PartA_Kiran (1)
PartA_Kiran (1)
PartA_Kiran (1)
INSTRUCTIONS: In this exercise, you will play the role of KIRAN. While you are reading the case and
working through the questions listed at the end, imagine that you are Kiran. You will have a total of
10 minutes to read the case and answer the question listed at the end. Please do not discuss the
case with anyone during this time.
About a month ago, Madhu Mathur and Kiran Kotha had together decided to start a company called
“Virtual Investments.” As both Madhu and Kiran had no prior entrepreneurial experience they
attended entrepreneurial support meetings to figure out what they should be doing. They were
repeatedly told by experienced entrepreneurs that most companies fail because the founders are
not able to specify appropriate startup partnership agreements. The most important next step, they
decided, was to specify a good partnership agreement.
Background
Madhu and Kiran met in the IIMB management program. They became close friends over the course
of the program and spent several evenings every week studying together, playing with other
classmates or talking about becoming entrepreneurs. Both of them were finance buffs and had taken
several finance courses in the MBA program.
Before joining the MBA program, Madhu worked in a large IT firm for 3 years, was passionate about
open-source software and contributed to a lot of open source initiatives whenever time permitted.
Besides finance classes, Madhu tried to take as many production and operations management
classes as was possible.
Kiran had worked as a sales manager in a consumer products company for three years before
coming to the MBA program. Kiran had a flair for marketing and had taken several marketing and
sales related courses at IIM.
The Company
During the summer between the first and second years of the MBA program, Madhu hit upon an
idea for a social networking site for potential investors. The idea was very simple:
...a website which would serve as a platform where multiple investors signed up and talked
about their investment activities. The ventures that a member invested in would be available
to all members of the website. The performance of these ventures would be tracked and
posted to all members. This would encourage further investments in firms that performed
well thus improving its chances of being funded.
Madhu talked about this with Kiran and mentioned the struggle to come up with a viable revenue
model for the venture. Kiran loved the concept of a networking site for investors and started
thinking about a way to make the website generate money. They decided to meet again in a week’s
time and brainstorm about it. When they met again, Kiran was very excited about having come up
with an idea for the revenue model:
...investors could of course be charged a registration fee when they signup on the website.
Apart from this, they could also be charged a commission for every deal made because of
the networks formed on the website. But the reason they would be willing to pay was
because Kiran’s uncle who had worked in the investment industry for more than 10 years
had agreed to be a part of the board of directors and provide special advice for paying
members.
Madhu loved the idea. They decided to become founding partners and named their venture, “Virtual
Investments”. Kiran would market the product and Madhu would work on building the actual
website. They knew they would both be almost broke at the end of the MBA program but could
afford to put in Rs.50,000 each towards the venture. They would both work full time in the venture
but decided that they would not draw any salary until the company started making a profit.