Really kinda curious where they're going with all of this Ahsoka/Barriss visual/thematic mirroring that's suddenly all over the place. also curious to know just how many yuri scholars there are in the LF animation crew because like it's definitely a non-zero number
Hey do you want to make a post going more in-depth about the similarities/differences between the Grand Inquisitor's and Barriss's Inquisifits and what can be extrapolated from that thematically (you know you do) (this is bait)
well :) if you INSIST
let's start off by briefly establishing the relationship between these two (or more appropriately one lack thereof): the grand inquisitor is implied, and confirmed by word-of-god, to be one of the temple guards present during the temple bombing trial, an event which aided in his descent to the dark side. barriss's speech spoke to doubts he already harbored about the order, and her own criticisms of the order confirmed a very particular bias of his about the jedi, one antithetical to the intention of barriss's speech which spoke to a collective disregard for the tenants of jedi order, namely that "fighting for dark-side" had warped the core of their belief system. we've been shown that every one of the grand inquisitor's choices has been made in selfishness, not selflessness. his many resentments and grievances are rooted in personal dissatisfaction and inadequacy with himself, that the jedi order did not balm his hurt is what led to his ultimate repudiation of it. barriss's resentments and grievances are rooted in a deep love for the jedi order that raised, loved, and respected her. they both felt betrayed by the order's misrepresentation of itself, but the grand inquisitor wrongly attributed barriss's feelings of betrayal to his.
now with that groundwork laid, let's talk about the threads! working top-down: the moment barriss defeats dante, her inquisitor helmet is presented to her. it was forged for her before she landed the killing blow. she had no say in its creation. the grand inquisitor is this coven's proud leader; he is responsible for his flock and fortress, and he chose this for her.
a replica, a replicated lapse in self-indulgence, a moment in time where barriss lets her darker impulses, her anger and her hatred, have their say. its design is slightly adjusted to better fit barriss and the inquisitorius' aesthetic, and in there is the implication she is wanted by this empire, she is an asset to this same regime she warned the republic of. we know she regrets the acts of violence she committed under duress as evidenced by both the remorseful expression she shoots ahsoka and by this deleted scene where she explicitly apologizes to her. but the grand inquisitor does not want her moving past this moment. it's a deep well of emotional turmoil that the dark side is eager to drink from. he wants her stewing in it, and 'it' taking the shape of a mode of sensory deprivation is a very happy coincidence! the dark side is at once a state of stasis and parasitism; it successfully feeds off of isolation and hyperfixation, oftentimes from a particularly traumatic event. barriss is forced to become the face of the darkest, most regrettable moment in her life, one where she becomes the betrayer. it reopens wounds which remind her she can operate as both aggressor and aggrieved. it strips her of a voice, modifies her speech, while also working as effective blinkers (blinders/tacks like those used on animals to limit their discernment). the former perpetually-masked temple guard is well acquainted with this hell and assuming the role of traitor! we'll get into his projection in a moment.
after barriss is given her 'gift', we hard cut to her now in full regalia. it's very in medias res; she seems to be in conversation with the grand inquisitor before the rest of the inquisitorius' fledgling brothers and sisters enter the scene. whatever might have been said is left up to our imagination, but judging by both of their expressions, i imagine it was a threat veiled in niceties, much like her 'gift'.
to understand how the grand inquisitor implements fashion mirroring (projection by any other name!) here, you should first have a keen familiarity with the visual language of the inquisitorius' aesthetic sensibilities so to properly pick apart what differentiates barriss's uniform from the rest of the herd's. unifying elements of inquisitors' uniforms are the use of black, grays, and reds, as well as a liberal application of plate-adjacent armour, and some ribbing which likely allows for better mobility.
here we have mommy dearest doing his capital best to suit up his mini-she. most notable are the silhouette's pauldrons and the piece of armour that is something between chest plate and gorget (his gorget has been readapted to be more pronounced/realistic since its inception in rebels and appearance in owk). minor details like the boots and imitation vambraces are also of note, but what i prefer to focus on is the how and why. there is a deliberate likeness, but it's as if hers had its edges sanded down. making her appear less threatening invites predation. it's not enough that she has proven herself capable of murdering her competition, she must remain in a state of hypervigilance around her brothers and sisters. this parasite has a varied palate! fear is a nice little amouse-bouche to rage. the grand inquisitor wants her skills in the dark-side ever-honed and improved upon if she's to be a testament to not just his teachings, but him. see, barriss does not exist to him as a person. since the trial, she has existed conceptually and amorphously to him as an extension of himself and his own issues with the order, but they do not share the same sentiments regarding the order's issues. their dynamic, in truth, more closely resembles that of a narcissistic parent and their child. the child apprentice exists simultaneously to placate his wounded ego, and to fill a void left by (self-imposed) loneliness. i find it a very appropriate representation of this brand of narcissism, to have their authentic relationship be expressed through the medium of costume; it's external, but rarely superficial, it's an assignment, and it's imposed, but unveils so much about both characters' true natures.
And I think it's fun to continue this throughline by looking at the one aspect of her imperial look that she *did* have significant personal influence/control over: her lightsaber. We know that both Reva and Iskat built their own lightsabers, therefore it can be assumed that's the standard process for Inquisitors as one of their inherited (corrupted, perverted) Jediisms.
First off, for comparison: TGI's, which was the first of this type both in and out of universe:
Again with the general Inquisitor design sensibility: simultaneously utilitarian and aggressive. Compare Lyn's (left) and Reva's (right): Lyn's is clearly patterned off of TGI's, while Reva's is patterned more off Vader's (and is that not a whole thing in itself outside the scope of this post) but shares the same general feelingas the others—matte black & gray, silver, the occassional red light, sharp edges and aggressive styling:
Which brings us to Barriss's:
It's got the hallmarks of a typical Inquisitor saber, and that in itself is an imposition on her; left to her own devices she wouldn't have built a saberstaff, *period*, much less the spinning variant, but it's clear that building it to this specification was a requirement. And to address the elephant in the room: there is no version of this where she was not forced to bleed the crystals for it herself under duress, as we know Reva and Iskat did; this is another one of those inverted Jediisms of the Inquisitorius meant to both coerce and humiliate the recently-converted Jedi, it's another sunk-cost to weigh on their consciences and keep them locked in on the path they've been set on.
But that being said: despite the Inquisitorisms forced on her (masking her, concealing her, protecting her from suspicion in their own twisted way) Barriss really broke from the pack here. The edges are smoothed, the indentations along the ring are subtle, the flared emitters not particularly intimidating. And, of course, the copper detailing as the only decoration on an otherwise simple hilt, wholly unique among the lightsabers of the Inquisitorius—and doesn't it feel a bit familiar?
As closely as possible, with the parts provided by the Empire, she rebuilt her lost Jedi lightsaber. Jedi design language cloaked in that of the Inquisitorius; the crypto-Jedi who never actually fell to the dark side but allowed those with the power of life and death over her to believe she had until she had the courage and the opportunity to escape them.
If the Grand Inquisitor had actually paid any real attention to her in the very brief time she was under his control, he might have noticed he was *not* the mentor whose lightsaber design Barriss was most influenced by.
KIMMY
...is finally done! You can read the whole book now—including the final, just-released chapters—on my Patreon for just $3, or you can preorder the Amazon release here. (Amazon will have a paperback version on launch, and the epub will be available from Itch.io and other retailers.)
Kimmy, the story of how a Halloween costume kinda sorta eats a guy, releases October 25th!
It’s quite a heavy story. Content warnings under the cut.
Kimmy is out now! And people seem to like it! If you want to join them, check out the links in the first post.
The Fourth Sister walked into a cave, and died there. Lyn Rakish stumbled back into the light, clutching a dying Jedi and determined to save her life. But she has no training, no skill as a healer, and no friends left in the galaxy--and Barriss, as night falls and her fever rises, is running out of time.
The weird thing wasn’t that Ahsoka hadn’t explained where they were going; it was that she was enjoying herself too much. “Seriously.” It was probably pointless, but Sabine tried one more time. “You’re in a really good mood, and that’s, like, automatically suspicious.” “Hurtful,” Ahsoka observed. Then, glancing over: “Strap in, padawan. I’m starting our landing sequence. There’s…someone I want you to meet.” Or: In which Sabine probably could have stood to know less about her Jedi Master's love life. She's also increasingly certain she must have missed some kind of orientation meeting on all of the ominous backstory references flying over her head. Or maybe she's just being hazed.
Luminara knew her history. She knew this was not the first time the Order had been scattered, that the Sith had ruled the galaxy. She knew what the histories told about the fate of captured padawans. Ahsoka tells Barriss what the Ghost crew learned of her master's fate; in the past, Luminara and the Grand Inquisitor argue over their shared pupil.
We are BACK, BABY! With our usual brand of DEPRESSING BULLSHIT and MIRIALAN CHARACTER STUDIES where our FAVORITE CHARACTERS are made to SUFFER!
This is an exploration of Luminara's canon execution by the Grand Inquisitor in light of Tales of the Empire, so that should tell you what all you can expect. (Warnings for brief self-harm and implicit suicidal ideation. We didn't feel the scene merited an archive warning--it's a brief mention in a single snapshot--but stay safe.)
Jedi Master Plo Koon was sent to Shili to retrieve a Force-sensitive youngling...and arrived just a few hours too late. Years later, a Jedi padawan and an indentured bounty hunter find themselves in the same spaceport. They shouldn't be friends, not really, but...they're more alike than they are different, straining under the weight of roles they can't escape. That bond is stronger than the galaxy's expectations. Until it isn't.
REMEMBER THAT FOX AND THE HOUND AU I PROMISED LIKE SEVEN YEARS AGO?
HERE WE ARE.
Mind the tags, everyone.
saddest girls in the world
My take on the Inquisitor number is that it's completely arbitrary; I know there's a sourcebook somewhere that says it's based on initiation order but that's just flagrantly Not True, unless you expect me to believe that Trilla was the second one inducted. (Always take lore details where the source is just one obscure sourcebook with a HUGE grain of salt.)
It's not a rank thing either—no way does the Inquisitorius have any strictly defined hierarchy, because that's antithetical to the whole point, Palps wants them squabbling with each other so they don't become a threat. Reva (the youngest, who definitely didn't get initiated as a full Inquisitor at twelve years old and yet has the super low number of Third) obviously doesn't have authority over Fifth.
So my point is: the numbers mean nothing, they're completely arbitrary and not assigned in order, but the Grand Inquisitor doesn't tell THEM whether or not they mean anything. Does having a lower number indicate higher status? Probably not...unless? They're always glancing at each other and wondering and driving knives into each others' backs about it.
And that's the point, because the overall management style of the Inquisitorius is just summed up perfectly by that cage fight in Barriss's first episode: the Sith turning a bunch of captive surviving Jedi against each other and making them fight each other to earn the right to keep living on their terms.
I know a lot of people got attached to a lot of ideas about how the Vader scene would go and are wondering what the point of it was if he didn’t even speak, and so my answer to that is: because it’s not about him.
That moment is not about Anakin Skywalker, his feelings about Barriss Offee, or Barriss Offee’s feelings about him. Anakin-as-Vader does not give a shit about her, which is to say he hates her the same way he hates everyone he meets. He puts the blame for Ahsoka leaving him squarely at Ahsoka’s feet, and hates her for it, wants her dead for it. Barriss doesn’t matter to him any more than any other Jedi he knew before the purge does. (If there’s any tinge of personal feeling, it’s more adjacent to satisfaction at seeing her stuck in the same despair trap as him than anything else.) And Barriss doesn’t have a clue who he is.
So: The point of that moment is that Barriss sees that she’s kneeling to a Sith Lord. She sees that things are so much worse than she had ever feared. She sees that she’s completely lost control of her life.
And in that moment, she cannot see the way out. She feels small and afraid and everyone she loves is dead and the entire oppressive structure of the Empire is bearing down on her and saying: If you want to live, this is what you have to be. This is all you can ever be. If you step a foot out of line you’ll be dead and it won’t even do anything to help anyone.
Later, when she gets back out in the galaxy and sees again the effect she can have on people, she’ll rekindle hope within her and see the way out. There was simply NO universe where Barriss “friend to all children” Offee could ever have been an Inquisitor past the moment where she actually had to fulfill the duties of one, and the whole point of this failed attempt to force her into the Inquisitorius was to show that was true; whether she ended that first mission dead or as another rogue Jedi on the run, she never would have been what the Grand Inquisitor wanted her to be.
But right then? Now? Kneeling to Vader, knowing that she’d be dead before she could even draw the new red lightsaber on her back—the one that she hates and that hates her back because she was forced to profane it herself?* When the Grand Inquisitor has kept her isolated and provoked her over and over again so that when she finally lashes out to defend herself he can tell her that’s who she really is? There’s nothing she can do. There’s nothing she can do.
That’s her lowest point. That’s the only moment she ever really was the First Sister.
The Hidden Path in OWK having a set of blueprints of Fortress Inquisitorius that they got from someone who downloaded them when it was under construction...sure would be interesting if there were, say, someone who was briefly an Inquisitor who was there when it was under construction, had severe doubts about the role she was being forced into, and who has been previously established to be capable of memorizing complex building layouts.
the grand inquisitor DOES NOT let them dress themselves. he has complete dominion over their wardrobes. overbearing mother who knows what works best for you.
WELCOME BACK EVELYN STOKER
Relationships that are adjacent. To me.
(When you're a Jedi Padawan and there's this one dark side guy who is projecting on you like crazy and he's like this is my favorite this kid is just like me for real this is my most specialist princess who I'm going to turn into my mini-me with a bunch of fucked up mindgames and you're like holy shit I have got to get out of here this is so messed up I want my real master back.)
Hey so are we going to talk about this or—
Anyway if the cinematic framing drawing a direct parallel between Lyn saving Barriss here and Barriss saving the enby Jedi from Lyn sixteen years earlier wasn't enough, and the fact that Barriss was visibly still moving after Lyn picked her up wasn't enough, and the fact that the scene would have no point if Lyn wasn't rewarded for her change of heart about Barriss wasn't enough, and the fact that Barriss was stabbed off-center (a narratively survivable wound) and there's a tent full of medical supplies RIGHT OUTSIDE wasn't enough—
It's just. Our last shot of Barriss here is a direct visual parallel to the last shot of Ahsoka in Twilight of the Apprentice—the episode where Ahsoka faced her darksider nemesis in an encounter that seemed sure to end in her death but that she survived against all odds, which probably takes place months at most after The Way Out does—with Barriss's shot light where Ahsoka's is dark and Barriss being carried out of the cave while Ahsoka is walking in, both having a symbolic rebirth after defeating the narrative they were seemingly doomed by?
If you're still at all worried that this was meant to be a death scene, I don't know what else to tell you.