#i can't blame someone for causing harm unknowingly #intent is what makes someone guilty #or is it?
I don't know you and I'm not equipped to help u in general re:ur comment. but in response to ur tags I would like to add that in my opinion intent does NOT matter as much as actions matter, and that was one of the intended points of my original post: that no one needs to invent intent that wasn't there in order to justify whatever pain they (or someone else) is feeling. they can simply feel that pain and work on healing from that pain without worrying about trying to read the mind of whoever hurt them.
understanding why abuse happens, and by extension understanding that it isn't something committed by unknowable "born evil" people but rather by complicated, normal, people just like u and me, is also an important step in figuring out how we should talk about abuse and prevent future abuse.
but at the same time, people who have committed abuse are not owed forgiveness or grace from the people they've hurt, nor are they completely free from the blame either. the argument I'm making is one that looks at context and external dynamics of structural power, not one that says anyone should be allowed to commit whatever harm they want without being questioned on it.
going on a tangent this paragraph, but I think this is a really messy and nuanced conversation to have. so the central ethics I return to in conversations like this will always be through the lens of anti-carceral transformative justice. in plainer words, following my personal example in the original post: I do not think my parents are unlovable or irredeemable monsters, they're just people. so I don't want to see my parents sent to jail, fined, or "punished" for what they did to me. I don't want them "called out" or socially exiled. in a better world, I would want them to have received better education and resources on how to treat a child with kindness and respect, and I would want the societal, structural dynamics of "the family" to be reworked in favor of legal youth liberation and autonomy. and importantly, on the other side of the coin: it was not and will never be my responsibility to forgive or "fix" them myself. I feel all that's my responsibility is just to distance myself from the abusive dynamic, heal, and ideally speak up in preventing it from happening again to future kids (see: me writing my original post).
this isn't how everyone needs to feel about their abuse, but it's how I feel and might provide insight on these broader points I'm trying to make here.
idk how helpful all of this rambling is with your situation or for explaining my post, but I hope there's something to be gained from it.
TL;DR intent isn't what makes someone guilty. actions are what makes someone guilty. if someone hurt you, you can blame them for that and feel that pain without needing to read their mind to know their intentions.
also, I'm sorry for what you've gone through, I'm sorry you're still struggling with it, and I genuinely hope it gets easier for u in the future.