Case Study 5 On The Job - Strategy Case of
Case Study 5 On The Job - Strategy Case of
Case Study 5 On The Job - Strategy Case of
com*
Info Edge (India) Limited was the first Internet Company to be listed on the Bombay Stock
Exchange and the National Stock Exchange on November 21, 2006. The Company was
incorporated on May 1, 1995 under the Companies Act, 1956 as Info Edge (India) Private
Limited and converted into a Public Limited on April 27, 2006. This was the officio-legal
face of the popular job site Naukri.com. Naukri is an Indian term meaning service, job or
employment. The journey started nearly two decades ago.
Right from school when he would have been 12 or 13 years of age, Sanjeev dreamt of doing
MBA, working for a few years, and then striking on his own—atypical young person‘s
dream. He comes from a middle-class family. His father was in government service. Like
most middle-class fathers in India, he gave his children good education. Sanjeev studied in
St. Columbus School at Delhi and then sat for the IIT entrance. He cleared it but realized that
that doing economics from St. Stephens College would be a better option for him: his rank
wasn‘t good, it would take five years to graduate, and medically he was colour-blind. After
doing economics from Delhi University in 1984, he got selected as executive trainee with
Lintas and worked in advertising for three years. He then sat for the CAT and secured
admission into IIM Ahmedabad. Subsequently he was selected in 1989 as a management
trainee with GlaxoSmithKline (then HMM) where he worked for a year- and-a-half and then
quit. The next few years were trying and tough as usually happens with entrepreneurs.
Sanjeev set up an office in his father‘s home in the servants‘ quarter above the garage and
paid Rs. 800 monthly rent.
He started a company and called it Info Edge. Another company was set up with a partner.
They worked on salary surveys and database for trademarks. Both were rudimentary jobs if
we look at them in today‘s context. For instance, Sanjeev and his partner would look for
trademark applications data from the public library of the trademark registry and put all the
data in a format and sell the info package to pharmaceuticals companies looking forward to
acceptance or rejection of their trademark applications. Likewise, for entry-level salary
surveys they set up interviews for engineering graduates fresh out of college, collected data,
put them into databases and then contacted companies. The customized reports were then
sold to them at a price of Rs. 5000 each. After some time, Sanjeev and his partner parted
company with Sanjeev retaining Info Edge and the trademarks company taken by his partner.
Nearly five years of struggle followed.
WHAT IS WWW!
Sometime in October 1996, there was an IT Asia exhibition at Delhi. Sanjeev used to go to
see this exhibition and was particularly interested in visiting the small stalls where interesting
things were showcased. On one stall, that had www written on it, Sanjeev asked the owner of
the stall what that meant. The guy explained it was the World Wide Web. That got him
interested. Soon he was learning about Internet and websites and servers and e-mails. He got
interested in setting up a website but was told that was not possible as the servers that hosted
the websites were all in the U.S. He contacted his brother who by this time was a professor at
UCLA. His brother agreed to loan money for paying for hiring a server.
The struggle continued for a few more years. Sanjeev got married; his wife worked for
Nestle. That was a great support. He had a two-wheeler as he couldn‘t afford to buy a car.
Those days even IIMA graduates couldn‘t afford to buy cars unlike today. In between, there
were tough times when he had to work part-time at two jobs to make the two ends meet. He
taught management courses part-time to earn his keep. But the entrepreneur in him enjoyed
the challenges as they helped him to work on his own and set his own priorities. He gathered
partners and paid them in company shares as he didn‘t have cash to pay, asking them to do
parts of the job like programming, data entry, and support.
The group of friends purchased a lot of newspapers, opened the job advertisements sections,
and asked the data entry guys to enter the data into a format. This floppy was taken to a techie
friend and in a week he helped to create a simple website that was called Naukri.com. At that
time many of the new Indian websites like rediff, Khoj, and Samachar were focusing on the
non-resident Indians in the US. Naukri.com focused on Indians in India. That got the
company a lot of attention as Internet was a new thing and the media was writing a lot of
stories on it.
Naukri.com got launched in April 1997. In the first year, it got a business of Rs. 2.35 lakh. At
that time there were an estimated 14000 Internet users in India (In end-2014 there were an
estimated 290 million us- ers growing at 14 per cent). These people could have free access to
the website. The companies paid for the recruitment services. In the second year, the revenue
jumped to Rs. 18 lakh. At this time, Sanjeev realised he was on to something big.Next year,
the revenue jumped to Rs. 36 lakh with a first-time profit of Rs. 1.8 lakh but Sanjeev was yet
to draw a salary. By April 2000 they needed more money, got it from venture capital- ists,
and started investing it in building the infrastructure for the company. By November the same
year, the dotcom bust started. The next year came 9/11. Naukri.com—the flagship of Info
Edge—was one of the few dotcoms to survive the Internet meltdown of the early 2000s and
the post 9/11 impact.
MATRIMONY AND PROPERTY
About a year after Naukri.com was launched, Sanjeev went to meet Anil Lall, a software
programmer who was head of technology at Info Edge. He asked Lall whether they could
create a matrimonial site. Sanjeev expressed his wish to have one more classified category
besides jobs. Lall was given a few details and within
a week he had the site Jeevansathi.com up and running. Jeevan means life and saathi means
partner in the Indian languages. Initially everything was offered free. In April 2001, ICICI
Ventures was approached for venture funding and they asked Sanjeev to close down
Jeevansathi.com and focus on Naukri.com and move to one of the big five auditors. Sanjeev
went to his then auditors to thank them and tell them that they were withdrawing. To his
surprise, the auditors—Amit and Rohit Tandon—said they themselves were thinking of
closing down their business and were planning to enter online business. A deal took place and
Jeevansathi. com was partly sold to the Tandon brothers who sold it back to Sanjeev after a
few years.
Happenstance and serendipity play no mean role in entrepreneurship and business. Sharad
Malik was one of Naukri.com‘s shareholder and a computer science professor at Princeton.
On one of his visits to India, meeting Sanjeev, he just remarked how difficult it was to sell off
his ancestral property in Delhi. He asked Sanjeev if he could start a real estate website. And
Sanjeev did just that. 99acres.com was launched.
This is, in short, the story of how Info Edge started its journey.
Looking to the businesses of Info Edge one can perceive a common thread in terms of the
life-cycle needs of people and the potential for using Internet to access information to satisfy
those needs. Thus, educational needs are followed by the need to look for a job. A job in hand
usually leads to the prospect of marriage. A marriage results in need for housing and so on.
When children arrive, they too need education and the life cy- cle starts all over again. But
did Sanjeev Bikhchandani think of his business like that? Quite likely, it seems.
Naukri.com is not just a recruitment site. In fact, 90 per cent of the revenues of Naukri.com
are derived from B2B from recruiters. This is done through providing access to resume
database, job listing and response management, and employer branding and visibility. It is an
advertising site as well as it offers panels and banners for advertising that are a rich source of
revenue for Info Edge. There is a mobile section for mobile hiring and usage of this access
method is growing being 35 per cent in October 2014. Value-added services such as resume
writing, resume display, resume flash, and job mails create a repertoire of services for job
seekers. Recruiters have a special entry point through their username and password where
they can access the databases of resumes, post jobs, manage resumes, and communicate with
potential employees about their organization.
The combination of being an early mover, designing a portal that is continually improved to
offer better services to users, backed up by aggressive marketing has made Naukri.com the
market leader. There is a virtuous cycle of having higher traffic owing to the presence of a
large number of available jobs. Higher traffic creates the possibilities of higher response
which in turns attracts more client companies and recruiters. The business strategy for
Naukri.com is based on providing new products for recruiters, access through mobile,
differentiation through superior search facilities, and back up through customer service.
Addition of new features is aimed at keeping the business ahead of its competitors. Some of
the features added are career site and response management, personal profiles of recruiters,
referral hiring through access to social networks, and semantic searches.
The attractiveness of the online recruitment services has drawn competitors into the field. The
on- line recruitment services in India are also offered by portals such as Monster.com,
TimesJobs.com and Shine.com and Indeed besides the professional social network LinkedIn.
There are smaller players such as Timesjob.com, Indeed, and Jobsahead.com among several
others. The print media continues to remain popu-
lar where national dailies such as The Times of India, Hindustan Times, and The Hindu and
the government jobs media Employment News / Rozgar Samachar rule the roost.
Recruitment consultants and executive search firms are scattered throughout the metros and
even smaller cities and towns in India in large numbers. Competition is intense especially at
the lower end of the market. The ups and downs in the recruitment market heighten
uncertainties. There is excessive dependence on the IT and ITES job markets. The possibil-
ity of the new entrants offering online recruitment services remains high.
Info Edge embarked on the online matrimonial services through the Jeevansathi.com portal in
September 2004. By that time, the matrimony services market was already crowded.
Shaadi.com had a dominating presence in this segment of online services since 1997 being
the first-mover but was pushed back by Bharat- matrimony. There are other formidable
competitors such as Simplymarry.com, 123matrimonials.com and Rishtaa.com.
Jeevansathi.com is No. 3 matrimonial site in the country much behind its rivals with 13 per
cent share of the Rs 300 crore online markets. Market segmentation in the matrimonial
services business is based on geography (North / South) or communities based on religion,
castes and sub-castes. Bharatmatrimony leads in South and the non-resident communities
from southern states. Shaadi.com dominates in Punjab and Gujarat and the non-resident
Indians from these states. Jeevansaathi.com as yet does not seem to have a clear focus on an
identified market segment.
Jeevansathi.com adopts the prevalent business model of matrimony websites of free listing,
search, and expression of interest and paid services for establishing contact with a party of
interest. It has a few offline centers where clients can walk in for matching services. It also
operates franchise centers. It is one of those unique businesses where once a client is served
successfully she or he no longer remains a customer. The key to profitability lies in
converting a free client to a paid client. Info Edge is adopting an analytics-based approach to
improve the strike rate of converting clients to paid ones. This is a difficult proposition and
the company is yet to be successful in making the matrimony site business successful.
Real estate is a growth industry. There are several reasons for the boom in the real estate
markets: rising incomes, changes in social structures, family mobility, urbanization, and
availability of home financing are some of the major ones. As compared to the job and
matrimony markets, the real estate market has some specific challenges. The real estate
market is fragmented; property exchange requires cumbersome paper- work; and it is difficult
to establish clear-cut norms leading to opaque dealings and involvement of black money. At
some places in India, the property dealing is also marred by the involvement of land mafia
and other criminal cabals.
99acres.com was launched in 2005 to serve various participants in the trading and exchange
of real estate. Among these are the buyers and sellers of property, developers, builders, and
brokers. The portal is comprehensive and provides services for advertising the availability of
properties, searching and browsing for properties, and gaining access to other Indian and
international sites related to property matters. Listing is paid for by agents and developers and
is free for individuals.
As of October 2014, 99acres.com claimed having a database of more than 540,000 real estate
listings and with 22000 paying agents and developers. Info Edge aims at its property listing
business improving traffic share and keep its growth rate high. For this, 99acres.com tries to
improve its number and quality of listings, improving sales team outreach and customer
service, enhancing product development, user experience and branding, and using mobile and
analytics to improve traffic share. Product development is in the form of offering price trends
to customers based on listings, showcasing new projects, and offering verification of listings
to improve quality of offering.
For Info Edge, 99acres.com is still a business in making. Despite earning revenue of Rs 76
crore, the loss at EBITDA level was Rs. 4.8 crore. This came about due to continued
investments in strengthening products and expanding sales networks. Real estate is perceived
as a big business from the viewpoint of advertising so 99acres.com is seen as a prospective
business.
Competition to 99acres.com arises from other popular property sites such as
Indiaproperty.com, magic- bricks.com, and makaan.com besides, commonfloor.com, and
housing.co.in with the first two posing stiff competition to 99acres.com and the print media
including the daily newspapers at the national, regional, and local levels. 99acres.com is the
leader in traffic share and one of India‘s first platforms to cater to the real estate market
online with 35 to 40 per cent share of the Rs 150 crore online businesses and around Rs 80
crore revenues from this segment and has a pan India listing of properties for sale, purchase
and rent spanning 25 plus cities. It brings together builders, brokers, dealers and interested
buyers /sellers and connects them over the online medium.
Education providers provide high revenue in advertising spend to print media. They are also
interested in online advertising which is accessible to much of the younger population.
Shiksha.com operates on the business model of attracting advertising from education
providers both in India and abroad and providing information to prospective candidates.
Shiksha.com provides information on colleges, courses, scholarships and admission
information for various courses and colleges. On the other hand, Shiksha.com provides help
to institutions to attract high quality and talented students. The focus is on post-graduate
programmes and vocational courses in management, engineering, information technology,
medicine, law and hospitality besides coaching for entry into institutions. The website is
designed as a meeting place for students and alumni and experts in education to interact.
It has launched several successful advertising campaigns for instance ―name calling‘ run by
good ad agencies such as FCB Ulka. Naukri.com is a highly visible brand and the brands of
Jeevansathi.com and 99acres.com have made good progress but not yet reached the visibility
of Naukri.com. New products are introduced regularly to stay ahead of competition. Some of
these involve complex analytics and research on consumer behavior, and the positive aspects
of competing products. Building brand and creating customer recall is a continual activity.
Heavy marketing and advertising expenditure is required to support the development of brand
equity. Nearly Rs. 86 crore was spent in the financial year 2013-2014 for advertising and
promotion of newer brands and sustenance of the older ones.
The human resource function at Info Edge is critical as the company is operating in the
service business. The number of employees has been steadily increasing from 870 in 2006 to
more than 3000 in October 2014. A formal induction programme has been put in place for
new recruits. Training is focused on continual upgrades of functional and domain knowledge
across disciplines. Continual addition has taken place at the senior and middle levels in
functions such as business development, finance, marketing, product, and tech- nology. There
is a human resource information system that helps to maintain employee records and
facilitates report generation for analysis. An in-house newsletter ‗Inside Edge‘ helps to
disseminate current events and major developments to employees. There is an employee
stock option plan in operation to motivate and involve employees in sharing wealth
generation.
Opportunities exist or could emerge for developing businesses in future. Shiksha.com the
prospective education portal about which not much is known as yet may prove to be another
winner for Info Edge. The creation of new ventures related to business networking modelled
on LinkedIn and expansion of offline of- ferings of the Company remain top priorities.
Since Info Edge is a public company, its success is closely watched. The business metrics
may not really be technical such as number of hits on the portals but the share value on the
stock exchanges. Serendipity has played a big role at times in Naukri.com‘s success: the
funding came when it was required so badly; and it came just before the dotcom bust
happened in 2000; Bikhchandani could get dedicated and commit- ted partner and retains
almost all of them. But there were failures too: Indiaventure2000 and Roltanet were started in
2000 and had to be closed down. For the first five years, Info Edge did not launch resume
database services that today accounts for a major part of its revenue.
The entrepreneurial zeal of the tough survivor of the dotcom bust Sanjeev Bikhchandani lives
on though considerably muted with ageand experience. He is considered nowto be more of an
ideas man and the public face of Naukri.com while members of the management team led by
Hitesh Oberoi, COO, run the day-to-day show. The ambition to make Info Edge a ‗world-
scale‘ company remains to be fulfilled. Sanjeev Bikhchan- dani has become an inspiration to
budding Indian entrepreneurs.
Digital space in India is attracting increasing attention and investments in recent years.
Competition is becoming more intense. Expectations of customers are on the rise.
Technology is also changing fast. India‘s internet-driven economy is expected to grow by
over Rs. 10 trillion by 2018 according to Internet and Mobile Association of India and its
contribution to the national GDP is also likely to grow. India is among three world‘s
countries where seven Internet companies have a billion plus dollars valuation. Info Edge is
among them along with MakeMyTrip.com, Justdial, Flipkart, Snapdeal.com, Partm.com and
InMobi.com.
Looking back, Sanjeev Bikhchandani has this to say: ―We not only created wealth but also
built an institution‖. Is it a tall claim or a realistic assertion? Only time can tell