Siren sounds (Part 2: The Final)
Peter Parker x Male Black Cat!Reader
Warnings: Slight angst, eventual Smut, dialouge heavy, happy ending, bottom!Reader, top!Peter, anal sex, oral sex (reader receiving), fingering, unprotected sex, missionary position…
Summary: A couple weeks after you and Peter’s identities were revealed to each other, you and him are once more made to face each other…
As you went to school the next couple of weeks everything felt awkward. It felt like everyone was staring at you, which usually wasn’t out of the ordinary, considering you’re the most popular guy in school. But now they were looking at the bruise on your face.
When your friends asked you about it you just said you’d gotten into a fight with a guy at a party.
Seeing Peter in class and in the hallways was the worst part. You looked away every time you passed by each other. One person who noticed this was none other than Flash Thompson who approached you once school had ended.
”Hey Y/n” he said leaning against the locker beside yours. You had no patience for him today ”What?” you asked directly. ”What’s going on between you and Parker?” he asked sneakily. ”It’s none of your business, Flash” you told him.
But Flash could tell something was up and then asked quietly ”If things are over between you and him then finally you might be able to make some time for me” he suggested with a smirk. ”No” you answered quickly.
”Cause you piss me off” you said getting fed up with him. You slammed your locker shut but Flash continued following you like a stray dog.
The students weren’t the only ones who noticed your bruise. Some teacher had reported it to the principal, who made you have a meeting with him. Asking if you had any ”problems” at home or with any of your classmates.
You told him the same lie you’d told everyone else. He didn’t question you any further about it but said that ”If” something happened to you there are people who can help. Though you doubted there was anything they could do about your quite specific situation.
Most people usually didn’t get punched in face aftaer a fight with a superhero/their hook-up-buddy after they found out you were the cities most talented cat burgular.
Speaking off you were still unsure what to make of the whole Peter is Spider-Man thing, was Peter, Spider-Man or was Spider-Man, Peter?… Was Peter even his real name?… What should you even call him in your head Spider-Peter, Peter-Man, Parker-Spider…
A couple of weeks later, when your face was fully healed, one of your friends invited you to his end of the year party. Honestly you weren’t really in a mood for partying but you’d blown off your friends for a couple weeks now and maybe a good bender would be just the thing to get you back on track and get Peter out of your head.
The week after Peter found out that Y/n was Black Cat felt like hell. Going to school knowing he’d have to face Y/n was a nightmare, especially to have to see the bruise he gave him. Peter still felt guilty about it, even though Y/n did stabbed him in response, but at least Peter healed quicky.
The worst part about it was that a couple other students picked up on his and Y/n’s sudden distance from each other. Coupled with the noticable mark on your face was a really bad look.
No one had approached him about it but he could tell some were looking at him as he walked down the hallway.
A couple of days into the week as he walked down the hallway. Y/n started walking closely next to him. ”What are you doing?” Peter asked suspiously. Y/n have him a annoyed look and said ”You know what assumption people are making of us, I’m just making sure it dosen’t get out of hand, okay?”.
While the two were currently at odds he appreciated that the y/c/h haired boy didn’t leave him hanging. So the two wordlessly made their way to the class they shared.
Y/n was right. Being seen together put as they walked to their shared classes made people stop looking. Though the two still weren’t talking after that.
Ned and MJ questioned their sudden coldness towards each other Peter was unsure if should tell them you were the Black Cat and just settled on that the two them had just had an arguement. Plus if Y/n in any way found out he’d told anyone his indentity he’d might actually murder him.
A couple weeks later while Peter was preparing to go home, Ned came running up to him excitedly. ”Caleb Johnson just invited us to his party next week” Ned told him. Caleb Johnson was one of Y/n’s friends.
”I don’t know, Ned, not really feeling it” Peter said trying to get out of it, knowing Y/n likely also be there but Ned just stared at him in disbelief and said ”Peter, did you not hear me CALEB JOHNSON, his parties are legendary, we need to show up to show him that we’re cool”.
”Ned, you should go, but I’m telling you, I’m not going to the party”
Peter was going to the party.
Not out of free will but Ned wouldn’t stop bugging him about it, saying if they went and Caleb Johnson thought they were cool then everyone else would think so too. As the two of them were dropped off by Ned’s mom, they could already hear the pounding of loud music coming from a brighly lit house.
The two walked closer to the door. ”Do you think we knock?” Ned asked. ”I don’t think anyone would be able to hear it” Peter said realistically. Peter was about to reach for the door handle as the door slammed open and a drunk couple stumbled outside, talking about going to a fast food place.
The two boys entered and saw the crowd of people inside. The two met up with MJ and they all got drinks. Soon both MJ and Ned had disappeared in the crowd of people, leaving a very awkward and lonely Peter to find a way to entertain himself.
He wandered around until he layed he finally stopped in his tracks. He saw Y/n sitting on the couch in the living room with some of his friends, looking just as bored as Peter himself felt. Soon Y/n turned and met his eyes.
The two were frozen in place. Both’s eyes communicating, neither of them really wanted to be there. They were both still upset about the whole thing between them. Y/n broke the eye contact, stood up, disappeared for a moment then he came back into view making his way through the party crowd.
Peter was transfixed as Y/n moved towards him, colored lights flashing around him, reminding him of the party where you first became close.
But Y/n just passed by Peter, but as he did he slid something into his hand. Peter opened his closed hand to find a scrunced up paper, he opened it and there was text written on the paper…
”Meet me where we first met at midnight”
Peter thought back, Y/n had been in the most of the same classes as him for most of high school, but he had no idea what the exact pin-point moment they’d met. Then Peter realized Y/n meant where they’d met as Spider-Man and Black Cat.
You stood waiting on top of the jewelry store as you heard the familiar ”twhip”s of Spider-Man’s webshooters coming closer. Spider-Man then landed in front of you. You made eye contact both wearing your masks.
”Why did you want to meet me here?” Peter asked a tension to his voice.
You shrugged and answered truthfully ”Neither of us wanted to be at that party, so I thought… let’s leave and do something we’d rather do instead”.
”What do you mean by ’rather do instead’?” Peter asked, he was in no mood for your antics.
”End this, we can’t go on living like this, we need to settle whatever we have going on now so we can both just move on” you told him seriously. ”And how do we do that?” Peter asked, you gave him a dry smirk. ”Yeah… that’s the part I’ve been trying to figure out while waiting for you… I have no idea” you told him honestly.
You both went quiet waiting for the other to say something. You ended up speaking first…
”I hated you for a while you know, after you stopped me from being able to get the blueprints and files I needed to break my mom out, I hated Spider-Man for it… Ironic that you were also my comfort after that without masks” you told him.
You then added ”And in the end you probably saved me from making things worse for my mom and me from making a mistake that might’ve gotten me arrested”.
”When I found out you were the Black Cat, I felt stupid. Because when I was jealous of you being with other people, we ended up hooking up in our costumes, but then you ended up having been the same person the whole time and I thought all this time you had just been you playing with my emotions” Peter confessed.
You thought back on all the times you and Peter had hooked up, your unofficial ”friends with benefits” status and never making it clear what you were to each other. And your time as the Black Cat where you had him chase you just for the fun of it, pushed him off buildings and made him fall in dumpsters in alleyways…
Maybe you had played with him, without really thinking about it.
”You said you loved me, when we found out about each other” you reminded him.
”Yeah…” Peter said a hint of pain in his voice.
You sighed deeply and said ”I’m sorry, Peter”, making the eyes on Peter’s mask widen in confusion. ”I’ve never been good enough for you, all this time you’ve always been there for me, supporting me, loving me. And all this time all I’ve ever done is cause you pain” you told him tears stinging in your eyes.
”You deserve better, someone who can treat you how you deserve to be treated. Because you’re the most amazing, kindhearted person I know” you said wiping away your tears. You walked closer to Peter who frozen on the spot in a stunned silence.
You lifted his mask to over his mouth and said ”This is for the best, goodbye Peter” and gave him a kiss on the cheek. You had made up your mind you needed to stay away from him, for his sake.
You then turned and ran, shooting of your grappling hook to another building. ”Y/n, wait!” Peter yelled behind you. But you swung away from the building. You heard the sound of his webslingers behind you.
You ran across rooftops but could hear him following you. ”Y/n, please!” Peter voice came from behind you. ”Why won’t you just let me do one good thing for you!” you yelled back tears still falling down your cheeks. And as you leapt the gap between two buildings, Peter tackled you mid-air as his arms wrapped around your waist.
You rolled together in a struggle over the next rooftop and Peter finally managed to pin you down. He ripped off his own mask looking down at you, his brown eyes filled with heavy emotions. He then said ”We always done things your way, on your terms, you run and I chase you cause it’s my duty, this time we’ll do it my way, let’s just talk”
”Peter, I-” you started. But Peter cut you off and said ”Let me speak, please”. You went silent. ”You say you’ve never been good for me but you have, with you I discovered sides of myself I didn’t know I had, you excite me and get me to try new things, with you everyday feels like an adventure Y/n”
”And even though you don’t always see it yourself, you’re exceptional. I could never find someone else in the world like you” Peter said before concluding ”And I’m not letting you run away just because you didn’t say you loved me back, I still want you in my life”.
You were stunned by Peter what Peter said, how highly he thought of you. It was time you told him your truth back.
”But I do love you Peter, you’re the most important person in my life… It’s just-… It’s my kind of love… that’s why I can’t keep-” But before you could give Peter another reason to why you weren’t good enough for him, he cut you off as he pressed his lips to yours.
His warm lips meeting yours was the best feeling in the world and you couldn’t help yourself but kiss him back. You laid on the rooftop trapped in your embrace for several minutes.
Suddenly a cold gust of wind brought you both out of current bliss. ”We should go inside” Peter said and you quickly added a ”Yeah”. Peter took you back to his apartment. May was out of town which would give the two of you some privacy.
You both climbed into Peter’s room through his window. As you climbed in he started rumaging through his closet to get you a change of clothes from your Black Cat suit. He handed you a hoodie with a dumb science pun on it and some sweatpants. He picked something out for himself too.
You pulled the zipper and started pushing the tight suit down your body. As you got it down to your underwear you looked over at Peter who’s suit was laying pooled on the floor and Peter was only in a set of boxers. He looked back at you as something hit both of you.
You dropped the change of clothes Peter had given you to the floor and the two of pulled each other into a deep passionate kiss, your bodies pressing together, your skin on his and his on yours feeling like the softest silk.
He frantically pushed your suit and underwear futher down until you were stood naked infront of him. All Peter could do was let out a silent ”Wow” he’d seen you naked before but tonight was different as if cupid had pierced his heart with an arrow.
Peter got down on his knees in front of you, wanting to do nothing more but to pleasure you. He took your hard big cock in his hand rubbing it softly. Peter then took the tip into his mouth playing with it with his tongue. You gasped at the amazing feeling.
Peter accepted more of your length into his mouth. ”Fuck Peter” you swore, the warm wet feeling of Peter’s mouth around your cock feeling amazing. Peter put his hands on the globes of your ass squeezing them as he sucked your cock.
Peter then took a web shooter off his suit, attaching it to his hand and used it to web a bottle of lube and pull it to himself. He spread lube on his fingers, He pulled you ass cheeks apart and started playing with your hole.
Peter fingering you open and sucking you off felt amazing, you could cum on the spot but you needed to wait. You put a hand under Peter’s chin tilting his head up towards you. ”Don’t make me cum just yet” Peter you told him.
Peter took your dick out of his mouth and stood up and guided you towards his bed, letting you lay down on your back. Peter climbed on top of you between your legs, putting his fingers back in your tight hole. Peter finger fucking you as you made out until you told him ”I’m ready”.
Peter lubed his cock and lined himself up with your hole. He carefully inserted himself and you felt as if electricity shot through your body, Peter’s fat cock filling you up was the most amazing feeling in the world. ”Peter, you feel so good” you groaned.
Peter moaned as he sheathed his cock in the warmth and comfortable tightness of your hole. Soon Peter started moving slowly in and out of you. You gasped as Peter’s sizeable cock pistoned into your heat.
”God, you’re perfect” Peter said, your ass clenching perfectly around his cock, massaging it with every time he rolled his hips to push into you. Peter fucked deeply into you making you see stars and making you blurt out ”Fuck- I love you Peter”.
Peter paused the rolling of his hips and gazed into your eyes with a smile spreading on his face. ”I love you too” he said and started kissing your neck as he continued fucking you. You grasped on to the sheets of Peter’s bed, feeling only ecstasy from Peter’s cock inside you.
The pace of Peter’s thrusts increased, getting more powerful and reaching deeper in to you. Peter’s cock hitting against your prostate making you a loud moaning mess beneath him. Yelling out from being overcome with pleasure.
The bed beneath you started rocking back and forward as Peter passionately plowed himself into your now streched out gaping hole. ”That feeling good?” Peter asked you through his heavy panting as rolled his hips at a quick pace.
In response you only moaned loudly, holding onto and squeezing Peter’s pecs, which he took as a sign that he was doing a good job. As you made out you both felt that you were both getting close to your orgasms.
You both communicated from the choir of moans and panting filling the room along with the sound of his powerful thrusts against you. Your naked bodies now glistening with sweat from your intimacy.
Peter started jerking you off to help you reach your high, and with one last thrust against your prostate you lost control and your cock started shooting ropes of cum uncontrollably, staining yourself and Peter’s abs with your load.
The sight of you covered in your own cum was enough for Peter’s thrusts to go erratic. He thrusted like it was the last time, he’d ever get to experience the feeling of your hole that felt like it was perfectly molded for his cock. He never wanted your bodies to be untangled from each other.
And with a last powerful roll och his hips, his thick cock buried deep inside you as he unloaded his seed in your ass. His cock flooding your insides with his cum. You both panted heavily as you held each other close.
Peter carefully pulled out of you, making his big load seep out of you. Peter stood up from bed and went to the bathroom and got a towel, using it to clean you up. He then helped you into the clothes he had lended you before.
As you were both changed you layed down in his bed, you held each other close that night as you fell asleep.
The next morning you awoke still in each others arms. ”Of all the things I’ve ever stolen, you’re worth more than any of it” you told Peter. And he smiled and hugged you tightly as you both got up and decided you’d go to a café for breakfast.
As you walked together hand in hand along the maze of tall buildings, you felt at peace and happy. But suddenly Peter stopped in his tracks in the middle of the sidewalk.
”I just remembered something” Peter said and you looked at him a curious glint in your eyes.
”When we were at the museum there was something I wanted to ask you” Peter told you.
”Will you be my boyfriend?”
You felt your cheeks heating up. It was such a simple question yet it managed to give you butterflies in a way you never truly felt before. Peter just smiled at you, as he waited for your answer giving you whatever time you needed to think.
”Yes” you answered and the two of you hugged and gave each other a kiss on the lips.
And as you walked hand in hand with your boyfriend you felt the spirit of the Black Cat go into hibernation inside you. You didn’t need Spider-Man to chase you for a thrill. You didn’t need anything else, no jewelry, art or money was worth anything anymore.
Because right now you were holding your whole world in your hand.