omg this this this this this-
words cannot explain how dirty Rick did especially the álfar in Magnus Chase. i love you MCGA but come on, they’re one of the most mysterious beings in Norse mythology and he turned them into the American 1% 😭😭 and i know we obviously can’t explore the culture of the other realms beyond what Magnus sees, but man. no explanation for why the álfar don't (can’t?) tolerate imperfections; we're just told they're all bigots and move along. meanwhile, the dwarves' culture is explained during our visit to Niðavellir, and while we hate that Blitz was ostracised for liking fashion, we get positive aspects of the dwarves' mixed in; they're a multifaceted culture with both values we appreciate and flaws we don’t. but Hearth is the only álf that isn't awful. even though, gotta be honest, he is kind of a snob.
Hearth is literally my fav, but i can see he is lowkey a snob in how he treats his own culture. he rants to Magnus about his people not appreciating nature anymore and 'not working and being on their phones' and i gotta be honest- why does it matter if they don't work? isn't the point of extreme wealth to get to do what you want without having to work? the end goal of most people is to get to do what you want (and for some, that may be their job, but not for all). and then, instead of meeting the álfar and having positive facets to them and their realm... Hearth is proved entirely correct; the álfar suck and are horrible. but the way he lumps in 'laziness' with ruining their environment rubs me the wrong way, it gives off a youngun hating their culture cos it treated them badly and only seeing that it’s awful while not appreciating the complexity of people and culture (which he kind of is: he’s 20 and angry at the world). it’s even worse, because Hearth’s complaint is that his people are lazy, not that they enslave the hulders and use the nøkker; he doesn’t bring that up in his rant, even though it is way worse than being slothful. Hearth is displayed as tho he feels superior to the rest of his people, because from how he describes them, he is. and then when we meet them, he is, once again, a better person than all the álfar we meet- but that’s not hard.
we meet cops, who ofc are gonna suck if the whole place is ableist and our narrator was a homeless youth with a Deaf person, but also the back of the cop car is lavish. so the álfar treat their criminals well? Magnus says this but sarcastically, but really doesn't that imply something about how the álfar treat each other? even when they break the law? but then there's the whole thing where the hulders are servants (slaves), and we get told this and we just accept it and move on as the álfar being even more awful; we have no idea what pixies are treated as, Hearth implies they're treated similar to cats, the nøkker are 'security spirits' but they're not that in mythical lore. so what is the deal with Álfheimr? why is every other sentient/potentially sentient species lesser to the álfar? svartálfar are made fun of because of the whole fashion/beauty and receipt thing, we get a reason for the dwarves looking down on their sister-race, but we don’t for the álfar.
(tho i also appreciate the idea of Álfheimr and Niðavellir as symbolic of the differences between rich white oppressors and poor POC communities @ that one tumblr post i can’t remember who by so sorry🙏, i just want more from world-building if you’re going to try and go all in on the ‘all these people are bad people bar the main character because’ shtick)
and hard agree, don’t get me sTARTED on how he treated Freyja… the scene with the walnut at the end? where she makes a comment about not liking them? and Freyr is like ‘haha sister you are so dumb and stupid this has Loki in it obviously’… literally disgusting don’t ever treat a feminine woman like she’s stupid in front of me for making a related to the conversation but slightly off topic comment.
and i kNOW her mountain of earrings but asking for more is like ‘gods are greedy and don’t value things’, but let women enjoy jewellery please?? not having earrings to match the vibe you're going for, even if you have 100 pairs already, is not that crazy, even if it is a very first-world problem. we meet Freyja and everything about her feels so lavish and wasteful, but then Freyr?? sits on a wooden throne with a deer antler as a staff and he’s so super chill and a good dad despite being even more absent in Magnus' life than Freyja was in Blitz's.
why is the goddess of love and SEIDR, amongst other things, treated like some frivolous idiot? all because she likes shiny things and has a lot of one-night stands that result in kids? as if the dwarven men she marries aren't just as guilty? like i'm sorry Blitz feels like a receipt and i get his mommy issues, but we can see his mother loves him in some way because she rushes to him at the end of the last book. but because she's an absent mother, like every other god, who had kids in exchange for jewellery, she sucks? as if every dwarf that wants to spend a night with her doesn't know she will leave them as a single parent but do it anyway and thus are also responsible for their kids feeling like receipts. Blitz's dad clearly loved him, and Blitz loves his dad, but are we really going to sit here and act like Bíli is blameless in his son feeling like he was a receipt for earrings? just because Blitz's conception was transactional, suddenly it's wrong. the woman is to blame for the marriages being shallow because she wanted something material out of it, as if the men she married didn't just want to sleep with her. the kids feeling like they don’t matter beyond being a receipt is the absent mother’s fault when the present fathers had their child’s whole development to assuage that insecurity.
and the treatment of Inge… all she gets to be is Hearthstone’s old best friend who likes him in the second book, and a damsel in distress in the 9 from the Nine book. She was his one person on his side in his childhood after his brother died but she’s reduced to having a crush on Hearthstone, she gets no personality beyond a bashful crush that wants to help and a nervous disposition around her enslavers. Hearth left her with his parents, and he isn’t to blame for getting out of an abusive household and not coming back, but we could have explored Inge from that point of view: she was left behind. she doesn’t get to get out on her own, Hearth has to release her from service (which he only does right before they leave, which i kind of hate even if i get it), and then when she is captured again, he has to go and save her. Inge is just a plot device for Hearth; she only exists to flesh out his story, which i hate because i adore her, and while it’s okay for background characters to exist purely for the development of the main, she deserved more.
we meet NO álfar women because Greta is dead and is just a plot device for Alderman's cruelty to Hearthstone, and we also meet NO dwarven women (if i’m wrong on that, then they were so unimportant that they didn’t register in my memory which is just as frustrating). the fandom even ignores Greta the way Rick does. i get it, Alderman is an active character in the books, but everyone forgets she was one of Hearth’s abusers too, she was awful to him too, but no one mentions that, she is pushed aside and forgotten because we never meet her. but we meet Hearth’s brother.
Sif is treated like a moron when we meet her, Blitz refers to her as ‘Thor’s wife’, which yes, she is, but she is a goddess in her own right- it’s just as stupid to bad mouth her in her own house as it is to bad mouth her before meeting her husband. yet, Blitz goes with the latter and frames her respect as dependent on her husband’s threatening nature, which i find ironic because he comes from a matriarchal society (which we don’t get to explore even though the concept of Blitz getting massive culture shock from the patriarchal realms would have been so interesting). Samirah’s grief with Sif is fair, the same goes for Alex, but only really Hearth actually respects her.
anyway, this is an essay and i got carried away and totally took over this post-
i love you diversity in Magnus Chase but you do nOT pass the Bechdel test and it makes me so mad that the Norse mythology-centric series treats women like this when the Norse treated their women with respect and a fair amount of freedom prior to Christianity
i know everything is biassed and not a full story because it's all through Magnus' lens but loooooord sometimes Rick's worldbuilding frustrates me