this was like genuinely years ago On Here which is like 70 years in normal people time but I have never ever ever ever stopped thinking about when there was a post on my dash that just said something to the effect of "when's the last time you read a book by a Black woman?" and the notes were just. absolutely festering with people old enough to be on god's green internet openly admitting that they genuinely weren't sure if they had read a book by a Black women literally ever in their entire lives. and I think about that just constantly because it really is evident in the greater tumblrina culture.
usually they don't write the race of the author next to their name on the book. or gender for that matter. and even if they did, i wouldn't read any of those, since i already don't read the name. i genuinely have no idea who any of the people who wrote the books i read are. i like what they did. with the books. but i don't know what their names are.
that's really cool, definitely something to be proud of
Reading the comments has me vaguely puzzled. I really wasn’t aware that one could only get a good grade as a decent person and reader by compiling a list of every gender and race and systematically checking the box as you go down the list. Forget what you like, forget your comfort reads you must make sure you have fulfilled the list. Telling people that if they’re not fulfilling an expansive enough list they aren’t good readers or decent people is a sure fire way to make them stop reading.
Also since I know I’m going to hear a screech of racist my favorite current books are The Pillowbook of Sei Shonagon and Fatima Mernessi’s Dreams of Trespass am I getting a good enough grade?
"forget what you like, forget your comfort reads"
if you have to forget everything you like and find comforting in order to read a book by a Black woman, that is evidence of systemic racism. the idea that Black women don't write books in your preferred genres is evidence of systemic racism. The idea that a book written by a Black woman will be fundamentally uncomfortable is evidence of systemic racism.
"could only get a good grade as a decent person and reader by compiling a list of every gender and race and systematically checking the box as you go down the list"
first, it's not about grades. that is something you've added into this. which tells me that you personally grade your own morality by the books you read. if you have to go down and make a list for yourself in order to avoid exclusively reading white men, that is evidence of systemic racism. the fact that you are so defensive about this instead of realizing you're missing out on a lot of good authors and just picking up a book in your preferred genre by a Black woman is evidence of systemic racism.
am i getting a good enough grade?
no. what you wrote was incredibly racist. you are getting high marks in defensive racism (WHY SHOULD I HAVE TO READ BLACK WOMEN????? WHY????? WHY????? WHY ARE YOU SAYING THIS TO ME???? I'M A GOOD READER LOOK AT THE OTHER MARGINALIZED IDENTITIES I READ!! I DON'T NEED ANY MORE!! IM A GOOD WHITE PEOPLE ALREADY!! TELL ME I'M GOOD!! ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I'M GOOD!!!!)
it's fully an option to go "oh! i don't read a lot of Black women and I never noticed. there's a lot of good fiction i haven't touched! yipeeeee more books for meeeeee!" getting so bogged down and self involved that you feel the need to announce to the world that you Do Not Need to read Black Women Authors to be a good person is a sign that you are not reckoning with the systemic racism in play and the way it has impacted the authors you're exposed to, you are instead trying to prove to yourself and others that you are pure and have cleansed yourself of systemic racism and have a Good And Legitimate Reason to Not Read Black Women. which you don't. there isn't one. there are a lot of Black women authors and a lot of books. if you haven't found any you like, that is evidence of systemic racism.
This I will respond to. At the age of 16 I read everything I could get my hands on of Octavia Butler. Xenogensis blew me away, in my mind it was a masterwork of showing both humanity and alien. Bloodchild gave me a moral quandary. I still reread these. I see Nnedi Okorafor and N. K. Jemisin as perhaps the newest most innovative of a generation of Science Fiction writers. If you think I’m limiting myself to just Science Fiction there is Amanda Gorman’s poetry. I AM NOT listing these things to prove I’ve cleansed myself of systemic racism. It is everywhere and unavoidable. I guess I didn’t convey precisely what I meant on my first statement. That is on me. The initial post had a point. The commentary however… insisting that readers must monitor their reading, must assess their prejudices, must check every book. This isn’t reality at least not out in the weeds. I work at a library it’s small the population is aging. Witness the discussion about my 90 year old. I was exceptionally proud to get her reading something else. Maybe it isn’t enough for the commentators in fact at least one person mocked it. But the truth is I’m trying, all librarians are trying to expand everyone’s horizons. But out and out attempts at shaming people or telling them they are racist for not branching out it doesn’t work it drives people away. I’ve heavily advocated in my library for the books I mentioned above. They are there and when someone comes in and says “I’m bored what have you got?” I sidle over to my favorites and say “here try this “ maybe it’s not enough for some people but with the resources we have and the times we live in all we can do is try. Biggest victory so far is getting our book group who’s average age is 70 to read Butler’s Parable of the Sower they loved it and wanted the second part.
As an addendum I am perfectly aware that I have biases and prejudices and yes I’m working on them. There is no such thing as being cleansed of racism and I sure as hell have no problem reading books written by black women. I also do not appreciate being compared to the alt right and the Woke statement. I’m a fucking librarian in a state that’s doing everything they can to restrict libraries. I’m doing my best to make sure diverse books stay on the shelves just like every librarian I know. The value of varied points of view is irreplaceable and censorship is an abomination. So don’t accuse me of racism if I state I feel shame is not the way to go.
i’m not going to absolve you either. if you feel ashamed of how few Black women you read, it’s easy to change.
I will say I find it absolutely baffling that a librarian (apparently from a red state working to keep these books on the shelves) is arguing against checking them out in order to coddle white people shame.
I don’t require absolution. I’m not ashamed of how many black women authors I read. I read more than science fiction which I used as an example.
You misunderstood. I want them checked out, I’m excited to share these books. The more they are checked out the more I can argue for more of them. But I will not use shame as a tool to get people to check them out. It doesn’t work, shame as a motivator never works.
In the end the goal is to get people to read and explore the things that they have never encountered.To see things from another side.To put a book down and realize their view of the world has been changed . I guess we will have to disagree on how to reach that point.
On another note I highly recommend Fatima Mernessi’s Dreams of Trespass. While she is not a black woman she was a leading scholar of women in Islamic history and the book explores what it was like to live in one of the last family harems in Algiers. It to will leave you with a changed view on women and harems.
if that was your goal, you could have redirected and provided recommendations, like many other people in the reblogs. you could have added a little blurb about why you loved each book. you could have said “it’s okay if you didn’t notice until now! but now that you have, here’s where and how to get started!” if you are actually in fact a librarian, I would have expected you to put those skills to work and direct people towards books written by Black women in a warm and welcoming way, thereby supporting the authors impacted by systemic racism and lessening the shame you’re so concerned about. and that likely would have gotten you positive responses instead of a barrage of criticism. you didn’t do that.
what you actually did (in public) is:
1) make it about you personally and your Progressivist Street Cred. it is not about you. it is about the wealth of incredible authors being ignored. it is about Black Women Authors And How To Support Them As They Face Systemic Racism.
2) divert the topic from systemic racism that Black women experience by using Asian American writers as a bludgeon in your argument (which. to be clear. you can be antiblack and racist towards Black people while being perfectly nice to Asian people. they are different groups of people with different experiences of the world and different hardships. reading asian authors is irrelevant to antiblack racism.)
3) prioritize white people’s feelings about racism over the real impacts of racism.
the fact of the matter remains. you personally do not regularly read Black women authors. you personally said a bunch of racist shit to defend your personal decision and argue to the public that nobody needs to make any particular effort to read Black women authors, especially if it makes them feel bad. this is systemic racism in action. part of systemic racism is prioritizing your feelings about racism over the well-being of people subjected to racism.
you are so focused on yourself, your morals, what it means about you that you’re not putting in this type of effort that you are arguing to the public that white people’s shame about their reading habits is more damaging and more important to cater to than systemic racism and suppression of diverse voices. you are more offended by the association between yourself and racism than by actual racism. you are wasting everyone’s time (mine most of all) on white guilt.
and to be clear, there are actions and behaviors that you SHOULD be ashamed of. racism is one of them. shame CAN be toxic when overloaded, but it is also an important emotion for managing sociality. you should feel ashamed for yelling at someone because that internal emotional reaction is part of the self control that prevents you from doing it again. if you had allowed yourself to feel shame and introspect about it the first time someone told you that you were being racist in this thread, you wouldn’t be at the bottom of a grave you dug for yourself right now. you personally should feel ashamed of your conduct in this thread. you have said a wealth of incredibly racist things, you have claimed to have access to library-based skills and resources that you did not use, and you have so thoroughly missed the point that you think the appropriate response is to hand deliver treatises about how you’re not racist to my inbox as if your fixation on defending your honor isn’t further evidence of the racism in and of itself.
Well I tried but apparently conversation or discussion really wasn’t in the works. This “discussion “ was really only about you laying down judgement and your judgement is that I’m a racist. No amount of talking or trying to communicate will change that judgement.You don’t actually seem to see a person only what you want project onto someone. That is your choice and now here is mine. I will walk away knowing I tried.