmo}99 msaJsl|dbai63B{a ojoejld}6}}QJ9®ao, 9®®0
®Soedo aegsdmo oaJg}(in m}aoQ] aoooo co(nJd 7 cB>}sl aLi®1ccoo{iflej sl ml®®o c@a(r7aDl al§6BB(fo 13(2),
(3), (4) iajdbo®o oldroo®wilct @©Qico5oo® aog6en{A ou®}col msaishade al2dedldb©1d}6>]tmedmv ®1®}Qlej
QJIQs!eBV fflDaolmrdd]@V Ofld®8coo medd±;I g®1moed g(crzDOQJac>2(m3,
CTkap
30.1.2®2
E= cooomjlafaced (©!c®6u)
icol.in)oE} ®6ml6,
alocoo Of s,
®|dbEUGq3®1.
aldb@tlv:- 1. rulcs}Eg aprLolmj@, ®l®2Qier (®!s8 cosulsl tnjllda,®18d]6>6n3®06mT)

2.ch©}®ct ao®ed
.r;.. -`::,,-,.. i,.

107 WP(C) 9440/2024
|L=.'|.J..i.i. r`:,4
• 4Z
mo. r®65600/2019 n:n#Gon:Oujrffl6##®Orm",colQ"ee

€nn36nd a nnocfe : o46926oi 2o2
g26)®®1ed: rdo.tvla@gmail.com
anl®®l : 1 3o42o2i
#Qm#"lcH6med@oanlmjd
anoul. g3mnaid
aor)6mocfa9o
ouri],
QJIof4®o:
go¥£rfu®®Oug_®£?££3jonsgqunngos24o82o2O®flwp(0i62037202O(A)
qualm : 1 )|uZ)1. al[mGq}Oof)r6, 'al|neln' 6)ulos1®Oslq}6)s (8T@6riJd3,s4.

2)6"or}.Gco]®g6t6)ofiGco6tos®1q}6tso4.o2.2oi56tEjwp(c)3262/15(G)
mo.9mu®rti.
3)g20 dD.O®50eJ®(orb)led rril`1129§ 18.04.2ol 56)ej a®3766/1 5
mo.msalsl|cft,no.
4)[uol. rndg!qaro 692oon8, ccs]091®sl®leJo® 6®(ulcoTb5,
:}3:3chfo:®£#jn££i£5£n2%s?gGn%£6:6£2£1£mnondm@Sndrs1[ife®o
27.03.201861eJ mono mo. 7 [uld3>0®q99 (8TZ)CnJc9".
7)g2rgcco®!OeJ®(Ore)16)eJ03.01.20206)eJr®61292/19/6)co>.oulni5
mo.m5alsl{cs,®o.
8)#T#)?]%23:/#2%#°msoco:#®:"qu®col24o82o2o
gfes:eegco:*dy6i::=¥£#:Q:ff::ed?®=:ii!±¥®S;f#252gT#non:?=6?so:®gg:Q*#s
:i::i::::::::::::i::;::::::::I::i:::.:::::::I`
::::::::::::::::.:::::::::::::::
ELndo%£rfe:m*5±1un%SnT%nn:£ffoffim##:2£`8c%ndnd:¥n#:ffed#m#ELrfu£%:fl%#:
108 WP(C) 9440/2024
L PQ,,I
_::::i::I::i::::::::;::i,:;::::;:.::;::i::;:::::::::i::,;:::i:::i::_
§Lgiv#Lfo&3::1:9fiMgg:O£*%£:#fjtg#££:4g£:%;:atco7[#cO:g#gm¥¥:un¥um¥gg:
2o,8@erw:£;'£2°@342%°iA#°con#ufldm#:n%no@®flouul%%@%n,?%::,2:((AT::gem:
#gq8de%£qmg!°gr@o:0:!iT#:®oug#no#cocofgap®gumu:Sn#|fo:mgfn°5G`£?£i£#¥
6>d3,0993rm.
"nu@]r"®GQjoQs.
o"md oul"1o:tl6med 63onatmjd

109 WP(C) 9440/2024

!"#$%" &'!"#(
")*$ +, -*"%.(
/0'1 2%3.!#" 4355"3(
!"#$%36"(
4'$3"$3 4171(
8!3%9:"55" 8!"59;(
4"<!"#"6<!3<<" =3.<%3><1
4?@ A +BC DDE
F.1
GH
D1 8!* =3.<%3>< '55*><'%( 4"<!"#"6<!3<<"(

3:35 /<"<3'#(
4"<!"#"6<!3<<" 4 7(
4"<!"#"6<!3<<" =3.<%3><1 4?@ A +BC+IJ
K1 8!* F355")* 7LL3>*%( 8!3%9:"55" F355")*(

8!3%9:"55" 4 7( 4"<!"#"6<!3<<" =3.<%3><1 4?@A +BC DED
,1 8!* M*:*#9* =3:3.3'#"5 7LL3>*%( M=7 7LL3>*(

8!3%9:"55"( 8!3%9:"55" 4 7(
4"<!"#"6<!3<<" =3.<%3><1 4?@ N +BCDED
I1 8!* 8"!.35$"%( 8!"59; 7LL3>*( 8!3%9:"55"(

8!3%9:"55" 4 7(
4"<!"#"6<!3<<" =3.<%3><1 4?@ N +BCDED
J1 8!* O'>"5 O*:*5 &'#3<'%3#) '663<<**(

M*P%*.*#<*$ Q- 3<. '#:*#'%( R)%3>95<9%"5 7LL3>*%(
8!3%9:"55" 2%3.!3Q!":"#(
2":96Q!")"6( 8!3%9:"55" 4 7(
4"<!"#"6<!3<<" =3.<%3><1
4?@A+BCDED1
110 WP(C) 9440/2024

!" #"$%&%'( )"*%*%'("+ %& !,$%(- .//. 0+" '1 2+3 4,(2 5'67+%&%(- %( #"
89+$"3 :' ;;;<;= /> 0+"&= ?@A ,(2 ;B/@ 0+"& %( 89+$"3 :' ;;;< %(
#"&9+$"3 C4'5D :' ;> %( !,(2,77"+ ?/;@ %( !%+9$,44, E%44,-" %(
!%+9$,44, !,49D %( ),*!,(,6*!%**, F%&*+%5* ,& 7"+ *!" 2'596"(*& "G"59*"2
H3 *!" 7+"$%'9& 'I("+& '1 *!" &,%2 7+'7"+*%"& +9" 5'73 '1 8,4" F""2
:';B@@<>J '1 8#K !%+9$,44, 2*?<BJ<>J "G"59*"2 H3 C!,&D,+,( ,(2
'*!"+& %( 1,$'9+ '1 L!,(2+, M'!,( %& 7+'295"2 !"+" I%*! ,(2 6,+D"2 ,&
NNOPQRO !" *+9" 5'73 '1 8,4" F""2 :'.;J<;BB '1 8#K !%+9$,44,
2*@<B.<B "G"59*"2 H3 )"((,66, ,(2 '*!"+& %( 1,$'9+ '1 L!,(2+, M'!,(
%& 7+'295"2 !"+" I%*! ,(2 6,+D"2 ,& NNOPQRO S !" *+9" 5'73 '1 8,4"
F""2 :'.;/<;BB '1 8#K !%+9$,44, 2*@<B.<B "G"59*"2 H3 F%$,D,+,( %(
1,$'9+ '1 L!,(2+, M'!,( %& 7+'295"2 !"+" I%*! ,(2 6,+D"2 ,& NNOPQRO
T !" *+9" 5'73 '1 8,4" F""2 :'???<>>> '1 8#K !%+9$,44,
2*B<B/<>> "G"59*"2 H3 M,+%,66, U9+%,( %( 1,$'9+ '1 L!,(2+, M'!,( %&
7+'295"2 !"+" I%*! ,(2 6,+D"2 ,& NNOPQRO
; !" ,H'$" &,%2 7+'7"+*%"& 5'67+%&"2 %( 0(("G9+" *' ? ,+" 43%(- ,2V,5"(*
*' *!" 7+'7'&"2 H37,&& '1 *!" M,%( L"(*+,4 #',2 %( !%+9$,44, 69(%5%7,4
*'I( ,(2 &' 6,(3 5'66"+5%,4 H9%42%(-& ,+" &%*9,*"2 (",+ *' *!" H'9(2,+%"&
'1 *!" 7"*%*%'("+W& 7+'7"+*3 +9" 5'73 '1 *!" 4,(2 *,G +"5"%7* 2,*"2
?<B/<;B> %&&9"2 H3 *!" E%44,-" '11%5"+X !%+9$,44, %& 7+'295"2 !"+" I%*!
,(2 6,+D"2 ,& NNOPQRO Y
@ Z* %& &9H6%**"2 *!,* *!" 7"*%*%'("+W& 7+'7"+*3 %& , 2+3 4,(2 ,(2 !,$%(- @B
3",+& '42 74,(*,*%'(& ,+" &%*9,*"2 *!"+"%( Z( *!" 3",+ '1 >>> *!" 4,(2
'I("+& '1 *!" 4'5,4%*3 %(5492%(- *!" 7"*%*%'("+ !,2 &9++"(2"+"2 *!"%+ 4,(2 %(
5'(&"(&9& I%*! *!" -'$"+(6"(* 1'+ *!" 2"$"4'76"(* '1 !%+9$,44, H37,&& '(
5'(2%*%'( *!,* *!"3 I%44 H" 7"+6%**"2 *' 1%44 *!" 7+'7"+*3 97 *' *!" +',2 4"$"4
+9" 5'73 '1 *!" 6%(9*"& :' 0@ [ @A><>>> 2,*"2 B<<>>> %& 7+'295"2
!"+" I%*! ,(2 6,+D"2 ,& NNOPQRO \"(5" *!" 7+'7"+*%"& H"4'(-& *' *!"
7"*%*%'("+ ,4'(- I%*! '*!"+ 4,(2 'I("+& 6"(*%'("2 %( 0(("G9+" / I"+"
5'($"+*"2 ,& 2+3 4,(2 H"1'+" *!" 3",+ '1 ;BBB H3 %*& 7+"$%'9& 'I("+&= ,(2
111 WP(C) 9440/2024

!
"
# $ %& '() (
* "+,%&+%& %+-+%&

* "+,%&+%& %+-+%&
.//01230 4 ) 5 6
( * 7 8%+%#
#+-+%& 9

* 7 8%+%# #+-+%&
.//01230 :
& $ %#

#;<

" 5 '
= #;< 6+%+%#
.//01230 >
,?@ -AB
CD ) %8-6
E E F G C
'
% AB C -%6
?@
= , &+%+%&
.//01230 HI "
5 8 %

,?@ #;<

- $

E E F
112 WP(C) 9440/2024

!"
# $
%& ' $ %& () )
) # &* +,,-./0- 11
' & ) )
23 & $ !"
4& ' $ ) )
# &* +,,-./0- 15 ' 678
# !" 9
& :;
< = &
& !" ( $ $

$ #
( $ ' $ *
# &* +,,-./0- 1>
? = & $ !"
%&@ 23 & :;
$ $ $ #
' $ A' ) (B
) ) $ :; 23

# &* +,,-./0- 1C ' #
# &
$ A '" 6 &
$
9 ' # && #
$ &$ $
A
$ "
$ # ' * $
7*
' $
113 WP(C) 9440/2024

!

!
!
"# $
% # & '()
*
+,
' '-
. /
/ # !

'0 )
' ! "* $

1

" $

*
" $

1 ! 2

3* 4
)
1 5+

6
114 WP(C) 9440/2024

!
" #
$ %
& '

()
* +
,

- - !
" ". / *001 02

3 ' #
*+ # 4 2 0 '
*+ 56060$

/ # * 718860$
56060$ 9::;<=>; ?@ *+
# 4 *
# 4 $)A
- !
# 4 B ' # 4 $
- ! "
" . / *221 02 "
# 4 $ *+
C 601600 " . / *221
115 WP(C) 9440/2024

! !" #$%
& & ' ( )*+ ,- .
!" #$% - - )/0
.1 # 2 " !" #$%
& & ' ( )*+
3
4 5 6 -7 8 59 : ;
2 < 2 =) -
! -
-- ! 7 2
> <" ( ! = 2 < 8 -
?.(@ ,ABC(>252D25C( .,A. 2 < 2
! -7 ! 2 <
; " 2 " 6 -7 8 59 :
2 < 2 !" @
2 B " - - ! " <
- E
+ 2 .1 F ! 2 < G"
- 2 " ; 2 <
2 =) H (
; B 2 <
!< < "
< 2 < G" I 6>2
- 2 "
( =+= 2 < ; B
JK
F 2 .1 # !" )/0 - L <
! ! ! I - -
!" M ! B 2 > <" ( ! =
2 < 8 - ?.(@ ,ABC(>252D25C( .,A.
2 < 2 ! -7
! 2 < ; " 2 " !
116 WP(C) 9440/2024

! "
# $""%

& # ' (
) # *+,- .! /0
12
(

+ (3 (4340*5
) $ / - 6 5
$$** , "$*"*$"$" 12
(
' 7889:;<9 =>? 6 5$$*$"
"*$*$" @ A B '
7889:;<9 == # %*$*$"
' 7889:;<9 =C
$" + +
D & & # !
! 0 E
3
& + 4 -
FGHIHJKKL IMN KJGO ONPQRHSNO HG IMN TU IV TW XNRN NRRVGNVYPKL HGQKYONO JP
XNI KJGO HG IMN OJIJ SJGZ [RN[JRNO YGONR IMN \NRJKJ ]VGPNR^JIHVG V_ [JOOL
KJGO JGO `NI KJGO TQI abbc JGO [NIHIHVGNR MJO [RN_NRRNO JG J[[KHQJIHVG YGONR
dYKN Wefg V_ IMN \NRJKJ ]VGPNR^JIHVG V_ [JOOL KJGO JGO `NI KJGO dYKNPh JP
N^HONGI _RVi IMN RN[VRI V_ IMN JjRHQYKIYRN IMJI HG IMN LNJR V_ abUk IV jNI
QVRRNQIHVGP HG IMN lJIJ mJGZ JGO HI HP N^HONGI _RVi IMN RN[VRI V_ IMN Wno
RNP[VGONGI IMJI IMN [RV[NRIL HP GVX NpQKYONO _RVi IMN lJIJ mJGZq
aUq r
# / s 3 $""%

t
) $ /
117 WP(C) 9440/2024

! " #$ % & ' ()* + )&&,
-$ - ! " - . / 0 1 & &
( * + 234 (5*6/ - 7 !7 !!
7 +89 7 !
7 ! ! 7: ! 7
; !! !7 !
7 < ) 7 8
9 $ 7;
=>?@ABC
/ - ! 7 7 3 7

+89 7 0 7 +
7 4
!# !! $
!
) 7 8 9 '3D/
5/ - 4 EFG ! $
7 H
; / I
$ 7 3$ D$ 2$ ) ! 7
E ! 7 . 7 ! 7
0 !!
! $ ! /&2/ &&2$ ; 7
7 7 + 7 8 J $ &&2/
K 3 7 7 !! 7
4LM ! !# !!
; ! /
/ NO PQR QSTU VW XUOWY OZQO TU PQXR [WU[SW U\ OZW SU]QSÔR ZQY
UVOQ^XWY V_^SY^X` [WaPÔ QXY U]]_[QX]R ]WaO^\^]QOW \Ua OZWâ V_^SY^X`
]UXTOa_]OWY ^X OZW XW^`ZVU_a^X` [aU[WaO^WT TÔ_QOWY QYbQ]WXO OU OZW
cZâ_dQSSQ eR[QTTf NXÔ^QSSR OZW SQXY YWT]a^VWY ^X OZW gh OU gi jWaW
WaaUXWU_TSR ^X]S_YWY QT jWO SQXY ^X OZW YQOQ VQXk [aW[QaWY _XYWa OZW
lWaQSQ mUXTWadQOÛX U\ [QYYR SQXY QXY nWO SQXY g]O oppq QXY [WOÔÛXWa
118 WP(C) 9440/2024

! " # $
%&

' ( " # $)
*+ ,- ./ 01 234 -33 4566 /5--657 01 8 /59.5/ 3: 9;6.2</ 3: -=5
>323;98065 >.<= ?3;9- 8/ .2 @53 A5-59 B+ C5B52;5 *.B./.3286
D::.E59 FGHIJ KLM NOP QLQRS C52T.-= N+A8;6 B+ C5B52;5 *.B./.3286
D::.E59 FGHIJ KGM NOP GUGRS V86.W B+ V-8-5 3: N59868 FGHIJ KLM NOP UHX
K*YMR -=8- .2 8 E8/5 4=595 -=5 /;0T5E- Z93Z59-1 =8/ 0552 E32B59-57 Z9.39
-3 E3W.2< .2-3 :39E5 3: -=5 GHHQ [E- 827 4=595 -=5 95\;./.-5 8ZZ6.E8-.32
;2759 C;65 UKGM 3: -=5 N59868 O827 ]-.6.^8-.32 D9759S IJU_ =8/ 0552
/;0W.--57 01 -=5 Z89-1 E32E59257 05:395 LH+IG+GHI_ K78-5 3: E3W.2<
.2-3 :39E5 3: -=5 8W52757 Z93B./.32/ 3: -=5 GHHQ [E- .2-937;E.2< V5E+G_[
-=5953:M 5-E+S -=52 2325 3: -=5 75-9.W52-86 827 87B59/5 E327.-.32/
:634.2< 3;- :93W -=5 /8.7 8W52757 Z93B./.32/ E82 05 Z95//57 .2-3 /59B.E5
8/ 8<8.2/- -=5 Z89-1 E32E59257 827 -=5 95/Z32752-`C*D ./ /-8-;-39.61
306.<57 -3 E32/.759 -=5 /8.7 Z658 :39 E32B59/.32 32 -=5 08/./ 3: -=5
Z93B./.32/ E32-8.257 .2 C;65 UKGM 3: -=5 N59868 O827 ]-.6.^8-.32 D9759S
IJU_+
a+ P=5 803B5 /8.7 8/Z5E- 3: -=5 W8--59 =8/ 86/3 0552 95.-598-57 01 8
95E52- T;7<W52- 3: -=5 *.B./.32 Y52E= 3: -=5 =32 >.<= ?3;9- .2 P=8/.6789S
P=37;Z;^=8 P86;b 827 823-=59 B+ C52T.-= @539<5 FGHGH KIM N>? QUc
K*YMR -=8- .2 8 E8/5 4=595 -=5 /;0T5E- Z93Z59-1 =8/ 0552 E32B59-57 Z9.39
-3 -=5 E3W.2< .2-3 :39E5 3: -=5 GHHQ [E- 827 4=595 C;65 UKGM 8ZZ6.E8-.32
;2759 -=5 N59868 O827 ]-.6.^8-.32 D9759S IJU_ =8/ 0552 /;0W.--57 05:395
LH+IG+GHI_S -=52 -=5 /8.7 Z658 3: -=5 Z89-1 =8/ -3 05 E32/.75957 .2 -59W/
3: -=5 Z93B./.32/ E32-8.257 .2 C;65 UKGM 3: -=5 N59868 O827 ]-.6.^8-.32
D9759 827 -=8- 2325 3: -=5 87B59/5 Z93B./.32/ E32-8.257 .2 -=5 8W52757
Z93B./.32/ 3: -=5 GHHQ [E- E82 05 Z95//57 .2-3 /59B.E5 8/ 8<8.2/- /;E= 8
Z89-1+ d3953B59S -=5 *.B./.32 Y52E= =8/ 86/3 95.-598-57 .2 C52T.-=e/ E8/5
FGHGH KIM N>? QUc K*YMR =567 -=8- .2 95/Z5E- 3: /;E= 8 Z93Z59-1S -=5
Z89-1 ./ 86/3 65<8661 52-.-657 -3 W8.2-8.2 82 8ZZ6.E8-.32 V5E+U[ 3: -=5
119 WP(C) 9440/2024

!
"! #
$# % & ' !( $
)*+,- .*/ -,0 ."/1(
2( *34
, '5 ( ,67
! ,+
8 8
# ,,( 9 ! ,,
8 #
:;4 57< *+,-
(
&( 9 ,,
*+,=
! ' !
"!
8 # ,*>+:>*+,? @ 5A +
*+,? *+,?.*/ 5-(
8( *+,=
! ' !
"!
8 # (
9(
!
( 9 !
,, 8 #
? ',+ # 0
B *++= (
C( 8 #
D E F*+,? .:/ 8# ???G H-( 9
120 WP(C) 9440/2024

! "
# $ % % & $ #
'
( ) %
# #
*+, -. / #
# #
(00 01 ! "
2

! "
3 1 " (+0(,
" "
#
! "4 5 #
" 6 0
- 2
# # 2
#

# $ 2
78
# # &29 #
# # : 2
" 0 ;
0666 #
" ( #
: 2 & 2 #
# $ #
- < " #
#
! 2 )
121 WP(C) 9440/2024

! "

# $ % #&

' ( & &
)
# *+,

-. /0,
1

# 2
3
4 5 67
889

:
+,
; # < *
=
*> % "
& 1

? =.@ ? 1 *>*>
&
" !
122 WP(C) 9440/2024
-'\ Ex+-P2£fa
IN THE HIGH counT OF KERALA AT ERusuLRE

Present :
THE HowouRABLE RE. etfsTI€E ALEun[BER THous
monday, the 24th day of fiizgust 2©2©/2nd Bhadra, igae
wprci to. i62©3/2®2e{±}
grtT0ng
CIIAf\!BRA HOHAIt, A6ED 63 YEARS
s+0.KR±snin p±iLdi, eitfflBRIriA, Fesee± p, o, , frmvALLA fmLex,
PATiiAEiAFiTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689116 ,
_RESPORIDENTS
1. THE DESTRICT COLLECTOR,
pATHAVAFT"ITTA, clvlL sTATlo«, P*TH]ayArmlTTA P,O. , pAThAENiREim
DISTRICT, PIRI-689 64§.
z. THE VILLAGE OFFlcER

TI]IRtrvALLA VILLAGE, THIRLIVALLA p. c. , pA"AIiAHTHITIA DlsTRICT,
PIH-689 1©1.
3. THE REVEiiuE DnflsloNAL OFFlcER

RDO OFFICE, THIRuvALLA, "IRLIVELLA p.e. ,
PATHAHJREHITTA DISTRICT, PI«-6891Si,
4. THE TfflsILDAR
TH4±.uK 0FF=SE, THIBIVAEIA, THIROv*LLA P.0-f
pATHA»ArmHlnA DlsTfHCT, plH-689 i©i.
5. THE LeeAL LEVEL ven!rroR±uG cO]aiI-TTEE

REPRESE«TEB By ITs CONVENOR, AeREceLTtiRAL oFFlcER, T»IRLrvALLA
telsHIBRAVAN, KAvucaBHAGAev, THIRuVALLA p.o. , PATttA»ArmlTTA DrsimcT.
plm-689 i©i.
6. STATE QF EKRALA
REPRESERITED BY THE PfrmcIPAL SECFmAV, DEPARTHERT 0F REVERE:r
SECRE"RET, THIRLrvAHARmtApuRAH-695 eel.
Writ Petition {civil} praying inter a]fa that in the circustances

scated in the affid-avit filed along with the WP(C} the High court be p±
to §Say tl?9 Exhaet P£§ anS may grg§r E`9 2na respgl.d9nt tg Ssue the
possession certificate for the properties comprised in Exhibit Pi to P4 With
an entry as 'dry land' duripg the pendency Of the Writ Petition (Civil} .
This petl±jrm coming on for orders Llpon perusing the REtition and the
affi±a¥it files in sgppert of ve{C} a!nd upe!t hear.chg the arg©:€s 8f
iws.VARL16HESE H EASO & VIVEl( VARGIIESE P.J., Advocates for the petitierrer, the
cotirt passed the following:
P.T.0
TRc/26-ce-2Bae
123 WP(C) 9440/2024
P -2L6 / 2-
_ALIE3§IABFBERTHGIsfriAS3Jo
===============================
Vt7.P'c€C} NO.162$3 Qf 20g®
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = == == = = = =
D.ated iiris iFle 2:4ti day o£ _4LugusE, 2:®=3
ORDER
I.earned Government Pleader will get instructictns as to the
basis on which the 3rd responderi± Revenue Divisional Cfficer has
proceeded on the premise in Ext.P15 as if the subject property is one
which has been included in the land data bank as Nilan/Paddy land.
Further t±hat in Ext.P17 statement held by the Convenor of the
LLMC, it is stated that the property is not included in the data bank
and thL at an adjacent similarly placed property has been given the
benefit Of Rule 6(2) of the RTLT order as per Ext.P21, but whh
condition to pay amounts as per See.27A(3), etc. The respondent
RDO will explain how the findings in EIft.Pi5 can be sustained in law
OfEife.Pngandp-21. -
sd./- FEE!EÈfiHBE.R EEous,, tFueGE:
grue copy
hnin Ass€±rar
ri/!-;i..=`--===.--
:\`-.,
124 WP(C) 9440/2024
>r
;rfzrf P 26/>
EEi£LN_0.i62©3;262®m
Exii|BIT .p± -TRUE copy 9F sa±5 ~Dap HS.2@33z97 OF sR9 T5RqufiELA iHme
in . 7 . gi .
E"IBIT p2 -"ue copy oF SALE Due se.1527/©10F SRo THIRuvALLfi Dfing

31. § . ©1 .
EXHIBIT p3 - TRijE copy OF SALE Era HO.i526;81.

EXHIBIT p4 -TRUE copy OF SALE DEED ro.i444zap OF SRO TIRuVALLA DT.18-es-9fs`.
EREIBIT pi5 -TRUE copy OF TI{E ORma HO.A3-766/2®i5 DATED 18.4.2®i5 er TifE
SRD REsueNDERET.
E3L#IBZT P1? - TRUE COPY 0F THE STATERE-T 0F FACTS PitEPARED BY T#E 5TH
RESpoNl)ENT WRIT PETITlon `.ng:ac two. 34997 0F 2©19.
EREIBIT pal -TRUE Copy oF "E ORDER ias-1292/ig/K.DIS DT.3.1.2©2© oF THE ='
RESPOAIDEF!T
125 WP(C) 9440/2024
cDtr h ft4v. v
fELw. v`wick vctor%e. p.jh
'.
BEFORE TRE HONOURABLE HIGH COURT 0F KERAIA

AT ERNAKU~
W.P.(C) No.16203 0F 2020
Vs.
The District Collector. Pathanamthitta

& Others
Respondents
Fn,ED BY Tee Sid
s.REHtrm
SPECIAL G017ERNRENT HJ=AZ}ER T0 iIAG
126 WP(C) 9440/2024
I",)2
BEFORE THE HONOuNARABLE HiGH couRT Or lcaRAiA AT ERNAKULAM
WP(C) NO.16203 Of z82S
Vs.
The District Collector, Pathanamthitta

& Others Respondents
COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED BY THE 3fc! RESPONDENT
i, K. Chandrasekharan E\àir, S/o. Kris+.ria.i;utt¥ REaLrh ageg S5 years residing at

Krishnavilasam, Kaithavalappu, Thathampally P.O.7 Aispprzha.
1` I am the Rev.enue Di¥isiGnal offlcer_7 Reeeece cifeiona! Office, Thiruvalla
ard the 3rd respondent in the above case. I know +ube ga[t5 Of the case as disclosed from
lr!e relevant records. All the allegations and averEiertsin the Writ Petition are not fully
€: rrect and except those that are specifically admaseqg haeueder, a re denied.
2. It is submitted that the petitiorier hasfiiedthe writ petition challenging
E*hibitP15 proceedings {assed dy the Revenue D±ij±sirmai Oifeer, ThiruvaHa. The case
ctr the petitioner is that he is in possession and enjtryr]gmeg# Of 56.65 Ares of dry land in
Pe Survey No. 222/2 and 16.setres,14.38Ares, 28J3Stes of land comprised in Re
Si±r,]ey No. 222/1 of Thiruva!le +rasage. The pet5t± had preferred Exhibit Plo
a#ication dated 05.01.2015 before the 3rd respor}derst der Section 6(2) of the Kerala
+iE
Sjrd utilisation Order, seeking perTredssion for de`regopng his land.
127 WP(C) 9440/2024
3. It is submitted that this petitioner has filed writ petition

No.3262/2015 before this Hon'ble Court and this Hon'ble Court disposed the
writ petition with a direction to the Revenue Divisional Officer, Thiruvalla to
consider and pass orders under Clause 6 of the Kerala Land Utilisation Order,
after obtaining report from the Agricultural Officer and after giving an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner on the representation filed by the
petitioner within two months from the date of receipt of copy of the judgment.
This Hon.ble Court in para 3 and 4 of the judgment dated 04.02.2015 has held
as follows;
3. The law has been declared as per the decision rendered in Jafar
Khan Vs. K A Kochumarakkar & Ors. [2012 (1) KHQ 523] that the
provisions Of the Conservation of Kerala paddy land and Wet land

Act are applicable only in respect of the land which were lying as
'paddy land' or 'wet land' as on the date of commencement of the
'Acr. It has been further asserted by another leamed Judge of this
Court in Asharaf K.K. And Ors Vs. Eramala Grama Panchayath and
Ors (2012 (3) KLT 323) that if the land is not included in the Data
Bank Register prepared under the Act, it cannot be classified as
'paddy land' or 'wet land'. It has been declared by a Division Bench
of this Court in Praveen Vs. Land Revenue Commissioner (2010 (2)

KLT 617) that. if the property concerned is not a paddy land or wet
land. the application if any preferred, is to be considered under the
relevant provisions of the Kerala Land Utilization Order, so as to
enable the party concerned to make use of the property for other
appropriate purpose. It has been further made clear by a Division
Bench of this Court .In Sunil Vs. Kjlllimangalam Panchal 5u'Ward
Nellulpadaka Samooham (2012 (4) KLT 511) that the land

reclaimed prior to the commencement of the W.P.(C) No.3262 Of
128 WP(C) 9440/2024
p2,lY
2D°u]=o:e:e'evant Act Can be {riade ue cf eien for '|ndustr|ai
Purpose,.
4't:res=e:=oedcnt:=:ri'.nrt.h.e.se_i_dc{rc&STTtsk.Trdher5rstrespondentis
d,jj:ehctèo:tth°eco°hn.S:dn:::^n.d.P_::s.appr==:]3otnreESxpt°pn7d:nntt;Se
'jsguh::fatnhdea°,::e.rvftabt:°^nLS._:_=deb;at=tt=n€bthuend=cX:s:o7n:nc;:eed
STuhpjrsasahnad,,a:Se:ria:::°^b:a_i_ni:g.areFxutfrmthai;a=u;;:'ruar/'So:tceecr.
T,h:£j:hnae':.ba:,::nae.ula.ftê:g_I.;ing=;i=nRE;gor%rr::g°::C;hr=
Pdea%:°onferr:oaetj;th:fe.a:I:e_:._::.anyrate,.;I;I:.::y;;::;hr::gfr:°mtthh€e
dateofreceiptofacopyofthisiudg;e;;.
4. Accordingly, the Revenue Divisional officer, ThiruvaHa heard the
petjtjoner on 12.03.2015 and recorded his statement. In the hearing, the

petltlonersubmitsthatthelandwaspartlaHyreclaimedandhewasnotwilling
tousethelandforcultivation.Thepetltioneralsosubmitsthathegathered
informationthat,thelandsofthepetitlonerwoujdbeacquiredforBypass
constructionhencehenotusedthelandforcultwatlon.
5. It js submitted that as per the directlons Issued by this Hon.ble

Court by Judgment dated 04 022015, the Revenue Divisional Officer,
ThiruvallahassoughtreportfromtheAgriculturalFieldOfficer,Thjruvallaand
areportwassubmlttedon19.03.2015InthereportoftheAgriculturalFjeld
Officer,itisstatedthatthepropertyofthepetitionerisincludedjntheDraft
DataBankas`reclajmed'and".TheAgr]culturalFieldOfflcerfurthersubmlts
thatonenqujry.itwasfoundthatthereclarnationwasdonei.naround50Cents
:hf:ann2doayneda:i.e:=s°:=v,'haonnd+:=S_S.==n__mars;;::ri,.ca::au:ek:nptafra°,#onwdf5o°rcme=:Se
than20years."isevidentfromthereportoftheAgn.culturalFieldOfficerthat
totalareaof40Centswererecàimedbefore2015andhence,therestofthe
propertywiHcomeunder{heprovisionsoftheKeralaConservatjonofPaddy
Land and Wetland Act, 2008.
I
129 WP(C) 9440/2024
p f„l €
6. It is respectfully submitted that in the report of the Village
Officer, Thiruvalla dated 09.04.2015, the property of the petitioner in question
is recorded as 'Paddy Lands' in the Revenue Records and js incliided in the
Draft Data Bank as .Nilam'. The Draft Data Bank for the said area ls ready for
Gazette Notification. It is also reported by the Village Officer that the land was
kept fallow for years and there ls water logging during rainy season.
7. It is submitted that there was clear contradiction in the reports
submitted by the Village Officer and the Agricultural Field Officer regarding the
entry of the land in question in the Draft Data Bank. On verification of the
connected records and the site inspection conducted by the Revenue

Divisional Officer, it is found that the land in question is a paddy land and
hence, the application filed by the petitioner under Section 6(2) of the Kerala
Land Utilisation Order is rejected on 18.04.2015,
8. It is contended by the petitioners that the land jn question is dry
land and have 30 year old plantations of various trees situated therein. This
claim is false. According to the site enquiry report submitted by the Village
Officer, Thiruvalla dated 30.01,2020, there are only two acacia trees having
around 5 years of growth in the land. The land has been kept fallow and is
covered in small bushes. Hence. this cannot be considered as plantations.
9. It is submitted that the petitioner claimed the present status of
the land comprised in Resurvey Nos.222/1 and 222/2 was "partially filled" to
the Revenue Divisional Officer dliring the hearing held on 12.03.2015. This is
incorrect. The Village Officer, Thlrwalla reported that a Stop Memo was
issued on 07.04.2016 under the Kerala Land Utilization Order and the Kera|a
Conservation of Paddy Land and Wet Land Act, 2008, when the petitioner
tried to illegally fill the 37.6 Ares in Resurvey No.222/1 and the 56.65 Ares in
130 WP(C) 9440/2024
5 p\G
Resurvey NO.222/2 by depositing around 2o loads of sand. Hence, jt is Clear
that the land remained unfiiied till 2oi6 much after the enactment Of the Act.
` T°` lt is Submitted that as perthe minutes of the meeting held on
09.11.1999 to discuss on the reiinquishment of land required for Thiruvalla
Bypass, the land owners unanimously put forth a condition that they Will
Surrender the pc>rtion coming in the alignment for 15meter wide road, if the
remaining portion of the land after surrender will not be acquired by the
Government or Housing Board or Municipality for any future development.
Further, the land owners will permit earth filling up to a width of 24meters, to
allow suitable embankment slope. Ownership of the land beyond 15 meters
will vest with the respective land owners. Accordingly, some of the land
owners filled their land fully and some filled partially. The Bypass construction
was started after the commencement of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy

Land and Wet Land Act, 2008. Since, majority of the paddy lands were
acquired and filled for the construction of Bypass, the remaining lands were
kept fallow by the land owners and no cultivation is undertaken by them, it is
better to fill up the sides of the Bypass.
Hence, there is no merit in the contentions raised by the petitioner in
the writ petition and is liable to be dismissed with cost.
All the facts stated above are true to the best of my knowledge, belief
and information.
Dated this the '+Iday of November, 2021.
DEPONENT
solemnly affirmed and signed before me by the deponent whom I know
on this the i i'Aday of November, 2021 at the office of the
•``,`(il}..`...
Sfa{::p::::;i§n§§iiei§£%cer
ii5E|
131 WP(C) 9440/2024
Ein ,,P 2#
2022:HER:S8217
P-
IN THE HIGII COURT 0F RERALA AT ERNAKUIAM
THE HONOURABIiE MR..USTICE N. NAGARESH
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY 0F OCTOBER 2022 / 3RI) KARTHIRA, 1944
WP(CI NO. 16203 0F 2020
PETITI0rm:
CHANDRA MOHAN, AGED 63 YEARS

S/O. REISHNA PII,IiAI, CIIANDRIMA,
PODIADI P.O. , THIRUVAIillA THALUK,
PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689110.
BY ADVS .
VARUGHESE M EASO
SRI.VIVEK VARGRESE P.7.
RESPONDENTS :
THE DlsTRlcT COLLECTOR, pATHANAimHITTA,

CIVIL STATION, PATHANAMTHITTA P.O. ,
PATIIANAMTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689 645.
THE VILLAGE OFFICER
THIRUVALLA VII,LACE , TIIIRUVAlilA P. O. ,
THE REVENUE DIVISI0NAI. OFFICER
RDO OFFlcE, THIRuvAI,I,A, THIRuvAI,In p.O. ,
THE TAIISILI)AR, THALUK OFFICE , THIRUVAI.lan,
THIRUVALIA P.O. , PATIIANAIFTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689101.
THE LOCAL LEVEI. MONITORING COMMITTEE
REPRESENTED BY ITS CONVENOR, AGRICUI.TURAI. OFFICER,
THIRuvAI.ILA KRlsHIBHAVEN, KAvuMBHAGAM, THIRuval.In p. O. ,
pATiiANADorHITTA DlsTRlcT, plN-6891ol.
STATE 0F EKRALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAI. SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE , SECRETARIAT ,
THIRUVENENTIIAPURAM-695 001.
BY ADV SHRI.K. P.JAYACIIANDRAN, AI)DL. ADVOCATE GENERAI.

SRI. S.RAN.ITH SPECIAL GP TO AAG(APPEARS)
SRI.S.RANJITH SE'L.GP TO AAG
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) IIA:VING CchE UP FOR ADMISSION 0N
25.10.2022, THE COURT 0N TIIE SARE DAY DELIVERED THE F0I.LOWING:

132 WP(C) 9440/2024
2022:HER:58217
WP(C) NO.16203 0F 2020
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 25th day of October, 2022
The petitioner owns more than 1 Acre of land in
Thiruvalla Village of Thiruvalla Taluk in Pathanamthitta District.
A portion of the property of the petitioner was acquired for
constructing Bypass of the Main Central Road in Thiruvalla
Town. The petitioner would submit that while acquiring the
land, permission was granted to develop the adjacent land.
2. It is the case of the petitioner that the Municipal
Authorities dumped municipal waste in the lands adjoining the
Bypass in order to strengthen and secure the road.
Thereafter, no cultivation was conducted in the properties
adjoining the Bypass. The applications submitted by other
land owners in the area, under Section 27A of the Kerala
Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 were
allowed.
133 WP(C) 9440/2024
2022:RER..58217
WP(C) NO.16203 0F 2020
3. However, to the predicament of the petitioner, the
application submitted by the petitioner under the provisions of
the Kerala Land Utilisation Order,1967 for using the land for
non-agricultural purposes, was rejected.
4. The petitioner pointed out that in Ext.P6 Minutes,
his land was decided to be acquired on conditions. In Ext.P7,
the Revenue Divisional Officer has pointed out that the lands
acquired for construction of the Bypass are filled up and are
left fallow for long years. The petitioner further pointed out
that in Ext.P8 communication issued by the District Collector
to the Municipal Secretary of Revenue (8) Department, it was
specifically pointed out that the petitioner and similarly
situated persons have surrendered their property for the Mini
Bypass and the remaining lands are uncultivable as on date.
In view of the above, the rejection of the petitioner's
application is unsustainable, contended the counsel for the
petitioner.
134 WP(C) 9440/2024
2022:HER:58217
WP(C) NO.16203 0F 2020
5. Government Pleader entered appearance and
resisted the writ petition on behalf of the respondents. A
counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the 3rd
respondent-Revenue Divisional Officer. The counter affidavit
justified Ext.P15 order. However, it has been stated in the
counter affidavit that some of the land owners filled their land
fully and some filled partially. The Bypass construction was
started after the commencement of the Kerala Conservation
of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. Since majority of the
paddy lands were acquired and filled for construction of
Bypass, the remaining lands were kept fallow by the land
owners and no cultivation is undertaken by them, as it is
better to fill up the sides of the Bypass.
6. I have heard the learned counsel forthe petitioner
and the learned Government Pleader representing the
respondents.
7. From the pleadings and arguments in the writ
petition, it is evident that the petitioner has surrendered a

135 WP(C) 9440/2024
2022:HER..58217
WP(C) NO.16203 0F 2020
substantial portion of his land for the development of the
Bypass. The Municipal Authorities used the adjoining lands
owned by the petitioner and the similarly situated persons for
dumping municipal waste. It appears that the authorities also
found it good to fill up the land adjoining the Bypass so as to
strengthen the Bypass Road.
8. The contention of the petitioner is that section 27A
applications submitted by other owners in the nearby areas for
changing the nature of the land in Revenue records, have
been allowed. The petitioner invoked his remedy under the
Kerala Land Utilisation Order,1967. However, the petitioner's
application stands rejected as per Ext.P15 order of the
Revenue Divisional Officer.
9. After hearing the counsel for the petitioner and the
Government Pleader, this Court finds that the petitioner has
already invoked his revisional remedy under Clause 14 of the
Kerala Land Utilisation Order,1967. Ext.P25 is the revision
petition. As the petitioner has invoked his statutory remedy, it

136 WP(C) 9440/2024
2022:HER:58217
WP(C) NO.16203 0F 2020
is just and proper that the revisional authority is directed to
consider the application in the light of Exts.P6 to P8.
The writ petition is therefore disposed of directing the
6th respondent to consider Ext.P25 revision petition filed by
the petitioner in the light of Exts.P6 to P8 and pass
appropriate orders thereon, within a period of two months.
Sd/-
N.NAGARESH
JUDGE
spk
137 WP(C) 9440/2024
2022:HER:58217
WP(C) NO.16203 0F 2020
APPENDIX OF WPIC) 16203/2020
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
E"IBIT PI TRUE COPY OF SALE DEED NO.2033/97 0F
SRO TIROvALIA DATED 14 . 7 . 97 .
EXHIBIT P2 TRUE COPY 0F SALE DEED NO.1527/010F
SRO THIRUVALLA DATED 31. 5 . 01.
EXHIBIT P3 TRUE COPY 0F SALE DEED NO.1526/01.
EXHIBIT P4 TRUE COPY OF SAIE DEED NO.1444/99 0F
SRO TIRUVAI.LA DATED 10.6.99.
EXHIBIT P5 TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAX RECEIPT
DATED 14.6.2019 BY THE VII.IAGE
OFFICER, THIRUVAlil-A.
EXHIBIT P6 TRUE COPY OF MINUTES NO.A3-3189/1999
HEI.D ON 10.11.1999.
EXHIBIT P7 TRUE COPY OF IETTER NO.B/3152/2015
DATED 1.6.15 BY RDO, THIRUVALIA T0
DISTRICT C0Iil.ECTOR.
EXHIBIT P8 TRUE COPY 0F TRE REPORT NO.C2-912/14
DATED 4.6.2015 0F DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
E>ATHANAIITHITTA T0 THE PRINCIPAli
SECRETARY, REVENUE (8) DEPT.
SECRETARIAT , THIRUVANANTHAPUREN.
E"IBIT P9 TRUE COPY 0F REQUEST T0 THE 4TH
RESPONDENT DATEI) 7.1.2014 BY THE
PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT Plo TRUE COPY OF REQUEST TO 3RD RESPONDENT
DATED 5.1.2015 BY THE PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT Pll TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT DATED 4.2.2015
IN WPC NO.3262/2015 0F THIS HON'BLE
COURT .
EXHIBIT P12 TRUE COPY 0F REE'RESENTATION DATED
20 . 2 . 2015 .
EXHIBIT P13 TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGE OF DATA
BANK NOTIFICATION.
EXHIBIT P14 TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO. KBT 26/2014-15
DATED 13.3.2015 ISSUED BY THE 5TH
RESPONDENT TO THE 3RD RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P15 TRUE COPY 0F THE ORDER NO.A3-766/2015
DATED 18.4.2015 0F THE 3RD EuSPONDENT.
138 WP(C) 9440/2024
2022..HER:58217
WP(C) NO.16203 0F 2020
EXHIBIT P16 TRUE COPY OF JUI)GMENT DATED 24.7.2020

IN WPC NO.34997 0F 2019 0F THIS
HON'BLE COURT.
EXHIBIT P17 TRtJE COPY 0F THE STATEMENT 0F FACTS
PREPARED BY THE 5TH RESPONDENT WRIT
PETITION WPC NO.34997 0F 2019.
EXHIBIT P18 TRUE COPY 0F THE KERALA GAZETTE VOI. IX
DATED 21.1.2020 CONTAIN THE DRAFT
MASTER pLmi FOR THE THIRuvAln TOwN
PREPARED 8¥ THE DEPARTinNT oF TowN ANI)
COUNTRY PIIANNING DEPARTMENT ALONG WITH
READABLE COPY 0F EULEVANT PAGE.
EXHIBIT P19 TRUE COPY OF THE MASTER PliAN FOR
THIRUVAILA TOWN-2031.
EXHIBIT P20 TRUE COPY 0F THE RES0I.UTION NO.20
DATEI) 21.7.2020 0F THIRUVAI,IA
MUNICIPAI, COUINCII-.
EXHIBIT P21 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER A6-
1292/19/K.DIS DT.3.1.2020 0F THE 3RE
EurspoNDENT
EXHIBIT P22 TRUE COPY OF TEE LETTER NO-A6-
1292/2019 DATED 9.12.2019 BY THE 3RI)
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P23 TRUE COPY 0F THE CHEIAN RECEIPT DATED
18 .12 . 2019
Exhibit P24 TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER N0 A6-
5600/2019 DATED 13.04.2021 ISSUED BY
THE 3RD RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P25 TRUE COPY 0F THE REVISION PETITION
I)ATED 14TH DAY 0F DECEMBER, 2020
(WITHOUT ANNEXURES) FILED BY THE
PETITIONER T0 THE SECRETARY T0 THE
REVENUE I)EPARTMENT.
Exhibit P26 TRUE COPY OF THE POSTAI, ACENOWLEDGMENT
CARD DATED 16.12.2020 0F EXHIBIT P25.
139 WP(C) 9440/2024
E`+ P29
BEFORE THE HON'BLE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
STATE OF KERALA
NOTICE N0 83/321/2023/REVENUE DATED 07/11/2023

IN
EXHIBIT P25 REVISION PE:TITION
IN
W P 16203 0F 2020

Vs.
Sub Collector Thiruvalla& others Respondents
FFIDAVIT SUBMITTED BY THE PETIT R ro coNslDER As T

ARGUMENT NOTE IN ThE ABO' VISION PETION
I, Chandra Mohan, aged 65 years, S/o Krishna Pillai, Chandrima House,
Podiyadi PO, Tr.1i-uvallaThaluk, Pathanamthitta District; do hereby solemnly
affirm and state as follows:
1. I am the petitioiier in the above writ petition (Civil) No 16203 of 2020
and I am conversant with the facts of the case. As per the judgment
dated 25/10,/2022, the writ petition has been disposed of directing the 6th
respondent to cons;`1er Ext.P25 revision petition filed by the petitioner in
the light of Exts.P6 to P8 and to pass approiiriate orders thereon, within
a period of two months and the time limit is all-eady over on 25/12/2022.
It is submitted that a h =aring was conducted by the office of the Principal
Secretary to Departmei I of Agriculture at 2.30 pin on 29/03/2023 before
Smt V L Beena, Deputy .jecretary, Department of Agriculture, as per the
NOTICE NO 287/NCA 2/.`.020/AGRICULTURE Di\TED 20/03/2023 and the
petitioner had already su].mitted the facts befoi e the said authority.
Page 1 of 7
140 WP(C) 9440/2024
p2:ql2-
Here I am authorising my advocate Mr Varghese M Easo, Advocate, High
Court of Kerala to place arguments on behalf of me before this
Honourable statutory authority.
Honourable High Court of Kerala as per the Judgment dated 25/10/2022
in WP (c) No 16203 of 2020 is clirectecl to consider the Exhibit P25
revision Petition in the light of Exhibit P6 to P8 docunnents.At the outset it
is humble submitted that the pleadings and the documents marked as
Exhibit Pl to P24 in WP (c) No 16203 of 2020 ancl also the report related
!Qm}Lproperty obtained by the agriculture officer from the KSREC are

very relevant for the proper adjudication of my petition, hence the same
mav be considered as the Dart and Darcel of this affidavit.
It may be considered the evidence from the Exhibit P6 to P8 that in the
year of 1999, the land owners of the locality including the petitioner had
surrendered their land in consensus with the government for the
development of Thiruvalla bypass on condition that they will be permitted
to fill the property up to the road level.
6. In the year of 2015 RDO Thiruvalla had submitted Exhibit p7 report to
the District Collector as per letter No 8/3152/2015 dated 01/06/2015,
recommended to grand permission to develop the land belongs to the
people including the petitioner. On the basis Exhibit P7, the District
collector had submitted the Exhibit P8 report No C2 -912/14 dated
04/06/2015 to the Government wherein recommended to grand
permission to develop the land belongs to the people including the
petitioner.
It mav be noted that the Detitioner herein had submitted the Exhibit P9
and Plo aDDlications under clause 6 of the KLU order Drior to the
enactment of amendments in the 2008 Act. The fended properties belong
to the petitioner were developed before the year of 2000 itself and there
are so many people of the locality had obtained building permit and
Page 2 of 7
141 WP(C) 9440/2024
p2;1\J
occupancy certificate for their building constructed in the neighboring
properties situated adjacent to the proposed project of Thiruvalla Bypass.

8. This Honourable Authority may kindly consider that the finding of the sub
Collector in Exhibit P15 is against the factual position of the property. The
same office of the Sub Collector had considered the case of a similar
property situated very near to the petitionerwas excluded from the DATA
BANK and passed the Exhibit P21 and P22 orders to regularize the BTR
documents as converted land related to the property and under Section
27A of the Paddy land Act.
9. It is humbly submitted that as per the order dated 24/08/2020 in the
above Writ Petition, the Honourable High Court directed the learned
Government Pleader to get instruction as to the basis on which the 3rd
respondent Revenue Divisional Officer has proceeded on the premise in
Exhibit P15 as if subject property is one which has been included in the
land data bank as Nilam/Paddy land. that an adjacent similarly placed
property has been given the benefit of Rule 6 (2) of the KLU order as per
Exhibit P21, but with condition to pay amount as per Section 27 A (3) etc.
The sub collector is bound to answer how the findings Exhibit P15 can
be sustained in light of Exhibit P15 and P21. Moreover it is evident from
the Exhibit P17 statement of the convenor of the LLMC that the
finding in Exhibit P15 related to the petitioner's property is discriminatory,
erroneous and arbitrary and liable to be set-aside by this Honourable
Authority.
10. This Honourable Authority may be noted that the Act, 2008 is not
intended for environmental protection as a whole. Sustaining the
ecological system contemplated by the Act, 2008 is for the purpose of
sustaining paddy land and wetland. The preamble itself permits the
restrictive coi'``version of paddy land and wet land. In the afore context,
when the competent authority considers my application, the predominant
factor for consideration should be whether the land which is sought to be
Page 3 of 7
142 WP(C) 9440/2024
p2=1\l
excluded from Data Bank is one where paddy cultivation is possible and
feasible. In the case of lands having any extent, the factor whether there
are proper irrigation facilities making the land suitable for paddy
cultivation would be important. Even if the land is of a comparatively
larger extent, if there are no irrigation and other requisite facilities, it
cannot be said that the land is suitable for paddy cultivation, merely
because it was once cultivated with paddy and it is described as paddy
land in revenue records.
11. This Honourable authority may considerthat, in thejudgment in salim
C.K. and another v. State of Kerala and others [2017 (1) KLT 392],
Honourable High Court held that the Data Bank that was contemplated
under the provisions of the Act, was to contain details only of cultivable
paddy land and wetland within the area of jurisdiction of the Local Level
Monitoring Committee concerned, and not intended to contain details of
any other category of land.
12. Honourable High court of Kerala in the case of Lalu p.S. v. State of
Kerala and others [2020 (5) KLT 712] considered the statutory procedure
for preparation of Data Bank contained in the Kerala Conservation of
Paddy Land and Wetland Rules and held that the Data Bank to be
prepared under the Act, 2008 is Data Bank of cultivable paddy lands
existing as on the coming into force of the Rules. The Village Officer has
to provide the Agricultural Officer particulars of the cultivable paddy lands
in the V"age in terms of the Revenue records and the Agricultural Officer
has to ins,. act those lands thereupon to ascertain whether they are
cultivable. Irì this case Honourable High Court further held that when the
LLMC has the ;,ower to prepare the Data Bank including the cultivable
paddy lands, c!3finitely it would have the power to look at whether the
same is suitable for cultivation and whether prospective cultivation is
feasible and whetl!er such proposition is financially viable. But in my
case the above principles were not considered by the Sub Collector.
Page 4 of 7
143 WP(C) 9440/2024
p2,,ls,
13. Honourable High court in Joy K.K. v. Revenue Divisional officer/ Sub
Collector, Emakulam and others [2021 (1) KLT 433] held that it is not the
capabilfty of using the land that matters to treat one land as a paddy land
or not. It is only the character and fitness of the land as available on
12.08.2008 that matters, to indude or exclude a land for the Data Bank.
16. Again, in the judgment in Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State
of Kerala and others [2022 (4) KLT Online 1222], High Court of Kerafa
held that the most relevant aspect while considering application for
excluding the property from the DATA BANK is whether the land in
question was a paddy land or a wetland when the Act, 2008 came into
force and whether the land is fit for paddy cultivation.
14. It is submitted that the properties converted mush prior to the enactment
of Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 and the
applications under KLU order 1967 were submitted before the
amendment in the said Act. But row the respondents are insisting the
petitioner to submit the application under Section 27A of Paddy land Act
which is against the legal principle laid dovvn by the Honourable High
Court in `Geo Peter Vs RDO Muvattupuzha and others', {2019 (4) KHC
400} and also in Thasildar, Thodupuzha Taluk and another v. Renjith
George [2020 (1) KHC 865 (DB)].
15. The properties comprised in survey Numbers 219-222 in Thiruvalla
VIllage are included in the COMMERCIAL ZONE marked in Blue colour in
the map of Thiruvalla Township and the same is ANNEXED HERE \/VITH.
The Annexed map is already published in the gazette and also in the
website of the Thiruvalla Municipality. Hence the petitioner has all the
rights to use his ow, landed properties for commercial cum residential
purpose as provided b\,/ the Kerala Land Utilieat.Ion order 1967. Hence this
Honourable authority may consider that the Exhibit P15 order issued by
the Sub Collector, Thiruvallais illegal, ultravires and unenforceable and
liable to be set-aside as it is against legal dictum laid down by the
Page 5 of 7
144 WP(C) 9440/2024
p2J1\t
Honourable High Court Kerala as well as the Honourable Supreme Court
of India, in various cases.
16. It may be noted thatthe KSREc reportwould also indicate thatthe land
was found under plantation/vegetation in the data of the year 2007. The
Revenue DMsional Officer rejected the application of the petitioner
stating that if the land is converted, it would affect paddy cultivation in
the nearby area. The Revenue DMsional Officer has accepted the said
contention of the Agricultural Field Officer in spite of the fact that there is
ample evidence to establish that the land was converted prior to the year
2008. It is evident from the Exhibit P17 statement from the convenor of
LLMC, Neither the LLMC nor the Agricultural Officer has stated that these
water chals are connected to the nearby paddy fields or that the water
chals in the petitioner's property is indispensable for irrigation of paddy
fields in the nearby area. In short, a decision has been taken by the RDO
to reject the application of the petitioner without a finding that it is
feasible and viable to cultivate the land of the petitioner with paddy. The
RDO has passed the order withiout any cogent evidence to conclude that
the water chals found in the petitioner's land are indispensable for paddy
cultivation in the nearby areas.
17. In the light of the pleadings an i document submitted before this
Honourable authority and also the legal principles laid down by the
Honourable Supreme Court of :idia and also the High Court of Kerala,
the Revision Petmon may be a Owed and may issue an order to call for
the records related to Exhibit J9 and P 10 applications submitted by the
petitioner under KLU and the ame may be allowed and issue directions
to correct the entr\/ of `wet la r'' as `dry land' in the Basic Tax Register
maintained by the l'`d responi ant related to the Exhloit Pl to P4
properties without insisting o comply the provisions of 2018

amendment in the Kerala Cor servation of Paddy land and wet land Act.
Page 6 of 7
145 WP(C) 9440/2024
\l,i).?
Ot:herwise the petitioner would be put to irreparable in].ury, loss and
hardship.
What is stated above in page 1 to 7 are true and correct.
Dat:ed this the loth day of NOVEMBER, 2023.
DEPONENT.
Solemnly affirmed and signed before me by the deponent who is personally
known to me on this the loth day of NOVEMBER, 2023 in my office at Ernakulam.
Varughese M Easo
ADVOCATE
ANNEXED REpoRTED ]LiiacMENTs

2022 /7` KHC 591 Dara 16
2021 /11 KHC 540 Dara 15
2020 f5` KHC 490 Dara 13,14
2017 (1) KHC 394_..pa.raJ2
Geo Peter Vs RDO Muvattupuzha and others', and also in
Thasildar, Thodupuzha Taluk and another v. Renjith George r2020 fl` KHC 865 /DB`
Page 7 of 7
146 WP(C) 9440/2024
EdyRgr
___-
wp(a) No.i62or¢o2o I/3
IN THE HIGH COuRT OF I(ERALA AT ERNAKULAM

PRESENT
"E IIONOURABLE MR.JuSTICE N.NAGARESH
Wednesday, the 13th day of December 2023 / 22nd Agraliayana, 1945

IA.NO.1/2023 IN WP(C) NO. 162®3 0F 202®lA}
miTs/RESpoNDENTS 1 To 6 IN wp(C`:
1. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR, PATl+ANAMTHITTA, CIVIL STATION,

PATHANAMTIIITTA P.O. , PATHANAMTllITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689 645.
2. Tl+E VILLAGE OFFICER, THIRUVALLA VILLAGE, THIRUVALLA P.O. ,
PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689 101.
3. THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL 0l:FICER, RD0 OFFICE, THIRUVALLA, THIRUVALLA
P.0. , PATllANAMTl]ITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689101.
4. THE TAllsILDAR, TALUK OFFICE, THIRUVALLA, THIRUVALLA P.0. ,
PATHANAMTIJITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689101.
5. TllE LOCAL LEVEL MONITORING COMMITTEE REPRESENTED BY ITS CONVENOR,
AGRICULTURAL OFFICER, THIRuVALLA, I(RISHIBHAVAN, KAVUMBHAGAM,
THIRuVALLA P.0. , PATHANAMTl]ITTA DISTRICT, PIN-6891®1.
6. STATE 0F KERALA REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT
OF REVENUE, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPuRAM-695 001.
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER IN WP(Clì .,x_I.
CHANDRA MOHAN, S/O. KRIsll DRIMA, PODIADI P.O.,
TiilRuvALLA THALUK, pATHAed

F' PIN-689 Ilo.
Appl.ication praying instances stated in the

af f idavit filed therewith jF pleased to grant a fLirther
period of 3 months f ron with the directions of this
Hon'ble Court in the judgment 0-2022 in WP(C).No.162®3/2020.
This Application coming on for orders upon perusing the application

and the affidavit fil.ed in support thereof and tliis court.s judgement
dated 25/1®/2®22 and upon hearing the arguments of GOVERNMENT PLEADER for
petitioners in IA/Respondents in WP(C) and of M/S.VARUGHESE M EASO & VIVEK
VARGIIESE P.J„ Advocates for the Respondent in IA/Petitioner in WP(C), the
court passed the following:
147 WP(C) 9440/2024
WP(C) No.1620312020 2/3

p3D(i-
N.NAGARESH, J.
I.A.No.1 of 2023
in
W.P.(C).No.16203 of 2020
Dated this the 13th day of December, 2023
ORDER
This is an application to grant a further period of three months
from 24.11.2023 to comply with the directions of this Court in the
judgment dated 25.10.2022. The respondent does not object to
extension of time. The re ubmitted Annexure-R1 (A)
affidavit along with the dogtqme hich`thay also be taken note of

li
while taking a decisioni C°ri%€1`Tfroq\§`-tfrpt§ .ies'8ondent,
ln the circumstances, the petition for extension of time is
allowed. The time is extended for a period of three months from
24.11.2023 and the respondents in the writ petition are directed to
consider Annexure-R1(A) affidavit along with the documents also,
while taking a decision in the matter.
Post after Christmas holidays.
Sd/-
N.NAGARESH
JUDGE
bng
13-12-2023 ITme Copy/ Assistant Registrar-

148 WP(C) 9440/2024
WP(C) No.1620312020 313

p32L3
AppEr\iDlx oi: wp(ci 16203/2®2o
Annexure Rl(A) TRUE COPY 0F TllE AFFIDA\/IT SUBMITTED BY ThE PETITIOwER
T0 CONSIDER AS THE ARGUMENT NOTE IN ThE ABOVE RE\/ISION
BEFORE "E PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPAR"ENT OF REVENUE
STATE OF KERALA AS PER NOTICE NO 83/321/2©23/RE\/ENUE
DATED ®7/11/2023
13-12-2023 ITrue Copy/ Assistant Registrar

149 WP(C) 9440/2024
Ear P,3\`,
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
Abstract
Re\Jenue Department - Acquisition of land in Tbiruvalla village for the construction of
Thirvalla Bypass -Judgment dated 25/10/2022 of the Honble High Cout in WP(c) No.
16203/2020 filed by Shri Chandra Mohan - Colnplied with - Orders issued
REVENUE q}) DEPARTMENT

G.O.(Rt)NO.488/2024mD Dated,Thiruvananthapuram. 07-02-2024
Read I. Judgment dated 25/10/2022 in WP(c) No. 16203/2020 filed by Shri
Chandra Mohau
2. Letter No. DCPTA/ 3479/2023/C4 dated 07/12/2023 & 31/01/2024 from
the District Collector, Pathanamthitta
ORDER
WP(c) No.16203/2020 has been filed by Shri Chandra Mohan before the Hon'ble High
Court of Kerala. The Petitioner states that he is having 56.65 Ares of land comprising in
Re Survey No 222/2,16.19 Ares,14.38 and 20.63 Ares in Survey No 222/1 in Resurvey
Block No 219 in Thandapper 14623 in Thiruvalla VIllage of Pathananthitta district and
tlie properties are lying adjacent to the proposed bypass of the Main Central Road in
Thiruvalla municipal tour. In the year 1999 the land owners of the locality including the
petitioner had sun.endered the portion coming in the alignment for a 15 meter wide road
on the condition that the landouner will be permitted earth filling up to a width of 24
meters to allow embankment slope. This bas been recorded in the minutes of the meeting
held by the then RD0 with the landholders on 09.11.1999. The Distriet collector,
Pathanamthitta had submitted the report No. C2 -912/14 dated 04/06/2015 (Ext P8) to the
Government requesting to allow permission to develop the land belongs to the people
including the petitioner on the basis of the Kerala Paddy & Wetland Act, 2008.
2. The petitioner is now planning to construct a commercial building within his
property and applied for a possession certificate. But the present village officer stating
that the he cannot issue the possession certificate as .dry land' because of the existing
entries stated in the register related to the property as 'wet land'. The petitioner submitted
review petition dated 14.12.2020 (Ext P25) to issue directions to correct the entry of `wet
land' as `dry land' in the Basic Tax
Register without insisting to comply the provisions of 2018 amendment in the Ki`rala
Conservation of paddy land and wet land Act.
3. The Hon'ble High Cout in the judgment dated 25.10.2022 in WP(c) No.
16203/2020 filed by Shri Chandra Mohan has directed the 6th respondent Viz. Secretary,
Revenue to consider Ext.P25 revision petition filed by the petitioner in the light of Ext.P6
to P8 and pass appropriate orders thereon, within a period
of two months.
4. As authorized by the Principal Secretary, the Under Secrettry heard the petitioner
on 14. I i.2023. Based on the hearing, the District Collector was requested to furnish the
fo I lowing documents/details.
150 WP(C) 9440/2024
P3,lL tkyrf
a. Total land held by the landholders
b. Extent of land purchased by KSTP in 2007 t>y executing Sale Deed
c. Whethei. the Sale Deed executed as per the negotiation done under the LA
Act,1894
d. If not so, how the land value has been fixed
e` Is there any Govt. Order/decision permitting the landholders for earth filling in rcturi
for the relinquishment done by them
f`. Whether any of the landholders has relinquished their land for the construction of
bypass of the Main Central Road in Thiruvalla municipal town
9. The lie and nature of the property of the petitioner
h. Whether the land held by them is reclaimed land. If so, to confirm whcthcr lhc
reclamation is being done before the introduction of the Kerala Paddy & Wetland Act,
2008.
5. The District Collector in the letter dated 07.12.2023 has informed that an extent of
52.10 Ares of land in Sy No. 222/1 and 70.80 Ares of land in Sy No. 222/2 of Thiruvalla
Village is in possession of Shri Chnadramohan. Out of this an extent of 14.50 Ares of land
in Sy No. 222/1 and 14.15 Ares of land in Sy No. 222/2 of Thiruvalla Village was
acquired for the construction of Thirvalla Bypass. The land was acquired by invoking the
provisions contained in LA Act,1894 and 4(i) Notification published in Kerala Gazette
dated 18.06.2005. The BVR was published in 11.12.2006. The land `Jaluc has been fixed
@ Rs. 29,666/- per Are. After executing sale deed the land \`'as purchased bv KSTP ii`
2007. The District Collector reported that none of the landholders has relinquished their
land for the construction of bypass and the land for the project has been acquired through
Direct Purchase by executing sale deed.
6. The District Collector in the letter dated 31.01.2024 has informed that the land
for constructing embankment slope for supporting the road has been acquired through
direct purchase by KSTP. The land in possession of the petitioner, where he js planning to
now planning to construct a commercial building is included in the data bank. Stop Memo
lias been issued by the Village Officer, Thiruvalla on 20.04.2022 for the action of the
petitioner in having dumped 20 loads of sand in his land in Sy No. 222/I. The petitioners
land in Sy No. 222/42, 222/I,2 is included in the data bank. The LLMC met on
10.03.2023 has decided to retain the petitioner land in the data bank.
7. The Hearing Officer noticed that as per sub-Section (3) of Section 5, it is clear
that the benefit of conversion of paddy land is given for the construction of residential
buildings for the owner of the paddy land alone. Section 9 of the Act. 2008 deals w'ith the
constitution of the District Level Authorized Committee. Sub-Section ( 1 ) thereto specifies
that notwithstanding anything contained in Section 3, each Collector shall constitute in the
District, a District Level Authorized Committee for considering the applications for
reclamation of paddy land for the construction of residential building to the owner of
paddy land and for taking suitable decision. However, the proviso thereto also restricts
the power of the District Level Authorized Committee that, it shall not take any decision
granting pemission for the filling up of paddy land for the construction of residential
building exceeding an extent of 4.04 Ares in a panchayat and an extent of 2.02 Ares in a
Municipality/Corporation, as the case may be.
8. The request placed by the petitioners to construct a commercial building, is
included in the data bank. By virtue of Section 9 of the Act, 2008, there will be a total
prohibition for the construction of commercial building.
9. The argument that in the year 1999 the land owners of the locality including the
151 WP(C) 9440/2024
P3,`3
petitioner had surrendered the portion coming in the alignment for a 15 meter wide road
on the condition that the landowner will be permitted earth filling up to a width of 24
meters to allow embankment slope, which is recorded in the minutes of the meeting held
by the tl]en RDO with the landholders on 09.11.1999, is totally false. An extent of 14.50
Ares of land in Sy No. 222/i and 14.15 Ares of land in Sy No. 222/2 of Thiruvalla Village
was acquired for the construction of Thirvalla Bypass. The land was acquired by invoking
the provisions contained in LA Act, 1894 and 4(1) Notification put)lished in Kerala
Gazette dated 18.06.2005. The BVR was published in 11.12.2006. The land value has
been fixed @ Rs. 29,666/- per Are. After executing sale deed the land \vas purchased by
KSTP in 2007. .There was no relinquishment done and the land has beeii taken bv
payment of coinpensation to the landholder.
10. Govt` have examined the matter in detail and the Ext.P25 revision petition
(I.eview petition dated 14.12.2020) to correct the entry of `wet land' as `dry land' in the
Basic Tax Register without insisting to comply the provisions of 2018 amendment in the
Kerala Conservation of Paddy land and wet land Act) is rejected on the following
grounds:
a. The argument that in the year 1999 the land o\vners of the locality including the
petitioner had surrendered the portion coming in the alignment for a 15 meter wide road
on the condition that the landowner will be perritted earth filling up to a width of 24
meters to allow embankment slope, which is recorded in the minutes of the meeting held
by the then RDO with the landholders on 09.11.19q9, is totally false. There was no
relinquishment done and the land has been taken by payment of compensation to the
landholder.
b. The request placed by the petitioners to construct a commercial building, is
inclndcd in tile data òank. By virtue of Section 9 of the Act, 2008` there will be a total
prohit)ition for the construction of commercial building.
c. The land in possession of the petitioner, where he is plarming to construct a
commercial building is included in the data bank. Stop Memo has been issued by the
Village Officer, Thiruvalla on 20.04.2022 for the action of the petitioner in having
dumped 20 loads of sand in his land in Sy No. 222/1.
d. The LLMC met on 10.03.2023 has decided to retain the petitioner land in the
data bank.
I I. The judgment dated 25/10/2022 of the Hon'ble High Court in WP(c) No.
16203/2020 filed by Shri Chandra Mohan is hereby complied with.
(By order of the Governor)

ABDUL NASAR a I A S
ADDITIONAL SECRETARY
To:
The District Collector, Pathanamthitta

The Accountant General (A&E/Audit), Kerala, Thiruvananthapuran
utri Chandra Mohan, Chandrima, Podiadi P.O., Thiruvalla, Pathanamthitta
PIN -689 Ilo
The Public Works Department
The I&PR (Web & New Media) Department.
Stock File/Office copy
Copy to : PA to Principal Secretary (Revenue)
PA to Additional Secretary (Revenue)
152 WP(C) 9440/2024
9 eel.S.32=
© ReE€#°6s#ogREo#22#th2/#3
°G?v?£m?n?ofK:?Ia
a 2021 RegNo.Kl/rvQT)/634reo18-2o
)
9
9 €db©9o)ou9u
KERALA GAZETTE
D
e cOcO3u3©Ono
EXTRAORDINARY
o©{ifldb3®1dba3®1 Lulm)leo oeds3co3m®-
3
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
®1®j"mmang®o, 2021 oao(en3onl 17
I 7th Februay 202 I
Ou;:bi'O) enpq)ch
1 1 96 dr?oeo 5
5th Kunbham 1196
Thimvananthaprmm,
3 Wednesdry 1942 a3aao 28
28th Magha 1942
? col®8oufl mco®co@
Q]1Egcooalmo
TP N). - 15750/19 2021 @aD@OudoJ®fl 17 `
2008 6iel cd9>®9 6>medQ[ca}ed coqL5ldoro>s tT\>o®d3]]±6m @r®d±R6]ei 4(2) 6nil

al§6aeu@ ialchooo col®6oues mu>®tT\>t3®!6>s ctu>go 6nio83;- ®q±)ooocolofl§gggcoo6rf.
cO(p)ho.34/2017/ Fiev(p)ITvm bet ed 30-5-2017, cO(p)rto. 4592/17 Pev(p)ITvm Oat ed.31-10-2017
/
aa)(mlQJ®66)s oroslonoo(T)asro)leJ6o , col®8QJG] mco®(T\)(3 aJ®1col®1eJ!gg ®1®6QJg],
dinoquocotrto, d3>!8q]3tg o€)tml Qilcg]ee3d3>986is oi®1col®1ed ged6>eds3tmco3o, 06.02.Z021 ed
rfu|5`® iulocacoldb mldicen±6m troalcol®36is co>ocodi©aootmrm>16>Q3 arosltTucomoro>led
on@rfldbdefaloed ol]1edni} 6]oaf!ltT\]d 6isin5 tTundgifljallsagg ®1®8QI8] coo)a(T\J@®!6)s
orondl® otu>Qo 6nlo8in- Q]1e6ro}oulmo ul!o6)eds!QJid}6)2(m6.
i,
I.t
1`,
:in,
i;J
jl
r, Thll li n 4lHltfllly -luned ouzciic.

ûtllontlolly may be VOH fled il`rouch hapsL//compose.kerah.gov.in/
I,
153 WP(C) 9440/2024
P-c3 + 2-
d3,19ad36ic96>® ®083nd sla2>Oaa @O®j
4/2 TP-11405
542 4.45
®olQtoam cog3ch
ulg£1Q]otT\]ch olloR]gfled Qioei®1ch TP-11406

543 4/3
oi]loo3Qgi- Qoleilg]u @o®j (BT@m| n[]|cormu
4.45
ol6©yo>chul o(niled ®oroio®1 aa}i6nlof.3o TP-11404

544 4/4
GO®i cngmjcfo Q®i6"Of>OO
4.45
545 5/ cto>3q;flch ce,9oro>1ed d3>66Trmm Qidd]6>1 TP-4333

25.15
alineQil®6or8ileda+aowndQflsned TP-10442
546 8/
tir\jl.o€)a.ococotT\>-ad3>cfo trolgBd ocooDmr
28.40
547 8/1 Oj!cni-cuu71®1 6>®tuildi6>ch 6mj06t6itT\>Gn TP-10641

Z2.02
S48 8/1-1 uldQu-ul cr>1®1 6>atujld36>ed 6>tro36>6>tT\jGn TP-10641

1.06
iiij ul `; .iul.+i n:iun` ii a.I+. it

549 8/2 TP-3368
ouduj'm). 32.40
-`550
8/3 ulio9]-cLl co1®1 6>®tu]1coed OrT\.36>6m]Gn TP-10641
28.40
6>d3,oso(a(oroilch ocoro71ch co(Tttro> (/olou

551 9/ tai'oq±)d, ctrrmiq}d, eicofl-®1 arom3trd TP-4336
®ancoJ®l 1.11
cLJaaH-aLJCO1®1 6x2roldJ6xtB
552 9/1 TP-9445
d36>aen6TT31 26.08
cLnl03]uulco" 6xzroldrd TP-9445

553 9/2
6mu - !a"6TT31 27.11
d£1to6}d}o q!di®;1ch (a)oQ)o{S®1

TP-7465
554 11/
a-u -I eJlm 14.45
nch Gfl.6i g3®1omu- ®and

TP-7463
5S5 11/1
6Xml a-- 47.95
al{pelaolled d],6Q9]-6TTio]lgg ®dinnd TP-10415

`.`` 1/
556
alicBcacnd 52.10
`,
j2Iimlae>led ca,ia9i-err)ullgg ace,cra TP-10415
557 2/
al(mcaond 70.50
mia®eiouo ®abtTolejl ed aaof7ca8. eJ6i2] TP4416

S58 3/
®dincTa all.Q€)o. co6"2tA ofico6>lo eJ6r2]
49.50
ousoqg®1 6mou og9otT\7oou ®dbnd eelgBl

559 4/ TP-10923
GeeocoQn- 13.30
QJ§Cva®1 6mor cg3otT`)rLou adbch g3le81

560 4/1 TP-10923
CsOouat-I- 13.30
This is a digitally signed Gazette.

Authendcily may be verified thouch https://coTnpose.kerala,gov.in/
154 WP(C) 9440/2024
MASTER PLAN FOR

THIRUVALLA TOWN
PROPOSED LAND USE MAP
MAP NO- MP/03 (MODIFIED)
LEGEND
MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY
VILLAGE BOUN[
BOUNDARY
21 M ROAD TO BE WIDENED
13 M ROAD !STING TO BE WIDENED
12 M ROAD ING TO BE WIDENED
10 M ROAD STING TO BE WIDENED
7 M ROAD -EXISTiNGTO BE WIDENED / PROPOSED

RAILWAY LINE
RESIDENTIALUSE ZONE
RESIDENTIAL MIXED LAND USE ZONE
COMMERCIAL USE ZONE
PUBLIC AND SEMIPUBLIC USE ZONE

INDUSTRIAL USE ZONE
DRY AGRICULTURAL USE ZONE
PADDY / ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE ZONE

TRAFFIC AND \TION USE ZONE
PARK AND OPEN SPACE USE ZONE
GREEN BUFFER ZONE
HHI
Land to a depth of 250m on either side of roads havIng proposed
DISTRICT of 21m, on side roads having
proposed width of 18m, 175m on either of
havIng proposed WIdth of 12Sm on either side of
roads having proposed width of 7m or more in Residential and Dry
AgrIculture Use Zones are also deemed as Residential Mixed Land Use Zone
1.OOC 500 1,000 Meters A

bVUMBHA1 FILLl
SCALE 1:10,000
LSGD PLANNING. GO\n. OF KERALA

THIRUVALLA
Office of the District ;R-
MUNICIPALITY
Pa a:
e HP
Assistant Town
Deputy Town Planner
Town Planner 1L R1pF /d1F1iI= ==

rBI
Office of the Chief Town Plan (Planning)
a
RhJI
P&N.
Assistant Town Planner
Deputy Town Planner
Senior Town Planner
Chief Town Planner (P

10
J
no wlenr IS
MB
q
I
a
al
I
CDD
I
Lu,
WP(C) 9440/2024 155
156 WP(C) 9440/2024
Before the Hon'ble High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam.
WPC No. of2024

CJicoc!Sq ròrfeg~ . petitioner
St4Jt¢ 4 \gz£4thtc>(let, Respondentj
3, CA"Ar4 rv7oEL, Qgivf " fro. rty7tfu% a+
fijritw¥iferfu#ipo,"`fuvatr
Pp°p::refi:r:Pep/::Lanthder:fo:eYj,Y:a¥p¥forrgptt:t:o:,)Pit.to¥oyd:ciua¥dh?:se#E:°fiife|d:£:¥tseaf:?VT
and all proceedings that may be taken in respect of any application for execution of any decree or order
passed therein and I/We empower my/our Advocate to produce in Court any money, document or
valuable security on my/our behalf to apply for their refum and to receive back the same to apply for and
obtain copy of all documents in the record of the proceedings to draw any moneys that may be payable to
me/us in the above suit or matter and to sign and file compromise petition and further to accept on my/our
behalf service of notice of all or any appeal or petitions filed in any Court of appeal reference or revision
with regard to said suit or matter, before disposal of the same in this Hon. Court and I/We do hereby agree
that everything lawfully done or made by me/our in said Advocate in the conduct of the suit or matter shall
be as valid and binding on me/us if done by me/us in iterson.
Datedthisthe 5ifayof mc$4 2o2i
eL3zi04as ry>
Duly signed before me

Witnesses :|t^ '#Jnsn:.\=lD2
A.S`
1]
The Executant is
The Executants ae
pasonffi tov;eREs`v,a,ka[,athwassjgnedfnmypresence.
Accepted
foror
Vivek
(K/400/2003) , Advocate •#fl3+iit/2ii% A4r#', . varghese.: rv7 ` EcngD
Vanghese M Easo (V4

(K/374H/2000)
ftc4ap+ :::;:
i?` pJ idv`
=n*.i:.._`
157 WP(C) 9440/2024

Online Copy of the WP 9440 of 2024 Chandramohan

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Online Copy of the WP 9440 of 2024 Chandramohan

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Online Copy of the WP 9440 of 2024 Chandramohan

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

E-FILING NO - EF-HCK-2024-023261

BEFORE THE HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

FILING NATURE : URGENT

1. ADV VARUGHESE M EASO

SL Title Description Page Nos

WP (C). NO. of 2024

Chandra Mohan Petitioner

State of Kerala & others Respondents

A. Petitioner is the owner in possession and enjoyment of 56.65 Ares of

222/1 in Resurvey Block No 219 in Thandepper 14623 in Thiruvalla

development of Thiruvalla bypass on condition that they will be

permitted to fill the property up to the road level. On the basis Of

8. The 3rd respondent RDO vide ExhiELP7 submitted a report to the

District Collector submitted Exhibit P8 report to the government

recommending such permission. Thereafter, during 2014, petitioner

had submitted Exhibit P9 to get corrections in the Basic Tax Register

Court Exhibit Pllordered that the Exhibit Plo has to be considered on

various judgments. Thereafter the petitioner had submitted Exhibit P12

after availing the report from the 5th respondent.

aggrieved on the non consideration of his applications by the statutory

previous applications Exhibit P9 and Plo. Hence it is revealed that the

position declared by this Hon Court.

P20 KSREC report that the property comprised in Exhibit Pl to P4 are

consider and pass appropriate orders in the pending Revision Petition

Honourable Supreme Court of India as well as this Honourable Court.

The lst respondent had purposefully ignored the specific directions

Exhibit P30. Hence aggrieved this Memorandum of Writ Petition (Civil)

DATES AND EVENTS

14/07/1997Execution of Sale Deed No.2033/97 (Exhibit P1)

10/06/1999Execution of Sale Deed No.1444/99 of SRO llruvalla(Exhibit P4)

10/11/1999 Minutes No A3 -3189/1999 (Exhibit P6)

31/05/2001 Execution of Sale Deed No.1527/01 of SRO Thiruvalla

31/05/2001 Execution of Sale Deed No.1526/01 of SRO Tiruvalla

07/01/2014 Request to the 4th respondent (Exhibit P9)

05/01/2015 Request to the 3rdrespondent (Exhibit Plo)

04/02/2015 Judgment in WP © No 3262/2015 by this Hon'ble Court

13/03/2015 Letter No KBT 26/2014-15 by the 5th respondent to the

18/04/2015 Order No A 3 -766/2015 of the 3rd respondent (Exhibit P15).

01/06/2015 Letter No 8/3152/2015 RDO, Thiruvalla to District Collector

04/06/2016 Report No C2 -912/14 of the District Collector, Pathanamthitta

04/02/2020 Statement of facts prepared by the 5th respondent

21/07/2020 Resolution No 20 of Thiruvalla Municipal Council(Exhibit P20).

24/07/2020 Judgment in WP © No 34997 of 2019 of this Hon'ble Court

Statutes referred to:

1. Kerala conservation of paddy land and wet land Act, 2008

Dated this the 5th day of March, 2024. `ir±T,- `

BEFORE THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM

WP (C). No. of 2024

I, Chandra Mohan, aged 71 years, S/o. Krishna Pillai, Chandrima

1. I am the petitioner in the above writ petition (Civil) and I am

conversant with the fads of the case.

Petition (Civil), as otherwise the petitioner will be put to irreparable injury,

(Civil) are true copies of original documents.

as part and parcel of this affidavit.

What is stated above are true and correct.

Dated this the 05th day of March, 2024.

Solemnly affirmed and signed before me by the deponent who is

*. 51 'r2tap Qfl rfd isl9> I i C} c> r* I ~ 9 c> rd6*zBO I,i,5„O

o r3~ 9o GJ /ir3 a 7r€l a5±V rJ`rT<try~n a3 vac­) aJJj

ul a s fyJa 3 I rr> ftJ,jic=,L£=£fl

. 51 'r2tap Qfl rfd isl9> I i C} c> r I ~ 9 c> rd6*zBO I,i,5„O

o r3~ 9o GJ /ir3 a 7r€l a5±V rJ`rT<try~n a3 vac) aJJj

I,,1J^`'',?cs:= rrr;`l r=~b> F2n..c

6`~, '',i?,I J `'==l,i/` <r;`.~J,=`'\,`T:.:.':,.:`:`,`:LJ'+`jL,':i~::Lrf2radii=='s3al3*±

::==:. `: i_i: liI rJ

: :i , :=J

:a*;#?'3+9j±gct=J|T=edfi;6#:_°o"3 I I _ '',I I_.__Il. I'afa,.

CXJ_ ,, ' . _ , _ ,_ A .... _ .. _ I

Qgr42J. C*QJ +.rdc,

•.t.a .,.. `r.." ,|Jt`O!

ul cope, apfu4" 9ng: ®giiou9tsQ¢ carfe

(:I ±1> |J I C, , , + ` 1~\, .r _

This is the true copy Of do( arid riarked