Pinned
okay time to talk about Cameron
the poetrustic scene
first, let's look at the shot composition and consider the context of this scene. Cameron comments, lighthearted, "I love the clarinet!"
only to be met with Charlie's jab, "I hated it!"
when watching the full film, there is a noticeable shift following this scene. before, Cameron is constantly involved in scenes, jokes, meetings, etc. following, he gradually fades out, and in the deleted scene he's even missing from the meeting following Neil's play.
notice, in the composition, all 6 other poets are seated in a circle with one another, while Cameron sits above. I can see three ways to interpret this, which are not entirely exclusive.
one is that Cameron sits himself higher than the others as a way to feel better about himself, that he is important. that he is important enough to sit up higher.
the second is that Cameron sits himself up higher because he believes he is genuinely better than the others in some way. this one feels least likely based on other characterization, but I still have to give it some space.
third is that he has been effectively shelved by the others. he doesn't exactly fit in, and they don't exactly have the space for him. maybe they don't even think to make space for him. this is not a jab at the others, I love all the poets, but it is very easy at 16-17 to exclude the people you find weird or unpleasant without meaning to.
I personally believe it's a combination of 1 & 3.
next, I'd like to examine the following shot.
this is the expression Cameron makes as everyone else laughs along with Charlie. he looks around, and everyone is laughing, seemingly at him. notably, he seems to first look in Neil's direction, but that can't be fully confirmed here.
he feels isolated, alienated. he has tried at every turn to be part of this group, and all his attempts are (at best) laughed at, and (at worse) made fun of by Charlie, his own roommate.
he feels rejected in this scene.
he has been rejected in this scene.
this is when he realizes they don't have space for him, and that showing up so often and joining in isn't worth the trouble. not worth the risk.
thank you for coming to my ted talk <3